et al.: Law Alumni Journal

A PUBLICATION

OF THE

LAW ALUMNI SOCIETY OF THE UNIVERSITY OF PENNSYLVANIA

Fall 1965 Volume!, Number 1

Published by Penn Law: Legal Scholarship Repository, 2014 1 Penn Law Journal, Vol. 1, Iss. 1 [2014], Art. 1

'law Alwnni Journal - Editor: VOLUME I NUMBER 1 FALL 1965 Barbara Kron Zimmerman, '56 Associate Editor: James D. Evans, Jr. TABLE OF CONTENT S Alumni Advisory Committee: Robert V. Massey, '31 ABORTING STATE COURT TRIAL IN CRIMINAL J. Barton Harrison, '56 CIVIL RIGHTS PROSECTIONS by Professor Anthony G. Amsterdam, '60 The Law Alumni Journal is published three times a year by the Law Alumni CHURCH AND STATE CONFERENCE HELD AT Society of the University of Pennsylvania LAW SCHOOL 2 for the information of its members. BICENTENNIAL FELLOWS 3 Please address all communications and manuscripts to: THE EVIL PRACTICE OF MAJORITY OPINIONS 4 The Editor A Report by Arnold Cohen, '63, on Professor Law Alumni Journal University of Pennsylvania Haskins' Address to the Coif Chapter Law School CLASS OF 1968 SERVICE MINDED 4 Thirty-fourth and Chestnut Streets Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19104 LAw H JvLn.LLrVH LA~. vALG1viNG-FINAL REPOR r 1964 1765 5 Benjamin Franklin Associates 6 Century Club 6 Report of Classes 8 Contributors 10 Regarding Law School Annual Giving 13 Cover: Professor Noyes E. Leech, '48, A Glance at Ten Years of Annual Giving 14 teaching Creditor's Rights class in McKean Hall. Corporate Matching Gift Program 14 Summary of Regions 18 Law Alumni Day 19 KICKOFF LUNCHEON FOR 1965-66 ALUMNI ANNUAL GIVING 20 SPECIAL Al\INOUNCEMENT: PICTURE CREDITS GOWEN FELLOWSHIPS AVAILABLE 20 cover Peter Dechert pages 2, 3, 9, COMMENTS ON LAW IN THE AFRICAN 18,19,22 Frank Ross COUNTRIES 21 page 20 Walter Holt page 23 Cherry Hill Portrait Studio ALUMNI NOTES 22 page 24 Jules Schick Studio PROFESSOR A. LEO LEVIN NAMED Cover Design: Lou Day VICE PROVOST OF UNIVERSITY 24 Printed at the University of Pennsylvania GRADUATE STUDENTS REPRESENT SIX printing office. COUNTRIES 24

https://scholarship.law.upenn.edu/plj/vol1/iss1/1 2 et al.: Law Alumni Journal

ABORTING STATE COURT TRIAL IN CRIMINAL CIVIL RIGHTS PROSECUTIONS* by Professor Anthony G. Amsterdam, '60

Federal trial courts can and must put a stop to Constitution. They have the power in the streets. The state criminal prosecutions such as those against Missis­ Constitution purports to limit state power, but power sippi Negro defendants for whom litigation in the state speaks immediately and effectively until it is effectively court is not a meaningful avenue to the enjoyment of stopped. State arrests and state prosecutions are the voice federal rights at or before the time of state court trial. of state power. They may voluntarily cease to speak, in This power and obligation of federal courts to intervene obedience to higher Jaw. But where the higher law is a exists whether one views the state criminal process in law for unpopulars, the probability that the popular these cases as one enormous malignant conspiracy of all organs of state prosecution will voluntarily cease to speak official state organs leagued in massive resistance and is small. In time, from locality to locality, these organs dedicated to the destruction of federal civil rights, or may unlearn old prejudices, but predictably they will merely as the product of prosecutorial perversity cou­ learn new ones. In time they may unlearn some of the pled with the heavy-fisted clumsiness and inefficiency fear and ignorance and interest which underlie all preju­ that is characteristic of American state criminal admin­ dices; but federal guarantees predictably will also develop istration (and not alone in the South), or as the mindless with time, and insofar as they are needed those guar­ and inevitable, unhappy creature of pervasive bigotry antees will always represent the gap between the evolving and popular intolerance, tugging along alike state prose­ ideal of freedom and the capacity of the representatives cutors, juries and judges (again, not alone in the South), of power to let men be free. The matter is not one for dog­ or sometimes one or another or a combination of these matism, but so far as one can predict, the probability is things. Only very far from practicality and from the ne­ that the popular organs of state prosecution will never cessity of proof are such distinctions meaningful. In its effectively protect federal civil liberties; that they will normal processes Mississippi justice too unbearably clogs remain instruments for harassment, not vindication, of the freedoms indispensable to a free society. In this re­ persons who dare to exercise freedoms to which the gard it differs only in degree from the justice administered United States is Constitutionally committed, but which in other southern States, and in States outside the South. its majorities who speak in the state process are not con­ For, institutionally, the processes of state criminal stitutionally built to accept. administration are designed to ignore or destroy such It is precisely to protect against probabilities of federal guarantees of civil liberty as free speech, free this sort that federal trial courts have been created and resort to the ballot, free access to the streets. much of their jurisdiction given. Since the inception of Although abstractly accurate, it is perfectly ab­ the Government, those courts have been employed in surd to say that the mayor and police chief have federally cases "in which the State tribunals cannot be supposed guaranteed immunities to make a speech, cast a vote, or to be impartial and unbiassed," for, as Hamilton wrote walk the sidewalks of their towns. They do not need in The Federalist, "[T]he most discerning cannot foresee these immunities. The Constitution gives them nothing. how far the prevalency of a local spirit may be found to Such protection as the Constitution gives, it gives to those disqualify the local tribunals for the jurisdiction of na­ in sore need, those whom other protections have failed, tional causes." The federal question jurisdiction of the who are so defenseless that society may arrest them or federal district courts in civil cases rests largely on the charge them with crime. They are the powerless, the un­ assumption that federal judges "are more likely to give popular; once it is known that a man is within this class full scope to any given Supreme Court decision, and par­ -and the fact of his prosecution is sufficient evidence ticularly ones unpopular locally, than are their state of it-his fate before a state jury, an elected justice of counterparts." The federal diversity jurisdiction has re­ the peace, or circuit judge is substantially decided. Prose­ cently been authoritatively justified in terms of "the pos­ cutors know this fact and can laugh at philosophies which sible shortcomings of State justice," inter alia, the ignore it. Defense counsel know it who have tried with­ localization of trial in small constituencies where "justice out success to make state trial judges read an opinion is likely to be impeded by the provincialism of the local from the United States Reports before ruling on a motion continued on page 24 for acquittal in a free speech case. True, state courts are competent to administer federal law, and they may by *Brief excerpt without footnotes from Professor Anthony self-denial act to vindicate federal liberties. Theory casts G. Amsterdam's monograph-length article "Criminal them in this protective role, but the battle is not over Prosecutions Affecting Federally Guaranteed Civil Rights: theory. The battle is for the streets, and on the streets Federal Removal and Habeas Corpus Jurisdiction to conviction now is worth a hundred times reversal later. Abort State Court Trial" 113 University of Pennsylvania Here the state authorities have the jump on the Law Review 793-912 (1965).

Fall1965 1

Published by Penn Law: Legal Scholarship Repository, 2014 3 Penn Law Journal, Vol. 1, Iss. 1 [2014], Art. 1

At the instance of several community leaders in­ terested in the current problems regarding the relation­ ship of church and state, Dean Jefferson B. Fordham Church arranged for a searching and provocative two-day Penn­ sylvania Conference on Church and State at the Law School on October 13 and 14. One hundred seventy-five influential Pennsylvanians with a vital interest in the sub­ ject and representing varying viewpoints were invited to attend a discussion, in legal and constitutional context, ?f current and emergent problems which are of large public State interest and importance. As those invited included teachers, school admin­ istrators, public officials, clergymen of different faiths, and lay people affiliated with various community organ­ Cot1fere11ce izations as well as lawyers, the first session, at which Dean Fordham presided, was devoted to "The Exposition of the Law of the Subject." In his discussion of "The Law in the Light of the Decided Cases," Professor Paul W. Held at Bruton concluded that the theme of the decided cases is adjustment and accommodation between the free exer­ cise and establishment clauses of the First Amendment as well as between the rights of the individual and secular Law School social considerations. In reviewing the cases, Mr. Bruton showed that the two clauses operate in a state of uneasy collaboration so that the Supreme Court arrives at "the least erroneous solution of insoluble problems," to quote Cardozo. Professor Paul G. Kauper of the University of Michigan Law School then discussed "The Issues Which Remain Open." Most of these issues arise under the establishment clause. Many of the questions are now be­ ing generated by the various federal aid to education provisions. He highlighted the peculiar question of whether the local school board can use federal money to do things it is prohibited from doing with state money by the terms of the state constitution. Professor Kauper also chose accommodation or benevolent neutrality toward religion as the guiding prin­ ciple for predicting the outcome of cases in this area rejecting both absolute separation and strict neutrality. Another major open area he discussed was tax exemptions. He took into account excise taxes and fed­ eral estate, gift, and income taxes, as well as the ad valorem property tax. Professor John Honnold of the law faculty pre­ sided at the next session devoted to "Religion in the Public Schools," Philip Jacobson, a lawyer and Program Coordinator of the National Community Relations Ad­ visory Council, and Professor William B. Brickman of the Graduate School of Education, University of Penn­ sylvania, presented opposing views in a colloquy on "Problems After the Schempp Case." Mr. Jacobson stated that the aim of developing morally upright stu­ dents in a religiously neutral public school is compli­ cated by the introduction of spiritual values equated with religion or theology. Although the legality of many public school practices has not been settled he feels that the Schempp case does serve as a moral guide which educators and clergy should not attempt to cir­ cumvent nor should they approve circumvention. To do

2 LAW ALUMNI JOURNAL https://scholarship.law.upenn.edu/plj/vol1/iss1/1 4 et al.: Law Alumni Journal

public schools will result in lack of moral standards or that moral truths will be accepted because they are state endorsed and enforced. He also looks on this exclusion as a suppression of religious convictions of both teachers and students. The concluding session on the "Organized Com­ munity and Church Related Institutions" was a lively de­ bate between William B. Ball, Esq., General Counsel, Pennsylvania Catholic Conference, and Leo Pfeffer, Esq., Special Counsel American Jewish Congress, with the Hon. Genevieve Blatt, Secretary of Internal Affairs, Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, presiding. The main focus was government financial aid to parochial schools and church-related institutions. Mr. Ball maintained that although government may not promote religion it may achieve secular goals through religious institutions and Dean Jefferson B. Fordham and the Hon. Gene­ must be permitted that control necessary to see that the vieve Blatt share a pleasantry. The others are public purpose is accomplished. l. to r. panel members Leo Pfeffer and William Pfeffer, on the other hand, foresees adverse effects B. Ball. on education especially where multiple facilities are re­ quired by the terms of the aid grant. Those improvements otherwise is, in his view, of more deleterious moral effect made through having consolidated school systems, fo r than the absence of religious expression in the public example, would be lost. He also contended that such an school. approach also has adverse effects on religion, and that Mr. Brickman, on the other hand, is afraid of circumventing the requirements of the Constitution in developing a religion of secularism and wonders why this way leads to disrespect for the law. that would not fa ll within the proscribed establishment The conference was financed by a grant from the of religion. It is his opinion that absolute church-state Philadelphia Foundation. separation is not necessary for religious liberty. One of his main aims is to keep the private school flo urishing so Bicentennial Fellows it will be available for all and parents will not be forced to send children to public schools to submit to a religion The Law School is pleased to be able to invite of secularism. outstanding scholars to spend a year here as Bicentennial In the panel discussion on "Teaching About Fellows in Criminal Law and Administration to further Religion in Pennsylvania," Professor Philip H. Phenix of their research in various aspects of this subject. Some the Teachers' College of Columbia University outlined of them offer a course or two while here. In either case, the stimulating course he conducts at Teachers' College they make a stimulating contribution to thought in the on the objective study of religion in public schools. He Law School. This year, for the first time, there are two thinks it is the educator's responsibility to accept the Bicentennial Fellows, Alan Milner former Dean and challenge of the Supreme Court to deal with the religious Professor of Law at Ahmadu Bello University in Zaria, dimensions of various subjects. Nigeria (see p. 21) and Eliahu Hamon of Israel. Dr. Professor Edwin D. Freed of the Department of Hamon is on leave of absence from the Faculty of Law Biblical Literature and Religion, Gettysburg College, dis­ of the Hebrew University of Jerusalem this year to make cussed so me of the objective facts archeology and other a comparative study of res judicata including double disciplines have recently added and which he incorpo­ jeopardy. rates in his teaching at the college level. Miss Elsie M. Robert Knowlton now Professor of Law at Murphy, English teacher in South Hills High School, Rutgers University, Edward L. Kimball now Assistant Pittsburgh, told about the dilemma she faces in teaching Professor of Law at the University of Wisconsin Law English in a public high school. Literature abounds with School and Willard D. Lorensen now Associate Pro­ religious ideas and references. This presents a problem fessor at the University of West Virginia Law School of objectivity for the teacher. were earlier Bicentennial Fellows. Dean Robert F. Drinan, S.J., Boston College Law Peter Louis Waller, who now occupies a senior School, addressed the group on Religious Differences and position on the Faculty of Law of Monash University, Community Understanding. He emphasized the major Melbourne, Australia, was Bicentennial Fellow last year. importance of the recent statement by Pope Paul VI on Other foreign experts who have now returned religious understanding as a ringing affirmation of to teaching in their own countries have included: Mirjan Catholic commitment to religious freedom. Damaska, Zagreb University, Yugoslavia; Ryszard He pointed out that it is only in the area of educa­ Krzyzanowski, University of Warsaw, Poland; Knud tion in this country that consensus on church-state mat­ Waaben, University of Copenhagen, Denmark; Hafeezul ters either never existed or has broken down. He is, Rahman, Aligahr University, India. Gillis Erenius is however, afraid that the absence of religion from the with the judiciary in Sweden. Fall 1965 3

Published by Penn Law: Legal Scholarship Repository, 2014 5 Penn Law Journal, Vol. 1, Iss. 1 [2014], Art. 1

The Evil Practice of Majority Opinions A Report by Arnold Cohen, '63, on Professor Haskins' Address to the Coif Chapter

Professor George L. Haskins is one of eight life tenure immunized federal judges from the popular scholars engaged in preparing the History of the Supreme will. Thus, the Republicans' ascension to power was as Court of the United States authorized by Congress pur­ yet incomplete. suant to the will of Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes. Dean One of Jefferson's chief aims was the destruction Jefferson B. Fordham is a member of the Permanent of the Federalist stronghold in the judiciary. Accordingly, Committee for the Oliver Wendell Holmes Devise. It is the power of the national courts had to be curtailed. Thus, under the aegis of this committee that the history is being the Judiciary Act of 1801-which had created the Circuit written. Mr. Haskins is personally responsible for the Courts and led to the appointment of the "Midnight volume dealing with the early period of Chief Justice Judges"-was repealed, the Circuit Courts abolished, John Marshall. His address to the annual luncheon and eighteen Federalist judges shorn of their robes. meeting of the University of Pennsylvania Chapter of Jefferson's part in engineering this repeal marked the first The Order of the Coif was based on his research for stage of his assault on the judiciary. this volume. Jefferson's second stage was to "purify" the Supreme Court. This was to be accomplished by the method of impeachment, and in 1805, Jefferson instituted the attempt to impeach Justice Chase. The title of Professor Haskins' address, "The Jefferson and the Republicans saw the Supreme Evil Practice of Majority Opinions", is a phrase bor­ Court, with its Federalist composition, as a roadblock to rowed from Thomas Jefferson's characterization of the the institution of reform and a body bent on overriding United States Supreme Court's practice in the early the will of the people and their chosen representatives. 1800's of having one justice speak for the majority. Jefferson's strong attacks on the Supreme Court, how­ Professor Haskins noted that prior to Marshall's ever, were not solely a result of his political theories. He appearance on the Supreme Court, the Court's practice had long been an inveterate enemy of his cousin, John was similar to that employed by English courts-namely, Marshall, and had publicly attacked Marshall's conduct each judge wrote a separate opinion. However, Jeffer­ and integrity on previous occasions. Professor Haskins son's attack on the Court forced the Court to adopt a noted that these factors, along with other evidence, indi­ united front and to dispense with concurring or seriatim cate that the real object of the Chase impeachment was opinions. Professor Haskins' talk dealt with the historical to institute an attack on Marshall. background for this abrupt change in judicial practice. This assault on the Court, and especially on In 1800, the Republicans drove the Federalist Marshall, continued in one form or another throughout Party from power in both the legislative and executive the early 1800's and forced the court to present a united branches of the government, and Thomas Jefferson be­ front and speak with a common voice. Professor Haskins came President. The Federalists, however, remained noted that it was quite some time before concurring strongly entrenched in the judiciary where the cloak of opinions began to reappear as part of our judicial practice.

CLASS OF 1968 SERVICE MINDED

The entering first year class in the Law School people. They have given volunteer assi s t~n c~ through includes 186 students from twenty widely scattered states boys' clubs and other community orgamzatrons. The and the District of Columbia representing sixty-two class also includes returning Peace Corpsmen. colleges. They have, of course, participate~ i? .a wide range William R. Shane, '61, Assistant Dean and Direc­ of other athletic and extra-curricular actlV!tres including tor of Admissions, characterizes the Class of 1968 as significant political work for ~oth the J?emocratic and being unusually community service minded. Many of Republican parties. Leadership potential has already them have engaged in extra-curricular tutoring of educa­ been demonstrated by the many who served as officers tionally disadvantaged children or have worked with pris­ of their class or of the various groups to which they oners, reformatory inmates and emotionally disturbed belonged.

4 LAW ALUMNI JOURNAL https://scholarship.law.upenn.edu/plj/vol1/iss1/1 6 et al.: Law Alumni Journal

UNIVERSITY OF PENNSYLVANIA

FINAL REPORT 1964-1965

EDWIN HAINES BU R G ES S 3700 NOIH" C"~•LlS $T Q< H UNIVERSI TY of PENNSYLVANI A B H H MO•( III. N ... TLMH> PHILADELPHIA 4

The Law School

OFFICE OF T H E DEAN

Oc t ob er 1, 1965 October 5 , 1965

Dean Jefferson B . Fo rdham The Law s chao 1 Edwin H. Burgess, Esquire University of Pennsylvania 3700 North Charles Stre et Baltimore 18, Nary land Philade l phia, Pennsylvania 19104

Dear Jeff : Dear Ed: It is with great pleasure that I accept your final report It gives me much pleasure to report that the sixteenth of the 1964-65 Law School Alumni Annual Giving Campaig n . The Law School Alumni An nual Giving Campaign prod uced a record­ impressive fund of $87,164 will be of great assistan ce t o us b r eaking total o f $87,164.20. This represents an increase in such areas as research, student financial aid, a n d library of about $14 , 200 o r 16.5\ over the 1963-64 amount. Alumni acquisition s . participation, although it remains at abou t 42\, was numer­ i cally greater than ever befo re. An inc rease o f 68 brought the total to 1859 contributors. We are now within a good stride of an annual level of $100,000, It is a great thing for the School to be abl e to look forward to supplemental income of this magnitud e. It I hope t h at with these funds you and your col leagues represents the yield upon capital funds of $2,500 0 00. on t he faculty can maintain that margin of excellence that 1 we all wish f o r the Law School. I can state ag ain without The Law School is deeply grateful to all who c ontrib uted q uestion that the s upport and devotion of the alumni to the to this effort. I s peak for it in e xpressi ng war m t hanks to School has ne ver been stronger or more enth usiastic than it is today . you for superb leadership as General Chairman . I extend spec ial thanks to Harris M. Wexler, Ch airman for Benjamin Frank l i n Associates; Richard P, Brown, Jr., Chairman for Century Clubt On beh alf. of the associated chairmen a nd all who worked Milton B, Garner, Chairman for Class Agents1 and J . Pennington on the campaign, I extend best wishes for institutional and Straus , Chairman for Regions, and to each class agent and person al fulfillment in the work of the School. regional chairman,

Sincerely, With every good wish, I remain

~General Chairman Law School Alumni Annual Giving

Fall 1965 5

Published by Penn Law: Legal Scholarship Repository, 2014 7 Penn Law Journal, Vol. 1, Iss. 1 [2014], Art. 1

EACH MEMBERSHIP IN THE CENTURY CLUB IS AWARDED IN RECOGNITION OF c1r A CONTRIBUTION OF ONE HUNDRED DOL­ LARS OR MORE TO THE LAW SCHOOL ALUMNI ANNUAL GIVING FUND.

THE SUSTAINING FELLOWS OF THE CEN­ TURY CLUB ARE THOSE MEMBERS WHO CHOSE TO GO BEYOND THE BASIC RE­ QUIREMENTS FOR MEMBERSHIP AND AS­ SISTED THE SCHOOL BY CONTRIBUTING TWO HUNDRED AND FIFTY DOLLARS OR MORE. Chairman-Richard P. Btown, Jr., L'48

SUSTAINING FELLOWS OF CENTURY CLUB

':'William B. Arnold, L'29 '''Melvin G. Levy, L'50 Isadore H. Bellis, L'45 Robert L. Lingelbach, L'34 ':'Richard P. Brown, Jr., L'48 Edward S. Lower, L'29 F. William Carr, L'35 •:•Desmond J. McTighe, L'25 BENJAMIN Hon. Vincent A. Carroll, L' 14 '''Raymond Pearlstine, L'32 Philip Dechert, L'30 •:·G. Ruhland Rebmann, L'22 FRANKLIN Laurence H. Eldredge, L'27 Theodore 0. Rogers, L'40 Herman M. Ellis, L'28 Paul N. Schaeffer, L'14 ':'Jefferson B. Fordham •:• Marvin Schwartz, L'49J ASSOCIATES •:'Robert M. Gilkey, L' 15 Emanuel G . Scoblionko, L'34 •:•Edward Hopkinson, Jr., L' 10 '''William G. Stathers, L'14 •:•william H. Kresch, L'30 Brig. Gen. John Thomas Taylor, L'l4 THE BENJAMIN FRANKLIN ASSOCIATES •:•Bernard V. Lentz, L'36 Robert S. Trigg, L'51 ARE A UNIVERSITY-WIDE GROUP OF •:•r ra Jewell Williams, L'97 ALUMNI AND FRIENDS WHO CONTRIB­ UTE ONE THOUSAND DOLLARS OR MORE TO THE ALUMNI ANNUAL GIVING FUND. John Charles Adams, L' 14 Edward V. Buckley, L'24 •:·walter M. Burkhardt, L' 14 LISTED ARE LAW SCHOOL ALUMNI WHO Alexander B. Adelman, L'3 1 •:•Philip Werner Amram, L'27 '''Harold F. Butler, L'22 JOINED THE BENJAMIN FRANKLIN David F. Anderson, L'33 J. Russell Cades, L'28 ASSOCIATES. James R. Anderson, Jr., L'31 Milton Cades, GL'37 Erich 0. Angermann, L'26 ':'Francis J. Carey, Jr. , L'49J Vincent J. Apruzzese, L'53 '''James D. Carpenter, L'08 Harris C. Arnold, L'25 Meyer L. Casman, L' 17 Chairman for the Law School Harry Norman Ball, L'28 Sidney Chait, L'33 -Morris M. Wexler, L'27 Augustus S. Ballard, L'48 Keron D. Chance, L'38 Hon. Alexander F. Barbieri, L'32 '''E. Calvert Cheston, L'35 *The late Albert Blumberg, L'33 •:•Ralph M. Barley, L'38 '''Morris Cheston, L'28 Max M. Batzer, L'33 Roland J. Christy, L'34 *Edwin H. Burgess, L'14 •:•walter W. Beachboard, L'32 •:• HeathS. Clark, L' 16 Sylvan M. Cohen, L'38 Thomas J. Beddow, L'39 '''Hon. JosephS. Clark, L'26 *Robert Dechert, L'21 '''Paul Bedford, L'OO •:• Roderick T. Clarke, L'36 L. Leroy Deininger, L'14 Sanford D . Beecher, L'28 Bert Cohen, L'99 •:•Hon. John C. Bell, Jr., L'17 David Cohen, L'37 Wilmot Fleming '''Robert K. Bell, L'24 •:•Hon. Herbert B. Cohen, L'25 *John F. Headly, L'27 •:•David Berger, L'36 William H. Conca, L'34 J. H. Ward Hinkson, L'22 Milton Berger, L'29 Alexander Conn, L' 14 Charles M. Justi, L'27 Leonard J. Bernstein, L'34 Charles R. Cooper, Jr., L'47 Marshall A. Bernstein, L'49J C. Russell Corson, L' 14 *Arthur Littleton, L'20 ':'Robert M. Bernstein, L'14 Hon. George C. Corson, L'14 W. James Macintosh, L'26 James E. Birdsall, L'36 '''Stuart Coven, L'51 Frank H. Mancil!, L'14 •:•samuel A. Blank, L'32 •:•Cassin W. Craig, L'49F David F. Maxwell, L'24 James C. Bly, L'46 •:•Albert J. Crawford, Jr., L'39 William Carson Bodi ne, L'32 •:•Ralph W. Crowell, L'l5 John L. McDonald, L'40 Francis H. Bohlen, Jr., L'21 Clive S. Cummis, L'52 Albert B. Melnick, L'27 •:• Rodney T. Bonsall, L' 17 •:•Guy W. Davis, L'27 *Morton Myers, L'25 Bernard M. Borish, L'43 J. Lawrence Davis, L'28 Benjamin H. Oehlert, Jr., L'33 •:•Cl ifford M. Bowden, L'28 Hon. John Morgan Davis, L'32 Hon. John A. Boyle, L' l4 William R. Deasey, L'49F Edmond H. Rogers, L' 12 '''John P. Bracken, L'3 9 Daniel De Brier, L'29 *Maurice B. Saul, L'05 Raymond J. Bradley, L'47 •:•Guy G. de Furia, L'28 H. James Sautter, L' 14 JohnS. Bradway, L'14 Joseph W. de Furia, L'35 Floyd E. Brandow, Jr., L'54 •:• Raymond K. Denworth, L' 17 Yale Schekter, L'14 Park B. Dilks, L'51 *William A. Schnader, L'12 Joseph Brandschai n, L'28 Hon. Jasper Yates Bri nton, L'Ol Ralph B. D'Jorio, L'49F *Bernard G. Segal, L'31 Mitchell Brock, L'53 ':'James B. Doak, L'35 Clarke M. Seltzer, L'14 Gerald Broker, L'59 Robert J. Dodds, Jr., L'40 Morris M. Wexler, L'27 Wallace Bromley, L' !O Miss Ethel F . Donaghue, L'20 •:•Hon. Francis Shunk Brown, Jr., L'16 •:•charles H. Dorsett, L'35 Hon. Hazel H . Brown, L'24 Hon. James H. Duff, L'07 *Denotes 5 or more consecutive years as a Arthur M. Eastburn, L'll Benjamin Franklin Associate. Herman M. Buck, L'35

LAW ALUMNI JOURNAL https://scholarship.law.upenn.edu/plj/vol1/iss1/16 8 et al.: Law Alumni Journal

'''Robert J. Eby, L'06 Emanuel H. Klein, L'40 P. Herbert Reigner, L' 17 WilliamS. Eisenhart, Jr., L'40 ''' Benjamin M. Kline, L'16 Paul H. Rhoads, L'31 Aaron Eisenstein, L'34 Meyer Kramer, L'44 '''Victor J. Roberts, L'37 Hon. Harold L. Ervin, L'20 Otto Kraus, Jr., L'08 Milton W. Rosen, L'41 Bernard Eskin, L'35 Aaron Kravitch, L' 17 David H . Rosenbluth, L'33 Harold Evans, L'lO Herman H. Krekstein, L'22 Samuel M. Rosenfeld, L'30 John Kennedy Ewing, III, L'27 David H. Kubert, L'32 Max Rosenn, L'32 Richard J. Farrell, L'41 George C. Laub, L'36 Hon. Samuel Y. Rossiter, L'1 3 Albert J. Feldman, L'53 SamuelS. Laucks, Jr., L'42 William Rowe, L'27 Joseph G. Feldman, L'26 Nathan Lavine, L'31 '''Wi ll iam B. Rudenko, L'32 Barton E. Ferst, L'44 Erwin Lerten, L'40 ''' W. Albert Sanders, L'31 Mrs. Myrna Paul Field, L'63 Louis Levinson, L' 14 '''Alex Satinsky, L'37 Joseph M. First, L'30 Louis E. levinthal, L'l6 Hon. Edwin H . Satterthwaite, L'40 '''Eugene C. Fish, L'34 Arthur Levy, L'55 ''' Hon. Harold D. Saylor, L' 17 Joseph P. Flanagan, Jr., L'52 Hon. Thomas M. Lewis, L'16 '''James W. Scanlon, L'30 Bernard Frank, L'38 '''William Barclay Lex, L'l2 '''John N . Schaeffer, Jr., L'37 Harry Friedman, L'27 Joseph H. Lieberman, L' 17 '''Nathan J. Schneider, L'27 '''Fred T. Fruit, L' 11 ''' Robert C. Ligget, L' 17 '''Andrew J. Schroder, II, L'30 Carl W. Funk, L'25 Hon. Abraham H. Lipez, L'29 '''lloyd J. Schumacker, L'30 John J. Galbally, L'51 '''Louis Lipschitz, L'27 Louis B. Schwartz, L'35 Milton B. Garner, L'36 SamuelS. Logan, L'41 '''Ernest Scott, L'29 Sylvester S. Garrett, L'36 '''Hon. JosephS. Lord, III, L'36 W. Frazier Scott, L'39 RobertS. Gawthrop, Jr., L'39 Wilfred R. Lorry, L'30 '''Irving R. Segal, L'38 ''' Jacques H. Geisenberger, L'27 ''' John G . Love, L'2 1 Milton H. Shapiro, L'40 Morris B. Gelb, L'29 ''' Daniel Lowenthal, L'31 W. Simms Sharninghausen, L'39 Frank H. Gelman, L'35 '''Edwin A. Lucas, L' l7 Robert M. Shay, L'61 '" Kenneth W. Gemmill, L'35 James C. Luitweiler, L'14 ''Hon. Charles A. Shea, Jr., L'36 Harry J. Gerber, L' 14 Hon. Alfred L. Luongo, L'47 ''' G. William Shea, L'36 Lewis M. Gill, L'36 ''' Harry K. Madway, L'36 Nathan Silberstein, L'33 William Ginsburg, L' 14 '''D. Arthur Magaziner, L' 14 Seymour S. Silverstone, L'25 Frederick P. Glick, L'3 5 David S. Malis, L' 11 '''Charles D. Smeltzer, L'24 '''Louis J. Goffman, L'35 Otto P. Mann, L'20 '''Alan J. Smith, L'29 Henry J. Goldberg, L'3 3 Robert Margolis, L'48 '''Carl D. Smith, L'07 ''' Hyman Goldberg, L'37 Jerome L. Markovitz, L'33 '''Geoffrey S. Smith, L'25 (in memory of Kalman Altman) '''Albert J. Marks, L' 17 Elvin R. Souder, L'42 Samuel A. Goldberg, L'23 James F. Masterson. l' 15 Samuel l. Sperling, L'32 ''' Jose ph K. Gordon, L'5 1 William L. Matz, L'29 Hen. Maurice W. Sporkin, L' 17 Mortimer E. Graham, L'25 ''' Baldwin Maull, L'25 Sigmund H. Steinberg, L'24 Philip R. Grant, L'50 '''Thomas McConnell, L'22 Lee N . Steiner, L'49F ''' Joseph A. Grazier, L'28 Jack J. McDowell, L'3 1 Philip Sterling, L' I 0 Oliver F. Green, Jr., L'51 '''Toin l. McDowell, L'36 Guy K. Stewart, L'32 Harry Arthur Greenberg, L'38 ''' Hugh P. McFadden, L'28 Thomas H. Stewart, L'5 l '''A lbert M. Greenfield, L'06 Hon. Thomas C. McGrath, L'57 ''' J. Pennington Straus, L'35 Harold D. Greenwell , L'27 ''' William B. Mcintosh, L'17 '''AaronS. Swartz, L'll W. Edward Greenwood, L'29 George W. McKee, L'34 '''Leonard A. Talone, L'30 '''Mary E. Groff, L'32 leon Meltzer, L'26 William E. Taylor, Jr., L'44 ''' Paul l. Guest, L'4l '''Thomas P. Mikell, L'27 Charles C. Townse nd , L'27 louis S. Hankin, L'37 A. Arthur Miller, L'34 ''' Robert l. Trescher, L'37 William D. Harkin s, L'22 Mrs. Dorothea Grater Minskoff, L'34 ''' Eugene K. Twining, L'33 Robert A. Hauslohner, L'50 Samuel W. Morris, L'49 Robert W. Valimont, L'49J John F. Healy , L'5l Emanuel Moss, L'20 Frederick A. VanDenbe rgh, Jr., L'37 ''' Jesse G. Heiges, L'38 ''' John C. Mueller, L'59 '''Charles B. P. Van Pelt, L'49F '''George K. Helbert, L'l 1 Paul A. Mueller, Jr., L'55 ''' Hon. Joseph Varbalow, L'1 7 Estate of George M. Hen ry, L'04 David H. Nelson, L'49J Maxwell E. Verlin, L'26 Charles J. Hepburn, Jr., L'35 Philip F. Newman, L' l7 Theodore Voorhees, L'29 Carl J. W. Hessinger, L'40 Eugene Nogi , L'32 Howard K. Wallace, L' 16 ''' Donald E. Hittle, L'42 ''' leon J. Obermayer, L'08 G uy E. Waltman, L'29 Edward B. Hodge, L'3 1 '''Thomas A. O'Boyle, L'40 ''' Stewart E. Warner, L'27 leon C. Holt, Jr., L'51 ''' John J. O'Brien, L'08 Wendell E. Warner, L'24 John 0. Honnold, Jr. Hon. Arturo Ortiz-Toro, L' 17 Mrs. Helen Moran Warren, L'30 Francis Hopkinson, L'40 Isidor Ostroff, L'30 Richard H. Warren, L'51 Andrew Hourigan, Jr., L'40 '''Gilbert W. Oswald, L'34 Hon. Gerald J. Weber, L'39 '''Samuel L. Howell, L'l l '''George Ovington, Jr., L'07 "'Wi lton W. Webster, L'I2 William S. Hudders, L'29 George Ovington, 3rd, L'40 JosephS. Weinfeld , L'3 1 ''' Hon. William F. Hyland, L'49J ''' Israe l Packet L'3 2 Jerome B. Weinstein, L'34 Joseph G . Jackson, L'29 Charles C. P~rli n , Jr., L'49J Lewis Weinstock, L'40 PaulL. Jaffe, L'50 Henry N. Paul, Jr., L'25 Sidney L. Weintraub, L'25 '''James L. Johnson, L'33 J. Craig Peacock, L' 12 H . John Weisman, L'42 Edward L. Jones, Jr., L'61 Morris Pfaelzer, 2nd, L'38 ''' Morri s Weisman, L'27 Ralph V. Jones, L'54 ''' Hon. Frank L. Pinola, L' 15 Lloyd B. White, L'50 '''Vernon S. Jones, L'l 6 Harry Polikoff, L'3 I ''' Thomas Raeburn White, Jr., L'36 ''' John Pemberton Jordan, L'28 Herman l. Pollock, L'27 William White, Jr., L'38 Lester E. Kabacoff, L'37 Herman B. Poul, L'38 ''' Morton Witkin L'l7 Lewis Kates, L'59 Howard I. Powell, L'I6 ''' Morris Wolf, L''o3 Solomon Katz, L'48 John B. Prather, L'27 H. Albert Young, L'29 ''' Ernest R. Keiter, L'l 9 Ernest D. Preate, L'34 John R. Young, L'30 Hon. Bernard J. Kelley, L'26 Lipman Redman, L'41 ''' Judah Zelitch, L'27 Robert G. Kelly, L'36 W. Foster Reeve, L' 17 ''' Davi d B. Zoob, L'27 William F. Kennedy, L'29 Pace Reich, L'54 F ra ncis J. Zugehoer, L'3 5 ''' lewis H. Kirk , L'l5 ''' Denotes 5 or more consecutive years as a Century Club Membe r.

Fall 1965 7 Published by Penn Law: Legal Scholarship Repository, 2014 9 Penn Law Journal, Vol. 1, Iss. 1 [2014], Art. 1

REPORT OF CLASSES Chairman-Milton B. Garner, L'36 1964-1965 1963-1964 No. in No. Per Cent N o. Per Cent Class Agent Class Giving Giving Amoun t Giving Giving Amount Non Alumni 4 $1,355.00 3 $1 ,750.00 1882-99 Milton B. Garner 14 5 36 430.00 6 30 250.00 1900 Charles H. Howson, dec'd 8 6 75 165.00 6 55 165.00 !901 Edwin Emhardt 4 2 50 125.00 1 25 25.00 1902 Joseph Sternberger 6 2 33 15.00 3 43 30.00 1903 Hon. L. Stauffer Oliver 16 4 25 170.00 4 24 185.00 !904 Milton B. Garner 6 3 50 30.00 2 20 27.00 1905 Frank G. Sayre, dec'd 13 3 23 1,020.00 9 64 1,105.00 1906 John Martin Doyle 9 4 45 125.00 6 55 360.00 1907 Stanley W. Root 12 6 50 345 .00 5 42 335.00 !908 John Arthur Brown 18 9 50 590.00 9 43 470.00 1909 Joseph J. Tunney 14 3 2 1 25.00 5 36 60.00 1910 Wallace Bromley 28 13 46 651.00 14 47 526.00 1911 Milton B. Garner 21 9 43 68 5.00 8 36 585.00 1912 Milton B. Garner 27 6 22 1,538.7 3 5 18 1,385.00 1913 Samuel R. Rosenbaum 24 8 33 270. 00 II 44 385.00 1914 Frank H. Mancill 39 37 95 II ,430.00 19 52 6,346.94 1915 James F. Masterson 31 12 39 1,270.00 13 40 1,540.00 1916 Martin Feldman 33 22 69 993 .00 23 70 745.00 1917 Raymond K. Denworth 51 30 59 2,295.00 32 62 2,045.00 1918-19 Milton B. Garner 14 3 2 1 165.00 3 20 130.00 1920 Otto P. Mann 17 9 53 1,600.00 9 50 1,500.00 1921 William I. Woodcock, Jr. 19 !5 79 910.00 14 74 1,540.00 1922 E. Perry Campbell 42 18 43 1,978.00 20 47 1,907.50 1923 Samuel Goldberg 20 10 50 2 17.00 9 41 202.00 1924 William C. Ferguson, Jr. 36 15 42 1,311.88 18 50 855.00 1925 Desmond J. McTighe 42 21 50 2,325.00 20 47 1,950.00 1926 Joseph G. Feldman 38 13 34 1,221 .00 14 36 1,166.00 1927 Herman I. Pollock 8 1 39 48 5,852.50 43 52 4,693 .3 1 1928 Sanford D. Beecher 76 30 40 1,705.00 30 38 1,192.50 1929 Alan J. Smith 88 31 35 2,045.00 28 32 1,785.00 1930 J. Russell Gibbons 98 35 36 2,229.50 32 33 1,778.05 1931 Knox Henderson 11 4 46 40 3,030.00 46 40 2,800.00 1932 Walter W. Beachboard 97 27 28 1,770.00 26 27 I ,423.50 1933 Nathan Silberstein 89 39 44 2,8 42.50 46 51 3,854.00 1934 Roland J. Christy 85 32 38 1,864.44 30 36 2,403.63 1935 Frank E. Hahn, Jr. 93 42 45 2,055.00 38 40 1,770.00 1936 Milton B. Garner 10 1 36 36 2,069.00 37 36 1,928.00 1937 F. A. VanDenbergh, Jr. 10 1 32 32 1,291.00 32 33 1,297.50 1938 Raymond J. Broderick 85 35 4 1 1,97 1.00 36 42 1,546.00 1939 Arthur R. Kane, Jr. & James Hunter, III 88 43 49 1,625.00 45 53 I ,465.00 1940 Lewis Weinstock 96 36 37 1,712.50 26 27 695 .00 1941 Paul A. Welkin 102 45 45 I ,256.00 4 1 40 953.50 1942 F. L. Ballard, Jr. 72 24 33 890.00 20 28 640.00 1943 Robert Hachenburg 48 8 17 220.00 12 24 270.00 1944 Barton E. Ferst 23 II 48 425.00 10 46 310.00 1945 Milton B. Garner 9 7 78 400.00 6 67 125.00 1946 John L. Esterhai & James C. Bly 27 12 45 225.00 8 30 180.00 1947 Robert M. Landis 75 18 24 605.00 22 29 485.00 1948 Raymond Jenkins 131 46 35 1,350.00 47 36 1,140.00 1949F Henry N. Platt, Jr. 87 36 4 1 1,216.00 28 32 891.67 1949J Thomas Mcivor 75 40 53 1,318.50 36 48 I ,048.37 1950 Stephen J. Kern !00 46 46 1,340.00 43 43 1,054.00 1951 John J. Galbally 130 58 45 2,028.00 54 42 1,296.8 1 1952 Joseph P. Flanagan 121 44 36 912.50 43 36 765.00 1953 Leonard Barkan ]37 59 43 1,161.00 57 42 960.00 1954 Morris M. Shuster 90 42 47 830.50 51 57 91 4.00 1955 Robert Kendall & Irving M. Hirsh !03 50 49 963 .00 47 48 776.00 1956 Alan G. Kirk, IT & Carl Schneider 125 62 50 846.00 53 44 55 8. 00 1957 Richard Schneider 10 1 54 54 664.00 56 58 574.00 1958 George B. McNelis !29 50 39 759.50 66 52 839.00 1959 George F. Reed 152 53 35 1,006.77 63 43 831.00 1960 Nicholas D . Vadino !1 7 35 30 435.00 31 29 270.00 1961 Raymond K. Denworth, Jr. 11 2 61 55 848.50 74 67 858.00 1962 E. Barclay Cale 127 76 60 744.50 90 75 751.00 1963 John L. Harrison 144 64 45 768 .00 48 36 33 8.00 1964 William J. Levy 145 67 46 633.38 4,374 1,860 42% $87,164.20 1,791 42% $72,935.33 Thirty-seven classes reported a gain in per cent of participation over last year; twenty-five classes failed to achieve as high a percentt:ge as last year; three classes reported no change in percentage; 8 the Class of 1964 has no comparative figures. LAW ALUMNI JOURNAL https://scholarship.law.upenn.edu/plj/vol1/iss1/1 10 et al.: Law Alumni Journal

Members of the Class of 1915 Law attending th e luncheon on Law Alumni Day. They are (1. to r.) H on. Robert V. Bolger, J. Wesley M cWilliams, James F. Masterson, Arnold M. Blumberg, and Hon. James F. Henninger.

CLASS PERFORMANCES ABOVE AVERAGE These Classes Equalled or Bettered the Over-all GREATEST NUMBER Alumni Participation of 42%: OF DOLLARS CONTRIBUTED Year Agent Per Cent 1914 Frank H. Mancil! 95 Class Agent Amount 1921 William I. Woodcock, Jr. (Under 25 members) 79 1945 (Handled by Class Agent Chairman) 191 4 Frank H . Mancill $11,430.00 (Under 25 members) 78 1927 Herman I. Pollock 5,852.50 1900 Charles H. Howson (Deceased) (Under 25 members) 75 1931 Knox Henderson 3,030.00 1916 Martin Feldman 69 1962 E. Barclay Cale 60 1917 Raymond K. Denworth 59 GREATEST NUMBER OF CONTRIBUTORS 1961 Raymond K. Denworth, Jr. 55 1957 Richard G. Schneider 54 Class A gent Number 1920 Otto P. Mann (Under 25 members) 53 1949J Thomas Mcivor 53 1962 E. Barclay Cale 76 1901 Edwin Emhardt (Under 25 members) 50 1964 William J. Levy 67 1904 (Handled by Class Agent Chairman) (Under 25 members) 50 1963 John L. Harrison 64 1907 Stanley W. Root (Under 25 members) 50 1908 John Arthur Brown (Under 25 members) 50 1923 Samuel Goldberg (Under 25 members) 50 BEST PER CENT OF PARTICIPATION 1925 Desmond J. McTighe 50 1956 Alan G . Kirk, II & Carl W. Schneider 50 (Classes of 25 or more) 1939 Arthur R. Kane, Jr. & James Hunter, III 49 1955 Robert Kendall & Irving M. Hirsh 49 Class Agent Per Cent 1944 Barton E. Ferst (Under 25 members) 48 1927 Herman I. Pollock 48 19 14 Frank H. Mancill 95 1954 Morris M. Shuster 47 19 16 Martin Feldman 69 1910 Wallace Bromley 46 1950 Stephen J. Korn 46 1962 E. Barclay Cale 60 1964 William J. Levy 46 1906 John Martin Doyle (Under 25 members) 45 1935 F rank E. Hahn, Jr. 45 BEST PER CENT OF PARTICIPATION 1946 John L. Esterhai & James C. Bly 45 1941 Paul A. Wolkin 45 (Classes of less than 25) 1951 John J. Galball y 45 1933 Nathan Silberstein 44 Class Agent Per Cent 1963 John L. Harrison 44 1921 William I. Woodcock, Jr. 79 1911 (Handled by Class Agent Chairman) (Unde r 25 members) 43 1945 (Handled by Class Agent Chairman) 78 1922 E. Perry Campbell 43 1953 Leonard Barkan 43 1900 Charles H. Howson (Deceased) 75 1924 William C. Ferguson, Jr. 42 Fall 1965 9 Published by Penn Law: Legal Scholarship Repository, 2014 11 Penn Law Journal, Vol. 1, Iss. 1 [2014], Art. 1 CONTRIBUTORS

NON-ALUMNI CLASS OF 1906 CLASS OF 1912 Robert F. Irwin, Jr. Number Giving 4 John Martin Doyle, Agent Number Giving 6 Lewis H. Kirk Amount $1,355.00 Per Cent Giving 22 James F. Masterson Number Giving 4 Hon. Frank L. Pinola Wilmot E. Fleming Per Cent Giving 45 Amount $1,538.73 Jefferson B. Fordham Harry N. Brenner Thomas Reath Amount $125.00 Alexander N. Rubin John 0. Honnold, Jr. John Martin Doyle W. Barclay Lex Mrs. F. A. Weisenback Robert J. Eby James C . Peacock CLASS OF 1916 Edmund H. Rogers CLASS OF 1897 Albert M. Greenfield Martin Feldman, Agent Isaac W. Roberts William A. Schnader Number Giving 2 Wilton W. Webster Number Giving 22 Per Cent Giving 29 CLASS OF 1907 Per Cent Giving 69 Amount $255.00 CLASS OF 1913 Amount $993.00 Stanley W. Root, Agent Charles E. Blackburn Samuel R. Rosenbaum, Agent James M. Brittain Ira Jewell Williams Number Giving 6 Number Giving 8 Hon. Francis Shunk Per Cent Giving 50 CLASS OF 1899 Per Cent Giving 33 Brown, Jr. Amount $345.00 Amount $270.00 Heath S. Clark Number Giving 3 Hon. James H. Duff Joseph L. Ehrenreich Per Cent Giving Schofield Andrews 43 Edward W. Evans Harry Feinstein Amount $175.00 Isidore Baylson Louis M. Fleisher Joseph J. Brown Martin Feldman Bert Cohen George Ovington, Jr. Edward T. Curry Benjamin B. Hoar Marcus S. Hottenstein Stanley W. Root Percy C. Madeira, Jr. Vernon S. Jones Charles Kuschke Carl D. Smith Bertram P. Rambo Robert G. Kleckner Benjamin M. Kline CLASS OF 1900 CLASS OF 1908 Samuel R. Rosenbaum Hon. Samuel Y. Rossiter Harry G. Lenzner The Late Charles H. John Arthur Brown, Agent Howson, Agent Hon. Louis E. Levinthal Number Giving 9 CLASS OF 1914 Hon. Thomas M. Lewis Number Giving 6 Per Cent Giving 50 Frank H. Mancill, Agent Howard I. Powell Per Cent Giving 75 Amount $590.00 Wolter L. Rodman Amount $165.00 Number Giving 37 John Arthur Brown Per Cent Giving 95 Thomas E. Shipley William S. Allen James D. Carpenter Amount $11 ,430.00 Elmer D. Simon Paul Bedford Moses J. Slonim Randolph W. Childs Harry S. Abrams Albert N. Garrett Robert T. Fox Edward Stone Charles H. Howson 1. Charles Adams Paul C. Wagner T. Walter Gilkyson Robert M. Bernstein Wilfred B. Wolcott Otto Kraus, Jr. Howard K. Wallace Hon. Charles A. Wolverton Hon. John A. Boyle Aaron Weiss Leigh M. Morss John S. Bradway CLASS OF 1901 Leon J. Obermayer Edwin H . Burgess CLASS OF 1917 John J. O'Brien Walter M. Burkhardt Edwin C. Emhardt, Agent Raymond K. Denworth, Number Giving 2 Hon. Vincent A. Carroll CLASS OF 1909 Alexander Conn Agent Per Cent Giving 50 Number Giving 30 Amount $125.00 Joseph J. Tunney, Agent C. Russell Corson Number Giving 3 Hon. George C. Corson Per Cent Giving 59 Hon. Jasper Yates Brinton L. Leroy Deininger Amount $2,295.00 Edwin C. Emhardt Per Cent Giving 21 Amount $25.00 Roy A. DeLong Harry E. Apeler CLASS OF 1902 Louis W. Robey Lewis J. Finestone Hon. John C. Bell, Jr. Joseph Sternberger, Agent Joseph J. Tunney Domenic Furia Rodney T. Bonsall Harry J. Gerber Meyer L. Casman Number Giving Russell Wolfe 2 William Ginsburg Edward Davis Per Cent Giving 33 Amount CLASS OF 1910 Hon. Lynn B. Griffith Raymond K. Denworth $15.00 John J. Goldy Wallace Bromley, Agent Romain C. Hassrick Hon. Edwin 0. Lewis Robert D. Hughes M. Joseph Greenblatt Joseph Sternberger Number Giving 13 Louis Levinson Hon. T. Linus Hoban Per Cent Giving 46 CLASS OF 1903 James C . Luitweiler Aaron Kravitch Amount $651.00 D. Arthur Magaziner Joseph H. Lieberman Hon. L. Stauffer Oliver, Wallace Bromley Frank H. Mancill Robert C. Ligget Agent Hon. E. Wallace Chadwick Mark T. Milnor Edwin A. Lucas Number Giving 4 Harold Evans William N. Ottinger Albert J. Marks Per Cent Giving 25 Roland C. Heisler Theodore S. Paul William B. Mcintosh Amount $170.00 Edward Hopkinson, Jr. H. James Sautter Marshall H . Morgan Benjamin Dintenfass Sidney Loewenstein Charles C. Savage, Jr. Philip F. Newman Hon. L. Stauffer Oliver Hon. Byron A. Milner Hon. Paul N . Schaeffer Hon. Arturo Ortiz-Toro Walter B. Saul Isaac T. Porter Yale L. Schekter Mrs. Rose Lerner Perlman Morris Wolf Hon. Forrest R. Shanaman Benjamin Schmerer W. Foster Reeve, 3rd Mrs. Rebecca Roberts Shelly Clarke M. Seltzer P. Herbert Reigner CLASS OF 1904 Francis A. Stanger, Jr. William G. Stathers Paul M. Robinson Number Giving 3 Philip Sterling Herman J . Tahl Maurice Saeta Per Cent Giving 50 Hon. W. Butler Windle Brig. Gen. John Thomas Hon. Harold D. Saylor Amount $30.00 Taylor Claude C. Smith Estate of George M. Henry CLASS OF 191 1 Charles S. Thompson Hon. Maurice W. Sporkin Estate of David Levinson Number Giving 9 Edward J. Swotes William C. Longstreth Per Cent Giving 43 CLASS OF 1915 Mervin R. Turk James F . Masterson, Agent Hon. Joseph Varbalow CLASS OF 1905 Amount $685.00 Ralph J. Baker Number Giving 12 Morton Witkin The Late Frank G. Sayre, Per Cent Giving 39 Agent Arthur M. Eastburn CLASS OF 1918-19 Fred T. Fruit Amount $1,270.00 Number Giving 3 George K. Helbert Justin S. Bamberger Number Giving 3 Per Cent Giving 23 Hubert J. Horan, Jr. Ralph W. Crowell Per Cent Giving 21 Amount $1,020.00 Samuel L. Howell R. McCall Gilkey Amount $165.00 Eugene S. Richardson David S. Malis David D. Goff Joseph H. Grubb, Jr. Maurice B. Saul Joseph Rosenstein Hon. James F. Henninger Ernest R. Keiter Frank G. Sayre AaronS. Swartz, Jr. Gilbert R. Hughes Ernest N. Votaw

10 LAW ALUMNI JOURNAL https://scholarship.law.upenn.edu/plj/vol1/iss1/1 12 et al.: Law Alumni Journal

CLASS OF 1920 CLASS OF 1924 Herman Eisenberg Morris B. Gelb Otto P. Mann, Agent Wm. C. Ferguson, Jr., Agent Laurence Eldredge Walter E. Greenwood, Jr. John Kennedy Ewing, III Edmund P. Hannum Number Giving Number Giving 15 9 Per Cent Giving 42 Harry Friedman Gilbert G. Harris Per Cent Giving 53 Amount $1,311.88 Jacques H. Geisenberger W. Lester Henry Amount $1,600.00 Nathan Goldman Albert M. Hoyt, Jr. Robert K. Bell Harold D. Greenwell William S. Hudders Miss Ethel F. Donaghue Benjamin N. Brown Michael H. Gurbarg Joseph G . Jackson Hon. Harold L. Ervin Hon. Hazel H. Brown John Harper Wil liam F. Kennedy Bernard L. Frankel Edward V. Buckley John F. Headly Hon. Abraham H. Lipez Arthur Littleton Mrs. Ida Oranovich Creskoff Harold H. Hoffman Edward S. Lower Otto P. Mann William C. Ferguson, Jr. Charles M. Justi Samuel Marx Emanuel Moss Edward H. P. Fronefield Louis Lipschitz William L. Matz Harry Polish Thomas M. Johnston Joseph A. Matt William L. Rubin Eugene H. Southall Harry Kaufman Albert B. Melnik Sidney Schulman Donald H. Williams Richard H. Klein Thomas P. Mikell Ernest Scott David F. Maxwell Herman I. Pollock Louis Sherr CLASS OF 1921 Philip S. Polis John B. Prather Hon. Kendall H. Shoyer Wm. I. Woodcock, Jr., Agent Charles D. Smeltze r Rev. Elwood F. Reeves, Jr. Alan J. Smith Sigmund Stei nberg William Rowe Theodore Voorhees Number Giving 15 Wendell E. Warner Nathan J. Schneider Guy E. Waltman Per Cent Giving 79 CLASS OF 1925 Manuel Sidkoff W. Wyclif Walton Amount $91 0.00 Desmond J. McTighe, A gent C. Leo Sutton H. Albert Young Charles C. Townsend Joseph F. M. Baldi N umber Giving 2 1 CLASS OF 1930 Samuel J. Becker Stewart E. Warner Per Cent Giving 50 Morris Weisman J. Russell Gibbons, Agent Francis H. Bohlen, Jr. Amount $2,325.00 A. Samuel Buchman William N. West, 3rd Number Giving 35 Robert Dechert Harri s C. Arnold Morris M. Wexler Per Cent Giving 36 Henry M. Dubbs, Jr. Laurence Brunswick John H. Wharton Amount $2,229.50 Benjamin C. Jones Hon. Herbert B. Cohen Judah Zelitch Samuel A. Armstrong Armand L. Koethen Meyer E. Cooper David B. Zoob George M. Brodhead Michael Edelman John G. Love CLASS OF 1928 Philip Dechert Clarence G . Myers Francis I. Farley George C. Denniston J. Howard Neely, Jr. Carl W. Funk Sanford D. Beecher, Agent Samuel E. Ewing John Russell, Jr. Mortimer E. Graham Number Giving 30 Joseph First Joseph Smith Samuel R. Greenwald Per Cent Giving 40 Edward W. Furia Isadore S. Wachs Charles P. Larkin, Jr. Amount $1,705.00 J. Russell Gibbons William I. Woodcock, Jr. Baldwin Mau ll Harry Norman Ball Samuel E. Gilbert Desmond J. McTighe Sanford D. Beecher Louis Gorrin CLASS OF 1922 Morton Meyers Franklin H. Berry Stanley Jakubowski Rabbi Louis Parris Clifford M. Bowden Norman J. Kalcheim E. Perry Campbell, Agent Henry N. Paul, Jr. Joseph Brandschain Joseph Kaplan Number Giving 18 James B. Sayers J. Russell Cades Herman Krakovitz Per Cent Giving 43 Walter Sei le r William V. Cherry William H. Kresch Amount $1 ,978.00 Seymour S. Silverstone Morris Cheston I. Harry Levin Geoffrey S. Smith J. Lawrence Davis Herbert M. Levy Franklin H. Bates Sydney L. Weintraub Guy G . deF uri a Wilfred R. Lorry Harold F. Butler Hon. J. Colvin Wright Herman M. Ellis Elias Magi! E. Perry Campbell CLASS OF 1926 David H. Frantz James W. Marvin W. Meade Fletcher, Jr. Clarence Mesirov Joseph G. Feldman, Agent Joseph A. Grazier William D. Harkins Martin Greenblatt Tsidor Ostroff J. H. Ward Hinkson Number Giving 13 Jesse Hyman Samuel M. Rosenfeld Frederick H . Knight Per Cent Giving 34 John P. Jordan James W. Scanlon Herman H. Krekstein Amount $1,221.00 Harrison G. Ki ldare Andrew J. Schroder, II Thomas McConnell, 3rd Erich 0. Angermann Samuel P. Lavine Lloyd J. Schumacker Hon. Leo H. McKay Henry W. Balka Hon. Paul S. Lehman Norman Snyder Clarence A. Patterson Julius C. Baylinson Abraham Levin Herman W. Steerman Edward A. G. Porter J. Warren Brock Hugh P. McFadden Alexander T. Stein G. Ruhland Rebmann, Jr. Hon. Joseph S. Clark, Jr. James A. Montgomery, Jr. Leonard A. Talone Henry D. M. Sherrerd Joseph G. Feldman Harold B. Ramsey Mrs. Helen Moran Warren A. Carson Simpson Rev. Edward B. Guerry Benson N. Schambelan F. N. Weidner, Jr. Arthur B. VanBuskirk John F . E. Hippe! A. Allen Simon Carroll R. We tzel Miss Sybil U. Ward Hon. Bernard J. Kelley Lawrence M. C. Smith John R. Young Allen H. White W. James Macintosh Leon Sobel Bernard M. Zimmerman Leon Meltzer Robert Stucke nrath CLASS OF 1923 Frank M. Travaline, Jr. Joseph Weintraub CLASS OF 1931 Samuel A. Gold be rg, Agent Maxwell E. Verlin Edward S. Weyl Knox Henderson, Agent Number Giving 46 Number Giving 10 CLASS OF 1927 CLASS OF 1929 Per Cent Giving 40 Per Cent Givi ng 50 Herman I. Pollock, Agent Alan J. Smith, Agent · Amount $3,030.00 Amount $217.00 Number Giving 39 Number Giving 31 Alexander B. Adelman Hon. E. Arnold Forrest Per Cent Giving 48 Per Cent Giving 35 Nathan Agran Samuel A. Goldberg Amount $5,852.50 Amount $2,045.00 Philip I. N. Alperdt Cadmus Z. Gordon, Jr. Herman P. Abramson William B. Arnold James R. Anderson, Jr. Hon. George W. Griffith Mrs. S. Mossell Alexander John H . Austin Joseph Atlas Henry R. Heebner Philip Werner Amram Mi lton Berger Arthur W. Bean Penrose Hertzler F rancis J. Beckley Herman Cohen Kellogg W. Beck Milton A. Kamsler J. Glenn Benedict Stanley B. Cooper John H. Bertolet Holman G. Knouse Alvin W. Carpenter Daniel De Brier William R. Bready, 3rd Hon. Felix Piekarski Rabbi E. Lewis Cooper Lawrence E. Frankel Philip Cohen Ezra S. Shapeero Guy W. Davis B. Graeme Frazier, Jr. Robert B. Ely, 3rd

Fall 1965 11

Published by Penn Law: Legal Scholarship Repository, 2014 13 Penn Law Journal, Vol. 1, Iss. 1 [2014], Art. 1

Natt M. Emery, Jr. Martin B. Ebbert E. Calvert Cheston CLASS OF 1937 Edward L. Frater Eugene H. Feldman Joseph W. deFuria Frederick A. Van Denbergh, Hon. Theodore R. Gardner Howard W. Fineshriber Hon. Chauncey M. Depuy Jr. , Agent Elihu A. Greenhouse Edward First James B. Doak N umber Giving 32 Samuel Handloff Joseph H. Flanzer Charles H. Dorsett Per Cent Giving 32 Knox Henderson Austin Gavin, Jr. Samuel Edes · Amount $1,291.00 Sylvan D. Einhorn Edward B. Hodge Henry J. Goldberg Mrs. Anne F leming Baxter Myron Jacoby Henry Greenwald Bernard Eskin Samuel Fessenden Joseph Bell Alexander Katzin Sidney E. Jaffe Claire G. Biehn George D. Kline James L. Johnson Solomon Forman Calvin J. Friedberg Lawrence M. Bregy Martin Kremer Joseph M. Leib James A. Burns Ashby M. Larmore William Lipkin Gordon W. Gabell Frank H. Gelman Milton Cades Nathan Lavine Carl P. Lundy Harrison H. Clement Herbert S. Levin Paul Maloney Kenneth W. Gemmill Fred P. Glick David Cohen Abraham J. Levinson Jerome L. Markovitz Edward I. Cutler Daniel Lowenthal Samuel Mink Louis J. Goffman Leonard Helfenstein Ivan M. Czap John B. Martin Francis J. Morrissey, Jr. Mrs. F. Schwartz Davidow Jack J. McDowell Benjamin H. Oehlert, Jr. Charles J. Hepburn, Jr. Donald V. Hock Albert B. Gerber Alex L. Nichols Henry B. Oestreich Hyman Goldberg Martin H. Philip John B. Pearson Robert F. Lehman A. Harry Levitan Louis S. Hankin Harry Polikoff Samuel Popper Herman F. Kerner Col. Shalon Ralph John E. Power, Jr. Daniel W. Long Josiah Macy, Jr. Frederick E. Lark Augustine Repetto 1. Josiah Ratner Benjamin S. Loewenstein Paul H. Rhoads David H. Rosenbluth William M. Maier Daniel F. Marple Randal Morgan Hon. Samuel J. Roberts Col. Francis M. Sasse Norman L. Plotka William B. Rudenko Gilliat G. Schroeder Harry R. Most John M. Ranck Paul Port W. Albert Sanders Nathan Silberstein Bayard H. Roberts Willis H. Satterthwaite James L. Stern Nathan L. Reibman John Ross Victor J. Roberts, Jr. Adelbert S. Schroeder Aaron Tollin Alex Satinsky Bernard G . Segal Eugene K. Twining Louis B. Schwartz Boyd L. Spahr, Jr. John N. Schaeffer, Jr. J. Tyson Stokes Paul Veret Lester J. Schaffer Allen C. Thomas, Jr. William C. Wise Harry E. Sprogell J. Pennington Straus Bruce D. Smith William H. Vincent Samuel R. Wurtman C. Wayne Smyth Joseph Weinfeld T. F. Dixon Wainwright CLASS OF 1934 Albert C. Weymann, Jr. C. Tracy Taylor Mrs. Edith H. West Robert L. Trescher Harry H. Wexelblatt Roland J. Christy, Agent Richard T. Williamson Irving Wilner Frederick A. Van Number Giving 32 Denbergh, Jr. CLASS OF 1932 Per Cent Giving 38 Arnold Winokur Walter W. Beach board, A gent Frank J. Zugehoer Ernest R. von Starck Amount $1,864.44 Benjamin Weinstein Number Giving 27 Arthur L. Adams CLASS OF 1936 Per Cent Giving 28 S. Samuel Arsht Milton B. Garner, Agent CLASS OF 19 38 Amount $1,770.00 William D. Barfield Number Giving 36 Raymond J. Broderick, Hon. Alexander F. Barbieri John S. Bernheimer Per Cent Giving 36 Agent Walter W. Beachboard Leonard J. Bernstein Amount $2,069.00 Number Giving 35 M. Robert Beckman Roland J. Christy Hon. Alfred C. Alspach Per Cent Giving 4 1 Samuel A. Blank William H. Conca David L. Baird Amount $1 ,97 1.00 William C. Bodine Louis W. Cramer Samuel Bard Hon. Walter E. Alessandroni John C. Bruton, Jr. Mrs. Irene R. Dobbs Richard Benson Ralph M. Barley Harold J. Conner Philip B. Driver, Jr. David Berger Samuel B. Blaskey Hon. John Morgan Davis Aaron Eisenstein James E. Birdsall Raymond J. Broderick Anthony F. Emory Anthony G. Felix, Jr. John Bishop, VI Theodore L. Brubaker Saul Finestone Eugene C. Fish Hon. S. Thomas Bucciarelli Keron D. Chance Hon. Thomas C. Gawthrop Edward r. Fishman Roderick T. Clarke Richard N. Clattenburg Miss Mary E. Groff Solomon Freedman Alfred F. Conard Sylvan M. Cohen David H. Kubert Hon. Albert H. Heimbach Harry B. Davidson J. Harry Covington, 3rd Harold C. Lohren Raymond Heimlich Herbert G. Du Bois M. Carton Dittmann, Jr. Eugene A. Nogi Abraham Hefferman Wayland F. Dunaway, 3rd Leonard L. Ettinger Israel Packel C. Sumner Katz Milton B. Garner Robert N. Ferrer Raymond M. Pearlstine Robert L. Lingelbach Sylvester S. Garrett, Jr. Bernard Frank Calvin H. Rankin George W. McKee, Jr. Lewis M. Gill Richard W. Goslin, Jr. Harold M. Rappeport Howard S. McMorris Hon. Edward J. Griffiths Harold P. Gould Max Rosenn A. Arthur Miller Charles S. Jacobs Harry A. Greenberg Bernard Schwartz Mrs. Dorothea Grater Robert G. Kelly Jesse G . Heiges Herbert J. Slaughter Minsk off George C. Laub Harry L. Jenkins, Jr. Daniel G. Smith Gilbert W. Oswald Bernard V. Lentz Gregory G. Lagakos Samuel L. Sperling Ernest D. Preate Berthold W. Levy Maurice Levin Sidney S. Stark Harold B. Saler Hon. JosephS. Lord, III Richard M. Martin Guy K. Stewart Emanuel G . Scoblionko Harry K. Madway Barron P. McCune Edward Z. Winkleman Milton C. Sharp Edwin S. Maimed John L. Owens Morris Smith Tom L. McDowell Morris Pfaelzer, 2nd CLASS OF 1933 Jules E. Spector Nathan Silberstein, Agent Charles W. Mi les, 3rd Herman B. Poul Jerome B. Weinstein Jerome A. O'Neill Solon L. Rhode, Jr. Number Giving 39 John N. Osterlund Roger Scattergood Per Cent Giving 44 CLASS OF 1935 Frank E. Hahn, Jr., Agent Joseph Rhoads Irving R. Segal Amount $2,842.50 Hon. Charles A. Shea, Jr. John S. Simpson David F. Anderson Number Giving 42 G . William Shea Charles M. Solomon Max M. Batzer Per Cent Giving 45 Nathan C. Staller James A. Sutton Albert Blumberg Amount $2,055.00 Karl H. Strohl Frank J. Toole Robert J. Callaghan Herman M. Buck Thomas Raeburn White, Jr. Samuel R. Wexelblatt Sidney Chait Henry M. Canby Hon. Daniel F. Wolcott William White, Jr. William H. Doerr, Jr. Frank W. Carr John K. Young Herbert G. Zahn

12 LAW ALUMNI JOURNAL https://scholarship.law.upenn.edu/plj/vol1/iss1/1 14 et al.: Law Alumni Journal

CLASS OF 193 9 Robert Ungerleider CLASS OF 1941 Wilson Stradley James Hunter, III, Agent Nelson D. Warwick Paul A. Wolkin, Agent Edwin K. Taylor Arthur R. Kane, Jr., Agent Hon. Gerald J. Weber Edmund P. Turtzo Roy Wilkinson, Jr. Number Giving 45 Roy J. Waychoff, Jr. Number Giving 43 Per Cent Giving 45 Paul A. Wolkin Per Cent Giving 49 CLASS OF 1940 Amount $1,256.00 Amount $1,625.00 Lewis Weinstock, Agent S. Lester Block CLASS OF 1942 Mrs. Roxanna Cannon Arsht N umber Giving 36 Herbert Brener Frederic L. Ballard, Jr. , Thomas J. Beddow Per Cent Giving 37 Horace R. Cardoni Agent John W. Bohlen Amount $1,712.50 Paul M. Chalfin Number Giving 24 John P. Bracken Oakford W. Acton, Jr. Frederick J. Charley Per Cent Giving 33 Philip A. Bregy Lloyd S. Benjamin John R. Clark Amount $890.00 Joseph W. P. Burke Robert D. Branch Marvin Comisky Thomas R. Butler Samuel A. Breene A. Lynn Corcelius Norman H . Abrahamson T. Sidney Cadwallader, 2nd Hon. Martin J. Coyne Robert I. Cottom Frederic L. Ballard, Jr. Alexander Cohen John C. Decker John J. Dautrich Philip E. Barringer Leo T. Connor H . Francis DeLone Edward M. David Pershing N. Calabro Albert J. Crawford, Jr. Robert J. Dodds, Jr. Herman S. Davis Watson S. Campbell Fronfield Crawford WilliamS. Eisenhart, Jr. Anthony L. Differ John R. Graham William H. Eg li Carl J. W. Hessinger David H . W. Dohan Donald E. Hittle Leon S. Forman Francis Hopkinson Richard J. Farrell Edmund Jones William L. F ox Andrew Hourigan, Jr. Benjamin Forer David A. Kerr Myrtile Frank, Jr. Albert G. Jacobs Wesley R. Frysztacki Samuel S. Laucks, Jr. RobertS. Gawthrop, Jr. Theodore B. Kingsbury, III Louis Goldstein A. Leo Levin Thomas P. Glassmeyer Emanuel H. Klein Paul I. Guest John M. Metten Seymour L. G reen Erwin Lerten Edmund L. Harvey Robert L. Mi ller Carl E. Heilman John L. McDonald Alvin E. Heutchy Charles E. Rankin James Hunter, Ill Samuel V. Merrick Chester C. Hilinski Mrs. Mabel D. Sellers Arthur R. Kane, Jr. Paul V. Miller Herbert J. Johnson, Jr. Craig M. Sharpe H. Allen Lochner Arthur E. Newbold, 3rd Robert C. Koury Samuel P. Shaw, Jr. William H. Loesche, Jr. Thomas A. O'Boyle Vincent J. LaBrasca Arnold M. Smith Percy C. Madeira, 3rd George Ovington, 3rd William T. Leith Elvin R. Souder Ralph S. Mason Anderson Page William E. Lindenmuth Thomas B. Stei ger Leroy S. Maxwell Mitchell E. Panzer Samuel S. Logan, Jr. Joseph W. Swain, Jr. Sherwin T. McDowell Theodore 0. Rogers William J. Lowry, 3rd H. John Weisman, Jr. Walter P. McEvilly Hon. Edwin H. Satterthwaite John R. McConnell Thomas H. Wentz Miss Doris E. Montgomery Robert W. Sayre H. Ray Pope, Jr. George C. Williams Walter L. Peters Jacob Seidenberg Robert E. Porter CLASS OF 1943 W. Frazier Scott Thomas L. Shannon, Jr. R. Stewa rt Rauch, Jr. Robert Hachenburg, Agent W. Simms Sharninghausen Milton H. Shapiro Lioman Redman Robert H. Shertz Mrs. H. Solis-Cohen Spigel Milton W. Rosen Number Giving 8 John P. Sinclair Cmdr. Kenneth D. Strickler George B. Ross Per Cent Giving 17 W. Lloyd Snyder, Jr. Lewis Weinstock Leonard Sarner Amount $220.00 Elias W. Soengler Adam G. Wenchel Norman Seidel Bernard M. Borish Benjamin F. Stahl, Jr. David L. Wilson Bernard J. Smolens Wi lliam J. Dickman Howard W. Taylor, Jr. John H. Wood. Jr. John M. Stocker Robert Hachenburg

REGARDING LAW SCHOOL ANNUAL GIVING

Two areas of concern have in some degree affected In order to receive credit in two or more schools, results of Annual Giving almost from its beginning. It is you are urged to send to each a separate check in the with this in mind that the following explanation is made. school envelope provided. However, if you wish to Roughly, one quarter of the Law School alumni make only one check and split your gift, the designated body are "double" graduates. These are alumni who amount should be clearly marked for each school. This have graduated from, and have allegiance to, more than will be very helpful in keeping things straight and as­ one school at the University. Although many in this suring observance of your wishes. situation do reply to appeals from each school, a large The second point to be covered is this: Alumni number do not. It is because of this fairly high per­ Annual Giving funds are separate and distinct from centage that it is felt worth discussion. funds contributed to the Law School Development and When Annual Giving was instituted, alumni who Capital program. The latter gifts are used solely fo r attended both undergraduate and professional schools the building program. On the other hand Annual Giving at the University automatically received duplicate credit gifts, as has already been shown, are used for daily in each for a single gift. Several years ago the University operating needs, faculty and student research, student revised its system and ruled out the "double" credit aid funds, the library, the Law Review and contingen­ because it did not reflect a true picture of gifts or donors. cies. Both classes of gifts are, of course, of great im­ Today each school conducts its own campaign and the portance to the well being of the School. proceeds are credited separately. Each has to rely on In view of the fact that payment of capital pledges these individual funds to meet daily operating needs and is far advanced, it is reasonable to expect that Annual opportunities not fully provided for within the general Giving will grow significantly. It is believed that the University budgetary framework. It is like the case of al~mni will keep the Law School's continuing needs in a law alumnus who received his undergraduate degree mmd when considering institutions worthy of their at another institution. support.

Fall 1965 13

Published by Penn Law: Legal Scholarship Repository, 2014 15 Penn Law Journal, Vol. 1, Iss. 1 [2014], Art. 1

Allan W. Keusch CLASS OF 1948 A GLANCE AT TEN YEARS Mrs. E. Hatton Landis Raymond Jenkins, Agent Joseph Shanis OF ANNUAL GIVING John N . Stull Number Giving 46 Ellis W. Van Horn, Jr. Per Cent Giving 35 Number of Per Cent Amount Amount $1,358.00 CLASS OF 1944 James G. Aiken Year Contributors Participation Contributed Joseph G. Ansel Barton E. Ferst, Agent Walter Y. Anthony, Jr. 1955-56 1056 29 36,830. Number Giving II John M. Bader Per Cent Giving 48 Augustus S. Ballard 1956-57 1027 28 30,078. Amount $425.00 Martin M. Bell 1957-58 1096 29 37,635. Mrs. Trudell Green Brown James C. Bowen Theodore A. Evans James F. Brown, Jr. 1958-59 1365 34 45,000. Barton E. Ferst Richard P. Brown, Jr. Frederick G . Kempin, Jr. James E. Buckingham 1959-60 1281 32 50,096. Meyer Kramer Hon. J. William Ditter, Jr. Carl F. Mogel Mark R. Eaby, Jr. 1960-61 1250 31 50,812. G. Selden Pitt Robert P. Frankel David V. Shapiro William J. Fuchs 1961-62 1498 37 53,325. William E. Taylor, Jr. Joseph F. Harvey Daniel H. Huyett, 3rd 63,389. Michael Waris, Jr. 1962-63 1680 41 PaulL. Wise R. M. Jones Solomon Katz 1963-64 1791 42 72,935. Eugene W. Lederer CLASS OF 1945 Marvin Levin 1964-65 1860 42 87' 164. Number Giving 7 Robert Margolis Per Cent Giving 78 Francis E. Marshall Amount $400.00 John E. McCarthy, Jr. Jay D. Barsky Mitchell W. Miller CORPORATE MATCHING Isadore H. Be ll is Robert M. Mountenay Edwin G. Fieldler, Jr. Robert C. O'Hara GIFT PROGRAM S. Harry Galfand Walter S. Peake Mrs. Jane Mahady Mcintyre Marvin D. Perskie Mrs. Violet Hursh Meehan Franklin Poul The names of corporate donors who have partici­ Mrs. M. Charleston White Henry T. Reath pated in this year's Law School Annual Giving Program George H. Reid are listed below. These corporations have generously Donald Reuter CLASS OF 1946 Herbert W. Salus, Jr. matched, wholly or in part, the gifts of our alumni in John L. Esterhai, A gent Scott W. Scully their employ. The number of the companies and the James C. Bly, Agent Charles S. Shapiro amount received from them increases each year as more Number Giving 12 E. Eugene Shelley join the matching gift program. Per Cent Giving 45 John A. Shrader Amount $225.00 Robert J. Spiegel Alumni who are eligible to have their gift matched John C. Bell, 3rd George W. Thompson are urged to send in their company's form in order that James C. Bl y James J. Walsh the Law School may benefit from it. The matching Mrs. M. Lubich Weisberg Ralph T. Buchsbaum Elkins Wetherill amount is also credited to you, your class and your William M. DeLong Leonard S. Wissow region. John L. Esterhai John K. Hanrahan Bernard Wolfman At present there are over 250 corporations known Milton A. Wollman John R. Miller John F. Zel ler, 3rd to have adopted a plan for matching gifts made by em­ Mrs. Emma Forry Mullen ployees, officers, and, often, directors to their schools Louis B. Nielsen CLASS OF 1949 February Col. David H. Pepper and universities. The Alumni Office will be glad to Harold Tull Henry N . Platt, Jr., Agent supply information to any alumnus who may be in a William H . G. Warner Number Giving 36 position to influence the establishment of a matching Per Cent Giving 41 gift plan in his company. CLASS OF 1947 Amount $1,216.00 Robert M. Landis, A gent Francis Ballard AIR PRODUCTS AND CHEMICALS, INC. Number Giving 18 Hyman L. Battle, Jr. ARMSTRONG CORK COMPANY Le wis B. Beatty, Jr. Per Cent Giving 24 William F. Bohlen ARTHUR ANDERSON & COMPANY Amount $605.00 Alan H. Cassman THE CONTINENTAL INSURANCE COMPANIES Arlin M. Adams Samuel B. Corli ss Raymond J. Bradley Cassin W. Craig Esso EDucA noN FouNDA noN Francis Shunk Brown, 3rd Clifford C. David James E. Carr William R. Deasey GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY Charles R. Cooper, Jr. Ralph B. D'Iorio GIRARD TRUST CoMPANY Emerson L. Darnell George C. Eppinger HooKER CHEMICAL CoRPORA noN Robert B. Doll Bernard.A. Fischer Albert G. Driver Alex L. Fricke INSURANCE COMPANY OF NORTH AMERICA Justin G. Duryea Roy A. Gardner Gordon W. Gerber KIDDER, PEABODY & CoMPANY John C. Hambrook George M. James M. Stuart Goldin MARINE MIDLAND TRUST CoMPANY OF NEw YoRK Robert M. Landis James W. Hagar OLIN MATHIESON CHEMICAL C ORPORATION Hon. Alfred L. Luongo Alexander Hemphill William H. Mann A. C. Reeves Hicks PHILCO CORPORATION Alfred W. Putnam RobertS. Lindsay, Jr. ScoTT PAPER CoMPANY Read Rocap, Jr. William F . Lynch, 2nd Hon. Herman M. Rodgers John T. Macartney SMITH, KLINE & FRENCH LA BORA TORIES Morris L. Weisberg Lawrence E. MacElree

14 LAW ALUMNI JOURNAL https://scholarship.law.upenn.edu/plj/vol1/iss1/1 16 et al.: Law Alumni Journal

Milford L. McBride, Jr. Edward S. Hicks, Jr. Francis H . Pykon Mrs. Elizabeth H ill Carson Samuel W. Morris Theodore H. Husted, Jr. David M. Satz, Jr. Gordon Cavanaugh Henry N . Platt, Jr. Thomas M. Hyndman Joseph J. Savitz William F. Chester, Jr. Charles B. Ruttenberg PaulL. Jaffe Henry G. Schaefer, Jr. Lee F. Driscoll, Jr. Philip M. Smithers Frederick J. Kling Edward M. Seletz Warren R. Dwyer Lee N. Steiner Louis J. Kober J. Marlin Shreiner Albert J . Feldman Caspar W. B. Townsend, Jr. Stephen J. Korn Robert M. Smith Louis S. Fine William D . Valente Joseph T. Labrum, Jr. John D. Smyers A. Theodore Flum Charles B. P. Van Pelt Melvin G. Levy Thomas H. Stewart Joseph H. Foster William T. Walsh Frederick C. N. Littleton Thomas J. Sullivan John C. Garner Henry M. Wick, Jr. Joseph L. Loughran William F. Trapnell G. Taylor Hess Carl A. Wiker Solomon Lubin Robert S. Trigg James R. Hornick Howard Yarus Merton J. Matz Richard H . Warren Edward H. Huss Bernard M. Kimmel CLASS OF 1949 June J. Grant McCabe CLASS OF 1952 Raymond W. Midgett, Jr. John P. Knox Thomas A. Mcivor, Agent Joseph P. Flanagan, Jr. , Louis E. Levy Murray S. Monroe Agent Number Giving 40 Ernest L. Nagy All an W. Lugg Per Cent Giving 53 William G . O'Neill Number Giving 44 Henry C. Maiale Amount $1 ,318.50 Peter Pl atten Per Cent Giving 36 Donald R. McKay Amount $912.50 Richard L. Baker Stanley W. Root, Jr. Ellis H. McKay William H. Bayer Harold S. Rosenbluth Saul P. Baker Charles E. Mechem Marshall A. Bernstein Alexander N. Rubin, Jr. John G. Bartol, Jr. Wi lliam E. Mikell John M. Bowers, Jr. Sylvan H. Savadove Robert F. Blanck George A. Moore, Jr. Francis J. Carey, Jr. Richard V. Scarpitti Mrs. Juliet T. Brace Edgar E. Moss, 2nd Louis J. Carter James H. Scheck J. Scott Calkins Ronald B. Myrter Basil S. Cole, Jr. Alvin R. Schomer John P. Chandler Frederick G. Norris Marvin R. Halbert Lawrence E. Stengel Ira B. Coldren, Jr. C. Lee Nutt, 3rd Mrs. Doris May Harris John J. Tinagli a George H. Conover, Jr. Thomas N. O'Neill , J r. Mrs. Virginia B. Wallace B. Patrick Costello Stanley M. Poplow Bancroft D. Haviland C live S. Cummis William M. Hebrank Lloyd B. White, Jr. Samuel F. Pryor, 3rd Frank S. Deming Irwin E. Robinson James A. Hemstreet Al len I. Dublin John F. Henderson CLASS OF 1951 William B. Scatchard, Jr. Hugh H. Howard John J. Galbally, Agent JohnS. F isher, 2nd Phil ip Shuchman Edward L. Flaherty, J r. Arthur R. G. Solmssen James F . Hyde, Jr. Number Giving 58 Joseph P. Flanagan, Jr. Hon. William F. Hyland Per Cent Giving 45 Alan M. Spector Charles E. Ingersoll Kiefer N . Gerstley George A. Spohrer Amount $2,028.00 Maxwell P. Gorson Stanley P. Stern Franklin E. Kepner C. Thomas Attix , Jr. Paul R. Kramer Robert S. Hass Joseph C. Van Cleve, Jr. Marvin K. Bailin Richard A. Huettner Donald P. Vernon Frederick H. Law, Jr. Milton Becket Alvin J. Ivers William D. Lucas Wi ll iam W. Vogel Harold Berger Robert M. Johnson David E. Wagoner Herman H. Mattleman JosephS. Bobman William A. Kelley, Jr. Thomas A. Mcivor Sheldon M. Weiss Christopher Branda, Jr. Allan M. Kluger C . Norwood Wherry William E. Miller, Jr. Crede C. Calhoun Edwin R. Lowry Miss Harriet M. Mims Alan D. Williams, Jr. Harold Caplan William J . Lubic Karl E. Wolf Edward W. Mullinix William J. Carlin Edward W. Madeira, Jr. David H. Nelson Wil liam A. Wyatt Stuart Coven Paul Maleson George C. Xakell is David W. O'Brien Harold Cramer Thomas A. Masterson Martin J. O'Donnell Richard S. Denney Anthony S. Min isi CLASS OF 1954 James A. O'Neill Park B. Dilks, Jr. Casper W. Morris, Jr. Charles C. Parlin, Jr. Charles E. Dillon Morris M. Shuste r, Agent L. George W. Nordham Hon. Daniel Quinlan, Jr. John L. Dolphin Edward J. O'Halloran Number Giving 42 Howard F. Reed, Jr. John F. A. Earley Marion D. Patterson, J r. Per Cent Giving 47 Francis M. Richards, Jr. Paul M. Eyster Benjamin F. Schweyer Amount $830.50 Marvin Schwartz Joseph B. Farrell Jules Silk Ernest N. Agresti Murray L. Schwartz John J. Galbally Jack Sirott Paul C. Astor Edward M. Spector Martin S. Goodman Edward J. Blake Abram Steinberg George V. Strong, Jr. Joseph K. Gordon Walter I. Summerfield, Jr. Stanley W. Bluestine Robert W. Valimont Oliver F. Green, Jr. John T. Synnestvedt Floyd E. Brandow, Jr. Peter M. Ward Francis B. Haas, Jr. William J. Taylor Aims C. Coney, Jr. CLASS OF 1950 Gerald J. Haas Robert E. Wachs Chester T. Cyzio Pasquale J. DiQuinzio Stephen J. Korn, Agent Mrs. P. Schacter Halpern Seymour C. Wagner George J. Hauptfuhrer, Jr. Seth W. Watson, Jr. Roland P. Ely, Jr. Number Giving 46 John F. Healy Mintern T. Wright, 3rd Carl A. Frahn Per Cent Giving 46 Maj. Edmond H. Heisler Marvin Garfinkel Amount $1,340.00 Charles F . Herr CLASS OF 1953 William L. G losser Morton Abrams Leon C. Holt, Jr. Leonard Barkan, Agent Manuel H . Greenberg William W. Atterbury, Jr. Henry M. Irwin Number Giving 59 Garry G. Greenstein J. William Barba Robert L. Lein inger Per Cent Giving 43 Lt. Col. Bennet N . Hollander Francis J. Bowden, Jr. Herbert M. Linsenberg Amount $1,161.00 Merton E. Jones Kenneth F . C. Char Jerome Lipman John T. Acton Ralph V. Jones Edward J. Cooke, Jr. Thomas J. Lykos Vincent J. Apruzzese Ben F. Kaito Arthur C. Dorrance, Jr. John H. McKeever E. Boyd Asplundh James M. Keating, Jr. John W. Douglass Edward B. Meredith Leonard Barkan Richard H. Knox Daniel H. Erickson Mrs. Regina Haig Meredith Walter L. Bartholomew, Jr. Samuel M. Lehrer James A. Esler George J. Miller Richard A. Bausher S. Gerald Litvin Peter Florey James E. O'Connell Don B. Blenko Albert F . McGee, Jr. John R. Gauntt William J. C. O'Donnell Edward J. Bradley Henry C. McGrath Richard J. Gordon Donald G. Oyler Jack Brian James J. McHugh, 3rd Phillip R. Grant James C. N. Paul M itchell Brock Thomas F. Meehan, Jr. Robert A. Hauslohner James H . Peters John Butterworth Gerald J. Mongelli John F. Heinz Louis C. Pulvermacher James S. Cafiero Mrs. Melva Long Mueller

Fall1965 15

Published by Penn Law: Legal Scholarship Repository, 2014 17 Penn Law Journal, Vol. 1, Iss. 1 [2014], Art. 1

Michael J. Piarulli Charles J. Basch Joseph E. Greene, Jr. Mortimer D. Rubin Will iam J. Purcell Edward F. Beatty, Jr. George C. Greer Joseph H . Savitz Pace Reich Robert M. Beckman Gerald E. Kandler Allan B. Schneirov Raymond C. Schlegel George L. Bernstein John 0. Karns Edwin W. Semans, Jr. David Seliger Donald K. Bobb Richard Kirschner David J. Steinberg Morris M. Shuster Richard L. Bond Goncer M. Krestal Richard W. Stevens Barry R. Spiegel Hugh P. Connell Seymour Kurland Louis G. Tarantino, Jr. James F. Swartz Paul C. Dewey William W. Lanigan Friedrich J. Weinkopf William Thatcher Angelo A. Di Pasqua Charles H . Laveson Marvin Weiss Richard J. Van Roden John A. Erickson William G. Malkames William H. Wolf, Jr. William A. Whiteside, Jr. Leonard Etz James F. McClure, Jr. Elliott Yampell Mrs. Joan P. Wohl Paul A. Feiner Stephen J. McEwen, Jr. Robert H. Zimmerman Edward A. Woolley Henry B. Fitzpatrick, Jr. Thomas C. McGrath, Jr. Sidney T. Yates Joseph F. Flanagan Edward M. Medvene CLASS OF 1959 Richard H. Floum Joseph S. Moloznik George F . Reed, Agent CLASS OF 1955 Leon H. Fox, Jr. Jerrold V. Moss Number Giving 53 Irving M. H irsh, Agent Isaac S. Garb James M. Mulligan Per Cent Giving 35 Robert L. Kendall, Agent Stephen W. Graffam D. Frederick Muth Amount $1 ,006.77 Number Giving 50 Paul D. Guth Jay G . Ochroch Russell R. Reno, Jr. Alan I. Aberman Per Cent Giving 49 J. Barton Harrison Mi ss Margaret E. Adam Amount $963.00 HermanS. Harvey, Jr. Thomas B. K. Ringe, Jr. Richard M. Rosenbleeth Louis J. Adler Robert B. Binswanger Jerome H. Harwitz L. Carter Anderson Samuel L. Hirshland Edward E. Russell John L. Boyle, Jr. Richard V. Holmes Richard G . Schneider Donald Beckman Thomas J. Calnan, Jr. Seymour Kanter Raymond Schwartz Sanford D. Beecher, Jr. Joel C. Coleman Richard L. Kearns J. Earl Simmons, Jr. Joseph Beller James R. Cooper Alan G. Kirk, II Theodore 0. Struk Gerald Broker Samuel Diamond Miss Dolores Korman Mrs. Ellen P. Queeney Suria H. Donald Busch ChristianS. Erb, Jr. George J. Lavin, Jr. John R. Suria Richard L. Cantor Thomas A. Everly, Jr. James J. Casby, Jr. Milton A. Feldman Arthur W. Leibold, Jr. Myles H. Tanenbaum Charles F. Ludwig Michael L. Temin Philip Cherry Stephen M. Feldman Robert B. McCullough Jonathan S. Cohen William Goichman Parke H . Ulrich, Jr. William Congreve, 3rd David J. Goldberg Richard L. McMahon E. Norman Veasey Mrs. Mercea Panfil Mears Hardy Williams Thomas S. Conlon Bernard J. Goodheart Wallace P. Cooney Manuel Grife James W. Moore Harvey G. Wolfe Raymond U. Mueller, Jr. Fred B. Ziesenheim Murray S. Eckell David C. Harrison J. Earl Epstein Francis J. Hartman Robert Neustadter Simon R. Zimmerman Harris Ominsky Seymour H. Feingold Charles H. Harvey CLASS OF 1958 William J. Geen Robert L. Hesse Mrs. Ruth Renner Percy Charles K. Plotnick Murray C. Goldman Irving M. Hirsh George B. McNelis. Agent Arthur R. Gorr James M. Howley Mrs. Guyla W. Ponomaretf Curtis R. Reitz Number Giving 50 Bernard M. Gross W. Scott Johns, 3rd Per Cent Giving 39 Jack G. Handler David J. Kaufman Richard G. Robins Alan M. Ruben Amount $759.50 Selwyn A. Horvitz Robert L. Kendall, Jr. John R. Rudders Norman M. Kranzdorf John S. Schmid Fred C. Aldridge, Jr. Carl W. Schneider Harris C. Arnold, Jr. Samuel H. Karsch Edwin Krawitz Edmund H. Kase, 3rd Charles D. Lemmond, Jr. Leonard S. Slavit Duffield Ashmead, III Donn P. Slonim Bennett I. Bardfeld Lew1s Kates Arthur Levy Robert G. Kleckner, Jr. Arthur H. Moss Dominic P. Toscani Harold J. Berger John A. Vuono S. David Brandt Albert W. Laisy Paul A. Mueller, Jr. John J . Lombard, Jr. Bertram S. Murphy John M. Wajert A. Balfour Brehman, Jr. Saul J. Weinstein Benjamin E. Carter Richard D. Monroe Joseph V. Reaph, Jr. Thomas B. Moorhead S. White Rhyne, Jr. Howard A. Wiener David R. Cohan Robert J. Wollet Martin Cohen John C. Mueller James M. Richardson Allen 0. Olin Angus M. Russell Vincent X. Yakowicz Philip Cohen John L. M. Yardley, Jr. Joseph A. Damico, Jr. Peter C. Paul HenryS. Ruth, Jr. Peter H. Pfund Hon. Ralph F. Scalera Robert K. Young Martin S. Evelev Wray G. Zeit, 3rd Stanley Frank Martin B. Pitkow Murray M. Schwartz George F. Reed AlbertS. Shaw, Jr. Mrs. Barbara K. Zimmerman Philip R. Frieder Jacques H. Geisenberger Jr. Jack A. Rounick William T. Shea CLASS OF 1957 Marshall A. Rutter Harry A. Short Howard Gittis ' Richard G. Schneider, Agent Melvin D. Glass Matthew J. Ryan, 3rd Edward L. Snitzer Number Giving 54 Boris Shapiro Alvin L. Snowiss Sidney R. Granite Per Cent Giving 54 RichardT. Gross Oscar F. Spicer Joseph H. Stanziani Amount $664.00 Joseph F. Strain Arthur J. Sullivan Bernard M. Guth Alvin S. Ackerman Henry R. Heebner, Jr. Thomas A. Swope, Jr. D. Charles Valsing Louis M. Tarasi, Jr. Joel H. Weinrott Maurice Axel rad Baron E. Kessler John E. Backenstoe Harry A. Kitey Ira P. Tiger Mervin M. Wilf David R. Tomb, Jr. Alfred T. Williams, Jr. William M. Barnes Charles F. Knapp Daniel B. Brandschain George D. Knapp Herbert A. Vogel Barry B. Wohlman John D. Wilson Norman P. Zarwin Isaac H . Clothier M1chael G. Kurcias Robert B. Cohen John P. Leemhuis Franklin A. Wurman CLASS OF 1956 Robert S. Cohen Harvey Levin CLASS OF 1960 John D. Cummings James A. Loughran Alan G. Kirl , II, Agent Nicholas D. Vadino, Jr., Carl W . Schneider, Agent Michael M. Dean Alan W. Margolis Nicodemo De Gregorio George B. McNelis Agent Number Giving 62 James N. Diefenderfer T. Weldon Monteith, Jr. Number Giving 35 Per Cent Giving 50 Charles M. Farbstein Ramon R. Obod Per Cent Giving 30 Amount $846.00 Miss Patricia H. Frankel Michael A. Orlando, 3rd Amount $43 5.00 Herbert J. Abedon Mahlon M. Frankhauser John W. Roberts Edward L. Batoff Harry D . Ambrose, Jr. Samuel L. Glantz Littleton W. Roberts, Jr. Michael Bernstein Louis D. Apothaker Robert E. Glaymon Ronald R. Rosenberg Ralph H. Clover 16 LAW AUJMNI JOURNAL https://scholarship.law.upenn.edu/plj/vol1/iss1/1 18 et al.: Law Alumni Journal

Edward I. Dobin Arthur D. Rabelow Stephen J. Moses Clarence W. Vandergrift John F. Dugan, II David V. Randall Alexander Neave Michael D. Varbalow Frank Federman Robert A. Rosin Thomas P. Nugent James L. Weisman Melvin S. Feldman Irwin M. Samuels Philip S. Nyman Thomas R. White, 3rd Mrs. Ruth M. Ferrell Robert J. Sann Lewis F. Parker Mrs. Faith Ryan Whittlesey Jay F. Frank James M. Scanlon Robert M. Philson Miss Susan P. Windle Miss Cherie A. Gaines William R. Shane Martin M. Pollock Edwin D. Wolf Lewis J. Gordon Robert M. Shay John H. Potts Stephen G. Yusem Robert J. Hastings Anthony J. Sobczak Charles B. Pursel Charles A. Heimbold, Jr. David L. Steck Miss Suzanne R. Schiffman CLASS OF 1964 John H. Higgs Richard K. Stevens, Jr. George H. M. Sc huler William J. Levy, A ge11 t Richard S. Hyland Marc L. Swartzbaugh Richard J. Sharkey Number Giving 67 John R. Jakubowski Gilbert Wasserman M. Michael Sharlot Per Cent Giving 46 Allan Katz Harold B. Wells, 3rd Louis P. Silverman Amount $633.38 Mark K. Kessler David H. Wheeler Martin W. Spector Charles G. Kopp Bruce B. Wilson Charles H. Thomas, Jr. John T. Andrews, Jr. Gerald G. Kramer Lawrence E. Wood Galen J. White, Jr. Richard A. Ash Randall D. Luke RogerS. Young Morris Zacher Steven T. Atkins Roland Morris Edward K. Zuckerman Arnold Zenker Peter F. Axelrad Benjamin S. Ohrenstein Frank B. Baldwin, 3rd Edward Robin CLASS OF 1962 CLASS OF 1963 Michael M. Baylson E. Barclay Cale, Agent George F. Robinson John L. Harrison, A ge11t George W. Bissell Number Giving 76 George C. Bradley David E. Seymour Number Giving 64 Lowell S. Thomas, Jr. Per Cent Giving 60 Earl T. Britt Amount $744.50 Per Cent Giving 45 Andrew B. Cantor Thomas T. Trettis, Jr. Amount $768.00 Nicholas Vadino, Jr. Milton D. Abowitz John A. C hanin Joseph T. Vodnoy Richard D. Atkins Steven A. Arbittier Robert L. Coles Alvin M. Weiss Paul Auerbach Donald V. Berlanti Nicholas D. Constan, Jr. Marvin M. Wodlinger Mrs. Andrea C. Balliette Aaron D. Blumberg Stephen A. Cozen Hillard N . Zebine William Balliette, Jr. Harold Bogatz George M. Dallas, 4th Ronald Ziegler Joseph F. Battle, Jr. A. Richard Caputo Mrs. Beryl Richman Dean Leigh W. Bauer Lt. Richard A. Carrick David Dearborn William M. Baumgartner Abraham J. Chasnoff Marshall A. Deutsch CLASS OF 196 1 Martin M. Berliner Arnold B. Cohe n Calvin S. Drayer, Jr. Raymond K. Denworth, Jr., Mrs. Barbara P. Berman Henry B. Cortesi Neil K. Evans Agent Richard R. Bl ock Thomas F. Cunnane Peter A. Eveleth Stuart S. Bowie Morton F. Daller Eugene E. Fike, 2nd Number Giving 61 R. David Bradley Nicholas P. Damico Dennis M. Flannery Per Cent Giving 55 Jonas Brodie Mrs. Joanne R. Denworth Michael 0. Floyd Amount $848.50 Scott P. R. Burnaman Lowell H. Dubrow Michael H. Frankel Edward N. Adourian, Jr. E. Barclay Cale, Jr. David M. Epstein Robert G . Fuller, Jr. James H. Agger William B. Christy, 4th Mrs. Myrna Paul Field John R. Gibbel Paul R. Anapol Robert B. Cohen Melvyn H. Freeman L. Anthony Gibson Lewis Becker Leonard J. Cooper Nathan G . Ginsburg Henry A. Gladstone Lawrence F. Corson Alfred W. Cortese, Jr. Edward M. Glickman Oscar B. Goodman Joseph M. Dalton, Jr. James D. Crawford Jay L. Goldberg Richard J. Haber Raymond K. Denworth, Jr. Kenneth M. Cushman Frederick P. Hafetz Henry S. Hilles, Jr. Jack Emas William J. Dale John L. Harrison, Jr. James G. Hirsh Arthur J. England, Jr. Mrs. Judith Norvick Dean Harold Jacobs George H. Jackson, 3rd Mrs. Ruth Morris Force George C. Decas Arthur S. Karafin Richard A. Jacoby Robert A. Freedman Richard D . Ehrlich Morris C. Kellett Matthew D. Janczewski Bernard Glassman Richard H. Elliott Martin N. Kroll Alan K. Kaplan Rayner M. Hamilton Alexander Endy Robert Kruger Miss Frederica B. Koller Mrs. Ann Epstein Harrison Nick S. Fisfis Judah I. Labovitz William J. Levy John B. Healy Joel P. Fishbein John J. Langenbach Richard A. Lippe Peter Hearn Gordon S. Freesman James R. Ledwith Richard K. Mandell James N. Horwood Joel Friedman Gerald M. Levin Charles M. Marshall Howard M. Jaffe Robert F. Y. Garrett, 3rd Arthur L. Levine Richard C. Montgomery Edward L. Jones, Jr. Bernard R. Gerber Robert C. Littman Francis J. Murphy Anthony L. Joseph John E. Gillmor Thomas Lumbard Mansfield C. Neal, Jr. Michael Joseph Francis E. N. Gleeson Arnold Machles Samuel H. Nelson Malcolm B. Kane Donald F. U. Goebert David H. Marion Bruce S. Nielsen Charles K. Keil Harold Greenberg Francis G. Mays William T. Onorato Eric G. Koskoff Gerald E. Haughey John H. McGrail Michael A. O'Pake Daniel M. Kristol Martin G. Heckler Paul R. Melletz David C. Patten Lewis S. Kunkel, Jr. John A. Herdeg Henry F . Miller Miss Marian R. Pearlman Franklin L. Kury Heinz K. Hintermann John R. Mondschein Paul D. Pearson Kenneth H. Lang Burton Hoffman Joseph L. Monte, Jr. David L. Robinson Herbert W. Larson Jerome A. Hoffman Louis H. Nevins Martin F. Robinson Henry W. Lavine Paul D. Horger Robert J. Partlow Christopher R. Rosser Anthony S. Leidner Steven D. Ivins Earle J. Patterson, 3rd Herbert F. Schwartz Paul G. Levy Warren J. Kauffman Thomas E. Quay Evan Y. Semerjian Wilfred F. Lorry John P. Kelley J. Ashley Roach Howard Shapiro Robert S. Lucarini Edmond M. Kirby Michael J. Rotko Gordon D. Simonds Jack K. Mandel Jerold G. Kievit Michael J. Rutenberg Daniel B. Slack Spencer G. Nauman, Jr. Daniel J. Lawler Peter M. Ryan Alan Steinberg David F. Norcross Edward J. Lewis Charles A. Shaffer James A. Strazzella Frederick D. Pettit David P. Loughran Stephen A. Sheller John L. Sullivan Francis J. Pfizenmayer Spencer A. Manthorpe Max Spinrad Irwin J. Tenenbaum Ronald Pinsky Robert W. Maris Albert M. Stark Jerome R. Verlin Paul B. Pollack David W. Miller Jonathan R. Steinberg Peter C. Ward Philip Price, Jr. Edwin S. Moore, 3rd Robert J. Stern Richard D. Wood, 3rd

Fal11965 17

Published by Penn Law: Legal Scholarship Repository, 2014 19 Penn Law Journal, Vol. 1, Iss. 1 [2014], Art. 1

SUMMARY OF REGIO ·s (Areas, other than Philadelphia, with 15 or more alumni) Chairman-J. Pennington Straus, L'35 No. Per Cent of No. of Partici- Participation Amount Region Chairman Alumni paling 1964-65 1963-64 1964-65 1963-64 Chester County, Pa. Thomas R. Butler, L'39 58 41 71 59 $ 1,594 $ 1,188 Cleveland, Ohio Henry W. Lavine, L'61 16 11 69 190 Lancaster County, Pa. Jacques H. Geisenberger, L'27 48 28 58 72 1,510 1,230 Atlantic City, N.J. Robert Neustadter, L'56 42 23 55 38 430 535 Lehigh County, Pa. Emanuel G. Scoblionko, L'34 56 30 54 59 1,200 901 Wilmington, Del. Herbert W. Larson, L'61 71 38 54 50 947 1,531 Delaware County, Pa. Albert Blumberg, L'33 Guy G. de Furia, L'28 183 91 50 38 5,546 4,598 Washington, D.C. Lipman Redman, L'41 137 67 49 50 1,987 1,280 Trenton, N.J. Edward B. Meredith, L'51 42 20 48 38 354 265 Boston, Mass. Philip G. Nyman L'62 20 9 45 100 Los Angeles, Calif. Marshall A. Rutter, L'59 36 16 45 43 753 475 Northampton County, Pa. John C. Hambrook, L'47 45 20 45 42 670 460 Camden, N.J. William F. Hyland, L'49 90 39 43 46 1,712 1,232 Bucks County, Pa. Charles M. Marshall, L'64 57 23 40 37 787 533 New York, N.Y. Richard M. Dicke, L'40 329 128 39 35 5,642 5,431 San Francisco, Calif. Ronald Pinsky, L'61 21 8 38 285 Erie County, Pa. Mortimer E. Graham, L'25 32 12 38 32 401 295 Chicago, Ill. Richard J. Farrell, L'41 19 7 37 275 Burlington County, N.J. Edward N. Adourian, Jr. , L'61 33 12 37 44 235 170 Dauphin County, Pa. Francis B. Haas, Jr., L'51 52 18 35 42 715 352 York County, Pa. E . Eugene Shelley, L'48 23 8 35 27 355 299 Lackawanna County, Pa. James W. Scanlon, L'30 46 15 33 44 725 755 Montgomery County, Pa. Victor J. Roberts, L'37 260 85 33 34 4,442 2,565 Luzerne County, Pa. Andrew Hourigan, Jr., L'40 78 24 31 31 811 650 Berks County, Pa. RichardT. Williamson, L'35 52 15 29 38 601 396 Allegheny County, Pa. George J. Miller, L'51 81 22 27 38 675 841 Schuylkill County, Pa. Calvin J. Friedberg, L'35 26 5 20 20 220 200 Totals 1953 815 42% 40% $33,162 $26,182

ABOVE AVERAGE These Regions Bettered the Over-all Alumni Participation of 42 % :

Region Chairman Per Cent

Chester County, Pa. Thomas R. Butler, L'39 71 Cleveland, Ohio Henry W. Lavine, L'61 69 Lancaster County, Pa. Jacques H. Geisenberger, L'27 58 Atlantic City, N.J. Robert Neustadter, L'56 55 Lehigh County, Pa. Emanuel G. Scoblionko, L'34 54 Wilmington, Del. Herbert W. Larson, L'6 1 54 Delaware County, Pa. Albert Blumberg, L'33 Guy G. de Furia, L'28 50 Washington, D.C. Lipman Redman, L'41 49 Trenton, N .J. Ed wa rd B. Meredith, L'51 48 Boston, Mass. Philip G. Nyman, L'62 45 Los Angeles, Calif. Marshall A. Rutter, L'59 45

A congenial chat among friends Northampton County, Pa. John C. Hambrook, L'47 45 in the Law Dormitory Courtyard. Camden, N .J. William F. Hyland, L'49 43

18 LAW ALUMNI JOURNAL https://scholarship.law.upenn.edu/plj/vol1/iss1/1 20 et al.: Law Alumni Journal Law Alumni Day May 13,1965

Attending the luncheon honoring the five-year classes Dean and Mrs. Jefferson B. Fordham (on right) chat and the graduating class are: (1. tor.) Hon. C. William with the Hon. and Mme. P. B. Gajendragadkar. The Kraft, Jr., '27; Ernest Scott, '29; Hon. John Biggs, latter gentleman is Chief Justice of the Supreme Jr.; Henry T. Reath, '48, President of the Law Court of India, and he delivered the Alumni Day Alumni Society; Dean Jefferson B. Fordham; Carroll Address. R. Wetzel, '30; Lennox L. Moak (back to camera).

Robert M. Bernstein, '14, and Lawrence H. Eldridge, '27, Members of the Class of 1965 were are attentive listeners at a Law Alumni Day Seminar. luncheon guests of the Law Alumni Society.

Fall 1965 19 Published by Penn Law: Legal Scholarship Repository, 2014 21 Penn Law Journal, Vol. 1, Iss. 1 [2014], Art. 1

Kickoff Luncheon for 1965-66 Alumni Annual Giving

About fifty alumni and guests attended the kick­ Luncheon in the Law School's Horace Stern Dining Hall off meeting and luncheon for the 1965-66 campaign for is enjoyed by Annual Giving workers and f?Uests. Law School Alumni Annual Giving held at the Law School on Saturday, October 30. The date coincided with the Pennsylvania-Harvard football game and home­ coming weekend when many alumni and their families were visiting the University campus. Edwin H. Burgess, L'14, General Chairman of the campaign, reported on the successes achieved last year in reaching a new high of $87,164, and sounded the keynote in calling for increased funds in 1965-66 to meet the expanding costs for academic excellence at the School. He announced that this year the Law School Alumni Annual Giving goal is $100,000. Other speakers who discussed their areas of responsibility were: Morris M. Wexler, L'27, Chairman of Benjamin Franklin Associates; Louis J. Goffman, L'35, Chairman of Cen­ tury Club; Milton B. Garner, L'36, Chairman of Class Agents; Dean Jefferson B. Fordham; and James D. Evans, Jr., Assistant to the Dean for Alumni Affairs. At the luncheon, held in Horace Stern Hall, Mr. Burgess presented the Class Performance Awards to the following Class Agents: Frank H. Mancill, L'14, Great­ est Number of Dollars Contributed; Frank H. Mancill, (l. to r.) Dean Jefferson B. Fordham and Edwin H. Burgess, '14, General Chairman for Law School L'14, Best Percent of Participation (Classes of 25 or Annual Giving, optimistically discuss the prospect more); William I. Woodcock, Jr., L'21, Best Percent of of another successful year while Morris M. Wexler, Participation (Classes of less than 25); E. Barclay Cale, '27, Chairman of Benjamin Franklin Associates, and L'62, Greatest Number of Contributors. Milton B. Garner, '36, Chairman of Class Agents, plan campaign strategy.

SPECIAL ANNOUNCEME~T: GOWEN FELLO SliPS AVAILABLE

William R. Shane, Assistant Dean for Admis­ sions Office of the Law School. The applicant must also sions and Student Aid, announces that Gowen Fellow­ include a detailed description of his graduate study and ships in amounts up to $4500 are available to graduates career plans. Applications must be filed by December of the Law School for the coming academic year. They 15, 1965. The Graduate Committee will make its deci­ may be used for graduate study at the Law School or at sions in January 1966. No letters of recommendation or another graduate school either in this country or abroad. transcript are required so that section of the form can Application forms are available from the Admis- be ignored.

20 LAW ALUMNI JOURNAL https://scholarship.law.upenn.edu/plj/vol1/iss1/1 22 et al.: Law Alumni Journal

COMMENTS ON LAW IN THE AFRICAN COUNTRIES Former Dean of Nigerian Law School Is Bicentennial Fellow Alan Milner LL.B., LL.M ., Ph.D., former Dean popular and timely new course, African Law Problems, and Professor of Law of Ahmadu Bello University in which has an enrollment of fifty-five students. Next Zaria, Nigeria is a visiting scholar supported by a Bicen­ semester he will teach Comparative Criminal Law. tennial Fellowship in Criminal Law and Administration Dr. Milner has published work in family law, during the current academic year. Dr. Milner started this jurisprudence, and legal education in addition to criminal law school which was the first in Northern Nigeria. In law. 1961 Northern Nigeria with a population of twenty-nine He is currently preparing a complete manual for million had three native lawyers. When Dr. Milner left the Nigerian Penal System intended to be used for ad­ the school in 1965 it had a faculty of fourteen, the library visory and training purposes in Nigeria. This book will contained 15,000 volumes, classes included about twenty­ include material hitherto unavailable in Nigeria on prac­ five students, and the school had graduated its first class tices, experiences and statistics from other legal systems. of four. The law school also helps upgrade existing court He is also organizing and editing articles by fifteen con­ personnel. A two-year law subdegree program has tributors from different countries into a book surveying granted fifteen diplomas and three month courses have African Penal Systems. been given to 1500 native court judges. After this year he will be Law Fellow of Trinity Dr. Milner had also taught at the College of College, Oxford University, England. Commerce, Leeds, England; University of Pittsburgh The following material on law in those African Law School, and Queen's University, Belfast, Northern countries which were former British colonies is based on Ireland. This semester Dr. Milner is teaching the very an interview with Dr. Milner. Conflict of Laws Major African Legal Problem In those African countries which were formerly In Northern Nigeria, for example, there are five British colonies, conflict of laws is an ever recurring legal classes of native courts. These range from "A" in which problem as two legal systems and court systems had de­ the traditional ruler, the Emir, serves as judge and has veloped simultaneously in each country. Customary law unlimited jurisdiction including capital jurisdiction, to applied to natives only, but law based on English statutes the loosely organized pagan court in which about fifteen and the common law had been introduced and applied to members of the village serve together as judges and both Europeans and natives. As these colonies become choose one of their members to act as chairman. Islamic independent countries, the question of how these two sys­ law is the common "customary" law of large areas of tems are to interrelate becomes a major problem further Northern Nigeria and serves as a unifying force. complicated by the fact that there is also conflict among Legal representation was not allowed in the cus­ the customary laws-there are thousands of tribes with tomary courts-the parties spoke for themselves if at all. different customs and even variations within tribes. Most It is interesting to note that one influence of of the so-called European legal material is available in colonial policy even in those countries we are consider­ English. The local law, however, is in the local language. ing, where the common law was the basis for the law in the A major project being undertaken in several countries at European courts, was that the only trial by jury provided this time is the codification of the customary law which was in capital cases-and that only in some countries. had not previously been reduced to writing in any lan­ Ghana, Tanzania and Gambia have attempted guage. Dr. Milner pointed out, however, that the work the unification of the court systems. Tanzania has accom­ of the comparative lawyer interested in African law is plished this by adding a new lowest court, the Primary being thwarted by such factors as Tanganyika (now Court, which has jurisdiction over former customary Tanzania) codifying its law in Kiswahili! matters as well as non-customary jurisdiction based on Although both types of law are now being re­ other factors such as the amount involved. The present tained, the problem of determining whether a given per­ District Courts and High Court alone formerly comprised son is to be classed as a native or non-native must, in the European system. many cases, be determined by statute. Two major steps which are being taken in unifi­ The duality has also spawned two systems of cation of the two systems are the abolition of customary courts. Judges in the European courts had to be qualified criminal law and giving the customary courts statutory lawyers and to have been members of the bar a specified jurisdiction to apply European law. Remembering, how­ length of time. Judges in the customary courts, on the ever, that judges in these courts do not necessarily know other hand, had no such formal educational require­ the language in which the law is written one can see why ments. They had to be learned in customary law as dem­ countries such as Northern Nigeria, Sudan, Uganda and onstrated by such factors as age and family. In the Kenya have resorted to saying that the native courts shall predominantly Moslem countries of Africa a Koranic use European legislation relating to procedure, evidence education may have been required as well as apprentice­ and crimes as guides. ship or attendance in a Moslem law school.

Fa111965 21

Published by Penn Law: Legal Scholarship Repository, 2014 23 Penn Law Journal, Vol. 1, Iss. 1 [2014], Art. 1 ALUMNI

1914 Officers of Coif chapter CLARKE M. SELTZER is celebrating the 100th anniversary attend to group's business. of his law office. The office was established by his second L. to r. Harold Cramer, '51, President; Vice Dean cousin with whom he practiced until the latter's death Theodore H. Husted, Jr., in 1917. He believes his office to be one of the oldest in '50, Secretary;and, seated, Pennsylvania. Louis J. Goffman, '35, Vice President. 1917 MERVYN R. TURK has been named first assistant in the Delaware County, Pennsylvania, Public Defenders office.

1920 THOMAS K. FINLETTER is now with Coudert Brothers, 200 Park Avenue, N.Y., after having represented the United States at the Paris headquarters of NATO since COIF LUNCHEON 1961.

Professor George L. Haskins addressed the an­ 1924 nual luncheon meeting of the University of Pennsylvania DAVID F. MAXWELL was elected president of the Crime Chapter of The Order of the Coif October 15, 1965 held Commission of Philadelphia. He was also elected to in the Mirage Room of the Barclay Hotel, Philadelphia membership in the Institute of Judicial Administration. on "The Evil Practice of Majority Opinions." For a report of this talk see page 4. 1927 PHILIP W. AMRAM, Chairman of the Pennsylvania Civil Procedural Rules Committee, had an article in the July New York Alumni Dinner American Bar Association Journal on "The Proposed International Convention on the Service of Documents The University of Pennsylvania Law School Abroad." Association of New York City held a dinner at the Uni­ versity of Pennsylvania Club in the Biltmore Hotel on HERMAN I. PoLLOCK was elected to membership in the November 17. Dean Jefferson B. Fordham was present, Institute of Judicial Administration. and Bernard G. Segal, '31, delivered the main address. Richard B. Smith, '53, President of the group, served as 1928 toastmaster. JuDGE BURTON R. LAUB has been named Dean of the The officers were re-elected for an additional one Dickinson School of Law effective upon his retirement year term. Richard B. Smith, '53, continues as President; as a member of the Erie County Common Pleas Court Edward M. Harris, Jr., '49, Vice President; Silas January 3, 1966. Spengler, '60, Secretary; and John C. Mueller, '59, Treasurer. 1929 THEODORE VooRHEES was elected Vice Chairman of the National Conference of Bar Presidents at Miami Class of 1925 Holds 40 Year Reunion Beach. The following fourteen members of the Class of 1931 1925 attended their fortieth reunion at the home of HERBERT S. LEVIN was appointed a judge in the newly Judge J. Colvin Wright at Bedford, Pennsylvania on formed Philadelphia Common Pleas Court Number 10. June 24, 1965: Harris C. Arnold, Lancaster, Pa.; Louis A. Bloom, Chester, Pa.; Hon. Herbert B. Cohen, York, Pa.; Myer E. Cooper, Philadelphia, Pa.; Michael Edel­ man, Philadelphia, Pa.; Carl W. Funk, Philadelphia, Pa.; COMING ALUMNI EVENT Mortimer E. Graham, Erie, Pa.; Daniel Marcu, Phila­ delphia, Pa.; E. E. Mather, Philadelphia, Pa.; Desmond The Pennsylvania Law Alumni Group will hold a J. McTighe, Norristown, Pa.; Morton Meyers, Johns­ luncheon during the 1966 Pennsylvania Bar Associ­ town, Pa.; Seymore S. Silverstone, Johnstown, Pa.; ation meeting on Thursday, January 20 in the Arthur M. Soll, Philadelphia, Pa.; Hon. J. Colvin Wright, Pittsburgh Hilton Hotel. Bedford, Pa. 22 LAW ALUMNI JOURNAL https://scholarship.law.upenn.edu/plj/vol1/iss1/1 24 et al.: Law Alumni Journal

Class of 1908 Holds Fifty-Seventh NOTES Annual Reunion The Class of 1908 held its fifty-seventh annual 1936 reunion at the Locust Club in Philadelphia on June 5, JEROME A. O'NEILL has been appointed a judge of the 1965. Dean Jefferson B. Fordham addressed the group. Philadelphia County Court. Each member of the class in attendance spoke. THOMAS RAEBURN WHITE, JR. was elected a Fellow of Most other members of the class sent letters. Extracts the American College of Trial Lawyers. from minutes of the first meeting of the class held in September 1905 and from subsequent class meetings 1938 were read. GREGORY G. LAGAKOS was appointed a judge of the Isaac Ash of Philadelphia took complete charge Philadelphia County Court. of arrangements. Leon J. Obermayer of Philadelphia is President of the class, and Edward F. Hitchcock of 1940 Media, Pennsylvania is Secretary of the class. EDWIN P. RoME was elected a Fellow of the American The following graduates of the class and their College of Trial Lawyers. families were present: Mr. and Mrs. Leon J. Obermayer; 1942 Mr. Edward F. Hitchcock and his son, Mr. Edward F. Hitchcock, Jr.; Mr. Russell L. Browne; Dr. and Mrs. GEORGE KERESTES was elected President of the Penn­ FrederickS. Baldi; Mr. John J. O'Brien; Mr. Isaac Ash; sylvania District Attorneys' Association. Mrs. Ellwood J. Turner and Mr. William H. Turner, 1950 widow and son of a member; Mr. and Mrs. Louis M. D. DoNALD JAMIESON was appointed a judge in Phila­ Cohen, son-in-law of a member; Mrs. Randolph W. delphia Common Pleas Court Number 9. This is a newly Childs and Mr. Dawson Childs, widow and son of a added court. member. Dean and Mrs. Jefferson B. Fordham were present as guests of the Class of 1908. 1951 At the Reunion letters were read from practically FRANCIS B. HAAS, JR. was honored by the Boys' Clubs every surviving member of the class who was unable of America for "material contributions to the cause of to be present including the following: Henry Arronson, juvenile decency." Charles H. Bracken, William J. Brady, John Arthur Brown, Hon. Frank B. Burch, James D. Carpenter, 1953 James Arthur Ewing, Robert T. Fox, Walter Gilkyson, EDWARD J. BRADLEY was appointed a judge in the newly Otto Kraus, Jr., Rev. Eugene A. Martin, Leigh M. Morss, added Philadelphia Common Pleas Court Number 10. Henry P. Norris, Howard S. Okie, Raymond Pitcairn, HARRY V. KLEIN, JR. was elected Commander of the Forrester H. Scott, and Arthur M. Widdows. American Legion, Department of Pennsylvania, the Legion's largest state organization. OFFICERS OF THE CLASS OF 1965 1958 JosEPH F. KEENER, JR. is first assistant defender of the L . to r. Stephen M. Goodman, Treasurer; Harvey Montgomery County, Pennsylvania, Voluntary Defender Bartle III, Class Agent; William H. Ewing, Presi­ Association. dent; Thomas Hamilton, Secretary; Alan M . Lerner, Vice President. 1963 THOMAS E. QuAY has recently joined William H. Rorer, Inc. as assistant counsel on the legal staff of the Fort Washington, Pennsylvania, pharmaceutical manufactur­ ing company.

ALUMNI SONS IN CLASS OF 1968 The following alumni have sons in the present first year class : Oscar Bregman, '34 Eric Bregman Robert J. Dodds, Jr., '40 Robert J. Dodds, III John W. Frazier, III, '38 John W. Frazier, IV Harry A. Greenberg, '38 Murray Greenberg Israel Packel, '32, LL.M '33 Richard S. Packel

Fall 1965

Published by Penn Law: Legal Scholarship Repository, 2014 25 Penn Law Journal, Vol. 1, Iss. 1 [2014], Art. 1

Civil Rights continued from page I judge and jury, the tendency to favor one of their own against an outsider, and the machinations of the local 'court house gang.'" Particularly, in civil cases involving civil rights, "Congress has declared the historic judgment Professor that within this precious area, often calling for a trial by jury, there is to be no slightest risk of nullification by A. Leo Levin state process." I believe that Congress made the same Named judgment in criminal cases; that here, too, it saw and acted on the probability that state courts would not ade­ Vice Provost quately protect federally guaranteed civil rights; that here, too, it authorized and commanded federal trial of courts to anticipate and supersede state court trials for the complete and timely enforcement of interests "of the University highest national concern.'' Two grants of jurisdiction to the federal district courts are specifically addressed to the problem: the civil rights removal jurisdiction, 28 U.S.C. § 1443 (1958), and President Gaylord P. Harnwell has named Pro­ the federal habeas corpus jurisdiction, 28 U.S.C. § 2241 fessor of Law A. Leo Levin, '42, vice provost of the (1958). The lower federal courts, with some support in University with primary responsibility in the area of Supreme Court decisions, are giving unduly narrow scope student affairs. Professor Levin will be responsible for to both. In cases like that of Mississippi Negro defend­ the offices of the Dean of Men, Dean of Women, Admis­ ants mentioned above, federal district courts have dis­ sions, Student Financial Aid, Foreign Students, Fellow­ allowed removal and refused to entertain habeas corpus. ship Information and Study Programs Abroad, and the Section 1443 is plagued by unlikely constructions which University Counseling Service. leave it impotent to cope with any state infringements of Mr. Levin will continue a substantial teaching civil rights save those which state ingenuity outgrew schedule in the Law School. He has resigned as chair­ three-quarters of a century ago. Section 2241, disfigured man of the University Senate and vice chairman of the by the doctrine requiring exhaustion of state remedies, University Council. has become largely the exclusive prerogative of long-term When announcing Mr. Levin's new position, state felony convicts claiming trial error. My study of the President Harnwell said, "This appointment reflects the background of the two jurisdictional grants and the ap­ marked changes in undergraduate life which have propriate scope of removal and habeas corpus in civil evolved in recent years. Characteristic of these changes rights cases reveals a way to minister to these ills. are the increased student concern for the educational My principal thesis is that under the federal re­ process and for closer faculty-student relationships. moval and habeas corpus statutes a petition filed before "As former chairman of the University Senate state trial by a state criminal defendant making a color­ and of the University Council's Undergraduate Publica­ able showing that the conduct for which he is prosecuted tions Committee, Professor Levin has been closely iden­ was conduct protected by the federal constitutional guar­ tified with both student and faculty affairs. As vice antees of civil rights authorizes and requires the appro­ provost, his special responsibility will be centered in priate federal district court to entertain and dispose of his the chief educational office of the University, insuring federal contention (in the case of habeas corpus) or of that the administration of student affairs will be con­ the whole prosecution against him (in the case of re­ cerned with the total educational experience of the moval) in advance of state trial-and this without regard undergraduate." to whether he also claims that the state courts are hostile, biased, conspiratorial, or incompetent. I appreciate that some will regard my proposal as an end of federalism. Graduate Students Represent Six Countries I fully share their concern for the preservation of an ap­ Of the nine graduate students this year, six are propriate federal balance, but I think the complaint from the following foreign countries: Israel, Korea, exaggerated. I am also concerned by the opportunities Philippines (2), Taiwan, Pakistan. for abuse which extension of pretrial federal intervention Although interests are clustered in various fields may allow state criminal defendants whose cases do not of international and comparative law-one of the three come within the scope of allowable removal or habeas American students also being interested in public and corpus as I understand those jurisdictions, but who may private international law-they do include criminal law, attempt to use federal petitions as a means for delaying corporate taxation, labor law and social legislation. or disrupting state trials. I think that the danger of these All but one of the these students has expressed abuses may be minimized, and so much danger as re­ an interest in teaching. Three who have already engaged mains is a price I am willing to pay for protection of in law teaching intend to continue on completion of federal constitutional liberties. More to the point, I think their work here. the price is one which Congress was willing to pay.

24 LAW ALUMNI JOURNAL https://scholarship.law.upenn.edu/plj/vol1/iss1/1 26 et al.: Law Alumni Journal

The Law Review has a New Face 0 0 0

and a New Format

The student section has been completely revamped. Only the former high level of scholarship and accuracy has been retained. Each student­ written piece will deal with a particular issue or area of the law and will be called a Comment. Here are some tentative offerings of Volume 114: Remedies for the Defrauded Consumer The Insurance Company's Duty to Defend Right to Jury Trial in Counterclaims in Bankruptcy The Treatment of Reapportionment Cases in the District Courts Retroactive Changes in Trustee Compensation Rates Defensive Lockouts The Articles are stimulating and useful. The topics will be more varied, some outright unconventional. The authors will be distinguished scholars and practitioners from every corner of the legal world. Some Articles in the works: The Planned Unit Development Symposium: Articles by Pro­ fessor Jan Krasnowiecki, Mr. Byran R. Hankey, Professor Daniel Mandelker, Mr. David W. Craig. Andenaes, The Deterrent Effects of Punishment Levin, On Assuring Flexibility in the Operation of Rules of Evidence Reich, Welfare in the Public-Private State Ruder, Public Obligations of a Private Corporation Sparer, The Best Interest Test in Welfare Administration Vestal, The Jurisprudential Implications of the West Publishing System Wolfman, Federal Tax Support of Science Use card inserted at page 14 to subscribe to the ·new Review.

Published by Penn Law: Legal Scholarship Repository, 2014 27