Aquatic Engineering, Inc.
Advancing the Science of Assessment, Management and Rehabilitation of our Aquatic Natural Resources!
2004 Bone Lake Water Quality
Technical Report
Prepared by:
Aquatic Engineering
Post Office Box 3634
La Crosse, WI 54602-3634
Phone: 608-781-8770 Fax: 608-781-8771
E-mail: [email protected] Web Site: www.aquaticengineering.org
2004 Bone Lake Water Quality Technical Report
February 2005
By N. D. Strasser1, and J. E. Britton2
In cooperation with the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources and the Polk County Land and Water Resources Department
1 Aquatic Engineering, Inc.; [email protected] PO Box 3634, La Crosse, WI 54602-3634 Phone: 608-781-8770 www.aquaticengineering.org
2 The Limnological Institute; [email protected] PO Box 304, La Crosse, WI 54602-0304 Phone: 800-485-1772; www.thelimnologicalinstitute.org
Acknowledgements
The 2004 Bone Lake Water Quality Monitoring Technical Report was completed with the assistance of the Bone Lake Management District and through a Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources (WDNR) Lake Planning Grant (#LPL-947-04) which provided funding for 75% of the monitoring costs. A special thanks to the following individuals for their help throughout the project:
Bone Lake Management District Commissioners
Robert Murphy Tim Laughlin Dale Vlasnik Mary Delougherty Brian Masters Dick Boss
Chairman Vice Chairman Treasurer Secretary Commissioner Commissioner
Bill Jungbauer Mark Lendway Wayne Shirley Ralph Johansen Ron Ogren
Commissioner Commissioner Town of Bone Lake Commissioner Polk County Commissioner Georgetown Commissioner
Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources
Danny Ryan Jane Malishke Heath Benike
Lake Coordinator Environmental Grants Specialist Fish Biologist
Polk County Land and Water Resources
Jeremy Williamson Amy Kelsey
Water Quality Specialist Information and Education Coordinator
i
Executive Summary
Bone Lake is a 1,781-acre drainage lake located in Polk County, Wisconsin. Four inflows are located in the sub-watersheds. The outflow is the Fox Creek, which flows into the Apple River. The Bone Lake watershed is part of the Upper Apple River watershed in the Saint Croix River Basin. This basin was designated as a priority for non-point source pollution control by the Saint Croix Water Quality Management Plan (WI DNR 1994) and included in the Polk County Land and Water Resource Plan (Bursik
2001).
The water quality of Bone Lake was sampled from June to October of 2004. A single sample station was selected for the North and South basins of Bone Lake. Parameters of reactive phosphorus, total phosphorus, total Kjeldahl nitrogen, and chlorophyll a were analyzed by the Water and Environmental Analysis Laboratory located at the University of Wisconsin - Stevens Point. Temperature, dissolved oxygen, conductivity, specific conductance, and salinity were recorded on site and measured with a YSI probe at onemeter intervals from the surface to the bottom. Secchi depth readings were also taken at each water quality sampling point. Measurements were taken weekly in June and July and once per month in August through October.
The water quality results and Secchi readings show that Bone Lake is a mesotrophic to slightly eutrophic lake with a composite1 TSI (Trophic Status Index) value of 48.3. The North basin of Bone Lake is slightly more eutrophic than the South basin with TSI values of 49.6 and 46.9, respectively. Bone Lake becomes thermally stratified in the summer and mixes well in the spring and fall. The condition of the lake water quality is similar to that of other lakes in the region.
The TSI values observed in 2004 were improvements from the values reported in the 1997 Barr Engineering report. The improvements may be due to the implementation of
1 A composite TSI value was calculated by averaging the TSITP, TSIChl a and TSIS values from both basins.
ii recommendations made in that report or could be due to seasonal variation in temperature and precipitation.
Recommendations outlined in the current management plan should continue to be implemented. In addition to current recommendations, it is recommended that Bone Lake manage its curly-leaf pondweed population every spring to minimize the phosphorus loading affects that occur each summer when CLP decays. Self-help monitoring and the creation and enforcement of zoning and land use ordinances will continue to play a major role in improving water quality within Bone Lake.
iii
2004 Bone Lake Water Quality Monitoring
Technical Report
Table of Contents
- Acknowledgments
- i
Executive Summary 1.0 Introduction 2.0 Methods ii 14
2.1 Water Sample Collection ____________________________________4 2.2 On-Site Water Quality Measurements __________________________4 2.3 Phytoplankton and Zooplankton Samples _______________________4 2.4 Trophic Status Calculations __________________________________5
- 3.0 Results
- 6
6789
3.1 Phosphorous 3.2 Chlorophyll a 3.3 Secchi Depth 3.4 Other Parameters
3.4.1 Total Kjeldahl Nitrogen (TKN) ___________________________9 3.4.2 Soluble Reactive Phosphorus (SRP) _______________________9 3.4.3 Temperature__________________________________________10 3.4.4 Conductivity and Specific Conductance ____________________12 3.4.5 Dissolved Oxygen _____________________________________12 3.4.6 Salinity______________________________________________14
3.5 Phytoplankton and Zooplankton_______________________________14
- 4.0 Discussion
- 18
18 18 18
4.1 Trophic Status Index 4.2 Water Quality 4.3 Phytoplankton and Zooplankton 5.0 Recommendations__________________________________________20
6.0 References 22
iv
List of Tables
Table 1 Table 2
Phytoplankton analysis of the 6-foot composite sample collected from the North basin sample site of Bone Lake, Polk Co., WI. 2004.____________15
Phytoplankton analysis of the 6-foot composite sample collected from the South basin sample site of Bone Lake, Polk Co., WI. 2004.____________15
List of Figures
Figure 1 Figure 2 Figure 3 Figure 4
Water quality locations within the North and South basins of Bone Lake, Polk County, WI. 2004. ________________________________________3
Total phosphorus measurements from the North and South basin sample locations in Bone Lake, Polk Co., WI. 2004. _______________________6
Chlorophyll a measurements from the North and South basin sample locations in Bone Lake, Polk Co., WI. 2004. _______________________7
Secchi depth readings from the North and South basin sample locations in Bone Lake, Polk Co., WI. 2004. _________________________________8
Figure 5 Figure 6 Figure 7
Bone Lake North basin temperature profiles for 2004. ________________11 Bone lake South basin temperature profiles for 2004._________________11 Dissolved oxygen profiles for the North and South basins of Bone Lake in 2004. _______________________________________________________13
Figure 8
Figure 9 Figure 10 Figure 11
Zooplankton community composition of Bone Lake North basin on August 19, 2004.______________________________________________16
Zooplankton community composition of Bone Lake South basin on August 19, 2004.______________________________________________16
Zooplankton community composition of Bone Lake North basin on September 8, 2004. ____________________________________________17
Zooplankton community composition of Bone Lake South basin on September 8, 2004. ____________________________________________17
v
List of Appendices
- Appendix A Water Quality Profile Raw Data
- 23
32 36
Appendix B WSLOH Water Quality Lab Reports Appendix C WSLOH Phytoplankton Lab Reports Appendix D Zooplankton Raw Data _________________________________________39
vi
1.0 Introduction
Bone Lake (WDNR Water Body Identification Code #2628100) is a 1,781-acre drainage
lake with a mean depth of 23 feet and a maximum depth of 43 feet, located in Polk County, Wisconsin. Four inflows are located in the sub-watersheds. The outflow is Fox Creek, which flows into the Apple River. The Bone Lake watershed is part of the Upper Apple River watershed in the Saint Croix River Basin, which was designated as a priority for non-point source pollution control by the Saint Croix Water Quality Management Plan (WI DNR 1994) and included in the Polk County Land and Water Resource Plan
(Bursik 2001).
The Bone Lake Management District was formed in 1975 to address issues of dense algal blooms and extensive weed beds. The District immediately sought help from the Office of Inland Lake Renewal, which conducted a survey of Bone Lake from 1977 to 1978. The results of the survey were presented to the District in 1980 and concluded that Bone Lake is eutrophic and that the algae and macrophyte problems stemmed from elevated phosphorous levels. The recommendations listed in the report included an alum treatment, to reduce the amount of phosphorous internally cycled, and macrophyte harvesting in certain areas.
The Bone Lake Management District has continued to be proactive in managing the lake. From 1988 to 1989 the WI DNR surveyed Bone Lake and designated 11 sensitive areas of the lake that were critical to supporting fish and wildlife. Since 1998, a volunteer from the District has collected water clarity data, as outlined by the WI DNR self-help monitoring program.
In 1997 the District contracted Barr Engineering to conduct a lake survey and write a Management Plan. The plan was completed in three phases, where the third phase was the development of a Management Plan. Management suggestions from this plan reinforced the recommended alum application and suggested creating ordinances for
1storm water, septic systems, and shoreland development. The District and Polk County have since followed through on creating ordinances for storm water, septic systems, and shoreland development but have chosen not to perform an alum application. The Management Plan also recommended continued self-help Secchi depth monitoring and water quality measurements for total phosphorous and chlorophyll a from the North and South basins every third year.
Studies leading to Barr Engineering’s Management Plan (Barr 1997 and 1999) addressed Bone Lake’s watershed, hydrology, and nutrient cycling processes, but the Plan itself did not contain an adequate aquatic plant management component. Increasing Curly-leaf pondweed populations1 are a concern for Bone Lake and should be addressed in a Management Plan update.
Curly-leaf pondweed (CLP) is an exotic aquatic plant that impacts water quality by releasing nutrients into the water column in mid-summer and promoting algal blooms (Crowell 2003). It was unintentionally introduced in Wisconsin during common carp stocking activities in the 1800’s and is now present in many Wisconsin lakes. All aquatic plants contribute nutrients to lakes as they decay, but native plants die off in the late summer or early fall, and their nutrients are consumed by bacteria before they can fuel algal growth. As much as 5.5 pounds of phosphorus per acre can be released from monotypic CLP beds (McComas 2000). Excess nutrients such as phosphorus cause murky water conditions and algal blooms.
1 Aquatic Engineering Inc. mapped 57.7 acres of Curly-leaf pondweed in May 2003.
2
Figure 1. Water quality locations within the North and South basins of Bone Lake, Polk County, WI. 2004.
3
2.0 Methods
2.1 Water Sample Collection
Water quality monitoring is a specific recommendation of the Polk County Land and Water Resource Plan (p. 22). Therefore, two sample sites were established at opposite ends of the lake; one site was selected in the North basin at the deep hole, and one in the South basin, just south of the island (Fig. 1). Water samples were collected by representatives of Polk County and were sent to the Water and Environmental Analysis Laboratory (WEAL) located at UW – Stevens Point, where they were analyzed for total phosphorus, soluble reactive phosphorus, chlorophyll-a, pH, total Kjeldahl nitrogen, nitrate + nitrite, ammonia, alkalinity, total hardness, chloride, and total suspended solids. These samples were collected at elbow depth and kept on ice until they arrived at the laboratory. Samples were collected weekly in June and July and then monthly until fall turnover.
2.2 On-Site Water Quality Measurements
Depth profiles were collected weekly at the two mid-basin sampling sites during the summer sampling period (June and July) and once per month until the fall turnover event. Data points were collected at one-meter intervals throughout the water column and measured on-site for dissolved oxygen, pH, conductivity, and temperature with a YSI SONDE probe.
2.3 Phytoplankton and Zooplankton Samples
Phytoplankton and zooplankton samples were collected in August at both lake water quality monitoring stations. A 2-meter integrated surface sampling device was used to collect a composite sample of the epilimnion. The device was lowered to approximately 1 foot below the water surface effectively capturing a 2 meter column of water from approximately 1 to 7 feet below the water surface. Phytoplankton samples were mailed
4overnight to the Wisconsin State Lab of Hygiene in Madison, WI. The most common organism was identified to species; remaining organisms were identified to division, and biomass estimates were calculated. Zooplankton samples were collected either from the bottom of the epilimnion to the water surface, or from two feet above the lake bottom to the surface, depending on field conditions. A vertical tow net with 66 µm mesh and collection cup was used for sampling. The most common taxa were identified to species; all other taxa were identified to genus, and the biovolume of each taxon was estimated. Zooplankton samples were mailed overnight to Phycotech, where all taxa were identified to species, and the biovolume of each taxon was estimated.
2.4 Trophic Status Calculations
Trophic status was calculated for each sampling location using the following equations
(the units of measurement required for each parameter are included as a subscript in the equation):
TSISD = 60 – 14.41* ln (SDm) TSIchl = 9.81* ln (chlµg) + 30.6 TSITP = 14.42 * ln (TP µg) + 4.15
The following scale is used to evaluate trophic status (Lillie and Mason 1983):
- TSI < 30
- oligotrophic
mesotrophic eutrophic
40 < TSI < 50 TSI > 50
5
3.0 Results
3.1 Phosphorous
The average total phosphorus (TP) for the North basin was 24.4µg/L with a maximum of 35µg/L and a minimum of 13µg/L. The average for the South basin was 21.4µg/L with a maximum of 34µg/L and a minimum of 9µg/L. The TSITP values for the North and South basins are 50.2 and 48.3, respectively.
Bone Lake Total Phosphorus 2004
40 35
Eutrophic
30 25
North Basin
20
15 10
5
South Basin
Mesotrophic Oligotrophic
0
- 6/8/04
- 7/8/04
- 8/19/04
- 9/8/04
- 10/27/04
Figure 2. Total phosphorus measurements from North and South basin sample locations in Bone Lake, Polk Co., WI. 2004.
6
3.2 Chlorophyll a
The average chlorophyll a (Chl a) a for the North basin was 10.12µg/L with a maximum of 17.6µg/L and a minimum of 5.4µg/L. The average Chl a for the South basin was 5.76µg/L with a maximum of 10.0µg/L and a minimum of <1.0µg/L. The TSIchl values for the North and South basins are 53.3 and 47.8, respectively.
Bone Lake Chlorophyll a 2004
20 18 16 14 12 10
8
Eutrophic
North Basin South Basin
6
Mesotrophic Oligotrophic
420
- 6/8/04
- 7/8/04
- 8/19/04
- 9/8/04
- 10/27/04
Figure 3. Chlorophyll a measurements from the North and South basin sample locations in Bone Lake, Polk Co., WI. 2004.
7
3.3 Secchi Depth
The average Secchi reading for the North basin was 9.08 ft with a maximum of 16.5 ft and a minimum of 5.0 ft, recorded on October 27th and August 9th, 2004, respectively. The average reading for the South basin was 9.45 ft with a maximum reading of 17.0 ft and a minimum of 6.5 ft, recorded on October 27th and September 8th, 2004, respectively. The TSIS for the North and South basins are 45.3 and 44.8, respectively.
Secchi Depth in Bone Lake
June-October 2004
6/8/2004 6/16/2004 6/30/2004 7/8/2004 7/14/2004 7/22/2004 7/29/2004 8/19/2004 9/8/2004 10/27/2004
1234
Eutrophic
56789
Mesotrophic Oligotrophic
10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18
North Basin South Basin
Figure 4. Secchi depth readings from the North and South basin sample locations in Bone
Lake, Polk Co., WI. 2004.
8
3.4 Other Parameters
Other parameters, such as total Kjeldahl nitrogen, soluble reactive phosphorus, temperature, conductivity, specific conductance, and salinity affect water quality in many different ways and are discussed separately in the following sections.
3.4.1 Total Kjeldahl Nitrogen (TKN)
The Kjeldahl technique is a laboratory test for measuring the amount of organic nitrogen contained in water. Organic nitrogen concentration is equal to total Kjeldahl nitrogen concentration (TKN) minus ammonia concentration. Organic nitrogen may exist as either dissolved or suspended particulate matter in water. High levels of organic nitrogen in water may indicate excessive biological production or organic pollution in the watershed. Animal and human waste, decaying organic matter, and live organic material like tiny algae cells can cause organic nitrogen enrichment of lake water (Tippecanoe
Environmental Lake and Watershed Foundation 2005). Nitrogen, like phosphorus, is an
essential macronutrient needed for algal production. Most Midwest lakes, however, are phosphorus-limited, and attempts to reduce lake nitrogen levels may have little effect on algal biomass (Holdren et al. 2001). The average TKN for Bone Lake in 2004 was 487µg/L. The N: P ratio was approximately 21 and supports the conclusion that Bone Lake is phosphorus-limited.
3.4.2 Soluble Reactive Phosphorus (SRP)
Soluble reactive phosphorus (SRP) is a dissolved form of phosphorus. Because dissolved phosphorus is readily available for uptake by plants, the amount of SRP found in a lake provides a good estimation of how much phosphorus is available for algae and plant growth. Because aquatic plant growth is typically limited by phosphorus, added phosphorus (especially in dissolved, bio-available form) can fuel plant growth and cause algae blooms. Sources of SRP can include failing septic systems, animal waste, fertilizers, decaying plants and animals, and sediment resuspension from the lake bottom. Because phosphorus is cycled so rapidly through biota, SRP concentrations as low as 5 µg/L are enough to maintain eutrophic or highly productive conditions in lake systems
9
(Tippecanoe Environmental Lake and Watershed Foundation 2005). The average SRP
for Bone Lake in 2004 was 16.3µg/L.
3.4.3 Temperature
Temperature plays a major role in water quality, especially in lakes that become thermally stratified. Thermal stratification occurs when water in the top layer of a lake becomes heated by the sun, and insufficient mixing action allows this warm water layer (epilimnion) to "float" on top of a cooler, more dense layer of water near the bottom (hypolimnion). As the summer progresses, the difference in density between the two layers increases, and when the difference becomes too great for wind energy to mix, the lake becomes stratified (Holdren et al. 2001). The region between the epilimnion and hypolimnion is called the metalimnion. The depth within the metalimnion where the rate of change in temperature is greatest is called the thermocline (Holdren et al. 2001). In 2004 Bone Lake formed a thermocline in both basins of the lake. The thermocline in the South basin, however, was more distinct than that in the North basin, but neither thermocline was particularly strong in 2004. The fetch of Bone Lake (the area of the lake affected by wind motion) allows for plenty of mixing action caused by wind and waves, and a steady flow of recreationalists also aids in mixing the water.
10
Bone Lake North Basin Temperature Profiles 2004