DERRIDA´S MACHINE
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Summer-Edition 2017 — vordenker-archive — Rudolf Kaehr (1942-2016) Title DERRIDAs Machines: Cloning Natural and other Fragments Archive-Number / Categories 2_13 / K02 Publication Date 2004 Keywords Web, Polycontextural Strategies, Logic, Dissemination of Formal Systems, Proemial Relation, Heterarchy, Chiasm, Diamond Strategies, Kenogrammatic, Algebras and Co-Algebras, Identity vs diversity, equality vs sameness vs non-equality – see also 3_12 Disciplines Artificial Intelligence and Robotics, Epistemology, Logic and Foundations, Cybernetics, Computer Sciences, Theory of Scinces Abstract This is a collection of different scientific essays such as “Cloning the Natural – and other Fragments”, “Exploiting Parallelism in Polycontextural Systems”, “Cybernetic Ontology and Web Semantics”, “Minsky´s new Machine”, “The new scene of AI-Cognitive Systems?”, “Dynamic Semantic Web” Citation Information / How to cite Rudolf Kaehr: "DERRIDAs Machines: Cloning Natural and other Fragments", www.vordenker.de (Sommer Edition, 2017) J. Paul (Ed.), URL: http://www.vordenker.de/rk/rk_DERRIDAs_Machines_2004.pdf Categories of the RK-Archive K01 Gotthard Günther Studies K08 Formal Systems in Polycontextural Constellations K02 Scientific Essays K09 Morphogrammatics K03 Polycontexturality – Second-Order-Cybernetics K10 The Chinese Challenge or A Challenge for China K04 Diamond Theory K11 Memristics Memristors Computation K05 Interactivity K12 Cellular Automata K06 Diamond Strategies K13 RK and friends K07 Contextural Programming Paradigm DERRIDA‘S MACHINES by Rudolf Kaehr PART ONE Cloning the Natural–and other Fragments Parallelism and Panalogy PART TWO Dynamic Semantic Web Final-Report 27. 07. 2004 (DRAFT-Version) The TransComputation Institute ThinkArt Lab Glasgow [email protected] Dr. Rudolf Kaehr, October 2003/July 2004 Rudolf Kaehr September 2, 2004 7/21/04 DRAFT DERRIDA‘S MACHINES 1 DDEERRRRIIDDAA‘‘SS MMAACCHHIINNEESS PART ONE CLONING THE NATURAL, PROEMIALITY, PANANALOGY, PARALLELISM Cloning the Natural–and other Fragments 1 A fundamental theory of the natural 2 2 Cloning naturality 10 3 Unicity, Intuition and Explication 12 4 Dissemination: Introducing the proemial relationship 13 5 Combinatorics of chiastic changes of categories 26 6 Proemiality between structural and processual understanding 35 7 Category Theory – and beyond? 39 8 Dissemination of natural objects 44 9 On interactivity between cloned systems 47 10 Introducing the metaphor of a tissue of coloured logics 53 11 Dissemination of deductive systems 55 12 Dissemination of a framework of Tableaux Logics 56 13 Classical and polycontextural logics 59 14 Modi of interactions: super-operators 66 15 Tactics of implementing polycontextural systems 80 16 Towards poly-versal algebras 81 17 Polylogical abstract objects 83 18 Some serious consequences of the superoperator construction 91 19 Computational Ontology and the Problem of Identity 106 20 Cloning the Ur-Logik 111 Some applications 1 Pragmatics of cloned natural systems 124 2 Programming languages in the context of proemiality 127 3 Internal vs. external descriptions of interactions 131 Rudolf Kaehr September 2, 2004 7/21/04 DRAFT DERRIDA‘S MACHINES 2 The new scene of AI: Cognitive Systems? 1 Cognitive systems, architecture, interactivity 133 2 Some coments on Hypercomputing 140 3 Some special institutions 142 4 Similar or complementary work to the PCL-Project 143 5 What are the decisive advantages of the PCL approach? 144 6 Comments on the Grand Chalenge Project 145 Non-Academic Projects Slide-diagrams PCL-CogSys Some non-technical background texts to PCL Limitations and Possibilities of Communication and Co-Creation 1 American Second-Order Cybernetics 158 2 In a nutshell: Proemiality and Polycontextural Logic 159 Discontexturality: The Art of Thinking Art in ThinkArt 1 Creativity and Computability beyond Science and Metaphor 161 2 Some reflections about the structure of the new Art Material 162 About the Art of Programming Art 1 Open_SourceThinking Project Glasgow 164 2 "Well-defined" problems in creating problems 164 3 What could we understand by creativity? 164 4 Cutting the Human/Machine-Interface again 165 5 To use and to be used by technology and beyond 166 6 Questions and Outlooks faced at the Academy of Media Arts 166 Computation and Metaphysics Rudolf Kaehr September 2, 2004 7/21/04 DRAFT DERRIDA‘S MACHINES 3 Exploiting Parallelism in PCL-Systems 1 Polycontextural Strategy towards the Challenge of Parallelism 175 2 Parallelism in Polycontextural Logic 193 3 Tableaux Logics 201 4 Why not Grid Computing? 203 Minsky´s new Machine 1 Proemiality and Panalogy 205 2 Complementary Work? 208 3 Minsky´s Architecture: The Six Level Model 210 4 The Polycontecturality Approach 210 5 Togetherness of living systems 213 6 Intra- and trans-contextural proemiality of/between cognitive systems 215 7 Cognition and Volition 221 Comparatistics of Models and Metaphors of Machines 1 Minsky Machines vs. Gunther Machines 227 2 Turing Machines vs. Gurevich Machines 227 3 Wegner Machines vs. Turing Machines 227 4 Minsky Machines vs. Derrida Machines 227 5 Keno Machines vs. Sign Machines (Markov Machines) Rudolf Kaehr September 2, 2004 7/21/04 DRAFT DERRIDA‘S MACHINES 4 PART TWO DYNAMIC SEMANTIC WEB Wozu Dynamic Semantic Web?* 1 Ziel: Was soll erreicht werden? 2 Einschränkung: Was soll nicht erreicht werden? 3 3 Methode: Wie und womit soll DSW erreicht werden? 3 4 Nutzen: Wozu soll DSW erreicht werden? 4 5 Institutionen: Wo und mit wem soll DSW erreicht werden? 5 6 Zeitrahmen: Wann soll DSW erreicht werden? 5 7 Abgrenzungen: Wogegen soll DSW erreicht werden? 5 Towards a Dynamic Semantic Web 1 The Semantic Web 7 2 How to introduce the Dynamic Semantic Web? 14 3 Development of a DSW Prototype Business Application 21 Cybernetic Ontology and Web Semantics 1 Life as Polycontexturality 29 2 Heideggers radical deconstruction of ontology 32 3 Ontologies in different fashions 33 4 Revival of classic ontology in Web Semantics? 34 1 On the General Ontological Foundations of Conceptual Modeling 39 2 Urelements and Sets 40 3 Formal Ontology and First Order Logic, revisted 41 4 Contributions to the Axiomatic Foundation of Upper-Level Ontologies 43 1 Orthogonalizing the Issues 46 Dynamic Semantic Web 1 SHOE: Dynamic ontologies on the Web 50 2 Polycontextural Dynamics 51 3 Short comparition of SHOE and DSW 52 Rudolf Kaehr September 2, 2004 7/21/04 DRAFT DERRIDA‘S MACHINES 5 4 Architectonic Parallelism of DSW 53 5 Dynamics in the Semantic Web Context 54 Dynamics in Ontologies and Polysemy 1 Dynamic Ontologies in SHOE 60 2 Polysemy: Ontology Extension with the procedure rename 65 3 Polycontextural modelling of polysemy 70 4 Some Polylogical Modelling of Polysemy 76 5 Polycontextural modelling of multiple inheritance 81 6 Query, questions and decisions 85 From Metapattern to Ontoprise 1 Parallelism in Polycontextural Logic 86 2 Ontological transitions 92 Interactions in a meanigful world 1 Queries, question-answering systems 96 2 Diamond based interrogative systems 96 3 Evocative communications 96 On Deconstructing the Hype 1 The hype of the distributed, decentralized and open Web 97 2 Conflicts between diversity and centralization of ontologies 99 3 Trees, Hierarchies and Homogeneity 100 4 Structuration: Dynamics and Structures 101 5 Problems with semantics? 102 6 Problems with inferencing? 102 SHOE Ontology Example "CS Department" CNLPA-Ontology Modelling 1 CNLPA-ONTOLOGY-object 106 2 CNLPA-ONTOLOGY-process 110 3 CNLPA-ONTOLOGY-metapattern 113 4 CNLPA-ONTOLOGY-polylogic 114 Rudolf Kaehr September 2, 2004 7/21/04 DRAFT DERRIDA‘S MACHINES 6 DERRIDA‘S MACHINES PART ONE Cloning the Natural – and other Fragments Exploiting Parallelism in PCL-Systems Cybernetic Ontology and Web Semantics Minsky´s new Machine The new scene of AI: Cognitive Systems? Slide-Diagrams PCL-CogSys Rudolf Kaehr September 2, 2004 8/26/03 DRAFT DERRIDA‘S MACHINES 1 Rudolf Kaehr September 2, 2004 8/26/03 DRAFT DERRIDA‘S MACHINES 2 A fundamental theory of the natural Cloning the Natural – and other Fragments There is no safety in numbers, or in anything else. Thurber 1 A fundamental theory of the natural If there is anything left in this world we live which is still untouched and natural then it is the naturalness of the natural numbers–and nothing else. "´Natural´ because they are given at the outset, taken for granted as a founding, unanaliz- able intuition, outside any critique that might demand an account of how they come or came–potentially or actually–to ´be´.“ Brian Rotman „0.5 Le nombre règle les représentations culturelles. „0.6. Le nombre, évidement, regle l´économie, et sans doute est-ce la ce que Luis Althusser aurait appelé la „détermination en dernière instance“ de sa suprématie. L´idéologie des so- ciétés parlemantaire moderne, s´il y a une, n´est pas l´humanisme, le Droit du Sujet. C´est le nombre, le comptable, la comptabilité.“ Alain Badiou, Le Nombre et les nombres. Seuil 1990 And why not Leopold Kronecker? "God made the integers, all the rest is the work of Man." As Natural as 0,1,2 Philip Wadler. Evans and Sutherland Distinguished Lecture, University of Utah, 20 Novem- ber 2002. "Whether a visitor comes from another place, another planet, or another plane of being we can be sure that he, she, or it will count just as we do: though their symbols vary, the numbers are universal. The history of logic and computing suggests a programming language that is equally natural. The language, called lambda calculus, is in exact correspondence with a formulation of the laws of reason,