ADI 2011 1 Research Lab Dev’t Assistance Generic Core DA Generic Core

DA Generic Core ...... 1 DA Fails – Western Model ...... 55 DA Fails – Politicized ...... 56 ***DA Solves*** ...... 3 DA Fails – Poverty ...... 57 DA Solves – Generic ...... 4 DA Fails – Governance Turn ...... 58 DA Solves – A2: Rejection ...... 5 DA Fails – Governance Turn ...... 59 DA Solves – A2: Transition ...... 6 DA Fails – Accountability Turn ...... 60 DA Solves – A2: Long term ...... 7 DA Fails – Transition Turn ...... 61 DA Solves – A2: Dependency ...... 8 DA Fails – Transition Turn ...... 62 DA Solves – A2: Parties ...... 9 DA Fails – Transition Turn – Impact Calc: Escalation ..... 63 DA Solves – A2: Definitional Problems ...... 10 DA Fails – Gov’t to Gov’t ...... 64 DA Solves – A2: Governance ...... 11 DA Fails – Gov’t to Gov’t ...... 65 DA Solves – A2: Governance ...... 12 ***NGO DA Solves*** ...... 66 DA Solves – A2: Local Context Key ...... 13 DA Solves – A2: Local Context Key ...... 14 NGO DA Solves – Aid Works ...... 67 DA Solves – A2: Backlash ...... 15 NGO DA Solves – Aid Works ...... 68 DA Solves – A2: Credibility/Politicization ...... 16 NGO DA Solves – A2: Repression ...... 69 DA Solves – A2: Credibility/Politicization ...... 17 NGO DA Solves – A2: Repression ...... 70 DA Solves – A2: Credibility/Politicization ...... 18 NGO DA Solves – NGO’s Good ...... 71 DA Solves – A2: Regime Change – No Link ...... 19 NGO DA Solves – NGO’s Good ...... 72 DA Solves – A2: Regime Change – Turn: Moderation ..... 20 NGO DA Solves – NGO’s Good ...... 73 DA Solves – A2: Western Model ...... 21 DA Solves – A2: Corruption ...... 22 ***NGO DA Fails*** ...... 74 DA Solves – A2: Coordination ...... 23 NGO DA Fails – Generally ...... 75 DA Solves – A2: Coordination ...... 24 NGO DA Fails – Gov’t Cooptation ...... 76 DA Solves – A2: Assessment ...... 25 NGO DA Fails – NGO’s =/= Gov’t Change ...... 77 DA Solves—A2: Complexity ...... 26 NGO DA Fails – Repression ...... 78 DA Solves—A2: Culture ...... 27 NGO DA Fails – Urban ...... 79 DA Solves—A2: Monitoring ...... 28 NGO DA Fails – Picking Winners ...... 80 ***DA Fails***...... 29 NGO DA Fails – Divisions ...... 81 NGO DA Fails – NGOs Bad – Generally ...... 82 DA Fails – Generic ...... 30 NGO DA Fails – NGO’s Bad – Accountability ...... 83 DA Fails – A2: Studies ...... 31 NGO DA Fails – NGO’s Bad – Accountability ...... 84 DA Fails – A2: Studies ...... 32 NGO DA Fails – NGO’s Bad – Representativeness ...... 85 DA Fails – A2: Studies ...... 33 NGO DA Fails – NGO’s Bad – Representativeness ...... 86 DA Fails – A2: Studies ...... 34 NGO DA Fails – K Link ...... 87 DA Fails – A2: Studies – Block Trick: No Solvency ...... 35 DA Fails – Rejection ...... 36 ***USAID Solves*** ...... 88 DA Fails – Cooptation ...... 37 USAID Solves – Generic ...... 89 DA Fails – Long-Term ...... 38 USAID Solves – Generic ...... 90 DA Fails – Complexity ...... 39 USAID Solves – A2: Contracting ...... 91 DA Fails – Culture ...... 40 USAID Solves – A2: Branding ...... 92 DA Fails – Monitoring ...... 41 DA Fails – Parties ...... 42 ***USAID Fails*** ...... 93 DA Fails – Parties ...... 43 USAID Fails – Coordination ...... 94 DA Fails – Agency Coordination ...... 44 USAID Fails – Coordination ...... 95 DA Fails – Separation of Powers ...... 45 USAID Fails – Local Populations ...... 96 DA Fails – Dependency ...... 46 USAID Fails – Politics ...... 97 DA Fails – Credibility ...... 47 USAID Fails – Generally ...... 98 DA Fails – Credibility ...... 48 USAID Fails – Contracting ...... 99 DA Fails – Credibility ...... 49 USAID Fails – Resources ...... 100 DA Fails – Local Context ...... 50 USAID Fails – Branding ...... 101 DA Fails – Local Context ...... 51 DA Fails – Local Context ...... 52 DA Fails – Local Context – A2: We Build Capacity ...... 53 DA Fails – Definitional Problems ...... 54 ADI 2011 2 Research Lab Dev’t Assistance Generic Core

***NED Solves*** ...... 102 ***NED Fails*** ...... 108 NED Solves – Democratization ...... 103 NED Fails- Politics ...... 109 NED Solves- k2 Democratization ...... 104 NED Fails- Politics ...... 110 NED Solves- k2 Democratization ...... 105 NED Fails- Credibility ...... 111 NED Solves- Relations ...... 106 NED Fails – Picking Winners ...... 112 NED Solves- Modeled ...... 107 NED Fails—Administration ...... 113

ADI 2011 1 Research Lab Framework Framework

Framework ...... 1 2NC Engaging Politics Solves Totalitarianism ...... 40 2NC Policy Debate Fractures Movements ...... 41 ***Kritiks Bad*** ...... 3 2NC No Spillover ...... 42 **Shells...... 3 **Answers To ...... 43 *Aff ...... 3 AT: Mitchell ...... 44 AT: Spanos ...... 45 2AC Shell ...... 4 AT: Kulynych ...... 46 *Neg ...... 5 AT: Karl Rove Was A Debater ...... 47 AT: Hicks & Greene...... 48 1NC Shell 1/3 ...... 6 AT: Hicks & Greene...... 49 1NC Shell 2/3 ...... 7 AT: You Exclude Critiques ...... 50 1NC Shell 3/3 ...... 8 AT: Debate Produces Bad Policymakers ...... 51 **Overviews...... 9 AT: You Create Spectators ...... 52 AT: K Precedes Theoretical Arguments ...... 53 *Aff ...... 9 AT: Rules Are Violent ...... 54 1AR Overview ...... 10 AT: Minority Participation ...... 55 AT: Resolved Is Before The Colon ...... 56 *Neg ...... 11 AT: Words Lack Determinate Meaning ...... 57 2NC Overview ...... 12 **Policymaking/Roleplaying ...... 58 **Interpretation Debate ...... 13 2NC Oasis Wall ...... 59 2NC Interpretation Extension ...... 14 2NC Oasis Wall ...... 60 2NC AT: Counter-Interpretation ...... 15 Policy Framework Good – Inevitable ...... 61 2NC AT: Your Interpretation is Exclusionary ...... 16 Policy Framework Good – Decision-Making ...... 62 2NC AT: We Meet – We Affirm the Rez as “X” ...... 17 Policy Framework Good – International Law ...... 63 Roleplaying Good – Education ...... 64 **Fairness Debate ...... 18 Roleplaying Good – Devil’s Advocate ...... 65 2NC Fairness Extension ...... 19 Roleplaying Good – Empowerment ...... 66 2NC AT: Nazis Wanted Fairness ...... 20 Roleplaying Good – Politics ...... 67 2NC AT: Your Conception of Fairness is Bad ...... 21 Roleplaying Good – Solves Exclusion ...... 68 2NC AT: Education Precedes Fairness ...... 22 Roleplaying Good – Democracy ...... 69 2NC AT: Fairness is Arbitrary ...... 23 A2: Roleplaying Utopian ...... 70 2NC AT: Fairness is Utopian ...... 24 **DA Specific Policy FW ...... 71 **Switch-Side Debate ...... 25 Aid Debates Good ...... 72 2NC Switch-Side Extension ...... 26 Aid Debates Good ...... 73 2NC AT: Switch-Side Kills Advocacy ...... 27 Aid Debates Good ...... 74 2NC AT: Switch-Side Causes Relativism ...... 28 Aid Debates Good ...... 75 **Shively Debate ...... 29 **Consequentialism ...... 76 2NC Shively Extension ...... 30 Policymaking Requires Consequentialism ...... 77 Policymaking Requires Consequentialism ...... 78 **Lutz Debate ...... 31 Consequentialism Good – Lesser Evil ...... 79 Consequentialism Good – Not Calculation ...... 80 2NC Lutz Extension ...... 32 Consequentialism Good – Morals ...... 81 **Boggs Debate ...... 33 Morality Bad – International Violence ...... 82 2NC Boggs Extension ...... 34 **Utilitarianism ...... 83 2NC AT: Debate  Social Movements ...... 35 Utilitarianism Good – Public Sphere ...... 84 2NC Apolitical Theorizing Does Nothing ...... 36 Utilitarianism Good - Inevitable ...... 85 2NC Apolitical Theorizing Does Nothing ...... 37 Utilitarianism Good – Moral ...... 86 2NC Policy Debate Can Influence Policymakers ...... 38 Survival Outweighs Morality ...... 87 2NC Theory Trades Off With Politics ...... 39 AT: Calculation Bad ...... 88 ADI 2011 2 Research Lab Framework

**Extinction ...... 89 Consequentialism Bad – Epistemology ...... 134 Extinction Outweighs – Laundry List ...... 90 **A2: Pragmatism ...... 135 Extinction Outweighs – Discussion Key ...... 91 Pragmatism Bad – Empty Rhetoric ...... 136 Extinction Outweighs – General ...... 92 Pragmatism Bad – Atrocities ...... 137 Extinction Outweighs – General ...... 93 Pragmatism Bad – Decision-Making ...... 138 Extinction Outweighs – Ontology ...... 94 Pragmatism Bad – Tautological ...... 139 **Pragmatism ...... 95 Pragmatism Bad – Epistemology ...... 140 Pragmatism 2AC – Rorty ...... 96 **A2: Switch Sides Debate ...... 141 Cede The Political 1NC – Ketels (1/2) ...... 97 Switch Sides Bad – Spanos ...... 142 Cede The Political 1NC – Ketels (2/2) ...... 98 Switch Sides Bad – Hicks and Green ...... 143 Cede The Political 1NC – Rorty (1/2)...... 99 Switch Sides Bad – Hicks and Green ...... 144 Cede The Political 1NC – Rorty (2/2)...... 100 Affirmative Kritiks Good ...... 147 AT: We Can Never Change Politics ...... 101 Affirmative Kritiks Good ...... 148 **Generic K Answers ...... 102 **State-Centricity Bad ...... 149 *Statism ...... 102 Statism Bad – Agency ...... 150 State Good – Movements ...... 103 Statism Bad – Agency ...... 151 State Good – Extinction ...... 104 Statism Bad – Violence ...... 152 State Good – Environment ...... 105 Statism Bad – Education ...... 153 State Good – Strategic Reversibility ...... 106 Statism Bad - Identity ...... 154 *Language ...... 107 **Answers To ...... 155 No Alternative ...... 108 AT: Predictability ...... 156 A2: Word PICs ...... 109 AT: Limits ...... 157 A2: Word PICs ...... 110 AT: Limits ...... 158 Punishment of Language Bad ...... 111 AT: Rules Good ...... 159 *Narratives ...... 112 AT: Education ...... 160 Narratives Bad – Self-Fulfilling Prophecy ...... 113 AT: You Lead To No Limits ...... 161 Narratives Bad – Self-Fulfilling Prophecy ...... 114 AT: Limits/Exclusion Inevitable ...... 162 Narratives Bad – Fetishization ...... 116 AT: Limits/Exclusion Inevitable ...... 163 Narratives Bad – Victimization ...... 117 AT: You Lead To Different Limits ...... 164 Narratives Bad – Narcissism ...... 118 AT: Shively ...... 165 Narratives Bad – Narcissism ...... 119 AT: Do It On The Neg ...... 166 Narratives Bad – Narcissism ...... 120 AT: Wrong Forum ...... 167 *Irony ...... 121 AT: Debate Community ...... 168 AT: Policymaking ...... 169 Irony Bad – Non-Falsifiable ...... 122 AT: Policymaking ...... 170 Irony Bad – Alt Fails ...... 123 AT: Policymaking ...... 171 Irony Bad – Apolitical ...... 124 AT: Policymaking ...... 172 Irony Bad – Solvency Turn ...... 125 AT: Policymaking Solves Violence ...... 173 Irony Bad – Not Subversive ...... 126 AT: Must Be Policy Relevant...... 174 A2: Irony Avoids Cooption ...... 127 AT: Elite Takeover ...... 175 ***Kritiks Good*** ...... 128 AT: Topical Version ...... 176 AT: Must Debate About Policy ...... 177 **A2: Utilitarianism/Consequentialism ...... 128 AT: Cede The Political ...... 178 AT: Cede The Political ...... 179 Utilitarianism Bad – Genocide/War/Morals ...... 129 AT: Cede The Political ...... 180 Utilitarianism Bad – Individuality ...... 130 AT: Focus On Solvency/Procedure ...... 181 Utilitarianism Bad – Morals ...... 131 AT: Focus On Solvency/Procedure ...... 182 Utilitarianism Bad – Mass Death ...... 132 Utilitarianism Bad – Value to Life ...... 133

ADI 2011 1/188 Frappier-Russell Agamben Answers K Answers Toolbox

K Answers Toolbox ...... 1 Agamben – Alt Fails (3/4) ...... 59 Agamben – Alt Fails (4/4) ...... 61 ***Western Feminism Answers*** ...... 3 Agamben – No Alt – A2: Witnessing ...... 62 Agamben – No Alt – A2: Whatever Being ...... 63 Western Feminism – No Link: Imperialism/Trade-Off ...... 4 Western Feminism – Perm Solves – Politics Key ...... 5 ***Empire Answers*** ...... 64 Western Feminism – Perm Solves – Generally ...... 6 Western Feminism – Perm Solves – Generally ...... 7 Empire – No Link: DA is Not Imperial ...... 65 Western Feminism – Perm Solves – Generally ...... 8 Empire – Imperialism Good ...... 66 Western Feminism – Perm Solves – Generally ...... 9 Empire – Imperialism Good ...... 67 Western Feminism – Perm Solves – Generally ...... 10 Empire – Hegemony Good ...... 68 Western Feminism – Alt Fails – Aff is a Prereq to the Alt ... 11 Empire – A2: US is Imperialist ...... 69 Western Feminism – Alt Fails – Essentialism Turn ...... 12 Empire – A2: US is Imperalist ...... 70 Western Feminism – Alt Fails – Exclusion Turn ...... 13 Empire – A2: US is Imperalist ...... 71 Western Feminism – Alt Fails – Generally ...... 14 Empire – Anti-Imperialism – Alt Fails ...... 72 Western Feminism – Alt Fails – Generally ...... 15 Empire – Anti-Imperialism – Alt Fails ...... 73 Empire – General Philosophy Bad ...... 75 ***Security Answers*** ...... 16 Empire – Perm ...... 76 Empire – Impact Debate 1/3...... 77 Security K – No Link – A2: State Bad ...... 17 Empire – Impact Debate 2/3...... 78 Security K – Link Turn: Sovereignty ...... 18 Empire – Impact Debate 3/3...... 79 Security K – AT: Security Discourse Bad ...... 19 Empire – Alt Debate ...... 80 Security K – AT: Security Discourse Bad ...... 20 Empire – Alt Debate ...... 81 Security K – Threats = Real – Generally and Historically ... 21 Empire – Alt Debate ...... 82 Security K – A2: Epistemology K ...... 22 Empire – Alt Debate ...... 83 Security K – AT: Root Cause ...... 23 Empire – Alt Debate ...... 84 Security K – Fear Good ...... 24 Empire – Alt Debate ...... 85 Security K – Apocalyptic Imagery Good – Social Change .. 25 Security K – Apocalyptic Imagery Good – Social Change .. 26 ***Whiteness Answers*** ...... 86 Security K – Apocalyptic Imagery – Alt Fails ...... 27 Security K – Predictions Good ...... 28 Whiteness – Democracy Good ...... 87 Security K – Predictions Good ...... 29 Whiteness – Democracy Good ...... 88 Security K – Perm Solves – Strategic Reversibility ...... 30 Whiteness – Democracy Good ...... 89 Security K – Perm Solves – Generally ...... 31 Whiteness – Democracy Good ...... 91 Security K – Perm Solves – A2: Security is Totalizing ...... 32 Whiteness – Colorblindness Good ...... 92 Security K – Alt Fails – Discourse ...... 33 Whiteness – Perm Solves ...... 93 Security K – Alt Fails – Generally ...... 34 Whiteness – Perm Solves ...... 94 Security K – Alt Turn – Exclusion ...... 35 Whiteness – Perm Solves ...... 95 Security K – Alt Fails – Reject Bad ...... 36 Whiteness – Perm Solves ...... 96 Security K – Alt Fails – Violence Inevitable ...... 37 Whiteness – Perm Solves – A2: Monolithic Power ...... 97 Security K – Alt Fails – Violence Inevitable ...... 38 Whiteness – A2: Time Wise ...... 98 Whiteness – ‘White Supremacy’ = Dirty Word ...... 99 ***Agamben Answers*** ...... 39 Whiteness – Alt Fails – Focus on White Supremacy Bad .. 100 Whiteness – Alt Fails – Focus on White Supremacy Bad .. 101 Agamben – Perm ...... 40 Whiteness – Alt Fails – AT: Olson Alt ...... 103 Agamben – Perm: Neg Totalizes ...... 41 Whiteness – LatCrit ...... 104 Agamben – Perm: Neg Totalizes ...... 42 Whiteness – LatCrit ...... 106 Agamben – AT: Aid Links (1/2) ...... 43 Whiteness – LatCrit ...... 107 Agamben – AT Aid: Links (2/2) ...... 44 Whiteness – LatCrit – A2: Spillsover ...... 108 Agamben – No Link: Liberalism Good ...... 45 Whiteness – LatCrit – A2: Spillsover ...... 109 Agamben – No Link: Liberalism Good ...... 46 Whiteness – LatCrit – A2: Marginalizes Black History ..... 110 Agamben – No Impact – Turn: Trivialization ...... 47 Whiteness – LatCrit – A2: Black Perspective Key ...... 111 Agamben – No Impact – Turn: Value to Life/Bare Life ...... 48 Agamben – No Impact – A2: Root Cause ...... 49 Agamben – No Impact – AT: Bare Life ...... 50 Agamben – No Impact – AT: Bare Life ...... 51 Agamben – AT: Soveriegn Power ...... 52 Agamben – AT: Biopower  Holocaust ...... 53 Agamben – Alt Bad – Overdetermined ...... 54 Agamben – No Alt – Turn: Sovereign Control ...... 55 Agamben – No Alt – Turn: Violence ...... 56 Agamben – Alt Fails (1/4) ...... 57 Agamben – Alt Fails (2/4) ...... 58 -1- ADI 2011 2/188 Frappier-Russell Agamben Answers ***Orientalism Answers*** ...... 149 ***Nietzsche Answers*** ...... 112 Orientalism – Perm Solvency ...... 150 Nietzsche – Perm (1/3) ...... 113 Orientalism – Perm Solvency ...... 151 Nietzsche – Perm (2/3) ...... 114 Orientalism – Said Defense- Ontology ...... 152 Nietzsche – Perm (2/3) ...... 115 Orientalism – Said Defense- Ontology ...... 153 Nietzsche – Perm – Solvency ...... 116 Orientalism – Said Defense- Useless Theory ...... 154 Nietzsche – Perm – Solvency ...... 117 Orientalism – Said Defense- Useless Theory ...... 155 Nietzsche – Link Turn – Liberal Institutions ...... 118 Orientalism – Said Defense- Useless Theory ...... 156 Nietzsche – Link Turn – Liberal Institutions ...... 119 Orientalism – Said Defense- Flawed Theory ...... 157 Nietzsche – Link Turn – Democracy ...... 120 Orientalism – Said Defense- Out of Context ...... 158 Nietzsche – Link Turn – Democracy ...... 121 Orientalism – Said Defense- Out of Context ...... 159 Nietzsche – Link Turn – Democracy ...... 122 Orientalism – Said Defense- Out of Context ...... 160 Nietzsche – Link Turn – Democracy ...... 123 Orientalism – Said Offense- Conclusions bad ...... 161 Nietzsche – Impact Turn – Genocide ...... 124 Orientalism – Said Offense- Conclusions bad ...... 162 Nietzsche – Impact Turn – Genocide ...... 125 Orientalism – Said Offense- Conclusions bad ...... 163 Nietzsche – Impact Turn – Violence ...... 126 Orientalism – Said Offense- Orientalist ...... 164 Nietzsche – Impact Turn – Rape ...... 127 Orientalism – Said Offense- Orientalist ...... 165 Nietzsche – A2: Suffering Link ...... 128 Orientalism – Said Offense- Advocates Violence ...... 166 Nietzsche – AT: Suffering Inevitable ...... 129 Orientalism – Said Offense- Flawed Theory ...... 167 Nietzsche – AT: Suffering Inevitable ...... 130 Orientalism – Said Offense- Flawed Theory ...... 168 Nietzsche – A2: Ressentiment ...... 131 Nietzsche – AT: Slave Morality (1/2) ...... 132 ***Neoliberalism Answers*** ...... 169 Nietzsche – AT: Slave Morality (2/2) ...... 133 Nietzsche – A2: Root Cause of Vio ...... 134 Neoliberalism – Turn: Cap Good ...... 170 Nietzsche – A2: Root Cause of Vio ...... 135 Neoliberalism – Turn: Cap Good – General ...... 171 Neoliberalism – Turn: Cap Good – Environment ...... 172 Nietzsche – A2: Root Cause of Vio ...... 136 Neoliberalism – Turn: Cap Good – Food Production ...... 173 Neoliberalism – Turn: Cap Good – Space ...... 174 Nietzsche – A2: Root Cause of Vio ...... 137 Neoliberalism – Turn: Cap Good – Freedom ...... 175 Nietzsche – Alternative – No Solvency ...... 138 Neoliberalism – Turn: Cap Good – War ...... 176 Nietzsche – Alternative – No Solvency ...... 139 Neoliberalism – AT: Inequality ...... 177 Nietzsche – Alternative – No Solvency ...... 140 Neoliberalism – AT: Value to Life...... 178 Nietzsche – Alternative – No Solvency ...... 141 Neoliberalism – Alt = Transition Wars ...... 179 Nietzsche – Alternative – No Solvency ...... 142 Neoliberalism – Alt = Transition Wars ...... 180 Nietzsche – Alternative – No Solvency – ER ...... 143 Neoliberalism – Perm Solves ...... 181 Nietzsche – Alternative – No Solvency – ER ...... 144 Neoliberalism – Perm Solves ...... 183 Nietzsche – Alternative – Turn – Otherness ...... 145 Neoliberalism – Alt Fails – Capitalism Inevitable ...... 184 Nietzsche – Alternative – Extinction Outweighs ...... 146 Neoliberalism – Alt Fails – Capitalism Inevitable ...... 185 Nietzsche – Alternative – Extinction Outweighs ...... 147 Neoliberalism – Alt Fails – Generic (And Cap Links) ...... 186 Nietzsche – A2: VTL ...... 148 Neoliberalism – Alt Fails – Totalizing Bad ...... 187 Neoliberalism – Alt Fails – Totalizing Bad ...... 188

-2- ADI 2011 1 Research Lab SKFTA DA SKFTA DA

SKFTA DA ...... 1 Alliance Good – Asia Stability Scenario (2/3) ...... 40 SKFTA 1NC ...... 2 Alliance Good – Asia Stability Scenario (3/3) ...... 41 SKFTA 1NC ...... 3 Brink – Asian Tensions High Now ...... 42 SKFTA 1NC ...... 4 Korea War Impact – Conflict Ensures Escalation ...... 43 Impact – Alliance Good – AT – Resiliency (1/2) ...... 44 ***UQ – SKFTA*** ...... 5 Impact – Alliance Good – AT – Resiliency (2/2) ...... 45 Uniqueness – SKFTA Will Pass Now ...... 6 Impact – Alliance Good – Warming (1/2) ...... 46 UQ – SKFTA Will Pass Now – AT: TAA Prevents (1/2) ...... 7 Impact – Alliance Good – Warming (2/2) ...... 47 UQ – SKFTA Will Pass Now – AT: TAA Prevents (1/2) ...... 8 SKFTA Good – Trade Policy ...... 48 Impact Uniqueness – AT – South Korea Won’t Pass (1/2) ...... 9 Trade Scenario - Japan ...... 49 Impact Uniqueness – AT – South Korea Won’t Pass (2/2) ...... 10 Trade Scenario - Japan ...... 50 Uniqueness – TAA-FTA Compromise Likely Now (1/5) ...... 11 Trade Scenario - Doha...... 51 Uniqueness – TAA-FTA Compromise Likely Now (2/5) ...... 12 SKFTA Good – AT – Deregulation ...... 52 Uniqueness – TAA-FTA Compromise Likely Now (3/5) ...... 13 SKFTA Good – AT – Impact Turns ...... 53 Uniqueness – TAA-FTA Compromise Likely Now (4/5) ...... 14 ***Aff*** ...... 54 Uniqueness – TAA-FTA Compromise Likely Now (5/5) ...... 15 Uniqueness & Internal Link Answer – Political Capital Not Key to ***Internal Links*** ...... 16 Trade Agreements ...... 55 Political Capital Key to Trade Agreements (1/2) ...... 17 Impact Uniqueness Answer – No TAA-FTA Compromise Now . 56 Political Capital Key to Trade Agreements (2/2) ...... 18 Uniqueness – Won’t Pass Now – TAA (1/3)...... 57 Internal Link – Obama Political Capital Key to SKFTA ...... 19 Uniqueness – Won’t Pass Now – TAA (2/3)...... 58 Internal Link – Obama Political Capital Key to SKFTA ...... 20 Uniqueness – Won’t Pass Now – TAA (3/3)...... 59 Internal Link – GOP Coop Key to SKFTA ...... 21 Uniqueness – Won’t Pass Now – Political Stalling ...... 60 Internal Link – Democrats Key to SKFTA ...... 22 Uniqueness – Won’t Pass Now – Republican Boycott ...... 61 Political Capital Key to Agenda (1/4) ...... 23 Economy Impact Uniqueness Answer ...... 62 Political Capital Key to Agenda (2/4) ...... 24 Impact Uniqueness – South Korea Won’t Pass Now (1/2) ...... 63 Political Capital Key to Agenda (3/4) ...... 25 Impact Uniqueness – South Korea Won’t Pass Now (2/2) ...... 64 Political Capital Key to Agenda (3/4) ...... 26 Impact Answer – No Conflict (1/2) ...... 65 Political Capital Finite (1/2) ...... 29 Impact Answer – No Conflict (2/2) ...... 66 Political Capital Finite (2/2) ...... 30 Impact Answer – AT – SKFTA Key to Econ ...... 67 Internal Link – Passage of TAA Key to FTAs ...... 31 Impact Answer – AT – SKFTA Key to Alliance ...... 68 Impact Answer – South Korea-US Alliance Resilient ...... 69 ***South Korean Free Trade Agreement Good ...... 32 SKFTA Bad – Economy (1/2) ...... 70 SKFTA Bad – Economy (2/2) ...... 71 SKFTA Good – Alliance Scenario ...... 33 SKFTA Bad – Financial Regulation Good ...... 72 SKFTA Good – Alliance Scenario ...... 34 SKFTA Bad – Financial Regulation Good ...... 73 SKFTA Good – Alliance Scenario – Link Xts ...... 35 FTAs Bad – Jobs ...... 74 Impact – SKFTA Good – Alliance – Military Doesn’t Solve ...... 35 FTAs Bad – AT – Trade Adjustment Assistance Checks ...... 75 Impact – SKFTA Good – Alliance – AT – SKFTA Not Key (1/2)...... 37 Impact – SKFTA Good – Alliance – AT – SKFTA Not Key (2/2)...... 38 Alliance Good – Asia Stability Scenario (1/3) ...... 39

Politics Link Core

Politics Link Core ...... 1 *****NEGSTUFF***** ...... 2 Dem Assist Unpopular - Public ...... 3 Foreign Aid Drains PC ...... 5 Dem AssistDrains PC ...... 6 USAID Drains PC ...... 8 Dem Assist Partisan ...... 11 Spending: Dem Assist ...... 13 Spending: Generic ...... 15 State and Defense ...... 17 McCain Opposes...... 18 Lugar Opposes ...... 20 Saudi Lobby ...... 21 Israel Lobby ...... 23 GOP Can Block Agenda ...... 26 Obama Gets Blame/Credit ...... 27 Public Popularity Internals ...... 29 Political Capital Internals ...... 31 PC Finite ...... 37 AT: Winners Win ...... 38 ***Country Links*** ...... 42 Egypt ...... 43 Tunisia ...... 44 Syria ...... 45 Syria ...... 46 Libya ...... 47 Bahrain ...... 48 Yemen...... 49 ***AFF STUFF*** ...... 50 Dem Assist Popular - Public ...... 51 Dem Assist Bipartisan ...... 53 Dem Assist Popular Think Tanks ...... 56 Think Tanks Key ...... 57 Winners Win Turn ...... 59 AT: Political Capital ...... 61 ***Country Links*** ...... 65 Egypt ...... 66 Libya ...... 67 Syria ...... 68 Tunisia ...... 69 Yemen...... 71 ***AT: Internal Links*** ...... 74 AT: McCain Key ...... 75 AT: DoD Key ...... 76 AT: Public k2 agenda ...... 77 AT: Think Tanks Key – Lack of Influence ...... 78 AT: Obama Gets the Blame ...... 79 AT: GOP hates the plan ...... 80 AT: Budget Fights ...... 81 AT: Popularity k2 Pocap ...... 82 AT: Saudi Key ...... 83 AT: Israeli Lobby Key ...... 84

ADI 2011 1 Research Lab IMET Aff

IMET AFF

IMET AFF ...... 1 Impact – Middle East Stability EXT ...... 57 Inherency 1AC ...... 3 Impact – Middle East Stability EXT ...... 58 Democracy Advantage – 1AC ...... 4 Impact – Terrorism EXT ...... 64 Democracy Advantage – 1AC ...... 5 ***Elections Advantage*** ...... 67 Democracy Advantage – 1AC ...... 6 Uq. – Military Screws up Elections Now ...... 67 Democracy Advantage – 1AC ...... 7 Uq. – Military Screws up Elections Now ...... 68 Democracy Advantage – 1AC ...... 8 Uq. – Military Screws up Elections Now ...... 69 Democracy Advantage – 1AC ...... 9 Uq. – Egyptian Democracy on the Brink 1/2...... 70 CMR Advantage – 1AC ...... 10 Uq. – Egyptian Democracy on the Brink 1/2...... 71 CMR Advantage – 1AC ...... 11 Uq. – Egyptian Democracy on the Brink 1/2...... 72 CMR Advantage – 1AC ...... 12 Uq. – Egyptian Democracy on the Brink 2/2...... 73 CMR Advantage – 1AC ...... 13 Military K2 Transition ...... 74 CMR Advantage – 1AC ...... 14 Solvency – Stabilizes Egypt ...... 75 CMR Advantage – 1AC ...... 15 Solvency – Stabilizes Egypt ...... 76 CMR Advantage – 1AC ...... 17 Solvency – Stabilizes Egypt ...... 77 CMR Advantage – 1AC ...... 18 Solvency – Stabilizes Egypt ...... 78 CMR Advantage – 1AC ...... 19 Solvency – Stabilizes Egypt ...... 79 1AC Solvency 1/2 ...... 20 Solvency – A2: Dem Fails – Islamic Beliefs ...... 80 1AC Solvency 2/2 ...... 21 Solvency – A2: Dem Fails – No Public Support ...... 81 ***Inherency*** ...... 22 Impact – Regional Stability/Oil ...... 82 IMET Cuts Now 1/2...... 22 Democracy Spills Over ...... 83 Top Officials are Soviet Trained 1/3 ...... 24 Democracy Spills Over ...... 84 Top Officials are Soviet Trained 2/3 ...... 25 Democracy Spills Over ...... 85 Top Officials are Soviet Trained 3/3 ...... 26 Democracy Spills Over ...... 86 Top Officials Block Transition 1/2 ...... 27 AT: Saudi DA ...... 87 Top Officials Block Transition 2/2 ...... 28 Democracy Spills Over ...... 88 ***CMR Advantage*** ...... 29 Democracy Spills Over ...... 89 CMR Low Now ...... 29 Egypt Modeling/Spillover ...... 90 CMR Low Now ...... 31 Egypt Modeling/Spillover ...... 91 CMR Low Now ...... 32 Impact – Terrorism 1/2 ...... 92 CMR Low Now ...... 33 Impact – Terrorism 2/2 ...... 93 CMR Low Now ...... 34 Impact – Terrorism EXT ...... 94 CMR Spills Over ...... 35 Impact – A2: Dem Bad – Israeli Conflict ...... 95 CMR Spills Over ...... 36 Impact – A2: Dem Bad – Muslim Brotherhood Gets CMR Spills Over ...... 37 Elected ...... 96 A2: CMR Fails – No Public Support ...... 38 Egyptian Economy – Uq...... 97 Solvency – IMET Solves CMR ...... 39 Dem Solves Egyptian Economy EXT ...... 98 Solvency – IMET Solves CMR ...... 40 Dem Solves Egyptian Economy EXT ...... 99 Solvency – IMET Solves CMR ...... 41 Dem Solves Egyptian Economy EXT ...... 100 Solvency – IMET Solves CMR ...... 42 Dem Solves Egyptian Economy EXT ...... 101 Pakistan – CMR Low Now ...... 43 Egyptian Economy – Economy Impact EXT ...... 102 Pakistan – A2: CMR in Pakistan cyclical ...... 44 Egyptian Economy – Food Wars Impact 1/2 ...... 103 Pakistan – A2: IMET training spillover won’t help Egyptian Economy – Food Wars Impact 2/2 ...... 104 Pakistani CMR ...... 45 Egyptian Economy – Regional Stability Impact ...... 105 Impact – Egyptian Stability...... 46 Egyptian Economy – Terrorism/Muslim Brotherhood Impact – Egyptian Stability...... 47 Impact 1/2 ...... 106 Impact – Democratic Transition 1/3 ...... 48 Egyptian Economy – Terrorism/Muslim Brotherhood Impact – Democratic Transition 2/3 ...... 49 Impact 2/2 ...... 107 Impact – Democratic Transition 3/3 ...... 50 Egyptian Economy – Terrorism Impact EXT ...... 108 Impact – Democratic Transition EXT ...... 51 ***Solvency*** ...... 109 Impact – Democratic Transition EXT ...... 52 Solvency – IMET Solves CMR ...... 109 Impact – Democratic Transition EXT ...... 53 Solvency – Egyptian IMET Effective ...... 110 Impact – Middle East Stability 1/2 ...... 54 Solvency – IMET Expansion Necessary EXT ...... 111 Impact – Middle East Stability 2/2 ...... 55 Solvency – Cuts Bad ...... 112 Impact – Middle East Stability EXT ...... 56 Solvency – A2: No Civilian Training ...... 113 ADI 2011 2 Research Lab IMET Aff

Solvency – A2: Squo Training Solves ...... 114 A2: Iran DA – Internal Link Turn- Brotherhood ...... 155 Solvency – In-Country Training Key ...... 115 ***A2: Saudi DA*** ...... 156 Solvency – IMET Teaches Democratic Values ...... 116 AT: Saudi DA – Egyptian Stability Solves ...... 156 Solvency – IMET Teaches Democratic Values ...... 117 AT: Saudi DA – No Prolif ...... 157 Solvency – IMET Teaches Democratic Values ...... 118 AT: Saudi DA – No Prolif ...... 158 Solvency – IMET Teaches Democratic Values ...... 119 *** A2: Spending DA*** ...... 159 Solvency – IMET Teaches Democratic Values ...... 120 A2 Spending DA – Cuts Coming Now ...... 159 Solvency – IMET Teaches Democratic Values ...... 121 A2 Spending DA – Link Turn ...... 160 Solvency – IMET Teaches Democratic Values ...... 122 ***A2: Israel DA*** ...... 161 Solvency – IMET Teaches Democratic Values ...... 123 No Link – Israel Fine With Military Aid ...... 161 CAFD MET Solvency ...... 132 ***A2: Arab Spring DA*** ...... 162 IMET Spills Over 1/2 ...... 133 A2: EU CP – US Military Best for CMR ...... 164 IMET Spills Over 2/2 ...... 134 A2: EU CP – US Military Best for CMR ...... 165 ***Add-Ons*** ...... 135 A2: EU Solvency—EU Ineffective CMR ...... 166 U.S.-Egypt Relations Add-On 1/2 ...... 135 A2: EU CP – Perm ...... 167 U.S.-Egypt Relations Add-On 2/2 ...... 136 A2: EU CP – Perm EXT ...... 168 U.S.-Egypt Relations EXT ...... 137 ***A2: Conditions CPs*** ...... 169 Readiness Add-On 1/2 ...... 138 Political Conditionality – Fails ...... 169 Readiness Add-On 2/2 ...... 139 A2: Economic Reforms ...... 170 Middle East Stability Add-On 1/2 ...... 140 ***K Answers*** ...... 171 Middle East Stability Add-On 2/2 ...... 141 Generic K Offense – Solves “Military Bad” Links .. 171 Naval Power Add-On ...... 142 ***T Answers*** ...... 172 Terrorism Add-On 1/2 ...... 143 No Consensus on DA ...... 172 Terrorism Add-On 2/2 ...... 144 A2: Only USAID = DA ...... 173 Terrorism Add-On EXT ...... 145 AT: USAID Only ...... 174 ***A2: Politics DA*** ...... 146 AT: USAID Only ...... 175 A2: Politics – Popularity L/T ...... 146 AT: IMET ≠ DA ...... 176 A2: Politics – Bipart L/T ...... 147 AT: IMET ≠ DA ...... 177 A2: Politics – Republicans L/T ...... 148 AT: IMET ≠ DA ...... 178 A2: Politics – Israel/Defense Lobbies L/T ...... 149 AT: IMET = Extra-T ...... 179 A2: Politics – Defense Lobby L/T EXT ...... 150 IMET = DA – Good Governance Reform ...... 180 A2: Politics – Israel Lobby Supports the Plan EXT ..151 IMET = DA – GJD ...... 181 A2: Politics – Israel Lobby k2 Agenda EXT ...... 152 CMR = DA ...... 182 ***A2: Iran DA*** ...... 153 A2: Iran DA – No Internal Link ...... 153 A2: Iran DA – Internal Link Turn- Brotherhood ...... 154

ADI 2011 1 Frappier Russell IMET Neg Egypt IMET Neg

Egypt IMET Neg ...... Error! Bookmark not defined. Plan Causes Democracy to Fail ...... 32 Egypt Democracy Bad ...... 32 ***Neg – IMET Inherency ...... 2 NATO ...... 33 IMET funding high now (1/8) ...... 2 Solvency Take-outs ...... 34 IMET funding high now (2/8) ...... 3 IMET funding high now (3/8) ...... 4 ***Neg – IMET Solvency ...... 35 IMET funding high now (4/8) ...... 5 Military focus guts solvency ...... 35 IMET funding high now (5/8) ...... 6 Egypt Reject Aid/Aid Fails ...... 36 IMET funding high now (6/8) ...... 7 IMET can’t solve - timeframe ...... 37 IMET funding high now (7/8) ...... 8 Econ decline tanks solvency ...... 39 IMET funding high now (8/8) ...... 9 Egyptian military kills transition (1/4) ...... 40 Egyptian military kills transition (2/4) ...... 41 ***Neg – CMR Advantage ...... 10 Egyptian military kills transition (3/4) ...... 42 Egypt CMR Prevents Regional CMR ...... 10 Egyptian military kills transition (4/4) ...... 43 CMR Bad (1/2) ...... 10 CMR Bad (2/2) ...... 13 ***Links to DAs ...... 44 *Solvency Take-outs ...... 14 Spending ...... 44 CMR doesn’t solve terrorism (1/3) ...... 14 Politics ...... 45 CMR doesn’t solve terrorism (2/3) ...... 15 CMR doesn’t solve terrorism (3/3) ...... 16 ***EU CP ...... 46 CMR increasing/high now (1/2) ...... 17 EU CP – Shell ...... 46 CMR increasing/high now (2/2) ...... 18 EU CP – Solvency ...... 47 U.S. influence high now ...... 19 CMR can’t solve – Conflict too great ...... 20 ***NED CP ...... 48 CMR stopped by military (1/5) ...... 21 NED CP – Shell (1/2) ...... 48 CMR stopped by military (2/5) ...... 23 NED CP – Shell (2/2) ...... 49 CMR stopped by military (3/5) ...... 24 NED CP – Solvency ...... 50 CMR stopped by military (4/5) ...... 25 CMR stopped by military (5/5) ...... 26 ***Topicality ...... 51 Topicality 1/6 ...... 51 ***Neg – Stability Advantage ...... 27 Topicality 2/6 ...... 52 Regional Stability Increasing/Stable Now ...... 27 Topicality 3/6 ...... 53 Plan Hurts Stability ...... 27 Topicality 4/6 ...... 54 Democracy Will Succeed Now (1/3) ...... 28 Topicality 5/6 ...... 55 Democracy Will Succeed Now (2/3) ...... 30 Democracy Will Succeed Now (3/3) ...... 31

ADI 2011 1 Research Lab IMET Aff IMET Aff Supplement

IMET Aff Supplement ...... 1 T – A2: Extra-T – E-IMET is Limited ...... 2 T – A2: Extra-T – E-IMET is Limited – Defense of the Plan...... 3 T – A2: Security Assistance ...... 4 A2: Spending/Politics ...... 5 Politics – Plan Popular – E-IMET ...... 6

ADI 2011 1 Research Lab IMET T Supplement IMET Aff T Supplement

IMET T Supplement ...... 1 T – DoD = DA ...... 5 T – Military Training = DA ...... 2 T – A2: Demo Promo =/= DA ...... 6 T – Military Training = DA ...... 3 T – Security Assistance Exclusion Overlimits ...... 4

ADI 2011 1 Roark AID T/O Disad Aid Tradeoff DA

1NC Tradeoff DA ...... 2 1NC Tradeoff DA ...... 3 1NC Tradeoff DA ...... 4 UQ ...... 5 Link/Impact ...... 6 Link Wall ...... 7 Link Wall ...... 8 Link Wall ...... 9 I/L: Zero-Sum ...... 10 A2 Plan = New Funding/No Tradeoff ...... 11 MPX: Turns Case ...... 12 MPX: Terror = Retal ...... 13 MPX: Terror = Extinction ...... 14 MPX: Foreign Exchange/Soft Power ...... 15 AFF – N/U ...... 16 AFF – Readiness D ...... 17 AFF – Readiness D ...... 18 AFF – Soft Power D ...... 19 AFF – Terror D ...... 20 AFF – Terror D ...... 21 AFF – Terror =/= Retal ...... 22

ASU 2011 1 Fellows Bahrain Aff

Bahrain Aff

Bahrain Aff ...... 1 1AC ...... 3 Inherency – No US Pressure Now ...... 20 Inherency – Unconditioned Military Aid Now ...... 22 Inherency – Assistance Disorganized Now ...... 23 Inherency – Bahrain not a Priority Now ...... 24 Inherency – Dictatorship Now ...... 25 Inherency – Security Crackdown Will Fail Now ...... 26 Inherency - Iran Backing Protesters Now ...... 27 Inherency – Fleet Out Now ...... 28 Adv – 5th Fleet/Iran ...... 30 Adv – 5th Fleet/Iran - Hormuz Impact ...... 33 Bases Key to Contain Iran ...... 34 ADV – 5th Fleet/ Terrorism and Hormuz ...... 37 Adv – 5th Fleet/Oil ...... 38 ADV – 5th/Pirates ...... 39 Bases Good - Key to US Strategy ...... 40 Basing Good- Hegemony ...... 41 Basing Good- Extended Deterrence ...... 42 Basing Good- A2: Echelon Rearward ...... 43 Adv Regional Econ Growth ...... 44 Must Address Shia Grievances ...... 45 Shia Want Democracy ...... 46 Should Encourage Bahrain’s Military to Respect HR ...... 47 US Credibility ...... 48 AT Iraq Undermines US Credibility ...... 49 Solvency - Intervention ...... 50 Solvency – Addressing Greivences ...... 51 Diplomatic Pressure Solvency ...... 52 Solvency – US Key ...... 55 Bahrain Key ...... 57 AT Saudi DA ...... 58

ASU 2011 2 Fellows Bahrain Aff

AT T Democracy Assistance ...... 60 Neg ...... 61 Inherency - No Shiite Takeover ...... 62 Inherency – Bahrain Reforming Now ...... 63 No Solvency – Too Late ...... 64 No Solvency – U.S. Can’t Do Anything ...... 65 No Solvency – U.S. Action Bad ...... 66 No Solvency – Alt Causes ...... 67 No 5th Fleet Kick Out ...... 68 Alts to Bahrain Solve ...... 69 We Will Shift ...... 71 Islamism Turn ...... 72 Basing Bad-A2: Heg ...... 73 Basing Bad- Oil Dependence ...... 74 Basing Bad- Terrorism ...... 75 Iran War Scenario ...... 76 Iran Defense ...... 79 AT Oil Shocks ...... 81 AT Strait of Hormuz ...... 83 AT Mideast War ...... 84 Pirate Defense ...... 87 Turn Pirates Attack the Navy ...... 90 PTX: Plan Unpopular ...... 91 Saudi DA Link ...... 92 Saudi DA Link Magnifier ...... 97 T Democracy Assistance ...... 98

ASU 2011 1 Fellows Bahrain Neg

Bahrain Neg

Bahrain Neg ...... 1 Inherency - No Shiite Takeover ...... 3 Inherency – Bahrain Reforming Now ...... 4 No Solvency – Too Late ...... 5 No Solvency – U.S. Can’t Do Anything ...... 6 No Solvency – U.S. Action Bad ...... 7 No Solvency – Alt Causes ...... 8 No 5th Fleet Kick Out ...... 9 Alts to Bahrain Solve ...... 10 Alts to Bahrain Solve ...... 11 We Will Shift ...... 12 Islamism Turn ...... 13 Basing Bad-A2: Heg ...... 14 Basing Bad- Oil Dependence ...... 15 Basing Bad- Terrorism ...... 16 Iran War Scenario ...... 17 Iran War Scenario ...... 17 Iran War Scenario ...... 18 Iran Defense ...... 20 Iran Defense ...... 21 AT Oil Shocks 1/2 ...... 22 AT Oil Shocks 2/2 ...... 23 AT Strait of Hormuz ...... 24 AT Mideast War ...... 25 AT Mideast War ...... 26 AT Mideast War ...... 27 Pirate Defense ...... 28 Pirate Defense ...... 29 Pirate Defense ...... 30 Turn Pirates Attack the Navy ...... 31 PTX: Plan Unpopular ...... 32 Saudi DA Link ...... 33

ASU 2011 2 Fellows Bahrain Neg

Saudi DA Link ...... 34 Saudi DA Link ...... 35 Saudi DA Link ...... 36 Saudi DA Link ...... 37 Saudi DA Link Magnifier ...... 38 T Democracy Assistance ...... 39

ADI 2011 1 Rumbaugh Military Intervention CP Military Intervention CP

Libya Intervention CP Libya Intervention CP 1NC ...... 3 Libya Intervention CP 1NC ...... 5 Libya Intervention Good- Heg ...... 6 Libya Intervention Good- Terrorism ...... 7 Libya Intervention Good- Stability ...... 8 Libya Intervention Good- Oil Shocks ...... 9 Libya Intervention Good- Oil Shocks ...... 10 Libya Intervention Good- Smooth Transition ...... 11 Libya Intervention Good- Signal Key ...... 12 Libya Intervention Good- A2: We Did That ...... 13 Libya Intervention Good- A2: Gaddafi Steps Down ...... 14 Libya Intervention Good- A2: Rebels Enough ...... 15 Libya Intervention Good- A2: AU Relations...... 16 Libya Intervention Bad- AU Relations ...... 17 Libya Intervention Bad- AU Relations ...... 18 Libya Intervention Bad- Middle East Democracy ...... 19 Libya Intervention Bad- A2: Hegemony ...... 20 Libya Intervention Bad- A2: Terrorism ...... 21 Libya Intervention Bad- A2: Oil Shocks ...... 22 Libya Intervention Bad- Ineffective ...... 23 Libya Intervention Bad- Links to Politics ...... 24

ADI 2011 2 Rumbaugh Military Intervention CP Syria Intervention CP Syria Intervention CP 1NC ...... 25 Syria Intervention CP 1NC ...... 26 Syria Intervention Good- Stability ...... 27 Syria Intervention Good- Heg ...... 28 Syria Intervention Good- Mil Intervention Key ...... 29 Syria Intervention Good- Assad Has to Go ...... 30 Syria Intervention Good- Successful ...... 31 Syria Intervention Good- A2: NATO ...... 32 Syria Intervention Good- A2: Turkey ...... 33 Syria Intervention Good- A2: Syria- Israel ...... 34 Syria Intervention Good- A2: CBW...... 35 Syria Intervention Good- Politics NB ...... 36 Syria Intervention Bad- Middle East War ...... 37 Syria Intervention Bad- Middle East War Extn ...... 38 Syria Intervention Bad- NATO Relations ...... 39 Syria Intervention Bad- Instability ...... 40 Syria Intervention Bad- Turkey Relations ...... 41 Syria Intervention Bad- Syria-Israel War ...... 43 Syria Intervention Bad- Syria-Israel War ...... 44 Syria Intervention Bad- CBW ...... 45 Syria Intervention Bad- CBW ...... 46 Syria Intervention Bad- Doesn’t Solve ...... 47 Syria Intervention Bad- Fails ...... 48 Syria Intervention Bad- Links to Politics ...... 49 Intervention Bad Generic- Democracy ...... 50 Intervention Bad- No Stable Transition ...... 51

ADI 2011 1 Fellows Internet Aff Internet Aff

Internet Aff ...... 1 1AC Internet Adv ...... 2 1AC Internet Adv ...... 3 1AC Internet Adv ...... 4 1AC Internet Adv ...... 5 1AC Internet Adv ...... 7 1AC Internet Adv ...... 9 1AC Internet Adv ...... 11 1AC US key Adv ...... 13 ***Uniqueness*** ...... 18 Inherency – Syria Failing Now ...... 19 Inherency – No Internet Access ...... 20 Inherency – Assad Regime Unsustainable ...... 21 Inherency – US Policy Fails ...... 23 Inherency – AT: Sanctions Solve ...... 26 Inherency – AT: Sanctions Solve ...... 28 ***Internet Advantage*** ...... 30 Internet key to Sopo ...... 31 Sopo Solve Laundry List ...... 33 Sopo Solve Hegemony ...... 34 Sopo Solve Terrorism ...... 36 Nuke Terror O/W ...... 37 Internet key to Human Rights Leadership ...... 38 Human Rights Impacts ...... 39 Internet key to Demo ...... 41 Plan Spurs Global Action ...... 45 ***Syria Advantage*** ...... 47 now key ...... 48 Syria = Lynchpin ...... 49 US Action Solves ME Prolif ...... 51 us action solves me stability ...... 53 Syrian Instability Impacts ...... 56 ME War ...... 57 ***Cyber-Feminism Add-On*** ...... 58 Cyberfeminism Add-On ...... 59 Cyberfeminism Good – Arab World Specific ...... 61 Cyberfeminism Good – Key to Destroying Patriarchy ...... 62 Cyberfeminism Good – Female Empowerment ...... 63 Cyberfeminism Good – Empowering ...... 64 Cyberfeminism Good – Fluid Subjectivity ...... 65 Cyberfeminism Good – AT: Cap/Whiteness Bad ...... 66 ***Solvency*** ...... 67 Tech Exists Now ...... 68 Solvency – Social Media  Revolution – Egypt proves ...... 70 Solvency – Grassroots Movements ...... 71 Solvency – Comm. Tech Key to Protests – Organization ...... 73 Solvency – Internet k2 Civil Society k2 Democracy ...... 74 Solvency – Conservative Dilemma k2 Civil Society ...... 76 A2: Slacktivism/Gladwell ...... 77 A2: They’ll Shut Down the Communications Grid ...... 78

ADI 2011 1 Fellows Internet Neg Internet Neg

Internet Neg ...... 1 AT: Inherency – Current Internet Efforts Solve ...... 2 AT: Inherency – Current Syrian Policy Solve ...... 3 Syrian Democracy Impossible ...... 4 Internet in a Suitcase Fails ...... 6 Internet in a Suitcase Bad – Breeds Anti-Americanism ...... 7 AT: Soft Power – Unsustainable ...... 8 AT: Soft Power – Unworkable ...... 9 AT: Soft Power – States Not Susceptible ...... 10 AT: Soft Power Key to Heg – Cannot Maintain ...... 11 AT: Soft Power – Useless w/o Hard Power ...... 12 AT: Soft Power – Doesn’t Solve – Too Weak ...... 13 AT: Soft Power Solves War – Deterrence Key ...... 14 AT: Middle East War – No War ...... 15 AT: Middle East War – No War ...... 16 AT: Middle East War – No War ...... 17 AT: Middle East War – No US Drag-in ...... 18 AT: Iran Prolif ...... 19 Solvency – US Action Fails ...... 21 Solvency – Int’l Action Key ...... 22 Solvency – No Tech Base/Globalization ...... 24 Solvency – Internet in a Box – Deliveries Check ...... 25 Solvency – Internet Censorship ...... 26 Solvency – Internet as Statecraft ...... 27 Solvency – Alt Cause ...... 28 Solvency – Soc. Networking =/= Rev ...... 29 Adv. CP – Release Political Prisoners ...... 30 Neolib Link – Communication Technology ...... 31 Neolib Link – Local Assistance ...... 32 Neolib Link – Media Assistance ...... 33 Neolib Link – Imperialism Internal link ...... 34 AT: Cyberfeminism – Western Values ...... 35 AT: Cyberfeminism – Race K ...... 36

ADI 2011 1 Fellows -- Sydnor Islamic Feminism K Islamic Feminism K Index

Islamic Feminism K Index ...... 1 1NC ...... 3 **Links** ...... 7 Democracy Assistance Link ...... 8 Democracy Assistance Link ...... 9 Feminism Link ...... 10 Freedom Link ...... 11 Secular-Liberalism Link ...... 12 Secular-Liberalism Link ...... 13 Violence Against Women Link ...... 14 **Impacts** ...... 15 Colonization ...... 16 Violence (AT: Perm – Blueprinting) ...... 17 **Alternative** ...... 18 Alternative Solves ...... 19 **Answers to Aff Answers** ...... 20 AT: Arab Spring States Aren’t Secular ...... 21 AT: Ethics ...... 22 AT: Feminism ...... 24 AT: Perm – Add Women and Stir ...... 25 AT: Perm – Foreclosure DA ...... 26 AT: Perm – K First ...... 27 AT: Politics Good / Framework ...... 29 AT: Politics Good / Framework ...... 30 AT: Politics Good / Framework ...... 31 AT: Resignification Good ...... 32 AT: They’re Shaped By Patriarchy ...... 33 AT: You’re Orientalist ...... 34 AT: You’re Sexist ...... 35 ADI 2011 2 Fellows -- Sydnor Islamic Feminism K

**Aff Answers** ...... 36 Agency Focus Bad ...... 37 Culturalism Bad ...... 38 Culturalism Bad ...... 39 Perm Solvency – Act and Rethink ...... 40 Perm Solvency—Rethink and Act ...... 41 Perm Solvency – AT: Perm Indicts ...... 42 State Good...... 43 Orientalism Turn ...... 44

ADI 2011 1 Fellows -- Roark Heg Good/Bad Hegemony & Leadership Toolbox

...... ===UQ=== ...... 3 Heg Up – Unipolarity ...... 4 Heg Up – Military...... 5 Heg Up – Military...... 6 A2: China Rising ...... 7 A2: Overstretch...... 8 A2: China Counterbalances ...... 9 Heg Down – ME ...... 9 Heg Down – Asia Rising ...... 11 Heg Down – China Rising ...... 12 Heg Down – China Rising ...... 13 Heg Down – Economy ...... 14 Heg Down – No US Pursuit ...... 15 Heg Down - Iraq ...... 16 A2: Peaceful China ...... 17 Soft Power Down...... 18 ===Links=== ...... 19 Iran Containment Key to Heg ...... 20 Demo Assist Key to Heg ...... 21 Demo Assist Key to Heg ...... 22 Demo Assist Key to Heg ...... 23 Demo Promo Key to Heg ...... 24 Demo Promo X Heg ...... 25 Demo Assist X Heg ...... 25 Demo Assist X Heg ...... 27 ===Heg Good=== ...... 28 Heg Sustainable ...... 29 Heg Good – Thayer ...... 30 Heg Good – Ferguson ...... 30 Heg Good – Kagan Giant ...... 32 Heg Good – Calculus ...... 35 Heg Good – Economy ...... 36 Heg Good – Prolif ...... 40 Heg Good - Terrorism ...... 42 ===Heg Bad/Defense=== ...... 45 Heg Bad – China...... 50 Heg Bad – Terrorism ...... 54 Heg Bad – War ...... 55 Heg Bad – War EXTN ...... 56 Obama Power Bad – Economy ...... 57 Obama Power Bad – Conflict ...... 57 Obama Power Fails ...... 59 Obama Power Fails ...... 60 A2 – Heg Solves War ...... 61 A2 – Heg Solves Transition Wars ...... 62

ADI 2011 2 Fellows -- Roark Heg Good/Bad A2 – ME Hegemony ...... 63 A2 – ME Hegemony ...... 64 A2 – ME Hegemony ...... 65 A2 – Soft Power ...... 66 A2 – Soft Power ...... 67 A2 – Soft Power ...... 68 A2 – Soft Power ...... 69 A2 – Soft Power ...... 70 A2 – Soft Power – HP OW ...... 71 A2 – Soft Power – X Key Heg ...... 72

ADI 2011 1 Fellows -- Woodruff Human Rights Credibility Good/Bad HR Cred Good/Bad

****HR CRED BAD**** ...... 2 HR Cred Bad – Uniqueness – HR Cred Low ...... 3 HR Cred Bad – Link – Generic ...... 4 HR Cred Bad – Link – Bahrain 1/2 ...... 5 HR Cred Bad – Link – Bahrain 2/2 ...... 6 HR Cred Bad – Internal Link – Credibility Leads to Pressure ...... 7 HR Cred Bad – Impact – Human Rights ...... 8 HR Cred Bad – Impact – US- Kazakhstan Relations ...... 9 HR Cred Bad – Impact – US- Russian Relations ...... 12 ****HR CRED GOOD**** ...... 24 HR Cred Good – Link Answer ...... 25 HR Cred Good – Impact – Soft Power...... 26 HR Cred Good – Impact – US-China Relations ...... 28 HR Cred Good – Impact – Heg ...... 31 HR Cred Good – Impact – US-EU Relations ...... 32 HR Cred Good – Impact – Laundry List...... 34 HR Cred Good – Impact – North Korea ...... 36 ****IMPACT ANSWERS****...... 38 Impact Answers – US-Kazakhstan Relations ...... 39 Impact Answers – Democracy ...... 40 Impact Answers – Russia War ...... 41 Impact Answers – Russia Relations ...... 42 Impact Answers – North Korea ...... 43

ADI 2011 1 Masterson Islam Reps K

Islam Reps K

Islam Reps K ...... 1 1NC – Islamic threat version ...... 3 1NC ...... 4 1NC—Civil Society Assistance version ...... 5 1NC – Both versions ...... 6 1NC ...... 6 Link Islamic Violence Reps ...... 8 Islamic Terrorism Reps Link...... 9 Islamic Terrorism Reps Link...... 10 Link Islam as a Threat to Democracy ...... 11 Link Jihad Reps ...... 12 Link Negative Portrayals of Islam ...... 13 Link Homogenization of Muslims ...... 14 Link Islam Political or Economic Impacts ...... 15 Link The Veil ...... 16 Link Fundamentalism ...... 17 Link Evil ...... 18 Link Using Art to Represent Muslims ...... 19 Link Extension– Civil Society Assistance & Women’s Empowerment20 Link Extension– Civil Society Assistance ...... 21 IL to Whiteness ...... 22 Intervention Impact ...... 23 K Turns Case ...... 24 Alt Solves ...... 25 Framing First ...... 26 Framing First ...... 26 Discourse First ...... 28 AT Experts ...... 29 AT Experts ...... 29 AT Consequentialism ...... 31

ADI 2011 2 Masterson Islam Reps K

AT Realism ...... 32 AT Perm ...... 34 AFF ...... 35 Perm -- Aff advocacy subverts orientalism ...... 37 Epistemology Focus Bad ...... 38 Epistemology Focus Bad ...... 39 Discourse Focus Bad ...... 40 Policy First ...... 41 Policy First ...... 42 Consequentialism Good ...... 43 Islam Threat Rhetoric Good ...... 44 Islam Threat Rhetoric Good ...... 44 Islam Threat Rhetoric Good ...... 46 AT Homogenization ...... 47 Threats Are Real ...... 48 Threats Are Real ...... 49 Realism Inevitable ...... 50 Realism AT Discourse ...... 51 Rejection Alts Fail ...... 52 Aff advocacy subverts orientalism ...... 53

ADI 2011 Neoliberal Cap K Fellows - Murray 1 Neoliberal Cap K Index 1NC Neoliberalism Cap K ...... 3 Link – Democracy Assistance ...... 8 Link – Democracy Assistance ...... 9 Link – Egypt ...... 10 Link - Egypt ...... 11 Link - Social Media Hypothesis ...... 12 Link - Qualifications ...... 13 Link - Identity Politics ...... 14 Link - Culture ...... 16 Link – Contingent Identity ...... 17 Link – Interpassivity ...... 18 ***IMPACTS*** ...... 20 Turns Case - Democracy ...... 20 Impact – Value to Life ...... 21 Impact – Super Extinction ...... 22 Impact – Environment ...... 24 Impact – Ecology ...... 25 Impact – Space Mil ...... 27 Class Oppression Outweighs All ...... 28 A/T: Cap Good ...... 29 A/T: Cap Good ...... 30 ***ALTERNATIVE*** ...... 32 A/T: Permutation ...... 33 A/T: Capitalism Inevitable ...... 36 Block Alt Ext...... 37 Alt Solves – Awakens Masses ...... 39 Can’t Give up on Revolution ...... 41 Leap of Faith ...... 43 Material Criticism ...... 44 Objectivity Key ...... 46 Objectivity Key ...... 47 Alternative Solves the Case/ Marxist Criticism Comes First ...... 48 A/T “You’re Violent” ...... 49 A/T Transition Wars ...... 50 ADI 2011 Neoliberal Cap K Fellows - Murray 2 ***AFF ANSWERS*** ...... 52 Turn – Space ...... 53 EXT – Capitalism Key to Space ...... 55 1AR Space Impacts ...... 56 Turn – Interdependence ...... 59 Turn – Disease ...... 60 No Root Cause ...... 61 EXT – No Root Cause ...... 62 AT: No Value to Life ...... 64 Predictions ...... 65 Uniqueness--Capitalism Sustainable ...... 66 Capitalism Inevitable—Utopia/Alt Fail ...... 67 AT: Unsustainable—Market Innovation ...... 69 A/T: Zizek ...... 70 A/T: Rev ...... 71 Transition Wars Bad ...... 72 ADI 2011 1 Marvin Carter A-Spring DA Arab Spring Movements DA

Shell ...... 2 1NC ...... 3 1NC ...... 4 Uniqueness ...... 6 Uniqueness- Change Will Come ...... 7 Uniqueness- Regimes Won’t Stop Movements ...... 8 Uniqueness- Headless Movements Work ...... 9 Uniqueness- Movements Empirically Have Worked ...... 10 Uniqueness- Movements Can Work ...... 11 Uniqueness- SQ is Fragile ...... 12 Uniqueness- US can’t support Middle East ...... 13 Uniqueness- Egypt Movements Solve ...... 14 Links ...... 15 Link- Democracy/NGOS Tanks Movements ...... 16 Link- US Help Hurts Indigenous Movements ...... 17 Link—US Inaction Spurs Movements ...... 18 Link- Hard Power ...... 19 Link- US Action in Syria...... 20 Link- US In Middle East ...... 21 Impacts ...... 22 Impact- Coups ...... 23 Impact- Instability ...... 24 Impact- Corruption ...... 25 Impact- Human Rights ...... 26 Impact- Destabilize Middle East ...... 27 Impact- Human Rights Cred...... 28 Impact- Terrorism ...... 29 Impact- Imperialism = extinction ...... 30 Impact- Colonization ...... 31 AT: Middle East Wants US ...... 32 AT: US Action Solve ...... 33

Aff Answers ...... 34 Aff- Democracy Regressing ...... 35 Aff- Headless Movements Fail ...... 36 Aff- Movements Can’t Solve ...... 37 Aff- Movements Fail in Syria ...... 38 Aff- Movements Fail in Tunisia ...... 39 Aff- Movements Fail in Egypt ...... 40 Aff- Middle East Movements Failing ...... 41 Aff- Movements Can’t Topple Regimes ...... 42 Aff- SQ will Fail ...... 43 Aff- Democracy is Failing Now ...... 44 Aff- Democracy is Failing Now ...... 45 Aff- Democracy is Failing Now ...... 46 Aff- Movements don’t Solve AU Regime...... 47 Aff- Human Rights Turn ...... 48 Aff- Syrian Destabilization Fails ...... 49

ADI 2011 1 Fellows--Carter Empire K Empire K Index

1NC ...... 2 Link- Yemen and Antiterrorism Advantages ...... 10 Link- Yemen and Antiterrorism Advantages ...... 11 Link- Ethics/Truth ...... 12 Link- Free Trade ...... 13 Link- Democratization and Good Governance Policy ...... 14 Yemen Impact- Oppression ...... 16 Impact- Hierarchy ...... 17 Impact- Violent Revolutions ...... 18 Impact- Extinction ...... 19 Impact- Empire ...... 20 Alt- Solvency ...... 21 Alt Solvency- Middle East ...... 22 Alt Solvency- Middle East ...... 23 Alt Solvency- Democracy ...... 24 Alt Solvency- Democracy ...... 25 Alt Solvency- Movements Solve Empire ...... 26 Alt Solvency- Colonialism ...... 27 Alt Solvency- Movements Key ...... 28 Alt Solvency- Acceleration ...... 29 AT: Perm ...... 29 AT: Our plan is too specific to link ...... 31 AT: The plan undermines universal oppression ...... 32 AT: Orthodox Marxism ...... 33

*Aff Answers* ...... 35 Empire Has Faulty Link Analysis ...... 36 Alt fails – Multitudes Too Vague...... 36 Alt fails – Multitudes cause economic collapse ...... 37 Alt fails – Aestheticizing politics preserves capitalism ...... 38 Alt Fails – Multitudes Fail to Appreciate Cultural Difference ...... 39 Alt Fails – Multitudes Fail to Appreciate Cultural Difference ...... 40 Alt fails – Utopian ...... 41 Alt fails – Utopian ...... 42 Perm – Adopt Plan in the Transition to Counter-empire ...... 43 Perm Solvency – Need State Action for Global Democracy ...... 45

ADI 11 1 Fellows and Dr. Dave Topicality Topicality 1NC-2AC shells Index *1NC Shells* ...... 2 Small increases in assistance T not substantial 1NC shell ...... 3 Conditioning assistance is not substantial 1NC shell ...... 6 IMET is not Democracy Assistance 1NC Shell ...... 8 Syria TV Resignation Call, Witnessing, Narratives not Democracy Assistance 1NC ..... 10 Critical Advocacy T --“USFG Should” Requires Advocating a Government Plan 1NC . 12 Critical Advocacy T -- Resolved Requires Plan Advocacy 1NC ...... 14

*2AC Shells* ...... 16 2AC: small increases in assistance spending not substantial ...... 17 2AC: assistance conditions not substantial T...... 19 2AC: IMET is democracy assistance ...... 21 2AC: Syria Call for Resignation, Witnessing, Narratives ...... 23 2AC: Critical T --“USFG Should” requires government plan ...... 25 2AC: Critical T- -“Resolved” requires plan advocacy ...... 26

ADI 11 1 Fellows and Dr. Dave Topicality Definitions Topicality Definitions Index

United States Federal Government ...... 2 Should...... 3 Substantially—general definitions ...... 4 Substantially—qualitative definitions ...... 5 Substantially—quantitative definitions ...... 6 Increase ...... 6 Its ...... 7 Democracy Assistance ...... 9 For ...... 15 One or more ...... 17 Of ...... 19 The ...... 20 Following ...... 21 Bahrain...... 22 Egypt ...... 23 Libya...... 24 Syria ...... 25 Tunisia ...... 26 Yemen...... 27

USE THESE TO MAKE YOUR OWN VIOLATIONS OR ANSWERS ASU 2011 1 Fellows -- Ziegler Corruption Reform CP

CORRUPTION REFORM CONDITION CP

Corruption Reform CP – 1NC (1/3) ...... 2 Corruption Reform CP – 1NC (2/3) ...... 3 Corruption Reform CP – 1NC (3/3) ...... 4 2NC/1NR Overview ...... 5 AT: Perm – Do Both ...... 6 AT: Perm – Do the CP ...... 7 AT: Textual Competition ...... 8 AT: Condition CP’s Bad ...... 9 EXT – We Should Condition Demo Assistace ...... 10 Say Yes – General ...... 11 Say Yes – Bahrain ...... 13 Say Yes – Egypt ...... 14 Say Yes – Libya ...... 16 Say Yes – Syria ...... 17 Say Yes – Yemen ...... 18 EXT – Corruption Now ...... 19 EXT – Corruption Kills Democracy ...... 20 EXT – Corruptions Reforms Solve ...... 21 EXT – Liberal Democracy Key ...... 22 Democracy Good – Poverty ...... 23 Democracy Good – Economy ...... 24 Democracy Good – Terrorism ...... 25 Democracy Good – Proliferation ...... 26 Democracy Good – Environment ...... 27 Turns Case – Egypt ...... 28 Turns Case – Syria ...... 30 Turns Case – Yemen ...... 31 Aff – Condition CP’s Bad...... 33 Aff – Functional Competition Bad ...... 34 Aff – Say No – General ...... 35 Aff – Say No – Syria ...... 36 Aff – Say No – Tunisia ...... 37 Aff – Say No – Yemen ...... 38 Aff – Corruption Reform Now – Egypt ...... 40 Aff – Corruption Inevitable ...... 42 Aff – Conditions Fail ...... 43 Aff – Conditions Bad – Overcrowding ...... 44 Aff – Democratic Peace Theory False ...... 45 Aff – Democracy No Solve War ...... 47

ADI 2011 1 Wes Rumbaugh Iran DA Iran DA

Iran DA ...... 1 Iran DA 1NC ...... 3 Iran DA 1NC ...... 3 Uniqueness ...... 5 Uniqueness‐ General ...... 6 Uniqueness‐ General ...... 7 Uniqueness‐Obama Weakness ...... 8 Uniqueness‐Domestic Issues ...... 9 Uniqueness‐ Iraq ...... 10 Links ...... 11 Links‐ Egypt ...... 12 Links‐ Bahrain ...... 13 Links‐ Syria ...... 14 Links‐ Syria Magnifier ...... 15 Links‐ Tunisia ...... 16 Links‐ Yemen ...... 17 Links‐ Libya ...... 18 Link‐ Influence Zero‐Sum ...... 19 Internal Link‐ Democracy Assistance=Containment ...... 20 Impacts...... 21 Containment Bad‐ Miscalc ...... 22 Containment Bad‐ Miscalc Extensions ...... 24 Containment Bad‐ Iran Prolif ...... 25 Containment Bad‐ Iraq Instability ...... 27 Containment Bad‐ Terrorism ...... 29 Containment Bad‐ A2: Stops Weapons Transfer ...... 30 Containment Bad‐ A2: Alliances ...... 31 Containment Bad – A2: Moderates ...... 32 Containment Bad‐ A2: Democracy ...... 33 Containment Bad‐ Ineffective‐ History Wrong ...... 34 Containment Bad‐ Ineffective‐ Resolve ...... 35

ADI 2011 2 Wes Rumbaugh Iran DA Aff Answers 36 Aff Answers‐Non UQ‐ Iraq/Afghanistan ...... 37 Aff Answers‐Non UQ ‐ Arab Spring ...... 38 Aff Answers‐ Non UQ‐ Egypt ...... 39 Aff Answers‐ Link Turn ...... 40 Aff Answers‐ No Link ...... 41 Aff Answers‐Containment Good‐ Moderate Takeover ...... 42 Aff Answers‐Containment Good‐ Iran Prolif ...... 44 Aff Answers‐ Containment Good‐ Democracy ...... 45 Aff Answers‐Containment Good‐ Causes Allied Support ...... 47 Aff Answers‐Containment Good‐ A2: Irrational/ Miscalc ...... 48 Aff Answers‐ Prolif D ...... 49 Aff Answers‐ Iran Prolif D ...... 50 Aff Answers‐ Middle East War D ...... 51 Aff Answers‐ Terrorism D ...... 52

ADI 2011 1 Steven Murray Saudi DA ***Saudi Disad***

***Saudi Disad*** ...... 1 1NC Saudi DA ...... 2 ***Uniqueness*** ...... 4 UQ – US-Saudi relations Low ...... 4 Relations UQ – No one Trusts Anyone ...... 6 ***Links*** ...... 7 2NC Link Wall ...... 7 Link – Democracy Assistance ...... 8 Link – Arab Spring ...... 9 Link - Bahrain ...... 11 Bahrain Link UQ ...... 12 Link - Shiites in Bahrain ...... 13 Link - Appeasing Iran ...... 14 Link – Egypt ...... 15 A/T: Relations Resilient – Oil ...... 16 A/T: Relations Resilient – Security ...... 17 ***Impacts***...... 18 2NC Proliferation ...... 18 Saudi Prolif Dominoes ...... 20 A/T: Deterrence ...... 21 A/T: Saudi Prolif Inevitable ...... 22 A/T: Pakistan Gives the Bomb ...... 23 A/T: Iran Prolif = Saudi Prolif inevitable ...... 24 Iran Prolif Good ...... 25 Saudi Prolif Terrorism ...... 27 Impact - Terrorism ...... 28 Impact – Dollar Heg ...... 29 Ext: Relz key to dollar heg ...... 31 EXT – Oil Security ...... 32 Impact – Regional Power Projection ...... 33 Impact – Middle East Stability ...... 34 Impact – China...... 35 EXT – China Fill-In ...... 37 ***AFF Answers*** ...... 38 Relations Low ...... 39 EXT – No Link ...... 40 US-Saudi Relations Resilient ...... 41 EXT – Relations Resilient: Oil and Security ...... 42 Saudi Prolif Good - Iran ...... 44 Saudi Prolif Good - Stability ...... 45 EXT – Saudi Prolif Inevitable ...... 46 A/T: Saudi Prolif – Incentive/Means ...... 47 A/T: Saudi Prolif – Iran Alt Cause ...... 49 Prolif: Not Bad...... 50 A/T: China Aggression ...... 51

ADI 2011 1 Sovereignty K Sovereignty K

AT: Cede the Political ...... 26 Sovereignty K ...... 1 AT: Framework ...... 27 1NC ...... 2 AT: Framework ...... 28 1NC ...... 3 AT: Framework ...... 29 1NC ...... 4 AT: Permutation ...... 30 **Links** ...... 6 AT: Sovereignty Solves War ...... 31 Democracy Link ...... 7 AT: State Co-option ...... 32 Democracy Link ...... 8

Democracy Link ...... 9 **Aff Answers** ...... 33 Economy Link ...... 10 Alt Fails ...... 34 Humanitarianism Link ...... 11 Biopower Good ...... 36 Security Link ...... 12 Cede the Political...... 37 Security Link ...... 13 Cede the Political...... 38 Terrorism Link ...... 14 Cede the Political...... 39 **Impacts** ...... 16 Democracy Solves ...... 40 Oppression Impact ...... 17 Democracy Solves ...... 41 Totalitarianism Impact ...... 18 No Impact ...... 42 Value to Life Impact ...... 19 No Impact ...... 43 **Alternative** ...... 20 Perm Solvency ...... 44 Individual Resistance Alt ...... 21 Utilitarianism Good ...... 45 Reject Democracy Alt ...... 22 Utilitarianism Good ...... 46 **Answers to Aff Answers** ...... 23 Strategic Sovereignty Good ...... 47 AT: Cede the Political ...... 24 Securitization Good ...... 48 AT: Cede the Political ...... 25 Securitization Good ...... 49 2011 Arizona Debate Institutes Spending Disad spending disad – 2011 adi - maria

1nc ...... 3

***Neg Uniqueness ...... 4 2nc uniqueness ...... 5 at: obama veto ...... 6 at: military spending outweighs ...... 7 at: funding demo assistance now ...... 8 --xt: republican factionism ...... 9 --xt: civil society ...... 10 --xt: egypt ...... 11 at: no credit downgrade ...... 12 at: econ low ...... 13

***Neg Links ...... 13 generic ...... 14 demo assistance ...... 15 civil society ...... 17 civil society/rule of law ...... 18 internet assistance ...... 19 usaid ...... 20 ned ...... 21

***Neg Internal Links ...... 21 deficit reduction key...... 22 fiscal discipline key ...... 23 deficit reduction and fiscal discipline key ...... 24 deficit plan key to solve credit downgrade ...... 25 credit downgrade --> econ collapse ...... 27 gridlock --> econ collapse ...... 28

***Neg Impacts ...... 28 dollar collapse --> collapse heg ...... 29 dollar collapse --> econ collapse ...... 30 dollar collapse --> trade wars ...... 31 xt: econ collapse --> war ...... 32 econ turns all impacts ...... 33 econ turns democracy ...... 34 econ turns heg ...... 35

***Aff Answers ...... 35 econ low ...... 36 no spending cuts ...... 38 no spending cuts – obama veto ...... 40 spending now – generic ...... 41 spending now – democracy assistance ...... 42 spending now – internet assistance ...... 44 spending now – egypt ...... 45 spending now – yemen ...... 46 link non-unique – lots of spending now ...... 47 no link ...... 48 plan saves money/link turn ...... 49 deficit spending good ...... 50 1

2011 Arizona Debate Institutes Spending Disad spending cuts bad ...... 51 deal not key to econ ...... 52 econ resilient – US ...... 53 econ resilient - world ...... 54 at: credit downgrade ...... 55 at: dollar collapse ...... 56 no impact – econ collapse ...... 58

2

china relations disad china relations disad ...... 1 1nc ...... 2 1nc ...... 3 1nc ...... 4

***uniqueness ...... 4 relations high ...... 5 relations high ...... 6 relations high – military ...... 7 relations high – human rights ...... 8 relations = brink ...... 9

***links ...... 9 --xt: paal 1nc link ...... 10 hates democracy ...... 11 hates democracy ...... 12 sco proves ...... 13 oppose obama policy ...... 14 intervention ...... 15 internet assistance ...... 16 unilat action bad ...... 17 at: oil concerns o/w democracy ...... 18

***impacts ...... 18 asian stability ...... 19 --xt: asian stability ...... 20 hegemony ...... 21 laundry list ...... 22 rogue prolif ...... 23 rogue prolif ...... 24 --xt: prolif ...... 25 taiwan war ...... 26

***aff answers ...... 26 relations low – taiwan ...... 27 relations low – taiwan ...... 28 relations low – military ...... 29 relations low – human rights ...... 30 relations resilient ...... 31 --xt: relations resilient ...... 32 alt causes ...... 33 alt causes ...... 34 no link – not worried about the middle east ...... 35 no link – only worried about oil ...... 36 relations bad – heg ...... 37 at: relations solve – asian stability ...... 39 at: relations solve – prolif ...... 40 at: fear ‘china spring’ ...... 41

ADI 2011 1 Fellows -- Ziegler Israel DA

ISRAEL DA

1NC (1/2) ...... 3 1NC (2/2) ...... 4 2NC/1NR – Overview ...... 5

***Uniqueness ...... 5 UQ – Relations Up Now ...... 6 UQ – Pro-Israel Assistance Policy now ...... 7 AT: Obama Shifted Relations ...... 8 Brink – US-Israel Relations on the Brink ...... 10

***Link ...... 10 Link – UQ – Security Up Now ...... 11 Link – Generic ...... 12 Link – Egypt ...... 15 Link – Egypt – Relations Zero Sum ...... 16 Link – Bahrain, Libya, Syria, Yemen ...... 17 Link – Syria ...... 18 Link – Syria – Failed Overthrow ...... 19 Link – Yemen/Gulf States ...... 20 Link – Magnifier – Israel is Delusional ...... 21 Link – Magnifier – Iran Factor ...... 22 AT: Link Turn – Israel Likes Democracy ...... 23

***Impact ...... 24 EXT – ME War On The Brink ...... 25 EXT – Relations Key to ME Stability ...... 26 Relations Good – Hegemony ...... 28 EXT – Relations Key to Heg ...... 29 Relations Good – Turns ME Democracy ...... 30 Relations Good – Iran Prolif ...... 31 AT: No Israel First Strike ...... 32 AT: No Israel First Strike Escalation ...... 33 EXT – Relations Check Iran Prolif ...... 34 Relations Good – Terrorism ...... 35 Relations Good – AT: Relations Bad ...... 36 AT: Peace Process – Fails...... 37 AT: Peace Process – Prolongs Conflict ...... 38

***Aff Answers ...... 38 Aff – Relations Down Now ...... 39 Aff – Alt Cause – Peace Process ...... 40 Aff – No Link ...... 41 Aff – Impact UQ Thumpers ...... 42 Aff – Relations Resilient ...... 43 Peace Process Turn – 2AC (1/3) ...... 44 Peace Process Turn – 2AC (2/3) ...... 45 Peace Process Turn – 2AC (3/3) ...... 46 Aff – AT: Relations Key to Heg ...... 47 Aff – No Issue Spillover ...... 48 Aff – Other Issues Key ...... 49 Aff – Relations Bad – Middle East Stability ...... 51 Aff – AT: Iran Prolif – Inevitable ...... 52 Aff – AT: Iran Prolif – Exaggerated ...... 53 Aff – Relations Bad – Terrorism ...... 54 Aff – EXT – Relations Cause Terrorism ...... 55

ADI 2011 2 Fellows -- Ziegler Israel DA

Aff – AT: Relations Key to Heg ...... 56 Aff – AT: Israel Lashout ...... 57

ADI 2011 1 Lundeen Syria

1AC - Inherency ...... 2 AT: CP – Other forms Dem Assistance...... 58 1AC – Advantage ...... 3 AT: CP – Fund Opposition ...... 59 1AC – Advantage ...... 4 AT: CP – Other Actor ...... 60 1AC – Advantage ...... 5 AT: UN CP ...... 61 1AC – Advantage ...... 6 AT: Syrians should decide for themselves ...... 62 1AC – Solvency ...... 8 AT: Plan Causes Crackdown ...... 63 1AC – Solvency ...... 9 AT: Radical Muslim Takeover ...... 64 Inherency ...... 10 Politics - Bipartisan Support for Syrian Democracy ...... 65 Inherency - AT: Syrian Opposition Solves SQ ...... 11 Politics - no loss of political capital ...... 66 Solvency - Calls to Step Down ...... 12 AT: Civil Society Bad Args ...... 67 Solvency - U.S support Key ...... 13 AT: K ...... 68 Solvency – Calls to Step Down ...... 14 AT: DA War Impacts ...... 69 Solvency – Demand step down ...... 15 Solvency – Diplomatic Pressure ...... 16 ***NEG*** ...... 70 Solvency - Only Assad Step Down Solves ...... 17 ***AT: Human Rights Adv.*** ...... 70 ***Human Rights Adv*** ...... 18 SQ Solves Human Rights ...... 71 SQ Solves – Syrian Reforms ...... 72 Human Rights Abuses ...... 19 SQ Solves – US Condemnation Now ...... 73 Human Rights Abuses ...... 20 US Human Rts Promotion Bad ...... 74 Human Rights Abuses ...... 21 AT: Women’s Human Rights ...... 75 Human Rights Abuses ...... 22 Human Rights Bad – War ...... 76 Human Rights Abuses ...... 23 No Solvency – Pressure Fails ...... 77 Human Rights Abuses ...... 24 No Solvency - US Hypocrisy ...... 78 Human Rights Abuses ...... 25 No Solvency – Human Rights ...... 79 Torture ...... 26 No Solvency - Negative U.S. image in Syria ...... 80 Freedom of Speech & Expression ...... 27 Turn - Plan Causes Civil War ...... 81 Homosexual discrimination ...... 28 Turn - Plan Causes Crackdown ...... 82 Must Act Now – Ramadan ...... 29 K – US Response is Hypocritical ...... 83 Impact - Genocide ...... 30 UN CP ...... 84 Impact - Terrorism ...... 31 UN CP ...... 85 Impact - Dehumanization ...... 32 Impact - Solves War ...... 34 Impact - Democracy ...... 35 Impact Democracy ...... 36 Impact - Extinction ...... 37 Plan Solves Human Rights Abuses ...... 38 Rhetorical Support Solvency ...... 39 AT: Need International Action/US Key ...... 40 AT: Reforms Solve ...... 41 AT: SQ Elections Solves ...... 42 AT: Human Rights are Western ...... 43 US Human Rts Credibiity Low Now ...... 44 Political Participation is Fundamental Right ...... 45 ***Regime Change***...... 46 Int’l Pressure Causes Regime Change ...... 47 Opposition Groups Ready to step In ...... 49 Ready for Post Assad ...... 50 Post Assad will be Democratic ...... 51 Shadow Government Ready...... 52 Regime Change Key ...... 53 Iran ...... 54 Food Shortages ...... 55 ***Answers To*** ...... 56 Topicality – Democracy Assistance ...... 57

ADI 2011 1 Critical Lab Nietzsche K Nietzsche Index

Nietzsche Index ...... 1 1NC Shell ...... 3 Link- Ascetic Life ...... 5 Link- Brutality ...... 6 Link- Causes ...... 7 Link- Crusade ...... 8 Link- Constitution and Rule of Law ...... 9 Link- Conscious ...... 10 Link- Denying ...... 11 Link- Doing Something >.< ...... 12 Link- Doing Something >.< ...... 13 Link- Democracy ...... 14 Link- Democracy ...... 15 Link- Democracy ...... 17 Link- Democracy ...... 18 Link- Evil ...... 19 Link- Evil ...... 20 Link- Guilt and Justice ...... 21 Link- Justice and Fairness ...... 22 Link- Justice Rhetoric ...... 23 Link- Morality ...... 24 Link- Morality ...... 25 Link- Morality ...... 26 Link- Memory ...... 27 Link- Root Causes ...... 28 Link- Resistance Movements ...... 29 Link- Regime Change ...... 30 Link- Science=Ascetic Ideal ...... 31 Link- Scientific Knowledge ...... 32 Link- Truth ...... 33 Link- Truth ...... 34 Link- Truth ...... 35 Link- Universal ...... 36 Impact- No Value to Life ...... 37 Impact- Passivity ...... 38 Impact- Purity ...... 39 Impact- Hate and Revenge ...... 40 Impact- Dehumanization ...... 41 Impact- Self Torture ...... 42 Framework ...... 43 Alt Solvency- Embrace Life ...... 44 Alt Solvency- Ascetics ...... 45 Alt Solvency- Forgetting ...... 46 Alt Solvency- Aceeptance ...... 47 Alt Solves- Democracy ...... 48 Alt Solvency- Empowering the Self ...... 49 AT: Perm-slave ...... 53 At: Rude ...... 54 AT: Exercising Power Bad ...... 55 AT: Pain ...... 56 AT: Perm is Slave Morality ...... 57 At: Impacts ...... 58 AT: Framework ...... 60 AT: Schopenhauer ...... 61 AT: Truth is Real ...... 62

ADI 2011 2 Critical Lab Nietzsche K

AT: Anti-Semetism ...... 63 Aff Answer ...... 64 Aff Answer ...... 65 Aff Answer ...... 66 Aff Answer ...... 67 Aff Answer ...... 68 Aff Answer ...... 69 Aff Answer ...... 70 Aff Answer ...... 72 Aff Answer ...... 73 Aff Answer ...... 74

ADI 2011 1 Nielson Bear Witness Syrian Bearing Witness Affirmative

Syrian Bearing Witness Affirmative ...... 1 Answer To: Something is Wrong with the Narrative ...... 54 FYI ...... 2 Answer To: Framework – Wrong Forum ...... 55 Syrian Bearing Witness Critical 1AC ...... 3 Answer To: Framework - Predictability ...... 58 Syrian Bearing Witness Poetics 1AC ...... 10 Answer To: Framework - Switch Sides ...... 59 Narrative: Riad Al-Turk ...... 13 Answer To: Framework – Policy Making Education ...... 61 Narratives: Torture Testimony ...... 16 Answer To: Framework – Aff is a Pre-req to the Topic .... 62 Harms: Syrian Police Force Violence ...... 19 Answer To: Framework – USFG Topicality ...... 64 Harms: Refugees ...... 20 Answer To: Framework Democracy Assistance ...... 65 Harms: Torture ...... 21 Answer To: Not 1st Hand Experience ...... 66 Impact: Freedom ...... 22 Answer To: Speaking for Others ...... 68 Impact: Torture ...... 23 Answer To: Desiring/Fetish the Other ...... 75 Advantage Add-On: Social Amnesia ...... 26 Answer To: Fetish/Pity/Resentment ...... 77 Advantage Add-On: Global Justice ...... 28 Answer To: Need to Hear the Silent ...... 78 Solvency – Bearing Witness Confronts Syria ...... 31 Answer To: Tyranny of Truth ...... 79 Solvency – Bearing Witness  Subjectivity ...... 33 Answer To: History Bad ...... 83 Solvency – Bearing Witness  Responsibilty ...... 35 Answer To: Hypocrisy ...... 86 Solvency - Bearing Witness  Action ...... 39 Answer To: Muslim Brotherhood Are Evil ...... 88 Solvency – Bearing Witness  Ethics ...... 44 Answer To: Humanitarian Intervention Bad ...... 90 Solvency - Bearing Witness & Media ...... 45 Answer To: Human Rights Kritiks ...... 92 Solvency – Spillover Effect ...... 46 Answer To: Feminism ...... 94 Solvency – Global Justice ...... 47 Answer To: Whiteness ...... 95 Solvency – Must Have A Plan ...... 48 Answer To: Terrorism ...... 96 Solvency – Poetry ...... 49 Answer To: Muslim Brotherhood ...... 98 Message In A Bottle Metaphor ...... 50 Answer To: Utilitarianism ...... 99 Answer To: Asad Reforming ...... 51 Answer To: Political Pluralism Reform ...... 52 Answer To: Riad Al-Turk Indicts ...... 53

ADI 2011 1 Critical Lab Syria Bearing Witness Neg Syrian Bearing Witness Case Negative

Syrian Bearing Witness Case Negative ...... 1 Harms Take-Outs ...... 2 Solvency Take-Outs: Bearing Witness ...... 6 Answer To: Torture Advantage ...... 11 No Obligation to the Other ...... 12 Riad Al-Turk Neg ...... 12 Framework: Must Have A Plan ...... 14 Framework: Fairness ...... 16 Exploiting the Other ...... 17 Speaking for Others ...... 18 Tyranny of Truth ...... 21 Confessions ...... 26 Ethics Bad ...... 27 Link: Western Imperialism K’s ...... 28 Link: Neoliberalism ...... 29 Disaster Porn K Shell ...... 31 Disaster Porn Link – Torture ...... 33 Critical Counter-Plan: Endless Mourning ...... 34 Counter-Plan: UN Sanctions ...... 36

ADI 2011 1 Nielson Whiteness

Whiteness Index

Biopower ...... 58 Whiteness Index ...... 1 Cultural Genocide ...... 59 1NC Shell ...... 3 Dehumanization ...... 60 1NC Shell ...... 4 Dehumanization ...... 61 1NC Shell ...... 6 Dehumanization ...... 62 1NC Shell ...... 7 Democracy ...... 63 Discrimination ...... 64 **Links** ...... 8 Ethics ...... 65 Imperialism...... 66 Christianity...... 9 Inequalities ...... 67 Colorblindness ...... 11 Inequalities ...... 69 Courts ...... 12 Interventionism ...... 70 Debate ...... 13 Interventionism ...... 72 Democracy Assistance ...... 15 Ontological Violence ...... 73 Democracy Assistance ...... 16 Segragation ...... 74 Democracy ...... 17 Violence ...... 75 Democracy ...... 18 War ...... 76 Democracy ...... 19 War ...... 77 Democracy ...... 20 White Suffering ...... 78 Democracy ...... 21 Difference ...... 22 **Alternative** ...... 79 Equality/Freedom ...... 23 Feminism/Marxism ...... 25 Abolish White Citizenship ...... 80 Human Rights ...... 26 Abolish White Citizenship ...... 81 Identity Politics ...... 27 Abolish White Citizenship ...... 82 Inclusion ...... 28 Abolish White Citizenship ...... 83 Individual Action ...... 29 Need Perspectives of Color ...... 84 International Law ...... 30 Ontological Criticism ...... 85 Kritikal Affs ...... 31 Ontological Criticism ...... 87 Marxism ...... 32 Outrage ...... 88 Multiculturalism ...... 33 Presence of Mind ...... 89 Negative Rights ...... 35 Refuse Normalized White Body ...... 90 Omission ...... 36 Resistance ...... 91 Omission ...... 37 **Answers To Aff Answers** ...... 92 Omission ...... 38 Omission ...... 39 AT: Apologies ...... 93 Postmodernism ...... 40 AT: Cap ...... 94 Postmodernism ...... 41 AT: Cap ...... 96 Postmodernism ...... 42 AT: Cap ...... 97 Postmodernism ...... 43 AT: Cap ...... 98 Postmodernism ...... 44 AT: Black/White Binary ...... 99 Racial Ideology ...... 46 AT: Black Responsibility ...... 101 Reform ...... 47 AT: Feminism ...... 102 Subaltern ...... 48 AT: Framework – Race First ...... 104 White Folk ...... 49 AT: Framework – Debate Key ...... 105 White Liberals ...... 50 AT: Framework – Ballot Key ...... 107 White Liberals ...... 52 AT: Framework – Bracketing Out Bad ...... 108 White Philosophy ...... 53 AT: Framework – Fairness/Predictability ...... 110 View from Nowhere ...... 54 AT: Framework – Ontological Expansiveness ...... 111 AT: Framework – Switch-Side Debate ...... 112 **Impacts** ...... 55 Switch Side Debate Bad ...... 113 Bad Faith ...... 56 Switch Side Debate Bad ...... 114 Bad Faith ...... 57 AT: Intersectionality...... 115 AT: No Link ...... 116

ADI 2011 2 Nielson Whiteness

AT: Perm ...... 117 AT: Utopianism Bad ...... 144 AT: Perm ...... 118 AT: Perm ...... 119 **Aff Answers** ...... 145 AT: Race is Biological ...... 120 Black/White Binary Bad ...... 146 AT: Race is Ethnicity ...... 121 Capitalism K Link ...... 147 AT: Race Isn’t Real ...... 122 Debate Space Bad ...... 148 AT: Race Isn’t Real ...... 123 Monolithic Turn ...... 150 AT: Race is Neutral ...... 124 Totalizing Turn ...... 151 AT: Homogenizes Whiteness...... 125 Essentialism ...... 154 AT: I Didn’t Intend To Be Racist! ...... 126 Privilege Talk Bad ...... 156 AT: “I Hate Racism Too” ...... 127 Victimization Turn ...... 157 AT: Inevitable ...... 128 Revealing Whiteness Bad ...... 158 AT: “Oprah Effect”/Blacks are Privileged ...... 129 White Bashing ...... 159 AT: Racism Inevitable ...... 130 Perms ...... 160 AT: Reverse Racism ...... 131 Perm: Policy Making ...... 161 AT: “That’s the Past” ...... 133 Reclaiming Whiteness Turn ...... 162 AT: “That’s The Past” ...... 134 AT: You Exclude Whites ...... 135 **Random** ...... 166 AT: WE ARE INDIVIDUALS ...... 136 Middle Eastern = Catch 22 ...... 167 AT: We Aren’t Racist ...... 137 Middle Eastern = Catch 22 ...... 168 AT: Whiteness is Monolithic ...... 138 Middle Eastern = Catch 22 ...... 169 AT: Whiteness Can Be Reclaimed ...... 139 White Privilege is Upheld Unconsciously ...... 170 AT: White Bashing ...... 140 White Privilege is Invisible ...... 171 AT: White Skin = Whiteness ...... 141

AT: White Skin = Whiteness ...... 142

AT: Uncomfortability ...... 143

ADI 2011 1 Critical Lab The Gift K The Gift Kritik Index

The Gift Kritik Index ...... 1 The Gift Shell ...... 2 Link: Gifts Secure Majority Power ...... 5 Link: Democracy ...... 6 Link: Democracy Assistance ...... 7 Link: NGO’s ...... 10 Link: NED ...... 11 Link: US Arab Spring Democ Assistance ...... 12 Link: Egypt ...... 13 Link: Bahrain ...... 15 Link: Bahrain Military to Military Assistance ...... 16 Link: Libya ...... 17 Link: Yemen ...... 18 Link: Democracy Process Aff’s ...... 19 Link: Conditions on Assistance ...... 20 Uniqueness: US influences Crumbling ...... 21 Impacts: Case Turn ...... 22 Impacts: Oppression ...... 23 Impacts: Democracy Turn ...... 24 Impact: Military Intervention ...... 25 Impact: Colonialism ...... 26 Alternative: Support the Agency of Springers ...... 27 Alternative: Global Citizenship ...... 28 Answer To: Perm ...... 35 Answers To: The Plan helps X Country ...... 36 Answer To: Democracy Assistance is Different from Aid/Promotion ...... 39 Answer To: Democ Assistance is Not Intervention ...... 40 Affirmative Answers: Perm ...... 42 Affirmative Answer: Global Citizenship Alt ...... 44 Affirmative Answer: Democracy Promotion Good ...... 45 Affirmative Answer: Target Wants the Plan ...... 46

ADI 2011 1 Critical Lab Aff Torture Impacts Torture Supplement

Torture Supplement ...... 1 Torture Impacts...... 2 Answer To: Disaster Porn ...... 9

ADI 2011 AFF Stuff 1 Egypt Aff/Neg Supplements

Egypt Aff/Neg Supplements ...... 1 ***Aff*** ...... 2 Inherency ...... 2 Inherency – Egyptian Econ Down ...... 3 Inherency – MB Wins Now ...... 4 Inherency – MB Wins Now ...... 5 Inherency – MB Wins Now ...... 6 Solvency – Elections – Dem Assist Solves Extremism ...... 7 MB Bad ...... 9 Obama Cred Adv – U: Heg Decreasing Now ...... 12 Obama Cred Adv – ME Peace Solvency ...... 15 Egyptian Democracy – International Pressure Key ...... 16 Egyptian Democracy – US Key ...... 17 Egypt Modeled ...... 18 A2: Kritik – No Alt to Liberal Order ...... 19 A2: Muslim Brotherhood Moderate ...... 20 A2: Talks w/ MB ...... 21 A2: EU CP – No Solvency ...... 22 A2: Regional Stability DA ...... 24 A2: Israel DA ...... 26 ***Neg ...... 27 No Inherency ...... 27 Inherency – MB Won’t Win Now ...... 28 Inherency – MB Won’t Win Now ...... 29 MB Good ...... 32 MB Good ...... 33 MB Good – Not anti-Israel ...... 36 MB Good – Moderate ...... 37 MB Good – Secular ...... 38 MB Good – Non-violent ...... 39 MB Good – Non-violent ...... 40 MB Good – Not Terrorists ...... 41 No Solvency ...... 43 No Solvency – NGOs ...... 46 A2: Democracy Advantage ...... 47 A2: US Credibility ...... 48 A2: US Credibility ...... 49 A2: US Credibility – anti-Arab perception ...... 50 CP Solvency – Conditions ...... 51 DA Turns Case – Econ ...... 52

ADI 2011 EU Supplement 1 ***EU CP Supplement***

EU CP Supplement ...... 1 Uniqueness – EU Cred Low ...... 2 Uniqueness – EU Cred Low ...... 3 Uniqueness – EU Cred Low ...... 4 Uniqueness – EU Cred High ...... 5 Solvency – Egypt ...... 6 Solvency Shield – US Aid Rejected ...... 7 Solvency – EU > US ...... 8 Solvency – Egypt Election Assistance ...... 9 Solvency – Arab Spring/ Generic ...... 10 ***AFF Counterplan Answers*** ...... 11 Permutation ...... 11

ASU 2011 1 Jason Sanchez File Title Aff

Aff ...... 1 Aff – Leadership in Yemen Down Now ...... 58 1AC - Inherency ...... 3 Aff – Democracy solves terrorism ...... 59 1AC - Plan ...... 4 Aff – Democracy Solves Econ ...... 60 1AC – Adv:_____ AQAP ...... 5 Aff – Solvency – State Formation ...... 61 1AC – Adv _____: Yemen Instability ...... 10 Aff – Solvency - State Formation ...... 62 1AC – Adv _____: Leadership ...... 12 Aff – Solvency – Free Media ...... 64 Aff – Solvency – US Action ...... 65 Inherency ...... 14 Aff –Solvency – CSO ...... 67 Aff – Inherency – Police Corrupt Now ...... 14 Aff –Solvency – CSO ...... 68 Aff - Major democracy assistance package solves Yemeni Aff – Inherency – Judges Corrupt Now ...... 15 support ...... 69 Aff – Inherency – No Independent Judiciary Now ...... 16 Aff – Solvency - Democracy Assistance ...... 70 Aff – Inherency – Judges Untrained Now ...... 17 Aff – Solvency – Democracy Assistance ...... 72 Aff – Inherency – AT Prosecuting Terrorists Now ...... 18 Aff – Solvency – Democracy Assistance – Terrorism ...... 74 Aff – Inherency - AT Military Solving Now ...... 20 Aff – Solvency – Governing Assistance ...... 75 Aff – Inherency – Military Aid Fails Now ...... 21 Aff – Solvency – Governing Assistance –Terrorism ...... 76 Aff – Inherency – More DA Needed...... 22 Aff – Solvency – Governing Assistance – Terrorism ...... 80 Aff – Inherency – Violence Now ...... 23 Aff – Solvency – Governing Assistance – Terrorism ...... 81 Aff – Solvency – Power-Sharing Solves Instability ...... 82 AQAP Advantage ...... 25 Aff – Solvency – Political Institutions ...... 83 Aff – Inherency – AQAP Strong Now ...... 25 Aff – Solvency – Peaceful Transition...... 85 Aff – Inherency - AQAP Strong Now ...... 26 Aff – Solvency – MEPI ...... 86 Aff – Inherency - AQAP Strong Now ...... 27 Aff – Solvency – Laundry List ...... 87 Aff – Military/security approach in Yemen fails ...... 28 Aff – Solvency – Structural Violence...... 88 Aff – Terrorism Advantage ...... 29 Aff – AT No Solvency – Tribes ...... 89 Aff – Terrorism Advantage ...... 30 Random Inherency Args Irrelevant to the Aff .. 90 Aff – Police - Terrorism ...... 31 Aff – Police – Bioterrorism ...... 32 Aff – Inherency – HR Abuse Now ...... 90 Aff – Drone Strikes Increase AQAP strength ...... 34 Aff – Inherency – Not Supporting Democracy Now ...... 91 Aff – Solvency – US Action - Terrorism ...... 35 Aff – Inherency – No Free Speech Now ...... 92 Aff – State department law enforcement training solves ... 36 Aff – Inherency – No Democracy Now ...... 93 Aff – Drone Internal Links ...... 37 Aff – Inherency – Yemen Water Crisis Now ...... 94 Instability ...... 38 Random Adv ...... 96 Aff – Yemen Instability Impact ...... 38 Aff – US Leadership Internal Links ...... 96 Aff – Yemen Instability Impact ...... 39 Aff – Inherency – No Women’s Rights Now ...... 99 Aff – Yemen Instability Impact ...... 40 Aff – Regional Instability ...... 41 Aff – Women’s Rights Adv ...... 100 Aff – Yemen Economic Collapse Impacts ...... 42 Aff – Women’s Rights Impact – Poverty ...... 101 Aff – Stability Spillover ...... 43 Aff – Women’s Rights Impact - Poverty ...... 102 Aff - Yemen Collapse causes Saudi take over ...... 44 Aff – Women’s Rights Impact - Ethics ...... 104 Aff – Inherency – Yemen Econ Collapsing Now ...... 45 Aff – Solvency – Democracy Assistance – Women’s Rights105 Aff - Corruption reforms key to solve...... 48 Aff – Yemeni Women Want Rights ...... 106 Aff – AT Companies Adapt to Corrupt Gov ...... 49 Aff – Courts Key to the Economy-General ...... 50 A2: Neg args ...... 107 Solvency ...... 51 Aff – AT Movements DA ...... 107 Aff – AT Movements DA ...... 108 Aff - Judicial Reform Key ...... 51 Aff – AT Succession DA NU ...... 109 Aff – Judical Reform Solves – Corruption ...... 52 Aff – AT Succession DA NL ...... 111 Aff – Judicial Reform Solves ...... 53 Aff – AT Succession DA No Impact ...... 112 Aff – Solvency – Law enforcement and Judiciary ...... 54 Aff – AT Saudi DA ...... 113 Aff – FYI-What Judicial Reform Initials ...... 56 Aff – AT Consult CP – Perm Do CP ...... 115 Aff - Democracy assistance undermines AQAP recruitment Aff – AT EU CP – Perm Do Both ...... 116 ...... 57 Aff – A2 EU CP ...... 117

ASU 2011 2 Jason Sanchez File Title

Aff – A2 EU CP ...... 118 Aff – AT UN CP – No Solvency - Method ...... 124 Aff – AT EU CP – No Solvency ...... 119 Aff – AT UN CP – No Solvency – Competing Visions .. 125 Aff – AT UN CP – No Solvency - Statistical Support ..... 120 Aff – AT UN CP – Supports Oppression ...... 126 Aff – AT UN CP – No Solvency – Special Interests ...... 121 Aff – AT Saudi CP – Perm Do Both ...... 127 Aff – AT UN CP – No Solvency – Socialism ...... 122 Aff – AT UN CP – No Solvency – Money Doesn’t Reach People ...... 123

ADI 2011 1 Pointer/Symonds Yemen Neg Yemen Neg

Yemen Neg ...... 1 Neg – Instability Answers – No Escalation ...... 37 Neg – AT Economic Instability ...... 39 Neg ...... 2 Neg – Movements DA ...... 40 Neg – SQ Solves ...... 2 Neg – Movements DA ...... 41 Neg – Inherency - Saudi Arabia Solves Now ...... 3 Neg – Movements DA ...... 42 Neg – Inherency – Aid Now ...... 4 Neg – Succession DA 1NC ...... 43 Neg – Inherency – AQAP Being Solved Now ...... 5 Neg – Succession DA 1NC ...... 44 Neg – Inherency – AQAP Being Solved Now ...... 6 Neg – Succession DA UQ ...... 45 Neg – Inherency – Leadership in Yemen High Now ...... 7 Neg – Succession DA Link ...... 46 Neg – Yemen Economy stabilizing ...... 8 Neg – Succession DA Impact ...... 47 Neg – Terrorism – No Nuclear Terrorism ...... 10 Neg – Succession DA Impact ...... 48 Neg – Terrorism – No Nuclear Terrorism ...... 11 Neg – Succession-Secession D/A ...... 49 Neg – No Nuclear Terrorism – AT: Retaliation ...... 12 Neg – Heg Answers ...... 51 Neg – No Solvency-Empirically Denied ...... 13 Neg – Conditions CP Solves ...... 53 Neg – No Solvency – Tribes ...... 14 Neg – UN CP...... 54 Neg – No Solvency – Yemen Leadership ...... 15 Neg – UN Solves - Police Training ...... 55 Neg – No Solvency – US Action ...... 16 Neg – UN Solves - Water Management ...... 56 Neg – No Solvency – Public Defection ...... 17 Neg – UN Solves - Experience ...... 57 Neg – No Solvency – Decentralization ...... 18 Neg – UN Solves - Good-Mandate ...... 58 Neg – No Solvency – Alt Causes ...... 20 Neg – US assistance bad for Yemen NGOs ...... 59 Neg – No Solvency – Alt Causes ...... 22 Neg – EU CP - Solves ...... 60 Neg – No Solvency – Ending Patronage ...... 23 Neg – PTX GOP Hates Plan ...... 61 Neg – No Solvency – Civil Society ...... 25 Neg – PTX GOP Hates Plan ...... 62 Neg – No solvency - Women’s Rights ...... 26 Neg – PTX GOP Hates Plan ...... 63 Neg – No solvency - Women’s Rights ...... 27 Neg – PTX Plan Partisan ...... 64 Neg – No solvency – Parliament ...... 28 Neg – PTX Congress Supports ...... 65 Neg – No solvency – NGOs ...... 29 Neg – PTX GOP Supports ...... 66 Neg – No Solvency - Corruption ...... 30 Neg – PTX Dems Support ...... 67 Neg – No Solvency ...... 31 Neg – Terrorism Turns ...... 68 Neg – No Solvency ...... 32 Neg – Terrorism Turns ...... 69 Neg – TURN – Governance Assistance bolsters AQAP .... 34 Neg – US is a terrorist nation ...... 70 Neg – Alt Cause Overwhelms the Case ...... 35 Neg – Fragmentation/US promotion Case Turns ...... 71 Neg – Democracy Assitance Not Key ...... 36

ADI 2011 1 Carter/Sydnor Democracy Assistance Neocolonialism Starter K Democracy Assistance Neocolonialism K

Democracy Assistance K ...... 1 Alt- Solvency ...... 20 1NC ...... 2 **Answers To** ...... 21 1NC ...... 3 1NC ...... 4 AT: Democracy Good ...... **Links** ...... 5 AT: Mouffe – Colonialism ...... 21 Link- Democracy Assistance ...... 5 AT: Perm ...... 23 Link- Governmental Action ...... 6 AT: State Good ...... 24 Link – Governmental Action ...... 6 AT: Democracy solves Liberation ...... 25 Link – Governmental Action ...... 7 AT: Moral Imperative ...... 26 Link- Soft Power ...... 9 Link- Soft Power ...... 10 **Aff Answers**……………………………………… Link- Terrorism ...... 11

Link- Terrorism ...... 12 Aff Answer – Perm + NB ...... 27 Link- State...... 13 Perm ...... 28 **Impacts** ...... Perm overcomes the link ...... 29 14 Aff- Egyptians prefer Democracy ...... 30 Impact- Extinction ...... 14 Aff- Democratization Good – Great Power Wars Kill ...... 31 Impact- Extinction ...... 15 Aff- Democratic Institutions = Liberation ...... 32 Impact- Democracy = Oppression ...... 16 Aff- Transition Assistance Requires US Action………… 33 **Alternative** ...... Aff- Demo Assistance Undermines...... Imperialism ...... 34 17 Aff- Demo Assistance Avoids the Link ...... 35 Rejection Alt / AT: Framework ...... 17 Rejection alt / AT: Framework ...... 18 Sub-Altern Strategies Alt ...... 19

ADI 2011 1 Fellows Egypt Aff Egypt Elections Aff

Egypt Elections Aff...... 1 Muslim Brotherhood Bad – Terrorism ...... 36 1AC ...... 2 Solvency – Political Organizations ...... 37 Obama Credibility Adv ...... 2 Solvency – Training Programs/Civil Society ...... 38 Obama Credibility Adv ...... 3 Solvency – Civil Society Key ...... 39 Obama Credibility Adv ...... 4 Solvency – Common Rules ...... 40 Obama Credibility Adv ...... 5 US assistance is key ...... 41 Obama Credibility Adv ...... 6 US assistance is key ...... 42 Obama Credibility Adv ...... 7 US assistance is key to defeating Muslim Brotherhood .... 43 Obama Credibility Adv ...... 8 AT: Monitoring Increases Violence ...... 44 Elections Adv ...... 9 ***Negative ...... 45 Elections Adv ...... 10 Inherency – Egyptian Econ Strong ...... 45 Elections Adv ...... 11 Inherency – International Aid ...... 46 Elections Adv ...... 12 Inherency – UNDP ...... 47 Elections Adv ...... 13 **Neg – Obama Cred Adv ...... 48 Elections Adv ...... 14 Status Quo Good ...... 48 Elections Adv ...... 15 Plan Sparks Backlash ...... 49 Egyptian Democracy Adv ...... 16 Plan Sparks Backlash ...... 50 Egyptian Democracy Adv ...... 17 Egyptian Democracy Adv ...... 18 **Neg – Elections Adv ...... 51 Egyptian Democracy Adv ...... 19 Inherency – No MB Takeover Now ...... 51 Solvency ...... 20 No Impact to MB ...... 52 Inherency – Aid ...... 21 No Impact to MB (Suez Canal) ...... 53 Inherency – NGOs ...... 22 **Neg – Brotherhood Moderation Adv ...... 54 Inherency – Election Monitoring ...... 23 Brotherhood Is Democratic ...... 54 Inherency – Egyptian Econ Collapsing ...... 24 Brotherhood is Tolerant/Peaceful ...... 55 Inherency – Election Violence Now ...... 25 Brotherhood is Tolerant/Peaceful ...... 56 ***Obama Cred Adv ...... 26 No Solvency – Egypt Demo Assist Fails – Empirically .... 57 Solvency - Plan Key to Heg ...... 26 No Solvency – Civil Society ...... 59 Solvency – Peaceful Transition ...... 27 No Solvency – Capital Flight ...... 60 Solvency – US Key/American Interests ...... 28 No Solvency – Rejection ...... 61 Impact – Smart Power – Laundry List ...... 29 No Solvency – Permits ...... 62 Impact – Soft Power – Terrorism ...... 30 No Solvency – Monitoring Fails ...... 63 Impact – Soft Power – Terrorism ...... 31 No Solvency – Blocked Funding ...... 64 Internal Link – Election k2 New Constitution ...... 32 No Solvency – Military Won’t Relinquish Control ...... 65 ***Egyptian Demo Adv ...... 33 Democracy Assistance Bad ...... 66 Democracy Assistance Bad – NGOs ...... 67 Solvency – ME Demo Spillover ...... 33 Democracy Assistance Bad – Hurts Liberals ...... 68 Election Monitoring Bad – Violence ...... 69 ***Elections Adv ...... 34 Inherency – MB Takeover Now ...... 34 Muslim Brotherhood Bad – Democracy ...... 35

ASU 2011 1 Fellows EU Counterplan European Union Counterplan

European Union Counterplan...... 1 Solvency – Women’s Rights ...... 18 ***Neg Section*** ...... 2 Solvency – Civic Engagement...... 19 1NC Cards...... 2 Solvency – Movements/ Local Politics ...... 20 EU Succeeds – Generic ...... 3 A/T: EU Fails ...... 21 EU Succeeds – Credibility Gap ...... 4 A/T: US is Superior ...... 22 EU Succeeds – Experience ...... 5 ***Aff Section*** ...... 23 EU Succeeds – A2: Not Committed ...... 6 EU = Ineffective - Method ...... 23 EU Succeeds – A2: EU empirically sucks ...... 7 EU = Ineffective - Goals ...... 24 EU Succeeds – CP Solves Better 1/3 ...... 8 EU Fails - Funding ...... 25 EU Succeeds – CP Solves Better 2/3 ...... 9 EU Fails - Infighting...... 26 EU Succeeds – CP Solves Better 3/3 ...... 10 EU Fails – Laundry List ...... 27 Solvency – Human Rights ...... 11 EU Fails – Credibility...... 28 Solvency – Conditions Affs ...... 12 EU Fails – Unconditional Aid ...... 29 Solvency – Bottom Up Development ...... 13 EU Fails – Decentralized ...... 30 Solvency – K affs ...... 14 EU Fails – Civil Society ...... 31 Solvency – Radicalism ...... 15 EU Fails – Egypt ...... 32 Solvency – Regional Stability/ Cooperation ...... 16 Solvency – Good Governance ...... 17

ASU 2011 1 Ziegler/Roark Ptx Starter Pack Politics – Starter Pack

Politics – Starter Pack ...... 1 AT – Default Short ...... 20 1NC ...... 2 Debt Ceiling K Econ ...... 21 1NC ...... 3 Debt Ceiling K Econ ...... 22 Yes Pass ...... 4 Econ MPX ...... 23 Yes Pass ...... 5 Econ MPX ...... 24 Yes Pass ...... 6 ***AFF ...... 24 Spending Link XT ...... 7 PC Key ...... 8 No Pass ...... 25 Yes PC ...... 9 No Pass ...... 26 AT: Thumpers – Demo Assistance ...... 10 No Pass ...... 27 AT: Thumpers – Egypt Demo Assistance ...... 11 Thumpers ...... 28 Republicans Link/IL ...... 12 No PC ...... 29 Egypt Unpopular – General ...... 13 No Link – No Conservative Backlash ...... 30 Egypt Unpopular – Spending ...... 14 Egyptian Election Assistance Popular ...... 31 Assistance Unpopular – Regime Change Egyptian Election Assistance Popular ...... 32 Conflation ...... 15 Winners Win ...... 33 AT: Plan Popular – Entropy ...... 16 PC =/= Key ...... 34 AT – LT: Winners Win ...... 17 MPX D – No Default ...... 35 PC K Agenda ...... 18 MPX D – Econ =/= War ...... 36 AT – No Default ...... 19