ADI 2011 1 Research Lab Dev’t Assistance Generic Core DA Generic Core DA Generic Core ................................................................. 1 DA Fails – Western Model ................................................ 55 DA Fails – Politicized ....................................................... 56 ***DA Solves*** ................................................... 3 DA Fails – Poverty ............................................................ 57 DA Solves – Generic ........................................................... 4 DA Fails – Governance Turn ............................................ 58 DA Solves – A2: Rejection .................................................. 5 DA Fails – Governance Turn ............................................ 59 DA Solves – A2: Transition ................................................. 6 DA Fails – Accountability Turn ........................................ 60 DA Solves – A2: Long term ................................................ 7 DA Fails – Transition Turn ............................................... 61 DA Solves – A2: Dependency ............................................. 8 DA Fails – Transition Turn ............................................... 62 DA Solves – A2: Parties ...................................................... 9 DA Fails – Transition Turn – Impact Calc: Escalation ..... 63 DA Solves – A2: Definitional Problems ............................ 10 DA Fails – Gov’t to Gov’t ................................................. 64 DA Solves – A2: Governance ............................................ 11 DA Fails – Gov’t to Gov’t ................................................. 65 DA Solves – A2: Governance ............................................ 12 ***NGO DA Solves*** ........................................ 66 DA Solves – A2: Local Context Key ................................. 13 DA Solves – A2: Local Context Key ................................. 14 NGO DA Solves – Aid Works .......................................... 67 DA Solves – A2: Backlash ................................................ 15 NGO DA Solves – Aid Works .......................................... 68 DA Solves – A2: Credibility/Politicization ........................ 16 NGO DA Solves – A2: Repression ................................... 69 DA Solves – A2: Credibility/Politicization ........................ 17 NGO DA Solves – A2: Repression ................................... 70 DA Solves – A2: Credibility/Politicization ........................ 18 NGO DA Solves – NGO’s Good ....................................... 71 DA Solves – A2: Regime Change – No Link .................... 19 NGO DA Solves – NGO’s Good ....................................... 72 DA Solves – A2: Regime Change – Turn: Moderation ..... 20 NGO DA Solves – NGO’s Good ....................................... 73 DA Solves – A2: Western Model ...................................... 21 DA Solves – A2: Corruption .............................................. 22 ***NGO DA Fails*** .......................................... 74 DA Solves – A2: Coordination .......................................... 23 NGO DA Fails – Generally ............................................... 75 DA Solves – A2: Coordination .......................................... 24 NGO DA Fails – Gov’t Cooptation ................................... 76 DA Solves – A2: Assessment ............................................ 25 NGO DA Fails – NGO’s =/= Gov’t Change ..................... 77 DA Solves—A2: Complexity ............................................ 26 NGO DA Fails – Repression ............................................. 78 DA Solves—A2: Culture ................................................... 27 NGO DA Fails – Urban ..................................................... 79 DA Solves—A2: Monitoring ............................................. 28 NGO DA Fails – Picking Winners .................................... 80 ***DA Fails***.................................................... 29 NGO DA Fails – Divisions ............................................... 81 NGO DA Fails – NGOs Bad – Generally .......................... 82 DA Fails – Generic ............................................................ 30 NGO DA Fails – NGO’s Bad – Accountability ................ 83 DA Fails – A2: Studies ...................................................... 31 NGO DA Fails – NGO’s Bad – Accountability ................ 84 DA Fails – A2: Studies ...................................................... 32 NGO DA Fails – NGO’s Bad – Representativeness ......... 85 DA Fails – A2: Studies ...................................................... 33 NGO DA Fails – NGO’s Bad – Representativeness ......... 86 DA Fails – A2: Studies ...................................................... 34 NGO DA Fails – K Link ................................................... 87 DA Fails – A2: Studies – Block Trick: No Solvency ........ 35 DA Fails – Rejection .......................................................... 36 ***USAID Solves*** ........................................... 88 DA Fails – Cooptation ....................................................... 37 USAID Solves – Generic .................................................. 89 DA Fails – Long-Term ....................................................... 38 USAID Solves – Generic .................................................. 90 DA Fails – Complexity ...................................................... 39 USAID Solves – A2: Contracting ..................................... 91 DA Fails – Culture ............................................................. 40 USAID Solves – A2: Branding ......................................... 92 DA Fails – Monitoring ....................................................... 41 DA Fails – Parties .............................................................. 42 ***USAID Fails*** .............................................. 93 DA Fails – Parties .............................................................. 43 USAID Fails – Coordination ............................................. 94 DA Fails – Agency Coordination ....................................... 44 USAID Fails – Coordination ............................................. 95 DA Fails – Separation of Powers ....................................... 45 USAID Fails – Local Populations ..................................... 96 DA Fails – Dependency ..................................................... 46 USAID Fails – Politics ...................................................... 97 DA Fails – Credibility ........................................................ 47 USAID Fails – Generally .................................................. 98 DA Fails – Credibility ........................................................ 48 USAID Fails – Contracting ............................................... 99 DA Fails – Credibility ........................................................ 49 USAID Fails – Resources ................................................ 100 DA Fails – Local Context .................................................. 50 USAID Fails – Branding ................................................. 101 DA Fails – Local Context .................................................. 51 DA Fails – Local Context .................................................. 52 DA Fails – Local Context – A2: We Build Capacity ......... 53 DA Fails – Definitional Problems ...................................... 54 ADI 2011 2 Research Lab Dev’t Assistance Generic Core ***NED Solves*** ............................................ 102 ***NED Fails*** ................................................ 108 NED Solves – Democratization ....................................... 103 NED Fails- Politics .......................................................... 109 NED Solves- k2 Democratization .................................... 104 NED Fails- Politics .......................................................... 110 NED Solves- k2 Democratization .................................... 105 NED Fails- Credibility .................................................... 111 NED Solves- Relations .................................................... 106 NED Fails – Picking Winners ......................................... 112 NED Solves- Modeled ..................................................... 107 NED Fails—Administration ............................................ 113 ADI 2011 1 Research Lab Framework Framework Framework ........................................................................... 1 2NC Engaging Politics Solves Totalitarianism ................. 40 2NC Policy Debate Fractures Movements ........................ 41 ***Kritiks Bad*** ................................................ 3 2NC No Spillover .............................................................. 42 **Shells................................................................... 3 **Answers To ....................................................... 43 *Aff ......................................................................... 3 AT: Mitchell ...................................................................... 44 AT: Spanos ........................................................................ 45 2AC Shell ............................................................................. 4 AT: Kulynych .................................................................... 46 *Neg ........................................................................ 5 AT: Karl Rove Was A Debater ........................................