Adirondack Park Regional Assessment Project Executive Summary • May 2009 The photo on the opposite page is a composite image of layers provided by NASA and NOAA. Nighttime lights and the Blue Line were superimposed on a daylight image of the northeastern United States and the Provinces of Quebec and Ontario. Seventy million people live within the bounds of the image. Only 132,000 people live within the Blue Line. APRAP would like to thank NOAA, NASA and Congressman

John McHugh for their assistance in the creation of this photo. NY. Speculator, COVER PHOTO © Darla J. Outhout: Summer day on the Kunjamuk River, The Adirondack Park Copyright AATV; Layers provided by NOAA and NASA Copyright AATV;

he history of the New York City merchants feared that Seven. The following words were Adirondack Park can be the same timber cutting would reduce added: T divided into a series of over- water flows to the Hudson River and lapping eras from the constitutional Erie Canal. These waterways were The lands of the state, protection of the Forest Preserve, to major transportation corridors, and now“ owned or hereafter the creation of the park, its incre- such disruption would have had an acquired, constituting the mental expansions, and the even- adverse effect on their commercial Forest Preserve as now fixed interests. Together, they achieved tual regulation of land use within by law, shall be kept as wild the park. The Adirondack Forest one of the earliest acts of public land forest lands. They shall not be Preserve was originally created by the protection in the country. leased, sold or exchanged, or New York State Legislature in 1885. The Adirondack Park was be taken by any corporation, Two diverse groups–preservationists established in 1892. After some and merchants–agreed that this attempts to weaken the enabling public or private, nor shall mountainous region of upstate New legislation that created the forest the timber thereon be sold, York needed protection. The preser- preserve, the state gave the area removed or destroyed. vationists were concerned about the even stronger protection in 1894 ” environmental effects of large scale by amending the New York State During the 1938 Constitutional timber harvesting, while influential Constitution, Section 7, Article Convention, these words were

May 2009 • Adirondack Park Regional Assessment Project [iii] The Adirondack Park reaffirmed as Article Fourteen, the abounds with mountains, lakes and Land Master Plan and the Adiron- guiding principle for the Adirondack rivers scattered throughout a unique dack Park Land Use and Develop- and Catskill forest preserves. natural landscape. The Adirondack ment Plan. These plans regulate use Park lies within a five hour drive for and development on all land–public The Adirondack Park’s boundary 50 million people who live in the and private–within the park. has expanded several times, eventu- urban centers of New York City, ally encompassing a land mass of Boston, Montreal and Toronto. In nearly 6 million acres. The park is 1971, New York State passed the comprised of 12 counties and 103 Adirondack Park Agency Act which municipalities with approximately called for the development of two 132,000 residents. The region plans: the Adirondack Park State

[iv] Adirondack Park Regional Assessment Project • May 2009 Executive Summary

Introduction what we found he Adirondack Park Regional Assessment The Adirondack Park has Project (APRAP) is a study by and for park doubled in size since its T communities. The project was conceived in 2006 creation in 1892, to more than by member communities of the Adirondack Association nine thousand square miles. Private of Towns and Villages in collaboration with the lands were first included in the Adirondack North Country Association. Research was definition of the park in 1912. conducted to gather information about the park from the perspective of community leaders within the “Blue Line” The Adirondack Park and from outside data sources. The intent of the project represents one-fifth of is to provide a factual baseline quantifying various trends New York’s land area, and for use in strategic planning and assessment updates. includes less than one percent The final report marks the culmination of a sizable of the state’s total population. research project involving the 103 towns and villages that comprise the park. As an area recognized for its unique Two-thirds of all ecological qualities, the park includes diverse communities state-owned lands in amid abundant state-owned lands constitutionally New York State are in the protected as “forever wild.” The report, along with its Adirondack Park. appendices, will provide a factual basis for ensuing discussion on park issues and planning. A deliberate Ninety percent of effort was made to avoid excessive interpretation or to arrive at conclusions, beyond the obvious. the Adirondack Forest Preserve is located in just 40 percent of the towns Findings in the Adirondack Park.

he results of the research effort affirm The Office of Real Property how Adirondack communities share in the Services lists 76 percent of Tchallenge of providing services for their residents the Adirondacks as “Wild, and visitors, while simultaneously serving as gateways Forested, Conservation to the park’s public lands. The findings from the Lands and Public Parks.” assessment provide important information with respect to community life, park demographics, education, Responses from local government, emergency services, land use and community leaders to the infrastructure. APRAP Community Survey show that while they generally respect DEC & APA staff, they often disagree with the policies guiding these agencies.

continued on page vi

May 2009 • Adirondack Park Regional Assessment Project [] Executive Summary what we found From 1980 to 2006, real Implications for the Park property tax as a portion of total revenue has decreased in he APRAP report provides a comparative the average Adirondack baseline and detailed picture of the park. Many in-park trends differ from the rest of New York State, Park community. T even in other rural areas. The decline in school enrollment is steeper and the median age of the population is rising Individuals with mailing addresses more rapidly than elsewhere. Household incomes are outside the park own lower than in much of New York State. There is an out- about 40 percent of the migration of young families and an in-migration of semi- parcels listed as residential which retired and retired persons. Approximately 40 percent of constitute half of the total the homes are owned by people whose primary residence residential property value. is outside of the Blue Line. The mines and mills of the Adirondacks are largely shuttered. Sparse populations and Government sector jobs account regulatory practices have contributed to a lag in private for more than 30 percent of all sector investment of broadband communication and data employment in Hamilton, Essex, transfer infrastructure. The park-wide loss of private sector Lewis and Washington counties. jobs has been offset temporarily by job increases in public In 2007, an estimated 44 health care, education and government employment. percent of employees The study provides essential information for the worked in the public discussion of the following issues: sector in Franklin County. These jobs do not include  How to provide quality employment in places that employment in public education. have suitable development opportunities inside the Blue Line? The regional economy is highly  What is the effect of continued state land acquisitions, dependent on correctional the use of easements, and private land use regulations on services. One of every 26 the social fabric and economy of park communities? people counted as living in the Adirondack Park resides in a correctional facility.

There are more than 5,000 miles of public roads in the park, half of which are maintained by the towns and villages. State and county highways make up the remainder in roughly equal amounts. Nine New York State Scenic Byways traverse the park.

continued on page vii

[vi] Adirondack Park Regional Assessment Project • May 2009 Executive Summary what we found Only 7 park communities have complete cell phone The obvious need to merge long-term economic coverage, while the remainder revitalization with environmental protection must occur have limited or no service at all. soon for the towns and villages within the Adirondack Park. Bold new strategies and investment will be required to address the complex needs of communities within Park residents average just a protected landscape. Such strategies must support under 43 years of age, sustainable development of communities consistent with older than any state for median age. both quality of life and environmental stewardship. The By 2020, only the west coast of data presented assesses the need for targeted and timely Florida will exceed the Adirondacks utilization of resources to address the questions listed above as the oldest region in America. and to drive the planning process to meet the fundamental needs of the people of the Adirondack Park. In the park, K-12 students represent 13.5 percent of the population, as compared to 18 percent nationally.

School enrollments in the park have decreased by 329 students annually throughout the current decade, which is equivalent to the loss of one average size Adirondack school district every 19 months.

The Saranac Lake School District (1,536 students) covers an area nearly the size of Suffolk County (69 districts and 254,629 students).

From 1970 to 2007, the number of teachers in Adirondack school districts increased by 34 percent, while the student population dropped by 31 percent.

May 2009 • Adirondack Park Regional Assessment Project [vii] About The Study he Adirondack Associa- appendices. Their skills were evident Due to the fact that a third of the tion of Towns and Villages, throughout the charting, mapping towns and most of the counties of T the Adirondack North and analysis of enormous amounts of the park are divided by the park Country Association, and the Towns data. Outreach and interviews were boundary, data related to those of Chester and Arietta partnered conducted with town and village communities partially within the in securing funding for this project officials, school superintendents, park was especially difficult to through the NYS Department of and emergency service coordinators. collect and assess. All efforts were State Quality Communities Grant Eighty-five communities completed made to aggregate data specific to Program. Matching funds were the Community Survey, while the towns and villages of the park. provided by the park communities. several state agencies contributed Donations from Stewart’s Shops and valuable information, including Extensive demographic, finance the Arrow Financial Corporation the Adirondack Park Agency, the and socio-economic data for every made it possible to extend research Office of Real Property Services, community in the park is presented in certain critical areas. The project the Department of Environmental in 103 individual municipal was managed by the partner organi- Conservation, the Department profiles. Printed and digital copies zations sharing a common interest in of Labor, the Department of of the profiles, project report and “fact-based” analysis as a foundation Education and the Department of appendices, including a digital for all future policy discussions. Correctional Services. The Siena database, are available at the Research Institute, the Center for Adirondack Association of Towns The LA Group was responsible Government Research, and the and Villages, at www.aatvny.org. for an extensive study of secondary Technical Assistance Center at –The APRAP Steering Committee data sources. They produced SUNY-Plattsburgh also played the Community Survey, a Final important roles in providing and Report, the community profiles and analyzing data.

AATV

This project was made possible with funding from the NYS Department of State Coastal Resources Division through the Quality Communities Grant Program.

[viii] Adirondack Park Regional Assessment Project • May 2009