Maine History Volume 45 Number 3 Maine Culture, High and Low Article 6 12-1-2010 Book Reviews Stanley R. Howe Bethel Historical Society Charles Horne Christian P. Potholm Bowdoin College David Chaplin Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.library.umaine.edu/mainehistoryjournal Recommended Citation Howe, Stanley R., Charles Horne, Christian P. Potholm, and David Chaplin. "Book Reviews." Maine History 45, 3 (2010): 291-304. https://digitalcommons.library.umaine.edu/mainehistoryjournal/vol45/iss3/6 This Book Reviews is brought to you for free and open access by DigitalCommons@UMaine. It has been accepted for inclusion in Maine History by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@UMaine. For more information, please contact [email protected]. BOOK REVIEWS Landscape with Figures: Nature & Culture in New England. By Kent C. Ryden. (Iowa City: University of Iowa Press, 2001. Pp. 317. Paper $19.95.); and Imagining New England: Explorations of Regional Identity from the Pilgrims to the Mid-Twentieth Century. By Joseph A. Conforti. (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2001. Pp. 384. Paper $19.95.) These two important books by faculty members of the American and New England Studies Program at the University of Southern Maine pro- vide significant insights into the New England past and how it has been interpreted through the centuries. For those focusing on Maine as part of the New England historical dynamic, there is much to be learned and analyzed here. In Landscape with Figures, Kent Ryden conducts a personal tour of noteworthy transitions in the world we associate with New England. His work is strongly influenced by that of William Cronon regarding the meaning of wilderness, virgin land, and the level of human influence upon the natural world. Ryden characterizes his study as a quest to de- velop his “historical, topographical, and ecocritical sensibility” (page 201). Maine readers will be interested in his review of Henry David Thoreau’s three trips to the northern part of the Pine Tree State. An ac- complished surveyor and map maker, Thoreau masterfully combined these two pursuits with his keen observation skills and polished literary style to create his posthumously published The Maine Woods. Ryden an- alyzes Thoreau’s assessment of the human impact upon this portion of Maine and draws his own conclusions about the role of logging in the course of the state’s history. From Thoreau, Ryden explores changes in the landscape by walking with Walter Hale on Hale’s farm in Sebago, Maine. Inspecting stone dumps, a charcoal kiln site, and the impact of dairy cow operations, the author came to appreciate the use of the land for agricultural and eco- nomic purposes. By the time of Ryden’s writing, most of the land had re- Maine History 45:3 December 2010 Maine History turned to forest, and it was only through Hale’s interpretation that the signs of past activity could be correctly and comprehensively “read” for their cultural, financial, and ecological implications. Another Maine example of the importance of landscape and its his- torical significance is the Cumberland and Oxford Canal, which opened in 1830 and was largely abandoned by 1872. Designed to connect the Portland waterfront to the Sebago Lake region, this transportation link was supposed to be a boon for trade, but from the beginning it was plagued with financial shortages and competition from rail interests. Ry- den observes the relics of this once busy technological marvel (which overcame formidable natural obstacles), including the ruins of the locks, depressed areas filled with stagnant water, abandoned tow-paths, and stone abutments lying forlorn in forested locations. One final example of a Maine operation, in this case made possible by the presence of the canal, was the gunpowder mill at Gambo Falls in Gorham. The sulfur and saltpeter arrived by canal boat from Portland, and charcoal was obtained from the nearby forest. Both the canal and the gunpowder mill, once symbols of the power of technology and man’s attempt to alter the course of nature, are now obscure survivals hidden by forest growth and largely re-conquered by natural forces.“Places have valuable lessons to teach us” notes Ryden, if the observer is willing to tread the fine line between the natural and cultural. Joseph A. Conforti’s thoughful Imagining New England offers a num- ber of observations and conclusions that will give the historian pause. Conforti begins by asserting that New England “developed as America’s first strongly imagined region” due to “its early historical consciousness and high rate of literacy and cultural production.” Early on, Puritanism gained a powerful imaginative hold on the region, but changes in the re- lationship with old England and in colonial living conditions led even- tually to a Revolutionary generation that possessed “the most well-de- veloped collective identity of any American region.” In the antebellum period, New Englanders intensified their cultural distinctiveness. During the middle years of the nineteenth century, emphasis on Yankee values, celebration of the Pilgrims, and the ordering of the New England village, among other influences, came into vogue. Following the Civil War, the Colonial Revival inspired confidence among Yankee traditionalists faced with rising foreign immigration and industrial and urban pressures. In the twentieth century, the “imaginary center” of authentic New England moved in a northerly direction, to what Conforti terms “Old New Eng- land.” To some observers, New England appeared to be in decline after Book Reviews World War II, but that was not the case. As the century wore on, the rise of the high technology and electronics industries was accompanied by creation of several important historical institutions, such as Plimouth Plantation, Old Sturbridge Village, and Strawberry Banke, which in- creased our knowledge of the New England experience. Readers intent on learning how Maine fits into these generalizations will not be disappointed. Beginning with Capt. John Smith’s characteri- zation of the Maine coast as a “country rather to affright than delight,”to Jedediah Morse’s view of Maine people as “hardy” and “robust,” to Tim- othy Dwight’s vision of a place with “dissolute characters” such as log- gers and fishermen, to Robert Herrick’s declaration in the 1920s that Maine was the new heartland of the Old New England, there is a steady cultural evolution according to Conforti. The rise of tourism after the Civil War brought the lobster into vogue as a much appreciated delicacy. The Maine coast was celebrated in the paintings of Thomas Cole, Fred- eric Church, Fitz Henry Lane, and Winslow Homer. In addition, Con- forti focuses on Old York as an outstanding example of the gentrifica- tion of a once-neglected coastal village — a premier exemplar of the colonial revival. Finally, Conforti uses examples from Robb Sagendorph’s Yankee magazine, which in the 1930s became strongly anti-New Deal, holding up Mane and Vermont after the 1936 presidential vote as the embodi- ment of “authentic” Yankee values. He even proposed a Yankee party, while his magazine emphasized the glory of the Maine coast, the success of L.L. Bean’s business, the writings of native son Robert P. Tristram Coffin, and John Gould’s celebration of the Pine Tree State’s town meet- ing tradition. All of the above and much more awaits the reader attempting to comprehend the New England experience in its national context and hoping to celebrate Maine’s part in keeping the New England tradition alive and well. STANLEY R. HOWE Bethel Historical Society Maine History A Good and Wise Measure: The Search for the American-Canadian Boundary, 1783-1842. By Francis M. Carroll. (Buffalo, New York: Univer- sity of Toronto Press, 2001. Pp. xxi + 462. Cloth $70. Paper $29.95.) Much has been written on the boundary dispute between Canada and the United States following the Treaty of Paris of 1783. The north- east portion of that boundary, which affected Maine so centrally, was part of this struggle, which was eventually settled by the 1842 Webster- Ashburton Treaty. Up until the publication of this book, Howard Jones’s To the Webster-Ashburton Treaty: A Study in Anglo-American Relations, 1783-1843 (1977) was considered the defining work on the subject, but Francis Carroll has provided new information and an enlarged perspec- tive that sheds additional light on the topic. Specifically, Carroll focuses on the labors of the land surveyors who were so essential in documenting the case for each side. He also exam- ines closely the search for distinguishing features that indicated the boundary, around which so much controversy raged. Using cartographic and testimonial evidence, Carroll follows the relationship between sur- veyors and those who evaluated their progress. Rich in detail, the book also provides the most comprehensive bibliography available on the boundary settlement, which will be of interest to those concerned with primary sources and recent scholarship. For Maine readers, there is much to contemplate, since the northeast boundary that separated this state from New Brunswick and Quebec was such an integral part of the Webster-Asburton negotiations. From the Treaty of 1783, which was supposed to establish Maine’s eastern and northern boundary, to the various attempts at determining the bound- ary following the War of 1812, then on to the arbitration of the King of the Netherlands, and finally to the threat of the Aroostook County “Pork and Bean War,” which precipitated a renewed effort to end chances of hostilities between the British and the Americans, this controversy has attracted the attention of a number of historians, writers and scholars. These include, but are not limited to J. Chris Arndt, J. R. Baldwin, Samuel F. Bemis, Henry S. Burrage, Albert B.