DOCSLIB.ORG

Coversheet for Thesis in Sussex Research Online

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Coversheet for Thesis in Sussex Research Online A University of Sussex DPhil thesis Available online via Sussex Research Online: http://sro.sussex.ac.uk/ This thesis is protected by copyright which belongs to the author. This thesis cannot be reproduced or quoted extensively from without first obtaining permission in writing from the Author The content must not be changed in any way or sold commercially in any format or medium without the formal permission of the Author When referring to this work, full bibliographic details including the author, title, awarding institution and date of the thesis must be given Please visit Sussex Research Online for more information and further details The nature of growth: The postwar history of the economy, energy and the environment Richard Lane PhD in International Relations University of Sussex September 2014 I hereby declare that this thesis has not been and will not be, submitted in whole or in part to another University for the award of any other degree. Signature:.................................................................................... Table of contents Acknowledgements 1 1. Research Summary 2 2. Introduction 3 3. The promiscuous history of the economy, energy and environment 11 The natural history of the great acceleration 13 Promiscuous history: relationality, performativity, translation 18 The national economy 23 Economy and growth 28 The promiscuous history of growth 33 4. Economy 36 The necessity of growth 38 The economy and the fear of postwar depression 39 Expansion economics and security 42 The scarcity of natural resources 44 Dewhurst, Malthus, and the postwar resource scarcity 45 Economy and scarcity: the postwar fears over growth 48 Resources for Freedom, resources for growth 50 The Paley report and the concern with growth 52 Scarcity and reserves 54 The Paley approach 59 Resources For the Future and scarcity 61 Growth and conservation 62 Resources For the Future 64 The death of absolute resource scarcity 67 The growth of the economy 71 5. Energy 76 Economy and energy 79 The system of energy 79 The postwar energy for growth 81 Oil and the international economy 85 Flows of oil, flows of money 85 The high price of cheap Middle Eastern oil 89 The domestic US basis of expanding foreign production 91 Energy and the threat from peak oil 94 Atoms for the economy 95 Hubbert and peak oil 97 Peak production and the threat to oil 99 Overcoming Hubbert’s peak 102 Oiling the system of energy 106 The restriction and expansion of oil 106 Securing the history and future of oil 109 The oil industry becomes the energy industry 112 The energy for growth 115 6. Environment 119 The benefits and costs of water 121 The Army Corps of Engineers and multiple-purpose water development 122 The search for consistency 126 The Green Book 128 Welfare economics, efficiency, and the conservationist backlash 130 Bringing welfare to water Making a portable economic technology 131 Making a portable economic technology 136 National efficiency and the conservationist backlash 138 The polluted Spaceship Earth 141 Pollution becomes pervasive 142 The coming Spaceship Earth 145 Environmental limits and the antigrowth movement 149 Nixon and NEPA 150 The limits to air pollution 153 The antigrowth movement 156 The environment and The Limits to Growth 158 7. The nature of growth 162 The sudden fragility of energy 164 The energy crisis 166 Energy price rises 168 The environment of economics 171 Water quality and the expansion of economic valuation 172 Materials Balance and pollution as externality 176 The economics of the new environment 179 The new limits to growth 182 Energy, economy, and the new limits to growth 183 Environmental economics and the Clean Air Act’s growth ban 188 The economic impact of environmental regulation 190 8. Conclusion: The economy, energy, environment and the nature of 192 growth References 200 Acknowledgements This thesis would not exist without the generous support, often in the face of outrageous provocation, of my supervisors Samuel Knafo, Pete Newell and in a previous incarnation, Jan Selby. As usual, Matthieu Hughes, Steffan Wyn Jones, and most of all, my bruv, Sahil Dutta have read and commented on everything I’ve written. In some cases numerous times. My thanks also go to Mareike Beck, Earl Gammon, Ben Stephan, Arno Simmons and Mat Paterson for thoughtful feedback at various points throughout this process. Niamh Kelly’s (apparently) near-endless generosity, support and love have enabled me to retain some semblance of sanity in the face of the vast and indifferent cyclopean horror of the PhD process. And Lola, who has been a constant source of joy, even though she’s too young to read this. And a dog. This work was financially supported by an ESRC studentship. And Niamh Kelly. Again. !1 1. Research Summary The environment and energy have been fundamental to the growth of the economy. This looks like a straightforward claim. But it is not. In order to understand how these are related, how growth came to be associated with the economy, and how this growth came to be seen as the unshakeable fundament of any environmental politics, this thesis focuses on a brief period of largely postwar history, and almost exclusively on a single country - America. At this time, and in this place, the technical removal of material constraints, the provision of energy, the construction of environmental limits and then their dismantling, forms the complex history of the growth of the environment and the environment of growth. This history created both the possibility of the contemporary political economy of the environment as well as its limits. This thesis traces the way that the economy, energy and the environment were co-constructed, transformed and interwoven in the US from the postwar years through to the mid 1970s, through the assembling, application and reassembling of the economic techniques and technologies that defined growth, scarcity and efficiency. To this end, it orients itself around the impacts of the 1952 President’s Materials Policy Commission - known as the Paley Commission, and the think tank that was set up in its wake: Resources For the Future (RFF). The Paley Commission report and the RFF would, through their technical innovations play a key role in the construction of the economy as a separate, measurable and observable sphere of monetary flows, driven by an associated logic of exponential growth; energy as an interchangeable system of sources powering this economy; and the environment, initially as encompassing the economy and defined by finite limits, then reconstructed as external to the economy and where pollution is considered as an example of market failure to be rectified by the internalisation of externalities. !2 2. Introduction The environment and energy have been fundamental to the growth of the economy. This looks like a straightforward claim. But it is not. In order to understand how these are related, how growth came to be associated with the economy, how energy was understood as powering growth, and how this growth came to be seen as the unshakeable fundament of any environmental politics, this thesis focuses on a brief, quarter century period - from around 1950 to 1975 - of almost exclusively US history. At this time, and in this place, the ‘great acceleration’, the sudden postwar speeding up of economic growth, oil consumption and environmental despoliation (Steffen, Crutzen & McNeill 2007) began. This thesis tells the story of the complex, promiscuous nature of postwar growth, and how the great acceleration was initiated through the technical removal of material constraints on the economy beginning in the 1950s, the provision of a system of energy, the subsequent construction of environmental limits and then their dismantling during the 1970s. This process created both the possibility of the contemporary political economy of the environment as well as its limits, and in order to understand this brief period of history, I will begin with a letter. W. Stuart Symington had only been Chairman of the US National Security Resources Board (NSRB) for nine months when, in December 1950, he wrote to President Truman to formally propose a Presidential Commission on the state of the nation’s material resources. Symington, echoing the prevalent fears at the time, stated: [t]here is nothing more important to the future security of the United States than obtaining, now and in the future, an adequate supply of those raw materials necessary to build up our defences and maintain our economy. Already in many cases shortages of such materials are serious, and in some cases critical (cited in Goodwin 1981a:52-53) !3 These fears may have been prevalent in 1950, but they weren’t universally shared. For William S. Paley, the Columbia Broadcasting Service (CBS) Chairman, or ‘absentee landlord’ as he was known, given his tendency towards long and increasingly frequent vacations, boredom was a more pressing concern. Paley had been having trouble reengaging with the day-to-day running of his broadcasting company since his return from the second world war; and by 1950, Paley’s restlessness and ennui had been noticed by Frank Stanton, the CBS President. Stanton found Paley’s predicament perplexing, and was even more surprised when Paley’s wife, Babe, one day arrived at his office and declared immediately “We’ve got to do something about finding something interesting for Bill to do. He’s Bored” (cited in Smith 1990:311). Some time after Babe’s visit, Stanton was contacted by his old friend, Harry Truman. President Truman was looking for someone to head the commission proposed by Symington to analyse the nation’s natural resources, and Stanton, with Babe’s concern in mind, suggested Paley. And even more curiously than the palindromic quality of Babe’s phrasing, the something that Stanton found for Paley to do - Chair what would become the President’s Materials Policy Commission (PMPC), commonly referred to as the Paley Commission - turned out to be a rather interesting something indeed.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Select Bibliography and Websites
    Select Bibliography and Websites 1. Primary Sources • Shakespeare quotations in the text are taken from The Complete Works of William Shakespeare (The Alexander text), published by Collins, 1951; 1981. • The Arden editions of the individual plays are usually worth buying for their extensive and often perceptive introductions. They are published by Thomson Learning. The website is at: http://www.ardenshakespeare.com • Shakespeare's Sonnets can also be read in the Arden edition, edited by Katherine Duncan-Jones, Thomson Learning, 1997. A. William of Stratford • William of Stratford's 'signatures' can be seen at: http://www.nationalarchives. gov.uk/museum/ • Documents on the life of William of Stratford can be read in David Thomas: Shakespeare in the Public Records, HMSO, 1985; Robert Bearman: Shakespeare in the Stratford Records, Alan Sutton, 1994; and Samuel Schoenbaum: William Shakespeare: A Documentary Life, Oxford, 1975. • Documents on William's life can also be read online at: http://fly.hiwaay.net/ ~paul/shakspere/evidence1.html or: http://www.william-shakespeare.info/william-shakespeare-facts.htm There are more than 100 references to William and his family in the public records—the product of assiduous research, especially in the 20th century. But, apart from wills, baptism, marriage and death certificates, they relate largely to acting, business, financial and legal matters. They indicate that he was an actor, that he was reluctant to pay his taxes, that he was a maltster, and that he was a moneylender who was quick to sue for debt. There is absolutely nothing in these records to connect him with the authorship of the works ascribed to him: no manuscripts of plays or poems; no letters to friends; no notes; no anecdotes about his writing; and no references to books or a library.
    [Show full text]
  • Treason and the State: Law, Politics, and Ideology in the English Civil War D
    This page intentionally left blank Treason and the State This study traces the transition of treason from a personal crime against the monarch to a modern crime against the impersonal state. It consists of four highly detailed case studies of major state treason trials in England beginning with that of Thomas Wentworth, First Earl of Strafford, in the spring of 1641 and ending with that of Charles Stuart, King of England, in January 1649. The book examines how these trials constituted practical contexts in which ideas of statehood and public authority legitimated courses of political action that might ordi- narily be considered unlawful – or at least not within the compass of the foundational statute of 25 Edward III. The ensuing narrative reveals how the events of the 1640s in England challenged existing conceptions of treason as a personal crime against the king, his family and his servants, and pushed the ascendant parliamentarian faction toward embracing an impersonal conception of the state that perceived public authority as completely independent of any individual or group. d. alan orr was educated at Queen’s University at Kingston, the University of Glasgow and the University of Cambridge, where he received his Ph.D. in 1997. He has taught subsequently at Carleton University in Ottawa and Queen’s University at Kingston. Cambridge Studies in Early Modern British History Series editors anthony fletcher Victoria County History, Institute of Historical Research, University of London john guy Professor of Modern History, University of St. Andrews and john morrill Professor of British and Irish History, University of Cambridge, and Vice-Master of Selwyn College This is a series of monographs and studies covering many aspects of the history of the British Isles between the late fifteenth century and the early eighteenth century.
    [Show full text]
  • Bibliographical Contributions
    BIBLIOGRAPHICAL CONTRIBUTIONS 2 UNIVERSITY OF KANSAS LIBRARIES 1976 University of Kansas Publications Library Series, 40 Copy for the title-page of the projected third edition of Pierre-Louis Roederer's Adresse d'un constitutionnel aux constitutionnels (see first article) BIBLIOGRAPHICAL CONTRIBUTIONS 2 UNIVERSITY OF KANSAS LIBRARIES Lawrence, Kansas 1976 PRINTED IN LAWRENCE, KANSAS, U.S.A., BY THE UNIVERSITY OF KANSAS PRINTING SERVICE Contents Pierre-Louis Roederer and the Adresse d'un Constitutionnel aux Constitutionnels (1835): Notes on a recent acquisition. By CHARLES K. WARNER The "Secret Transactions" of John Bowring and Charles I in the Isle of Wight: a Reappraisal. By ALLAN J. BUSCH Catesby, Curll, and Cook: or, The Librarian and the 18th Cen• tury English Book. By ALEXANDRA MASON Pierre-Louis Roederer and The Adresse d'un Constitutionnel Aux Constitutionnels (1835): Notes on a Recent Acquisition CHARLES K. WARNER In 1832, Louis-Philippe, King of the French since the July Revolution of 1830, appointed Count Pierre-Louis Roederer, an aging but still ener• getic notable of the Revolutionary and Napoleonic eras, to the Chamber of Peers, the upper house of France's new parliament. In February 1835, during what was to be his eighty-second and last year, Roederer published a small pamphlet, Adresse d'un constitutionnel aux constitutionnels, which burst like an embarrassing bombshell in the middle of the worst ministerial crisis of the July Monarchy's early years.1 Briefly, Roederer's pamphlet fustigated the efforts of such parliamentary leaders as Thiers, De Broglie and Guizot to obtain a ministry in some degree responsible to parliament and, more immediately, the right for the cabinet to meet apart from the King.
    [Show full text]
  • Liber Famelicus
    LIBER FAMELICUS. THIS book I began to write in, the 18 April 1609, anno 7 Jacobi regni sui Anglise, et Scotise 42. In it I en tend to set downe roemorialls for my posterity of thinges most properly concerning myself and my familye. Oculis in solem, alis in coelum. Motto de cognisance.* Vive diu Whitlocke, tuis sic utere fatis Vt referent sensus alba nee atra tuos. JAMES WHITELOCKE. My father RICHARD WHITELOCK: was the fourthe sun of Richard Whitelock, and was born in the ancient seat of the Whitelocks, called Beeches, situate neer Okingham, a market towne in the countye of Barkes, whiche land hathe continued in our blud sithence the year of our Lord 1231; for it appeerethe by a deed in my cosen William f Whitelockes hand of Beches that Robert J then bishop of Salisburye, who was lord of the manor of Sunning neer Okingham, did give to William de la Beche, out of his purpres- ture§ of Bear Wood, that verye land my cosen William Whitelock now holdethe by discent from his father, and he bathe the originall • This "motto of cognisance" refers to the arms borne by the Whitelocke family, a chevron between three falcons, or, as they are called in one pedigree, three eagles, and the crest, a like bird rising out of a tower. +• My father's elder brother's son, and heir of the family ; William the eldest being ded without issue. Note by the writer of the MS. J Robert de Bingham, bishop of Salisbury 1228—1246. § Inclosure. CAMD. 8OC. B 2 LIBER FAMELICUS.
    [Show full text]
  • Acq. by Mar. Early 18Th C., Built Mid-18Th C., Sold 1914) Estates: 4528 (I) 2673
    742 List of Parliamentary Families Seat: Prehen, Londonderry (acq. by mar. early 18th c., built mid-18th c., sold 1914) Estates: 4528 (I) 2673 Knox [Gore] Origins: Descended from an older brother of the ancestor of the Earls of Ranfurly. Mary Gore, heiress of Belleek Manor (descended from a brother of the 1 Earl of Arran, see Gore), married Francis Knox of Rappa. One of their sons succeeded to Rappa and another took the additional name Gore and was seated at Belleek. 1. Francis Knox – {Philipstown 1797-1800} 2. James Knox-Gore – {Taghmon 1797-1800} Seats: Rappa Castle, Mayo (Knox acq. mar. Gore heiress 1761, family departed 1920s, part demolished 1937, ruin); Moyne Abbey, Mayo (medieval, burned 1590, partly restored, acq. mid-17th c., now a ruin); Belleek Manor (Abbey, Castle), Mayo (rebuilt 1831, sold c. 1942, hotel) Estates: Bateman 30592 (I) 11082 and at Rappa 10722 (I) 2788 (five younger sons given 1,128 acres worth £408 pa each in mid-19th c.) Title: Baronet 1868-90 1 Ld Lt 19th Knox Origins: Cadet of the Rappa line. 1. John Knox – {Dongeal 1761-68 Castlebar 1768-74} 2. Lawrence Knox – Sligo 1868-69 Seat: Mount Falcon, Mayo (acq. 19th c., built 1876, sold 20th c., hotel) Estates: Bateman 5589 (I) 2246. Still owned 93 acres in 2001. LA TOUCHE IRELAND Origins: Huguenot refugees who came from Amsterdam to Ireland with William III’s army. One fought at the Boyne. Sheriff 1797. They operated a poplin factory in Dublin from 1694 and then became bankers (1712) and country gentlemen simultaneously in the 18th and 19th centuries.
    [Show full text]
  • Wills from Doctors' Commons. a Selection from the Wills of Eminent
    UC-NRLF B 3 MflD fiMS J?.^. WILLS FEOM DOCTORS' COMMONS. A SELECTION THE WILLS OF EMINENT PEESONS PROVED IN THE PREROGATIVE COURT OF CANTERBURY, 1495-1695. EDITED BY JOHN GOUGH NICHOLS AND JOHN BRUCE. UNIVFli PRINTED FOR THE CAMDEN SOCIETY. M.DCCC.LXIII. ^ 8 83 WESTMINSTER : PRINTED BY JOHN BOWYER NICHOLS AND SONS, 25, PARLIAMENT STREET. ?^'y' [no. lxxxiii.] COUNCIL OF THE CAMDEN SOCIETY FOR THE YEAR 1862-63. President, THE MOST HON. THE MARQUESS OF BRISTOL, V.P.S.A. ARTHUR ASHPITEL, ESQ. F.S.A. WILLIAM HENRY BLAAUW, ESQ. M.A., F.S.A. Treanurer. BERIAH BOTFIELD, ESQ. M.P. F.R.S. F.S.A. JOHN BRUCE, ESQ. F.S.A. Director. WILLIAM DURRANT COOPER, ESQ. F.S.A. JAIilES CROSBY, ESQ. F.S.A. JOHN FORSTER, ESQ. LL.D. THE REV. LAMBERT B. LARKING, M.A. JOHN MACLEAN, ESQ. F.S.A. FREDERIC OUVRY, ESQ. Treas.S.A. EVELYN PHILIP SHIRLEY, ESQ. M.P. M.A. F.S.A. WILLIAM JOHN THOMS, ESQ. F.S.A. Secretary. WILLIAM TITE, ESQ. M.P. F.R.S. F.S.A. ALBERT WAY, ESQ. M.A. F.S.A. HIS EXCELLENCY M. VAN DE WEYER,D.C.L., Hon. F.S.A The Council of the Camden Society desire it to be under- stood that they are not answerable for any opinions or observa- tions that may appear in the Society's publications; the Editors of the several Works being alone responsible for the same. INTEODUCTION. " Wills feom Doctors' Commons." Wills from an office, of which it was said, not without reason, in a volume published by the Camden Society in 1853, that it was believed to be the only de- pository of historical documents, if not the only office of any kind, in the kingdom, in which there
    [Show full text]
  • Lives of Eminent Serjeants-At-Law of the English
    This is a reproduction of a library book that was digitized by Google as part of an ongoing effort to preserve the information in books and make it universally accessible. https://books.google.com II I I I .Ml J I I I M I 3 3433 00866722 6 ■. Hv>:N^x LIVES OF EMINENT SERJEANTS-AT-LAW. LIVES OK EMINENT SERJEANTS-AT-LAW OV TUB ENGLISH BAR. BY HUMPHRY WILLIAM WOOLKYCtf, Serjeant-aULaw. IN TWO VOLUMES. „ - . .*. VOL. I. ' ";':: ;D:' ^' / LONDON: Wm. H. ALLEN & CO., 13, WATERLOO PLACE, PALL MALL. 8.W. 18G9. i D0»SEP13/'i Lew1s & Son, Printers, Swan Bu1ldings, Moorgalc Street. TO THE RIGHT HONOURABLE EARL OF DERBY, K.G., HER MAJESTY'S MOST HONOURABLE PRIVY COUNCIL. Chancellor of tjjt Unibttsits of ftgftrt, "LIVES OF EMINENT SERJEANTS,? WITH HIS LOHDSHIP S PF.11MISSIOK, ARE RESPECTFULLY DEDICATED. LIST OF THE SERJEANTS CONTAINED IN THESE LIVES. 1. ADAIR. 30. HOSKINS. 2. BARHAM. 31. KELYNG. 3. BARNARDI8TON. 32. LEEDS. 4. BENDLOES. 33. LENS. 5. BOND, NATHANIEL. 34. MAYNARD. 6. BOND, GEORGE. 35. METHOLD. 7. BONYTHON. 36. MORE. 8. CALLICE. 37. ONSLOW. 9. CARTHEW. 38. PELL. 10. CHAUNCEY. 39. PLOWDEN. 11. CHES8HYRE. 40. PRIME. 12. CONYERS, WILLIAM. 41. ROW. 13. CONYERS, TBISTRAM. 42. SALKELD. 14. CREW. 43. SELLON. 15. DARNALL, JOHN, Sek1ob. 44. SHEPHERD. 16. DARNALL, JOHN, JVNIOB. 45. SKINNER. 17. DAVYS. 46. SKIPWITH. 18. DAVY. 47. STRODE, GEORGE 19. FINCH. 48. STRODE, THOMAS 20. FLEETWOOD. 49. THOMPSON. 21. GLANVILK. 50. TOLLER. 22. GLYN. 51. TREMAINE. 23. HABDBES. 52. TRENCHARD. 24. HAWKINS. 53. WHITAKER. 25. HELE. 54. WHITLOCKE. 26. HEYWOOD. 55.
    [Show full text]
  • Squire Law Library Accessions List September 2015
    Squire Law Library Accessions List September 2015 CR.22.TL.2 Gids voor de rechtenstudie en juridische beroepen 2015-2016 / hoofdredacteur Dimitri Kolias. Amsterdam: Stichting Duc In Iura; Deventer: Wolters Kluwer Nederland, [2015] ISBN: 9789013126945 (pbk.) EN.9.A.2 Ayliffe, John, 1676-1732. Parergon juris canonici Anglicani: or, a commentary, by way of supplement to the canons and constitutions of the Church of England / by John Ayliffe. London: [s.n.], 1726. F.cc.9.L.31 Liu, Hin-Yan. Law's impunity: responsibility and the modern private military company / Hin-Yan Liu. Oxford, UK: Hart Publishing Ltd., 2015. ISBN: 9781849465168 (hbk.) F.hfm.9.F.3 Fox, Hazel. Law of state immunity / Hazel Fox CMG QC; Philippa Webb. Revised and updated third edition. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press, 2015. ISBN: 9780198744412 (pbk.) F.jg.9.P.2 Papanicolopulu, Irini. Il confine marino: unità o pluralità ? / Irini Papanicolopulu. Milano: Giuffre, 2005. ISBN: 8814121680 F.jmk.9.S.8 Prosecuting maritime piracy: domestic solutions to international crimes / edited by Michael P. Scharf, Michael A. Newton and Milena Sterio. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2015. ISBN: 9781107081222 (hbk.) F.nmp.9.G.3 Grange, Edward. Extradition law: a practitioner's guide / Edward Grange and Rebecca Niblock. Second edition. London: Legal Action Group, 2015. ISBN: 9781908407603 (pbk.) F.t.3.1.3 Luxembourg Workshop on Space and Satellite Communication Law (2nd) Dispute settlement in the area of space communication. 2nd Luxembourg Workshop on Space and Satellite Communication Law / Prof. Dr. Mahulena Hofmann (ed.). Baden-Baden: Nomos Verlagesellschaft, 2015. ISBN: 9783848718528 (hbk.) F.umg.9.H.3 Hagan, John.
    [Show full text]
  • Law, Language and the Printing Press in the Reign of Charles I
    Law, Language and the Printing Press in the Reign of Charles I: Explaining the Printing of the Common Law in English Ian Williams The common law became more accessible to non-specialists during the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. As Richard Ross observes, “[a]n Englishman not privy to the manuscripts and oral traditions of the London-based legal professional would have had an easier time in 1640 than in 1550 learning about the procedure and duties of the royal courts, the boundaries of political and property rights, and the lineaments of the constitution”.1 Existing scholarship has rightly identified the general shift towards the printing of the law in English.2 However, it has not identified an important change during Charles I’s reign, Associate Professor, Faculty of Laws, University College London. My thanks to audiences at the American Society for Legal History conference in Toronto, the Cambridge Centre for Legal History and the Oxford Legal History Seminar for their comments on earlier drafts. Contractions in primary sources have been silently expanded. Original spelling has been retained. 1 Richard J. Ross, “The Commoning of the Common Law: The Renaissance Debate over Printing English Law, 1520-1640,” University of Pennsylvania Law Review 146 (1998): 396, https://doi.org/10.2307/3312623. 2 E.g. Ross, ‘Commoning’ and David J. Harvey, The Law Emprynted and Englysshed: The Printing Press as an Agent of Change in Law and Legal culture 1475-1642 (Oxford: Hart Publishing, 2015). It should not be assumed that the movement of texts was always from print to manuscript. Incomplete printed texts might be finished in manuscript (see, e.g., G.J.
    [Show full text]
  • Impeachment, Attainder, and a True Constitutional Crisis: Lessons from the Strafford Trial Craig S
    REVIEW Impeachment, Attainder, and a True Constitutional Crisis: Lessons from the Strafford Trial Craig S. Lernert Proceedingsin the Opening Session of the Long Parliament:House of Commons and the Strafford Trial (Volume 3:22 March-17 April 1641). Maija Jansson, ed. University of Rochester Press, 2001. Pp xxxviii, 608. In the months that preceded President Clinton's impeachment trial, observers in the media breathlessly reported the so-called "death struggle" between the President and Kenneth Starr.' Distinguished academic commentators, such as Ronald Dworkin and Arthur Schlesinger, Jr., were equally overheated in their rhetoric, predicting that the President's impeachment would shred the American constitu- tional fabric.' Of course, Clinton was impeached, with no discernible unraveling of the regime. The immediate political stakes were high, to be sure, and both sides fought with energy-as a minor participant in the struggle, I can attest to that.3 But no lives, and very few persons' liberty, were ever in jeopardy and, contra Dworkin and Schlesinger, the U.S. Constitution was safe throughout the ordeal. If this all seems obvious to many now,4 I mention it only to note the disproportion be- t Assistant Professor, George Mason University School of Law. The author thanks Mi- chael Abramowicz, Frank Buckley, Philip Hamburger, Peter Hansen, Renee Lettow Lerner, Nel- son Lund, and Daniel Polsby. I See, for example, Jill Abramson, Baby Boomers; and There the Likeness Ceases, NY Times All (Feb 16,1998). 2 See The Committee for Censure, Not Impeachment, An Appeal to the US. Congressand the Public,NY Times A21 (Oct 7,1998) (including Dworkin and Schlesinger, Jr.
    [Show full text]
  • A Compleat History of the Late Septennial Parliament
    speciAL coLLecooNS tDOUQlAS LibRARy queeN's uNiveusiTy AT kiNQsroN klNqSTON ONTARIO CANAtiA A Com pleat H f^ T O R Y Of the Late Septennial Pariiamenf. W H E R E I If All their P rp c e,e q i n g s are particularly Brfquir'd into, and faitiituUy Related ; with proper Remarks; and many Secret Me- moir^, interfpers'd, concerning the late Times. To which is Prefix'd, Honeft A tTV I C E to the Freeholders of Great Britain- iii.—.: m, . LONDON'^ in rnter- Printed for J. Pehlt. at loc-^e'^-Head mfler-Roiv. M.DCC.X)fii. (Price One Shilling^ ficfii. /'7S';?.c6^ <iii) PREFACE. [HIS "Preface, to my Hiflory of the Septennial Parliament, is principally dejtgn^d foi" the Freeholders of England. And I hopcy after what I ha've covwiimicated to the Tuhlicky there will he 'very little occafiou for much to he faid^ to hiafs Ihem in the Choice of proper Reprefe/itatii'esy at the* approaching B^^ Uaio?i^ (iv) 7 think that they oiight^ in Juflice to "The7/ifeheSy to he 'very cantions i?i the JBjlc'cli7ig 7/ia7iy of our late Keprefenta- tices ; / would have them well coiifider of their paji^ 'Beha^viour-, before they n)en- tnre to chufe them again : they have al^ ready done Mi[chief fufficie72t^ and 7nore tha7i their Children, or eve7i their Qra7id-Childre7iy will ever fee Kerne- died' Sut as feveral Meinhers of the laft ^arlia7nc7it were 7nade by the worfi of Mea7is ; by iDouble a7id Falfe Ketur7is^ by Bribery, a7id every thing elfe that could proinife and foretell Miferies to the SuhjeB, what could we expeB but extraordinary and U7iprecede72tcd Tro- ceedi7tgs
    [Show full text]
  • County of Buckingham CALENDER to the SESSIONS RECORDS VOLUME II. 1694 to 1705 Edited by WILLIAM LE HARDY, M.C., F.S.A
    County of Buckingham CALENDER to the SESSIONS RECORDS VOLUME II. 1694 to 1705 Edited by WILLIAM LE HARDY, M.C., F.S.A. GEOFFREY LI. RECKITT, M.C., M.A. AYLESBURY: PubliShed by Guy R. Crouch, LL.B., Clerk of the Peace, County Hall. 1936 COMPILED UNDER THE DIRECTION OF THE STANDING JOINT COMMITTEE OF THE BUCKINGHAMSHIRE QUARTER SESSIONS AND COUNTY COUNCIL. [All RightS ReServed] Printed by HUNT, BARNARD & CO., LTD., AYLESBURY. CONTENTS PAGE Preface . .vii Schedule of Offences and PuniShmentS . xxxiv Calendar to the SeSSions Records, 1694 to 1705 1-453 Appendix I. JusticeS of the Peace, 1694 to 1705 . 454-456 Appendix II. SHERIFFS, 1694 to 1705 . 456 Index . 457 PREFACE ThiS preSent volume, which embraceS a period from MidSummer, 1694, to Epiphany, 1704- 05, and formS Volume II of the Calendar to the SeSSionS RecordS of the County of Buckingham, iS a continuation of the firSt volume of the series, published in 1933. Although only forty-three SesSionS have been covered, as againSt Sixty-four SeSSionS in the previous volume, the three Quarter SeSSionS BookS which have been calendared—BookS 4, 5, and 6—contain more pages in the original than the first three BookS, and, Starting from Easter, 1700, fifteen bundleS of the Quarter SeSSions RollS have been incorporated. It is obvious that only a Small proportion of the original SeSSions RollS haS been preServed, and it will be seen that they have not alwayS been collected into bundleS in the correct chrono- logical order. In moSt caSeS, the Rolls only confirm or supplement the entries from the SesSionS BookS, but in certain instances they do introduce new matter.
    [Show full text]