Steve Jobs: Mystery Patent Pool to Attack Ogg Theora Email Roasts 'Open Source' Codecs by Cade Metz in San Francisco Posted in Software, 30Th April 2010 20:11 GMT

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Steve Jobs: Mystery Patent Pool to Attack Ogg Theora Email Roasts 'Open Source' Codecs by Cade Metz in San Francisco Posted in Software, 30Th April 2010 20:11 GMT Steve Jobs: mystery patent pool to attack Ogg Theora Email roasts 'open source' codecs By Cade Metz in San Francisco Posted in Software, 30th April 2010 20:11 GMT Steve Jobs has apparently claimed that a patent pool is being assembled to "go after" Ogg Theora, the open source video codec used by the latest browsers from Google, Mozilla, and Opera. The claim was made in an email the Apple CEO appears to have sent in response to an open source software advocate who questioned Apple's attachment to the patented H.264 codec. On Thursday, Hugo Roy, an activist with the Free Software Foundation Europe, sent an email to Steve Jobs in response to the Apple CEO's much-discussed open letter on Adobe Flash. The note praised Jobs for his letter - in which he reiterated the company's commitment to HTML5 and other "open standards" - but Roy also made a point of telling Jobs that such talk of open standards should not include H.264. "May I remind you that H.264 is not an open standard?" Roy wrote in a missive also posted [http://blogs.fsfe.org/hugo/2010/04/open-letter-to-steve-jobs/comment-page- 1/#comment-72 ] to the web. "This video codec is covered by patents...This is why Mozilla Firefox and Opera have not adopted this video codec for their HTML5 implementation, and decided to choose Theora as a sustainable and open alternative." Roy sent his note to what is believed to be Steve Jobs' email address - [email protected] - and three hours later, he received a reply. "All video codecs are covered by patents," read the reply. "A patent pool is being assembled to go after Theora and other 'open source' codecs now. Unfortunately, just because something is open source, it doesn't mean or guarantee that it doesn't infringe on others patents. An open standard is different from being royalty free or open source." The email's headers indicate the message did indeed come from Jobs - the Apple boss has sent several emails of late that have turned up on the web - and Roy tells The Reg he has no reason to believe that the email is less than genuine. In the email, Jobs does not say who is assembling the alleged patent pool or what patents are involved or what "other 'open source' codecs" he's referring to. And it's unclear 1 From www.theregister.co.uk/2010/04/30/steve_jobs_claims_ogg_theora_attack/ 10 April 2011 whether Apple is part of the pool. But the prospect of such an attack is of grave concern the open source world. "Multimedia codecs are one of the worst patent minefields out there, enforcement is aggressive and there's no such thing as a video standard 100% unencumbered by patents," Florian Mueller, another open source advocate, says in an email to The Reg. "There are too many software patents out there to perform reliable clearance and patent offices often grant new patents on old ideas." Ogg Theora is based on the VP3 codec, which was released into the public domain by On2 Technologies in 2001 under an irrevocable free license. Mozilla, Google, and Opera tried to make it part of the HTML5 standard, but they faced hefty opposition from Apple. As it stands, the HTML5 video standard does not specify a codec, so browser makers are free to use whatever codec they like. Mozilla, Firefox, and Opera use Ogg. Apple's Safari uses H.264. Google uses both. And though Internet Explorer 8 does not support the HTML5 video tag, Microsoft will include H.264-happy HTML5 with IE9. Today, with a blog post [http://blogs.msdn.com/ie/archive/2010/04/29/html5-video.aspx], Microsoft also argued that the rights to "other codecs are less clear." Google recently acquired On2 Technologies, and it's rumored that the company will open source the latest On2 codec, VP8, to create a license-free codec that offers better performance than Ogg. Google has said that it hasn't adopted Ogg exclusively because it's not fast enough for a site like YouTube. H.264 is licensed by MPEG LA, which controls a patent pool around the technology, and Apple is a contributor to the H.264 patent pool. Presumably, in his email, Jobs is referring to some other pool. But it's worth noting that in the past, the MPEG LA has said [http://www.streamingmedia.com/Articles/ReadArticle.aspx?ArticleID=65782 ] it "believes" that Ogg infringes at least some of its patents. Apple has said in the past that it avoids Ogg because of an "uncertain patent landscape." But this is the first mention of a pool designed to "go after" the open source codec. The company has also indicated that it prefers H.264 because Ogg has limited hardware support. Even if you set the mystery patent pool claim to one side, the alleged Jobs email doesn't do much to clarify Apple's position. "I'm completed confused by it," Roy tells The Reg. The last sentence of the email - "an open standard is different from being royalty free or open source" - is a truth that doesn't really respond to what Roy was trying to say in his original note. And he questions why Jobs would even respond. But in recent days, the man has exhibited what would seem to be a compulsive tendency to answer his critics. 2 From www.theregister.co.uk/2010/04/30/steve_jobs_claims_ogg_theora_attack/ 10 April 2011 .
Recommended publications
  • Download Media Player Codec Pack Version 4.1 Media Player Codec Pack
    download media player codec pack version 4.1 Media Player Codec Pack. Description: In Microsoft Windows 10 it is not possible to set all file associations using an installer. Microsoft chose to block changes of file associations with the introduction of their Zune players. Third party codecs are also blocked in some instances, preventing some files from playing in the Zune players. A simple workaround for this problem is to switch playback of video and music files to Windows Media Player manually. In start menu click on the "Settings". In the "Windows Settings" window click on "System". On the "System" pane click on "Default apps". On the "Choose default applications" pane click on "Films & TV" under "Video Player". On the "Choose an application" pop up menu click on "Windows Media Player" to set Windows Media Player as the default player for video files. Footnote: The same method can be used to apply file associations for music, by simply clicking on "Groove Music" under "Media Player" instead of changing Video Player in step 4. Media Player Codec Pack Plus. Codec's Explained: A codec is a piece of software on either a device or computer capable of encoding and/or decoding video and/or audio data from files, streams and broadcasts. The word Codec is a portmanteau of ' co mpressor- dec ompressor' Compression types that you will be able to play include: x264 | x265 | h.265 | HEVC | 10bit x265 | 10bit x264 | AVCHD | AVC DivX | XviD | MP4 | MPEG4 | MPEG2 and many more. File types you will be able to play include: .bdmv | .evo | .hevc | .mkv | .avi | .flv | .webm | .mp4 | .m4v | .m4a | .ts | .ogm .ac3 | .dts | .alac | .flac | .ape | .aac | .ogg | .ofr | .mpc | .3gp and many more.
    [Show full text]
  • Ardour Export Redesign
    Ardour Export Redesign Thorsten Wilms [email protected] Revision 2 2007-07-17 Table of Contents 1 Introduction 4 4.5 Endianness 8 2 Insights From a Survey 4 4.6 Channel Count 8 2.1 Export When? 4 4.7 Mapping Channels 8 2.2 Channel Count 4 4.8 CD Marker Files 9 2.3 Requested File Types 5 4.9 Trimming 9 2.4 Sample Formats and Rates in Use 5 4.10 Filename Conflicts 9 2.5 Wish List 5 4.11 Peaks 10 2.5.1 More than one format at once 5 4.12 Blocking JACK 10 2.5.2 Files per Track / Bus 5 4.13 Does it have to be a dialog? 10 2.5.3 Optionally store timestamps 5 5 Track Export 11 2.6 General Problems 6 6 MIDI 12 3 Feature Requests 6 7 Steps After Exporting 12 3.1 Multichannel 6 7.1 Normalize 12 3.2 Individual Files 6 7.2 Trim silence 13 3.3 Realtime Export 6 7.3 Encode 13 3.4 Range ad File Export History 7 7.4 Tag 13 3.5 Running a Script 7 7.5 Upload 13 3.6 Export Markers as Text 7 7.6 Burn CD / DVD 13 4 The Current Dialog 7 7.7 Backup / Archiving 14 4.1 Time Span Selection 7 7.8 Authoring 14 4.2 Ranges 7 8 Container Formats 14 4.3 File vs Directory Selection 8 8.1 libsndfile, currently offered for Export 14 4.4 Container Types 8 8.2 libsndfile, also interesting 14 8.3 libsndfile, rather exotic 15 12 Specification 18 8.4 Interesting 15 12.1 Core 18 8.4.1 BWF – Broadcast Wave Format 15 12.2 Layout 18 8.4.2 Matroska 15 12.3 Presets 18 8.5 Problematic 15 12.4 Speed 18 8.6 Not of further interest 15 12.5 Time span 19 8.7 Check (Todo) 15 12.6 CD Marker Files 19 9 Encodings 16 12.7 Mapping 19 9.1 Libsndfile supported 16 12.8 Processing 19 9.2 Interesting 16 12.9 Container and Encodings 19 9.3 Problematic 16 12.10 Target Folder 20 9.4 Not of further interest 16 12.11 Filenames 20 10 Container / Encoding Combinations 17 12.12 Multiplication 20 11 Elements 17 12.13 Left out 21 11.1 Input 17 13 Credits 21 11.2 Output 17 14 Todo 22 1 Introduction 4 1 Introduction 2 Insights From a Survey The basic purpose of Ardour's export functionality is I conducted a quick survey on the Linux Audio Users to create mixdowns of multitrack arrangements.
    [Show full text]
  • Tamil Flac Songs Free Download Tamil Flac Songs Free Download
    tamil flac songs free download Tamil flac songs free download. Get notified on all the latest Music, Movies and TV Shows. With a unique loyalty program, the Hungama rewards you for predefined action on our platform. Accumulated coins can be redeemed to, Hungama subscriptions. You can also login to Hungama Apps(Music & Movies) with your Hungama web credentials & redeem coins to download MP3/MP4 tracks. You need to be a registered user to enjoy the benefits of Rewards Program. You are not authorised arena user. Please subscribe to Arena to play this content. [Hi-Res Audio] 30+ Free HD Music Download Sites (2021) ► Read the definitive guide to hi-res audio (HD music, HRA): Where can you download free high-resolution files (24-bit FLAC, 384 kHz/ 32 bit, DSD, DXD, MQA, Multichannel)? Where to buy it? Where are hi-res audio streamings? See our top 10 and long hi-res download site list. ► What is high definition audio capability or it’s a gimmick? What is after hi-res? What's the highest sound quality? Discover greater details of high- definition musical formats, that, maybe, never heard before. The explanation is written by Yuri Korzunov, audio software developer with 20+ years of experience in signal processing. Keep reading. Table of content (click to show). Our Top 10 Hi-Res Audio Music Websites for Free Downloads Where can I download Hi Res music for free and paid music sites? High- resolution music free and paid download sites Big detailed list of free and paid download sites Download music free online resources (additional) Download music free online resources (additional) Download music and audio resources High resolution and audiophile streaming Why does Hi Res audio need? Digital recording issues Digital Signal Processing What is after hi-res sound? How many GB is 1000 songs? Myth #1.
    [Show full text]
  • Detail Streaming Support Protocols
    Encore+ User Guide Detail Streaming Support Protocols Supported Audio Codecs Supported Container Formats • MP3 • WAV • AAC • M4A • FLAC • OGG • LPCM/WAV/AIFF • AIFF • ALAC Supported Protocols • WMA, WMA9 • SHOUTcast • Ogg Vorbis • HTTPS Supported Playlist • WMA streaming • ASX • RTSP/SDP • M3U • PLS • WPL 43 Detail Audio Codec Support Encore+ User Guide Supported MP3 encoding parameters • Sampling rates [kHz]: 32, 44.1, 48 • Resolution [bits]: 16 • Bit rate [kbps]: 32, 40, 48, 56, 64, 80, 96, 112, 128, 160, 192, 224, 256, 320, VBR • Channels: stereo, joined stereo, mono • MP3PRO playback • MP3 File extensions: *.mp3 • Decoding of ID3v1, ID3v2, MP3 ID tags including optional album art in .jpeg format up to 2 megapixels • Gapless MP3: Playback is gapless if the container provides LAME encoder delay and padding tags. Supported Vorbis encoding parameters • Sampling rates [kHz]: 32, 44.1, 48 • Resolution [bits]: 16 • Nominal bit rate [kbps] (quality level): 80 (Q1), 96 (Q2), 112 (Q3), 128 (Q4), 160 (Q5), 192 (Q6), • Channels: stereo • The audio player supports reading of Vorbis content stored in Ogg containers. Supported file name extensions: *.ogg and *.oga. • The audio player supports decoding of Vorbis comments. NOTE: There is no specification for tag names. The system relies on the OSS implementation. • Tag names decoded: TITLE, ALBUM, ARTIST, GENRE. • Binary data (e.g. for album art) is not supported. • The audio player supports gapless Vorbis playback. Supported FLAC encoding parameters • Sampling rates [kHz]: 44.1, 48, 88.2, 96, 176.4, 192 • Resolution [bits]: 16, 24 • Channels: stereo, mono • The audio player supports reading of FLAC content stored in native FLAC containers.
    [Show full text]
  • (A/V Codecs) REDCODE RAW (.R3D) ARRIRAW
    What is a Codec? Codec is a portmanteau of either "Compressor-Decompressor" or "Coder-Decoder," which describes a device or program capable of performing transformations on a data stream or signal. Codecs encode a stream or signal for transmission, storage or encryption and decode it for viewing or editing. Codecs are often used in videoconferencing and streaming media solutions. A video codec converts analog video signals from a video camera into digital signals for transmission. It then converts the digital signals back to analog for display. An audio codec converts analog audio signals from a microphone into digital signals for transmission. It then converts the digital signals back to analog for playing. The raw encoded form of audio and video data is often called essence, to distinguish it from the metadata information that together make up the information content of the stream and any "wrapper" data that is then added to aid access to or improve the robustness of the stream. Most codecs are lossy, in order to get a reasonably small file size. There are lossless codecs as well, but for most purposes the almost imperceptible increase in quality is not worth the considerable increase in data size. The main exception is if the data will undergo more processing in the future, in which case the repeated lossy encoding would damage the eventual quality too much. Many multimedia data streams need to contain both audio and video data, and often some form of metadata that permits synchronization of the audio and video. Each of these three streams may be handled by different programs, processes, or hardware; but for the multimedia data stream to be useful in stored or transmitted form, they must be encapsulated together in a container format.
    [Show full text]
  • Ogg Audio Codec Download
    Ogg audio codec download click here to download To obtain the source code, please see the xiph download page. To get set up to listen to Ogg Vorbis music, begin by selecting your operating system above. Check out the latest royalty-free audio codec from Xiph. To obtain the source code, please see the xiph download page. Ogg Vorbis is Vorbis is everywhere! Download music Music sites Donate today. Get Set Up To Listen: Windows. Playback: These DirectShow filters will let you play your Ogg Vorbis files in Windows Media Player, and other OggDropXPd: A graphical encoder for Vorbis. Download Ogg Vorbis Ogg Vorbis is a lossy audio codec which allows you to create and play Ogg Vorbis files using the command-line. The following end-user download links are provided for convenience: The www.doorway.ru DirectShow filters support playing of files encoded with Vorbis, Speex, Ogg Codecs for Windows, version , ; project page - for other. Vorbis Banner Xiph Banner. In our effort to bring Ogg: Media container. This is our native format and the recommended container for all Xiph codecs. Easy, fast, no torrents, no waiting, no surveys, % free, working www.doorway.ru Free Download Ogg Vorbis ACM Codec - A new audio compression codec. Ogg Codecs is a set of encoders and deocoders for Ogg Vorbis, Speex, Theora and FLAC. Once installed you will be able to play Vorbis. Ogg Vorbis MSACM Codec was added to www.doorway.ru by Bjarne (). Type: Freeware. Updated: Audiotags: , 0x Used to play digital music, such as MP3, VQF, AAC, and other digital audio formats.
    [Show full text]
  • Spb Tv Encoder
    SPB TV ENCODER INPUT IP Input Interfaces 2x Gigabit Ethernet SPB TV Encoder is a professional solution for the fast, high- that processes multi-format video streams for delivery to different quality transcoding of live and on-demand video streams from end-user devices: Mobile, Tablet, Desktop, and connected TV-sets. Optional Digital Input Interfaces SDI, DVB-S a single headend to multi-screen devices. Leverage your network SPB TV Encoding solution can be delivered in a flexible software- Input IP Streams UDP Unicast/Multicast, HTTP, HLS, RTSP, RTMP, MMS with a unified platform for IP TV, OTT TV and mobile TV services based configuration or as off the-shelf equipment. Supported Codecs MPEG-2, MPEG-4, H.264, MPEG-1, MPEG-1 Layer 3, AAC, HE AAC, AC3, WMV 7, WMV 8, WMV 9, WMA 1, WMA 2, WMA 9 Pro, On2 VP3, On2 VP5, On2 VP6, On2 VP8, PNG Filters Video cropping, Image insertion on input source loss, automatic audio loudness adjustment Up to 100 multi-rate channels FEC (Forward Error Correction) OUTPUT Live and on-demand video encoding 5.1 Audio, auto audio gain support IP Output Interfaces 2x Gigabit Ethernet Remote monitoring tools Keeping aspect ratio Output IP streams RTP Unicast/Multicast Image insertion on input loss Image overlay Output Codecs H.264 (Baseline, Main, High), MPEG-4, AAC, HE AAC, H.265 Web GUI and CLI interfaces Hardsubs overlay VoD Output Multi Track MP4 VoD Publishing FTP, SFTP SNMP 3D encoding support Thumbnails PNG, JPEG Managed updates to include the latest Multi output support codecs, formats, profiles and devices MANAGEMENT/MONITORING
    [Show full text]
  • Voxpro/Audionlabs Was Acquired by Wheatstone Corporation in the Fall of 2015
    NOTE: VoxPro/AudionLabs was acquired by Wheatstone Corporation in the fall of 2015. As a result the contact information and support links listed in this legacy document are no longer current. Should you require further assistance regarding the information presented here, please refer to the following contact info: EMAIL: [email protected] TEL: +1.252-638-7000 (9am-5pm EST) WEB: wheatstone.com [menu item: VoxPro] MAIL: Wheatstone Corporation 600 Industrial Drive New Bern, NC. 28562 USA 100716 Contents 3 Table of Contents 0 Chapter 1 Introduction 8 Chapter 2 Getting Started 10 1 VoxPro Main................................................................................................................................... Window 11 2 VoxPro Control................................................................................................................................... Panel 12 3 User Accounts................................................................................................................................... 13 4 Passwords ................................................................................................................................... 14 Chapter 3 Recording 16 1 Create New ...................................................................................................................................Recording 16 2 Create Empty................................................................................................................................... Recording 18 3 Create Recording..................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Google Chrome Browser Dropping H.264 Support 14 January 2011, by John Messina
    Google Chrome Browser dropping H.264 support 14 January 2011, by John Messina with the codecs already supported by the open Chromium project. Specifically, we are supporting the WebM (VP8) and Theora video codecs, and will consider adding support for other high-quality open codecs in the future. Though H.264 plays an important role in video, as our goal is to enable open innovation, support for the codec will be removed and our resources directed towards completely open codec technologies." Since Google is developing the WebM technology, they can develop a good video standard using open source faster and better than a current standard video player can. The problem with H.264 is that it cost money and On January 11, Google announced that Chrome’s the patents for the technologies in H.264 are held HTML5 video support will change to match codecs by 27 companies, including Apple and Microsoft supported by the open source Chromium project. and controlled by MPEG LA. This makes H.264 Chrome will support the WebM (VP8) and Theora video expensive for content owners and software makers. codecs, and support for the H.264 codec will be removed to allow resources to focus on open codec Since Apple and Microsoft hold some of the technologies. patents for the H.264 technology and make money off the licensing fees, it's in their best interest not to change the technology in their browsers. (PhysOrg.com) -- Google will soon stop supporting There is however concerns that Apple and the H.264 video codec in their Chrome browser Microsoft's lack of support for WebM may impact and will support its own WebM and Ogg Theora the Chrome browser.
    [Show full text]
  • Game Audio the Role of Audio in Games
    the gamedesigninitiative at cornell university Lecture 18 Game Audio The Role of Audio in Games Engagement Entertains the player Music/Soundtrack Enhances the realism Sound effects Establishes atmosphere Ambient sounds Other reasons? the gamedesigninitiative 2 Game Audio at cornell university The Role of Audio in Games Feedback Indicate off-screen action Indicate player should move Highlight on-screen action Call attention to an NPC Increase reaction time Players react to sound faster Other reasons? the gamedesigninitiative 3 Game Audio at cornell university History of Sound in Games Basic Sounds • Arcade games • Early handhelds • Early consoles the gamedesigninitiative 4 Game Audio at cornell university Early Sounds: Wizard of Wor the gamedesigninitiative 5 Game Audio at cornell university History of Sound in Games Recorded Basic Sound Sounds Samples Sample = pre-recorded audio • Arcade games • Starts w/ MIDI • Early handhelds • 5th generation • Early consoles (Playstation) • Early PCs the gamedesigninitiative 6 Game Audio at cornell university History of Sound in Games Recorded Some Basic Sound Variability Sounds Samples of Samples • Arcade games • Starts w/ MIDI • Sample selection • Early handhelds • 5th generation • Volume • Early consoles (Playstation) • Pitch • Early PCs • Stereo pan the gamedesigninitiative 7 Game Audio at cornell university History of Sound in Games Recorded Some More Basic Sound Variability Variability Sounds Samples of Samples of Samples • Arcade games • Starts w/ MIDI • Sample selection • Multiple
    [Show full text]
  • Codec Is a Portmanteau of Either
    What is a Codec? Codec is a portmanteau of either "Compressor-Decompressor" or "Coder-Decoder," which describes a device or program capable of performing transformations on a data stream or signal. Codecs encode a stream or signal for transmission, storage or encryption and decode it for viewing or editing. Codecs are often used in videoconferencing and streaming media solutions. A video codec converts analog video signals from a video camera into digital signals for transmission. It then converts the digital signals back to analog for display. An audio codec converts analog audio signals from a microphone into digital signals for transmission. It then converts the digital signals back to analog for playing. The raw encoded form of audio and video data is often called essence, to distinguish it from the metadata information that together make up the information content of the stream and any "wrapper" data that is then added to aid access to or improve the robustness of the stream. Most codecs are lossy, in order to get a reasonably small file size. There are lossless codecs as well, but for most purposes the almost imperceptible increase in quality is not worth the considerable increase in data size. The main exception is if the data will undergo more processing in the future, in which case the repeated lossy encoding would damage the eventual quality too much. Many multimedia data streams need to contain both audio and video data, and often some form of metadata that permits synchronization of the audio and video. Each of these three streams may be handled by different programs, processes, or hardware; but for the multimedia data stream to be useful in stored or transmitted form, they must be encapsulated together in a container format.
    [Show full text]
  • Submitting Electronic Evidentiary Material in Western Australian Courts
    Submitting Electronic Evidentiary Material in Western Australian Courts Document Revision History Revision Date Version Summary of Changes October 2007 1 Preliminary Draft December 2007 2 Incorporates feedback from Electronic Evidentiary Standards Workshop February 2008 3 Amendments following feedback from Paul Smith, Martin Jackson and Chris Penwald. June 2008 4 Amendments by Courts Technology Group July 2008 5 Amendments from feedback August 2008 6 Courtroom Status Update February 2010 7 Address details and Courtroom Status Update May 2013 8 Status Update November 2013 9 Status & Location Update February 2017 10 Incorporates range of new formats and adjustment to process December 2019 11 Updates to CCTV Players, Court Location Courtroom Types and Microsoft Office versions. Page 1 of 15 SUBMITTING ELECTRONIC EVIDENTIARY MATERIAL IN WESTERN AUSTRALIAN COURTS 1. INTRODUCTION ..................................................................................3 1.1. Non-Compliance with Standards ................................................................ 3 1.2. Court Locations ...................................................................................... 3 1.3. Courtroom Types .................................................................................... 3 1.3.1. Type A & B ........................................................................................ 3 1.3.2. Type C .............................................................................................. 3 1.4. Contacting DoJ Courts in Relation to Electronic
    [Show full text]