DOCSLIB.ORG

Good Laws, Good Food

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Good Laws, Good Food GOOD LAWS, GOOD FOOD: PUTTING STATE FOOD POLICY TO WORK FOR UR OMMUNITIES O C November 2012 WRITTEN BY THE HARVARD LAW SCHOOL FOOD LAW AND POLICY CLINIC UNDER THE SUPERVISION OF EMILY BROAD LEIB IN PARTNERSHIP WITH MARK WINNE ASSOCIATES Cover photos courtesy of Alli Condra MARK WINNE ASSOCIATES TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................................. 1 About This Toolkit ............................................................................................................................................ 2 About the Authors ............................................................................................................................................ 4 SECTION I: GENERAL LEGAL SETTING ....................................................................................................... 5 Overview ........................................................................................................................................................... 5 Federalism and the Interplay of Federal, State, Local, & Tribal Law ................................................................ 5 Understanding Legislation & Regulation ........................................................................................................ 10 Getting to Know Your State Government ........................................................................................................ 14 State Food System Assessment ......................................................................................................................... 16 Conclusion ....................................................................................................................................................... 17 SECTION II: FOOD SYSTEM INFRASTRUCTURE .................................................................................. 18 Overview .......................................................................................................................................................... 18 Production ....................................................................................................................................................... 18 Processing ........................................................................................................................................................ 24 Aggregation & Distribution ............................................................................................................................. 25 Retail ................................................................................................................................................................ 26 Food Waste Management ................................................................................................................................. 27 Conclusion ....................................................................................................................................................... 27 SECTION III: LAND USE & PLANNING ............................................................................................. 28 Overview .......................................................................................................................................................... 28 Basic Concepts of Land Use & Planning .......................................................................................................... 28 Farmland Preservation Techniques: State Land Use Policies ........................................................................... 29 Farmland Preservation Techniques: Restricting Land to Agricultural Uses .................................................... 30 Other Farmland Preservation Techniques ....................................................................................................... 36 Conclusion ....................................................................................................................................................... 39 SECTION IV: FOOD ASSISTANCE PROGRAMS .................................................................................... 40 Overview .......................................................................................................................................................... 40 SNAP ................................................................................................................................................................ 40 WIC .................................................................................................................................................................. 44 Maximizing Food Assistance Program use to Benefit the Local Food Economy .............................................. 48 Conclusion ....................................................................................................................................................... 53 SECTION V: CONSUMER ACCESS & CONSUMER DEMAND .................................................................. 54 Overview .......................................................................................................................................................... 54 Improving Consumer Access ........................................................................................................................... 54 Improving Consumer Demand for Healthy Foods ........................................................................................... 60 Conclusion ....................................................................................................................................................... 62 SECTION VI: FARM TO INSTITUTION ............................................................................................... 63 Overview .......................................................................................................................................................... 63 What is Farm to Institution? ............................................................................................................................ 63 Farm to State Agencies ..................................................................................................................................... 65 Farm to School ................................................................................................................................................. 68 Farm to University Programs ........................................................................................................................... 73 Farm to Other Institutions ............................................................................................................................... 74 Conclusion ....................................................................................................................................................... 76 SECTION VII: SCHOOL FOOD & EDUCATION ................................................................................... 77 Overview .......................................................................................................................................................... 77 School Nutrition .............................................................................................................................................. 77 Health & Nutrition Education ......................................................................................................................... 84 Conclusion ....................................................................................................................................................... 88 SECTION VIII: FOOD SAFETY & PROCESSING ................................................................................... 89 Overview .......................................................................................................................................................... 89 Overview of Food Safety Regulations: Federal & State .................................................................................... 89 Quality Certification Programs for Agricultural Producers ............................................................................ 91 Food Safety Regulations for Processed Foods .................................................................................................. 93 Meat, Poultry, & Egg Processing for Small-Scale Producers ............................................................................ 96 Conclusion ..................................................................................................................................................... 101 SECTION IX: RESOURCES ............................................................................................................ 102 INTRODUCTION As an increasing number of consumers look to influence the system that brings food from the field to their dinner plates, they often find that it is policy that they are looking to change. “Food policy”—a term used to describe the set of laws and regulations that inform how, why, and when food is produced, transported, distributed, and consumed—has only recently emerged as an identified field of study. This recent emergence is largely a result of the piecemeal nature of food and agricultural policy in the United States. The U.S. food system is governed by a combination of laws and regulations spanning various
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Sugar-Sweetened Beverage Taxes and Sugar Intake: Policy Statements, Endorsements, and Recommendations Updated January 2017
    Sugar-Sweetened Beverage Taxes and Sugar Intake: Policy Statements, Endorsements, and Recommendations Updated January 2017 Policy Statement/Resolution/Statements in Support of Taxes American Academy of Pediatrics Obesity/Advocacy Policy: Change Relative Price. See bottom of web page. Implement a tax strategy to discourage consumption of food and beverages with minimal nutritional value, including a soda tax. National Consumers League NCL supports a tax on sweetened drinks, with proceeds devoted to school nutritional education programs. Acknowledgement of Taxes as a Public Health Strategy American Medical Association Policy Statement, June 2012. Taxes on beverages with added sweeteners are one means by which consumer education campaigns and other obesity-related programs could be financed in a stepwise approach to addressing the obesity epidemic….Where taxes on beverages with added sweeteners are implemented, the revenue should be used primarily for programs to prevent and/or treat obesity and related conditions…. Reports Recommending Taxes Bipartisan Policy Center Restoring America’s Future. Reviving the Economy, Cutting Spending and Debt, and Creating a Simple, Pro-Growth Tax System. November 2010, pp. 69-71. Introduce an excise tax on the manufacture and importation of beverages sweetened with sugar or high-fructose corn syrup (non-diet soft drinks, sweetened fruit drinks, etc.) to reduce obesity-related healthcare costs. Brookings Institution Bending the Curve. Effective Steps to Address Long-Term Health Care Spending Growth. August 2009, pg. 7. Target obesity reduction through price incentives, such as sugar-sweetened beverage taxes, and through aggressive piloting and evaluation of other reforms that are designed to improve the evidence base of reforms that demonstrably reduce obesity — for example, community-, school-, and work-site interventions.
    [Show full text]
  • State Farm to School Policy Handbook: 2002–2020 Builds on a Survey That Was Originally Released in 2011, and Updated in 2013, 2014, 2017, and 2019
    State Farm to School Policy Handbook 2002–2020 Includes state policies introduced between January 2002 and December 2020, as publicly available at the time of the Handbook’s publication. PUBLISHED | JULY 2021 Table of Contents 3 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS 6 INTRODUCTION 7 What’s New in this Edition 7 Our Methodology 8 How to Use this Handbook 9 What is Farm to School? 9 Why Farm to School? 10 Why State Farm to School Legislation Matters 11 Key Strategies for Advancing Farm to School through Policy 12 TRENDS IN FARM TO SCHOOL POLICY 15 Overall Look at State Policy Efforts 16 2019–2020 Legislative Trends 19 Emerging Farm to School Opportunities 20 POLICY IN ACTION 21 Promising Practices 23 Advocacy Strategies 28 Next Steps for Advocates 30 CASE STUDIES 31 Local Procurement Incentives: Lessons from the Field 35 Farm to School State Policy Strategies to Support Native Food and Tribal Sovereignty 38 State Policy Responses to COVID-19 Impacting Farm to School 40 BILL SUMMARIES 145 APPENDIX 146 Methodology: The Coding Process 147 Additional Farm to School Resources 148 US Territories 149 2018 Case Studies 149 Hawai‘i 151 Michigan 153 New Mexico 155 US Virgin Islands 157 Vermont 159 State Rankings Chart Acknowledgements This project is funded by the National Agricultural Library, Agricultural Research Service, US Department of Agriculture. About the Authors National Farm to School Network has a vision of a strong and just food system for all. We seek deep transformation toward this vision through farm to school – the ways kids eat, grow, and learn about food in schools and early care and education settings.
    [Show full text]
  • The Urgent Call U.S. National Food Strategy
    THE URGENT CALL for a U.S. NATIONAL FOOD STRATEGY An Update to the Blueprint october 2020 Authors and Acknowledgments Report Authors: The lead authors of this report are Emily M. Broad Leib, Clinical Professor of Law and Director of the Food Law and Policy Clinic at Harvard Law School and Laurie Beyranevand, Professor of Law and Director of the Center for Agriculture and Food Systems at Vermont Law School, with significant research, writing, input, and editing support fromEsther Akwii, Clinical Fellow of the Food Law and Policy Clinic at Harvard Law School and Cydnee Bence, LLM Fellow, Center for Agriculture and Food Systems at Vermont Law School. In addition, the following students contributed significant research and writing to the report: Bradley Adams, Madison McDonald, Tessa Pulaski, Ali Ruxin, and Ali Schklair. Finally, the following Food Law and Policy Clinic Students at Harvard Law School contributed additional editing and writing support: Libby Dimenstein, Oscar Heanue, and Stephanie Kelemen. This report would not have been possible without the assistance, partnership, and tremendous production support of Lihlani Skipper Nelson, Associate Director and Research Fellow, Center for Agriculture and Food Systems at Vermont Law School and the support of Kyra Sanborn, Advancement Officer at the Center for Health Law and Policy Innovation, on report production, release, and communications. We thank the following people for reviewing this report. The reviewers do not necessarily concur with the report’s arguments and recommendations, but provided useful guidance on portions of its content: Jerold Mande, Senior Advisor, Center for Science in the Public Interest, Margot Pollans, Professor of Law, Director of Pace-NRDC Food Law Initiative at Elisabeth Haub School of Law, and Emily Spiegel, Assistant Professor and Faculty Fellow, Center for Agriculture and Food Systems at Vermont Law School.
    [Show full text]
  • Food Safety Policy
    Food Safety Policy Laurian J. Unnevehr, University of Illinois in prepared form, consumers exercise less control Background over food safety. Public policy sets standards for food safety. Such standards reflect policy decisions about acceptable Food safety encompasses many kinds of potential risks and costs of risk avoidance. For many food hazards in food. Examples include foodborne safety hazards, consumers cannot detect the hazard pathogens such as salmonella, naturally occurring at the time of purchase, and producers may also be mycotoxins, such as aflatoxin, or pesticide residues. unable to measure or guarantee a particular level of These hazards can pose acute risks (consumers safety. Therefore, consumers cannot always make become ill immediately) or chronic risks (consumers’ their demand for safer food known through purchase risk of chronic illness is enhanced). Some hazards decisions, and producers cannot always supply what are easily controlled or detected while others occur consumers demand. Public policies attempt to naturally and may be difficult for producers to see or address this market failure by setting standards that eliminate. ensure some level of acceptable safety for all Most food safety hazards pose only small risks consumers. due to the quality of U.S. food production and the Food safety previously has not been addressed strong standards in place. However, food safety directly in the Farm Bill, but it is a public policy issue issues are receiving more attention now for several that affects farm and food industry profitability, reasons. First, science is now better able to trace product reputation, and competitiveness in many foodborne illnesses and their outcomes to international trade.
    [Show full text]
  • Agricultural-Food Policy Review: Perspectives for the 1980S
    United States % Department of Agriculture Agricultural*Food AgEconomics andulture Statistics Service AFPR-4 Policy Review: Perspectives for the 1980's Page 1 Global Prospects 27 Changes in the Farm Sector 59 Inflation 69 Capacity for Greater Productior" 81 Transportation 95 Trade Issues 107 Commodity Programs 119 Policy Setting 135 A Policy Approach -rH---. Agricultural-Food Policy Review: Perspectives for the 1980's. Economics and Statistics Service, U.S. Department of Agriculture. AFPR4. Preface The nine articles collected here provide background for discussions on new legislation. to replace the Food and Agriculture Act of 1977, which expires this year. New legislation will be influenced by the much altered nature of U.S. farming. * Almost all easily available cropland, including that once idled by farm programs, is now back in production. Millions of acres of potential cropland remain, but are not as productive or need to be improved (cleared, drained, irrigated, for example). * The long period of overproduction, burdensome surpluses, and depressed farm prices now seems to be behind us, although there may still be occasional years of excess production. * International food needs now heavily influence the well-being of U.S. agriculture in any given year. * The character of U.S. farming has changed as fewer but larger farms now produce most of our total agricultural production. Agricultural-FoodPolicy Review is an occasional publication that addresses important policy and legislative matters pertaining to agriculture and food. Washington, D.C. 20250 April 1981 Contents Page Foreword .............................................. v Global Prospects for Agriculture. PatrickM. O'Brien ........................ 2 Abstract: The eighties are likely to show continued strong growth in foreign demand for agricultural products, but reduced growth in foreign production.
    [Show full text]
  • FOOD LAW and POLICY CAREER GUIDE October 2017 Researched and Prepared By
    FOOD LAW AND POLICY CAREER GUIDE October 2017 Researched and Prepared by: Harvard Law School Food Law and Policy Clinic Emily Broad Leib, Director Christina Rice, Clinical Fellow Teresa Pulaski, Intern [email protected] http://www.chlpi.org/flpc The Food Law and Policy Clinic of Harvard Law School (FLPC), a division of the Center for Health Law and Policy Innovation, was established in 2010 to link Harvard Law School students with opportunities to work with clients and communities on various food law and policy issues. The FLPC provides legal and policy guidance to a range of clients seeking to increase access to healthy foods, assist small and sustainable farmers in breaking into new commercial markets, and reduce waste of healthy, wholesome food, while educating law students about ways to use law and policy to impact the food system. The FLPC engages a strong policy orientation as well as substantive expertise in the food system to assist a range of federal, state, and local clients around the world in understanding the legal and policy regimes that apply to food production and sales. Harvard Food Law Society Alex Leone, Tommy Tobin, Lisa Gluckstein, & Steven Gonzalez www.law.harvard.edu/orgs/foodlaw/ The Harvard Food Law Society fosters on-campus dialogue on issues in food law and policy. Food- related issues often implicate broader questions of public health, environmental sustainability, income inequality, economic development, and human rights. The Food Law Society supports a network of students, professionals, and food-lovers who support a healthier, more equitable food system. Members participate in clinical research projects and conferences, host speakers, take trips and collaborate with groups throughout the University and the world in their effort to address food issues.
    [Show full text]
  • Municipal Urban Food Policy Scan
    CITY FOOD POLICY AND PROGRAMS: LESSONS HARVESTED frOM AN EMERGING FIELD Researched and written by Molly M. Hatfield City of Portland, Oregon Bureau of Planning and Sustainability Funded by Innovation Fund of the Urban Sustainability Directors Network, a Project of Global Philanthropy Partnership City of Portland, Oregon Bureau of Planning and Sustainability Sam Adams, Mayor, Commissioner-in-charge Susan Anderson, Director Contributors Steve Cohen, Food Policy and Programs Manager, City of Portland Bureau of Planning and Sustainability Michael Armstrong, Sustainability Manager, City of Portland Bureau of Planning and Sustainability Prepared in partnership with: Lauren Baker, Toronto, Ontario Steve Cohen, Portland, Oregon Paula Daniels, Los Angeles, California Holly Freishtat, Baltimore, Maryland Paula Jones, San Francisco, California Kim Kessler, New York City, New York Sharon Lerman, Seattle, Washington Wendy Mendes, Vancouver, British Columbia Edith Murnane, Boston, Massachusetts Gayle Prest, Jane Shey, Minneapolis, Minnesota Elizabeth Reynoso, Newark, New Jersey Amanda Wagner, Sarah Wu, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Theresa Zawacki, Louisville, Kentucky The Bureau of Planning and Sustainability is committed to providing equal access to information and hearings. If you need special accommodation, please call 503-823-7700, the City’s TTY at 503-823-6868, or the Oregon Relay Service at 1-800-735-2900. Contents Executive Summary . 1 Introduction and Methodology . 7 Origins . 11 Funding . 13 Organization . 17 Priorities and Metrics . 19 Interdepartmental Coordination . 23 Community Involvement . 27 Conclusion and Next Steps . 31 Bibliography . 33 Appendices A. Existing Food Policy Programs . A-1 B. Sample Questionnaire . B-1 C. Sample Interview Script . C-1 www.portlandoregon.gov/bps/food | October 2012 3 CITY FOOD POLICY AND PROGRAMS: LESSONS HARVESTED FROM AN EMERGING FIELD Food democracy is the new agenda for democracy and human rights.
    [Show full text]
  • Food Law & Policy: the Fertile Field's Origins and First Decade
    Food Law & Policy: The Fertile Field's Origins and First Decade The Harvard community has made this article openly available. Please share how this access benefits you. Your story matters Citation Baylen J. Linnekin & Emily M. Broad Leib, Food Law & Policy: The Fertile Field's Origins and First Decade, 2014 Wis. L. Rev. 557 (2014). Citable link http://nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:12795534 Terms of Use This article was downloaded from Harvard University’s DASH repository, and is made available under the terms and conditions applicable to Open Access Policy Articles, as set forth at http:// nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:dash.current.terms-of- use#OAP FOOD LAW & POLICY: THE FERTILE FIELD’S ORIGINS AND FIRST DECADE BAYLEN J. LINNEKIN* EMILY M. BROAD LEIB** Legal knowledge, learning, and scholarship pertaining to the production and regulation of food historically centered around two distinct fields of law: Food & Drug Law and Agricultural Law. The former focuses on the regulation of food by the Food and Drug Administration under the Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act, while the latter examines the impacts of law on the agricultural sector’s production of food and fiber. Neither field—alone or in tandem—focuses in whole or in part on many of the most pressing legal issues that currently impact our food system. Consequently, elements of these two fields converged roughly one decade ago to create a significant and distinct new field of legal study: “Food Law & Policy.” This field explores legal and policy issues well outside the scope of Food & Drug Law and of Agricultural Law to address important questions about food that had never been explored fully within the legal academy.
    [Show full text]
  • Integrating Food Policy in Comprehensive Planning: Strategies and Resources for the City of Seattle a Contract Project for the City of Seattle
    Integrating Food Policy in Comprehensive Planning: Strategies and Resources for the City of Seattle A CONTRACT PROJECT FOR THE CITY OF SEATTLE Puget Sound Regional Council PSRC August 2012 Contents 1.0 Introduction ........................................................................................................................................ 1 Findings ............................................................................................................................................... 1 Context and Objectives for Addressing Food in the Comprehensive Plan ......................................... 2 Seattle’s Planning Framework ............................................................................................................. 3 2.0 Methodology ....................................................................................................................................... 4 3.0 Findings from Research ....................................................................................................................... 5 Local Food Policy Scan ......................................................................................................................... 5 Literature Addressing Food Policy in Seattle ...................................................................................... 5 Review of Other Cities’ Plans .............................................................................................................. 7 4.0 Inventory of Policies by Food Policy Category ...................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Food Policy in Action Science [Lesson Duration: 45 Minutes, Plus 20 Optional Minutes] Health
    Lesson 15 Social Studies Food Policy in Action Science [Lesson Duration: 45 minutes, plus 20 optional minutes] Health Students will explore key areas of policy influence on the food system and Lesson Overview learn how individuals and communities can influence food policy decisions. The lesson wraps up with a mock food policy council, where students will adopt the perspectives of different stakeholders and propose their own food policy interventions. This lesson leads naturally into the culminating Food Citizen Action Project. Learning ◼ Explain how policy influences the food system and provide examples. ◼ Analyze the power of engaged citizens to change the food Objectives system through policy. Essential ◼ How can policy address food system problems? Questions ◼ How can individuals and communities influence food policy? ◼ Student handouts Materials ◼ Presentation slides ◼ Food Policy primer ◼ FoodSpan Infographic Resources ◼ Food Policy primer (www.foodsystemprimer.org/food-policy) Lesson 15: Food Policy in Action l www.foodspan.org [1] © 2020 Johns Hopkins University Warm-up Main Activities Wrap-up Extensions Warm-up: Main Activity: Mapping Policy’s Influence Prioritizing Federal [5 minutes] Food Policy Goals Have students look at their FoodSpan Infographic Science, Health, Social Studies and mark areas where they think the government [15 minutes] has influence and how. Ask volunteers to share their Students will examine key areas of food policy and ideas and discuss: How does government policy debate which types of programs should be prioritized. affect the food system? Have students read the Food Policy Goals Handout to familiarize themselves with these goals: supporting farmers, feeding the hungry, keeping the food supply safe, and protecting the environment (refer to the Food Policy primer for references and additional details).
    [Show full text]
  • Food Policies and Their Implications on Overweight and Obesity Trends in Selected Countries in the Near East and North Africa Region
    REGIONAL PROGRAM WORKING PAPER 30 DECEMBER 2020 Food Policies and their Implications on Overweight and Obesity Trends in Selected Countries in the Near East and North Africa Region Kibrom A. Abay, Hosam Ibrahim, Clemens Breisinger, and Nomindelger Bayasgalanbat TABLE OF CONTENTS Executive Summary ........................................................................................................................ v 1 Introduction ............................................................................................................................... 1 2 Trade (Food) Policies and Nutritional Implications ..................................................................... 4 3 Data and Data Sources ............................................................................................................. 6 4 Macro-level Analysis and Evidence ........................................................................................... 8 4.1 Evolution of Body Weight in the Near East and North Africa Region ................................. 8 4.2 Evolution of Trade (Food) Policies in Egypt, Jordan, and Iraq ......................................... 13 4.3 Evolution of Food Systems in Egypt, Jordan, and Iraq .................................................... 18 4.4 Empirical Relationships between Trade (Food) Policies and Body Weight ...................... 24 5 Micro-level Analysis and Evidence .......................................................................................... 31 5.1 Egypt ..............................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • School Food Policy Brief
    Publication #2008-40 4301 Connecticut Avenue, NW, Suite 350, Washington, DC 20008 Phone 202-572-6000 Fax 202-362-8420 www.childtrends.org SCHOOL FOOD UNWRAPPED: WHAT’S AVAILABLE AND WHAT OUR KIDS ACTUALLY ARE EATING By Elizabeth Hair, Ph.D., Thomson Ling, and Laura Wandner November 2008 OVERVIEW Childhood obesity has emerged as a critical health problem of the 21st century.30 The seriousness of this issue stems from the grave health consequences of overweight and obesity that begin in child- hood and persist later in life.1,4,23,27 In light of these consequences, public health officials and others have begun to focus on schools as key settings in which to foster healthy eating and exercise habits. Their efforts reflect a growing recognition that the school food environment (that is, the types of food sold to children) represents a natural place for intervention. This Research Brief examines the prevalence of vending machines, school stores, and other outlets in elementary schools that often provide non-nutritious foods, the types of food and beverages sold within these outlets, and student consumption of food at school among a nationally representative sample of fifth-grade students. We found that competitive foods (i.e., foods that are not part of the National School Lunch and School Breakfast programs) are available in most schools and that as many as one in four children reports buying unhealthy competitive foods. Contrary to popular belief, we also found that most of these purchases are made in school cafeterias, rather than through vending machines. Our findings also run counter to the expectation that the kind of food available in a school depends on the income level of its students.
    [Show full text]