The Development of the Imperial Japanese Navy, 1875-1905
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
University of Calgary PRISM: University of Calgary's Digital Repository Graduate Studies Legacy Theses 2001 After battle, tighten your helmet strings: the development of the imperial Japanese navy, 1875-1905 Kirk, Dylan Kirk, D. (2001). After battle, tighten your helmet strings: the development of the imperial Japanese navy, 1875-1905 (Unpublished master's thesis). University of Calgary, Calgary, AB. doi:10.11575/PRISM/20187 http://hdl.handle.net/1880/41057 master thesis University of Calgary graduate students retain copyright ownership and moral rights for their thesis. You may use this material in any way that is permitted by the Copyright Act or through licensing that has been assigned to the document. For uses that are not allowable under copyright legislation or licensing, you are required to seek permission. Downloaded from PRISM: https://prism.ucalgary.ca THE UNWFJtsIlY OF CALGARY After Battle, Tighten Your Helmet Strings: The Development of the Imperial Japanese Navy, 1875-1905 by Dylan Kirk A THESIS SUBMITTED TO THE FACULTY OF GRADUATE STUDIES IN PARTIAL FULFILMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF ARTS CENTRE FOR MILITARY AND STRATEGIC STUDIES CALGARY, ALBERTA AUGUST, 2001 0 Dylan Kirk 2001 Natianal Lii Bibliotheque natiorrale du Canada uisitions and Acquisitions el "1.81blographic Services services bibliographiques 395 womgkm Street 395. wm* O(twwON KlAW -ON K1AW CaMdo Canada The author has granted a non- L'auteur a accorde une licence non exclusive licence allowing the exc1usive pennettant a la National Ll'brary of Canada to Bibliothique nationale du Canada de reproduce, loan, di.stri'bute or sell reproduire, prhr, dislribuer on copies of this thesis in microform, v&e des copies de cette these sous paper or electronic formats. la fmede microfiche/film, de reproduction sur papier ou sm format electronique. The author retains ownership of the L'auteur conserve la propriete du copyright in this thesis. Neither the droit d'auteur qui protege cette these. thesis nor substantial extracts fiom it Ni la these ni des extraits substantiels may be printed or otherwise de celle-ci ne doivent etre imprimes reproduced without the author's ou autrement reproduits sans son permission. autorisation. Gwd weapons are imthments of fear; all creatures hate them. mereforefofllowers of Tao never use tb. me mse nran prefers the Zefz, me man of wmprefers the right. Weapons are instruments of*; they are not a wise man's rools. He uses them only when he has no choice. Peace md pier me deor to his heart, And victory no casefor rejoicing. ifyou delight in victory, you delight in kiIIing; rfyou delight in killing, you yarnotfir&illymrse& On hqpy OCC~SI~OI~S,precedence is given to the Zelf On sud OCC~SI~OI~Sto the right. In the army the general s&m& on the lep, The commander-in-chief on the right. This means war is conducled like afineral. When many people me kiiled, They should be mourned in heaJelt sorrow. Thal is why victory must be observed like af.nerol. -Lao4 Dao De Jing Translated by Gia-Fu Feng and Jane English Abstract A discussion of the nature of Japanese naval strategy fiom the origins of the Japanese Navy to the Second World War. It embraces the Taiwan Incident 1876, Satsurna Rebellion 1877, Tonghak Rebellion and Sino-Japanese War 1894-95, Anglo- Japanese Alliance 1902, and Russo-Japanese War 1904-5. Specifically, it addresses the problem of critical reassessment of the IJN regarding their early victories, and inability to change their basic mode of operation before the Pacific War. Acknowledgements My parents are the reason I am here. They never forced knowledge on me, but forced me to gain my own knowledge. My beloved fiande, Tomoko, who kicks my behind without fail, whether I want it or not. My fiends, including but not exclusive to Todd and Craig, for seventeen years. Ry and Ky, for listening when they did not have to. Kierin, for QBL and magia. Shane, Christine and Sorcha, for staying in touch. Eva, for her warmth. Chris, for commiseration on things thesis-related. Eun-kyong, along with Tomoko, one of the voices that kept telling me to get back to work. My thanks to the kind, generous and understanding Dr. Ferris, my advisor for four years and two degrees. He suffered long through my terrible writing style and yet found it in his heart to edit every page. To Dr. Hewwhose lectures I would prefer to a novel or a movie. To Dr. Huebert, for being both approachable and constantly challenging. Dr. Archer, now I cannot go to a historic site without checking the latrines either. To Kenneth Macksey, for writing Tank: a history of the armoured fiphtinp vehicle, which I picked up in grade three. Thanks to you, I never became an astrophysicist, paIeontologist, microbiologist, or geologist. Not nearly enough things get blown up in ANY of those disciplines for them to be interesting anyway. Did I mention my gratitude to my fiancCe, Tomoko? To Yoshida Tomoko, who had me convinced that if I did not get to work on my thesis, Co&cius would come out of the closet and give me what-for- and.. To my parents, who know why. Table of Contents .. Approval Page. ................ .. .................................................................... I I ... Abstract. .............................................................................................. 111 Acknowledgements. ................................................................................ iv Dedication. ........................................................................................... .v Table of Contents. .................................................................................. .vi .. List of Tables....................................................................................... .VII ... List of Figures.. ................................................................................... -.VIII Introduction.. ........................................................................................ -1 . Chapter One - Ongln............................................................................... -17 Chapter Two - Expression........................................................................ -32 Chapter Three - Theory........................................................................... ..49 Chapter Four - Practice............................................................................ -67 Conclusion - Downfall.. ........................................................................... -84 . Blbltography ...................................................................................... .I00 List of Tables Fleet Size Comparison Prior to the Sino-Japanese War ........................................ 48 Graph of IJN ship purchases by tormage/year ..................................................-53 Table of Russian vs . Japanese naval expenditures (Kuropatkin) .......................... -54-5 Chart of IJN vs . IJA expenditures................................................................. 57 Fleet Size Comparison Prior to the Russo-Japanese War ..................................... -66 List of Figures Plate 1. Picture from Japanese reading textbook - flag.. ....................................... 1 I Plate 2. Picture from Japanese reading textbook - troops.. .................................... 1 1 Introduction [1866] A gunboat or two cbangcd hands at this period, and altogether the various Japanese governors collected between them a small, heterogeneous fleet, the very existence of which was scarcely known outsick theit awn anm!ry. Indeed, twenty years later comparatively few pooplo knew, aod stin liwa csnQ that Jopan posses& a navy at dl' -Fred T. Jane, The ImDaial Jal~aneseNaw [1893] On her own soil [Japan] could fhce any foreign pawer. Her navy was her weak point, and of this she was fblly aware. It was a sflendid fleet of small,light auisers, and splendidly handled. Its admiral, without the los of a single vessel, had annihilated the Chinese fleet in two engagements; but it was not yet &ficiently heavy to face the combined navies of three European powers.. .2 -Lafcadio Heam, "After the War," [I9031 So was commmated perhaps tbe most decisive and complete naval victory in history. The Japanese had lost 1t 7 ofiicem and men killed ad583 wounded Three torpedo boats had been sunk and two or three other units of the flotilla disabled, but not one sbip had been in- seriously enough to mther carzying on the campaign The losses of the Russians were about 5,000 killed or drowned, and the prisoners numbered close on 6,000. Four ships and one destroyer had been captured, twelve ships, four destroyers and three auxiliaries had been sunk in action .. , and of the whole 38 units of the Baltic Fleet, only one cruiser, the Alma, and hvo destroyers, Gmiand Bmi, got through to tell the tale at Wadivostok.' -Sir Juiian Stafford Corbett, Maritime Owrations in the Russo-Ja~aneseWar. Volume II 1905 was as triumphant a year for the Japanese as 1759 and 1805 were for the British. The battle of Tsushima - accompanied by the final Japanese Army victory at Mukden - sealed the fate of the Russian Army in Manchuria and guaranteed the security of the Japanese homeland against foreign invasions fiom Asia. The Battle of Tsushima was the culmination of a naval buildup which had started long before the Sino-Japanese War, which saw Japanese ship manufacture and purchase ramped up to meet military threats. The greatest expression of this naval preparation was the three-ship MiRaa purchase completed in 1901, which gave Japan its first first-class