A comprehensive & objective rating of the Elected Representatives’ performance

DELHI

MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016

MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 1 he´pee SkeÀ Dehe#eheeleer mebmLeeve nw pees 1999 mes GÊejoe³eer Meemeve keÀes me#ece yeveeves Praja is a non-partisan organisation working towards enabling accountable governance since 1999. Praja empowers citizens keÀer efoMee ceW keÀece keÀj jner nw~ he´pee veeieefjkeÀeW keÀes peevekeÀejer Deewj heefjhe´s#³e he´oeve keÀj to participate in governance by providing knowledge and Meemeve‑efJeefOe ceW Yeeie uesves kesÀ efueS MeefÊeÀ he´oeve keÀjleer nw leeefkeÀ Jes cele-hesìer lekeÀ ner meerefcele perspective so that they can become politically active and ve jns Deewj jepeveereflekeÀ ªhe mes meef¬eÀ³e Deewj meeqcceefuele nes mekeWÀ~ ³en J³eehekeÀ MeesOekeÀe³e& involved beyond the ballot box. It undertakes extensive keÀjleer nw Deewj veeieefjkeÀeW keÀer mecem³eeDeeW keÀes Gpeeiej keÀjleer nw leeefkeÀ Jes GmekesÀ he´efle peeieªkeÀ research and highlights civic issues to build the awareness of, and mobilize action by the government and elected nes mekeWÀ, Deewj mejkeÀejer Deewj ®e³eefvele he´efleefveefOe³eeW kesÀ keÀece keÀes ueeceyebo keÀj mekeWÀ~ representatives.

mecem³ee he´pee keÀer he´efleef¬eÀ³ee THE PROBLEM PRAJA's RESPONSE he´pee keÀe ceevevee nw efkeÀ De®íer Meemeve-efJeefOe keÀer he´pee DeeBkeÀæ[eW hej DeeOeeefjle MeesOekeÀe³e& keÀjleer nw Praja believes that uninformed and Praja conducts data driven keÀceer kesÀ efueS DeveefYe%e Deewj Deueie-Leueie heæ[s Deewj veeieefjkeÀeW, ceeref[³ee, Deewj mejkeÀejer he´Meemeve disengaged elected representatives research and provides information and administration, rather than on civic issues to citizens, media, efveJee&ef®ele he´efleefveefOe Deewj he´Meemeve ef]peccesoej keÀes peve mecem³eeDeeW mes mecyebefOele peevekeÀejer he´oeve existing systems or policies, are and government administration and nQ, ve efkeÀ ceewpetoe mece³e kesÀ leb$e ³ee veerefle³eeB~ keÀjleer nw Deewj ®egves ieS he´efleefveefOe³eeW kesÀ meeLe responsible for the lack of good works with elected representatives FmekesÀ DeefleefjÊeÀ, veeieefjkeÀeW Deewj mLeeveer³e efceuekeÀj GvekeÀer keÀe³e&-he´Ceeefue³eeW ceW DekegÀMeuelee governance. Additionally, there is a to identify and address inefficiencies mejkeÀej kesÀ yeer®e he´YeeJeMeeueer Jeeo-J³eJnej keÀer hen®eeve keÀjves Deewj Gme keÀes otj keÀjves, met®evee paucity of tools to facilitate effective in their work processes, bridge the keÀes megefJeOeepevekeÀ yeveeves kesÀ GhekeÀjCeeW kesÀ Yeer kesÀ Deblej keÀes heeìves, Deewj GvnW megOeej nsleg Ghee³e interaction between citizens and information gaps, and aid them in the local government. taking corrective measures. DeeYeeJe nw~ keÀjves ceW ceoo keÀjves kesÀ efueS keÀece keÀjleer nw~ HOW DID IT EVOLVE? FmekeÀe efJekeÀeme kewÀmes ngDee? 1999 2003 2005 2008 2014 1999 2003 2005 2008 2014 Praja, along with the Teamed up with BMC Published Mumbai Initiated Praja Conducted Brihan Mumbai Municipal and built its citizen's Citizen's Handbook to Dialogue; launched workshops Corporation (BMC), grievance redressal demystify governance CityScan, an online with elected he´pee ves ye=nve cegcyeF& veiej efveiece yeerScemeer kesÀ meeLe efceuekeÀj GmekesÀ cegcyeF& kesÀ Meemeve keÀes he´pee mebJeeo keÀer Meg©Deele keÀer; ®egves ieS he´efleefveefOe³eeW keÀes veerefle³eeW created Mumbai's first mechanism, The in Mumbai; About collation of extensive representatives, (yeerScemeer) kesÀ meeLe efceuekeÀj, veeieefjkeÀeW keÀe efMekeÀ³ele efveoeve jnm³e‑jefnle Deewj mheä keÀjves kesÀ efmeìermkewÀve keÀe DeejcYe, cegcyeF& kesÀ Deewj YetefcekeÀeDeeW keÀe %eeve osves kesÀ Citizen Charter Online Complaint and 2 lakh copies data on civic and educating them on Management System distributed security Issues In policies and roles; cegcyeF& keÀe henuee veeieefjkeÀ leb$e, Dee@veueeFve kebÀhueWì Sb[ efueS cegcyeF& efmeìerpevme nQ[yegkeÀ veeieefjkeÀ SJeb megj#ee kesÀ cegÎeW hej efueS keÀe³e&Meeuee³eW Dee³eesefpele (OCMS), and conducted Mumbai; Published started the Delhi DeefOekeÀej he$e yevee³ee cewvespeceWì efmemìce (DeesmeerSceSme) he´keÀeefMele keÀer; ueieYeie 2 ueeKe J³eehekeÀ DeeBkeÀæ[eW keÀer Dee@veueeFve keÀer; cegcyeF& ceW efJekeÀefmele cee@[ue complaint audits in the Councilor handbook; Chapter to replicate ensuing years and annual report the model developed lew³eej efkeÀ³ee, Deewj Deeieeceer Je

Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 1 efJe

DeO³ee³e he=ÿ mebK³ee Chapter Pg. No.

ìerce 4 The Team 5

efjheesì& keÀe[& keÀer DeeJeM³ekeÀlee ke̳eeW heæ[er Deewj FmeceW ke̳ee nw? 6 Why was a Report Card needed and what does it contain? 7

he´ekeÌkeÀLeve 8 Foreword 9

DeeYeej 10 Acknowledgements 11

Jemlegefveÿ lejerkesÀ mes Hee

Hee

ÞesCeer Jeeues he=ÿ keÀes kewÀmes heæ{W 16 How to read the Ranking Page 16 Key Analysis 154 cegK³e efJeMues

185 (4) pevecele mebie´n kesÀ Devegmeej ueesieeW keÀer OeejCee kesÀ efueS ceeHeob[ (4) Parameters for People’s Perception as per Opinion Poll 198

190 (5) $eÝCeelcekeÀ ceeHeob[ (5) Parameters for Negative Marking 204

2 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 3 ìerce THE TEAM

he´pee ì^mìer yees[& [e@ megcee ef®eìveerme Praja Board of Trustee Dr. Suma Chitnis meeceeefpekeÀ Jew%eeefvekeÀ SJeb hetJe& GhekegÀueheefle, Social Scientist & former Vice Chancellor, SNDT University efveleeF& cesnlee SmeSve[erìer efJeéeefJeÐeeue³e Nitai Mehta Managing Trustee, Praja Foundation; he´yebOekeÀ ì^mìer, he´pee HeÀeGb[sMeve; Vinay Sanghi efJeve³e meebIeer Entrepreneur Entrepreneur J³eJemee³eer J³eJemee³eer, Sumangali Gada megcebieueer ie[e Founder Trustee, Praja Foundation; Market Research Agency mebmLeehekeÀ ì^mìer, he´pee HeÀeGb[sMeve; J³eJemee³eer yeepeej DevegmebOeeve SpeWmeer Entrepreneur Hansa Research nbmee jerme®e& Devegpe YeieJeleer Anuj Bhagwati Ashok Das Managing Director, Hansa Research ì^mìer, he´pee HeÀe@GC[sMeve; J³eJemee³eer DeMeeskeÀ oeme Trustee, Praja Foundation; Entrepreneur DeeFefjme ceoerje he´yebOe efveosMekeÀ, nbmee efjme®e& Iris Madeira Anjan Ghosh Senior Vice President, Hansa Research ì^mìer, he´pee HeÀeGb[sMeve]; efMe#ee meueenkeÀej Debpeve Iees

4 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 5 WHY WAS A REPORT CARD NEEDED AND efjheesì& keÀe[& keÀer DeeJeM³ekeÀlee ke̳eeW heæ[er Deewj FmeceW ke̳ee nw? WHAT DOES IT CONTAIN?

Yeejle kesÀ ueesie ves efveJee&ef®ele he´efleefveefOe³eeW efceues nQ efpevneWves efheíues 60 JeIndia have had Elected Representatives representing them in efJeefYeVe efvekeÀe³eeW ceW he´efleefveefOelJe efkeÀ³ee nw~ various bodies from the parliament to the panchayat for the last 60 years. These representatives have deliberated, debated, questioned, proposed Fve he´efleefveefOe³eeW ves efJe®eej-efJeceMe& efkeÀ³ee, yenme keÀer, meJeeue efkeÀS, veS keÀevetveeW keÀe he´mleeJe jKee, ve³ee keÀevetve new laws, passed new laws and governed the nation at all levels using the heeefjle efkeÀ³ee Deewj Yeejle kesÀ mebefJeOeeve Üeje GvnW efoS ieS leb$e keÀe Ghe³eesie keÀjles ngS meYeer mlejeW hej jeä^ mechanisms given to them by the Constitution of India. The 1950 constitution hej Meemeve efkeÀ³ee~ 1950 keÀe mebefJeOeeve pees nceveW mJe³eb keÀes meeQhee Gmeves yelee³ee efkeÀ nce kewÀmes Kegohej jepe which we gave to ourselves laid out the way in which we would govern keÀjW~ efheíues leerve oMekeÀeW ceW nceves efJeefYeVe keÀejCeeW mes Meemeve keÀer iegCeJeÊee ceW ueieeleej efiejeJeì osKeer nw, ourselves. In the last three decades we have seen a steady decline in the quality of governance due to various reasons, prime amongst them being GveceW mes he´cegKe jns nQ jepeveerefle keÀe J³eeJemee³eerkeÀjCe Deewj DehejeOeerkeÀjCe, efpememes nceejs osMe ceW Meemeve keÀe commercialisation of politics and criminalisation of politics, this has created a yengle DeefOekeÀ DeeYeeJe hewoe nes ie³ee nw~ huge governance deficit in our country. Fme kesÀ DeefOekeÀebMe Yeeie ceW celeoelee SkeÀ cetkeÀ ieJeen yevee jne nw Deewj mejkeÀej Deewj efveJee&ef®ele he´efleefveefOe³eeW The Electorate has remained a silent witness for most part of this and mes efvejeMe Deewj veeje]pe cenmetme keÀj jne nw~ are feeling let down and frustrated by the Government and the elected representatives. ®egveeJeeW kesÀ oewjeve ner veeieefjkeÀeW keÀer `me®eceg®e' megveer peeleer nw Deewj Ssmee heeB®e meeueeW ceW SkeÀ yeej neslee nw~ The time when the citizen has a ‘real’ say, is during elections which happens ®egveeJe keÀe mece³e ner Jen mece³e neslee nw peye efveJee&ef®ele he´efleefveefOe³eeW keÀe Gme DeJeefOe ceW GvekesÀ he´oMe&ve kesÀ efueS once in five years. The elections are the only time when the elected celeoeleeDeeW Üeje DeebkeÀueve efkeÀ³ee peelee nQ~ representatives are appraised for their performance in the corresponding term by the electorate. Meemeve keÀer yeæ{leer mecem³eeDeeW Deewj veeieefjkeÀeW keÀer ueieeleej yeæ{leer peªjleeW keÀes osKeles ngS, SkeÀ melele mebJeeo Looking at the growing problems of Governance and the ever increasing Deewj efveJee&ef®ele he´efleefveefOe³eeW keÀer keÀe³e&he´Ceeueer kesÀ cetu³eebkeÀve keÀer DeeJeM³ekeÀlee nw~ needs of the citizens there is a need of a continuous dialogue and appraisal ³en melele mebJeeo Deewj cetu³eebkeÀve keÀer DeeJeM³ekeÀlee kesÀ keÀejCe he´pee ves Fme efjheesì& keÀe[& keÀes efJekeÀefmele of the working of the elected representatives. efkeÀ³ee nw~ It is this need of continuous dialogue and appraisal that made Praja develop this Report Card. efveJee&ef®ele he´efleefveefOe³eeW kesÀ efve

6 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 7 he´ekeÌkeÀLeve Foreword

he´pee ves efouueerJeeefme³eeW kesÀ mece#e efouueer kesÀ leerveeW veiej efveieceeW kesÀ hee

efveleeF& cesnlee, NITAI MEHTA, J³eJemLeehekeÀer³e efJeéemle, Managing Trustee, he´pee HeÀeTb[sMeve Praja Foundation

8 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 9 DeeYeej Acknowledgements

Fme yeele hej keÀYeer Yeer mebosn cele keÀjes efkeÀ efJe®eejMeerue, he´efleye× veeieefjkeÀeW keÀe SkeÀ Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed íesìe mee mecetn ogefve³ee yeoue mekeÀlee nw; ³ener SkeÀcee$e yeele nw pees DeyelekeÀ ngF& nw~ citizens can change the world; indeed, it’s the only thing that – ever has. ceeiee&jsì ceer[ – Margaret Mead

peneB mece³e keÀer ³en ceeBie nw efkeÀ nce GþW Deewj Gme heefjJele&ve keÀer ceeBie keÀjW Deewj Gmes uee³eW~ The change comes when people stand up and demand for it, and then strive to get it. Today we are at that juncture of history where time demands that we stand Fme efjheesì& keÀe[& keÀes lew³eej keÀjves ceW Meeefceue ueesie hetjer lejn mes ³en ceeveles nQ efkeÀ peye mece³e Gvemes kegÀí up and demand that change and go and get it. keÀjves keÀer Gcceero keÀj jne nw lees Jes ®eghe-®eehe meyekegÀí osKeles ngS Fble]peej veneR keÀj mekeÀles~ Fme efjheesì& keÀe[& Individuals involved in developing this report card strongly believe that they cannot keÀes efJekeÀefmele keÀjves kesÀ efueS Gve meYeer ueesieeW ves Yeejle kesÀ mebefJeOeeve Deewj GmekesÀ Üeje - mebefJeOeeve kesÀ G®®e just wait and remain mute spectators when time is demanding action from them. All DeeoMeeX - v³ee³e, mJeleb$elee, meceevelee Deewj YeeF&®eejs keÀes neefmeue keÀjves kesÀ iegj keÀer efoMee ceW - yesnlej Deewj of them have come together to develop this report card with a over-arching belief kegÀMeue Meemeve yeveeves kesÀ DeJemej ceW J³eehekeÀ efJeéeeme kesÀ meeLe efceuekeÀj keÀece efkeÀ³ee nw~ in the Constitution of India and the opportunity it creates for improved and efficient governance - the mean towards achieving the high ideals of the constitution - Justice, ³en hegeqmlekeÀe he´pee keÀer ceewefuekeÀ ìerce kesÀ JeemleefJekeÀ, mebye× he´³eemeeW keÀe SkeÀ mebie´n nw~ nce, efJeMes

Madhu Mehta Foundation Madhu Mehta Foundation ìeìe ì^mìdme ves Fme heefj³eespevee ceW he´pee HeÀeGb[sMeve keÀes men³eesie efo³ee nw~ ³en ì^mì De®íer Tata Trusts have supported Praja Foundation in this project. The lejn mes metef®ele veeieefjkeÀeW ceW efJeéeeme jKeleer nw Deewj Fmeer efoMee ceW ìeìe ì^mìdme veeieefjkeÀeW Trusts believe in a society of well-informed citizens and it is to this effect that Tata Trusts supports Praja’s efforts to communicate with keÀes DeefYeveJe SJeb he´YeeJeMeeueer lejerkeÀeW kesÀ ceeO³ece mes Deheves he´MeemekeÀeW kesÀ meeLe yeele-®eerle and enable citizens to interact with their administration through Deewj Gvemes efceueves-pegueves kesÀ efueS me#ece yeveeves kesÀ he´pee kesÀ he´³eemeeW keÀe men³eesie keÀjles nQ~ innovative and effective methods.

10 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 11 ASSESSING THE PERFORMANCE OF Jemlegefveÿ lejerkesÀ mes Hee

Yeejle ceW jepeveerefle%eeW keÀer Deeuees®evee keÀe he´®eueve nw~ he´Mve ³en Gþlee nw efkeÀ: nceejs ®e³eefvele he´efleefveefOe³eeW The air in India is thick with criticism of politicians. The question that arises is: how can the performance of our elected representatives be assessed kesÀ he´oMe&ve keÀe Jemlegefveÿ DeebkeÀueve kewÀmes efkeÀ³ee pee mekeÀlee nw? ³e]keÀerveve Gvemes GvekesÀ ner efJe®eej hetívee objectively? Surely the right way cannot be by asking them for their opinion mener lejerkeÀe veneR nesiee~ ve ner GvekeÀe DeebkeÀueve keÀjves kesÀ efueS ®ebo jepeveweflekeÀ hebef[leeW (efpevekeÀe Dehevee ner of themselves. Nor is it adequate to get a few political pundits (who may have ¢eqäkeÀesCe nes mekeÀlee nw) keÀes hetívee he³ee&hle nesiee~ their own angles) to evaluate them. Ssmee DeebkeÀueve keÀjves keÀe SkeÀcee$e lejerkeÀe pees efve

12 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 13 Details of MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS PROFILES who have not been consider in Report Card

AND Name Party Details Reasons PERFORMANCE Age: 45 Mayor Education: Senior Secondary (2015-2016) School OF Profession: Business & Director in Pvt. Ltd. Companies Zone: Karol Bagh MUNICIPAL BJP Constituency: 91, (Area: Karol Bagh) COUNCILLORS Ravinder Gupta Corporation: NDMC

Age 72 Mayor (2015-2016) Education: Higher Secondary Profession: Business Zone: West Constituency: 105 BJP (Area: Rajouri Garden) Corporation: SDMC Subhash Arya

Age: 51 Mayor (2015-2016) Education: L.L.B. Profession: Business Zone: Shahdara North Constituency: 248 BJP (Area: Welcome Colony) Corporation: EDMC Harshdeep Malhotra Of the total 272 Municipal Councillors from the city, the overall ranking is done for 255; while three Councillors who are Mayor were not ranked and 14 seats were vacant. Councillors' party, education, profession, constituency details & age have been taken from the affidavit submitted by the candidate during the election and/or from Delhi corporation website. For understanding details on the ranking and scales of the marking kindly go to the section While 14 seats vacant for the following Constituencies were not ranked : Quammruddin of methodology. Nagar(44); Shalimar Bagh (55); Wazirpur (67); Ballimaran (86); Milap Nagar (119); Vikas Nagar Henceforth : MCD - Municipal Corporation of Delhi; NDMC - North Delhi Municipal Corporation; (124); Nawada (126); Matiala (136); Munirka (166); Nanak Pura (168); Bhati (176); Tekhand SDMC - South Delhi Municipal Corporation; EDMC - East Delhi Municipal Corporation. (199); Khichripur (214); Jhilmil (238).

14 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 15 HOW TO READ THE RANKING PAGE : DELHI’S

Overall Rank for the current year (2016) is given after summation of all the weightages. The top three ranks are MUNICIPAL awarded a trophy - The Torch. The First gets gold, the second silver and the third bronze. COUNCILLORS

NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK AND THEIR COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30 RANKINGS C 67.59 3 A 15.00 A 9.08 E 13.04 A 5 C 20.48

Total Scores Personal A details

Areas for ranking: Colour Coding: B 1. Attendance Grade ‘A’ – 100% to 80% marks 2. Issues Raised 3. Quality of Issues Raised Grade ‘B’ – Less than 80% to 70% marks (Importance of Issue Raised + Grade ‘C’ – Less than 70% to 60% marks Issue Raised Compared to Citizen's Grade ‘D’ – Less than 60% to 50% marks E Complaints) Grade ‘E’ – Less than 50% to 35% marks C 4. Least Criminal Record Grade ‘F’ – Less than 35% marks F (including the negative marking for criminal records) 5. Perceived Performance D (Perception of Public Services + Perceived as Accessible + Perceived Least Corrupt + Broad Measures)

16 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 17 NDMC

Not to Scale

18 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 19 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

67.28 14.78 8.26 12.02 5 20.22 2016 C 4 A A E A C BJP

Age: 36, Edu.: HSC, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Narela Ward Committee, Kesh Rani Zone: Narela, Constituency No.: 1, (Area: Narela), Corporation: NDMC Environment Management Services Committee, Rural Area Committee

64.98 11.90 10.00 11.04 5 20.03 2016 C 13 B A F A C BJP

Mohan Prasad Age: 62, Edu.: B.A., Profession & Occupation: Pensioner, Agriculturist Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Narela Ward Committee, Municipal Accounts Committee, Bhardwaj Zone: Narela, Constituency No.: 2, (Area: Bankner), Corporation: NDMC Standing Committee, Rural Area Committee

56.03 7.35 4.38 13.49 5 18.81 2016 D 59 E E E A C INC

Age: 35, Edu.: Not Given, Profession & Occupation: Housewife Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Narela Ward Committee, Medical Relief & Public Health Aruna Devi Zone: Narela, Constituency No.: 3, (Area: Alipur), Corporation: NDMC Committee, Law & General Purposes Committee, Hindi Committee, Rural Area Committee

32.67 2.47 0 0 5 19.20 2016 F 98 F F F A C BSP

Age: 33, Edu.: Not Given, Profession & Occupation: Agriculture Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Narela Ward Committee, Reeta Zone: Narela, Constituency No.: 4, (Area: Bakhtawarpur), Corporation: NDMC Rural Area Committee

20 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 21 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

65.82 14.46 8.87 10.99 5 19.50 2016 C 8 A A F A C BJP Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Civil Line Ward Committee, Appointments Promotions, Ram Kishan Age: 49, Edu.: B.A. IInd year, Profession & Occupation: LIC Commission Agent Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Zone: Civil Line, Constituency No.: 5, (Area: Bhalswa Jahangirpuri), Corporation: NDMC Bansiwal Rural Area Committee, Education Committee

56.81 9.98 6.63 14.09 0 19.12 2016 D 56 C C E F C LJSP

Gulab Singh Age: 45, Edu.: Matric, Profession & Occupation: Self employed Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Civil Line Ward Committee, Rathore Zone: Civil Line, Constituency No.: 6, (Area: Mukandpur), Corporation: NDMC Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Municipal Accounts Committee, Rural Area Committee

62.08 11.99 6.83 12.61 5 19.65 2016 C 23 B C E A C INC Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Civil Line Ward Committee, Appointments Promotions, Age: 37, Edu.: HSC, Profession & Occupation: Social Worker Aman Tyagi Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Environment Management Services Committee, Zone: Civil Line, Constituency No.: 7, (Area: Burari), Corporation: NDMC Rural Area Committee

64.25 14.13 5.81 13.44 5 18.87 2016 C 16 A D E A C BJP Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Civil Line Ward Committee, Environment Management Services Age: 42, Edu.: B.A., Profession & Occupation: Businessman & Social Worker Committee, Law & General Purposes Committee, High Powered Property Taxes Committee, Raj Pal Rana Zone: Civil Line, Constituency No.: 8, (Area: Jharoda), Corporation: NDMC Rural Area Committee

22 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 23 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

59.85 11.47 7.95 10.71 5 18.73 2016 D 36 B B F A C INC

Age: 40, Edu.: Up to 10th, Profession & Occupation: Readymade Garments Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Civil Line Ward Committee, Medical Relief & Public Health Guddi Devi Zone: Civil Line, Constituency No.: 9, (Area: Malka Ganj), Corporation: NDMC Committee, High Powered Property Taxes Committee, Code of Conduct for Councillors Committee

45.92 5.26 1.93 9.48 5 17.25 2016 E 88 E F F A D INC

Age: 45, Edu.: B.A., Profession & Occupation: Partnership in L.P.G. Distributorship Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Civil Line Ward Committee, Hindi Committee, Sunita Chaudhary Zone: Civil Line, Constituency No.: 10, (Area: Timarpur), Corporation: NDMC Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee, High Powered Property Taxes Committee, Education Committee

40.48 5.23 0.40 5.78 5 17.07 2016 E 96 F F F A D BJP Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Civil Line Ward Committee, Assurance Committee, Age: 53, Edu.: PHD in Law, Profession & Occupation: Professor Rajni Abbi Appointments Promotions, Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Municipal Accounts Committee, Zone: Civil Line, Constituency No.: 11, (Area: Mukherjee Nagar), Corporation: NDMC Code of Conduct for Councillors Committee

47.23 4.34 0.91 12.38 5 17.61 2016 E 85 F F E A D BJP

Age: 37, Edu.: Graduate, Profession & Occupation: Teacher Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Civil Line Ward Committee, Reema Kaur Zone: Civil Line, Constituency No.: 12, (Area: G T B Nagar), Corporation: NDMC Environment Management Services Committee, Garden Committee, Law & General Purposes Committee

24 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 25 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

65.37 10.07 9.79 12.30 5 22.20 2016 C 10 C A E A B INC

Mukesh Kumar Age: 55, Edu.: Utama in Economics, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Civil Line Ward Committee, Appointments Promotions, Goel Zone: Civil Line, Constituency No.: 13, (Area: Dhirpur), Corporation: NDMC Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, High Powered Property Taxes Committee, Standing Committee

64.39 13.17 7.24 11.69 5 21.29 2016 C 14 A B E A B BJP Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Civil Line Ward Committee, Appointments Promotions, Age: 50, Edu.: B.A., Profession & Occupation: Business Neelam Budhiraja Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Works Committee, Garden Committee, Zone: Civil Line, Constituency No.: 14, (Area: Adarsh Nagar), Corporation: NDMC High Powered Property Taxes Committee

50.78 8.79 5.81 12.22 -2 18.97 2016 D 79 D D E F C BSP

Parmesh Kumar Age: 43, Edu.: Eleventh, Profession & Occupation: Cable TV Operator Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Civil Line Ward Committee, Chauhan Zone: Civil Line, Constituency No.: 15, (Area: Sarai Pipal Thala), Corporation: NDMC Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Hindi Committee, High Powered Property Taxes Committee

55.91 9.58 4.38 11.59 5 20.36 2016 D 61 C E E A C INC

Parma Bhai Age: 46, Edu.: Seventh, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Civil Line Ward Committee, Works Committee, Solanki Zone: Civil Line, Constituency No.: 16, (Area: Jahangir Puri - I), Corporation: NDMC Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Environment Management Services Committee

26 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 27 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

57.90 9.02 5.00 12.84 5 19.04 2016 D 48 C D E A C BJP

Age: 49, Edu.: Matriculation, Profession & Occupation: Employed Mamta Rathore Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Civil Line Ward Committee, Municipal Accounts Committee Zone: Civil Line, Constituency No.: 17, (Area: Samaypur Badli), Corporation: NDMC

53.78 7.21 2.34 12.77 5 19.47 2016 D 68 E F E A C BJP

Age: 67, Edu.: Higher Secondary, Profession & Occupation: Social Worker/Land Lady Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Civil Line Ward Committee, Medical Relief & Public Health Anguri Devi Zone: Civil Line, Constituency No.: 18, (Area: Libaspur), Corporation: NDMC Committee, Law & General Purposes Committee, Hindi Committee, Rural Area Committee

65.70 14.11 7.75 12.76 5 19.07 2016 C 9 A B E A C INC Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Civil Line Ward Committee, Ajeet Singh Age: 52, Edu.: Graduation, Profession & Occupation: Farmer Works Committee, Environment Management Services Committee, Zone: Civil Line, Constituency No.: 19, (Area: Bhalswa), Corporation: NDMC Yadav Garden Committee, Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee, Rural Area Committee

58.52 13.79 3.46 11.15 5 19.12 2016 D 43 A F F A C BJP

Satya Wati Age: 56, Edu.: HSC, Profession & Occupation: Housewife Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Civil Line Ward Committee, Garden Committee, Chauhan Zone: Civil Line, Constituency No.: 20, (Area: Jahangir Puri-II), Corporation: NDMC Hindi Committee, Municipal Accounts Committee

28 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 29 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

59.86 10.21 6.93 12.48 5 18.24 2016 D 35 C C E A C BJP Age: 52, Edu.: B.A., Profession & Occupation: Prop. In M/s Semtron India Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Rohini Ward Committee, Works Committee, Parvesh Wahi (Manufacturing of TV Parts) Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee, Standing Committee Zone: Rohini, Constituency No.: 21, (Area: Rohini), Corporation: NDMC

58.99 9.60 1.42 13.87 5 22.10 2016 D 40 C F E A B INC

Age: 46, Edu.: M.A., Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Rohini Ward Committee, Shashi Zone: Rohini, Constituency No.: 22, (Area: Rithala), Corporation: NDMC Medical Relief & Public Health Committee

55.99 8.56 4.08 12.47 5 18.88 2016 D 60 D E E A C BJP

Age: 47, Edu.: SSC, Profession & Occupation: Property Dealer Anil Sharma Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Rohini Ward Committee, Assurance Committee Zone: Rohini, Constituency No.: 23, (Area: Budh Vihar), Corporation: NDMC

IND 51.75 7.96 2.85 12.55 5 17.39 2016 D 75 D F E A D

Age: 42, Edu.: Seventh, Profession & Occupation: Housewife & Social Worker Pushpa Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Rohini Ward Committee Zone: Rohini, Constituency No.: 24, (Area: Vijay Vihar), Corporation: NDMC

30 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 31 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

61.26 13.19 4.38 10.63 5 21.05 2016 C 30 A E F A B BJP

Age: 41, Edu.: Matriculation, Profession & Occupation: Self employed Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Rohini Ward Committee, Devender Solanki Zone: Rohini, Constituency No.: 25, (Area: Pooth Kalan), Corporation: NDMC Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee, Rural Area Committee

59.90 14.20 6.42 13.33 5 14.95 2016 D 34 A C E A E INC

Sharadha Nand Age: 47, Edu.: B.A., Profession & Occupation: Self employed Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Rohini Ward Committee, Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Sangwan Zone: Rohini, Constituency No.: 26, (Area: Sahibabad Daulat Pur), Corporation: NDMC Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee, Rural Area Committee

61.82 13.52 6.02 12.33 5 18.95 2016 C 28 A C E A C BJP

Age: 59, Edu.: Seventh, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Narela Ward Committee, Hindi Committee, Jag Roshni Zone: Narela, Constituency No.: 27, (Area: Begumpur), Corporation: NDMC High Powered Property Taxes Committee, Rural Area Committee

47.38 6.37 7.34 12.01 0 15.66 2016 E 84 E B E F D INC

Age: 49, Edu.: SSC, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Narela Ward Committee, Devender Kumar Zone: Narela, Constituency No.: 28, (Area: Bawana), Corporation: NDMC Environment Management Services Committee, Hindi Committee, Rural Area Committee

32 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 33 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

32.17 1.46 0 0 5 18.71 2016 F 99 F F F A C INC

Manisha Jasbir Age: 43, Edu.: Matriculation, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Narela Ward Committee, Assurance Committee, Karala Zone: Narela, Constituency No.: 29, (Area: Karala), Corporation: NDMC Appointments Promotions, Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Rural Area Committee

56.84 11.48 5.40 12.09 3 18.87 2016 D 55 B D E C C BJP

Age: 64, Edu.: Bachelor of Arts, Profession & Occupation: Self Pension Azad Singh Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Narela Ward Committee, Rural Area Committee Zone: Narela, Constituency No.: 30, (Area: Mundka), Corporation: NDMC

62.32 13.34 6.73 12.75 5 17.50 2016 C 20 A C E A D INC

Bhoomi Age: 41, Edu.: HSC, Profession & Occupation: Social Worker Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Narela Ward Committee, Standing Committee Rachhoya Zone: Narela, Constituency No.: 31, (Area: Nangloi Jat West), Corporation: NDMC

IND 32.78 2.69 0.30 5.82 5 12.97 2016 F 97 F F F A E

Age: 35, Edu.: HSC, Profession & Occupation: Social Worker Reeta Shokeen Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Narela Ward Committee, Rural Area Committee Zone: Narela, Constituency No.: 32, (Area: Nilothi), Corporation: NDMC

34 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 35 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

55.28 12.40 3.97 11.30 5 16.61 2016 D 64 A E F A D BJP

Ram Dayal Age: 43, Edu.: Eighth, Profession & Occupation: Building Material Supplier and Flour Mill Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Rohini Ward Committee, Works Committee, Mahto Zone: Rohini, Constituency No.: 33, (Area: Pratap Vihar), Corporation: NDMC Medical Relief & Public Health Committee

59.52 14.54 2.65 11.82 5 19.51 2016 D 39 A F E A C BJP Age: Not Given, Edu.: Secondary School, Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Rohini Ward Committee, Hindi Committee, Nirmla Profession & Occupation: Social Worker/Housewife High Powered Property Taxes Committee, Rural Area Committee Zone: Rohini, Constituency No.: 34, (Area: Nithari), Corporation: NDMC

56.87 10.79 4.18 13.86 5 16.03 2016 D 54 B E E A D BSP

Age: 43, Edu.: B.A., Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Rohini Ward Committee, Works Committee, Medical Relief & Satyapal Singh Zone: Rohini, Constituency No.: 35, (Area: Kirari Suleman Nagar), Corporation: NDMC Public Health Committee, Environment Management Services Committee, Rural Area Committee

41.72 3.17 1.12 11.21 5 16.22 2016 E 94 F F F A D BSP

Age: 48, Edu.: Graduate, Profession & Occupation: Social Worker Pushp Raj Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Rohini Ward Committee Zone: Rohini, Constituency No.: 36, (Area: Prem Nagar), Corporation: NDMC

36 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 37 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

56.15 8.37 5.20 13.12 5 18.46 2016 D 58 D D E A C BJP

Age: 38, Edu.: Ninth, Profession & Occupation: Councillor (Sitting) Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Rohini Ward Committee, Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Sushila Kumari Zone: Rohini, Constituency No.: 37, (Area: Sultanpuri East), Corporation: NDMC Garden Committee, Code of Conduct for Councillors Committee

53.46 9.92 3.67 10.50 5 19.37 2016 D 69 C E F A C BJP

Age: 43, Edu.: Upto 5th, Profession & Occupation: Social Worker Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Rohini Ward Committee, Works Committee, Manju Devi Zone: Rohini, Constituency No.: 38, (Area: Mangolpuri North), Corporation: NDMC Environment Management Services Committee, Hindi Committee

48.29 4.12 3.06 12.32 5 16.78 2016 E 83 F F E A D BSP

Age: 36, Edu.: HSC, Profession & Occupation: Self employed Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Rohini Ward Committee, Works Committee, Prabhu Dayal Zone: Rohini, Constituency No.: 39, (Area: Sultan Pur Majra), Corporation: NDMC Hindi Committee, Rural Area Committee

45.57 4.85 1.93 11.54 5 16.25 2016 E 91 F F F A D BSP

Age: 41, Edu.: Not Given, Profession & Occupation: Self employed Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Rohini Ward Committee, Manisha Gupta Zone: Rohini, Constituency No.: 40, (Area: Sultanpuri South), Corporation: NDMC Garden Committee, Rural Area Committee

38 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 39 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

53.45 8.18 1.63 11.08 5 20.56 2016 D 70 D F F A C BJP

Surender Mohan Age: 54, Edu.: Senior School Certificate Examination, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Rohini Ward Committee, Pandey Zone: Rohini, Constituency No.: 41, (Area: Guru Hari Kishan Nagar), Corporation: NDMC Environment Management Services Committee, Law & General Purposes Committee

66.75 12.36 9.38 12.89 5 20.12 2016 C 5 A A E A C INC

Prithvi Singh Age: Not Given, Edu.: SSC, Profession & Occupation: Income from Rental & Pension Holder Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Rohini Ward Committee, Rathore Zone: Rohini, Constituency No.: 42, (Area: Peera Garhi), Corporation: NDMC Works Committee, Standing Committee

61.78 11.91 5.40 12.10 5 20.37 2016 C 29 B D E A C BJP

Age: Not Given, Edu.: Not Given, Profession & Occupation: Not Given Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Rohini Ward Committee, Environment Management Services Renu Zone: Rohini, Constituency No.: 43, (Area: Nangloi East), Corporation: NDMC Committee, Law & General Purposes Committee, Rural Area Committee

45.92 11.35 1.63 11.60 -5 20.34 2016 E 87 B F E F C BJP

Age: 52, Edu.: Fifth, Profession & Occupation: Business Sanjana Singh Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Rohini Ward Committee, Garden Committee, Hindi Committee Zone: Rohini, Constituency No.: 45, (Area: Rohini South), Corporation: NDMC

40 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 41 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

48.77 6.52 2.34 8.48 5 19.43 2016 E 82 E F F A C INC

Age: 30, Edu.: HSC, Profession & Occupation: Service (Computer Teacher) Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Rohini Ward Committee, Environment Management Services Committee, Seema Jatav Zone: Rohini, Constituency No.: 46, (Area: Mangolpuri East), Corporation: NDMC Garden Committee, Municipal Accounts Committee, Code of Conduct for Councillors Committee

52.85 8.59 3.06 13.65 5 15.54 2016 D 73 D F E A D INC

Ashok Kr. Age: 47, Edu.: B.A., Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Rohini Ward Committee, Assurance Committee, Garden Committee, Shokeen Zone: Rohini, Constituency No.: 47, (Area: Mangolpuri), Corporation: NDMC Law & General Purposes Committee

54.78 8.69 5.30 12.45 5 17.34 2016 D 65 D D E A D BSP

Age: 28, Edu.: Bachelor of Arts, Profession & Occupation: Social Worker Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Rohini Ward Committee, Appointments Promotions, Poonam Zone: Rohini, Constituency No.: 48, (Area: Mangolpuri West), Corporation: NDMC Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee

57.27 12.96 6.32 10.83 3 17.16 2016 D 52 A C F C D BJP

Vijay Prakash Age: 47, Edu.: Graduate (B.A.), Profession & Occupation: Self Employed Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Rohini Ward Committee, Pandey Zone: Rohini, Constituency No.: 49, (Area: Rohini North), Corporation: NDMC Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Environment Management Services Committee

42 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 43 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

53.86 9.19 2.75 12.13 5 17.79 2016 D 67 C F E A D BJP

Age: 52, Edu.: Ph.D., Profession & Occupation: Social Worker Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Rohini Ward Committee, Appointments Promotions, Shobha Vijender Zone: Rohini, Constituency No.: 50, (Area: Rohini Central), Corporation: NDMC Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Law & General Purposes Committee

65.97 14.75 8.06 11.20 5 19.96 2016 C 7 A A F A C BJP

Tara Chand Age: 56, Edu.: B.A., Profession & Occupation: Property Dealer/Consultant Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Rohini Ward Committee, Assurance Committee, Appointments Bansal Zone: Rohini, Constituency No.: 51, (Area: Rohini East), Corporation: NDMC Promotions, Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Works Committee, Law & General Purposes Committee

55.46 12.90 1.93 8.32 5 20.30 2016 D 62 A F F A C BJP

Age: 47, Edu.: Not Given, Profession & Occupation: Not Given Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Rohini Ward Committee, Assurance Committee, Neelam Goel Zone: Rohini, Constituency No.: 52, (Area: Naharpur), Corporation: NDMC Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee

58.23 12.31 3.77 10.48 5 19.67 2016 D 45 A E F A C BJP

Chandi Ram Age: 60, Edu.: Higher Secondary, Profession & Occupation: (Business) Housery Under Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Rohini Ward Committee, Appointments Promotions, Chawla Zone: Rohini, Constituency No.: 53, (Area: Pitampura South), Corporation: NDMC Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Works Committee, Garden Committee

44 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 45 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

53.35 6.82 3.87 9.69 5 20.97 2016 D 71 E E F A C BJP

Age: 41, Edu.: B.Com, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Rohini Ward Committee, Rekha Gupta Zone: Rohini, Constituency No.: 54, (Area: Pitampura North), Corporation: NDMC Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee, Standing Committee

61.94 12.28 7.14 10.45 5 20.07 2016 C 25 A B F A C BJP

Age: 47, Edu.: Master of Science, Profession & Occupation: Teacher Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Rohini Ward Committee, Garden Committee, Mamta Nagpal Zone: Rohini, Constituency No.: 56, (Area: Shalimar Bagh South), Corporation: NDMC Education Committee

62.37 12.42 7.55 11.39 5 20.00 2016 C 19 A B F A C BJP

Age: 58, Edu.: M.B.B.S, Profession & Occupation: Medical Practice Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Rohini Ward Committee, Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Sanjiv Nayyar Zone: Rohini, Constituency No.: 57, (Area: Paschim Vihar South), Corporation: NDMC Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee, Standing Committee

58.15 13.03 4.89 9.07 5 19.16 2016 D 46 A E F A C BJP

Age: 54, Edu.: B. Ed., Profession & Occupation: Coaching Institute Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Rohini Ward Committee, Garden Committee, Renu Kamboj Zone: Rohini, Constituency No.: 58, (Area: Pashcim Vihar North), Corporation: NDMC Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee

46 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 47 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

51.29 11.24 0.61 10.11 5 17.33 2016 D 78 B F F A D INC

Age: 60, Edu.: Higher Secondary, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Rohini Ward Committee, Assurance Committee, Appointments Dev Raj Arora Zone: Rohini, Constituency No.: 59, (Area: Rani Bagh), Corporation: NDMC Promotions, Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Works Committee

54.04 12.18 1.32 11.60 5 16.94 2016 D 66 A F E A D INC

Age: 36, Edu.: B.A., Profession & Occupation: Home Maker Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Rohini Ward Committee, Jyoti Aggarwal Zone: Rohini, Constituency No.: 60, (Area: Saraswati Vihar), Corporation: NDMC Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Law & General Purposes Committee

IND 60.94 14.54 6.12 12.72 5 16.55 2016 C 32 A C E A D

Age: 60, Edu.: Eighth, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Civil Line Ward Committee, Appointments Promotions, Suresh Kumar Zone: Civil Line, Constituency No.: 61, (Area: Tri Nagar), Corporation: NDMC Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Environment Management Services Committee, Garden Committee

50.26 10.87 2.34 8.72 5 17.33 2016 D 80 B F F A D INC

Age: 46, Edu.: HSC, Profession & Occupation: Housewife Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Civil Line Ward Committee, Garden Committee, Gita Yadav Zone: Civil Line, Constituency No.: 62, (Area: Rampura), Corporation: NDMC Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee

48 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 49 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

61.94 11.93 8.36 11.34 5 18.31 2016 C 26 B A F A C BJP

Tilak Ram Age: 64, Edu.: Matric, Profession & Occupation: Businessman Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Civil Line Ward Committee, Appointments Promotions, Gupta Zone: Civil Line, Constituency No.: 63, (Area: Kohat Enclave), Corporation: NDMC Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee, Standing Committee

41.08 4.68 0.20 5.52 5 18.68 2016 E 95 F F F A C BJP

Age: 39, Edu.: HSC, Profession & Occupation: Property Dealer Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Civil Line Ward Committee, Hindi Committee, Kishan Lal Zone: Civil Line, Constituency No.: 64, (Area: Shakurpur), Corporation: NDMC Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee

45.69 6.45 1.93 10.28 5 17.03 2016 E 90 E F F A D INC

Age: 29, Edu.: B.A., Profession & Occupation: Housewife Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Civil Line Ward Committee, Works Committee, Sonia Zone: Civil Line, Constituency No.: 65, (Area: Nimri Colony), Corporation: NDMC Environment Management Services Committee, Garden Committee, Hindi Committee

43.44 5.67 0.81 7.83 5 18.13 2016 E 93 E F F A C BJP

Age: 54, Edu.: B.A., L.L.B., Profession & Occupation: B.A., L.L.B. Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Civil Line Ward Committee, Meera Aggarwal Zone: Civil Line, Constituency No.: 66, (Area: Sawan Park), Corporation: NDMC High Powered Property Taxes Committee

50 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 51 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

55.29 9.32 4.38 13.12 5 16.47 2016 D 63 C E E A D BJP

Age: 31, Edu.: HSC, Profession & Occupation: Service in Abhinandan steels Poonam Sharma Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Civil Line Ward Committee Zone: Civil Line, Constituency No.: 68, (Area: Ashok Vihar), Corporation: NDMC

59.64 11.09 2.95 11.85 5 21.75 2016 D 37 B F E A B BJP Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Civil Line Ward Committee, Works Committee, Age: 38, Edu.: Bachelors in Commerce, Profession & Occupation: Business Arvind Garg Environment Management Services Committee, Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee, Zone: Civil Line, Constituency No.: 69, (Area: Kamla Nagar), Corporation: NDMC High Powered Property Taxes Committee

58.36 10.16 1.42 13.99 5 20.79 2016 D 44 C F E A C BJP

Age: 55, Edu.: B.A., Profession & Occupation: Advertisement Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Civil Line Ward Committee, Appointments Promotions, Renu Gupta Zone: Civil Line, Constituency No.: 70, (Area: Rana Pratap Bagh), Corporation: NDMC Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee

63.88 12.93 7.04 11.84 5 20.07 2016 C 17 A B E A C BJP

Age: 50, Edu.: Intermediate, Profession & Occupation: Business of Interior Decorator Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Civil Line Ward Committee, Madhav Prasad Zone: Civil Line, Constituency No.: 71, (Area: Sangam Park), Corporation: NDMC Environment Management Services Committee, Law & General Purposes Committee

52 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 53 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

57.36 10.42 3.26 12.21 5 19.47 2016 D 51 C F E A C BJP

Age: 61, Edu.: B. Com., Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Civil Line Ward Committee, Surender Gupta Zone: Civil Line, Constituency No.: 72, (Area: Model Town), Corporation: NDMC Law & General Purposes Committee, High Powered Property Taxes Committee

58.83 9.35 8.36 11.82 5 18.31 2016 D 41 C A E A C BJP Age: 52, Edu.: Higher Secondary, Diploma in General Nursing and Public Health Nursing, Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Sadar Paharganj Ward Committee, Law & General Purposes Neelam Dhiman Profession & Occupation: Social Worker Committee, Hindi Committee, High Powered Property Taxes Committee, Municipal Accounts Committee, Zone: Sadar Paharganj, Constituency No.: 73, (Area: Shastri Nagar), Corporation: NDMC Code of Conduct for Councillors Committee

46.29 5.86 1.12 8.19 5 20.12 2016 E 86 E F F A C INC Age: 31, Edu.: Master of Arts, Master in Human Resource Management, Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Karol Bagh Ward Committee, Prerna Singh Profession & Occupation: Working in Private Company Law & General Purposes Committee, Municipal Accounts Committee Zone: Karol Bagh, Constituency No.: 74, (Area: Inderlok Colony), Corporation: NDMC

57.95 12.46 9.28 11.96 -2 19.25 2016 D 47 A A E F C INC

Age: 64, Edu.: Matriculate, Profession & Occupation: Sitting Councillor Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Sadar Paharganj Ward Committee, Satbir Sharma Zone: Sadar Paharganj, Constituency No.: 75, (Area: Kishan Ganj), Corporation: NDMC Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, High Powered Property Taxes Committee, Education Committee

54 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 55 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

56.95 10.91 3.26 11.11 5 19.67 2016 D 53 B F F A C BJP

Age: 52, Edu.: Graduation (B.A. Hons.), Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Sadar Paharganj Ward Committee, Pinki Jain Zone: Sadar Paharganj, Constituency No.: 76, (Area: Deputy Ganj), Corporation: NDMC Assurance Committee, Works Committee, Medical Relief & Public Health Committee

51.97 11.35 0.71 10.57 5 18.35 2016 D 74 B F F A C INC Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Civil Line Ward Committee, Appointments Promotions, Age: 39, Edu.: Baccalaureate of Laws (L.L.B.), Profession & Occupation: Advocate Harsh Sharma Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Law & General Purposes Committee, Zone: Civil Line, Constituency No.: 77, (Area: Kashmiri Gate), Corporation: NDMC Code of Conduct for Councillors Committee

45.78 3.36 0.51 11.31 5 18.60 2016 E 89 F F F A C INC

Age: 55, Edu.: SSC, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Civil Line Ward Committee, Naina Premwani Zone: Civil Line, Constituency No.: 78, (Area: Manju Ka Tilla), Corporation: NDMC Law & General Purposes Committee, Municipal Accounts Committee

44.24 5.26 1.02 10.89 5 18.07 2016 E 92 E F F A C RLD

Age: 35, Edu.: Eighth, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), City Ward Committee, Garden Committee, Khurram Iqbal Zone: City, Constituency No.: 79, (Area: Jama Masjid), Corporation: NDMC Law & General Purposes Committee

56 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 57 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

62.13 12.27 8.97 13.51 5 16.37 2016 C 22 A A E A D BJP

Age: 47, Edu.: B.A. (Hons), Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), City Ward Committee, Surekha Zone: City, Constituency No.: 80, (Area: Chandni Chowk), Corporation: NDMC Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Garden Committee, Law & General Purposes Committee

58.83 8.38 6.22 13.87 5 20.36 2016 D 42 D C E A C INC

Age: 71, Edu.: SSC, Profession & Occupation: Social Worker Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), City Ward Committee, Appointments Promotions, Ramesh Dutta Zone: City, Constituency No.: 81, (Area: Minto Road), Corporation: NDMC Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Hindi Committee

68.59 13.31 9.18 14.72 5 20.39 2016 C 2 A A E A C BSP

Age: 46, Edu.: HSC, Profession & Occupation: Businessman Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), City Ward Committee, Appointments Promotions, Rakesh Kumar Zone: City, Constituency No.: 82, (Area: Kucha Pandit), Corporation: NDMC Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Garden Committee, Standing Committee

69.78 15.00 8.36 14.11 5 22.32 2016 C 1 A A E A B INC

Age: 45, Edu.: Secondary School Examination, Profession & Occupation: Self house hold Seema Taihra Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), City Ward Committee, Law & General Purposes Committee Zone: City, Constituency No.: 83, (Area: Bazar Sita Ram), Corporation: NDMC

58 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 59 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

51.53 8.28 4.79 13.83 0 20.63 2016 D 77 D E E F C RLD

Aaley Mohammed Age: 26, Edu.: HSC, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), City Ward Committee, Iqbal Zone: City, Constituency No.: 84, (Area: Turkman Gate), Corporation: NDMC Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee, High Powered Property Taxes Committee

57.39 9.76 4.18 13.15 5 19.30 2016 D 50 C E E A C INC

Age: 38, Edu.: B.A. (Hons.) English, Profession & Occupation: Teaching Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Sadar Paharganj Ward Committee, Saima Riaz Zone: Sadar Paharganj, Constituency No.: 85, (Area: Idgah road), Corporation: NDMC Environment Management Services Committee

67.59 15.00 9.08 13.04 5 20.48 2016 C 3 A A E A C BJP

Age: 37, Edu.: Eighth, Profession & Occupation: Social Worker Lata Sodhi Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Sadar Paharganj Ward Committee, Assurance Committee Zone: Sadar Paharganj, Constituency No.: 87, (Area: Ram Nagar), Corporation: NDMC

51.56 4.17 1.83 13.51 5 21.06 2016 D 76 F F E A B BJP

Age: 72, Edu.: Ninth, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Sadar Paharganj Ward Committee, Hoor Bano Zone: Sadar Paharganj, Constituency No.: 88, (Area: Qasab Pura), Corporation: NDMC Medical Relief & Public Health Committee

60 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 61 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

66.35 13.36 9.69 12.38 5 18.92 2016 C 6 A A E A C BJP

Age: 49, Edu.: SSC, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Sadar Paharganj Ward Committee, Virender Babbar Zone: Sadar Paharganj, Constituency No.: 89, (Area: Pahar Ganj), Corporation: NDMC Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee, Standing Committee

63.53 11.33 9.59 13.87 5 17.74 2016 C 18 B A E A D INC

Age: 57, Edu.: Matriculation, Profession & Occupation: Ental Income and Khurana Novelties Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Sadar Paharganj Ward Committee, Appointments Promotions, Madhu Khurana Zone: Sadar Paharganj, Constituency No.: 90, (Area: Model Basti), Corporation: NDMC Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Works Committee, Medical Relief & Public Health Committee

65.12 13.69 9.89 11.29 5 19.25 2016 C 12 A A F A C BJP

Yogender Age: 53, Edu.: B.A., Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Karol Bagh Ward Committee, Chandoliya Zone: Karol Bagh, Constituency No.: 92, (Area: Dev Nagar), Corporation: NDMC Standing Committee, Code of Conduct for Councillors Committee

60.83 11.35 7.75 13.10 5 17.63 2016 C 33 B B E A D BJP

Age: 46, Edu.: Bachelor of Arts, Profession & Occupation: Housewife Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Karol Bagh Ward Committee, Shyam Bala Zone: Karol Bagh, Constituency No.: 93, (Area: Baljit Nagar), Corporation: NDMC Works Committee, Garden Committee

62 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 63 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

62.20 14.76 7.34 12.45 5 17.66 2016 C 21 A B E A D BJP

Bhim Singh Age: 73, Edu.: SSC, R.M.P. Ayurvedic, Profession & Occupation: Doctor (Ayurvedic) Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Karol Bagh Ward Committee, Sharma Zone: Karol Bagh, Constituency No.: 94, (Area: West Patel Nagar), Corporation: NDMC Code of Conduct for Councillors Committee

61.92 13.64 5.61 13.10 5 17.57 2016 C 27 A D E A D BJP

Poornima Age: 60, Edu.: Higher Secondary, Profession & Occupation: Social Worker Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Karol Bagh Ward Committee, Vidyarthi Zone: Karol Bagh, Constituency No.: 95, (Area: East Patel Nagar), Corporation: NDMC Works Committee, Environment Management Services Committee

61.95 11.76 7.65 11.90 5 18.64 2016 C 24 B B E A C BJP Age: 50, Edu.: Bachelor of Commerce, Archana Gupta Profession & Occupation: (Director) Academy of Commerce Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Karol Bagh Ward Committee, Hindi Committee Zone: Karol Bagh, Constituency No.: 96, (Area: New Ranjit Nagar), Corporation: NDMC

61.18 11.05 8.77 12.32 5 18.04 2016 C 31 B A E A C BJP

Raj Kumar Age: 43, Edu.: Ninth, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Karol Bagh Ward Committee, Works Committee Lamba Zone: Karol Bagh, Constituency No.: 97, (Area: Kirti Nagar), Corporation: NDMC

64 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 65 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

57.72 10.03 8.16 10.26 5 18.27 2016 D 49 C A F A C BJP

Age: 54, Edu.: Not Given, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Karol Bagh Ward Committee, Usha Mehta Zone: Karol Bagh, Constituency No.: 98, (Area: Mansarover Garden), Corporation: NDMC Appointments Promotions, Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Education Committee

64.34 13.62 8.67 12.97 5 17.08 2016 C 15 A A E A D BJP

Bharat Bhushan Age: 56, Edu.: Eleventh, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Karol Bagh Ward Committee, Appointments Promotions, Madan Zone: Karol Bagh, Constituency No.: 99, (Area: Moti Nagar), Corporation: NDMC Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, High Powered Property Taxes Committee

53.12 9.28 3.57 9.63 5 18.64 2016 D 72 C E F A C BJP

Age: 47, Edu.: HSC, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Karol Bagh Ward Committee, Surinder Kaur Zone: Karol Bagh, Constituency No.: 100, (Area: Karam Pura), Corporation: NDMC Assurance Committee, Garden Committee

65.30 13.52 9.48 12.03 5 19.27 2016 C 11 A A E A C BJP

Age: 51, Edu.: HSC, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Karol Bagh Ward Committee, Rajesh Bhatia Zone: Karol Bagh, Constituency No.: 149, (Area: Rajinder Nagar), Corporation: NDMC Law & General Purposes Committee, Code of Conduct for Councillors Committee, Standing Committee

66 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 67 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

59.63 10.58 6.42 12.88 5 19.74 2016 D 38 B C E A C INC

Age: 56, Edu.: Seventh, Profession & Occupation: Social Worker Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Karol Bagh Ward Committee, Prem Lata Zone: Karol Bagh, Constituency No.: 150, (Area: Pusa), Corporation: NDMC Works Committee, Garden Committee

49.19 11.22 5.10 11.15 -2 17.72 2016 E 81 B D F F D BJP

Age: 56, Edu.: SSC, Profession & Occupation: Private Job Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Karol Bagh Ward Committee, Environment Management Suraj Kumar Zone: Karol Bagh, Constituency No.: 151, (Area: Inder Puri), Corporation: NDMC Services Committee, Law & General Purposes Committee, Code of Conduct for Councillors Committee

IND 56.60 10.61 5.71 12.05 5 16.23 2016 D 57 B D E A D

Age: 47, Edu.: HSC, Profession & Occupation: Traser of kerosene oil contractual Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Karol Bagh Ward Committee, Appointments Promotions, Parmod Tanwar leather, fabrication, two wheeler repairing job Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Environment Management Services Committee, Zone: Karol Bagh, Constituency No.: 152, (Area: Naraina), Corporation: NDMC High Powered Property Taxes Committee, Municipal Accounts Committee

68 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 69 SDMC

Not to Scale

70 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 71 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

65.62 14.73 8.72 11.71 5 18.46 2016 C 8 A A E A C BJP Age: 53, Edu.: Graduation (B.A. - History Hons.), Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), West Ward Committee, Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Suman Tyagi Profession & Occupation: Business & Income from Rented Property Assurance Committee, Environment Management Services Committee, Zone: West, Constituency No.: 101, (Area: Raja Garden), Corporation: SDMC High Powered Property Taxes Committee, Code of Conduct for Councillors Committee

64.45 12.80 8.29 12.58 5 18.78 2016 C 11 A A E A C INC

Age: 56, Edu.: 3 Year Diploma in Electrical Engineering, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), West Ward Committee, Pradeep Sharma Zone: West, Constituency No.: 102, (Area: Raghubir Nagar), Corporation: SDMC Works Committee, Appointments, Promotions, Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee

31.86 2.33 0 0 5 17.53 2016 F 95 F F F A D BJP

Satwinder Kaur Age: 44, Edu.: B.A. Part II, Profession & Occupation: Housewife Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), West Ward Committee, Appointments, Sirsa Zone: West, Constituency No.: 103, (Area: Punjabi Bagh), Corporation: SDMC Promotions, Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Garden Committee

60.64 13.22 6.06 12.40 5 17.96 2016 C 29 A C E A D BSP

Age: 43, Edu.: SSC, Profession & Occupation: Social Worker Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), West Ward Committee, Parwati Zone: West, Constituency No.: 104, (Area: Madipur), Corporation: SDMC Environment Management Services Committee, Garden Committee, Hindi Committee

72 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 73 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

55.26 7.69 3.93 12.09 5 19.55 2016 D 59 D E E A C INC

Sunita Subhash Age: 50, Edu.: SSC, Profession & Occupation: Housewife Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), West Ward Committee, Assurance Committee, Yadav Zone: West, Constituency No.: 106, (Area: Tagore Garden), Corporation: SDMC Environment Management Services Committee, Garden Committee

50.04 7.62 6.38 13.28 -2 18.76 2016 D 78 D C E F C INC

A Meghraj Age: 35, Edu.: HSC, Profession & Occupation: Owner Chandela Plastics Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), West Ward Committee, Education Committee, Chandela A Zone: West, Constituency No.: 107, (Area: Vishnu Garden), Corporation: SDMC Law & General Purposes Committee, High Powered Property Taxes Committee

42.16 4.08 0.31 5.87 5 20.90 2016 E 90 F F F A C INC

A. Meenakshi Age: 31, Edu.: B.A., Profession & Occupation: Cattle Farming Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), West Ward Committee, Chandela A Zone: West, Constituency No.: 108, (Area: Khayala), Corporation: SDMC Environment Management Services Committee

59.38 13.28 9.14 12.01 0 17.95 2016 D 35 A A E F D BJP

Age: 52, Edu.: SSC, Profession & Occupation: Not Given Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), West Ward Committee, Standing Committee, Medical Relief & Public Shyam Sharma Zone: West, Constituency No.: 109, (Area: Janakpuri North), Corporation: SDMC Health Committee, Appointments, Promotions, Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Works Committee

74 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 75 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

64.89 13.67 7.97 11.72 5 19.54 2016 C 9 A B E A C BJP

Age: 35, Edu.: HSC, Profession & Occupation: Housewife Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), West Ward Committee, Radhika Setia Zone: West, Constituency No.: 110, (Area: Nangal Raya), Corporation: SDMC Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Garden Committee, Municipal Accounts Committee

58.77 6.88 7.44 13.63 5 19.82 2016 D 41 E B E A C INC

Age: 53, Edu.: Bachelor of Arts, Profession & Occupation: Pension & Rent Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), West Ward Committee, Hindi Committee, Raj Kumari Zone: West, Constituency No.: 111, (Area: Hari Nagar), Corporation: SDMC Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee, Municipal Accounts Committee

51.32 7.43 4.04 11.41 5 17.44 2016 D 74 E E F A D INC

Age: 49, Edu.: HSC, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), West Ward Committee, Manju Setia Zone: West, Constituency No.: 112, (Area: Subash Nagar), Corporation: SDMC Environment Management Services Committee, Municipal Accounts Committee

64.48 14.40 9.57 10.67 5 17.84 2016 C 10 A A F A D BJP

Age: 74, Edu.: M.A., Profession & Occupation: Pensioner Yash Pal Arya Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), West Ward Committee, Education Committee Zone: West, Constituency No.: 113, (Area: Mahavir Nagar), Corporation: SDMC

76 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 77 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

60.91 13.75 7.02 9.63 5 18.51 2016 C 27 A B F A C BJP

Age: 28, Edu.: P.G. Diploma in Management, Profession & Occupation: Social Service Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), West Ward Committee, Garden Committee, Ritu Vohra Zone: West, Constituency No.: 114, (Area: Tilak Nagar), Corporation: SDMC Law & General Purposes Committee, High Powered Property Taxes Committee

43.30 6.50 0.31 5.87 5 18.62 2016 E 89 E F F A C BJP Age: 40, Edu.: HSC, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), West Ward Committee, Dimple Chadha Zone: West, Constituency No.: 115, (Area: Major Bhupinder Singh Nagar) Law & General Purposes Committee, Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee Corporation: SDMC

56.75 6.49 5.74 13.16 5 19.36 2016 D 51 E D E A C INC Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), West Ward Committee, Appointments, Age: 31, Edu.: B.Com. (H), L.L.B., Profession & Occupation: Advocate Amrita Dhawan Promotions, Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Environment Management Services Committee, Zone: West, Constituency No.: 116, (Area: Vikaspuri East), Corporation: SDMC Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee

63.73 7.92 9.89 11.47 5 22.45 2016 C 15 D A F A B BJP Age: 49, Edu.: Bachelor of Commerce (Hons.), Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), West Ward Committee, Standing Committee, Ashish Sood Profession & Occupation: Director, NCNL Info Media Pvt. Ltd. Appointments, Promotions, Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Works Committee Zone: West, Constituency No.: 117, (Area: Janak Puri West), Corporation: SDMC

78 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 79 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

72.41 14.65 9.68 12.99 5 23.08 2016 B 1 A A E A B BJP

Age: 54, Edu.: Under HSC, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), West Ward Committee, Assurance Committee, Rajni Mamtani Zone: West, Constituency No.: 118, (Area: Janak Puri South), Corporation: SDMC Environment Management Services Committee, Garden Committee, Hindi Committee

55.95 8.63 4.78 14.73 5 16.80 2016 D 56 D E E A D INC

Age: 47, Edu.: Seventh, Profession & Occupation: Housewife/Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), West Ward Committee, Vimla Devi Zone: West, Constituency No.: 120, (Area: Sita Puri), Corporation: SDMC Environment Management Services Committee

52.98 11.46 8.93 12.48 -2 17.10 2016 D 68 B A E F D BJP

Pankaj Kumar Age: 38, Edu.: B.D.S., Profession & Occupation: Social Service Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), West Ward Committee, Standing Committee, Rural Area Committee, Singh Zone: West, Constituency No.: 121, (Area: Kunwar Singh Nagar), Corporation: SDMC Appointments, Promotions, Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Garden Committee

58.92 13.25 8.08 9.83 5 15.77 2016 D 38 A A F A D BJP

Age: 46, Edu.: B. Ed., Profession & Occupation: Teacher in Pvt. School Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), West Ward Committee, Education Committee, Shashi Prabha Zone: West, Constituency No.: 122, (Area: Hastsal), Corporation: SDMC Rural Area Committee, Hindi Committee

80 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 81 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

67.33 14.38 7.02 12.86 5 21.07 2016 C 4 A B E A B BJP

Karam Vir Age: 53, Edu.: L.L.B., Profession & Occupation: Assistant Manager in Colombia Junior School Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), West Ward Committee, Appointments, Promotions, Disciplinary & Shekhar Zone: West, Constituency No.: 123, (Area: Vikaspuri), Corporation: SDMC Allied Matters Committee, Environment Management Services Committee, Law & General Purposes Committee

44.28 3.52 2.02 12.56 5 14.18 2016 E 87 F F E A E INC

Age: 26, Edu.: B.A. II year, Profession & Occupation: Student Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), West Ward Committee, Garden Committee, Anju Gupta Zone: West, Constituency No.: 125, (Area: Mohan Garden), Corporation: SDMC Law & General Purposes Committee

51.64 11.05 3.40 10.15 5 17.03 2016 D 73 B F F A D BJP

Age: 26, Edu.: B. Ed., Profession & Occupation: Teaching Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), West Ward Committee, Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Shivali Sharma Zone: West, Constituency No.: 127, (Area: Uttam Nagar), Corporation: SDMC Works Committee, Law & General Purposes Committee, Hindi Committee

IND 57.65 9.03 6.59 11.57 5 18.45 2016 D 48 C C E A C

Age: 50, Edu.: Matric, Profession & Occupation: Businessman Deshraj Raghav Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), West Ward Committee Zone: West, Constituency No.: 128, (Area: Bindapur), Corporation: SDMC

82 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 83 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

57.19 11.83 5.10 9.66 5 18.60 2016 D 50 B D F A C INC

Tilotma Age: 54, Edu.: B.A., Profession & Occupation: Teaching (Councillor) Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Najafgarh Ward Committee, Chaudhary Zone: Najafgarh, Constituency No.: 129, (Area: Dabri), Corporation: SDMC Medical Relief & Public Health Committee

60.40 14.49 6.91 11.16 0 20.84 2016 C 31 A C F F C INC

Age: 50, Edu.: SSC, Profession & Occupation: Housewife Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Najafgarh Ward Committee, Maya Devi Zone: Najafgarh, Constituency No.: 130, (Area: Manglapuri), Corporation: SDMC Works Committee, Garden Committee

IND 63.76 11.22 8.82 12.19 5 19.53 2016 C 14 B A E A C

Age: 48, Edu.: Master of Arts in History, Profession & Occupation: Manager Parveen Rajput Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Najafgarh Ward Committee, Standing Committee Zone: Najafgarh, Constituency No.: 131, (Area: Sagarpur), Corporation: SDMC

IND 60.08 12.56 6.06 13.06 5 17.40 2016 C 34 A C E A D

Age: 55, Edu.: Primary Education, Profession & Occupation: MCD Councillor Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Najafgarh Ward Committee, Usha Gupta Zone: Najafgarh, Constituency No.: 132, (Area: Sagarpur West), Corporation: SDMC Works Committee, Code of Conduct for Councillors Committee

84 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 85 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

IND 57.91 10.86 5.31 11.23 5 18.51 2016 D 47 B D F A C

Age: 40, Edu.: B. Ed., Profession & Occupation: Private Teacher & Political Activist Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Najafgarh Ward Committee, Rural Area Committee, Pardeep Kumar Zone: Najafgarh, Constituency No.: 133, (Area: Chhawla), Corporation: SDMC Appointments, Promotions, Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee

IND 58.41 11.83 7.76 13.47 5 14.34 2016 D 43 B B E A E

Satendra Singh Age: 43, Edu.: Matriculation, Profession & Occupation: Proprietor & Social Worker Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Najafgarh Ward Committee, Rural Area Committee Rana Zone: Najafgarh, Constituency No.: 134, (Area: Nangli Sakrawati), Corporation: SDMC

61.41 11.22 7.02 14.27 5 16.90 2016 C 22 B B E A D BJP

Age: 55, Edu.: J-High School, Profession & Occupation: Housewife Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Najafgarh Ward Committee, Shashi Tomar Zone: Najafgarh, Constituency No.: 135, (Area: Kakraula), Corporation: SDMC Environment Management Services Committee, Hindi Committee, Municipal Accounts Committee

IND 53.86 9.19 3.40 12.08 5 17.19 2016 D 63 C F E A D

Age: 34, Edu.: Degree of Master of Arts, Profession & Occupation: Housewife Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Najafgarh Ward Committee, Rural Area Committee, Indu Zone: Najafgarh, Constituency No.: 137, (Area: Roshanpura), Corporation: SDMC Law & General Purposes Committee

86 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 87 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

33.21 7.47 0.31 4.21 -5 19.21 2016 F 94 E F F F C INLD

Age: 40, Edu.: SSC, Profession & Occupation: Agriculturalist Kirshan Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Najafgarh Ward Committee, Works Committee Zone: Najafgarh, Constituency No.: 138, (Area: Najafgarh), Corporation: SDMC

47.22 6.81 1.06 9.47 5 18.88 2016 E 82 E F F A C INLD

Age: 33, Edu.: M.A. (English), Profession & Occupation: Housewife Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Najafgarh Ward Committee, Rural Area Committee, Neelam Zone: Najafgarh, Constituency No.: 139, (Area: Dichaon Kalan), Corporation: SDMC Works Committee, Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee

55.11 7.00 1.91 13.64 5 20.56 2016 D 60 E F E A C BJP

Age: 39, Edu.: Not Given, Profession & Occupation: Not Given Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Najafgarh Ward Committee, Rajkumari Zone: Najafgarh, Constituency No.: 140, (Area: Khera), Corporation: SDMC Garden Committee, Rural Area Committee

60.25 11.55 2.65 13.17 5 20.88 2016 C 32 B F E A C INC

Age: 49, Edu.: Graduate, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Najafgarh Ward Committee, Assurance Committee, Parveen Rana Zone: Najafgarh, Constituency No.: 141, (Area: Bijwasan), Corporation: SDMC Appointments, Promotions, Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee

88 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 89 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

IND 44.34 6.50 1.06 9.37 0 21.41 2016 E 86 E F F F B

Poonam Age: 34, Edu.: Matriculation, Profession & Occupation: Housewife & Social Worker Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Najafgarh Ward Committee, Bhardwaj Zone: Najafgarh, Constituency No.: 142, (Area: Raj Nagar), Corporation: SDMC Law & General Purposes Committee

50.97 7.31 2.23 10.03 5 20.41 2016 D 76 E F F A C BJP Age: 49, Edu.: Eighth, Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Najafgarh Ward Committee, Medical Relief & Public Health Jai Prakash Profession & Occupation: Resigned from the post of Safai Karamchari in MCD Committee, Rural Area Committee, Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee Zone: Najafgarh, Constituency No.: 143, (Area: Kapashera), Corporation: SDMC

IND 59.05 10.81 5.31 12.18 5 18.76 2016 D 37 B D E A C

Krishan Kumar Age: 48, Edu.: B.A., Profession & Occupation: Businessman Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Najafgarh Ward Committee, Sehrawat Zone: Najafgarh, Constituency No.: 144, (Area: Mahipalpur), Corporation: SDMC Rural Area Committee, Assurance Committee

IND 49.85 7.97 1.38 9.20 5 19.30 2016 E 79 D F F A C

Age: 45, Edu.: Bachelor of Arts, Profession & Occupation: Business (Design work) Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Najafgarh Ward Committee, Seema Pandit Zone: Najafgarh, Constituency No.: 145, (Area: Palam), Corporation: SDMC Medical Relief & Public Health Committee

90 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 91 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

61.19 7.89 9.36 11.64 5 20.30 2016 C 25 D A E A C BJP

Age: 50, Edu.: SSC, Profession & Occupation: Self Employed Kuldeep Solanki Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Najafgarh Ward Committee, Municipal Accounts Committee Zone: Najafgarh, Constituency No.: 146, (Area: Sadh Nagar), Corporation: SDMC

58.34 10.14 3.40 12.96 5 19.84 2016 D 44 C F E A C BSP

Age: 46, Edu.: Intermediate Education, Profession & Occupation: Social Worker Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Najafgarh Ward Committee, Sudesh Wati Zone: Najafgarh, Constituency No.: 147, (Area: Mahavir Enclave), Corporation: SDMC Law & General Purposes Committee, Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee

61.95 13.97 9.04 11.88 0 20.06 2016 C 20 A A E F C BJP

Pawan Singh Age: 40, Edu.: L.L.B., Profession & Occupation: Advocate Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Najafgarh Ward Committee, Rathee Zone: Najafgarh, Constituency No.: 148, (Area: Madhu Vihar), Corporation: SDMC Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Municipal Accounts Committee

69.46 13.93 8.61 12.67 5 22.25 2016 C 2 A A E A B BJP Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Central Ward Committee, Age: 61, Edu.: M. Sc. (Chemistry), Profession & Occupation: Profession Simmi Jain Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Garden Committee, Zone: Central, Constituency No.: 153, (Area: Darya Ganj), Corporation: SDMC Law & General Purposes Committee, Hindi Committee, Municipal Accounts Committee

92 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 93 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

63.62 9.42 9.78 12.38 5 20.04 2016 C 16 C A E A C INC Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Central Ward Committee, Standing Committee, Age: 59, Edu.: Graduation (B. Com Hons.), Profession & Occupation: Self Employed Farhad Suri Appointments, Promotions, Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Works Committee, Zone: Central, Constituency No.: 154, (Area: Nizamuddin), Corporation: SDMC High Powered Property Taxes Committee

56.40 9.81 5.53 9.80 5 19.26 2016 D 53 C D F A C INC

Age: 48, Edu.: Higher Secondary, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Central Ward Committee, Kavita Malhotra Zone: Central, Constituency No.: 155, (Area: Lajpat Nagar), Corporation: SDMC Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Works Committee, Code of Conduct for Councillors Committee

63.04 13.26 6.27 12.74 3 20.77 2016 C 18 A C E C C INC

Age: 50, Edu.: B. Ed., Profession & Occupation: Councillor Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Central Ward Committee, Darshna Zone: Central, Constituency No.: 156, (Area: Bhogal), Corporation: SDMC Appointments, Promotions, Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Works Committee

56.05 8.27 5.95 11.92 5 17.92 2016 D 55 D D E A D INC

Age: 70, Edu.: Matric, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Central Ward Committee, Ravi Kalsi Zone: Central, Constituency No.: 157, (Area: Kasturba Nagar), Corporation: SDMC Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Garden Committee, Law & General Purposes Committee

94 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 95 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

IND 56.12 7.05 4.36 13.83 5 18.88 2016 D 54 E E E A C

Age: 45, Edu.: B.A. Part - 1, Profession & Occupation: Housewife Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Central Ward Committee, Kusum Lata Zone: Central, Constituency No.: 158, (Area: Kotla Mubarakpur), Corporation: SDMC Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Code of Conduct for Councillors Committee, Hindi Committee

58.79 8.67 5.10 14.68 5 18.35 2016 D 40 D D E A C INC Age: 36, Edu.: Post Graduate Degree in Executive M.B.A. (Marketing Management), Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Central Ward Committee, Abhishek Dutt Profession & Occupation: Business Appointments, Promotions, Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee Zone: Central, Constituency No.: 159, (Area: Andrews Ganj), Corporation: SDMC

64.28 11.60 9.36 12.25 5 19.07 2016 C 12 B A E A C BJP

Age: 56, Edu.: Bachelor of Education, Profession & Occupation: Housewife Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Central Ward Committee, Standing Committee, Savita Gupta Zone: Central, Constituency No.: 160, (Area: Amar Colony), Corporation: SDMC High Powered Property Taxes Committee, Code of Conduct for Councillors Committee

44.65 2.70 0.95 9.86 5 19.14 2016 E 85 F F F A C BJP

Age: 54, Edu.: B.A., Profession & Occupation: Business Satish Upadhyay Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), South Ward Committee Zone: South, Constituency No.: 161, (Area: Malviya Nagar), Corporation: SDMC

96 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 97 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

40.51 3.42 0.31 6.06 5 18.72 2016 E 91 F F F A C INC

Age: 48, Edu.: Senior Secondary, Profession & Occupation: Housewife Nutan Kochar Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), South Ward Committee, Assurance Committee Zone: South, Constituency No.: 162, (Area: Village Hauz Rani), Corporation: SDMC

55.69 10.27 3.08 10.42 5 19.91 2016 D 57 C F F A C BJP Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), South Ward Committee, Appointments, Promotions, Age: 42, Edu.: Graduate, Hotel Management, Profession & Occupation: Municipal Councillor Shailender Singh Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, High Powered Property Taxes Committee, Zone: South, Constituency No.: 163, (Area: Safdarjung Enclave), Corporation: SDMC Code of Conduct for Councillors Committee

39.27 6.96 0 0 5 20.32 2016 E 92 E F F A C BJP Age: 26, Edu.: Diploma in International Business Marketing, Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), South Ward Committee, Works Committee, Ankita Saini Profession & Occupation: Social Service Law & General Purposes Committee Zone: South, Constituency No.: 164, (Area: Hauz Khas), Corporation: SDMC

67.86 11.36 10.00 11.91 5 22.58 2016 C 3 B A E A B BJP Age: 67, Edu.: Matriculation, 3 Year Diploma in Civil & Rural Engineering, Radhey Shyam Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), South Ward Committee, Profession & Occupation: Business: Managing Director - Private Ltd. Company Standing Committee, Municipal Accounts Committee Sharma Zone: South, Constituency No.: 165, (Area: Vasant Vihar), Corporation: SDMC

98 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 99 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

65.87 14.06 8.19 11.78 5 19.84 2016 C 6 A A E A C INC

Age: 42, Edu.: SSC, Profession & Occupation: Business & Political Activist Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), South Ward Committee, Environment Management Services Dharmvir Singh Zone: South, Constituency No.: 167, (Area: R.K Puram), Corporation: SDMC Committee, Assurance Committee, Medical Relief & Public Health Committee

53.29 8.74 2.44 11.45 5 18.66 2016 D 66 D F F A C INC

Age: 39, Edu.: SSC, Profession & Occupation: Housewife Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), South Ward Committee, Garden Committee, Anita Zone: South, Constituency No.: 169, (Area: Lado Sarai), Corporation: SDMC Hindi Committee, Municipal Accounts Committee

66.24 13.40 8.40 12.93 5 19.50 2016 C 5 A A E A C NCP

Age: 47, Edu.: Senior Secondary, Profession & Occupation: Housewife Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), South Ward Committee, Standing Committee, Pushpa Singh Zone: South, Constituency No.: 170, (Area: Mehrauli), Corporation: SDMC High Powered Property Taxes Committee

49.67 8.68 2.12 9.13 5 19.73 2016 E 80 D F F A C INC

Age: 51, Edu.: Illtrate, Profession & Occupation: Housewise Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), South Ward Committee, Omwati Zone: South, Constituency No.: 171, (Area: Vasant Kunj), Corporation: SDMC Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Hindi Committee

100 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 101 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

55.68 9.07 4.78 9.49 5 21.35 2016 D 58 C E F A B BJP

Age: 47, Edu.: B. Com. 1st Year, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), South Ward Committee, Education Committee, Kusum Khatri Zone: South, Constituency No.: 172, (Area: Kishan Garh), Corporation: SDMC Rural Area Committee, Law & General Purposes Committee, High Powered Property Taxes Committee

61.22 13.80 3.40 11.89 5 20.13 2016 C 24 A F E A C BJP

Age: 56, Edu.: B.A., Profession & Occupation: Self Employed (Rental Income) Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), South Ward Committee, Ram Pal Zone: South, Constituency No.: 173, (Area: Said Ul Ajaib), Corporation: SDMC Rural Area Committee, Hindi Committee

60.52 13.49 6.48 10.01 5 18.54 2016 C 30 A C F A C RLD

Age: 46, Edu.: B.A., Profession & Occupation: Housewife/Social Worker Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), South Ward Committee, Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Anita Tyagi Zone: South, Constituency No.: 174, (Area: Chhatarpur), Corporation: SDMC Rural Area Committee, Appointments, Promotions, Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Garden Committee

58.69 13.18 4.57 12.23 5 18.71 2016 D 42 A E E A C BJP

Age: 71, Edu.: Third, Profession & Occupation: Self Employed Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), South Ward Committee, Gyasi Zone: South, Constituency No.: 175, (Area: Aya Nagar), Corporation: SDMC Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Rural Area Committee, High Powered Property Taxes Committee

102 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 103 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

43.71 5.03 0.74 5.85 5 20.09 2016 E 88 F F F A C BJP

Age: 42, Edu.: B. Ed., Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), South Ward Committee, Appointments, Promotions, Sarita Choudhary Zone: South, Constituency No.: 177, (Area: Sangam Vihar), Corporation: SDMC Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee

53.66 8.75 3.40 10.47 5 20.03 2016 D 64 D F F A C INC Age: 57, Edu.: Studied upto 10th Std., Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), South Ward Committee, Rural Area Committee, Satish Gupta Profession & Occupation: Prop. Gupta Kerosene Oil Depot/Consultant Appointments, Promotions, Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Municipal Accounts Committee Zone: South, Constituency No.: 178, (Area: Deoli), Corporation: SDMC

IND 54.33 9.47 2.23 11.43 5 20.20 2016 D 62 C F F A C

Age: 33, Edu.: Eighth, Profession & Occupation: Housewife Sarita Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), South Ward Committee Zone: South, Constituency No.: 179, (Area: Tigri), Corporation: SDMC

52.45 7.17 2.65 10.34 5 20.28 2016 D 70 E F F A C INC

Age: 39, Edu.: B. Ed., Profession & Occupation: Teacher Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), South Ward Committee, Works Committee, Anju Sehwag Zone: South, Constituency No.: 180, (Area: Dakshin Puri Extension), Corporation: SDMC Hindi Committee, High Powered Property Taxes Committee

104 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 105 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

59.11 12.42 9.25 12.03 -2 20.41 2016 D 36 A A E F C BJP

Satender Age: 49, Edu.: HSC, Profession & Occupation: Investment Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), South Ward Committee, Prakash Zone: South, Constituency No.: 181, (Area: Khanpur), Corporation: SDMC Standing Committee, Assurance Committee, Hindi Committee

46.18 7.87 0.74 6.09 5 19.48 2016 E 83 D F F A C BJP

Khushi Ram Age: 42, Edu.: B.A., Profession & Occupation: Property Consultant Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), South Ward Committee, Appointments, Promotions, Chunar Zone: South, Constituency No.: 182, (Area: Ambedakar Nagar), Corporation: SDMC Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee

62.29 12.13 5.63 12.57 5 20.95 2016 C 19 A D E A C BSP

Age: 32, Edu.: Eighth, Profession & Occupation: Housewife Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), South Ward Committee, Environment Management Services Sarita Zone: South, Constituency No.: 183, (Area: Madangir), Corporation: SDMC Committee, Law & General Purposes Committee, Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee

65.67 11.68 7.02 13.35 5 21.62 2016 C 7 B B E A B BJP Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), South Ward Committee, Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Age: 51, Edu.: Till 10th, Profession & Occupation: Consultant (Const.) M. Nagarajan Appointments, Promotions, Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Environment Management Services Zone: South, Constituency No.: 184, (Area: Pushp Vihar), Corporation: SDMC Committee, Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee, High Powered Property Taxes Committee

106 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 107 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

58.20 9.52 3.19 14.73 5 18.76 2016 D 45 C F E A C NCP

Age: 37, Edu.: SSC, Profession & Occupation: Housewife Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Central Ward Committee, Works Committee, Babli Zone: Central, Constituency No.: 185, (Area: Tughlakabad Extension), Corporation: SDMC Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee

63.94 11.75 5.74 14.50 5 20.95 2016 C 13 B D E A C BJP

Kali Charan Age: 60, Edu.: HSC, Profession & Occupation: Business as Screen Printing Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Central Ward Committee, Medical Relief & Public Health Sharma Zone: Central, Constituency No.: 186, (Area: Sangam Vihar West), Corporation: SDMC Committee, Assurance Committee, Environment Management Services Committee

IND 60.14 12.44 7.76 13.82 0 21.12 2016 C 33 A B E F B

Age: 44, Edu.: Ninth, Profession & Occupation: Social Worker Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Central Ward Committee, Kalpana Jha Zone: Central, Constituency No.: 187, (Area: Sangam Vihar Central), Corporation: SDMC Environment Management Services Committee, Hindi Committee

58.12 12.05 2.87 10.42 5 20.78 2016 D 46 A F F A C BJP

Age: 44, Edu.: SSC, Profession & Occupation: Property Dealer Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Central Ward Committee, Works Committee, Law & General Purposes Neeraj Gupta Zone: Central, Constituency No.: 188, (Area: Sangam Vihar East), Corporation: SDMC Committee, Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee, Code of Conduct for Councillors Committee

108 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 109 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

53.25 10.87 1.06 10.04 5 20.27 2016 D 67 B F F A C BJP

Age: 43, Edu.: Ninth, Profession & Occupation: Self Employed Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), South Ward Committee, Appointments, Promotions, Sunita Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Environment Management Services Committee, Zone: South, Constituency No.: 189, (Area: Chirag Delhi), Corporation: SDMC Law & General Purposes Committee, High Powered Property Taxes Committee

61.34 11.15 6.59 12.77 5 19.84 2016 C 23 B C E A C INC Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Central Ward Committee, Appointments, Promotions, Age: 47, Edu.: B.A., L.L.B., Profession & Occupation: Advocate Virender Kasana Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Works Committee, Law & General Purposes Committee, Zone: Central, Constituency No.: 190, (Area: Chitranjan Park), Corporation: SDMC High Powered Property Taxes Committee

51.91 10.21 1.70 8.56 5 19.44 2016 D 72 C F F A C BJP

Age: 31, Edu.: B.A., Profession & Occupation: Housewife Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), South Ward Committee, Works Committee, Meenu Zone: South, Constituency No.: 191, (Area: Shahpur Jat), Corporation: SDMC Garden Committee, Law & General Purposes Committee

53.42 9.27 3.19 12.55 5 18.41 2016 D 65 C F E A C BJP

Kishan Chand Age: 69, Edu.: Middle School, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Central Ward Committee, Works Committee, Taneja Zone: Central, Constituency No.: 192, (Area: Greater Kailash-I), Corporation: SDMC High Powered Property Taxes Committee

110 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 111 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

51.06 10.37 4.78 11.39 -2 19.53 2016 D 75 C E F F C INC

Age: 41, Edu.: B. Ed., Profession & Occupation: Tutions Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Central Ward Committee, Education Committee, Indu Zone: Central, Constituency No.: 193, (Area: Sriniwas Puri), Corporation: SDMC Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Code of Conduct for Councillors Committee

61.48 12.34 7.65 12.29 5 18.20 2016 C 21 A B E A C BJP

Age: 57, Edu.: Eleventh, Profession & Occupation: Housewife Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Central Ward Committee, Works Committee, Urmila Zone: Central, Constituency No.: 194, (Area: East of Kailash), Corporation: SDMC Garden Committee, Hindi Committee, High Powered Property Taxes Committee

52.71 5.62 1.38 13.67 5 20.04 2016 D 69 E F E A C JD (United) Age: 38, Edu.: B.A., Pursuing M.A., Chander Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Central Ward Committee, Profession & Occupation: Director in R. B. Capital Services Pvt. Ltd., Rental Business Law & General Purposes Committee, Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee Prakash Zone: Central, Constituency No.: 195, (Area: Govind Puri), Corporation: SDMC

56.44 7.97 4.04 12.68 5 19.75 2016 D 52 D E E A C INC

Narinder Kaur Age: 43, Edu.: Under Graduate, Profession & Occupation: Not Given Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Central Ward Committee, Garden Committee, Captain Zone: Central, Constituency No.: 196, (Area: Kalkaji), Corporation: SDMC Law & General Purposes Committee

112 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 113 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

50.53 9.62 4.25 14.85 -2 17.81 2016 D 77 C E E F D BJP Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Central Ward Committee, Appointments, Age: 55, Edu.: Eighth, Profession & Occupation: Building Material Supplier Chote Ram Promotions, Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Zone: Central, Constituency No.: 197, (Area: Tughlakabad), Corporation: SDMC Environment Management Services Committee, Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee

48.87 8.05 1.70 10.71 5 17.40 2016 E 81 D F F A D BJP

Age: 37, Edu.: Illiterate, Profession & Occupation: Fabricator Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Central Ward Committee, Rekha Zone: Central, Constituency No.: 198, (Area: Pul Pehlad), Corporation: SDMC Rural Area Committee, Garden Committee

57.41 10.60 6.59 10.40 5 18.82 2016 D 49 B C F A F NCP Age: 50, Edu.: PG Diploma in Hindi Journalism, Diploma in Acting 1 Year, Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Central Ward Committee, Jivan Lal Profession & Occupation: Not Given Environment Management Services Committee, Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee Zone: Central, Constituency No.: 200, (Area: Harkesh Nagar), Corporation: SDMC

46.00 7.28 1.38 6.09 5 20.24 2016 E 84 E F F A F NCP

Age: 39, Edu.: Uneducated, Profession & Occupation: Self Employed Sikha Shah Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Central Ward Committee, Rural Area Committee Zone: Central, Constituency No.: 201, (Area: Jaitpur), Corporation: SDMC

114 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 115 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

63.16 10.42 8.51 13.65 5 19.58 2016 C 17 C A E A F NCP Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Central Ward Committee, Standing Committee, Dharamvir Age: 48, Edu.: Ninth, Profession & Occupation: Social Worker & Property Dealing Rural Area Committee, Environment Management Services Committee, Hindi Committee, Zone: Central, Constituency No.: 202, (Area: Meetha Pur), Corporation: SDMC Awana High Powered Property Taxes Committee, Code of Conduct for Councillors Committee

IND 55.07 11.00 4.36 10.94 5 16.77 2016 D 61 B E F A F

Age: 52, Edu.: B. Ed., Profession & Occupation: Service Phool Kali Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Central Ward Committee, Rural Area Committee Zone: Central, Constituency No.: 203, (Area: Badarpur), Corporation: SDMC

52.11 6.48 2.44 13.22 5 18.96 2016 D 71 E F E A C NCP

Age: 32, Edu.: M.A. English, Pursuing B. Ed., Profession & Occupation: Social Worker Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Central Ward Committee, Rural Area Committee, Timshi Kasana Zone: Central, Constituency No.: 204, (Area: Molarband), Corporation: SDMC Environment Management Services Committee, Medical Relief & Public Health Committee

60.83 11.44 7.55 15.72 0 19.13 2016 C 28 B B E F C INC

Age: 51, Edu.: B.A., Profession & Occupation: Politician Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Central Ward Committee, Shoeb Danish Zone: Central, Constituency No.: 205, (Area: Zakir Nagar), Corporation: SDMC Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Environment Management Services Committee

116 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 117 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

58.92 10.27 4.57 12.37 5 19.72 2016 D 39 C E E A C INC

Age: 46, Edu.: HSC, Profession & Occupation: Housewife Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Central Ward Committee, Ishrat Begum Zone: Central, Constituency No.: 206, (Area: Okhla), Corporation: SDMC Garden Committee, Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee

60.93 13.01 2.87 13.07 5 19.98 2016 C 26 A F E A C BSP

Age: 56, Edu.: SSC, ITI, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Central Ward Committee, Rural Area Committee, Works Committee, Bir Singh Zone: Central, Constituency No.: 207, (Area: Madanpur Khadar), Corporation: SDMC Garden Committee, Law & General Purposes Committee, Code of Conduct for Councillors Committee

34.34 3.77 0 0 5 18.58 2016 F 93 F F F A C INC

Age: 30, Edu.: B. Com., Profession & Occupation: Not Given Neetu Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Central Ward Committee, Garden Committee Zone: Central, Constituency No.: 208, (Area: Sarita Vihar), Corporation: SDMC

118 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 119 EDMC

Not to Scale

120 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 121 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

49.47 7.68 1.83 11.71 5 17.26 2016 E 48 D F E A D INC

Age: 38, Edu.: Not Given, Profession & Occupation: Not Given Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara South Ward Committee, Gurmeet Kaur Zone: Shahdara South, Constituency No.: 209, (Area: Mayur Vihar Ph-I), Corporation: EDMC Assurance Committee, Garden Committee

51.74 7.00 1.33 14.26 5 17.15 2016 D 42 E F E A D INC

Age: 36, Edu.: B.A., Profession & Occupation: Not Given Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara South Ward Committee, Environment Management Anjana Zone: Shahdara South, Constituency No.: 210, (Area: Dallupura), Corporation: EDMC Services Committee, Code of Conduct for Councillors Committee

IND 21.55 3.48 0 0 -5 17.07 2016 F 61 F F F F D

Age: 42, Edu.: Not Given, Profession & Occupation: Not Given Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara South Ward Committee, Garden Committee, Kamal Zone: Shahdara South, Constituency No.: 211, (Area: Trilokpuri), Corporation: EDMC Hindi Committee, Code of Conduct for Councillors Committee

56.03 11.02 5.00 12.57 5 18.43 2016 D 31 B D E A C BJP Age: 40, Edu.: Not Given, Profession & Occupation: Not Given Niki Singh Zone: Shahdara South, Constituency No.: 212, (Area: New Ashok Nagar), Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara South Ward Committee, Standing Committee Corporation: EDMC

122 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 123 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

51.13 11.13 4.66 9.78 5 18.57 2016 D 45 B E F A C BJP

Raj Kumar Age: 51, Edu.: Graduate, Profession & Occupation: Not Given Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara South Ward Committee, Education Committee, Dhillo Zone: Shahdara South, Constituency No.: 213, (Area: Kalyan Puri), Corporation: EDMC Environment Management Services Committee, Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee

47.11 3.49 4.16 14.64 5 17.82 2016 E 53 F E E A D BSP

Priyanka Age: 30, Edu.: Bachelor of Law (L.L.B.), Profession & Occupation: Advocate Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara South Ward Committee, Environment Management Gautam Zone: Shahdara South, Constituency No.: 215, (Area: Kondli), Corporation: EDMC Services Committee, Law & General Purposes Committee, Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee

61.16 11.51 9.50 12.66 3 17.50 2016 C 15 B A E C D INC Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara South Ward Committee, Age: 41, Edu.: HSC, Profession & Occupation: Self Employed Rajiv Kumar Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Garden Committee, Zone: Shahdara South, Constituency No.: 216, (Area: Gharoli), Corporation: EDMC Law & General Purposes Committee, Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee

55.55 13.44 3.50 13.53 5 17.08 2016 D 33 A F E A D BJP

Sarala Age: 51, Edu.: Literate, Profession & Occupation: Housewife Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara South Ward Committee, Assurance Committee, Chaudhari Zone: Shahdara South, Constituency No.: 217, (Area: Vinod Nagar), Corporation: EDMC Environment Management Services Committee, Hindi Committee, Code of Conduct for Councillors Committee

124 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 125 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

54.06 10.41 3.00 11.66 5 17.98 2016 D 38 C F E A D BJP

Age: 50, Edu.: Literate, Profession & Occupation: Housewife Sudeshana Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara South Ward Committee Zone: Shahdara South, Constituency No.: 218, (Area: Mandawali), Corporation: EDMC

33.80 9.17 0 0 0 18.63 2016 F 59 C F F F C BJP Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara South Ward Committee, Age: 43, Edu.: SSC, Profession & Occupation: Business (Milk Saller) Devendra Kumar Law & General Purposes Committee, Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee, Zone: Shahdara South, Constituency No.: 219, (Area: Mayur Vihar Ph-II), Corporation: EDMC Appointments Promotions, Disciplinary & Allied Matters

49.55 9.94 4.50 14.92 -5 18.18 2016 E 47 C E E F C BJP

Age: 47, Edu.: SSC, Profession & Occupation: Social Worker/House Maker Sandhya Verma Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara South Ward Committee Zone: Shahdara South, Constituency No.: 220, (Area: Patparganj), Corporation: EDMC

49.26 8.56 5.33 11.66 -2 18.71 2016 E 49 D D E F C BJP

Age: 57, Edu.: B. Tech., Profession & Occupation: Engineer, Farmer & Social Worker Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara South Ward Committee, B. B. Tyagi Zone: Shahdara South, Constituency No.: 221, (Area: Kishan Kunj), Corporation: EDMC Standing Committee, High Powered Property Taxes Committee, Municipal Accounts Committee

126 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 127 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

55.74 10.89 3.50 10.65 5 20.70 2016 D 32 B F F A C BJP

Age: 59, Edu.: Master Arts (M.A.), Profession & Occupation: Housewife Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara South Ward Committee, Asha Singh Zone: Shahdara South, Constituency No.: 222, (Area: Laxmi Nagar), Corporation: EDMC Assurance Committee, Hindi Committee, Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee

57.25 9.78 3.16 12.87 5 21.44 2016 D 30 C F E A B BJP

Sushil Age: 43, Edu.: SSC, Profession & Occupation: News Paper Distribution Agency Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara South Ward Committee, Upadhyay Zone: Shahdara South, Constituency No.: 223, (Area: Shakarpur), Corporation: EDMC Environment Management Services Committee, Garden Committee

65.50 11.24 9.83 11.92 3 23.52 2016 C 4 B A E C B BJP

Age: 41, Edu.: L.L.B., Profession & Occupation: Legal Consultancy Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara South Ward Committee, Standing Committee, Lata Gupta Zone: Shahdara South, Constituency No.: 224, (Area: Pandav Nagar), Corporation: EDMC High Powered Property Taxes Committee, Municipal Accounts Committee

63.92 14.30 7.16 11.33 5 19.13 2016 C 8 A B F A C BJP

Mahindra Age: 58, Edu.: Bachelor of Law, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara South Ward Committee, Hindi Committee, Kumar Zone: Shahdara South, Constituency No.: 225, (Area: Anand Vihar), Corporation: EDMC High Powered Property Taxes Committee

128 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 129 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

66.12 14.26 9.16 12.99 5 18.71 2016 C 3 A A E A C INC

Age: 58, Edu.: Ninth, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara South Ward Committee, Ratan Singh Zone: Shahdara South, Constituency No.: 226, (Area: Vishwas Nagar), Corporation: EDMC Works Committee, Garden Committee, Code of Conduct for Councillors Committee

64.48 12.13 9.00 13.07 5 19.29 2016 C 6 A A E A C INC Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara South Ward Committee, Age: 45, Edu.: HSC, Profession & Occupation: Tution & Rental Income Geeta Sharma Appointments Promotions, Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Zone: Shahdara South, Constituency No.: 227, (Area: I.P. Extension), Corporation: EDMC Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, High Powered Property Taxes Committee

47.64 6.74 1.50 8.09 5 20.32 2016 E 50 E F F A C INC Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara South Ward Committee, Education Committee, Gurcharan Age: 51, Edu.: Under Matriculation, Profession & Occupation: Business Appointments Promotions, Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Hindi Committee, Zone: Shahdara South, Constituency No.: 228, (Area: Preet Vihar), Corporation: EDMC Singh Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee, Municipal Accounts Committee

64.99 14.15 9.33 12.57 5 16.93 2016 C 5 A A E A D BJP

Kalpana Devi Age: 59, Edu.: Higher Secondary, Profession & Occupation: Housewife Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara South Ward Committee, Works Committee, Jain Zone: Shahdara South, Constituency No.: 229, (Area: Krishna Nagar), Corporation: EDMC Environment Management Services Committee, Law & General Purposes Committee

130 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 131 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

IND 47.59 10.12 2.16 12.33 0 17.99 2016 E 51 C F E F D

Age: 61, Edu.: Seventh, Profession & Occupation: Job Work of Manufacturing Utensils Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara South Ward Committee, Environment Management Bansi Lal Zone: Shahdara South, Constituency No.: 230, (Area: Geeta Colony), Corporation: EDMC Services Committee, Garden Committee, Code of Conduct for Councillors Committee

59.44 8.39 8.16 13.38 5 17.51 2016 D 20 D A E A D INC

Age: 34, Edu.: Bachelor of Law (L.L.B.), Profession & Occupation: Advocate Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara South Ward Committee, Appointments Promotions, Ishrat Jahan Zone: Shahdara South, Constituency No.: 231, (Area: Ghondli), Corporation: EDMC Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Works Committee, Law & General Purposes Committee

58.28 9.92 6.00 11.87 5 18.49 2016 D 26 C C E A C BJP

Age: 60, Edu.: B. Com. (IInd Year), Profession & Occupation: Tailors (Service sector) Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara South Ward Committee, Appointments Promotions, Jai Gopal Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Garden Committee, Zone: Shahdara South, Constituency No.: 232, (Area: Anarkali), Corporation: EDMC Law & General Purposes Committee, High Powered Property Taxes Committee

57.66 8.19 3.83 14.91 5 20.73 2016 D 28 D E E A C INC

Age: 35, Edu.: Eighth, Profession & Occupation: Business - Boutique Tulshi Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara South Ward Committee, Hindi Committee Zone: Shahdara South, Constituency No.: 233, (Area: Dharampura), Corporation: EDMC

132 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 133 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

54.59 7.83 2.00 14.62 5 20.14 2016 D 37 D F E A C INC

Age: 51, Edu.: HSC, Profession & Occupation: Rental Income Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara South Ward Committee, Anjana Sharma Zone: Shahdara South, Constituency No.: 234, (Area: Gandhi Nagar), Corporation: EDMC Assurance Committee, High Powered Property Taxes Committee

58.52 10.66 3.33 12.90 5 19.64 2016 D 24 B F E A C BJP

Age: 40, Edu.: M.A. (Budhijam), Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara South Ward Committee, Works Committee, Jitender Zone: Shahdara South, Constituency No.: 235, (Area: Azad Nagar), Corporation: EDMC Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, High Powered Property Taxes Committee

67.60 11.19 9.66 12.39 5 22.37 2016 C 1 B A E A B INC

Age: 64, Edu.: SSC, Profession & Occupation: Rental Income Varyam Kaur Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara South Ward Committee, Standing Committee Zone: Shahdara South, Constituency No.: 236, (Area: Raghubarpura), Corporation: EDMC

61.18 14.30 5.33 14.34 5 17.21 2016 C 14 A D E A D BJP Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara South Ward Committee, Works Committee, Age: 67, Edu.: Fifth, Profession & Occupation: Retire (Times of India) Pesioner Balbir Singh Environment Management Services Committee, Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee, Zone: Shahdara South, Constituency No.: 237, (Area: Shahdara), Corporation: EDMC Code of Conduct for Councillors Committee

134 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 135 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

IND 57.89 8.98 7.83 10.85 5 18.23 2016 D 27 D B F A C

Age: 57, Edu.: Under Graduate, Profession & Occupation: Member of MCD/Social Worker Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara South Ward Committee, Works Committee, Preeti Zone: Shahdara South, Constituency No.: 239, (Area: Vivek Vihar), Corporation: EDMC Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Garden Committee

60.24 10.44 10.00 10.91 5 17.89 2016 C 17 C A F A D BJP

Ram Narayan Age: 71, Edu.: Junior High School, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara North Ward Committee, Dubey Zone: Shahdara North, Constituency No.: 240, (Area: Dilshad Colony), Corporation: EDMC Standing Committee, High Powered Property Taxes Committee, Municipal Accounts Committee

59.96 13.27 7.00 12.05 5 15.64 2016 D 18 A B E A D BJP

Age: 44, Edu.: M.A., Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara North Ward Committee, Swati Gupta Zone: Shahdara North, Constituency No.: 241, (Area: Dilshad Garden), Corporation: EDMC Works Committee, Law & General Purposes Committee

59.04 14.29 5.16 10.61 5 16.98 2016 D 22 A D F A D BJP

Sunil Kumar Age: 37, Edu.: B.Com., Profession & Occupation: Public Transportation Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara North Ward Committee, Jha Zone: Shahdara North, Constituency No.: 242, (Area: New Seemapuri), Corporation: EDMC Assurance Committee, Municipal Accounts Committee, Code of Conduct for Councillors Committee

136 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 137 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

62.37 12.24 6.83 11.93 5 19.38 2016 C 11 A C E A C INC Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara North Ward Committee, Age: 41, Edu.: Matric, Profession & Occupation: Social Worker Rinku Appointments Promotions, Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Zone: Shahdara North, Constituency No.: 243, (Area: Nand Nagari), Corporation: EDMC Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Law & General Purposes Committee

53.90 11.66 4.83 11.30 5 17.11 2016 D 39 B E F A D BJP

Age: 46, Edu.: Literate, Profession & Occupation: Shop Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara North Ward Committee, Kamlesh Zone: Shahdara North, Constituency No.: 244, (Area: Sunder Nagari), Corporation: EDMC Garden Committee, Hindi Committee

66.34 12.27 8.33 13.47 5 20.28 2016 C 2 A A E A C INC

Age: 41, Edu.: L.L.B., M.A., Profession & Occupation: Advocate (Practice) Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara North Ward Committee, Anil Gautam Zone: Shahdara North, Constituency No.: 245, (Area: Durga Puri), Corporation: EDMC Works Committee, Law & General Purposes Committee, Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee

50.10 5.90 0.66 9.27 5 22.27 2016 D 46 E F F A B BJP

Age: 48, Edu.: B.Com. (Hon.), L.L.B., Profession & Occupation: Advocate Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara North Ward Committee, Sanjay Surjan Zone: Shahdara North, Constituency No.: 246, (Area: Ashok Nagar), Corporation: EDMC Works Committee, Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Law & General Purposes Committee

138 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 139 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

45.19 6.74 1.00 6.66 5 18.79 2016 E 55 E F F A C BJP Age: 49, Edu.: Graduate, Degree in Shiksha Visharad, Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara North Ward Committee, Sushma Sharma Profession & Occupation: Proprietor, Dealing in Handloom & Part time Teaching Education Committee, Garden Committee Zone: Shahdara North, Constituency No.: 247, (Area: Ram Nagar), Corporation: EDMC

54.62 7.35 4.33 11.64 5 22.30 2016 D 35 E E E A B BSP

Age: 48, Edu.: Eighth, Profession & Occupation: Housewife Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara North Ward Committee, Asma Begum Zone: Shahdara North, Constituency No.: 249, (Area: Chauhan Bangar), Corporation: EDMC Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Environment Management Services Committee

47.45 6.19 1.00 10.98 5 20.28 2016 E 52 E F F A C BSP

Age: 45, Edu.: Fifth, Profession & Occupation: Milk Dairy/Social Worker Shakila Begum Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara North Ward Committee, Hindi Committee Zone: Shahdara North, Constituency No.: 250, (Area: Jafrabad), Corporation: EDMC

60.29 14.36 6.66 8.89 5 23.38 2016 C 16 A C F A B BJP Age: 46, Edu.: B.A. Programme (One Paper Short), Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara North Ward Committee, Education Committee, Profession & Occupation: Prop. of M/s Satya Sharma & Business Consultancy Satya Sharma Appointments Promotions, Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee Zone: Shahdara North, Constituency No.: 251, (Area: New Usmanpur), Corporation: EDMC

140 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 141 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

51.22 9.63 0.83 10.17 5 23.59 2016 D 44 C F F A B BJP Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara North Ward Committee, Age: 42, Edu.: B. Com., L.L.B., Profession & Occupation: Businessman Sanjay Jain Appointments Promotions, Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Garden Committee, Zone: Shahdara North, Constituency No.: 252, (Area: Maujpur), Corporation: EDMC Law & General Purposes Committee, High Powered Property Taxes Committee

54.62 10.67 8.66 10.98 5 17.31 2016 D 36 B A F A D INC Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara North Ward Committee, Education Committee, Age: 48, Edu.: Bachelor of Commerce, Profession & Occupation: Businessman Rekha Rani Appointments Promotions, Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Zone: Shahdara North, Constituency No.: 253, (Area: Bhajanpura), Corporation: EDMC Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Law & General Purposes Committee

51.74 8.55 2.66 12.07 5 17.45 2016 D 41 D F E A D BJP

Age: 47, Edu.: Bachelor Art, Profession & Occupation: Social Worker Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara North Ward Committee, Mahak Singh Zone: Shahdara North, Constituency No.: 254, (Area: Brahampuri), Corporation: EDMC Appointments Promotions, Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee

57.53 12.87 7.33 13.15 5 14.18 2016 D 29 A B E A E INC

Age: 47, Edu.: SSC, Profession & Occupation: Businessman Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara North Ward Committee, Raj Kumari Zone: Shahdara North, Constituency No.: 255, (Area: Ghonda), Corporation: EDMC Environment Management Services Committee, Hindi Committee, High Powered Property Taxes Committee

142 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 143 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

58.50 13.18 7.33 11.29 5 17.70 2016 D 25 A B F A D BJP

Age: Not Given, Edu.: Not Given, Profession & Occupation: Not Given Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara North Ward Committee, Appointments Promotions, Asha Tayal Zone: Shahdara North, Constituency No.: 256, (Area: Yamuna Vihar), Corporation: EDMC Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Garden Committee, Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee

61.65 9.44 8.50 12.89 5 18.82 2016 C 12 C A E A C INC

Age: 49, Edu.: Secondary School, Profession & Occupation: Manufacturing & Rental Income Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara North Ward Committee, Standing Committee, Savita Sharma Zone: Shahdara North, Constituency No.: 257, (Area: Subhash Mohalla), Corporation: EDMC Garden Committee, High Powered Property Taxes Committee, Municipal Accounts Committee

61.53 13.20 6.50 12.07 5 17.75 2016 C 13 A C E A D BJP Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara North Ward Committee, Age: 51, Edu.: Master of Art & Bachelor of Education, Profession & Occupation: Home Tuition Chanda Sharma Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Environment Management Services Committee, Zone: Shahdara North, Constituency No.: 258, (Area: Kardampuri), Corporation: EDMC Garden Committee, Law & General Purposes Committee

59.81 13.44 6.16 11.75 5 17.46 2016 D 19 A C E A D INC

Age: 42, Edu.: Bachelor of Art, Profession & Occupation: Readymade Garments Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara North Ward Committee, Zakir Khan Zone: Shahdara North, Constituency No.: 259, (Area: Janta Colony), Corporation: EDMC Assurance Committee, Works Committee, Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee

144 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 145 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

64.08 13.71 6.33 13.90 5 18.14 2016 C 7 A C E A C SP

Age: 53, Edu.: B. Ed. M.D., Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara North Ward Committee, Rekha Vasisht Zone: Shahdara North, Constituency No.: 260, (Area: Babarpur), Corporation: EDMC Environment Management Services Committee, Hindi Committee

55.53 13.22 2.83 10.08 5 17.40 2016 D 34 A F F A D BJP

Age: 47, Edu.: L.L.B., Profession & Occupation: Advocacy Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara North Ward Committee, Sanjay Kaushik Zone: Shahdara North, Constituency No.: 261, (Area: Jeevanpur), Corporation: EDMC Works Committee, Medical Relief & Public Health Committee

51.50 5.50 3.83 13.07 5 18.10 2016 D 43 E E E A C BSP

Choudhary Age: 47, Edu.: Eighth, Profession & Occupation: Own Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara North Ward Committee, Balraj Zone: Shahdara North, Constituency No.: 262, (Area: Gokalpur), Corporation: EDMC Hindi Committee, Municipal Accounts Committee, Code of Conduct for Councillors Committee

62.53 13.52 7.66 10.76 3 20.60 2016 C 10 A B F C C BJP

Age: 58, Edu.: Post Graduate, Profession & Occupation: Not Given Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara North Ward Committee, Standing Committee, Deepti Joshi Zone: Shahdara North, Constituency No.: 263, (Area: Saboli), Corporation: EDMC Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee

146 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 147 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

59.40 10.77 5.83 12.36 5 18.44 2016 D 21 B D E A C BJP

Manoj Kumar Age: 40, Edu.: B.A., Profession & Occupation: Business (Cable TV) Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara North Ward Committee, Standing Committee, Tyagi Zone: Shahdara North, Constituency No.: 264, (Area: Harsh Vihar), Corporation: EDMC Assurance Committee, Appointments Promotions, Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee

46.18 10.44 2.33 9.89 5 17.53 2016 E 54 C F F A D BJP

Age: 31, Edu.: HSC, Profession & Occupation: Housewife Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara North Ward Committee, Meenakshi Zone: Shahdara North, Constituency No.: 265, (Area: Shiv Vihar), Corporation: EDMC Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Municipal Accounts Committee

51.79 13.29 5.66 11.51 5 14.33 2016 D 40 A D F A E BJP Age: 49, Edu.: HSC (Madhyama), Profession & Occupation: Housewife Usha Devrani Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara North Ward Committee, Works Committee, Zone: Shahdara North, Constituency No.: 266, (Area: Karawal Nagar East) Shastri Medical Relief & Public Health Committee, Appointments Promotions, Disciplinary & Allied Matters Corporation: EDMC

58.84 13.79 8.83 14.38 3 17.84 2016 D 23 A A E C D INC

Age: 52, Edu.: Eighth, Profession & Occupation: Business Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara North Ward Committee, Works Committee, Taj Mohammad Zone: Shahdara North, Constituency No.: 267, (Area: Nehru Vihar), Corporation: EDMC Environment Management Services Committee

148 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 149 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

26.97 5.26 0 0 5 15.71 2016 F 60 E F F A D INC

Age: 38, Edu.: Forth, Profession & Occupation: Housewife/Boutique Business Parveen Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara North Ward Committee Zone: Shahdara North, Constituency No.: 268, (Area: Mustafabad), Corporation: EDMC

43.13 7.31 2.50 10.69 5 16.63 2016 E 56 E F F A D INC

Age: 48, Edu.: Eighth, Profession & Occupation: Food Business Aas Mohammad Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara North Ward Committee Zone: Shahdara North, Constituency No.: 269, (Area: Khajoori Khas), Corporation: EDMC

62.86 14.08 8.00 13.38 5 17.40 2016 C 9 A A E A D BJP

Age: 45, Edu.: High School (Fail), Profession & Occupation: Housewife Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara North Ward Committee, Rural Area Committee, Anita Sharma Zone: Shahdara North, Constituency No.: 270, (Area: Tukh Mirpur), Corporation: EDMC Environment Management Services Committee

IND 40.83 5.61 1.66 10.49 5 17.07 2016 E 57 E F F A D

Age: 46, Edu.: Uneducated, Profession & Occupation: Business Dharmendra Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara North Ward Committee, Zone: Shahdara North, Constituency No.: 271, (Area: Karawal Nagar West) Rural Area Committee, Works Committee, Medical Relief & Public Health Committee Singh Corporation: EDMC

150 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 151 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL ISSUES RAISED ISSUES RAISED RECORD PERFORMANCE Political Party GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLORS Score Score Score Score Score % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 33 out of 5 out of 30

37.21 5.61 0.50 9.72 5 15.38 2016 E 58 E F F A D BJP

Annapurna Age: 61, Edu.: Ph.D, Profession & Occupation: Social Worker Committee: General Body Meeting (GBM), Shahdara North Ward Committee, Rural Area Committee, Mishra Zone: Shahdara North, Constituency No.: 272, (Area: Sonia Vihar), Corporation: EDMC Appointments Promotions, Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee, Law & General Purposes Committee

152 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 153 cegK³e efJeMues

Note: Number of MUNICIPAL Councillors who were ranked in NDMC : 99; sdmc : 95 & edmc : 61

Aendance Importance of Issue Raised A - 100% to 80% marks A - 100% to 80% marks B - Less than 80% to 70% marks 34 B - Less than 80% to 70% marks 35 C - Less than 70% to 60% marks 60 C - Less than 70% to 60% marks Avg. Score: D - Less than60% to 50% marks 53 D - Less than 60% to 50% marks 52 E - Less than 50% to 35% marks 68% in NDMC, E - Less than 50% to 35% marks 30 F - Less than 35% marks 66% in SDMC 26 F - Less than 35% marks 50 46 & 68.6% in 43 42 rs EDMC 25 rs llo i 20 21 llo 40 ci 20 18 Avg. Score: 34.5% in NDMC,

of Counc 15 15 15 30

. 34.7% in SDMC 14 of Coun 15 . & 35.7% in EDMC No 19

11 11 No 9 10 10 10 20 10 7 7 10 5 2 000000000 0 0 0 0 0 NDMC SDMC EDMC NDMC SDMC EDMC Corporaon Corporaon

No. of Issues Raised Issue Raised Compared to Cizen's Complaints

34 A - 100% to 80% marks 35 34 60 0 1 to 10 54 B - Less than 80% to 70% marks 28 29 11 to 20 21 to 50 C - Less than 70% to 60% marks 30 51 to 100 Above 100 50 46 D - Less than60% to 50% marks 42 E - Less than 50% to 35% marks 25 Total No. Issues F - Less than 35% marks Raised: 8,011 in 40 Avg. Score: 34 37 18 NDMC, 5,521in 35.2% in

20 rs

rs 17 17 16 SDMC & 4,523 16 NDMC, 31.6% illo illo in EDMC 30 15 in SDMC & 31.1% in EDMC 19 Counc 9

of Counc 20

of 8 10 7 .

er 6 11

5 No

mb 333 7 5 2 10 4 Nu 0000000 0 1 0 0 NDMC SDMC EDMC NDMC SDMC EDMC Corporaon Corporaon

154 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 155 Quality of Issues Raised Percepon of Public Services A - 100% to 80% marks B - Less than 80% to 70% marks 48 60 60 55 50 A - 100% to 80% marks C - Less than 70% to 60% marks Avg. Score: B - Less than 80% to 70% marks D - Less than60% to 50% marks 43 45 61.5% in C - Less than 70% to 60% marks E - Less than 50% to 35% marks 50 NDMC, 62.1% D - Less than60% to 50% marks F - Less than 35% marks 40 E - Less than 50% to 35% marks 39 40 in SDMC & 35 59.7% in EDMC F - Less than 35% marks rs 30 rs 40 Avg. Score: 36 illo llo i 34.7% in 30 24 26 NDMC, 33.7% 25 30 in SDMC & 25 19 of Counc of Counc 34.3% in EDMC . 20 . 15 No No 20 15 10 11 10 10 6 10 4 3 3 5 1 110 0000000000 0 0 0 0 NDMC SDMC EDMC NDMC SDMC EDMC Corporaon Corporaon

Perceived Accessibility Perceived Least Corrupt A - 100% to 80% marks B - Less than 80% to 70% marks 39 A - 100% to 80% marks C - Less than 70% to 60% marks 40 37 B - Less than 80% to 70% marks 40 38 D - Less than60% to 50% marks C - Less than 70% to 60% marks E - Less than 50% to 35% marks D - Less than60% to 50% marks 34 F - Less than 35% marks 35 Avg. Score: E - Less than 50% to 35% marks 35 32 53% in NDMC, F - Less than 35% marks 31 55% in SDMC 30 28 Avg. Score: & 48.9% in 30 rs

rs 67.3% in EDMC 23 illo llo 25 NDMC, 70.8% i 25 in SDMC & 68.1% in EDMC 20 Counc 16 16 16 20 of of Counc 14 16 . 15 15 12 12 12 er No 10 11 13 mb 15 12 8 8 9 11 10 6 Nu 9 4 10 6 7 5 2 5 2 0 001 0 NDMC SDMC EDMC 0 Corporaon NDMC SDMC EDMC Corporaon

156 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 157 Least Criminal Record Average Score for Different Parameters 90 90 80 90 82 70 Good e or 60

80 Average Sc Poor e 50 70 ag 40 er

Av 30 60 Number of Municipal Councillors with: NDMC SDMC EDMC 52

rs 20 FIRs as per Affidavit 2012, since elected 5 11 9 llo 50 10 ci New FIRs Registered as on 31st December 2015 4 2 2* 0 40 Charge sheeted as on 31st December 2015 4 6 1 NDMC SDMC EDMC Delhi Aendance 68.02 66.00 68.60 67.41 of Coun

. 30 Issues Raised 49.64 49.36 49.75 49.56 No 20 12 Importance of Issue Raised 34.47 34.68 35.70 34.84 Issue Raised Compared to Cizen's Complaints 35.20 31.56 31.14 32.87 7 4 5 10 2 1 Perceived Accessibility 52.97 54.96 48.93 52.75 Percepon of Public Services 61.4962.14 59.72 61.31 0 Perceived Least Corrupt 67.30 70.80 68.07 68.79 NDMC SDMC EDMC Least Criminal Record 89.90 83.79 85.25 86.51 Overall Score 56.22 56.04 54.52 55.75 Corporaon

(*) Includes 2 Councillors (EDMC) who had FIRs before elections as declared in their affidavit.

Overall Grade

A - 100% to 80% marks 50 47 B - Less than 80% to 70% marks 44 C - Less than 70% to 60% marks 45 D - Less than60% to 50% marks 40 E - Less than 50% to 35% marks Avg. Score: F - Less than 35% marks 33 56.2% in 33 rs 35

llo NDMC, 56% in

i 29 30 SDMC & 54.5% in EDMC 25 of Counc . 20 16 17 No 14 15 12 10 333 5 000 1 0 0 0 NDMC SDMC EDMC Corporaon

158 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 159 Overall Top 5 Councillors Overall Bottom 5 Councillors

NDMC NDMC

Political Score Overall Political Score Overall Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 100) Rank Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 100) Rank

City 83 INC Seema Taihra 69.78 1 Narela 29 INC Manisha Jasbir Karala 32.17 99

City 82 BSP Rakesh Kumar 68.59 2 Narela 4 BSP Reeta 32.67 98

Sadar Paharganj 87 BJP Lata Sodhi 67.59 3 Narela 32 IND Reeta Shokeen 32.78 97

Narela 1 BJP Kesh Rani 67.28 4 Civil Line 11 BJP Rajni Abbi 40.48 96

Rohini 42 INC Prithvi Singh Rathore 66.75 5 Civil Line 64 BJP Kishan Lal 41.08 95

SDMC SDMC

Political Score Overall Political Score Overall Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 100) Rank Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 100) Rank

West 118 BJP Rajni Mamtani 72.41 1 West 103 BJP Satwinder Kaur Sirsa 31.86 95

Central 153 BJP Simmi Jain 69.46 2 Najafgarh 138 INLD Kirshan 33.21 94

South 165 BJP Radhey Shyam Sharma 67.86 3 Central 208 INC Neetu 34.34 93

West 123 BJP Karam Vir Shekhar 67.33 4 South 164 BJP Ankita Saini 39.27 92

South 170 NCP Pushpa Singh 66.24 5 South 162 INC Nutan Kochar 40.51 91

EDMC EDMC

Political Score Overall Political Score Overall Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 100) Rank Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 100) Rank

Shahdara South 236 INC Varyam Kaur 67.60 1 Shahdara South 211 IND Kamal 21.55 61

Shahdara North 245 INC Anil Gautam 66.34 2 Shahdara North 268 INC Parveen 26.97 60

Shahdara South 226 INC Ratan Singh 66.12 3 Shahdara South 219 BJP Devendra Kumar 33.80 59

Shahdara South 224 BJP Lata Gupta 65.50 4 Shahdara North 272 BJP Annapurna Mishra 37.21 58

Shahdara South 229 BJP Kalpana Devi Jain 64.99 5 Shahdara North 271 IND Dharmendra Singh 40.83 57

160 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 161 Top 5 Councillors in Attendance Bottom 5 Councillors in Attendance

NDMC NDMC

Political Score Overall Political Score Overall Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 15) Rank Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 15) Rank

City 83 INC Seema Taihra 15.00 1 Narela 29 INC Manisha Jasbir Karala 1.46 99

Sadar Paharganj 87 BJP Lata Sodhi 15.00 3 Narela 4 BSP Reeta 2.47 98

Narela 1 BJP Kesh Rani 14.78 4 Narela 32 IND Reeta Shokeen 2.69 97

Karol Bagh 94 BJP Bhim Singh Sharma 14.76 21 Rohini 36 BSP Pushp Raj 3.17 94

Rohini 51 BJP Tara Chand Bansal 14.75 7 Civil Line 78 INC Naina Premwani 3.36 89

SDMC SDMC

Political Score Overall Political Score Overall Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 15) Rank Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 15) Rank

West 101 BJP Suman Tyagi 14.73 8 West 103 BJP Satwinder Kaur Sirsa 2.33 95

West 118 BJP Rajni Mamtani 14.65 1 South 161 BJP Satish Upadhyay 2.70 85

Najafgarh 130 INC Maya Devi 14.49 31 South 162 INC Nutan Kochar 3.42 91

West 113 BJP Yash pal Arya 14.40 10 West 125 INC Anju Gupta 3.52 87

West 123 BJP Karam Vir Shekhar 14.38 4 Central 208 INC Neetu 3.77 93

EDMC EDMC

Political Score Overall Political Score Overall Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 15) Rank Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 15) Rank

Shahdara North 251 BJP Satya Sharma 14.36 16 Shahdara South 211 IND Kamal 3.48 61

Shahdara South 225 BJP Mahindra Kumar 14.30 8 Shahdara South 215 BSP Priyanka Gautam 3.49 53

Shahdara South 237 BJP Balbir Singh 14.30 14 Shahdara North 268 INC Parveen 5.26 60

Shahdara North 242 BJP Sunil Kumar Jha 14.29 22 Shahdara North 262 BSP Choudhary Balraj 5.50 43

Shahdara South 226 INC Ratan Singh 14.26 3 Shahdara North 271 IND Dharmendra Singh 5.61 57

162 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 163 Top 5 Councillors in Issues Raised Bottom 5 Councillors in Issues Raised

NDMC NDMC

Political No. of Overall Political No. of Overall Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name issues raised Rank Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name issues raised Rank

Narela 2 BJP Mohan Prasad Bhardwaj 809 13 Narela 4 BSP Reeta 0 98

Karol Bagh 92 BJP Yogender Chandoliya 645 12 Narela 29 INC Manisha Jasbir Karala 0 99

Civil Line 13 INC Mukesh Kumar Goel 367 10 Civil Line 64 BJP Kishan Lal 1 95

Sadar Paharganj 89 BJP Virender Babbar 309 6 Narela 32 IND Reeta Shokeen 2 97

Sadar Paharganj 90 INC Madhu Khurana 226 18 Civil Line 11 BJP Rajni Abbi 3 96

SDMC SDMC

Political No. of Overall Political No. of Overall Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name issues raised Rank Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name issues raised Rank

South 165 BJP Radhey Shyam Sharma 800 3 West 103 BJP Satwinder Kaur Sirsa 0 95

West 117 BJP Ashish Sood 374 15 South 164 BJP Ankita Saini 0 92

Central 154 INC Farhad Suri 229 16 Central 208 INC Neetu 0 93

West 118 BJP Rajni Mamtani 158 1 West 108 INC A.Meenakshi Chandela A 1 90

West 113 BJP Yash pal Arya 120 10 West 115 BJP Dimple Chadha 1 89

Najafgarh 138 INLD Kirshan 1 94

South 162 INC Nutan Kochar 1 91

EDMC EDMC

Political No. of Overall Political No. of Overall Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name issues raised Rank Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name issues raised Rank

Shahdara North 240 BJP Ram Narayan Dubey 312 17 Shahdara South 211 IND Kamal 0 61

Shahdara South 224 BJP Lata Gupta 264 4 Shahdara South 219 BJP Devendra Kumar 0 59

Shahdara South 236 INC Varyam Kaur 201 1 Shahdara North 268 INC Parveen 0 60

Shahdara South 216 INC Rajiv Kumar 187 15 Shahdara North 272 BJP Annapurna Mishra 3 58

Shahdara South 229 BJP Kalpana Devi Jain 177 5 Shahdara North 246 BJP Sanjay Surjan 4 46

164 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 165 Top 5 Councillors in Importance of Bottom 5 Councillors in Importance of Issue Raised Issue Raised

NDMC NDMC

Political Score Overall Political Score Overall Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 23) Rank Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 23) Rank

City 83 INC Seema Taihra 10.57 1 Narela 4 BSP Reeta 0 98

City 82 BSP Rakesh Kumar 10.43 2 Narela 29 INC Manisha Jasbir Karala 0 99

Rohini 26 INC Sharadha Nand Sangwan 10.24 34 Civil Line 64 BJP Kishan Lal 5.52 95

Narela 3 INC Aruna Devi 10.14 59 Narela 32 IND Reeta Shokeen 5.53 97

Rohini 37 BJP Sushila Kumari 10.10 58 Civil Line 11 BJP Rajni Abbi 5.55 96

SDMC SDMC

Political Score Overall Political Score Overall Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 23) Rank Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 23) Rank

Central 187 IND Kalpana Jha 10.55 33 West 103 BJP Satwinder Kaur Sirsa 0 95

Najafgarh 131 IND Parveen Rajput 10.51 14 South 164 BJP Ankita Saini 0 92

South 184 BJP M. Nagarajan 10.26 7 Central 208 INC Neetu 0 93

Central 186 BJP Kali Charan Sharma 10.16 13 Najafgarh 138 INLD Kirshan 4.04 94

South 170 NCP Pushpa Singh 10.13 5 West 108 INC A.Meenakshi Chandela A 5.54 90

West 115 BJP Dimple Chadha 5.54 89

South 162 INC Nutan Kochar 5.54 91

EDMC EDMC

Political Score Overall Political Score Overall Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 23) Rank Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 23) Rank

Shahdara North 245 INC Anil Gautam 10.74 2 Shahdara South 211 IND Kamal 0 61

Shahdara South 233 INC Tulshi 10.24 28 Shahdara South 219 BJP Devendra Kumar 0 59

Shahdara South 220 BJP Sandhya Verma 10.22 47 Shahdara North 268 INC Parveen 0 60

Shahdara South 215 BSP Priyanka Gautam 10.09 53 Shahdara South 228 INC Gurcharan Singh 6.39 50

Shahdara North 264 BJP Manoj Kumar Tyagi 10.00 21 Shahdara North 247 BJP Sushma Sharma 5.62 55

166 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 167 Top 5 Councillors in Issue Raised Bottom 5 Councillors in Issue Raised Compared to Citizen's Complaints Compared to Citizen's Complaints

NDMC NDMC

Political Score Overall Political Score Overall Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 10) Rank Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 10) Rank

Civil Line 68 BJP Poonam Sharma 5.74 63 Narela 4 BSP Reeta 0 98

Rohini 24 IND Pushpa 5.68 75 Narela 29 INC Manisha Jasbir Karala 0 99

Civil Line 70 BJP Renu Gupta 5.62 44 Civil Line 64 BJP Kishan Lal 0 95

Civil Line 72 BJP Surender Gupta 5.40 51 Narela 32 IND Reeta Shokeen 0.28 97

Karol Bagh 99 BJP Bharat Bhushan Madan 5.38 15 Civil Line 11 BJP Rajni Abbi 0.24 96

SDMC SDMC

Political Score Overall Political Score Overall Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 10) Rank Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 10) Rank

Central 205 INC Shoeb Danish 5.95 28 West 103 BJP Satwinder Kaur Sirsa 0 95

Central 158 IND Kusum Lata 5.86 54 South 164 BJP Ankita Saini 0 92

Central 197 BJP Chote Ram 5.82 77 South 182 BJP Khushi Ram Chunar 0 83

Central 206 INC Ishrat Begum 5.72 39 Central 208 INC Neetu 0 93

South 175 BJP Gyasi 5.58 42 Najafgarh 138 INLD Kirshan 0.18 94

EDMC EDMC

Political Score Overall Political Score Overall Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 10) Rank Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 10) Rank

Shahdara South 212 BJP Niki Singh 6.11 31 Shahdara South 211 IND Kamal 0 61

Shahdara South 237 BJP Balbir Singh 5.31 14 Shahdara South 219 BJP Devendra Kumar 0 59

Shahdara North 267 INC Taj Mohammad 5.29 23 Shahdara North 268 INC Parveen 0 60

Shahdara South 217 BJP Sarala Chaudhari 5.21 33 Shahdara North 272 BJP Annapurna Mishra 0.33 58

Shahdara North 270 BJP Anita Sharma 5.13 9 Shahdara North 252 BJP Sanjay Jain 0.58 44

168 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 169 Top 5 Councillors in Quality OF Issues Raised Bottom 5 Councillors in Quality OF Issues Raised

NDMC NDMC

Political Score Overall Political Score Overall Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 33) Rank Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 33) Rank

City 82 BSP Rakesh Kumar 14.72 2 Narela 4 BSP Reeta 0 98

City 83 INC Seema Taihra 14.11 1 Narela 29 INC Manisha Jasbir Karala 0 99

Civil Line 6 LJSP Gulab Singh Rathore 14.09 56 Civil Line 64 BJP Kishan Lal 5.52 95

Civil Line 70 BJP Renu Gupta 13.99 44 Civil Line 11 BJP Rajni Abbi 5.78 96

Sadar Paharganj 90 INC Madhu Khurana 13.87 18 Narela 32 IND Reeta Shokeen 5.82 97

SDMC SDMC

Political Score Overall Political Score Overall Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 33) Rank Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 33) Rank

Central 197 BJP Chote Ram 14.85 77 West 103 BJP Satwinder Kaur Sirsa 0 95

West 120 INC Vimla Devi 14.73 56 South 164 BJP Ankita Saini 0 92

Central 185 NCP Babli 14.73 45 Central 208 INC Neetu 0 93

Central 159 INC Abhishek Dutt 14.68 40 Najafgarh 138 INLD Kirshan 4.21 94

Central 205 INC Shoeb Danish 15.72 28 South 177 BJP Sarita Choudhary 5.85 88

EDMC EDMC

Political Score Overall Political Score Overall Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 33) Rank Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 33) Rank

Shahdara South 220 BJP Sandhya Verma 14.92 47 Shahdara South 211 IND Kamal 0 61

Shahdara South 233 INC Tulshi 14.91 28 Shahdara South 219 BJP Devendra Kumar 0 59

Shahdara South 215 BSP Priyanka Gautam 14.64 53 Shahdara North 268 INC Parveen 0 60

Shahdara South 234 INC Anjana Sharma 14.62 37 Shahdara North 247 BJP Sushma Sharma 6.66 55

Shahdara North 267 INC Taj Mohammad 14.38 23 Shahdara South 228 INC Gurcharan Singh 8.09 50

170 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 171 Top 5 Councillors in Accesibility Bottom 5 Councillors in Accesibility

NDMC NDMC

Political Score Overall Political Score Overall Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 5) Rank Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 5) Rank

Rohini 22 INC Shashi 4.46 40 Civil Line 20 BJP Satya Wati Chauhan 1.09 43

Civil Line 16 INC Parma Bhai Solanki 4.44 61 Karol Bagh 151 BJP Suraj Kumar 1.19 81

Civil Line 71 BJP Madhav Prasad 4.44 17 Karol Bagh 152 IND Parmod Tanwar 1.21 57

Civil Line 13 INC Mukesh Kumar Goel 4.39 10 Rohini 60 INC Jyoti Aggarwal 1.25 66

Civil Line 70 BJP Renu Gupta 4.38 44 Karol Bagh 94 BJP Bhim Singh Sharma 1.26 21

SDMC SDMC

Political Score Overall Political Score Overall Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 5) Rank Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 5) Rank

Najafgarh 140 BJP Rajkumari 4.48 60 West 120 INC Vimla Devi 1.25 56

South 179 IND Sarita 4.42 62 West 103 BJP Satwinder Kaur Sirsa 1.47 95

Central 196 INC Narinder Kaur Captain 4.42 52 Central 200 NCP Jivan Lal 1.55 49

South 181 BJP Satender Prakash 4.26 36 West 101 BJP Suman Tyagi 1.60 8

South 172 BJP Kusum Khatri 4.24 58 West 114 BJP Ritu Vohra 1.62 27

EDMC EDMC

Political Score Overall Political Score Overall Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 5) Rank Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 5) Rank

Shahdara South 236 INC Varyam Kaur 4.58 1 Shahdara North 266 BJP Usha Devrani Shastri 1.01 40

Shahdara South 234 INC Anjana Sharma 4.15 37 Shahdara North 267 INC Taj Mohammad 1.15 23

Shahdara South 223 BJP Sushil Upadhyay 3.85 30 Shahdara North 241 BJP Swati Gupta 1.17 18

Shahdara South 233 INC Tulshi 3.79 28 Shahdara South 210 INC Anjana 1.26 42

Shahdara North 263 BJP Deepti Joshi 3.62 10 Shahdara South 211 IND Kamal 1.27 61

172 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 173 Top 5 Councillors in Perception of Bottom 5 Councillors in Perception of Public Services Public Services

NDMC NDMC

Political Score Overall Political Score Overall Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 11) Rank Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 11) Rank

Rohini 42 INC Prithvi Singh Rathore 8.84 5 Rohini 35 BSP Satyapal Singh 3.81 54

Rohini 43 BJP Renu 8.67 29 Rohini 47 INC Ashok Kr. Shokeen 4.14 73

Civil Line 18 BJP Anguri Devi 8.64 68 Civil Line 68 BJP Poonam Sharma 4.22 63

Rohini 41 BJP Surender Mohan Pandey 8.63 70 Rohini 36 BSP Pushp Raj 4.28 94

Sadar Paharganj 87 BJP Lata Sodhi 8.47 3 Narela 32 IND Reeta Shokeen 4.29 97

SDMC SDMC

Political Score Overall Political Score Overall Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 11) Rank Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 11) Rank

South 165 BJP Radhey Shyam Sharma 9.79 3 Najafgarh 134 IND Satendra Singh Rana 3.57 43

South 184 BJP M. Nagarajan 9.21 7 West 125 INC Anju Gupta 4.25 87

West 123 BJP Karam Vir Shekhar 8.90 4 Najafgarh 129 INC Tilotma Chaudhary 4.88 50

Central 153 BJP Simmi Jain 8.85 2 West 122 BJP Shashi Prabha 5.12 38

Central 187 IND Kalpana Jha 8.69 33 West 120 INC Vimla Devi 5.29 56

EDMC EDMC

Political Score Overall Political Score Overall Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 11) Rank Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 11) Rank

Shahdara South 224 BJP Lata Gupta 9.19 4 Shahdara North 255 INC Raj Kumari 3.86 29

Shahdara North 251 BJP Satya Sharma 9.11 16 Shahdara North 266 BJP Usha Devrani Shastri 4.34 40

Shahdara North 252 BJP Sanjay Jain 9.10 44 Shahdara North 272 BJP Annapurna Mishra 4.55 58

Shahdara North 249 BSP Asma Begum 8.53 35 Shahdara North 269 INC Aas Mohammad 4.71 56

Shahdara South 222 BJP Asha Singh 8.08 32 Shahdara North 256 BJP Asha Tayal 4.97 25

174 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 175 Top 5 Councillors in Perceived Least Corrupt Bottom 5 Councillors in Perceived Least Corrupt

NDMC NDMC

Political Score Overall Political Score Overall Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 7) Rank Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 7) Rank

City 83 INC Seema Taihra 6.11 1 Narela 32 IND Reeta Shokeen 2.48 97

Sadar Paharganj 89 BJP Virender Babbar 6.11 6 Rohini 49 BJP Vijay Prakash Pandey 2.88 52

Civil Line 15 BSP Parmesh Kumar Chauhan 6.04 79 Rohini 52 BJP Neelam Goel 3.28 62

Civil Line 20 BJP Satya Wati Chauhan 6.00 43 Rohini 48 BSP Poonam 3.30 65

Rohini 33 BJP Ram Dayal Mahto 5.89 64 Rohini 47 INC Ashok Kr. Shokeen 3.37 73

SDMC SDMC

Political Score Overall Political Score Overall Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 7) Rank Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 7) Rank

Najafgarh 130 INC Maya Devi 6.56 31 West 107 INC A Meghraj Chandela A 3.16 78

South 180 INC Anju Sehwag 6.51 70 Najafgarh 143 BJP Jai Prakash 3.16 76

West 117 BJP Ashish Sood 6.45 15 Najafgarh 133 IND Pardeep Kumar 3.68 47

Central 156 INC Darshna 6.45 18 South 167 INC Dharmvir Singh 3.69 6

South 165 BJP Radhey Shyam Sharma 6.15 3 South 175 BJP Gyasi 3.76 42

EDMC EDMC

Political Score Overall Political Score Overall Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 7) Rank Zone Constituency No. Party Councillors Name (out of 7) Rank

Shahdara South 233 INC Tulshi 6.45 28 Shahdara North 244 BJP Kamlesh 3.31 39

Shahdara North 246 BJP Sanjay Surjan 6.28 46 Shahdara North 241 BJP Swati Gupta 3.74 18

Shahdara North 251 BJP Satya Sharma 6.24 16 Shahdara North 242 BJP Sunil Kumar Jha 3.77 22

Shahdara North 252 BJP Sanjay Jain 6.23 44 Shahdara North 255 INC Raj Kumari 3.77 29

Shahdara North 249 BSP Asma Begum 6.16 35 Shahdara South 227 INC Geeta Sharma 3.83 6

176 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 177 Menj kesÀ he´l³eskeÀ veiej hee

178 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 179 leeefuekeÀe 1: hee

180 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 181 ie. DeehejeefOekeÀ DeefYeuesKe 4. ie´eceerCe #es$e meefceefle jepeveerefle keÀe DehejeOeerkeÀjCe SkeÀ og:Keo JeemleefJekeÀlee nw~ yeæ[er mebK³ee ceW ®e³eefvele he´efleefveefOe³eeW keÀe DeehejeefOekeÀ 5. Deeéeemeve meefceefle efjkeÀe@[& neslee nw DeLee&le, 1) GvekesÀ efKeueeHeÀ SHeÀDeeF&Deej ope& ngF& nesleer nw; 2) Deejeshe he$e oeefKeue efkeÀS 6. efve³egefÊeÀ³eeW keÀer heoesVeefle, DevegMeemeveelcekeÀ SJeb mebye× ceeceues meefceefle ngS nesles nQ 3) ³eneB lekeÀ efkeÀ Deoeuele Üeje oes

182 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 183 Ke. Gþe³es ieS cegÎs keÀer mebK³ee Ie. veeieefjkeÀeW keÀer efMekeÀe³eleeW keÀer leguevee ceW GþeS ieS cegÎs efkeÀmeer he´efleefveefOe Üeje GþeS peevesJeeues cegÎeW keÀer mener mebK³ee kesÀ efueS keÀesF& Yeer le³e leue-ef®evn veneR nes mekeÀlee~ neueeBefkeÀ, Scemeer[er ves veeieefjkeÀeW keÀer efMekeÀe³eleeW keÀe helee ueieeves kesÀ efueS SkeÀ he´Ceeueer efJekeÀefmele keÀer nw~ veeieefjkeÀeW kesÀ nceejs osMe Üeje meecevee efkeÀS peevesJeeues cegÎeW keÀer mebK³ee SJeb peefìuelee keÀes osKeles ngS, he´efleefveefOe kesÀ efueS ³en DeefveJee³e& nw he´efleefveefOe kesÀ leewj hej, veiej hee

184 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 185 DeefOekeÀ Fve #es$eeW keÀes cenlJe efo³ee peevee ®eeefnS~ meyemes yeæ{keÀj yeele ³en nw efkeÀ efkeÀmeer J³eefÊeÀ keÀe mechetCe&  ³eeveblej vesceke̳ee keÀesCel³ee J³ekeÌleeR®eer efveJe[ keÀje³e®eer ns þjJeues, les Heg{erueÒeceeCes ë meceie´ he´oMe&ve De®íe nes mekeÀlee nw uesefkeÀve peye efJeefYeVe iegCeeW kesÀ yeejs ceW ienve hetí-leeí keÀer peeleer nw lees mener  heg©

186 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 187  he´ot

¬eÀce ceeheob[ he´cegKe mecetn DebkeÀ DeefOekeÀlece DebkeÀ 19 he´ot

5 peerJeveMewueer ceW megOeej he´cegKe meceie´ Ghee³e 69 100 ¬eÀce peeueeroej ®ej efveOee&efjle YeejebkeÀ DebkeÀ DeefOekeÀlece DebkeÀ mebK³ee 6 Ye´äe®eej Ye´äe®eej met®ekeÀebkeÀ 72 100 1 peevekeÀejer Deewj hengB®e 5 74 100 7 meeHeÀ-meHeÀeF& Deewj mJe®ílee megefJeOee³eW ueesieeW keÀer OeejCee - mlej 1 70 100 2 he´cegKe meceie´ Ghee³e 7 64 100 8 me[keÀeW keÀer neuele ueesieeW keÀer OeejCee - mlej 2 76 100 3 Ye´äe®eej met®ekeÀebkeÀ 7 72 100 9 peve-GÐeeve/Kegues cewoeveeW keÀer GheueyOelee ueesieeW keÀer OeejCee - mlej 2 58 100 4 ueesieeW keÀer OeejCee - mlej 1 6 70 100 10 DemheleeueeW Deewj Dev³e ef®eefkeÀlmee megefJeOee³eW ueesieeW keÀer OeejCee - mlej 2 77 100 5 ueesieeW keÀer OeejCee - mlej 2 4 67 100 11 Gef®ele mketÀue Deewj keÀe@uespe ueesieeW keÀer OeejCee - mlej 2 68 100 6 ueesieeW keÀer OeejCee - mlej 3 1 65 100

188 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 189 Yeeefjle Debeflece mkeÀesj THE methodology veiej hee

190 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 191 The following information was required to judge the performance of each pertaining to the elected representative are taken into consideration such as: Municipal Councillor in the city: the FIR cases registered against them as stated in the election affidavit; new FIR cases registered against them after being elected in the current term; and 1. Some of the tangible parameters like an elected Municipal Councillors important pending charge sheets. attendance in the Corporation and the Committee Meetings, the number of issues raised she/he has raised in the above forums (Corporation and Table 1: Scale for Ranking Performance for Councillor Committee Meetings), importance of those issues raised, and utilization of funds allotted to her/him. Scale of Ranking Sr. Indicator Max Comments 2. Some parameters on her/his background such as educational qualification, No. % income tax records & criminal record (if any). 1 Present 3. Some soft parameters like the perception/impression of the people in his/ A Attendance in the 15 Refer Point 3a on page 195 for details Corporation and her constituency, awareness about them, satisfaction with their work and Committee Meetings improvement in the quality of life because of the Municipal Councillor. B Number of Issues Raised 10 Against Group Percentage Rank. 10 being the top most Once the areas of evaluation were finalised, it was important to decide upon percentiles and so on to the lowest for 0 the methodology which would best provide the required information. Information C Importance of Issues 23 Refer Point 3c on page 197 for details mentioned in points 1 & 2 above was gathered from RTI & by means of secondary Raised research. Municipal Councillor Scores have been derived out of maximum 100 D Issues raised compared to 10 Refer Point 3d on page 198 for details marks with 70% weightage given to tangible facts about the Municipal Councillor. Citizen’s Complaints For the Information on the 3rd point a primary survey was conducted amongst E Total Discretionary Funds 5 Refer Point 3e on page 198 for details the citizens in each constituency to evaluate the perceived performance of the Utilised during April, 2015 Municipal Councillor. 30% weightage was given to perceived performance of to March, 2016 Municipal Councillors in the minds of common man. Total 63 2 Past The data used for points 1 and 2 has been collected from government sources: A Education Qualification 1 A minimum of 10th Pass - 1; if not - 0 a. MCD, Website and State Election Commission, Delhi. B Income Tax 1 Possessing PAN Card - 1; if not - 0 b. Under Right to Information Act from Municipal Secretary, MCD. C Criminal Record 5 If the candidate has zero cases registered against her/ c. Citizen's Complaints were taken from the 12 Zonal Control Rooms under him, then 5; else as below: Right to Information Act. (1) Criminal Cases Registered excluding the following d. Under Right to Information Act from Engineering (Planning) & Accounts charges: Murder, Rape, Molestation, Riot, Extortion - 3 Department, MCD (2) Rest - 0 Total 7 e. Under Right to Information Act from Delhi Police. 3 Perception Based on a opinion poll of 29,950 people spread People’s perception as per point 3 has been mapped through an opinion poll of 29,950 across different constituencies in the city of Delhi people across the city of Delhi by Hansa Market Research conducted through a A Perceived Performance 11 Score on Public Services structured questionnaire. B Awareness & Accessibility 5 Score on Awareness amongst people about their representative, their political party and ease of access It is very important to understand here that the matrix is objectively designed to the representative and provides no importance to the political party of the representative or to C Corruption Index 7 Score on perceived personal corruption of the any personal/political ideology. representative Criminalisation of politics in the country has been growing since independence D Broad Measures 7 Score on overall satisfaction and improvement in and is a phenomenon which if not checked now can destroy the democratic quality of life foundations of our nation. Hence personal criminal record related parameters Total 30

192 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 193 Scale of Ranking c. Criminal Record Sr. Indicator Max Comments Criminalisation of politics is a sad reality. A significant number of elected No. % representatives have a criminal record i.e. 1) they have FIRs registered against 4 Negative marking for new -5 For any new FIR registered during the year. them; 2) charge sheets filled; and 3) even convictions given by the courts of law. criminal cases registered during the year There is no excuse for not having moral probity in public life. It is the right of the citizens to have people representing them with no criminal records. Hence 5 Negative marking for -5 For any Charge sheet in a criminal case. Charge sheet the scheme of ranking has into account marks for people with clean records:

6 Negative marking for -5 This can be done on own website, newspaper, Praja i. Those with absolutely no criminal FIRs registered are given five marks. no annual pro-active Website or any other source which should be announced ii. Those with FIRs registered against, with cases containing the following disclosures by the elected publicly. charges: murder, rape, molestation, riot and extortion are given zero marks. representatives of Assets Also marks would be cut for wrong disclosures in the and Liabilities and Criminal above mentioned forums. iii. Those with other FIRs registered against, other than those mentioned in record (*) No. ii above, are given three marks. Total 100 We have negative markings as explained in No. 5 below for other parameters (*) This negative parameter on proactive disclosures has not been applied for the current year. related to crime records like charge sheet. But as one the primary purpose of the Yearbook is to promote transparency amongst elected representatives, it is imperative that they proactively provide personal information on their Kindly note that allocating scoring for each individual case would have been personal annual economic status and to emphasise their probity in public life, they should complex, instead scoring for cases after them being categorised as above share every year their updated criminal record. seemed more logical and hence number of individual cases are not of that important but the category of case needed for the scoring. 2. Parameters for Past Records as per Affidavit 3. Parameters for Present Performance in the Corporation and Committee Parameters for Past Records are based on information in election affidavit that Meetings includes educational, criminal and financial records of Municipal Councillors. Total seven Marks out of Maximum 100 marks are allocated for this parameter. In an indirect, representative democracy like India’s, citizens elect their representatives so that these representatives can represent them in the houses a. Education of legislation and deliberate on issues related to the citizens and form needed If the elected representative has declared in his affidavit, education qualification legislations under the guidelines of and using the mechanisms of the constitution. as 10th pass or more then on the scale one mark is allocated, else zero marks Thus it is very clear that the weightages in the performance scale have to be are given. more biased to these functions of the elected representatives i.e. of Deliberation. As a developing 21st century country, basic modern education is an important a. Attendance criterion for human development. Even at lowest clerical jobs in the government, The mandate given by citizens to the representatives is to attend the business of the government insists on a minimum educational level. Going by the same logic the respective legislative houses. It is hence prudent that the representatives attend and the times, it is prudent that a similar yardstick be applied to our elected 100% or near to 100% sessions of their respective houses. Hence the marking is representatives. However, we also believe that the educational parameter should based on percentage of attendance: 100% getting 15 while 0% getting zero. be given a minimal weightage in the overall scheme vis-a-vis other parameters that are more crucial for judging performance of the elected representatives. However, in the MCD a councillor is always a member of the Corporation and a particular Ward Committee, and apart from that some of the councillors are b. Income Tax members of various committees viz: It is widely published and believed in India that annual income levels and 1. General Body Meeting (GBM) wealth of those who are elected sees a manifold increase in the few years 2. Standing Committee when they represent. Marks are allocated for possessing a PAN card (one mark), as per the affidavit; else if not possessing a PAN card than zero marks 3. Education Committee are allocated. 4. Rural Area Committee

194 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 195 5. Assurance Committee Devices used for asking ‘Issues Raised’ that have been considered in the marking: 6. Appointments Promotions, Disciplinary & Allied Matters Committee • Supplementary Question 7. Works Committee • Discussion on a Matter of Public Importance 8. Medical Relief & Public Health Committee • Resolutions under Proviso to Sec 74 9. Environment Management Services Committee • Adjourned Meetings 10. Garden Committee • Motion in respect of certain matter 11. Law & General Purposes Committee • Point of Order • List of Business 12. Hindi Committee • Amendment 13. Sports Promotions & Allied Matters Committee • Matter of Privilege 14. High Powered Property Taxes Committee • Short Notice Questions (Rule-32) 15. Municipal Accounts Committee • DMC Act 1957: Sec 81 (2) 16. Code of Conduct for Councillors Committee • Question 17. Central Ward Committee • Issues Raised in Ward Committee 18. Najafgarh Ward Committee The marking for this section is out of a maximum 10 marks that the 19. South Ward Committee representative can get for being the person with the maximum number of 20. West Ward Committee issues raised asked. 21. City Ward Committee The marking here is done against Group Percentage Rank: 22. Civil Line Ward Committee 10 being the top most percentile and so on to the lowest for 0. 23. Karol Bagh Ward Committee 24. Narela Ward Committee c. Importance of issues raised 25. Rohini Ward Committee The Delhi Municipal Corporation is not the sole authority in carrying out all 26. Sadar Paharganj Ward Committee Civic duties. In fact, there are certain duties which don’t fall within the ambit of 27. Shahdara North Ward Committee the Municipal Corporation. Water, Sewage, and Electricity, for example, come 28. Shahdara South Ward Committee under the responsibility of the State. Similarly the issues relating to the Big Thus, it is understood that there can be two categories of councillors and they Roads/Highways are the responsibility of the Central/State Government, while need to be allocated the 15 marks in different ways: the issue of small roads only comes under the Municipal Corporation. Attendance Similar is the case with Education and Health. Primary Education and Councillor Corporation General Ward Committee Different Committee Total Body Meetings (GBM) Meetings Meetings (mentioned above) Public Health & Primary Health come under the Jurisdiction of the Municipal Category A 9 6 N.A. 15 Corporation and Secondary Education and rest come under the Centre/State. Category B 7 4 4 15 National Capital Territory (NCT) Delhi Act 1991 and MCD Delhi Act 1957 under section (42 & 43) defines obligatory and discretionary functions of Corporation. b. Number of Issues Raised Delhi Based on the above classifications the weightages for the importance of There cannot be really a set benchmark for the right number of issues the issues raised has been designated as below from the total marks out of raised that have to be asked by a representative. However given the range 100 in the overall scale: and complexity of issues that our country is facing, it is necessary for the representative to raise as many issues as they can, which are necessary for Issues/Duties Obligatory Discretionary State/Central Total the citizens. Hence to stimulate the representatives to ask maximum number of issues raised the scale uses the percentile system for scoring. Marks 11 8 4 23

196 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 197 d. Issues raised compared to Citizen Complaints The rationale for giving the above scoring points was to give more importance MCD has developed a system for tracking, recording citizen complaints. As to the key issues like facilities in the area & corruption as compared to citizens’ representatives, it is expected that Municipal Councillors also raise Municipal Councillor being aware and accessible or overall feel of the people issues to resolve citizens’ issues (complaints). Hence the current parameter being positive. This is because we believe that scoring positively overall or is based on comparing issues raised by councillors related to the citizen being popular is actually a function of your work in different areas. Hence, these areas should be given more importance than the overall satisfaction. complaints based on the data collected by filing RTIs to all 12 zones of Moreover a blanket overall performance for an individual may be good but the Municipal Corporation of Delhi. One year of data has been taken from when interrogated deeply about different traits the positives and negatives can Municipal Corporation of Delhi (April 2015 to March 2016) for complaints and be clearly pointed. deliberations. The data helped in understanding the trends that are prevalent regarding the registration of civic complaints. The next step after assigning weightages to government’s four broad areas The departments of MCD that are covered under this criteria are as follows: was to make sure that facilities which come under local jurisdiction to get more Buildings, Colony officer, Drainage, Estate, Garden, License, MCD related, Pest importance than the ones which come under the state or central government’s control, Roads, Shop and Establishment (S & E), Solid Waste Management jurisdiction. Hence the weightage for Perception of Public Services was further (SWM), Storm Water Drainage, Toilet, etc. divided into a hierarchy of 3 levels to meet the desired objective.

A maximum of 10 marks have been allocated for this parameter. Level 1 included facilities which are more critical to local government whereas e. utilisation of Discretionary Funds Utilised April 2015 to March 2016 Level 3 included facilities that are more critical to state government. Municipal Councillors get a total 50 lakh for NDMC, 30 lakh for SDMC and 25 n Level 1 – This level included areas like Cleanliness & Sanitation facilities lakh for EDMC in every financial year. This fund they can spend as per their like garbage disposal etc. It was given a weightage of 6 points. discretion on certain specified development work in their constituencies. It is necessary that the funds are utilised in a planned phased manner to achieve n Level 2 – This level included areas like Condition of roads in your area, optimal results. Hence, the marks given are based on percentage of the funds Availability of public Gardens/open playgrounds for recreation in your area, utilised (booked) out of the maximum 50 lakh for NDMC, 30 lakh for SDMC Hospitals and other medical facilities in your area, Appropriate schools and 25 lakh for EDMC financial years 2015-2016: and colleges for availing education facilities, Water logging during rainy season, Availability of Footpaths and pedestrian walking areas. It was (1) 100% (or more) to 91% - five marks; (2) 90% to 76% - four marks; (3) 75% to 61% - three marks; (4) 60% to 51% - two marks; and (5) 50% given a weightage of 4 points. and below - zero marks. n Level 3 – This level included areas like Traffic Jams & congestion of roads 4. Parameters for People’s Perception as per Opinion Poll in your area, Availability of public transport facilities like Auto rickshaw, Taxis, Buses & Local trains in your area, Availability of food through ration Since perceived performance was given a weightage of 30 points, we divided it shops, Power Supply in your area, Water Supply from the Delhi Jal Board, further in to four broad areas in order to evaluate the performance in detail. All Pollution problems in your area, Instances of Crime in your area, Overall these four areas were given differential weightage based to the importance in Law & Order situation like police control/patrolling etc, Adequacy of public defining the Municipal Councillors performance. The weightages were divided transport facility. It was given a weightage of 1 point. in the following scheme: n Perception of Public Services (impression of the people about the facilities Research Design: in the area) was given a weightage of 11 points, n Awareness & Accessibility of the Municipal Councillor was given a n A Municipal Councillor is a representative elected by the voters to over see weightage of 5 points, the functioning of the ward. n Corruption index was given a weightage of 7 points and n Winner of elections in each ward is termed as a Municipal Councillor and n Broad overall measures were given a weightage of 7 points has the power to manage the functioning of the ward.

198 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 199 n This division helps to provide clear delegation of responsibilities at the Parameters of Evaluation: ground level. While deciding the parameters of evaluation for a Municipal Councillor, we n Since, our study focused on evaluating the performance of Municipal decided to capture the information on four important aspects. These were as Councillors it was necessary to cover and represent all the wards to which follows: each of these Municipal Councillors belonged. n Impression of the people about different facilities in his/her area n Hence, we decided to cover a sample from each ward. We decided to cover all the 272 municipal wards equally, with a sample of 100 in each p Condition of Roads ward. p Traffic jams & Congestion of roads n The initial total sample for the study covered: 272 municipal wards X 100 respondents = 27200 respondents. p Availability of public gardens/open playgrounds

n Next step was to define the target group for the study. We finalised on p Availability of public transport facilities like Auto, Taxis & Buses covering within each ward: p Availability of food through ration shops p Both Males & Females p Hospitals and other medical facilities p 18 years and above (eligible to vote) p Appropriate schools and colleges n Once the target group was defined, quotas for representing gender and age groups were set. p Power Supply

n The quotas were set on the basis of age and gender split available through p Water Supply Indian Readership Study (Large scale baseline study conducted nationally by Media Research Users Council (MRUC) & Hansa Research group. p Water Logging during rainy season

n The required information was collected through face to face interviews p Pollution problems with the help of structured questionnaire. p Instances of Crime n In order to meet the respondent, following sampling process was followed: p Law & Order situation p 100 interviews were conducted in each municipal ward. p “Availability of Footpaths and pedestrian walking areas” and “Adequacy p 2-3 prominent areas in the ward were identified and the sample was of public transport facility” divided amongst them. These areas were mainly crowded areas such as market place, railway stations, malls etc. p Cleanliness & Sanitation facilities

p Respondents were intercepted in these areas and the required n Awareness & Accessibility of the Municipal Councillor information was obtained from them. n Perception of corruption for Municipal Councillor n Sample composition of age & gender was corrected to match the universe profile using the baseline data from IRS. (Refer to weighting paragraph on n Broad overall measures like overall satisfaction with Municipal Councillor next page). & improvement in quality of life because of Municipal Councillor.

200 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 201 Illustration of Scorecard for an Municipal Councillor: Sr. Parameters Broad Groupings Scores Maximum No. Score Below is an illustration of scorecard for a Municipal Councillor which will help us to understand the scoring pattern: 16 Availability of food through Impression of people - Level 3 73 100 ration shops Parameter Scores 17 Power Supply Impression of people - Level 3 63 100 Sr. Parameters Broad Groupings Scores Maximum No. Score 18 Water Supply Impression of people - Level 3 59 100

1 Recall for party name to which Awareness & Accessibility 77 100 19 Pollution problems Impression of people - Level 3 64 100 the Municipal Councillor belongs 20 Instances of Crime Impression of people - Level 3 63 100

2 Recall for name of the Awareness & Accessibility 77 100 21 Law & Order situation Impression of people - Level 3 71 100 Municipal Councillor 22 Adequacy of public transport Impression of people - Level 3 69 100 3 Accessibility of the Municipal Awareness & Accessibility 69 100 facility Councillor

4 Satisfaction with the Municipal Broad Overall Measures 59 100 Councillor Scores of Netted Variables:

5 Improvement in Lifestyle Broad Overall Measures 69 100 Sr. Netted Variables Weightage Assigned Scores Maximum 6 Corruption Corruption Index 72 100 No. Score

7 Cleanliness & Sanitation Impression of people - Level 1 70 100 1 Awareness & Accessibility 5 74 100 facilities 2 Broad Overall Measures 7 64 100 8 Condition of Roads Impression of people - Level 2 76 100 3 Corruption Index 7 72 100 9 Availability of public Impression of people - Level 2 58 100 gardens/open playgrounds 4 Impression of people - Level 1 6 70 100

10 Hospitals and other medical Impression of people - Level 2 77 100 5 Impression of people - Level 2 4 67 100 facilities 6 Impression of people - Level 3 1 65 100 11 Appropriate schools and Impression of people - Level 2 68 100 colleges Weighted Final Scores 12 Water Logging during rainy Impression of people - Level 2 56 100 season Perceived performance score of the Municipal Councillor = 13 Availability of Footpaths and Impression of people - Level 2 68 100 ((5*74)+(7*64)+(7*72)+(6*70)+(4*67)+(1*65))/100 = 20.8 out of 30 pedestrian walking areas In this case, we compared the age & gender compositions achieved in our 14 Traffic jams & Congestion of Impression of people - Level 3 67 100 survey with the similar compositions in IRS study (Indian Readership Survey). roads In the process, minor deviations for demographics were corrected. 15 Availability of public transport Impression of people - Level 3 59 100 facilities like Auto, Hence, weighting not only helped us to remove the demographic skews from our Taxis & Buses sample data but also ensured that the representation of demography was correct.

202 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2016 203 5. Parameters for Negative Marking for new FIR cases registered

If there has been a new FIR registered against the elected representative after THE FOUR LION TORCH his election then this happens to be a matter of concern; and hence out of the marks earned by the representative, five marks would be deducted. MeefÊeÀ, meenme, ieJe& Deewj DeelceefJeéeeme oMee&les, DeMeeskeÀ mlebYe kesÀ ®eej Mesj, nceejs mebefJeOeeve ceW efveefnle Yeejleer³e Do note that in the process of allocating marks does not take into account number of new criminal FIR cases, but simply takes into account even a single ieCeleb$e kesÀ ueeskeÀe®eej nQ~ nce efouueer kesÀ 3 ®eesìer kesÀ veiej hee

Do note that in the process of allocating marks does not take into account number of criminal charge sheets, but simply takes into account even a single occurrence for allocating marks based on the severity of the crime.

Negative marking for no annual pro-active disclosures by the elected representatives of Assets and Liabilities and Criminal record

As per the election commission norms the candidate standing for elections have to file an affidavit detailing amongst other things, their own asset and liabilities and criminal records. The candidate who gets elected later, does not share this information with his constituency or the election commission until and unless he/she stands for re-election or for a new election on different seat or post. However given the need of the time, we feel that it is necessary that the elected representatives proactively make their assets and liabilities (income status) and criminal records available to their constituencies at the end of every financial year when they are representing. This can be done through Newspapers or other Public Medias or through their own Websites or through Praja Website. This will bring larger transparency.

#1: GOLD #2: SILVER #3: BRONZE

The four lions of the Ashoka Pillar, symbolising power, courage, pride and confidence are the ethos behind the Indian Republic as embedded in our Constitution. We salute the top 3 ranking Municipal Councillors of Delhi as torch bearers of this idea. They have topped the list by on an objective ranking system as explained earlier in this report card, performing more efficiently relative to their peers. Jai Hind.

204 Delhi REPORT CARD MUNMUNICIPALICIPAL COUNCCOUNCILLORSILLORS 2016 205 THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA WE, THE PEOPLE OF INDIA, HAVING SOLEMNLY RESOLVED TO CONSTITUTE INDIA INTO A SOVEREIGN SOCIALIST SECULAR DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC AND TO SECURE TO ALL ITS CITIZENS: JUSTICE, SOCIAL, ECONOMIC AND POLITICAL; LIBERTY OF THOUGHT, EXPRESSION, BELIEF, FAITH AND WORSHIP; EQUALITY OF STATUS AND OF OPPORTUNITY; AND TO PROMOTE AMONG THEM ALL FRATERNITY ASSURING THE DIGNITY OF THE INDIVIDUAL AND THE UNITY AND INTEGRITY OF THE NATION.

From: Praja Foundation Mumbai Address: Delhi Address:Room No. 901, Victoria Building, 9th Floor, Nirmal Tower, 1st Floor, Agiary Lane, 26 Barakhamba Road, Off Mint Road, Fort, New Delhi 110 001, India Mumbai 400 001, India Phone: +91 11 2332 1559. Phone: +91 22 2261 8042.

206 Delhi REPORT CARD