A428 Black Cat to Caxton Gibbet Improvements Report on Public Consultion February 2019
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
A428 Black Cat to Caxton Gibbet improvements Report on public consultion February 2019 Report on public consultation Date: 30 August 2017 Version: 2.0 Registered office Bridge House, 1 Walnut Tree Close, Guildford GU1 4LZ Highways England Company Limited registered in England and Wales number 09346363 A428 Report on public consultation Table of Contents 1. Executive summary 4 1.1 Context 4 1.2 Report purpose 4 1.3 Consultation options 4 1.3.1 Orange Route 5 1.3.2 Purple Route 5 1.3.3 Pink Route 5 1.3.4 Option A 5 1.3.5 Option B 5 1.3.6 Option C 5 1.4 Consultation arrangements 6 1.5 Effectiveness of the consultation 6 1.6 Consultation findings 6 1.7 Next steps 7 2. Introduction 8 2.1 Background to the scheme 8 2.2 Developing options 8 2.2.1 Identify issues and objectives 9 2.2.2 Long list of options 9 2.2.3 Shortlisting options 9 2.2.4 Select options for consultation 10 2.3 Consulted options 11 2.3.1 Orange Route 11 2.3.2 Purple Route 11 2.3.3 Pink Route 11 2.3.4 Option A 11 2.3.5 Option B 11 2.3.6 Option C 11 3. Consultation arrangements 12 3.1 Information events 12 3.1.1 Locations and dates of public events 12 3.1.2 Event attendance 13 3.1.3 Feedback of the events 13 3.2 Publicising the consultation 13 3.2.1 Media engagement 13 3.2.2 Online engagement 14 3.2.3 Social media 14 3.2.4 Poster campaign 14 3.2.5 Advertising campaign 14 3.2.6 Letter 14 3.2.7 Deposit locations 14 3.2.8 Additional communication channels 15 3.2.9 Forums 15 3.3 Consultation materials 16 3.3.1 Consultation brochure and questionnaire 16 3.3.2 Exhibition panels 16 3.3.3 Technical reports 16 4. Effectiveness of the public consultation 18 4.1 Public event attendance 18 4.2 Social media 18 4.3 Press 18 5. Methodology 19 Page 2 of 39 A428 Report on public consultation 5.1 Data receipt and digitisation of all submissions 19 5.2 Limits of information 19 5.3 Next steps 20 6. Responses received 20 6.1 Responses by channel 21 6.2 Demographic information 21 6.2.1 Gender 21 6.2.2 Age 22 6.2.3 Disability 23 6.2.4 Ethnicity 23 6.2.5 Religion 25 6.2.6 How respondents heard about the consultation 25 6.3 Feedback from consultation 26 6.3.1 Channels of communication 26 6.3.2 The consultation process 26 6.3.3 Our response 26 7. Analysis of responses 27 7.1 A428 route and Black Cat roundabout improvement options - general 27 7.1.1 Comments in support 27 7.1.2 Comments in opposition 27 7.2 Analysis of options 28 7.3 Consultation Orange Route 28 7.3.1 Comments in support 28 7.3.2 Concerns 29 7.4 Consultation Purple Route 29 7.4.1 Comments in support 29 7.4.2 Concerns 29 7.5.1 Comments in support 30 7.5.2 Concerns 30 7.6 Black Cat options: 31 7.7.1 Comments in support 31 7.7.2 Concerns 32 7.8.1 Comments in support 32 7.8.2 Concerns 32 7.9.1 Comments in support 33 7.9.2 Concerns 33 8. Alternative options received as part of the feedback 34 8.1 Suggestions for additional measures 34 8.2 Caxton Gibbet alternative suggestions 34 8.3 Route alternative suggestions 35 8.4 Orange Route alternative suggestions 35 8.5 Pink Route alternative suggestions 36 9. General issues raised 37 9.1 Compensation and blight 37 9.2 Ox-Cam Error! Bookmark not defined. 9.3 Mitigation measures 37 10. Conclusion 37 11. Appendix 39 Page 3 of 39 A428 Report on public consultation 1. Executive summary 1.1 Context Highways England’s Project Control Framework sets out the methodology for delivery of a major highways scheme. The process is split into 8 stages, of which this scheme is currently in Stage 2, as follows: • Stage 0 (strategy, shaping and prioritisation) – problem definition, scheme requirements and strategic business case; • Stage 1 (option identification) – option identification and sifting out of options that are likely to perform less well compared to others; • Stage 2 (option selection) – detailed option assessment and selection of the Preferred Option, including detailed public consultation of the options; • Stage 3 (preliminary design) – scheme development including design of the Preferred Option in sufficient detail to produce draft orders and preparation of the Environmental Assessment; • Stage 4 (statutory procedures and powers) – gaining authority to construct the scheme through the normal statutory processes as laid down in legislation; • Stage 5 (construction preparation) – procurement of the construction contractor and detailed design of the scheme; • Stage 6 (construction) – construction of the scheme; • Stage 7 (handover and close-out) – project close out. The development of improvements to the A428 Black Cat to Caxton Gibbet were announced as part of the Government’s Road Investment Strategy 1 (RIS1). 1.2 Report purpose The purpose of this report is to provide a summary of the public consultation held from 6 March to 23 April 2017 and the responses gathered during the process. The report presents how the public were informed of the public consultation events, how the options identified were presented, the responses received from members of the public as well as statutory stakeholders and other bodies and consideration of the consultation responses. In addition to factors such as value for money, constructability, safety and meeting the scheme’s objectives, these responses assist in identifying the preferred option as well as design requirements as the scheme approaches statutory consultation and application for development consent. 1.3 2017 Consultation options The flow chart below shows the process used to get to the 4 options presented at consultation in 2017 (see section 2.2). Page 4 of 39 A428 Report on public consultation Create a long list Identify issues of options to Select options for Options Shortlist options and objectives achieve consultation consultation objectives 1.3.1 Orange Route The Orange Route would upgrade Black Cat roundabout to improve connections between the A1, A421 and the new A428 and will improve the junction at Caxton Gibbet connecting the existing A428 and the A1198. This option is 11.7km in length and runs along parallel to the North of the existing A428, creating a new junction at Cambridge road to link to the existing A428 and Cambridge Road/B1428. 1.3.2 Purple Route The purple route, one of the two southerly route options, would upgrade Black Cat roundabout to improve connections between the A1, A421 and the new A428 and will improve the junction at Caxton Gibbet connecting the existing A428 and the A1198. This option is 11.4km in length and runs to the North of Abbotsley. 1.3.3 Pink Route The Pink route, one of the two southerly route options, would upgrade Black Cat roundabout to improve connections between the A1, A421 and the new A428 and will improve the junction at Caxton Gibbet connecting the existing A428 and the A1198. This option is 11.4km in length and runs to the South of Abbotsley. 1.3.4 Option A Option A is a three-tiered roundabout, removing the current Black Cat roundabout and the construction of two roundabouts to the west of the current roundabout would be undertaken. A new free-flow continuous link from the A421 eastbound towards the A1 northbound would be created along with slip roads to and from the A421, the A1 and the A428. With this option the A1 would become a free-flow continuous road going under the slip roads. 1.3.5 Option B Option B is a two-tiered roundabout, retaining the existing Black Cat roundabout and creates a new free-flow continuous link from the A421 eastbound towards the A1 northbound. The addition of slip roads would provide a free-flow link, bypassing the roundabout traffic moving southbound onto the A421with the A1 remaining the same. 1.3.6 Option C Option C is a three-tiered roundabout, enlarging the existing Black Cat roundabout and creates a new free-flow continuous link from the A421 eastbound towards the A1 Page 5 of 39 A428 Report on public consultation northbound. Slip roads would be built from the A421 to the A1, and the A428 and the A1 would become a continuous free-flow road under the widened Black Cat roundabout. 1.4 2017 Non-Statutory Consultation on Options The public consultation period ran from Monday 6 March 2017 to Sunday 23 April 2017, a period of 7 weeks. During this time, 7 public information events, including a landowner specific event were held in towns and villages affected by the scheme. We used a range of communication channels to reach the community. This included: • Producing brochures • Delivering brochures to centralised locations in towns and villages • Posters in key locations along the current A428 • Updates to the scheme website • Emails to stakeholders and forum attendees • A press release issued to local press In addition to the general requirements of consultation, we: • Sent letters to 28,000 households within 500m of the proposed routes • Advertised on two different local radio stations The consultation material consisted of a consultation brochure and questionnaire, exhibition boards available to view at the events, as well as the Options Assessment Report and Traffic Data Collection Report, with key documents being available on our website.