The Great British Transport Competition 2 Foreword
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THE GREAT BRITISH TRANSPORT COMPETITION 2 FOREWORD The case for scrapping High Speed 2 (HS2) gets stronger by the day. Increasingly, people from across the political spectrum are waking up to the fundamental issues which have plagued this project. Whether it be the spiralling costs, environmental damage, consistent mismanagement or overwhelming unpopularity of the project, the tide is turning against HS2. With the latest evidence suggesting that costs could almost double, taxpayers are demanding more for their money. Even on current estimates, scrapping HS2 would free up at least £50 billion to improve transport links up and down the country. But were this to happen, what should replace it? With this question in mind, we joined the TaxPayers’ Alliance in launching The Great British Transport Competition in September 2018, to find popular alternatives to HS2. We asked all interested parties from across the United Kingdom to submit ideas for transport infrastructure projects. As the judges for this competition - including qualified surveyors, engineers, accountants, politicians and transport industry experts - we have been lucky to receive and assess so many fantastic entries from all around the country. The judging process began in early January and was concluded by early March. After many hours of detailed deliberation and discussion, 28 winning entries were chosen and the sum total of their construction costs came to £45.1 billion. We were incredibly impressed by the high standard and variety of the entries we received. What particularly stood out was that many of the entries required only relatively small sums of money to achieve vast benefits for local communities. Thank you to everyone who submitted. Taken together, we believe these projects would dramatically transform the transport infrastructure of the nation and have a real impact on many peoples’ lives. All for less than the cost of HS2. I hope you enjoy reading the winning entries as much as we did judging them. Thank you to everyone who supported the judging process, including Chris Stokes and Harry Fone. We are delighted now to present the winners of the Great British Transport Competition. Phil Basey • Lord Berkeley OBE • Michael Byng Lord Framlingham • James Roberts • Craig Tracey MP MEET THE JUDGES 3 PHIL BASEY Research Fellow, TaxPayers’ Alliance LORD BERKELEY OBE Member of the House of Lords MICHAEL BYNG Infrastructure & Procurement Specialist LORD FRAMLINGHAM Member of the House of Lords JAMES ROBERTS Political Director, TaxPayers’ Alliance CRAIG TRACEY MP Member of Parliament for North Warwickshire 4 CONTENTS PAGE THE WINNERS 6 A1 - DUAL CARRIAGEWAY FROM DURHAM TO EDINBURGH 7 REOPEN THE SKIPTON-COLNE RAILWAY LINE 8 REOPEN THE BEVERLEY TO YORK RAILWAY 9 ASHINGTON, BLYTH & TYNE RAILWAY 10 BRITAIN’S S-BAHN NETWORK: LEEDS 11 REOPEN THE KESWICK TO PENRITH RAILWAY 12 UPGRADE THE SETTLE & CARLISLE RAILWAY 13 REOPEN BLACKBURN TO HELLIFIELD 14 HIGH SPEED UK-NORTH 15 THE WHITACRE LINK 16 REOPEN STOURBRIDGE TO LICHFIELD 17 UPGRADE THE RUGBY TO BIRMINGHAM RAILWAY LINE 18 UPGRADE THE A5 TO EXPRESSWAY STANDARD 19 REOPEN THE SUTTON PARK LINE TO PASSENGERS 20 CHILTERN MAIN LINE ELECTRIFICATION 21 MIDLAND MAIN LINE ELECTRIFICATION 22 IMPROVE THE FELIXSTOWE TO NUNEATON FREIGHT ROUTE 23 REOPEN THE MARCH TO WISBECH LINE TO PASSENGERS 24 A NEW STATION ON THE BURY ST EDMUNDS TO ELY LINE 25 EXTEND CROSSRAIL TO STANSTED AIRPORT & CAMBRIDGE 26 LOWER THAMES CROSSING 27 BRIGHTON MAINLINE 2: SUSSEX PHASE 28 IMPROVE CONNECTIVITY TO BRISTOL TEMPLE MEADS 29 REBUILD CULLOMPTON STATION 30 EXETER TO PLYMOUTH VIA OKEHAMPTON 31 REOPEN THE BODMIN TO WADEBRIDGE RAILWAY LINE 32 CROSS CORNWALL RAIL LINK 33 BUILD CYCLE PATHS NEXT TO MOTORWAYS & A-ROADS PAGE APPENDIX 34 JUDGING CRITERIA 35 COSTINGS OF WINNING ENTRIES MAP OF WINNING ENTRIES 5 6 A1 - DUAL CARRIAGEWAY FROM DURHAM TO EDINBURGH ENTRANT: REGION: Camaro Kimberley-Blackstar North East & Scotland TIMESCALE: COST: 10 to 15 years £1.3 billion The aim of this scheme is to operators. Upgrading the road would significantly upgrade a stretch of the help to ease congestion as cars would A1 road from single carriageway to be able to pass slower moving lorries, at least dual carriageway and ideally which in turn would greatly improve motorway specifications. safety and lower the road’s accident rate. The proposed section for upgrade is between Durham and Edinburgh and The environmental impact is likely is approximately 140 miles long. to be minimal and air quality may actually improve, as vehicles will be Improving this stretch of the A1 able to travel at more optimal speeds, would greatly improve transport links resulting in shorter journey times and between the North East of England engines being used more efficiently. and Scotland, particularly for haulage 7 REOPEN THE SKIPTON-COLNE RAILWAY LINE ENTRANT: REGION: Derek Jennings North East & North West Skipton & East Lancs Rail Action Partnership TIMESCALE: COST: 4 years £100 million Reopening a short stretch of the Powerhouse’s vision and objectives. missing link railway line between By linking Pendle & Burnley directly to Skipton and Colne would extend a both Leeds and Bradford city centres, regional passenger service from East this reopened rail line will boost Lancashire to Leeds City Centre. This 12 employment opportunities, economic mile line could be built on the formation growth, urban regeneration and the of the currently-disused original route availability of low-cost housing. As a of 1848, which crosses the county result, it provides an impressive cost- boundary between Lancashire and benefit ratio. Yorkshire in the central Pennines. The project enjoys widespread support, This ‘Northern Link’ will complete a new including all eight MPs representing coast-to-coast East-West route, which constituencies along the route, several is fully compatible with both Transport important regional businesses and for the North’s (TfN) and the Northern multiple district and county councils. 8 REOPEN THE BEVERLEY TO YORK RAILWAY ENTRANT: REGION: Dr Adrian Morgan North East Minsters Rail Campaign TIMESCALE: COST: 5 to 8 years £300 million Hull and Beverley are linked with network, needed because the existing Market Weighton, Pocklington, rail infrastructure serving Hull lacks Stamford Bridge and York by the resilience. increasingly congested A1079. The project calls for the reinstatement of Regionally, the line will contribute the 32 mile Beverley to York ‘Minsters’ to the government’s ‘Northern rail line which was closed in 1965. Powerhouse’ initiative, improving east- west connectivity between East and This will contribute substantially North Yorkshire. Hull to York would to the long-term economic and take just 56 minutes and Beverley to social future of the East Riding, York only 46 minutes. Existing bus improving public transport, reducing services take significantly longer. car dependency and encouraging sustainable development. It will also A 2005 feasibility study estimated be an alternative link from Hull and costs at £239 million which will likely be the East Riding to the rest of the rail nearer £300 million in 2019. 9 ASHINGTON, BLYTH & TYNE RAILWAY ENTRANT: REGION: Dennis Fancett North East South East Northumberland Rail Users Group TIMESCALE: COST: 3 to 4 years £50 million This proposal seeks to reintroduce as a Park & Ride facility for commuters passenger services on the fully from the outlying villages of Newbiggin- operational and maintained freight line by-the-Sea, Linton, Lynemouth and between Newcastle and Ashington, Ellington. In addition, off-peak demand with intermediate stations at would be created for visitors to the Northumberland Park (which forms part aforementioned mining museum. Blyth of the Tyne and Wear Metro), Seghill, would be served by a new station at Seaton Delaval, Newsham for Blyth, Newsham, on the outskirts of the town, Bebside and Bedlington. and the station at Bebside. Beyond Ashington, the working freight The proposal has widespread public line continues and passes alongside support. It would serve as a very the Woodhorn Museum of Mining and useful commuter service to Newcastle Northumberland Life, a major tourist especially given new housing attraction in the region. A station developments in the area. adjacent to the museum would serve 10 BRITAIN’S S-BAHN NETWORK: LEEDS ENTRANT: REGION: Paul Magson North East TIMESCALE: COST: 5 to 6 years £1 billion This proposal examines how a model Leeds suffers from a lack of transport similar to the S-Bahn rapid transit infrastructure; the local transport railway system in Munich, Germany network is woefully inadequate. could be implemented in Leeds. Several hundred thousand people commute into Leeds every day but S-Bahns travel along existing rail only 3.7 per cent of them do so by tracks and then go underground for train, which are full to capacity. short distances under the city centre, using ‘supertrams’ as the rolling stock. This scheme would increase capacity on the rail network by transferring They can travel at greater speeds commuters from national trains to than either surface trams or cars local supertrams, reduce the number during busy periods meaning faster of car journeys, get commuters closer journey times. to their final destination, decrease air pollution and boost economic growth. 11 REOPEN THE KESWICK TO PENRITH RAILWAY ENTRANT: REGION: Cedric Martindale North West CKP Railways PLC TIMESCALE: COST: 3 to 4 years £110 million Rail passenger services ran between Sustrans into a railway path that forms Keswick and Penrith until ceasing part of the Coast to Coast National in 1972 following the recommended Cycle Route 71 but industry experts closure of the line in the Beeching advise that it can be easily rerouted. Report. The line will form part of the national Much of the trackbed and many of the rail network with services to Penrith existing structures remain in place. and further afield. The amount of congestion caused by cars is a significant issue in the Lake The scheme will reduce air pollution by District and led to the proposal to re- taking cars off the road and would help open the railway in the mid-1990s.