The Economic and Social Impacts of Protecting the Environmental Values of the Waters of the Capricorn and Curtis Coasts

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Economic and Social Impacts of Protecting the Environmental Values of the Waters of the Capricorn and Curtis Coasts OCTOBER 2014 The economic and social impacts of protecting the environmental values of the waters of the Capricorn and Curtis Coasts Report prepared for the Department of Environment and Heritage Protection Marsden Jacob Associates Financial & Economic Consultants ABN 66 663 324 657 ACN 072 233 204 Internet: http://www.marsdenjacob.com.au E‐mail: [email protected] Melbourne office: Postal address: Level 3, 683 Burke Road, Camberwell Victoria 3124 AUSTRALIA Telephone: +61 3 9882 1600 Facsimile: +61 3 9882 1300 Brisbane office: Level 14, 127 Creek Street, Brisbane Queensland, 4000 AUSTRALIA Telephone: +61 7 3229 7701 Facsimile: +61 7 3229 7944 Perth office: Level 1, 220 St Georges Terrace, Perth Western Australia, 6000 AUSTRALIA Telephone: +61 8 9324 1785 Facsimile: +61 8 9322 7936 Sydney office: 119 Willoughby Road, Crows Nest New South Wales, 2065 AUSTRALIA Telephone: +61 418 765 393 Authors: Jim Binney, Gene Tunny (alphabetical order) Contact: Gene Tunny, +61 7 3229 7701 This report has been prepared in accordance with the scope of services described in the contract or agreement between Marsden Jacob Associates Pty Ltd ACN 072 233 204 (MJA) and the Client. Any findings, conclusions or recommendations only apply to the aforementioned circumstances and no greater reliance should be assumed or drawn by the Client. Furthermore, the report has been prepared solely for use by the Client and Marsden Jacob Associates accepts no responsibility for its use by other parties. Copyright © Marsden Jacob Associates Pty Ltd 2014 TABLE OF CONTENTS Page Key messages .................................................................................................................... 1 1. Introduction ............................................................................................................... 3 1.1 Terms of reference ...................................................................................................................... 3 1.2 Purpose of this study ................................................................................................................... 3 1.3 Context ....................................................................................................................................... 5 2. Capricorn Coast .......................................................................................................... 11 2.1 Introduction ............................................................................................................................... 11 2.2 Socio‐economic profile – Capricorn Coast .................................................................................. 12 2.3 Water quality in the Capricorn Coast .......................................................................................... 21 2.4 Benefits of maintaining Environmental Values ........................................................................... 26 2.5 Costs of improving or maintaining water quality objectives ........................................................ 30 3. Curtis Coast ............................................................................................................... 35 3.1 Introduction ............................................................................................................................... 35 3.2 Socio‐economic profile – Curtis Coast ........................................................................................ 36 3.3 Water quality in the Curtis Coast ................................................................................................ 45 3.4 Benefits of maintaining Environmental Values ........................................................................... 54 3.5 Costs of improving or maintaining water quality objectives ........................................................ 58 4. Implementation issues .............................................................................................. 69 4.1 Intervention choice .................................................................................................................... 69 4.2 Enhancing intervention efficiency ............................................................................................... 72 LIST OF TABLES Page Table 1: Demographic summary 2001, 2006, 2011 – Capricorn Coast .................................................................... 13 Table 2: Educational attainment – Capricorn Coast ............................................................................................... 15 Table 3: Employed persons by industry – Capricorn Coast ..................................................................................... 17 Table 4: Estimated anthropogenic loads data for key pollutants – Capricorn Coast ............................................... 23 Table 5: Economic and demographic drivers and future risks to EVs ...................................................................... 25 Table 6: Gross value of commercial fishing catch (2005) ........................................................................................ 28 Table 7: Consumer surplus from recreational fishing in the Capricorn Coast region ............................................... 29 Table 8: Key rural land uses (2009) ........................................................................................................................ 30 Table 9: Regional groundcover statistics ............................................................................................................... 31 Table 10: Urban diffuse management – estimated costs and load reductions over the next 10 years ...................... 33 Table 11: Indicative wastewater treatment costs (annual $ per tonne of pollutant removed) ................................. 34 Table 12: Demographic summary 2001, 2006, 2011 – Curtis Coast ........................................................................ 37 Table 13: Educational attainment – Curtis Coast ................................................................................................... 40 Table 14: Employed persons by industry – Curtis Coast ......................................................................................... 41 Table 15: Estimated anthropogenic loads data for key pollutants – Curtis Coast .................................................... 49 Table 16: Economic and demographic drivers and potential future risks to EVs ..................................................... 50 Table 17: Gross value of commercial fishing catch (2005) ...................................................................................... 56 Table 18: Consumer surplus from recreational fishing in the Curtis Coast region ................................................... 57 Table 19: Key rural land uses (2009) ...................................................................................................................... 59 Table 20: Regional groundcover statistics ............................................................................................................. 59 Table 21: Urban diffuse management – estimated costs and load reductions over the next 10 years ...................... 61 Table 22: Indicative wastewater treatment costs (annual $ per tonne of pollutant removed) ................................. 64 Table 23: Major projects in the Curtis Coast region (established and emerging) ..................................................... 66 Table 24: Recommended intervention options ..................................................................................................... 70 LIST OF FIGURES Page Figure 1: Regional context map .............................................................................................................................. 4 Figure 2: Map of the Capricorn Coast .................................................................................................................... 11 Figure 3: Population projections – Capricorn Coast ............................................................................................... 12 Figure 4: Average weekly gross family income – Capricorn Coast .......................................................................... 14 Figure 5: SEIFA indices – Capricorn Coast, 2011 .................................................................................................... 15 Figure 6: EMC‐related visitations .......................................................................................................................... 18 Figure 7: Operational mines – Capricorn Coast ...................................................................................................... 20 Figure 8: Map of the Curtis Coast .......................................................................................................................... 35 Figure 9: Population projections – Curtis Coast ..................................................................................................... 36 Figure 10: Average weekly gross family income – Curtis Coast .............................................................................. 38 Figure 11: SEIFA indices – Curtis Coast, 2011 ......................................................................................................... 39 Figure 12: Gladstone region visitors for the year ending September 2011 .............................................................. 44 Figure 13: Operational mines – Curtis Coast .........................................................................................................
Recommended publications
  • Social Infrastructure Strategic Plan
    Nnpcr ^u.:^ Uric: ^2^ ` to - l-0 Member : Mvs Cam. tiwU11.5" Tabled Tabled, by leave Incorporated, Remainder incorporated, by leave by leave Clerk at the Table: Z Social Infrastructure Strategic Plan Queensland Government GLADSTONE REGIONAL COUNCIL Contents Foreword As Mayor of Gladstone Regional Council, I am proud to be a partner in the development of the Social Infrastructure Strategic Plan for the Gladstone region. The results of this extensive research and planning work have already delivered value to Council in terms of guiding current community planning activities. Adequate planning for social infrastructure and services is fundamental to managing growth. The development of the Gladstone Region Social Infrastructure - Voluntary Industry Contributions Framework will enable companies to channel funds to the areas of need as determined by a thorough analysis of the existing social infrastructure capital base, the impacts of future growth on community facilities and services as well as feedback through community engagement. I fully support the Queensland Government's proposal to establish the Gladstone Foundation as a regionally based pooled industry fund - it is essential to the successful implementation of the Social Infrastructure Strategic Plan. I urge major companies to get behind the proposed Gladstone Foundation and help to implement these important investment priorities in social infrastructure across the region. The Gladstone Region Social Infrastructure - Voluntary Industry Contributions Framework will ensure a strong and strategic structure is in place to guide industry investment in social infrastructure. The preparation of this Framework is essentially the beginning of a process - it is a "living" document and one which requires continuous update and review to ensure industry funds are directed to areas which deliver maximum benefits to the community.
    [Show full text]
  • Methods for the Mackay-Whitsunday-Isaac 2018
    METHODS FOR THE MACKAY-WHITSUNDAY-ISAAC 2018 REPORT CARD ENVIRONMENTAL INDICATORS Authorship statement The Mackay-Whitsunday-Isaac Healthy Rivers to Reef Healthy Partnership (Partnership) Methods for Environmental Indicators for the Mackay-Whitsunday-Isaac 2018 Report Card technical report was compiled by the Partnership’s Technical Officers, Alysha Lee and Jessica Gillespie. Substantial input was received from the Regional Report Cards Technical Working Group (TWG) members. Some content was also drawn from technical reports from earlier Mackay-Whitsunday- Isaac report cards. Regional Report Cards Technical Working Group members Diane Tarte (TWG Chair July 2018 onwards) Adam Fletcher Paulina Kaniewska Nicola Stokes Richard Hunt Reinier Mann Tegan Whitehead Angus Thompson Emma Maxwell Nathan Waltham Alysha Lee Alex Carter Jessica Gillespie Michael Rasheed Carl Mitchell Glynis Orr Nyssa Henry Luke Galea Michael Holmes Eddie Jebreen David Moffatt Ken Rhode Andrew Moss Travis Sydes Lynne Powell Lyndon Llewellyn Judith Wake Nadine Marshall Donna Audas Paul Groves Chris Dench Stephen Lewis Michael Nash Chris Manning Melinda Louden Adam Folkers Acknowledgements The authors also thank Phillip Trendell, Bernie Cockayne, Bronwyn Houlden, Carol Honchin, Len McKenzie, Jamie Corfield and Matt Curnock for their technical input into various aspects of document development and/or their review of the document. Members of the Reef Independent Science Panel are also gratefully acknowledged for their advice and review of this document. Suggested citation Mackay-Whitsunday-Isaac Healthy Rivers to Reef Partnership (2019). Methods for the Mackay- Whitsunday-Isaac 2018 Report Card: Environmental Indicators, Technical Report. Mackay- Whitsunday-Isaac Healthy Rivers to Reef Partnership, Mackay. This technical report was finalised and released online in November 2019.
    [Show full text]
  • Australia Pacific LNG Project
    Australia Pacific LNG Project Volume 5: Attachments Attachment 45: Economic Baseline Report for the Gladstone Region Volume 5: Attachments Attachment 45: Economic Baseline Report for the Gladstone Region Disclaimer This report has been prepared on behalf of and for the exclusive use of Australia Pacific LNG Pty Limited, and is subject to and issued in accordance with the agreement between Australia Pacific LNG Pty Limited and WorleyParsons Services Pty Ltd. WorleyParsons Services Pty Ltd accepts no liability or responsibility whatsoever for it in respect of any use of or reliance upon this report by any third party. Copying this report without the permission of Australia Pacific LNG Pty Limited or WorleyParsons is not permitted. Australia Pacific LNG Project EIS Page ii March 2010 Volume 5: Attachments Attachment 45: Economic Baseline Report for the Gladstone Region Economic Baseline Report for the Gladstone Region Report for Australia Pacific LNG project Professor John Rolfe Centre for Environmental Management CQUniversity, Rockhampton September 2009 Contributions to this report have also been made by Mr Peter Donaghy and Mr Grant O’Dea Australia Pacific LNG Project EIS Page 1 March 2010 Volume 5: Attachments Attachment 45: Economic Baseline Report for the Gladstone Region Contents 1. Introduction ............................................................................................................................... 1 1.1 Project background..................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Gladstone Region Population Report, 2016
    Queensland Government Statistician’s Office Gladstone region population report, 2016 Introduction The Gladstone region population report, 2016 provides estimates of Figure 1 Gladstone region the non-resident population of the Gladstone region during the last week of June 2016, based on surveys conducted by Queensland Government Statistician’s Office (QGSO). Information regarding the supply and take-up of commercial accommodation by non-resident workers is also summarised. The non-resident population represents the number of fly-in/fly-out and drive-in/drive-out (FIFO/DIDO) workers who were on-shift in the region at the time of collection. This group includes those involved in the production, construction, and maintenance of mining and gas industry operations, projects and related infrastructure. Non-resident workers are not included in estimated resident population (ERP) data released annually by the Australian Bureau of Statistics. As a result, the full–time equivalent (FTE) population estimates presented in this report, which combine the resident and non-resident populations, provide a more complete indicator of total demand for certain services than either measure used alone. Key findings Key findings of this report include: The non-resident population of the Gladstone region was The Gladstone region – at a glance estimated at 1,540 persons at the end of June 2016, around 3,890 persons or 72% lower than in June 2015. The Gladstone region comprises the local government area (LGA) of Gladstone (R), which Gladstone region's non-resident population in 2015–16 largely includes the city and port of Gladstone, as well as comprised FIFO/DIDO workers engaged in construction of three other residential centres and the rural hinterland.
    [Show full text]
  • Invest Capricorn Coast Region Economic Development Plan a Message from the Mayor
    Invest Capricorn Coast Region INVEST CAPRICORN COAST REGION ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT PLAN A MESSAGE FROM THE MAYOR Bill Ludwig Mayor Livingstone Shire Council As one of the faster-growing detailed strategic initiatives and supporting activities that, in conjunction with enabling projects, will facilitate areas outside the southern future economic growth. corner, the Capricorn Coast While Council has a critical role to play as both a ‘champion‘ and facilitator of economic growth, the region offers unrivalled successful delivery of a plan of this scope and magnitude investment and commercial can only be achieved in partnership, and with collective input from every business and industry sector. These opportunities, as well as premier sectors must include local business, tourism, service lifestyle options. Importantly, our delivery, construction, primary production and resource industries. Extensive engagement with the community region is well-positioned with the and all sectors was undertaken in the development of critical infrastructure required this plan. to service a diverse and growing It is equally critical that our EDP has input and support from all tiers of government to ensure that, where economy. necessary, our plan is as closely aligned as possible with current and future regional, state and national economic The Invest Capricorn Coast Region Economic development strategic initiatives, many of which have Development Plan (EDP) documents our current been considered and referenced in the EDP. economic status, our assets, opportunities
    [Show full text]
  • Great Keppel Island Resort Project
    Great Keppel Island Resort project Coordinator-General’s report on the environmental impact statement March 2013 © State of Queensland. Published by Queensland Government, March 2013, 63 George Street, Brisbane Qld 4000. The Queensland Government supports and encourages the dissemination and exchange of information. However, copyright protects this publication. The State of Queensland has no objection to this material being reproduced, made available online or electronically but only if it is recognised as the owner of the copyright and this material remains unaltered. Copyright inquiries about this publication should be directed to [email protected] or in writing to: Administrator (Crown Copyright and Other IP), Department of State Development, Infrastructure and Planning, PO Box 15517, City East, Qld 4002. The Queensland Government is committed to providing accessible services to Queenslanders of all cultural and linguistic backgrounds. If you have difficulty understanding this publication and need a translator, please call the Translating and Interpreting Service (TIS National) on 131 450 and ask them to telephone the Queensland Department of State Development, Infrastructure and Planning on 132 523. Disclaimer: This report contains factual data, analysis, opinion and references to legislation. The Coordinator-General and the State of Queensland make no representations and give no warranties regarding the accuracy, completeness or suitability for any particular purpose of such data, analysis, opinion or references. You should make your own enquiries and take appropriate advice on such matters. Neither the Coordinator-General nor the State of Queensland will be responsible for any loss or damage (including consequential loss) you may suffer from using or relying upon the content of this report.
    [Show full text]
  • Coastal Queensland & the Great Barrier Reef
    ©Lonely Planet Publications Pty Ltd Coastal Queensland & the Great Barrier Reef Cairns & the Daintree Rainforest p228 Townsville to Mission Beach p207 Whitsunday Coast p181 Capricorn Coast & the Southern Reef Islands p167 Fraser Island & the Fraser Coast p147 Noosa & the Sunshine Coast p124 Brisbane ^# & Around The Gold Coast p107 p50 Paul Harding, Cristian Bonetto, Charles Rawlings-Way, Tamara Sheward, Tom Spurling, Donna Wheeler PLAN YOUR TRIP ON THE ROAD Welcome to Coastal BRISBANE FRASER ISLAND Queensland . 4 & AROUND . 50 & THE FRASER Coastal Queensland Brisbane. 52 COAST . 147 Map . 6 Redcliffe ................94 Hervey Bay ............149 Coastal Queensland’s Manly Rainbow Beach .........154 Top 15 . 8 & St Helena Island .......95 Maryborough ..........156 Need to Know . 16 North Stradbroke Island ..96 Gympie ................157 What’s New . 18 Moreton Island ..........99 Childers ...............157 If You Like… . 19 Granite Belt ............100 Burrum Coast National Park ..........158 Month by Month . 21 Toowoomba ............103 Around Toowoomba .....106 Bundaberg .............159 Itineraries . 25 Bargara ............... 161 Your Reef Trip . 29 THE GOLD COAST . .. 107 Fraser Island ........... 161 Queensland Outdoors . 35 Surfers Paradise ........109 Travel with Children . 43 Main Beach & The Spit .. 113 CAPRICORN COAST & Regions at a Glance . 46 Broadbeach, Mermaid THE SOUTHERN & Nobby Beach ......... 115 REEF ISLANDS . 167 MATT MUNRO / LONELY PLANET IMAGES © IMAGES PLANET LONELY / MUNRO MATT Burleigh Heads ......... 116 Agnes Water Currumbin & Town of 1770 .........169 & Palm Beach .......... 119 Eurimbula & Deepwater Coolangatta ............120 National Parks ..........171 Gold Coast Hinterland . 122 Gladstone ..............171 Tamborine Mountain ....122 Southern Reef Islands ...173 Lamington Rockhampton & Around . 174 National Park ..........123 Yeppoon ...............176 Springbrook Great Keppel Island .....178 National Park ..........123 Capricorn Hinterland ....179 DINGO, FRASER ISLAND P166 NOOSA & THE WHITSUNDAY SUNSHINE COAST .
    [Show full text]
  • Extreme Weather Event Contingency Plan Gladstone Region – 2020/2021
    Extreme Weather Event Contingency Plan Gladstone Region – 2020/2021 incorporating Mary River, Hervey Bay, Tin Can Bay, Bundaberg, Gladstone, Port Alma, Fitzroy River and Rosslyn Bay Introduction Maritime Safety Queensland (MSQ) is an agency of the Dept. of Transport and Main Roads (DTMR) which works closely and cooperatively with the disaster management agencies, the industry and community on both a State wide and local basis. The recent extreme weather events throughout Queensland have highlighted the need for awareness and vigilance to the risks such events present to the maritime community. MSQ’s core focus is on the preservation of life and property on the State’s waters and in the prevention/response to ship-based pollution. Aligning itself with the MSQ mantra of 'safer and cleaner seas'. The extreme weather events of recent seasons have highlighted the need for awareness and vigilance to the risks such events present to maritime operations. MSQ has built on these recent experiences and is reissuing its contingency plans as one way of ensuring stronger resilience within the maritime community. Timely awareness and adequate preparation will reduce the impact of such events. This extreme weather event contingency plan for Gladstone Region sets out the broad framework that will apply for this region. MSQ takes advice on developing weather situations from the Bureau of Meteorology (BOM) which is the government’s primary source of weather intelligence. The Gladstone Region encompasses the area of the coast and waterways from St Lawrence in the North to Double Island Point in the South. The Region includes the Ports of Gladstone, Port Alma and Bundaberg, all boat harbours and marinas and includes all navigable rivers, creeks and streams as well as off shore islands within Queensland jurisdiction.
    [Show full text]
  • Gladstone Region Major Industry & Infrastructure Providers
    Gladstone region Major Industry & Infrastructure Providers CONTENTS NRG Gladstone Power Station 2 Central Queensland Ports Authority 3 Gladstone Area Water Board 5 Queensland Rail 6 Queensland Gas Pipeline 7 Boyne Smelters Limited 8 Cement Australia (Qld) Pty Ltd 9 Queensland Energy Resources Limited 11 Comalco Alumina Refinery 11 Queensland Alumina Limited 12 Orica Australia Pty Ltd 14 Austicks and Frost Enterprises 15 Industry Profiles: January 2005 The Gladstone Region NRG GLADSTONE POWER The station was sited to take advantage of seawater for cooling and to be near to Central STATION Queensland’s vast coal reserves. The station’s six-megawatt turbogenerators each output 16,200 volts to transformers that convert the power to a level suitable for transmission at 132,000 or 275,000 volts. CUSTOMERS The Gladstone Power Station sells most of its electricity to Boyne Smelters under a long-term contract. The station remains inter-connected with the Queensland Electricity grid and the remainder of the power generated is committed to OWNERSHIP AND OPERATION the state. The Gladstone Power Station is a world class COAL SUPPLY power station providing safe, reliable low cost electricity to customers. Since 1994 the station More than four million tonnes of coal each year has been operated by NRG Gladstone Operating are railed to the station from coalfields in Central Services on behalf of the joint venture Queensland. participants, Comalco Ltd (42.125%) and NRG Energy Inc (37.5%), as well as SLMA GPS Pty Coal is stockpiled after unloading, then reclaimed Ltd (8.50%), Ryowa II GPS Pty Ltd (7.125%) and from the stockpiles by either of two stacker YKK GPS (Queensland) Pty Ltd (4.75%).
    [Show full text]
  • Paula Jean Atkinson Postal Address: 184 Flaxton Dr., Flaxton 4560
    Name: Paula Jean Atkinson Postal Address: 184 Flaxton Dr., Flaxton 4560 Email: [email protected] Date:01/11/2018 Chief Executive Officer Gladstone Regional Council PO Box 29 Gladstone QLD 4680 Via Email: [email protected] Attention: Assessment Manager Dear Sir/Madam, DA / 3 / 2018 - PUBLIC NOTIFICATION MATERIAL CHANGE OF USE FOR RELOCATABLE RETIREMENT LIVING LOTS 11, 4 & 1 BRUCE HIGHWAY, BENARABY (CNR BRUCE HIGHWAY & TANNUM SANDS ROAD) 11SP200678, 1RP620530 & 4CTN2091 I write to express my support for the development application described above. I understand the proposal and offer my support for this development application for the following reasons: Insert your points here I have been looking for something like this in the region but there is nothing available, I am selling up on the sunshine coast to move back to the Gladstone area to be closer to my daughter & her family after the untimely death of my husband earlier this year. A resort style retirement facility like this would suit me & the family could have peace of mind that I am in a safe environment. It would also keep many older & retiring people in the region where at the moment most of the Gladstone older folk live mostly in the Bundaberg area, retaining this part of the population has to be good for the townships as they have more disposable income to spend, that would be of enormous benefit for the whole area & would keep a more balanced population. This facility would provide employment across the board ie., shops, eateries, coffee shops etc etc. Thank you for including my support in your considerations and I trust you will agree that this development is desperately needed and ideally located within the Gladstone Region.
    [Show full text]
  • Our Living Coast: Coastal Hazard Adaptation Strategy
    Our Living Coast Livingstone Coastal Hazards Adaptation Strategy 1 Table of Contents Mayor's Message.........................................................................................................................................................3 1.0 Introduction.............................................................................................................................................................4 1.1 Purpose of the Our Living Coast Strategy...............................................................................................4 1.2 A community driven plan for a resilient coast........................................................................................6 1.3 How did we develop the Our Living Coast Strategy?......................................................................7 1.4 Our journey in responding to coastal hazards....................................................................................8 2.0 Our Coastal Values.............................................................................................................................................10 2.1 Our Coast...............................................................................................................................................10 2.2 Our Coastal Environment......................................................................................................................12 2.3 Our Coastal Economy.........................................................................................................................13
    [Show full text]
  • Scenic Coast Trail
    Scenic Coast Trail The Scenic Coast Loop tourist drive takes in some of the most picturesque views and attractions that the Capricorn Coast has to offer – from bustling Rockhampton to the golden coastline. 3. Yeppoon Lagoon 5. Keppel Bay Marina & The brand new Yeppoon Lagoon Rosslyn Bay is a great place to have a swim (15 minute drive from Yeppoon) overlooking the Keppel Islands. The Rosslyn Bay Harbour is the departure beach is easily accessible from the point for trips to Great Keppel Island. 2. Yeppoon foreshore with disabled access. Here you will find ferry transfers The gateway to the Capricorn Coast, The foreshore precinct has an array and cruises to Great Keppel Island. 6. Great Keppel Island Yeppoon is a magical beachside of activities to be enjoyed by all ages. The Harbour is also home to Keppel Take a welcome diversion across to community, well known for its There’s heaps of family fun including Bay Marina, which boasts a seaside Great Keppel Island. The island is well delicious seafood. Towering palms the kids water play area the “Keppel restaurant, brokerage, cruises and worth a day trip and there’s a variety and pines line the streets against a Kraken”, skate park and playground, charters. of accommodation if you wish to backdrop of the sky, sea and islands. a perfect spot for a family gathering stay longer. The island is popular for Quaint cafés and boutique stores with barbecue facilities available. line the main streets and for some bushwalking and snorkelling and has added family fun. 3 a café and watersports hut.
    [Show full text]