The Unionization of Faculty, Academic Librarians and Support Staff at Carleton University (1973–1976)

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Unionization of Faculty, Academic Librarians and Support Staff at Carleton University (1973–1976) Solidarity by Association: The Unionization of Faculty, Academic Librarians and Support Staff at Carleton University (1973–1976) by Martha Attridge Bufton, B.B.A (Hons) A thesis submitted to the Faculty of Graduate and Postdoctoral Affairs in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in History Carleton University Ottawa, Ontario © 2013, Martha Attridge Bufton Abstract In the mid-1970s, three employee groups at Carleton University changed campus labour relations dramatically: the professors and librarians who belonged to the Carleton University Academic Staff formed the first Ontario faculty union in June 1975; nine months later the Ontario Labour Relations Board certified the Carleton University Support Staff Association as the bargaining agent for the administrative and technical staff. The history of faculty labour action at Carleton has been told but not that of either academic librarians or support staff so this case of unionism provides a unique opportunity to compare their experiences. Working primarily with oral histories, I argue that status was critical to mobilizing labour action at Carleton. These employees—many of whom were women—wanted a fair workplace but deliberately chose an independent association over a trade union because such “solidarity by association” was compatible with their deeply held beliefs about their work and place on campus. ii Acknowledgements This is first and foremost an oral history project and so the place of honour goes to the women and men who shared their stories—I am most grateful not only for their time but for the legacy they have left to those of us who are working at Carleton University and enjoying the benefits that come from a unionized workplace. In particular, I want to single out six people whose contributions were particularly generous: Sylvia Gruda and Pat Finn, leaders of the support staff association during the certification drive, were willing to meet with me more than once, share their personal papers and connect me with other individuals who might have interesting stories to tell. Likewise, librarians Susan Jackson and Frances Montgomery did not object to being part of a “captive audience” in the library when I needed to check out a fact or share a brilliant insight. I was especially blessed when, upon her retirement, Susan cleaned out her office and found six inches of files devoted to the Association of Professional Librarians of Carleton University, which she did not shred but gave to me. Frances, perhaps inspired by this treasure trove, promptly went to her basement and found her own files—some of which overlapped but many of which did not. Frances, who is a true mentor, is also responsible for my having the opportunities to turn the research on librarians into a book chapter and to learn how to cite provincial legislation. iii Finally, Don and Margaret McEown welcomed me into their home at a time that was challenging for them. Don was dying of cancer and could very easily have passed on the tiring task of answering the questions of someone he did not really know. But he did not and, more than that, he recognized an opportunity for Margaret to tell her story and for me to find out more about the lives of working women at Carleton during the 1960s and early 1970s. They were a delight to be with, particularly as with each interview (there were three in all for this research) they found more stories to share and laugh over. Don has since died but I am glad that I was able to capture some of their infectious enthusiasm, for the university and each other. I would also like to thank my supervisor Dr. Dominique Marshall for her interest, support and contributions to this thesis as well as my thesis examiners Dr. Joan Sangster (Trent University) and Dr. John Walsh (Carleton University) for their careful attention to my research and insightful questions. In addition, Dr. Pamela Walker’s on-going confidence in my ability to wrestle hundreds of pages of transcribed oral histories into something meaningful was encouraging when my own faith faltered. As usual at a university, the researcher has been nothing without the assistance of support staff. Linda White, Carleton’s former corporate archivist, made this work possible by not only giving me access to the university’s corporate files but also for being so thorough that I had a list of all the fonds, boxes and folders that I had consulted to iv refer to any time I needed it. When she left the university and was not replaced, we lost an invaluable resource. Who will be the next Blair Neatby or Don McEown? Barbara Steele in the University Secretariat has stepped in since Linda left and provided support while Patti Harper, the library’s archivist and her crew of Lloyd Keane and Al McClellan, have given me access to the old issues of The Carleton, This Week Times Two and advice on citing online archival documents— information which it turns out is hard to come by in this digital age. Joan White, the graduate administrator for Carleton’s Department of History, is a saint. No email or extension letter is too much trouble. My only regret is that I didn’t interview her for this research too because I know that she loved working with Evelyn Aldridge (“Mrs. A.”). Regina Aulinskas and Irene Sanna in the main office are always more than helpful—as students we are very lucky to have staff this devoted to working on our behalf. My colleagues Susan Tudin and Kristof Avramsson in Reference Services at the Carleton University Library were interested in this work—and would take the time to listen and throw out suggestions. This was especially nice at the times when, as a part-time student, I felt isolated and without a cohort to call my own. Finally, the staff in the Carleton University Library Access Services group were enormously helpful. Christine Taylor and Patricia Paquette of Interlibrary Loans ensured that I received all the materials I requested while Neil McFayden was v consistently patient as I renewed the over 100 books that I had signed out at one point. My friend Christina Turnbull has never stopped being enthusiastic about the writing process and has read numerous pages, most of which were not so coherent at the beginning. I needed her zen-like calm—and the coffee at Geronimo’s. My husband Ian Bufton and our sons Bruce and Sean have been steadfast in their understanding and willingness to listen to bits and pieces and proofread, even when what they’d rather be doing was playing basketball. Especially in the last week of writing when I was freaking at the Mount Everest-like stack of footnotes and bibliographic entries left to do, they continued to be supportive. As Bruce said, “They should give you an A for effort Mom—you sure do have a lot of paper there.” Ian is a proofreader extraordinaire—thank goodness! Love you lots. Finally, this thesis is dedicated to my parents, Harriet and Bruce Attridge and my aunt Elaine Empey. Over time, their family stories and loving constancy have kept me connected with my past. I just wish my parents were alive to read this work—I’d like to think they would have enjoyed it. vi Table of Contents Abstract ........................................................................................................................................... ii Acknowledgements ....................................................................................................................... iii Table of Contents………………………………………………………………………………..vii List of Tables, Illustrations and Graphs ..................................................................................... ix List of Appendices .......................................................................................................................... x Chapter 1 Introduction ................................................................................................................. 1 Historiography ............................................................................................................................ 7 Explanatory Framework .......................................................................................................... 40 Research Method: Oral History ............................................................................................... 49 Sources and Outline ................................................................................................................. 59 Chapter 2 “Taking the plunge”: Professors Certify the Carleton University………………………….63 Academic Staff Association Introduction…………………………………………………………………………………...63 “They Were the University”: Creating a Community of Scholars (1942–1973)…………....65 The Seeds of Discontent: From Collaboration to Negotiation………………………………92 Going from Association to Union: “Michael Made Some Mistakes”…….………………..102 Conclusion and Epilogue…………………………………………………….……………...152 Chapter 3……..…………………………………………………………………….…………..158 A “Honey” of a Union Deal: The Labour Action of Carleton University Librarians Introduction……………………………………………………………………………….…158 Hilda Gifford and Early Recognition for Librarianship at Carleton (1948–1968)…….….161 Conversations About the Status of Librarianship……………………………………….….182 The Association of Professional Librarians of Carleton University joins CUASA…….….189 Overcoming the Resistance of Professors……………………………………………….…..202 Conclusion and Epilogue…………………………………………………………………....215 Chapter 4……………………………………………………………………………………….221 Not to be "Squeezed Out": The Carleton University Support Staff Union Certifies
Recommended publications
  • Illuminating the Past
    Published by PhotoBook Press 2836 Lyndale Ave. S. Minneapolis, MN 55408 Designed at the School of Information and Library Science University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill 216 Lenoir Drive CB#3360, 100 Manning Hall Chapel Hill, NC 27599-3360 The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill is committed to equality of educational opportunity. The University does not discriminate in o fering access to its educational programs and activities on the basis of age, gender, race, color, national origin, religion, creed, disability, veteran’s status or sexual orientation. The Dean of Students (01 Steele Building, Chapel Hill, NC 27599-5100 or 919.966.4042) has been designated to handle inquiries regarding the University’s non-discrimination policies. © 2007 Illuminating the Past A history of the first 75 years of the University of North Carolina’s School of Information and Library Science Illuminating the past, imagining the future! Dear Friends, Welcome to this beautiful memory book for the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill School of Information and Library Science (SILS). As part of our commemoration of the 75th anniversary of the founding of the School, the words and photographs in these pages will give you engaging views of the rich history we share. These are memories that do indeed illuminate our past and chal- lenge us to imagine a vital and innovative future. In the 1930’s when SILS began, the United States had fallen from being the land of opportunity to a country focused on eco- nomic survival. The income of the average American family had fallen by 40%, unemployment was at 25% and it was a perilous time for public education, with most communities struggling to afford teachers and textbooks for their children.
    [Show full text]
  • Solidarity by Association: the Unionization of Faculty, Academic Librarians and Support Staff at Carleton University (1973–1976)
    Solidarity by Association: The Unionization of Faculty, Academic Librarians and Support Staff at Carleton University (1973–1976) by Martha Attridge Bufton, B.B.A (Hons) A thesis submitted to the Faculty of Graduate and Postdoctoral Affairs in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in History Carleton University Ottawa, Ontario © 2013, Martha Attridge Bufton Abstract In the mid-1970s, three employee groups at Carleton University changed campus labour relations dramatically: the professors and librarians who belonged to the Carleton University Academic Staff formed the first Ontario faculty union in June 1975; nine months later the Ontario Labour Relations Board certified the Carleton University Support Staff Association as the bargaining agent for the administrative and technical staff. The history of faculty labour action at Carleton has been told but not that of either academic librarians or support staff so this case of unionism provides a unique opportunity to compare their experiences. Working primarily with oral histories, I argue that status was critical to mobilizing labour action at Carleton. These employees—many of whom were women—wanted a fair workplace but deliberately chose an independent association over a trade union because such “solidarity by association” was compatible with their deeply held beliefs about their work and place on campus. ii Acknowledgements This is first and foremost an oral history project and so the place of honour goes to the women and men who shared their stories—I am most grateful not only for their time but for the legacy they have left to those of us who are working at Carleton University and enjoying the benefits that come from a unionized workplace.
    [Show full text]
  • Education for Librarianship: the Design of the Curriculum of Library Schools
    "M LIBRARIANSHIP: v u &"" *•* <t "• li i iv P u JS R Sk /"Hi E T ft i E pfpRAPY €f UAA1 C LIBRARY OF THE UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS AT URBANA-CHAMPAIGN 020 I29m no . 11 Llr tu Qcl&ncc. The person charging this material is re- sponsible for its return on or before the Latest Date stamped below. Theft, mutilation, and underlining of books are reasons for disciplinary action and may result in dismissal from the University. UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS LIBRARY AT URBANA-CHAMPAIGN DECjfejt 06,1992 JUL 08 2 6i008.o« Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2011 with funding from University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign http://www.archive.org/details/educationforlibr11gold EDUCATION FOR LIBRARIANSHIP: THE DESIGN OF THE CURRICULUM OF LIBRARY SCHOOLS Monograph No. 11 Papers Presented at a Conference on The Design of the Curriculum of Library Schools Conducted by the University of Illinois Graduate School of Library Science September 6-9, 1970 EDUCATION FOR LIBRARIANSHIP: THE DESIGN OF THE CURRICULUM OF LIBRARY SCHOOLS Edited by HERBERT GOLDHOR University of Illinois Graduate School of Library Science Urbana, Illinois COPYRIGHT © 1971 The Board of Trustees of the University of Illinois LC Card Number: 78-633332 ISBN: 0-87845-033-5 This and previous monographs are available from the mini Union Bookstore, 715 S. Wright Street, Champaign, Illinois 61820. A list of those volumes available can be obtained from the Publications Office— Graduate School of Library Science, 215 Armory Building, Champaign, Illinois 61820. v^o. TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION vii Herbert Goldhor DESIGNS ON THE CURRICULUM 1 Neal Harlow ,/THE CURRICULUM OF LIBRARY SCHOOLS TODAY: A HISTORICAL OVERVIEW I 9 Sarah R.
    [Show full text]
  • Librarytrendsv40i3 Opt.Pdf
    ILLINOIS UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS AT URBANA-CHAMPAIGN PRODUCTION NOTE University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign Library Large-scale Digitization Project, 2007. LIBRARY TRENDS WINTER 1992 40(3)377-573 Libraries and Librarians: Meeting the Leadership Challenges of the 21st Century Barbara B. Moran Issue Editor University of Illinois Graduate School of Library and Information Science STATEMENT OF OWNERSHIP, MANAGEMENT AND CIRCULATION 1. Titleof publication: Library Trends. 2. Dateof filing: 12 September 1990.3. Frequency of issue: quarterly; no. of issues published annually: four; annual subscription price: $60 ($65 foreign). 4. Location of known office of publication: University of Illinois Graduate School of Library and Information Science, 249 Armory Bldg., 505 E. Armory St., Champaign, IL 61820. 5. Same as 4. 6. Publisher: University of Illinois Graduate School of Library and Information Science, Champaign, IL 61820; Editor: F. W. Lancaster, 410 David Kinley Hall, 1407 W. Gregory Dr., Urbana, IL 61801; Managing Editor: James S. Dowling, 249 Armory Bldg., 505 E. Armory St., Champaign, IL 61820. 7. Owner: University of Illinois Graduate School of Library and Information Science, 249 Armory Bldg., 505 E. Armory St., Champaign, IL 61820. 8. Known bondholders, mortgages, and other security holdrs owning or holding 1 percent or more of total amount of bonds, mortgages or other securities: None. 9. The purpose function and nonprofit status of the organization and the exempt status for Federal income tax purposes have not changed during preceding 12 months. Actual no. copies Average no. copies of single issues each issue during published nearest 10. Extent and nature of circulation preceding 12 months to filing date A.
    [Show full text]
  • Vol-108-No-4-View-The-Full-Issue
    DON’T LOSE ACCESS TO Vol. 108, No. 4 THE ICLR LAW REPORTS Fall 2016 1 JANUARY 2017. DEADLINE DAY. JOURNAL LIBRARY LAW The ICLR – publisher of the official law reports for L A W England and Wales – is about to disaggregate its law reports from the online services operated by LexisNexis and Thomson Reuters in Australia, L I B R A R Y Canada, New Zealand and the United States. If you are renewing an annual subscription with J O U R N A L LexisNexis or Thomson Reuters in 2016 that includes access to ICLR content, access to that content will end as of 1 January 2017. Vol. 108, No. 4 Fall 2016 Fall 4 108,No. Vol. ARTICLES The Need for Experiential Legal Research Education [2016-26] Thereafter, the ICLR will provide its case law service Alyson M. Drake 511 directly through its established online platform, ICLR Online. Here Come Your New Colleagues: Are They Ready? A Survey of U.S. Library and Information Science Programs’ If you wish to continue to be provided with access Education of Aspiring Law Librarians [2016-27] to The Law Reports, The Weekly Law Reports and Elizabeth Caulfield 535 other ICLR content, it is essential that you contact the Human Subjects Research Review: Scholarly Needs ICLR as soon as possible so we can help to ensure a and Service Opportunities [2016-28] smooth transition of service. To find out more, Sarah E. Ryan 579 including why we are disaggregating, visit iclr.co.uk/disaggregation Discovering the Knowledge Monopoly of Law Librarianship Under the DIKW Pyramid [2016-29] Alex “Xiaomeng” Zhang 599 Pages 505–740 Pages Third Circuit Court Reports (1789–1879) [2016-30] Joel Fishman 623 Contact [email protected] call us on +44 207 242 6471 or sign up for a free trial at iclr.co.uk 0023-9283(201623)108:4;1-B Vol.
    [Show full text]
  • Ideals and Standards : the History of the University of Illinois Graduate
    Ideals and Standard The History of the University of lUinois Graduate School of Library and Information Science, 1893-1993 S^ig^:£i-o Digitized by tine Internet Archive in 2010 witii funding from University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign http://www.archive.org/details/idealsstandardshOOalle Ideals and Standards: The History of the University of lUinois Graduate School of Library and Information Science, 1893-1993 © 1992 by The Board of Ihistees of the University of Illinois ISBN 0-87845-089-0 Printed in the United States of America on acid-free paper Ideals and Siandards BBPBB maammm nwiwrn pariHiAiws ^ I ^HE ilLlNOlSl I LlBRAilYSGDOL ^" r ' :c]!l Katharine Lucinda Sharp, 1865-1914 (has relief by Lorado Taft) Contents Foreword i * Leigh Estabrook Introduction ii Walter Allen 1 Remarkable Beginnings: The First Half Century of the Graduate School of Library AND Information Science 1 Laurel Grotzinger 2 The School's Third Quarter Century with an Addendum by Robert W. Oram 23 Robert B. Downs 3 The Fourth Quarter Century: A Personal Reminiscence 36 Laivrence W. S. Auld 4 A Place of Our Own: The School's Space 57 Dale S. Montanelli 5 The Library and Information Science Library 68 Patricia Stenstrom 6 To Become Well Trained and Well Educated: Technical Services Education at the Graduate School of Library and Information Science 81 Kathryn Luther Henderson 7 Services and Sources: Reference and Other Public Service Courses 115 Christine Beserra and T^rry L Weech 8 From Mechanization in Libraries to Information Transfer: Information Science Education AT Illinois 134 Linda C. Smith 1 9 Children and Youth Services: Education for Librarianship 157 Mary E.
    [Show full text]