DOCSLIB.ORG

Third Interim Report of the Tribunal of Inquiry Into Protected Disclosures Made Under the Protected Disclosures Act 2014 and Certain Other Matters

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Third Interim Report of the Tribunal of Inquiry Into Protected Disclosures Made Under the Protected Disclosures Act 2014 and Certain Other Matters Third interim report of the tribunal of inquiry into protected disclosures made under the Protected Disclosures Act 2014 and certain other matters Established by the Minister for Justice and Equality under the Tribunals of Inquiry (Evidence) Acts 1921 to 2004, on 17th February 2017 by instrument Chairman: The Honourable Mr Justice Peter Charleton Report on matters dealing with the conduct of the Health Service Executive, the Child and Family Agency (TUSLA), Raidió Teilifís Éireann, Garda Headquarters, and Garda officers concerning Sergeant Maurice McCabe and related matters pursuant to terms of reference (a) to (o) Solicitor to the tribunal: Elizabeth Mullan Registrar to the tribunal: Peter Kavanagh 2 3 4 Contents A note on structure ............................................................................................................. 10 Part 1: Report on the TUSLA file and Sergeant Maurice McCabe .................................... 10 The relevant terms of reference .......................................................................................................... 10 Debate on tribunal reports ................................................................................................................. 13 Jurisdiction and the original allegation by Ms D .................................................................................. 13 Tribunals and gardaí ........................................................................................................................... 13 Quantum of costs and tribunals of inquiry ......................................................................................... 14 Tribunal personnel ............................................................................................................................. 15 Tribunal function ............................................................................................................................... 15 How a tribunal differs from a court case ............................................................................................ 16 A tribunal is a final resort ................................................................................................................... 17 The parties to a tribunal must engage meaningfully ............................................................................ 18 Finding facts ...................................................................................................................................... 19 Matters of credibility .......................................................................................................................... 22 The task of finding facts ..................................................................................................................... 23 The guarded nature of judicial pronouncements ................................................................................. 26 Quotes, background, ranks and chronology ........................................................................................ 26 Social services .................................................................................................................................... 27 Purpose of introductory explanation .................................................................................................. 28 Garda Keith Harrison: a brief summary.............................................................................................. 28 Maurice McCabe and another garda family ......................................................................................... 29 Events unfold .................................................................................................................................... 30 Public concern ................................................................................................................................... 33 The O’Higgins Commission issues ..................................................................................................... 34 Chronology and correspondence of issues .......................................................................................... 37 The Maurice McCabe issues ............................................................................................................... 39 The complaint of Ms D in 2006 ......................................................................................................... 39 The DPP’s ruling on the D complaint ................................................................................................ 42 The nature and effect of a sexual abuse allegation .............................................................................. 43 Conclusion on the D investigation ..................................................................................................... 44 The aftermath of the 2006 complaint ................................................................................................. 45 The 2006 complaint and social services .............................................................................................. 48 What should have happened: what did happen ................................................................................... 49 Effective closure of the D case in 2007 by social services ................................................................... 50 5 The years between 2006 and 2014 ...................................................................................................... 53 Ms D returns to counselling in 2013 ................................................................................................... 56 Articles by Paul Williams in 2014 ....................................................................................................... 58 Paul Williams and Superintendent David Taylor ................................................................................. 62 Ms D complains in 2014 about Inspector Cunningham and PULSE .................................................. 65 Ms Y complains against Mr Z: word processing errors ....................................................................... 65 Credibility and coincidence ................................................................................................................. 67 The afterlife of the word processing error .......................................................................................... 68 Measuring the pressure ....................................................................................................................... 71 Another series of derelictions of duty ................................................................................................. 72 Initial garda reaction to the rape offence complaint ............................................................................ 74 Laura Brophy responds to the error ................................................................................................... 76 TUSLA react to notification of the error ............................................................................................ 77 The Garda reaction to the corrected report ........................................................................................ 80 The Laura Brophy error explained ...................................................................................................... 85 Garda Headquarters ........................................................................................................................... 89 The Mullingar meeting of 16 July 2014 ............................................................................................... 91 Maurice McCabe in the dark ............................................................................................................... 95 Senior officers and Maurice McCabe .................................................................................................. 96 The afterlife within TUSLA of the incorrect report ............................................................................ 96 The five-point plan ignored .............................................................................................................. 101 The letter received in January 2016 and the response ........................................................................ 103 Failure to face the problem .............................................................................................................. 105 The file goes to SART ...................................................................................................................... 106 Conclusions on the Health Service Executive/TUSLA affair ............................................................ 110 Part 2: Report on the allegations relating to the O’Higgins Commission .......................... 114 A note on structure .......................................................................................................................... 114 Term of reference (e) ....................................................................................................................... 114 Commission of investigation, tribunal of inquiry .............................................................................. 114 Unfairness to the media.................................................................................................................... 116 Chairing the O’Higgins Commission ...............................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Goldsmith Festival 2013 Brochure
    OBJECTIVES To develop a deeper insight into the writings of Oliver Goldsmith To promote Goldsmith Country thth as a major tourist attraction 2929 AnnualAnnual For further information please contact: GoldsmithGoldsmith www.goldsmithfestival.ie InternationalInternational Goldsmith Literary Tour LiteraryLiterary FestivalFestival Bus Tour featuring readings from selected works of Goldsmith at well known locations including May 31stst - JuneJune 22nd Forgney Church, Lissoy and Kilkenny West 2013 Beginning at 11.00 am and returning to the Goldsmith Monument, Ballymahon Library Admission €10 GOLDSMITH LITERARY FESTIVAL COMMITTEE Theme: Chairman: Seamus McCormack Secretary: Adrian Duncan Treasurer: Niall Nally The Gathering - Committee: Joe Farrell, William Dowler, Cecil English, Are Faraway Hills Greener ? Teddy McGoey, Sean Ryan, Dr. Pat Kelly, Willie Flanagan, Anne Tully “Such is the patriot’s boast, where’er we roam, Produced with Financial Assistance from His first, best country ever is, at home.” The Traveller (1764)- Oliver Goldsmith Longford County Council Designed and printed by Arthur Conlon, Ballymahon - 086 8716763 st Sally Mulready is an elected Labour Party Councillor in the London Borough of Friday May 31 Rustic Inn, Abbeyshrule Adm. €10 Hackney and was appointed to the Irish Council of State in January 2012 by President Michael D. Higgins. She has a solid history of community politics, long 8.00 pm Recital by Innyside Singers term union involvement and championing human rights in Britain and abroad. She is a founder member, and current Chair, of the Irish Women Survivors Network and 8.30 pm Chair: Ciaran Mullooly is the Director of the Irish Elderly Advice Network, a charity supporting older Irish people living in and around London.
    [Show full text]
  • Provided by the Author(S) and University College Dublin Library in Accordance with Publisher Policies
    Provided by the author(s) and University College Dublin Library in accordance with publisher policies. Please cite the published version when available. Title Justice, 2015 Authors(s) Black, Lynsey Publication date 2016-02-16 Publication information Administration: Journal of the Institute of Public Administration in Ireland, 63 (4): 49-60 Publisher De Gruyter Item record/more information http://hdl.handle.net/10197/8270 Publisher's version (DOI) 10.1515/admin-2016-0005 Downloaded 2021-09-04T18:40:46Z The UCD community has made this article openly available. Please share how this access benefits you. Your story matters! (@ucd_oa) © Some rights reserved. For more information, please see the item record link above. 05 Justice_Admin 63-4 23/01/2016 21:51 Page 49 Administration, vol. 63, no. 4 (2016), pp. 49–60 doi: 10.1515/admin-2016-0005 Justice, 2015 Lynsey Black Trinity College Dublin The year 2015 saw the Department of Justice and Equality continue to deal with the fallout from the events of 2014, a year in which Alan Shatter’s resignation as minister was accompanied by the reassignment of Brian Purcell from the post of secretary general1 and the retirement of Martin Callinan as garda commissioner. The shifts of 2014 followed allegations of improper practice regarding penalty points, the recording of phone calls to Garda stations and serious criticisms of how the department responded to these issues. In 2015 the repercussions of these events were still being felt as the department pledged to enhance accountability and restore public confidence. In this vein, the year brought further challenges for An Garda Síochána in the form of the highly critical Garda Inspectorate report, which recommended far-reaching reforms for the organisation.
    [Show full text]
  • Disclosure Log 2019 (Q3)
    Disclosure Log of completed Freedom of Information requests RTÉ Freedom of Information – Q3 (July – September 2019) FOI No. Date FOI Received Freedom Of Information Request Requester Decision 64. 29.05.2019 All emails and memos: Member of the public Refused. 1. To/from Dee Forbes, Michael Kealy and Rory Coveney Section 15(1)(h). that discuss Eurovision and 'Palestine' and/or 'Palestinian' from 12/05/18 to 30/04/19. 2. To/from Dee Forbes, Michael Kealy and Rory Coveney that discuss Eurovision and 'protest' and/or 'boycott' from 12/05/18 to 30/04/19. 3. To/from Michael Kealy that discuss 'Sarah McTernan' from 12/05/18 to 30/04/19. 4. All emails between Michael Kealy and Sarah McTernan from 12/05/17 to 30/04/19. 5. All emails between Michael Kealy and [email protected] and/or DWB Music Limited from 12/05/17 to 30/04/19. 81. 04.06.2019 From 1 Jan 2018 to date, copies of all guest lists for the Journalist. Refused. following shows ‘The Late Debate’, ‘Morning Ireland’, ‘The Late Late Show’, ‘Prime Time’, ‘Today with Sean O’Rourke’, Section 15(1)(d). ‘Drive Time’, ‘This Week’, ‘The Ray D’Arcy Show’. Disclosure Log of completed Freedom of Information requests RTÉ Freedom of Information – Q3 (July - September 2019) FOI No. Date FOI Freedom Of Information Request Requester Decision Received 85. 11.06.2019 1. All formal complaints received by RTÉ over its coverage of Journalist. Refused. Donald Trump's visit to Ireland. Statutory Instrument SI 115 of 2000.
    [Show full text]
  • How Irish Radio Made Strides for Women's Rights
    Salve Regina University Digital Commons @ Salve Regina Pell Scholars and Senior Theses Salve's Dissertations and Theses 5-11-2020 Her Voice on Air: How Irish Radio Made Strides for Women's Rights Emilie R. Hines Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.salve.edu/pell_theses Part of the English Language and Literature Commons, European History Commons, Film and Media Studies Commons, Women's History Commons, and the Women's Studies Commons Her Voice on Air: How Irish Radio Made Strides for Women’s Rights By Emilie Hines Prepared for Dr. Madeleine Esch Department of English, Communications and Media Salve Regina University May 11, 2020 Hines 1 Her Voice on Air: How Irish Radio Made Strides for Women’s Rights ABSTRACT: Radio is the voice of the people; this is no less true in Ireland, a nation that prefers talk radio and phone-ins. These formats were popular from 1970-2000, formative years for the feminist movement. Scholarship suggests a correlation between radio and women’s issues in Ireland but does not answer what elements create this. Here, I analyze 10 archival radio clips from Ireland’s national public service broadcaster, RTÉ, looking at how women’s issues are framed. After analyzing these clips, I found that Irish identity embedded in the shows allows for the discussion of controversial ideas. Radio promotes an inclusive environment, by dispelling shame and encouraging political conversation among women. This allows women to hear and be heard, creating a space for equal representation. Introduction As I was sitting on a bus from Dublin airport back to my apartment in Cork City, I heard a late-night radio show playing on the bus speakers.
    [Show full text]
  • Papers of Gemma Hussey P179 Ucd Archives
    PAPERS OF GEMMA HUSSEY P179 UCD ARCHIVES [email protected] www.ucd.ie/archives T + 353 1 716 7555 © 2016 University College Dublin. All rights reserved ii CONTENTS CONTEXT Biographical History iv Archival History vi CONTENT AND STRUCTURE Scope and Content vii System of Arrangement ix CONDITIONS OF ACCESS AND USE Access xi Language xi Finding Aid xi DESCRIPTION CONTROL Archivist’s Note xi ALLIED MATERIALS Allied Collections in UCD Archives xi Published Material xi iii CONTEXT Biographical History Gemma Hussey nee Moran was born on 11 November 1938. She grew up in Bray, Co. Wicklow and was educated at the local Loreto school and by the Sacred Heart nuns in Mount Anville, Goatstown, Co. Dublin. She obtained an arts degree from University College Dublin and went on to run a successful language school along with her business partner Maureen Concannon from 1963 to 1974. She is married to Dermot (Derry) Hussey and has one son and two daughters. Gemma Hussey has a strong interest in arts and culture and in 1974 she was appointed to the board of the Abbey Theatre serving as a director until 1978. As a director Gemma Hussey was involved in the development of policy for the theatre as well as attending performances and reviewing scripts submitted by playwrights. In 1977 she became one of the directors of TEAM, (the Irish Theatre in Education Group) an initiative that emerged from the Young Abbey in September 1975 and founded by Joe Dowling. It was aimed at bringing theatre and theatre performance into the lives of children and young adults.
    [Show full text]
  • Date 29 March 2013 Page11 SPEECH J Callinan MINISTER J
    Date 29 March 2013 Page 11 WALKOUT COPS By CATHAL McMAHON, Crime Reporter THE fourBACK gardai who walked out on GardaCALLINAN Com- missioner Martin Callinan have escaped punishment after apologising and retracting their comments. The sergeants caused a stir when they left the room as Commissioner Callinan and Justice Minister Alan Shatter rose to speak at the Association of Garda Sergeants and Inspectors (AGSI) conference in Sligo. Ted Hughes, Joseph Hanly, Pat Baldwin and John Foley said they were mandated by their members to make the move. They went on J SPEECH Callinan J MINISTER Shatter to say they had no confidence in Commis- been played out publicly. He added: “All sioner Callinan and his office. parties consider the matter now resolved and But after six hours of talks at Templemore look forward to continuing to serve the garda training college, Co Tipperary, community.” yesterday the four withdrew their Commissioner Callinan had earlier indi- comments. cated that he was willing to let the four A garda statement confirmed that the officers away without discipline so long as matter had been resolved. It added: “The four they apologised.. representatives of Kilkenny Carlow branch He said: “I have made my comments very of the AGSI indicated that they meant to cause clear in that respect and this is a time for no offence to the Commisioner. cool heads and it is a time for appropriate “They personally have full confidence in reflection on what happened.” the Commissioner of An Garda Síochána. The Earlier in the Dail Mattie McGrath TD said Commissioner enjoys the full confidence of that what was happening with the four the Association of Garda Sergeants and sergeants was totally unacceptable.
    [Show full text]
  • Statement to the Oireachtas Committee of Inquiry Into the Banking Crisis in Ireland Ed Mulhall
    Statement to the Oireachtas Committee of Inquiry into the Banking Crisis in Ireland Ed Mulhall The starting premise for a discussion of RTÉ's editorial policy on the coverage of any area of public interest is that there is no single expression of it. RTÉ's output is based on a set of principles which are derived from its statutory obligations. These principles form the framework for editorial decision making and there is an editorial structure in place to monitor, discuss and challenge the editorial selections being made so as to ensure they are being adhered to. In addition, all RTÉ's activities are subject to a regulatory structure to ensure that the organisation is meeting its public service obligations. Those working in editorial roles in RTÉ operate under a shared understanding of RTÉ’s obligations under various statutes, notably the 1976 Broadcasting Act as amended and the 2009 Broadcasting Act. In RTÉ News, this translates into a very simple premise: inform the audience in the public interest. The political scientist Jean Blondel - in an essay written in honour of the late RTÉ broadcaster Brian Farrell - calls the role to inform the noblest of tasks because it is the most difficult. It requires the reporting of facts, sometimes the establishment of facts, their selection according to their importance and the presentation of them with related material to allow their meaning or significance to be understood. What is important to report in the public interest is a constantly evolving question that is impacted on by events and does not adhere to any fixed state of national consensus.
    [Show full text]
  • Radio Telefís Éireann Annual Report and Group Financial Statements 2007 Radio Telefís Éireann
    RADIO TELEFÍS ÉIREANN ANNUAL REPORT AND GROUP FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 2007 RADIO TELEFÍS ÉIREANN Contents Highlights 3 Independent Auditor’s Report 39 Organisation Structure 4 Statement of Accounting Policies 40 What we do 5 Group Income Statement 44 Chairman’s Statement 6 Group and RTÉ Statement of Total Director-General’s Review 7 Recognised Income and Expense 45 Operational Reviews 8 Group Balance Sheet 46 Financial Review 26 Group Cash Flow Statement 47 Authority 30 RTÉ Balance Sheet 48 Executive Board 32 RTÉ Cash Flow Statement 49 Corporate Governance 34 Notes to the Financial Statements 50 Authority Members’ Report 37 Charter 81 Statement of Authority Members’ Other Statistical Information 92 Responsibilities 38 Financial History 95 Radio Telefís Éireann Authority Forty-seventh Annual Report and Group Financial Statements for the 12 months ended 31 December 2007, presented to the Minister for Communications, Energy and Natural Resources pursuant to sections 25 and 26 of the Broadcasting Authority Act, 1960. RTÉ’s vision is to grow the trust of the people of Ireland as it informs, inspires, reflects and enriches their lives. RTÉ’s mission is to: • Nurture and reflect the cultural and regional diversity of all the people of Ireland • Provide distinctive programming and services of the highest quality and ambition, with the emphasis on home production • Inform the Irish public by delivering the best comprehensive independent news service possible • Enable national participation in all major events 2 ANNUAL REPORT & GROUP FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
    [Show full text]
  • Report an Taoiseach, Enda Kenny TD
    Report TO A n T a o isea c h , Enda Kenny TD ON A REVIEW OF THE ACTION TAKEN BY AN GARDA S io c h An a PERTAINING TO CERTAIN ALLEGATIONS MADE BY SERGEANT MAURICE M c C a b e S ean G uerin SC 6 M ay 2014 Table of Contents Chapter 1: Introduction........................................................................3 Chapter 2: Background................................................................. 11 Chapter 3: Structure and Method.................................................... 17 Chapter 4: Public Order Incident at Kingscourt on 25 February 2007...........21 Complaints about the Handling of the Investigation.................................. 23 The Disciplinary Proceedings........................................................... 25 Findings of the Byrne-McGinn Report..................................................32 Sergeant McCabe’s Complaints......................................................... 33 Analysis.................................................................................. 35 Chapter 5: Assault at the Lakeside Manor Hotel on 14 April 2007...............39 The Garda Investigation................................................................ 39 The Trial of | ...........................................................................48 The Byrne-McGinn Investigation....................................................... 48 Complaints by Sergeant McCabe....................................................... 52 Analysis.................................................................................. 54
    [Show full text]
  • Supreme Court Visit to NUI Galway 4-6 March, 2019 Welcoming the Supreme Court to NUI Galway
    Supreme Court Visit to NUI Galway 4-6 March, 2019 Welcoming the Supreme Court to NUI Galway 4-6 March, 2019 Table of Contents Welcome from the Head of School . 2 Te School of Law at NUI Galway . 4 Te Supreme Court of Ireland . 6 Te Judges of the Supreme Court . 8 2 Welcome from the Head of School We are greatly honoured to host the historic sittings of the Irish Supreme Court at NUI Galway this spring. Tis is the frst time that the Supreme Court will sit outside of a courthouse since the Four Courts reopened in 1932, the frst time the court sits in Galway, and only its third time to sit outside of Dublin. To mark the importance of this occasion, we are running a series of events on campus for the public and for our students. I would like to thank the Chief Justice and members of the Supreme Court for participating in these events and for giving their time so generously. Dr Charles O’Mahony, Head of School, NUI Galway We are particularly grateful for the Supreme Court’s willingness to engage with our students. As one of Ireland’s leading Law Schools, our key focus is on the development of both critical thinking and adaptability in our future legal professionals. Tis includes the ability to engage in depth with the new legal challenges arising from social change, and to analyse and apply the law to developing legal problems. Te Supreme Court’s participation in student seminars on a wide range of current legal issues is not only deeply exciting for our students, but ofers them an excellent opportunity to appreciate at frst hand the importance of rigorous legal analysis, and the balance between 3 necessary judicial creativity and maintaining the rule of law.
    [Show full text]
  • An Garda Síochána Annual Report 2011
    An Garda Síochána Annual Report 2011 The mission of An Garda Síochána is Working with Communities to Protect and Serve Annual Report of An Garda Síochána 2011 1 Foreword Fighting Crime Contents Fighting Crime 3 Community 11 Managing Our Resources 14 Traffic 17 Regional Reports 19 Strategic Goals 28 Statistics 37 I am pleased to present the Annual Report for We will continue to engage meaningfully and 2011, detailing the work of An Garda Síochána effectively with all stakeholders, as well as across all divisions. The report outlines working to protect our most vulnerable persons achievements and successes across our core areas and responding sensitively and effectively to of activity including the prevention and detection victims of crime. of crime, the protection of national security, and our daily work to keep our road network and our One of the most significant challenges for An communities safe. Garda Síochána during 2011 was its critical remit in the management of the State visits in May. The community itself continues to be our greatest Gardaí throughout the country were more than ally in providing a safe and secure environment equal to this challenge, and the effective for everyone and during 2011 we continued to execution of the largest policing operation in the work on developing our critical and long-standing State’s history made a vital contribution to the relationships in communities. This work yields success of these visits. tangible daily results as we aim to provide a visible Garda presence, reduce both crime and the An Garda Síochána is not immune from the harsh fear of crime, maintain a strong relationship of economic realities which are impacting on the trust between Gardaí and the people who live and community and the public sector.
    [Show full text]
  • Maclochlainn Commission of Investigation Final Report
    FINAL REPORT Commission of Investigation (Ronan MacLochlainn) Mary Rose Gearty, S.C. 13 May 2016 ii Index Acknowledgements ........................................................................................................ ix Acronyms & Abbreviations ........................................................................................... x Executive Summary ....................................................................................................... xi Introduction ................................................................................................................................. xi Factual Background .................................................................................................................... xi The First Attempt ..................................................................................................................... xii Operation Morrison .................................................................................................................. xiii Events of 1st May 1998 .............................................................................................................. xv The Securicor Van is Spotted ............................................................................................... xvii The Securicor Van is Attacked .............................................................................................. xix The 1998 Investigation ..........................................................................................................
    [Show full text]