Climate Change in Fiction Master’S Thesis by Miglė Šaltytė
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Università Ca' Foscari Venezia Climate Change in Fiction Master’s Thesis by Miglė Šaltytė Miglė Šaltytė 1-10-2019 Table of Contents Introduction........................................................................................................................................................2 1. Climate Fiction …………………………………….……………………….................................................5 2. “Serious” Climate-Change Fiction …………................................................................................................8 3. Artistically Compelling Climate-Change Fiction.........................................................................................11 4. What Climate-Change Fiction Reveals About Our Attitudes towards the Human and the Non-Human.…13 5. The Works Chosen and the Structure of the Thesis………………………………………………...….…..14 6. Truth, Politics, and Climate Change…..….......…………………………………………………….….…..15 6.1 Flight Behaviour by Barbara Kingsolver……………………………………………………………..…..16 6.2 The State of Fear by Michael Crichton………………………………………………………………..….20 6.3 Solar by Ian McEwan……………………………………………………………………………..………24 7. The Human Point of View in Climate-Chamage Fiction …………………………………………....…….30 7.1 “Shooting the Apocalypse” by Paolo Bacigalupi………………………………………………..………..31 7.2 “A Hundred Hundred Daisies” by Nancy Kress………………………………………………….………34 7.3 “The Mutant Stag at Horn Creek” by Sarah K. Castle……………………………………………..……..36 7.4 “The Tamarisk Hunter” by Paolo Bacigalupi…………………………………………………….………40 8. Climate Change on the Fringe of “Serious” Literature…………………………………………….………43 8.1 Carbon Diaries 2015 by Sacy Lloyd……………………………………………………………..………46 9. Science Fiction and Climate-Change Fiction……..……...………………………………………..…….…52 9.1 The Windup Girl by Paulo Bacigalupi…………………………………………………………..………..56 9.2 The MaddAddam trilogy by Margaret Atwood………………………………………………..………….62 10. Climate Change in Children’s Literature……………………………………………………..…………..68 10.1 The Lorax by Dr Seuss………………………………………………………………………...………...70 10.2 George Saves the World by Lunchtime by Dr Jo Readman……………………………………..….…...72 10.3 The Tantrum that Saved the World by Megan Herbert and Dr Michael E. Mann…………………..…..73 10.4 Where’s the Elephant? by Barroux………………………………………………………………..…….74 10.5 The Trouble with Dragons by Debi Gliori……………………………………………………….……...75 Conclusions ......................................................................................................................................................79 Works Cited .....................................................................................................................................................83 Summary ..........................................................................................................................................................91 1 Introduction It has been said that throughout history, fiction has always responded to wars, crises and calamities (Ghosh 16). This is only natural bearing in mind that narratives have been said to help deal with threats by making them understandable and therefore bearable (Bruner 16), and even being an essential part of healing, not just metaphorically but physically as well (Charon 3). Naturally, this highlights the importance of fiction as the field that invents, reflects upon, and changes narratives that influence our daily lives. It also explains why we expect fiction to respond to the most urgent and pressing issues of our times, of which today climate change is undoubtedly the most serious. However, the response to climate change in fiction has been said to be so inadequate as to be almost non-existent. In 2005, writer Robert Macfarlane argued that climate change “does not yet, with a few exceptions, exist as art. Where are the novels, the plays, the poems, the songs, the libretti, of this massive contemporary anxiety?”(guardian.com). Eleven years later, in 2016, Amitav Ghosh expressed the same concern in The Great Derangement: In a substantially altered world, when sea-level rise has swallowed Sundarbans and made cities like Kolkata, New York and Bangkok uninhabitable, when readers and museumgoers turn to the art and literature of our time, will they not look, first, and most urgently, for traces and portents of the altered world of their inheritance? And when they fail to find them, what should they what can they do other than to conclude that ours was a time when forms of art and literature were drawn into the modes of concealment that prevented people from recognizing the realities of their plight? (16). On the other hand, it seems simply wrong to declare that fiction that concerns itself with climate change does not exist in fact, works explicitly on this topic can be found as early as the 19th century. Lord Byron’s poem Darkness, inspired by the disastrous cooling of the climate during the famous “year without a summer”, describes a world where the Sun is extinguished, leading to famine and death. Jules Verne’s The Purchase of the North Pole, published in 1889, tells the story of a project to tilt the Earth’s axis, making it easier to mine and sell the coal that is believed to lie under the ice in the North Pole, which presents the theme of ruthless capitalism that is more than relevant today. This is not to mention the ancient Deluge narratives that are found in numerous civilizations. As for contemporary works, fiction that concerns itself with climate change has become widespread enough to inspire the term “cli-fi”, which Margaret Atwood defines as “books in which an altered climate is part of the plot” (Atwood 2013). 2 Yet it is not easy to dismiss the argument that climate change fiction is not nearly as pervasive as one could expect. Nor is it difficult to find works in which the issue is not treated with the seriousness it deserves, or those that Kim Stanley Robinson describes as “so didactic, so obviously meant to warn and teach us, that they no longer work as fiction” (Everything Change 8). On the other hand, great works of art may be criticised for losing sight of their message. In all cases, however, they can provide revealing insights into society’s approach to the issue of climate change (Clode and Stasiak, 2014). For this reason, this thesis aims to examine a diverse sample of contemporary works of Anglophone literature that focus on climate change and discuss the way contemporary fiction responds to the issue. It aims to determine how these works address the issue, how (and if) they make it artistically compelling, and examines the approach towards climate change that these works reveal. Relevance of the Thesis. As mentioned above, literature has been criticised as having failed to adequately respond to the looming crisis of climate change. Many of these criticisms seem to assume that literature on climate change is either non-existent, or incapable of addressing the issue with the seriousness it deserves, or artistically ineffective. However, these assumptions ignore the fact that there is a growing body of literary works that deals explicitly with climate change (and that this subject is by no means new) and fails to examine why the existing works are seen as less serious than the subject demands and/or artistically unsuccessful. It also fails to examine the manner of thinking about climate change that is revealed and strengthened by these narratives. Therefore, instead of discussing a specific climate change-related aspect of a particular work, this thesis aims to take a broader look at a diverse sample from the existing body of climate change fiction and examine what it reveals about the approach to climate change in Anglophone literature, how it addresses the issue, and whether it presents an artistically compelling work. Object, Aim, and Structure of the Thesis. The thesis will examine several works that will be referred to as “climate-change fiction”. This definition is kept purposefully broad in order to examine a wide range of works that are set both in the present and the future, have elements of both realism and science fiction, deal with the issue of climate change both explicitly and implicitly, and are aimed at different audiences. Several works of children’s literature will also be examined as a source of common climate change fiction clichés and a source of inspiration for different ways of presenting the issue. The thesis will examine the following works: Flight Behaviour by Barbara Kingsolver; The State of Fear by Michael Crichton; Solar by Ian McEwan; The Carbon Diaries: 2015 by Saci Lloyd; MaddAddam by Margaret Atwood; and Windup Girl by Paolo Bacigalupi, as well as the short stories “Shooting the Apocalypse” and “The Tamarisk Hunter” by Paolo Bacigalupi, “A Hundred Hundred Daisies” by Nancy Kress, and “The Mutant Stag at Horn Creek” by Sarah K. Castle from the anthology Loosed Upon the World. It will also examine these works of children’s 3 literature: The Lorax by Dr Seuss; The Tantrum that Saved the World by Megan Herbert and Dr Michael E. Mann; George Saves the World by Lunchtime by Dr Jo Readman; The Trouble with Dragons by Debi Gliori; and Where’s the Elephant? by Barroux. The thesis will focus on English-language fiction by mainly American, British, and Canadian authors. These works will be discussed in separate sections, focusing on these aspects: 1. How the authors respond to the fact that the issue has been heavily politicised (at least in the USA), i.e., do they examine the attitudes and uncertainties implicit in the subject or avoid them; 2. How the relationship between scientific