DOCSLIB.ORG

The Independent Commission Report #2

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Independent Commission Report #2 THE INDEPENDENT COMMISSION REPORT #2 January 14, 2016 Independent Commission Investigation Submitted: January 14, 2016 Independent Commission Independent Commission President Members Richard W. Pound, Q.C., Ad. E Professor Richard H. McLaren Günter Younger, Kriminaldirektor WADA Investigations Jack Robertson Chief Investigations Officer Independent Commission Investigation Staff: David Tinsley, Martin Dubbey, Brian Talay, Nick Connon, Greg Kitsell, Gabriella Re Independent Commission Investigative Report Co-ordinator: Diana Tesic Table of Contents Chapter 10: International Association of Athletics Federation .......................................... 1 P A R T I ....................................................................................................................................... 2 10.1 Introduction to the Criminal Side of the IC investigation .................................................... 2 10.2 The Interpersonal Links and Relationships Facilitating Corruption ................................. 3 10.2.1 The President ........................................................................................................................... 3 10.2.2 The Presidential Legal Advisor ............................................................................................. 6 10.2.3 The IAAF “Consultants” ........................................................................................................ 7 10.2.4 The IAAF Treasurer ................................................................................................................ 9 10.2.5 The IAAF Medical and Anti-Doping Department ............................................................. 9 10.2.6 Dr. Gabriel Dollé - the Medical and Anti-Doping Department Administrator ........... 10 10.2.7 Key Findings on the Interpersonal Links and Relationships Facilitating Corruption 11 10.3 Close and Improper Relationship Between ARAF and IAAF ............................................ 12 10.3.1 Key Findings on Improper Relationships .......................................................................... 13 10.4 Usurpation of the IAAF MADept. functions ......................................................................... 13 10.4.1 Backdrop ................................................................................................................................. 13 10.4.2. The MADept.’s Derailment ................................................................................................. 14 10.4.3 The Internal Workings of the MADept. in 2012 & 2013. ................................................. 18 10.4.4 Key Findings on Usurpation of the MADept. Functions ................................................ 21 10.5 Extortion of Russian Athlete Liliya Shobukhova ................................................................. 22 10.5.1 Events at the IAAF in relation to Shobukhova ................................................................. 24 10.5.2 Key Findings in Respect of Russian Athlete Shobukhova .............................................. 27 10.6 Black Tidings return of Euro 300,000 to Shobukhova .......................................................... 28 10.6.1 The Players behind Black Tidings ...................................................................................... 29 10.6.2 The Company ........................................................................................................................ 29 10.6.3 Key Findings in relation to Black Tidings Refund ........................................................... 30 10.7 Extortion of Turkish Athlete Asli Alptekin (nee Cakir) ..................................................... 31 10.7.1 Key Findings in Relation to Turkish Athlete Alptekin .................................................... 33 10.8 Conclusion of Part I .................................................................................................................... 34 10.9 Part 1 Recommendations ........................................................................................................... 34 With respect to the Links & Cross Links Facilitating Corruption ............................................. 34 With respect to the Close & Improper Relationship Between ARAF and IAAF .................... 35 With respect to the Extortion of Russian Athlete Liliya Shobukhova ...................................... 35 With respect to the Black Tidings return of Euro 300,000 to Shobukhova .............................. 36 With respect to the Extortion of Turkish Athlete Asli Alptekin (nee Cakir) ........................... 36 P A R T II .................................................................................................................................. 37 10.10 Developments following the release of IC Report#1 and the leaked email dated 19 July 2013 from IAAF Deputy Secretary General Nick Davies to Papa Massata Diack ......... 37 10.10.1 IC particular conclusions on the Nick Davies e-mail ..................................................... 41 i 10.11 IC Macro-level Conclusions regarding the IAAF’s Conduct ............................................ 44 10.11.1 Governance .......................................................................................................................... 45 10.11.2 Corrupt Conduct ................................................................................................................. 46 10.11.3 Circle of Knowledge ........................................................................................................... 46 10.12 Part II Findings .......................................................................................................................... 47 10.13 Part II Recommendations ........................................................................................................ 49 P A R T III ................................................................................................................................... 51 Allegations on ADR Television and in The Sunday Times regarding IAAF and Suspicious Test Results ........................................................................................................... 51 Executive Summary ............................................................................................................................ 51 Background .......................................................................................................................................... 52 The IC Investigation ........................................................................................................................... 53 1. Obtain a copy of the leaked database and confirmation by the IAAF that it is – or was –all or part of an IAAF database ........................................................................................................... 54 2. Obtain a copy of the report prepared by the Australian scientists ....................................... 54 3. Obtain from WADA the precise dates of the progress toward adoption of the ABP and the application of the applicable protocols for bringing anti-doping rule violation charges based on the ABP, as well as any statements by WADA (or others) regarding inappropriateness of the use of suspicious or abnormal test results as proof of doping ...... 55 4. Verify what portions of the IAAF database have been recorded in ADAMS ..................... 56 5. Identify suspicious test results that should have led to targeted testing ............................. 58 6. Verify the actions of the IAAF in dealing with such suspicious test results, including the timeliness and frequency of any subsequent actions, by examining the IAAF records on a case-by-case basis, and report accordingly to the IC .................................................................. 61 7. Provide timelines established by the foregoing verifications (e.g., date of test, date of receipt of results, date of decision to target test, date(s) of targeted testing, date(s) results were received, date(s) of decision to proceed with sanctioning process, date(s) of process and decision(s) to sanction, date(s) of any provisional sanction) ............................................. 63 8. Verify the actions of WADA regarding IAAF follow-up on suspicious values in the test results, while bearing in mind that the relevant ADO with full responsibility is the IAAF, not WADA, which has a primary role as monitor, rather than principal, in matters of doping in Athletics, and report accordingly to the IC ................................................................ 65 9. Determine to what extent, if any, were IAAF actions the result of WADA’s actions. Determine what internal processes were in place at WADA to coordinate follow-up with the IAAF and other ADOs in relation to suspicious test results ............................................... 65 10. Identify any athletes having abnormal values in test results who were later discovered to have doped as a result of targeted testing, with timelines and outcomes .......................... 69 11. Draw attention to any misstatements made in media releases and other statements ..... 70 12. Make appropriate findings and recommendations .............................................................. 71 Meeting with Experts ......................................................................................................................... 71 Accusations of Inactivity by the IAAF ...........................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • El Periódico
    EL PERIÓDICO Lydia Valentín: "Sabía que competía con rivales que no iban limpias" La bronce olímpica de halterofilia en Rio 2016 recuperará también medallas de Pekín 2008 y Londres 2012 JORDI COTRINA Lydia Valentín posa este viernes en Barcelona. JOAN CARLES ARMENGOL / BARCELONA VIERNES, 21 DE OCTUBRE DEL 2016 - 18:01 CEST Lydia Valentín está en Barcelona. Esta sábado se pone delante de 300 personas en una clase magistral de fitness, patrocinada porBridgestone, bajo el lema 'Persigue tu sueño, supera los obstáculos', que viene como anillo al dedo a una deportista que ha llegado a lo más alto en su modalidad, la halterofilia, tras superar multitud de piedras en el camino y vicisitudes de lo más pintorescas. La leonesa de Camponaraya, pequeño pueblo cercano aPonferrada (León) donde nació hace 31 años, es la única deportista que en un mes ha sido medallista olímpica tres veces… en tres Juegos distintos. A principios de agosto se enteró de que el podio de su categoría (75 kilos) de Londres 2012 se había caído entero al reanalizarse las muestras antidopaje, lo que le daba la victoria; el día 12 se colgó el bronce en Río 2016, y pocos días después de regresar a casa otra revisión de Pekín 2008 la llevó del quinto al segundo puesto. Oro, bronce y plata en un mes. "Voy a reclamar las medallas y los premios del 2008 y el 2012 porque es justo y estoy en mi derecho" -¡Qué montón de sensaciones debió sentir durante ese mes, ¿no?!Muchísimas. Fue la mezcla de muchos sentimientos. Primero sentí una alegría inmensa, pero después piensas: ¡Cómo me han podido fastidiar tanto! ¡Cómo es posible que se permita esto! Estamos hablando de deporte.
    [Show full text]
  • FINAL ITINERARY Gardens and Temples of Japan
    FINAL ITINERARY Gardens and Temples of Japan October 6 - October 23, 2003 October 6: Monday. Depart. Depart on your flight on United Airlines to Tokyo. Please check your luggage all the way through to Narita. October 7: Tuesday. Tokyo. Arrive Tokyo and clear immigration and customs. Once in the arrivals hall locate the Japan Airlines Limo Bus counter. Please give them the voucher we have given you and in exchange, you will be given a ticket for the bus. You MUST exchange the voucher for a bus-ticket as the limo-bus cannot accept the vouchers. The limo bus will take you directly to the Imperial Hotel (please note that the bus may make one other stop right near the hotel). This ticket has been pre-paid and so you will not need to make any payment. Upon arrival check yourself in to the Imperial Hotel where a pre-paid reservation is being held in your name. The reservation has been made through Kintetsu Travel. You will be given breakfast vouchers upon arrival and so make sure that you keep these in a safe place. Please note that these breakfast vouchers can be used in the Imperial Viking Restaurant which offers a buffet breakfast between 7.00am-9.30am, or the Les Saisons Restaurant which offers a set menu between 7.00-10.00am, or the Eureca Restaurant which offers a set menu between 6.00am-11.00am, or the Nadaman Restaurant which offers a Japanese breakfast between 7.00am-9.30am. Balance of the day at leisure. Meals aloft.
    [Show full text]
  • Tokyo GB Eng.Pdf
    http://www.kankyo.metro.tokyo.jp/en/index.html Introduction In the year 2000, the Tokyo Metropolitan Government (TMG) replaced the Tokyo Metropolitan Pollution Prevention Ordinance with the Tokyo Metropolitan Environmental Security Ordinance, which covers countermeasures for vehicle pollution, chemical substances and climate change. The reason for the replacement was a shift in Tokyo’s environmental problems from industrial pollution mainly attributable to factories to urban and domestic pollution due to vehicle emissions and chemical substances, which may sometimes be related to climate change problems. In 2002, we started two programmes on which Tokyo’s present climate change strategy has been based: Tokyo Green Building Program for new buildings and Tokyo Carbon Reduction Reporting Program for existing large facilities. Since 2005, we have been promoting environmentally superior developments by introducing a mechanism to evaluate and disclose facilities’ efforts made in the programmes. In Tokyo’s Big Change - The 10-Year Plan developed in 2006, we set a goal of reducing citywide greenhouse gas emissions by 25% below 2000 levels by 2020 to make Tokyo a city with the least environmental impact in the world. Then in 2007, we announced the Tokyo Climate Change Strategy, which clarified our basic attitude toward tackling climate change for the next 10 years. Following a revision of the Tokyo Metropolitan Environmental Security Ordinance in 2008, we launched the Tokyo Cap-and-Trade Program for large facilities, the world’s first urban cap- and-trade scheme that covers office buildings as well, and the Carbon Reduction Reporting Program for small and medium facilities, committed to advancing our climate change strategy ever since then.
    [Show full text]
  • 2010 New York Marathon Statistical Information Men New York Marathon All Time List
    2010 New York Marathon Statistical Information Men New York Marathon All Time list Performances Time Performers Name Nat Place Date 1 2:07:43 1 Tesfaye Jifar ETH 1 4 Nov 2001 2 2:08:01 2 Juma Ikangaa TAN 1 5 Nov 1989 3 2:08:07 3 Rodger Rop KEN 1 3 Nov 2002 4 2:08:12 4 John Kagwe KEN 1 2 Nov 1997 5 2:08:17 5 Christopher Cheboiboch KEN 2 3 Nov 2002 6 2:08:20 6 Steve Jones GBR 1 6 Nov 1988 7 2:08:39 7 Laban Kipkemboi KEN 3 3 Nov 2002 8 2:08:43 8 Marilson Gomes dos Santos BRA 1 2 Nov 2008 9 2:08:45 John Kagwe 1 1 Nov 1998 10 2:08:48 9 Joseph Chebet KEN 2 1 Nov 1998 11 2:08:51 10 Zebedayo Bayo TAN 3 1 Nov 1998 12 2:08:53 11 Mohamed Ouaadi FRA 4 3 Nov 2002 13 2:08:59 12 Rod Dixon NZL 1 23 Oct 1983 14 2:09:04 13 Martin Lel KEN 1 5 Nov 2007 15 2:09:07 14 Abderrahim Goumri MAR 2 2 Nov 2008 16 2:09:08 15 Geoff Smith GBR 2 23 Oct 1983 17 2:09:12 16 Stefano Baldini ITA 5 3 Nov 2002 18 2:09:14 Joseph Chebet 1 7 Nov 1999 19 2:09:15 17 Meb Keflezighi USA 1 1 Nov 2009 20 2:09:16 Abderrahim Goumri 2 4 Nov 2007 21 2:09:19 18 Japhet Kosgei KEN 2 4 Nov 2001 22 2:09:20 19 Domingos Castro POR 2 7 Nov 1999 23 2:09:27 Joseph Chebet 2 2 Nov 1997 24 2:09:28 20 Salvador Garcia MEX 1 3 Nov 1991 25 2:09:28 21 Hendrick Ramaala RSA 1 7 Nov 2004 26 2:09:29 22 Alberto Salazar USA 1 24 Oct 1982 27 2:09:29 23 Willie Mtolo RSA 1 1 Nov 1992 28 2:09:30 24 Paul Tergat KEN 1 6 Nov 2005 29 2:09:31 Stefano Baldini 3 2 Nov 1997 30 2:09:31 Hendrick Ramaala 2 6 Nov 2005 31 2:09:32 25 Shem Kororia KEN 3 7 Nov 1999 32 2:09:33 26 Rodolfo Gomez MEX 2 24 Oct 1982 33 2:09:36 27 Giacomo
    [Show full text]
  • Does Advertising Deserve a Museum? Study And
    Revista de Comunicación Vivat Academia RevistaRevistaISSN: 1575-2844de de Comunicación Comunicación · DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.15178/va.2015.131.1-37 Vivat Vivat Academia Academia ISSN: ISSN: 1575-2844 1575-2844 Junio Diciembre2015Junio · Año 2015 XVIII 2011 Año · nº XVIIIAño 131· XIV pp. Nº131 1-37 Nº117 pp. 1-18 pp 131-163 RESEÑA/REPORTINVESTIGACIÓN/RESEARCH Received: 18/02/2015---Accepted: 20/04/2015---Published: 15/06/2015 CRÍTICAS DE CINE / FILM REVIEWS Octubre-Diciembre, 2011 DOES ADVERTISING DESERVE A MUSEUM? STUDY AND GLOBAL ANALYSIS OF MUSEUMS OF ADVERTISING Jesús Miguel Sáez-González1: Crítico de cine. Alcalá de Henares. España Consuelo Balado Albiol 1: Universitat Jaume I of Castellón. Spain. [email protected] [email protected] Octubre 2011 Eva Breva Franch: Universitat Jaume I of Castellón. Spain [email protected] ABSTRACT The changes occurring in both the design of museums from the 1970s, and advertising communications in recent decades have made the authors reflect on the absence of an international museum of advertising that has a physical space to showcase their collections and an area for study or research in this field. Thus, from the analysis of the importance of advertising for market economy and society, on the one hand, and how the new information and communication technologies have influenced the way of thinking about communication, on the other hand, the authors establish the museological lines where this hypothetical museum should focus from the study of the ELbibliography ÁRBOL DE about LA VIDA the subject. DE TERRENCE In a second MALICK phase they proceeded with a detailed analysis of physically based museum projects addressing the advertising field today.
    [Show full text]
  • Course Records Course Records
    Course records Course records ....................................................................................................................................................................................202 Course record split times .............................................................................................................................................................203 Course record progressions ........................................................................................................................................................204 Margins of victory .............................................................................................................................................................................206 Fastest finishers by place .............................................................................................................................................................208 Closest finishes ..................................................................................................................................................................................209 Fastest cumulative races ..............................................................................................................................................................210 World, national and American records set in Chicago ................................................................................................211 Top 10 American performances in Chicago .....................................................................................................................213
    [Show full text]
  • MEGAMIASTO TOKIO RAJMUND MYDEŁ 7 Miast Świata (UN World Urbanization Prospect), Wyróżniana Jest Ta Nowa Kategoria Wielkościo­ Wa Miejskich Form Osadniczych
    M EGAMI ASTO ТОКІО RAJMUND MYDEŁ Być małą kroplą w oceanie wiedzy, piękne marzenie Rajmund Mydeł M EGAMI ASTO ТОКІО RAJMUND MYDEŁ Kraków 2014 SPIS TREŚCI WPROWADZENIE............................................................................................................................................................ 7 1. PRZEDMIOT I CEL STUDIUM................................................................................................................................... 17 2 . KONCEPCJE PLANISTYCZNE ROZWOJU M EGAMI ASTA ORAZ PRZESTRZENNO-FUNKCJONALNE EFEKTY ICH REALIZACJI......................................................................................................................................... 29 3 . STRUKTURA WIELKOŚCIOWA MIAST ORAZ JEJ PRZESTRZENNE ZRÓŻNICOWANIE..........................lO l 4 . DEMOGRAFICZNO-SPOŁECZNY ORAZ FUNKCJONALNY OBRAZ M EGAMI ASTA I JEGO PRZESTRZENNA ZMIENNOŚĆ............................................................................................................... 121 5 . ROZWÓJ I PRZEMIANY PRZESTRZENNYCH UKŁADÓW RYNKU PRACY...................................................141 6. FUNKCJONOWANIE MEGAMIASTA ORAZ ZRÓŻNICOWANIE ŚRODKÓW TRANSPORTU W PRZEWOZACH PASAŻERSKICH.......................................................................................................................153 PODSUMOWANIE........................................................................................................................................................ 173 BIBLIOGRAFIA...............................................................................................................................................................177
    [Show full text]
  • 6 World-Marathon-Majors1.Pdf
    Table of contents World Marathon Majors World Marathon Majors: how it works ...............................................................................................................208 Scoring system .................................................................................................................................................................210 Series champions ............................................................................................................................................................211 Series schedule ................................................................................................................................................................213 2012-2013 Series results ..........................................................................................................................................214 2012-2013 Men’s leaderboard ...............................................................................................................................217 2012-2013 Women’s leaderboard ........................................................................................................................220 2013-2014 Men’s leaderboard ...............................................................................................................................223 2013-2014 Women’s leaderboard ........................................................................................................................225 Event histories ..................................................................................................................................................................227
    [Show full text]
  • [email protected] Media Relations Department, New York Road
    Contacts: Lauren Loeb | 212.423.2271 | [email protected] Media Relations Department, New York Road Runners Robin Monsky | 312.992.6630 | [email protected] Director, Media Relations, Bank of America Shamrock Shuffle 8K Two-Time World Marathon Majors Series Champion Liliya Shobukhova Gears Up for Olympics with Back-to-Back Races in WMM Cities Shobukhova Opens Her 2012 Season Next Month at the NYC Half and Chicago’s Bank of America Shamrock Shuffle 8K NEW YORK/CHICAGO, February 22, 2012 – Two-time World Marathon Majors series champion and three-time Bank of America Chicago Marathon winner Liliya Shobukhova of Russia will open her 2012 season at the NYC Half on Sunday, March 18, followed with a run at the Bank of America Shamrock Shuffle 8K in Chicago on Sunday, March 25, it was jointly announced today by NYRR president and CEO Mary Wittenberg and Bank of America Chicago Marathon and Shamrock Shuffle 8K Executive Race Director Carey Pinkowski. Shobukhova, 34, an early favorite for the Olympic Games Marathon in London this summer said of her spring trip to the U.S., "This Olympic year will be the most important of my career, so I am choosing all of my competitions carefully. The NYC Half will allow me to test my fitness and compete against some of the same runners I will face in the Olympic Marathon, while going to Chicago for the Bank of America Shamrock Shuffle 8K will allow me to connect with all of the great fans and runners there on a course that feels like home to me in the city where I have had so much success.
    [Show full text]
  • Chicago Year-By-Year
    YEAR-BY-YEAR CHICAGO MEDCHIIAC INFOAGO & YEFASTAR-BY-Y FACTSEAR TABLE OF CONTENTS YEAR-BY-YEAR HISTORY 2011 Champion and Runner-Up Split Times .................................... 126 2011 Top 25 Overall Finishers ....................................................... 127 2011 Top 10 Masters Finishers ..................................................... 128 2011 Top 5 Wheelchair Finishers ................................................... 129 Chicago Champions (1977-2011) ................................................... 130 Chicago Champions by Country ...................................................... 132 Masters Champions (1977-2011) .................................................. 134 Wheelchair Champions (1984-2011) .............................................. 136 Top 10 Overall Finishers (1977-2011) ............................................. 138 Historic Event Statistics ................................................................. 161 Historic Weather Conditions ........................................................... 162 Year-by-Year Race Summary............................................................ 164 125 2011 CHAMPION/RUNNER-UP SPLIT TIMES 2011 TOP 25 OVERALL FINISHERS 2011 CHAMPION AND RUNNER-UP SPLIT TIMES 2011 TOP 25 OVERALL FINISHERS MEN MEN Moses Mosop (KEN) Wesley Korir (KEN) # Name Age Country Time Distance Time (5K split) Min/Mile/5K Time Sec. Back 1. Moses Mosop ..................26 .........KEN .................................... 2:05:37 5K .................00:14:54 .....................04:47
    [Show full text]
  • The International Olympic Committee (IOC) OFFERS the FOLLOWING VIDEO NEWS RELEASE to ALL NEWS AGENCIES, BROADCASTERS and ALL ONLINE PLATFORMS FREE of CHARGE ​
    Story script and Shot log The International Olympic Committee (IOC) OFFERS THE FOLLOWING VIDEO NEWS RELEASE TO ALL NEWS AGENCIES, BROADCASTERS AND ALL ONLINE PLATFORMS FREE OF CHARGE ​ STORY HEADLINE: INTERNATIONAL OLYMPIC COMMITTEE’S OLYMPISM IN ACTION FORUM IN BUENOS AIRES DISCUSSES THE BATTLE TO COMBAT DOPING, CORRUPTION, MATCH FIXING AND ABUSE IN SPORT DATE: 5 October, 2018 ​ LOCATION: Buenos Aires, Argentina ​ LANGUAGE: English ​ Broadcast quality footage available at the IOC Newsroom: http://iocnewsroom.com ​ ​ STORY SCRIPT: Integrity in sport was at the heart of the first day of the International Olympic Committee’s (IOC) Olympism in Action Forum in Buenos Aires. The challenge of combating doping, corruption, match fixing and abuse were discussed by athletes, coaches and administrators as well as leaders of national government agencies. IOC President Thomas Bach wants the Forum to bring people from all walks of life together to express a wide range of views as part of the Olympic Agenda 2020, the strategic roadmap for the future of the Olympic Movement. Emphasising the Forum’s open approach, the battle to combat doping in sport brought together the World Anti-Doping Agency’s director of intelligence and investigations Gunter Younger alongside Benjamin Cohen, Director General of the newly created International Testing Agency (ITA), with the British cyclist David Millar, who was banned for two years in 2004 after admitting taking banned performance-enhancing drugs before becoming a prominent anti-doping campaigner. 1,600 delegates from all walks of life are attending the forum, which takes place in the Argentine capital ahead of the 3rd Summer Youth Olympic Games.
    [Show full text]
  • Aleksandr TRETIAKOV Born on 19 April 1985, Russian Federation, Athlete, Skeleton
    DECISION of the IOC Disciplinary Commission sitting in the following composition: Denis Oswald, Chairman Juan Antonio Samaranch Tony Estanguet in the proceedings against Aleksandr TRETIAKOV born on 19 April 1985, Russian Federation, Athlete, Skeleton (SML-022) SML-022 TABLE OF CONTENT I. FACTS ............................................................................................................................................. 4 II. APPLICABLE RULES ...................................................................................................................... 9 Ill. DISCUSSION ................................................................................................................................. 12 A. MISSION OF THE DISCIPLINARY COMMISSION ............................................................... 12 B. CONDUCT OF INDIVIDUAL PROCEEDINGS ...................................................................... 13 C. PROOF ................................................................................................................................... 13 D. THE EVIDENCE AT THE DISPOSAL OF THE DISCIPLINARY COMMISSION ................... 14 a. Evidence obtained from Prof. McLaren .......................................................................... 14 1. The Mclaren Report and the Affidavit from Prof. Mclaren .................................... 14 2. EDPs and Dossier of Evidence ............................................................................... 16 (i) Sochi Duchess List (EDP0055) ................................................................
    [Show full text]