“Energy, Electricity and Hydrogen” Thesaurus of Suggested Didactical Experiments
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
“Energy, Electricity and Hydrogen” Thesaurus of suggested didactical experiments Structure of experiments The proposed experiments constitute a list, from which teachers, according to their local educational needs/ possibilities may construct own scenarios. We suggest that chosen elements from this list are inserted into the preferred by teachers lesson scenarios. Therefore, the list does not contain “must-have” experiments, but an open directory. By the color we sign the level of difficulty and/or complexity and/or special safety requirements: green – simple (in our intent possible to experiment in the age 8-10 yrs), blue – intermediate (11-12 yrs), red – difficult (13-17 yrs), violet – expert (not only difficult, but principally expensive). Main contents We start from very simple experiments on mechanical energy that can be done on the elementary level. Then we discuss experiment in electrochemistry and electromagnetism (4 experiments on electrochemistry on elementary-school level are described separately, with worksheets). Alternative energies and fuel cell are discussed in details in separate documents, on the secondary level The experiments are organized to follow the “production” line of energy making a fuel-cell car move. LIST OF EXPERIMENTS 1. Energy, its forms and energy conversion These experiments aim to show that the energy cannot be “produced” but only transformed from one type to another: mechanical energy, electricity, heat. ● 1.1. Jumping balls: a heavier rubber ball (make a small cavity in the upper side) and a ping- pong ball. This is the simplest experiment that (from our didactical experience with children) spontaneously induces the idea of energy: children exclaim “the heavier ball transmitted the energy to the upper one”. The exact calculation, assuming that the lower mass M is M>>m where m is the mass of the upper ball shows that the upper ball will be projected to the high H= 9h where h is the height from which the two balls started. 1) Didactics: make the two ball fall from the same high and mark (we use a pupil as a height meter) the amplitude of the jump; then make the experiment with two balls twice (children concentrate spontaneously the attention on the upper ball) and the third time asking to observe the heavier ball. The explanation comes directly form children and immediately. ● 1.2. Wooden woodpecker To be found in many regional editions: will slide down, step-by-step, but first it must be risen to the top of the “trunck”. Careful observation shows that the woodpecker stops from time to time before a next step. But when it stops, the spring is bent and pushes the woodpecker back to the trunk. It allows a next step of sliding down. During this sliding down, the potential energy transforms in steps to the kinetic one, than the kinetic into the elastic (potential) energy of the spring, and then a next portion of the potential (gravitational) energy is consumed. At the and of the trunk the whole initial potential energy is transformed into the heat. Could the woodpecker climb up? Yes, if somebody delivers the energy, like in this climbing chimney cleaner (that requires a hand to pull the rope, that delivers, using the interplay between static and dynamic friction, portions of energy needed to climb step by step). ● 1.3. “Death” loop This is a “classical” school experiment that is usually used to explain the existence of the centrifugal (non-inertial) force that acts on the ball (or a motorbike rider in the circle) in the uppermost part of the loop. In practice, to solve the problem, the budget of energy must be used: assuming the radius of the loop R, in the highest point of the loop the potential energy is 2mgR and the kinetic energy must be at least mv2/2=mgR/2 in order to deliver the centrifugal force mv2/R balancing the gravity force mg. Therefore the initial potential energy must be 5mgR/2. The lowest initial altitude (in the case the engine of motorbike stops unexpectedly) must be 5R/2. Literature: dydaktyka.fizyka.umk.pl/zabawki1/files/mech/mech-en.html clean energy we understand the electric power stations (home, local, centralized) that do not require the use of nuclear nor gas/ coal fuels. 2. Electricity “production” By “electricity” production we understand different ways to obtain the separation of electrostatic charges (like in the triboeletric effect) and/or electrical currents. We show few examples, out of many possible. ● 2.1. “Electricity” by friction Electrostatic charges are easy to be shown: any piece of cloth and any piece of plastic (i.e. polymer) material should work. To detect one con, construct Volta’s electrometer, using a glass, an aluminium foil and a toothpick. Much more fun in the class we get if we use the electrically charged stick to detect if girl’s hair are clean: girl’s hair, especially natural blond, are usually thinner and longer, so it is easy to rise them by approaching with the charged stick. Not to make any harassment, we use our own (hairy) hand as an alternative detector of electrical charges on the plastic stick. ● 2.2. Triboelectric effect - intermediate Experiments with fur (or silk, plastic bag) pieces and glass/ Sulphur/ ebonite, plexiglass bars are present in every school. School textbooks usually say that glass is positively charged, while plastics have negative charge. This is not essential didactically. What would be useful is to show that both the ebonite bar and the piece of cloth gain net electric charges, like in the example with the silk scarf pulled out from a woolen coat. ● ● 2.3. Electrostatic generators It is useful as a social competence in experiments with the electrostatic charges to show sparks from electrostatic machines. According to the narrative didactics, before making the experiment we inform pupils that a spark 1 cm long corresponds to the voltage of 30 kV. We separate the electrodes by 3 cm, saying that if a spark occurs, the voltage created will be 100 keV. To make this value understandable for small children, we ask about the meaning of kilo-meter, and we make them check what is the voltage of their phone cells: “you understand now, that your phone close to this machine would be destroyed, do not you?” A simple voltmeter can be used to establish which electrode of the machine is positive and which negative, but the voltmeter must be connected to the machine before we start turning the disks. Due to the current flow through the voltmeter, the voltage read is low, not hundredths of kV but single volts. Wimhurst machine is a simple and robust equipment. It must be kept free from dust, dry and the combs collecting the charge must not touch the rings. 3. Volta’s piles Original Volta’s pile “glasses-like” (a bicchieri); photo from Como museum, concession by Comune di Como. Volta’s (or Galvani, as you like) pile, despite of more than two hundreds years (AD 1797) from its construction, is still the unique way of storing/ supplying the electric current in phones and portable computers. Lead batteries are in every car. And, in spite of the time elapsed, we are still far from quantitative understanding of its functioning. In a series of experiments, even if simple also quantitative, we show how to construct Volta’s piles from “almost” nothing. 3.1. First Volta’s pile The first Volta’s pile, described in his letter to xx in March 1798 was a pile (this is the origin of the name) of tin (Sn) and silver (Ag) coins. Every second pair was separated with a piece of cloth wetted by salty water. Coins currently used in EU (and another type used in Poland) are based on copper and copper-nickel alloys, so they are practically useless (to make Volta’s pile). Here, below, a photo of the pile made from old Polish coins, that were from aluminum and from copper/nickel. As you see, the coins get corroded after some time: these are chemical reaction (“corrosion”) that drive the electrical current. 3.1a. Volta’s tongue “volt-meter” Obviously, Volta did not measure the “voltage” in volts neither by a voltmeter. He used his own tong. This is not a very hygienic experiment, but worth mentioning. Volta noticed an “sour” taste when he positioned a pair of coins, Sn/Ag on his tongue, with Sn on the tongue’s tip. We know now that it was an acid taste since Sn+ ions go into the solution (i.e. into Volta’s saliva). It is easy to repeat this experiment with eurocent coins: a half of the 5 cents coin is wrapped into Al foil. Now the coin can be easily placed on the tongue (remember to extend it outside your mouth, like Einstein in his famous photo). ● 3.2 Lemon battery The core of Volta’s invention was the use of two different metals with a liquid (called electrolyte) between them. In the first version of a pile of coins (Ag/Sn), the electrolyte was salty water, in the second version with glasses (Cu/ Zn) the electrolyte was the diluted sulfuric acid. But the electrolyte can be any water-based solution – human hand, a cucumber or a lemon. ►Needed: - simple digital voltmeter, with cables and “crocodiles” - two pieces of metal (Al or Fe, Cu or brass, in the form of nails or triangles) - different fruits Ask pupils to bring from home any vegetable. - Divide pupils into groups of 3-4 and give an empty sheet of paper to every group. - Explain how to switch on the voltmeter, chose the “2V” range, and ask pupils to check if the voltmeter shows zero when two wires are short-cut (make them write the value read) - Ask pupils to measure (and record) the voltage in different fruits when the free ends of voltmeter wires are inserted - If more metals are available make them repeat measurement with different metals (and fruits).