F. Cocos I Malay
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
This is the published version Welsh,A 2015, Cocos Malay Language since integration with Australia, Shima: the international journal of research into island cultures, vol. 9, no. 1, pp. 53- 68. Available from Deakin Research Online http://hdl.handle.net/10536/DRO/DU:30072695 Reproduced with the kind permission of the copyright owner Copyright: 2015, Macquarie University Welsh: Cocos Malay language COCOS MALAY LANGUAGE SINCE INTEGRATION WITH AUSTRALIA ALISTAIR WELSH Deakin University <[email protected]> Abstract The Cocos (Keeling) Islands are a remote Australian territory in the Indian Ocean and are home to the Cocos Malay people, who have developed a distinct dialect. It was predicted over 30 years ago that the Cocos Malay language faced extinction, perhaps even within the timeframe of one generation. Two possible threats to the Cocos Malay language were identified. It was felt that English, as the language of power, may replace the Cocos Malay language. The other possibility was language convergence, where Cocos Malay would be subsumed by another, larger Malay dialect. With these issues in mind, I explore developments in the Cocos Malay language since the Islands’ full integration with Australia in 1984. Drawing from extensive ethnographic work and linguistic research into Cocos Malay I also refer to the work of other researchers to analyse how the Cocos Malay language has developed over the past 30 years, in a time of great social change. I argue that integration with Australia and attempts at assimilation have resulted in social dynamics where Cocos Malay language remains a defining marker of Cocos Malay identity positioning. In this social environment, Cocos Malay therefore remains viable and, despite language change, does not face immediate extinction. Keywords Cocos Malay, linguistic imperialism, language extinction, language convergence Introduction The Cocos (Keeling) Islands (henceforth simply referred to as the Cocos Islands) is an external territory of Australia located at 12.1 degrees south and 96.5 east - 900 kilometres south west of Christmas Island (Figure 1). Collectively the Cocos Islands and Christmas Island form the administrative entity of the Australian Indian Ocean Territories. The Cocos Islands fully integrated with Australia in 1984, following a United Nations’ supervised referendum. The ensuing 30 years has been a period of rapid and significant social, economic and political change for the Cocos Malay community; marked by an increase in disposable income for families and enhanced mobility of Cocos Malay people. The Clunies-Ross family ruled the Cocos Islands under the umbrella of various legal entities as part of the British Empire, including a period under Singaporean administration and under Australian sovereignty since 1955 (Clunies-Ross, 2009). Throughout these periods of different jurisdictions, the Cocos Malay community remained under the authority and, in practical terms, the responsibility of the Clunies- Ross regime. However, in the 1970s and early 1980s Australia came under increased ________________________________________________________ Shima: The International Journal of Research into Island Cultures Volume 9 Number 1 2015 - 53 - Welsh: Cocos Malay language international criticism for not appropriately exercising its sovereignty over its citizens and ensuring their rights to self-determination and access to basic human rights including education. It was against this contextual background that in 1984 the Cocos Malay community were offered an act of self-determination witnessed by the United Nations with three options: a) full integration with Australia; b) independence; or c) free association (ie maintaining the status quo under the Clunies-Ross regime) (Bunce, 1988). The vote resulted in full integration with Australia. Figure 1 – Christmas Island and the Cocos Islands and their location in the north east Indian Ocean (source: http://www.princeton.edu/main/news/archive/S38/13/46E21/ Despite high levels of unemployment on the Cocos Islands since integration, contrasted to recollections of some older Cocos community members of ‘full-employment’ in the Clunies-Ross era, the introduction of minimum wages and a range of welfare benefits mean that the disposable income of Cocos Malay families has increased substantially since integration with Australia (Welsh, 1999). Compulsory education has become the norm and has increased mobility and led to social change. Cocos Malay children are educated on the Australian mainland for their last two years of high school, ie years 11 and 12 (Welsh, 1999), with partial funding support to do so. In recent times an increasing proportion of Cocos Malay students have continued on to tertiary education. This has meant that young Cocos Islanders who have been schooled on the Australian mainland have tended to stay on the Australian mainland on a longer-term basis. These educational opportunities also have a socially divisive outcome. For Cocos Malay young people who complete a university education, there are few employment opportunities back in the islands (Welsh, 1999). This remains the case today. Moreover, young graduates, with little employment experience in their chosen profession, find it difficult to compete for so few sought-after professional positions on the Cocos Islands. Given that the current population of the Cocos Islands is only around 600 people, jobs are scarce, particularly in specialised professional fields. This means that young people who have moved to the Australian mainland often find it difficult to return to the islands on a permanent basis. ________________________________________________________ Shima: The International Journal of Research into Island Cultures Volume 9 Number 1 2015 - 54 - Welsh: Cocos Malay language The history of human settlement in the Cocos Islands is well documented from first settlement in 1826, on what were originally uninhabited islands. The group of first settlers represented a diverse ethnic mix and purportedly included people from Bali, Bima, Celebes, Madura, Sumbawa, Timor, Sumatra, Malacca, Penang, Batavia, Cerebon, Banjarmasin, Pontianak and Tasikmalaya (Bunce, 1988). In addition, convict and contract labourers from Java were brought in to the islands between 1837 and 1910 (Hunt, 1989). From first settlement, Malay was adopted as the main language of communication in the Cocos Islands’ community. The origins of Cocos Malay have been linked to “the trading Malay lingua franca of the East Indies” (Bunce, 1988: 43). The unique mix of Malay speakers in the Cocos Islands, including the British colonials, compounded by geographic isolation, enabled the fusion and consolidation of different linguistic elements to develop as a unique Malay dialect. This included the adoption of loan words from Javanese, Sundanese and English, lexical and morphological ‘distortion’ and the emergence of original lexical items. Arthur Keyser, an author and colonial resident in territories of what are now Malaysia, reflected on his visit to the Cocos Islands in 1896, observing that “their language, mixed with English and Javanese words, was gradually becoming an exclusively local dialect” (Keyser, 1922: 205). In more recent times, Cocos Malay has been recognised as a unique Malay dialect (Lapsley, 1983; Adelaar, 1996; Welsh, 2001) and as a Malay creole (Lewis, 2009; Soderberg, 2014). In terms of the Cocos Islands context today, Cocos Malay is not used as a koine (a language or dialect arising from contact between two or more groups with mutually intelligible varieties of the same language) since its speakers, who have grown up in the Cocos Islands, do not speak other Malay dialects, nor other languages aside from English. Moreover, Sundanese, Javanese and English languages, from which loan words are evident in Cocos Malay, are not mutually intelligible with Cocos Malay. However, it is possible that Cocos Malay functions as a koine in other Cocos Malay speech communities, such as those in Malaysia. Based on Soderberg’s (2014) research of Cocos Malay in Malaysia, it seems likely that Cocos Malay is used alongside other mutually intelligible Malay dialects. Since full integration with Australia in 1984, the Malay community on the Cocos Islands has had to respond to rapidly changing social, political and economic environments. The past three decades have also been a time of great technological change, characterised by communication technologies and enhanced human mobility. In the face of such significant change and trends of globalisation, it has been predicted that the Cocos Malay language faces the imminent threat of extinction. In recent years English-medium education has been introduced to the islands, and while the language is adapting to a rapidly changing socio- political environment, it is doubtful whether it will survive the present generation - given the size and the socio-linguistic vulnerability of the community. (Lapsley, 1983:12) It is against this contextual background that I seek to evaluate the predictions of Lapsley (1983) and Adelaar (1996) that Cocos Malay faces imminent extinction. In this article, I examine predictions of Cocos Malay being replaced with English, and of Cocos Malay converging with standard Malay. While discussion necessarily extends to other Cocos Malay speech communities, namely those on the Australian mainland, Singapore and Malaysia, my focus in this article is on Cocos Malay in the context of the Cocos Islands’ speech community. ________________________________________________________