Identity, Politics, and Ideology in Folk Music in Post-Brexit Scotland
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
1 “Each of Us Is Just a Little Microcosm of Scotland:” Identity, Politics, and Ideology in Folk Music in Post-Brexit Scotland A Thesis Presented to The Faculty of the Department of Sociology Colorado College In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Bachelor of Arts in Sociology Celia O’Brien November 2017 Emily Schneider 2 On my honor, I have neither given nor received unauthorized aid on this thesis. Celia O’Brien 3 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Thank you to Emily Schneider for her guidance, knowledge, and encouragement throughout this process, and for her patience as I fumbled my way through, sometimes while still jet-lagged. A special thanks to the Keller Family Venture Grant Fund at Colorado College, whose financial support enabled me to carry out this research. Thank you to all of my wonderful, talented, thoughtful interviewees; thank you for your craft and for opening up to me. I'm deeply indebted to everyone at Black Medicine Coffee Co. for the love, laughter, fuel and office space. Thanks also to beautiful family and friends for their love and support, even (especially) when I only (barely) made sense to myself. I would also like to thank Kathy Giuffre for helping me nurture the seeds of ideas that eventually blossomed into this thesis, for the endless wisdom, and for understanding everything I mean about home. This paper is dedicated to the incredible musicians I interviewed and listened to—singing, talking, playing, sometimes all at once—and who welcomed me into their world. 4 ABSTRACT The research presented in this paper seeks to understand whether political attitudes about the failed Scottish Independence Referendum in 2014, and Brexit in 2015, are manifested in contemporary folk music in Scotland. Building upon social identity and field theories, I examined how music serves to foster and negotiate national and political identities in this time of political turmoil. By conducting interviews and focus groups with 16 respondents, and through six sessions of participant observations, I investigated how musicians define notions of Scottish identity and authenticity regarding their and others’ folk music. I found that in general, musicians are not overtly political in their music, but the practice of “doing” folk music allows them to establish and validate their widespread left-wing, socially liberal ideologies. 5 A BRIEF HISTORY OF SCOTTISH POLITICS Scottish history involves a long thread of wars over, declarations of, and struggles for independence and self-sovereignty. The Declaration of Arbroath was signed in 1320, during the First War of Scottish Independence, to declare Scotland as its own free nation (Goring 2014). In 1707, the Union of the Scottish and English Parliaments formed the United Kingdom. This marked a turning point in Scottish history, a “political twinning…[which] remains a painful subject in certain quarters, and some nationalists still gnaw over its bones” (Goring 2014:111). The 18th century saw a series of failed attempts, known as the Jacobite Uprisings, to restore a Catholic (and Scottish), rather than Protestant English, king to the British throne. Over 200 years after the last of these rebellions, in the 1960s, the discovery of oil resources within Scottish territory helped fuel rapid economic development (Symon 1997). In 1967, the Scottish National Party (SNP) won a second seat in the English Parliament, showing that the party “would be a force to be reckoned with” (Goring 2014:380), thus demonstrating a growth in political growth. These developments fostered a new sense of Scottish national identity that was separate from England, although not strongly enough to pass the first proposed devolution referendum in 1979 (Symon 1997). In 1999, though, a Scottish Parliament was established, giving the nation the autonomy to control certain (arguably small-scale) areas, such as the education and legal systems (McCracken 2014). All of these events have contributed to a growing sense of self-confidence within Scotland; the most recent demonstration of which was the vote for Scottish independence in 2014. Despite promising (from the pro-Independence side) reports from polls leading up to the vote, Scotland voted “No,” 55 to 45 percent, to the question: “Should Scotland be an independent country?” The debate over independence was largely economical, but social and cultural issues 6 and differences also played a part. For example, McCracken (2014) mentions that David Cameron, the United Kingdom (U.K.) Prime Minister at the time, symbolized “the archetype of Imperialist privilege; something that is about as far removed from Scottish sensibilities as possible.” In this way, the effort to get out from under the Westminster government, so dominated by similar politicians, was an ideological concern as well as an economic one. In 2015, another dramatic vote took place, and Britain opted to leave the European Union. Nicola Sturgeon, the First Minister of Scotland and leader of the SNP, consequently demanded a new vote for Scottish independence because “Scotland must have a choice about [its] future. A choice between following the U.K. down the Brexit path, and becoming an independent country” (Cheyne 2017, quoting Sturgeon). However, in the past year, this call for another referendum has been put on hold until Brexit negotiations become clearer (Bews 2017). Thus, since the Union in 1707, Scotland has made several attempts to establish political autonomy, from restoring a Catholic king to the British throne, to aiming for full independence from the U.K. in 2014. Now, Scotland is at a liminal point in history, struggling with the Westminster government and the isolating economic, political and cultural ramifications Brexit will have. LITERATURE REVIEW National Identity and Scottish Nationalism As illustrated in the Introduction, Scotland’s political relationship to England has been contentious throughout history. As a result, its national identity has been partially constructed in relation (indeed opposition) to England. The history of this relationship has, for some, fuelled a desire to construct Scottish identity as distinct and separate from “the English,” because 7 “English” connotes domination and subjugation. Ian Telfer (1999), a Scottish musician from the British group Oysterband, for example, wrote that “you [can] define yourself in opposition to whatever bits you don’t like of the society you actually have to live in...We [Scots] are artists at this, past-masters. We like to define ourselves versus the English” (p. 75, emphasis added). Telfer’s statement demonstrates a phenomenon of social identity theory, whereby adopting and identifying with certain favorable qualities helps to paint oneself/one’s group as supposedly better than others (Tajfel and Turner 1979). This premise helps inform the research presented in this paper, which is concerned with the possible ways in which Scottish identity is being redefined and renegotiated in light of recent political struggles with England, specifically the Scottish Independence Referendum in 2014 and Brexit in 2015. Social Identity Theory and Belonging Social identity theory, developed by Tajfel and Turner (1979), seeks to explain how one’s membership in a group shapes one’s perception of self through the processes of social categorization, identification, and comparison (Tajfel and Turner 1979). They suggest that people’s sense of self-worth comes from their membership in groups; as a result, they ascribe positive definitions and qualities to their own group and negative ones to out-groups, to elevate their own group’s status. Michael Billig (1995) furthers this point by arguing that different identities become more or less salient in different contexts so that no individual is always consciously thinking about each identity all the time, a phenomenon he calls the “latency” of identity. In the research presented here, I seek to understand how folk music in Scotland helps to catalyze this salience. An “us and them” dichotomy ensues from people’s attempts to distinguish themselves and their group from non-members and out-groups. This relates to Bourdieu’s (1984) 8 field theory, because these attempts to distinguish oneself and one’s group is also a strategy to achieve dominance in a given field. Bourdieu theorizes that cultural fields involve a struggle among actors for legitimacy and power (Bourdieu 1984, Swartz 1997). Due to the nature of the constant struggle, all actors are positioned relationally to each other; when the position of one actor or group shifts, so do those of other actors. Thus, anyone’s position is never fixed or guaranteed, and all positions are interrelated. For some actors to be dominant in the field, there must be others with subordinate positions. Building on social identity and field theories, this study is concerned with how folk music, as a platform for expression of identity and politics, can also function as a platform for questions and discourses about Scottish identity and Scottish nationalism post-Referendum and post-Brexit. As Scotland struggles for political autonomy from the Westminster government, it is worth investigating if and how these political struggles and attitudes, and understandings of identity, are playing into Scottish folk music (the reason for choosing this lens will be discussed below). In other words, given the potential for homologies to exist between different fields, it is important to think of possible homologies between the political field and folk music field, whereby changes in one might reflect changes in the other (Bourdieu 1984, Swartz 1997, Symon 1997). One issue worth addressing, however, is the risk of essentializing what “Scottish” means, because it risks “[reproducing] notions of the ‘boundedness’ or ‘purity’ of territorial or national identities,” as Symon (1997) articulates. Posing questions about Scottish identity and “Scottishness” is contentious and problematic because it essentializes identity, and risks presuming a certain fixed, frozen definition. Rather, my research aims to understand and highlight whatever shifts in people’s definitions might be taking place, as consequences of 9 current political events, and through the lens of folk music.