DOCSLIB.ORG

Obama Hope Poster: a Copyright Problem

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Obama Hope Poster: a Copyright Problem Obama Hope Poster: A Copyright Problem Jeffrey Donnell MRDC 3104 894-8568 Spring, 2011 J Donnell / MechE 2110 Wired Magazine [1] The iconic poster that became popular during the 2008 election campaign. J Donnell / MechE 2110 The photograph from which the image was created. J Donnell / MechE 2110 Hoffmania.com [2] The New York Times [3] A comparison of the poster and the photo in the New York Times. J Donnell / MechE 2110 The website of Shepard Fairey, who created the poster. Fairy‟s statement on the Associated Press‟s lawsuit is linked on the right side. http://obeygiant.com/ J Donnell / MechE 2110 The website of Mannie Garcia, whose photo was used to make the poster. The HOPE link at the top of the page will take you to Garcia‟s comments on ownership of the image. http://web.mac.com/manniegarcia/iWeb/mannie%20 garcia/About%20Me.html J Donnell / MechE 2110 The Associated Press (AP) has sued Shepard Fairey, claiming that he illegally reproduced and sold an image that AP owns. The suit, filed in early 2009, has not been resolved. A related criminal investigation was opened in January 2010 and is ongoing. http://www.ap.org/ J Donnell / MechE 2110 04/16/2009 Statement: Statement from The Associated Press on Shepard Fairey Counterclaims Response The Associated Press is still in the process of reviewing Shepard Fairey's response to its Counterclaims, but it is very revealing that rather than present any evidence to justify his own obvious misappropriation of the AP‟s copyrighted work, he instead focuses on making collateral attacks on the AP, one of the oldest and largest news organizations in the world, regarding standard newsgathering activities. Even more disappointing is the fact that Mr. Fairey appears to have deliberately omitted from his filing information regarding the newsgathering context in which the various images were generated and in which they are used. We note that Mr. Fairey admits that he engaged in the hypocritical conduct discussed in the AP‟s Counterclaims, including using the work of others without obtaining a license while at the same time threatening others for using his own works. The Associated Press [4] J Donnell / MechE 2110 The Associated Press. (4-16-09). “Statement from The Associated Press 07/16/2009 Statement Statement from The Associated Press on Mannie Garcia's Employment AP clearly owns the copyright in the photograph as a work for hire. Mannie Garcia was a salaried employee from whom taxes were withheld and to whom overtime was paid, among many other documented indicators providing proof that he was a staff employee at the time the photo was taken in 2006. At the same time, the AP notes that Mr. Garcia shares AP's position that the photo used by Mr. Fairey is protected by copyright. Like AP, Mr. Garcia also disputes Shepard Fairey's assertion of the Fair Use Doctrine and claims infringement of copyright. Paul Colford Director of Media Relations The Associated Press [5] J Donnell / MechE 2110 The Associated Press. (7-16-09). “Statement from The Associated Press on The Moral of the Story • Record the authors and the owners of all information you obtain. • Cite and prepare a reference entry for each borrowed display and each quotation that you use in your reports or presentations. • If you do not cite a source and prepare a reference entry, you are claiming by default that you prepared and own the information. J Donnell / MechE 2110 References 1. J. Wortham, “‟Obey‟ Street Artist Churns out „Hope‟ for Obama.” Wired Magazine (electronic version), September 21, 2008. 2. Hoffmania.com. (1-23-09). “Photo of George Clooney with Barack Obama.” [online]. Available http://hoffmania.com/2009/01/page/2/ 3. The New York Times.com. (4-14-09). “Obama Poster Photographer Says He Owns the Picture.” [online]. Available http://artsbeat.blogs.nytimes.com/tag/barack-obama/page/2/ 4. The Associated Press. (4-16-09). “Statement from The Associated Press on Shepard Fairey Counterclaims.” [online]. Available: http://www.ap.org/pages/about/pressreleases/pr_041609a.html 5. The Associated Press. (7-16-09). “Statement from The Associated Press on Mannie Garcia's Employment.” [online]. Available: http://www.ap.org/pages/about/pressreleases/pr_071609a.html J Donnell / MechE 2110.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Anthony T. Falzone (Pro Hac Vice Pending) Julie A. Ahrens (JA0372)
    Anthony T. Falzone (pro hac vice pending) Julie A. Ahrens (JA0372) Stanford Law School Center for Internet and Society 559 Nathan Abbott Way Stanford, CA 94305 Telephone: (650) 736-9050 Facsimile: (650) 723-4426 Email: [email protected] Mark Lemley (pro hac vice pending) Joseph C. Gratz (pro hac vice pending) Durie Tangri Lemley Roberts & Kent, LLP 332 Pine Street, Suite 200 San Francisco, CA 94104 Telephone: (415) 362-6666 Email: [email protected] Attorneys for Plaintiffs UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK SHEPARD FAIREY and OBEY GIANT ART, INC., Case No.: Plaintiffs, COMPLAINT FOR -against- DECLARATORY JUDGMENT AND INJUNCTIVE RELIEF THE ASSOCIATED PRESS, Defendant. DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL Plaintiffs Shepard Fairey (“Fairey”) and Obey Giant Art, Inc. (“Obey Giant”) (collectively “Plaintiffs”), by and through their attorneys, bring this action and allege against Defendant The Associated Press (“AP”) as follows: NATURE OF THE ACTION AND RELIEF SOUGHT 1. This is a civil action for declaratory and injunctive relief to vindicate the rights of visual artist Shepard Fairey and Obey Giant in connection with the series of iconic works Fairey created to support the candidacy of President Barack Obama. Fairey’s work became a ubiquitous symbol of Obama’s historic presidential campaign and stood as powerful symbols of Obama’s grassroots support. 2. The AP has asserted that Fairey’s work – one piece of which now hangs in the Smithsonian Institution’s National Portrait Gallery in Washington D.C. – infringes the AP’s copyrights in a photograph that was apparently taken by photographer Mannie Garcia, which depicts Obama at a panel discussion at the National Press Club in April 2006 with actor George Clooney.
    [Show full text]
  • Dale M. Cendali Claudia Ray Brendan T. Kehoe KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP
    Dale M. Cendali Claudia Ray Brendan T. Kehoe KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP Citigroup Center 153 East 53rd Street 601 Lexington Avenue New York, New York 10022 Tel: (212) 446--4800 Fax: (212) 446-4900 dcendali [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] Attorneys for Defendant/, Counterclaim Plaintiff and Cross Claim Plaintiff/Defendant THE ASSOCIATED PRESS UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK SHEPARD FAIREY and OBEY GIANT ART, INC., Case No.: 09-1123 (AKH) Plaintiffs, ECF Case v. THE ASSOCIATED PRESS’S FIRST THE ASSOCIATED PRESS, AMENDED ANSWER, AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES AND COUNTERCLAIMS OF Defendant and DEFENDANT, THE ASSOCIATED PRESS Counterclaim Plaintiff, v. SHEPARD FAIREY, OBEY GIANT ART, INC., OBEY GIANT LLC and, STUDIO NUMBER ONE, INC., and ONE 3 TWO, INC. (d/b/a OBEY CLOTHING) Counterclaim Defendants. And MANNIE GARCIA, Defendant, Counterclaim Plaintiff and Cross Claim Plaintiff/Defendant, v. SHEPARD FAIREY AND OBEY GIANT ART, INC., Counterclaim Defendants, And THE ASSOCIATED PRESS, Cross Claim Plaintiff/Defendant. Defendant, The Associated Press (hereinafter “The AP”), by and through its attorneys, Kirkland & Ellis LLP, hereby answers the Amended Complaint of Plaintiffs Shepard Fairey (“Fairey”) and Obey Giant Art, Inc. (“Obey Inc.Giant Art”) (collectively, “Plaintiffs”), in this action, dated February 9,October 16, 2009, as follows: NATURE OF THE ACTION 1. Denies knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the allegations contained in ¶ 1 of the Complaint and therefore denies the same, except admits that Plaintiffs have asserted claims for declaratory and injunctive relief. 2. Denies the allegations contained in ¶ 2 of the Complaint, except admits that The AP has asserted that Plaintiffs have created derivative works that infringe The AP’s rights in and to one or more of its copyrighted works, and further admits that Plaintiffs have asserted claims for declaratory and injunctive relief which seek, among other things, a declaration that Plaintiffs have not infringed The AP’s copyrights.
    [Show full text]
  • Collection of the Center for the Study of Political Graphics
    http://oac.cdlib.org/findaid/ark:/13030/c8959k7m No online items Collection of the Center for the Study of Political Graphics Center for the Study of Political Graphics 3916 Sepulveda Blvd. Suite 103 Culver City, California 90230 (310) 397-3100 [email protected] http://www.politicalgraphics.org/ 2020 Collection of the Center for the See Acquisition Information 1 Study of Political Graphics Descriptive Summary Title: Collection of the Center for the Study of Political Graphics Dates: 1900- ; bulk 1960- Collection Number: See Acquisition Information Creator/Collector: Multiple creators Extent: 330 flat files Repository: Center for the Study of Political Graphics Culver City, California 90230 Abstract: The collection of the Center for the Study of Political Graphics (CSPG) contains over 90,000 domestic and international political posters and prints relating to historical and contemporary movements for social change. The finding aid represents the collection in its entirety. Language of Material: English Access The CSPG collection is open for research by appointment only during the Center's operating hours. Publication Rights CSPG does not hold copyright for any items in the collection. CSPG provides access to the materials for educational and research purposes only. Users are responsible for obtaining all necessary permissions for use. Preferred Citation [Identification of item], Collection of the Center for the Study of Political Graphics (CSPG). Acquisition Information CSPG acquires 3,000 to 5,000 items annually, primarily through donations. Each acquisition is assigned a unique acquisition number and is written on individual items before these are sorted and filed by topic. Scope and Content of Collection The collection represents diverse social and political movements.
    [Show full text]
  • Plagiarism Policy
    Plagiarism Policy A simple definition of plagiarism from the Merriam-Webster Dictionary is “to steal and pass off the ideas or words of another as one's own.” This concept can be applied to writing, art, and photography among other artistic mediums. This includes copyright infringement for other arts. Therefore, it applies to all submissions to Sister Cities International’s Young Artists and Authors Showcase. While we realize that many works of art draw on inspiration from others, every submission will be thoroughly evaluated for originality. Submissions based on photographs or other two-dimensional art that was not created by the submitting artist must include express written consent for use from the original creator of the art on which the submission was based. Any submissions determined to have plagiarized the work of others will be rejected. As a reference, below are high profile examples of alleged visual plagiarism that led to legal challenges in the U.S. Left: Art Rogers, Puppies, 1985. Right: Jeff Koons, String of Puppies, 1988 Source: “Copyright In The Visual Arts.” WordPress. Dec 2011. Web. September 3, 2015. https://cpyrightvisualarts.wordpress.com/2011/12/20/art- rogers-vs-jeff-koons/ Left: Associated Press photo of Barack Obama by Mannie Garcia. Right: Poster by Shepard Fairey Source: Kennedy, Randy. “Artist Sues The A.P. Over Obama Image.” The New York Times. 9 Feb 2009. Web. September 3, 2015 http://www.nytimes.com/2009/02/10/arts/design/10fair.html?_r=0. Any questions about plagiarism and the Young Artists and Authors Showcase can be directed to Jina Shim, Communications and Programs Coordinator, at [email protected].
    [Show full text]
  • American Studies Today New Research Agendas
    WINFRIED FLUCK ERIK REDLING SABINE SIEEKE HUBERT ZAPF (Eds.) American Studies Today New Research Agendas Universitatsverlag WINTER Heidelberg UDO J. HE BEL 'American' Pictures and (Trans-)National Iconographies: Mapping Interpictorial Clusters in American Studies 1 The iconic turn propagated with considerable fervor in the early 1990s and exerting widespread influence across the humanities in the two decades afterwards marked less of a watershed for American Studies. Visual representations of'America' and visual constructions of'Ameri- can' identities and US American ideologies had long been an integral part of the interdisciplinary cultural studies agenda and cultural history project of American Studies when Gottfried Boehm and W. J. T. Mitchell proclaimed their respective versions of what came to be known as the iconic or pictorial turn on both sides of the Atlantic. Alan Trachtenberg's magisterial study Reading American Photographs of 1989 with its still noteworthy subtitle Images as History as well as Gerhard Hoffmann's exhibition and scholarly catalog Indianische Kunst im 20. Jahrhundert of 1985 and also Thomas W. Gaehtgens' and Heinz Ickstadt's American Icons: Transatlantic Perspectives on Eighteenth- ami Nineteenth Century American Art of 1992 may serve as examples to illustrate that the discipline of American Studies has indeed paid atten- tion to American visual cultures since the myth-and-symbol school of the 1950s and 1960s. In her assessment of American fine arts from 1670 to 1980, Bettina Friedl claims that well into the 1980s American Studies did more for the study of American painting than Art History itself did for this field of American visual cultures.
    [Show full text]
  • University of Denver Sports and Entertainment Law Journal
    University of Denver Sports and Entertainment Law Journal COPYRIGHT LAW AND THE VISUAL ARTS: FAIREY V. AP Elizabeth Dauer* and Allison Rosen** I. Introduction Shepard Fairey is a prominent figure in the world of visual modern art known for his creation of controversial works of political and social commentary.1 To support Barack Obama‘s presidential campaign in 2008, Fairey created the ―Obama Hope‖ and ―Obama Progress‖ posters,2 which became widely recognizable throughout the historic campaign.3 While the posters generated a great deal of positive favor for Barack Obama‘s presidential candidacy, the effect of the posters on the artist who created them did not generate such a favorable result.4 Upon discovering that The Associated Press (―AP‖) owned the rights to the reference photograph used in the posters, the AP claimed that Fairey‘s posters infringed its copyright.5 Fairey maintains that the incorporation of the photograph into the posters constitutes a fair use and that the posters were not created in violation of any valid copyright held by the AP.6 This essay examines the status of the recent copyright infringement litigation in Shepard Fairey, et al. v. The Associated Press, and analyzes the issues in the context of the fair use factors enumerated in the Copyright Act of 1976 (―Copyright Act‖ or ―Act‖).7 Part II sets the stage by reviewing copyright law and its application to the visual arts. Part III then details the lawsuit‘s factual and procedural background. Finally, Part IV applies the four fair use factors to the case. * J.D.
    [Show full text]
  • 03 Conscious Hip-Hop, Change, and the Obama Era | American Studies Journal 11/29/14, 9:44 PM
    03 Conscious Hip-Hop, Change, and the Obama Era | American Studies Journal 11/29/14, 9:44 PM NUMBER 54 (2010) HIP-HOP, OBAMA 03 Conscious Hip-Hop, Change, and the Obama Era BY MURRAY FORMAN This article identifies a particular aspect of hip-hop’s range of cultural production – conscious rap – in order to isolate one of the more politicized discursive options available to youth in America and a site where critical perspectives on post-Civil Rights America have emerged most forcefully. It further suggests that Obama’s political rise corresponds with a new phase in hip-hop and has impacted the ways in which its creative artists frame and articulate issues of race, class, and identity. In 2002, media and hip-hop scholar Todd Boyd wrote, “we cannot live in the past forever. Civil rights had its day; now it is time to move out of the way” (Boyd, 2002: 152). Six years later, during the 2008 U.S. presidential election year, Double O (of the rap group Kidz in the Hall) declared, “I think hip-hop culture has helped a younger generation see race in a slightly different perspective” (Hale, 2008: 64). These statements, each uttered under different conditions and in separate contexts, ultimately address a transitional phase and a new emergent sensibility pertaining to cultural politics in the United States. For many, U.S. President Barack Obama’s 2008 campaign and subsequent election signal a decisive break from the Civil Rights era, providing a crucial moment in the transformation of the nation’s discourse around race, culture, and identity.
    [Show full text]
  • Press Galleries *
    PRESS GALLERIES * SENATE PRESS GALLERY The Capitol, Room S–316, phone 224–0241 www.dailypress.senate.gov Director.—Laura Lytle Senior Media Relations Coordinators: Amy H. Gross Kristyn K. Socknat Media Coordinators: Elizabeth B. Crowley John E. Mulligan III Samantha J. Yeider HOUSE PRESS GALLERY The Capitol, Room H–315, phone 225–3945 Superintendent.—Annie Tin Deputy Superintendent.—Justin J. Supon Assistant Superintendents: Ric Anderson Laura Reed Drew Cannon Molly Cain STANDING COMMITTEE OF CORRESPONDENTS Siobhan Hughes, Wall Street Journal, Chairwoman Peter Urban, Stephens Media Group, Secretary Colby Itkowitz, Washington Post Kate Hunter, Bloomberg News Emily Ethridge, CQ Roll Call RULES GOVERNING PRESS GALLERIES 1. Administration of the press galleries shall be vested in a Standing Committee of Cor- respondents elected by accredited members of the Galleries. The Committee shall consist of five persons elected to serve for terms of two years. Provided, however, that at the election in January 1951, the three candidates receiving the highest number of votes shall serve for two years and the remaining two for one year. Thereafter, three members shall be elected in odd-numbered years and two in even-numbered years. Elections shall be held in January. The Committee shall elect its own chairman and secretary. Vacancies on the Committee shall be filled by special election to be called by the Standing Committee. 2. Persons desiring admission to the press galleries of Congress shall make application in accordance with Rule VI of the House of Representatives, subject to the direction and control of the Speaker and Rule 33 of the Senate, which rules shall be interpreted and administered by the Standing Committee of Correspondents, subject to the review and an approval by the Senate Committee on Rules and Administration.
    [Show full text]
  • Dale M. Cendali Claudia Ray KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP
    Case 1:09-cv-01123-AKH Document 13 Filed 03/11/2009 Page 1 of 61 Dale M. Cendali Claudia Ray KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP Citigroup Center 153 East 53rd Street New York, New York 10022 Tel: (212) 446-4800 Fax: (212) 446-4900 [email protected] [email protected] Attorneys for Defendant/Counterclaim Plaintiff THE ASSOCIATED PRESS UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - x SHEPARD FAIREY and OBEY GIANT : ART, INC., : : Civil Action No.: 09-01123 (AKH) Plaintiffs, : : v. : ANSWER, AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES : AND COUNTERCLAIMS OF THE ASSOCIATED PRESS, : DEFENDANT, THE ASSOCIATED : PRESS Defendant and x Counterclaim Plaintiff, : : v. : : SHEPARD FAIREY, OBEY GIANT ART, : INC., OBEY GIANT LLC and STUDIO : NUMBER ONE, INC. : : Counterclaim Defendants. : - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - x Defendant, The Associated Press (hereinafter “The AP”), by and through its attorneys, Kirkland & Ellis LLP, hereby answers the Complaint of Plaintiffs Shepard Fairey (“Fairey”) and Obey Giant Art, Inc. (“Obey Inc.”) (collectively, “Plaintiffs”), in this action, dated February 9, 2009, as follows: Case 1:09-cv-01123-AKH Document 13 Filed 03/11/2009 Page 2 of 61 NATURE OF THE ACTION 1. Denies knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the allegations contained in ¶ 1 of the Complaint and therefore denies the same, except admits that Plaintiffs have asserted claims for declaratory and injunctive relief. 2. Denies the allegations contained in ¶ 2 of the Complaint, except admits that The AP has asserted that Plaintiffs have created derivative works that infringe The AP’s rights in and to one or more of its copyrighted works, and further admits that Plaintiffs have asserted claims for declaratory and injunctive relief which seek, among other things, a declaration that Plaintiffs have not infringed The AP’s copyrights.
    [Show full text]
  • In This Issue
    www.cjr.org July/August 2009 In This Issue There’s wide- spread agreement that for journalism to survive in the Inter- net age, newspapers will need to figure out With every issue, CJR produces a study guide for jour- how to turn Internet nalism students to delve into the areas we’ve covered, eyeballs into paying providing topics for classroom discussion and addi- customers — to “mon- tional activities to test the ideas put forward. etize,” as the buzzword has it, what so far has To get CJR into your students’ hands through low-cost been a market enthusias- subscriptions, check out the options at http://www.cjr. tic to read the news, but org/student_subscriptions/ and contact Dennis Giza at not to pay for it. [email protected]. This issue of CJR tackles the thorny issues 1. groundhog day (pp. 15–17): Health care cov- around making Web work pay. Alissa Quart looks erage has failed to heed the lessons of 1993’s debate. at the case of Obama poster artist Shepard Fairey, and whether he should have shared the wealth — a) Have all members of your class write down what or at least the credit — with The Associated Press they think is the difference between a single-payer freelancer whose photograph he appropriated. model, a public-plan option, and private insur- Peter Osnos calls on Google to ensure that the ance. What does this indicate about the quality of sites that generate news content, not just those news coverage? who aggregate it, get a fair share of revenues.
    [Show full text]
  • The Media Student's Book, Fifth Edition
    The Media Student’s Book The Media Student’s Book is a comprehensive introduction for students of media studies. It covers all the key topics and provides a detailed, lively and accessible guide to concepts and debates. Now in its fifth edition, this bestselling textbook has been thoroughly revised, reordered and updated, with many very recent examples and expanded coverage of the most important issues currently facing media studies. It is structured in three main parts, addressing key concepts, debates, and research skills, methods and resources. Individual chapters include: Approaching media texts • Narratives • Genres and other classifications • Representations • Globalisation • Ideologies and discourses • Media as business • ‘New media’ in a ‘new world’? • The future of television? • Regulation now • Debating advertising, branding and celebrity • News and its futures • Documentary and ‘reality’ debates • From ‘audience’ to ‘users’ • Research: skills and methods. Each chapter includes a range of examples to work with, sometimes as short case studies. They are also supported by separate, longer case studies which include: Slumdog Millionaire • Online access for film and music • CSI and crime fiction • Let the Right One In and The Orphanage • Images of migration • The Age of Stupid and climate change politics. The authors are experienced in writing, researching and teaching across different levels of undergraduate study, with an awareness of the needs of students. The book is specially designed to be easy and stimulating to use, with: •
    [Show full text]
  • Consumer Culture Theory, Nonverbal Communication, and Contemporary Politics: Considering Context and Embracing Complexity
    J Nonverbal Behav DOI 10.1007/s10919-010-0085-y COMMENTARY Consumer Culture Theory, Nonverbal Communication, and Contemporary Politics: Considering Context and Embracing Complexity Kristin J. Lieb • Dhavan V. Shah Ó Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2010 Abstract This commentary addresses Olivola and Todorov’s ‘‘Elected in 100 ms: Appearance-Based Trait Inferences and Voting’’ and considers its valuable contribution to the field of nonverbal communication. This work suggests that contemporary politics and voting behavior are so complex that they can be better understood outside of laboratory settings where the vital elements on culture and context come into play. By using consumer culture theory and other cultural theories of branding, this commentary evaluates elements of Barack Obama’s presidential run, and considers why his campaign resonated so well with voters in contemporary United States culture. Keywords Brand Á Brand management Á Political communication Á Consumer culture theory Á Person brands Á Nonverbal communication Á Cultural branding Á Context Á Culture Olivola and Todorov’s (2010) ‘‘Elected in 100 ms: Appearance-Based Trait Inferences and Voting’’, offers a valuable contribution to the field of nonverbal communication by suc- cinctly summarizing the work in this field to date, and advancing its application through new experiments using computer modeling. The findings in the works reinforce what political strategists have known for decades—arguably since the Kennedy/Nixon debate of 1960—that candidate appearance, visual cues, gestures, facial contortions, and speech patterns are all critical factors to be managed by professionals in campaigns (Cho et al. 2009). Since then, scholars have studied how political audiences make sense of candidates by attempting to measure the impact of specific factors (e.g., dimensions of appearance and voice) on estimations of likability and competence.
    [Show full text]