Chapter 18 Noise Guide
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
April 2017 Noise Guide CHAPTER 18 NOISE GUIDE 18.0 INTRODUCTION The problem of noise generated by highway traffic involves physical, physiological, and psychological factors that cause varying reactions by the public. Highway traffic noise should be considered in the location and design of roadways. This chapter is intended to help designers identify issues related to highway traffic noise, understand the applicable federal and state regulations and guidelines, analyze traffic noise for specific projects, and select and implement noise mitigation measures. From a project's inception, noise mitigation measures may need to be considered as a part of the project. As early in the process as possible, consult the appropriate environmental documentation, if available, to determine if mitigation commitments were made. Contact the Region Environmental Staff for assistance with these determinations and the appropriate regulatory requirements. This chapter contains a summary of basic concepts and supplements existing published material. If more detail is needed concerning any of the following specific subjects, consult the references provided at the end of this chapter. If existing regulation or guidance is revised, or if additional regulation or guidance is published after the date this chapter was published, the new material takes precedence. 18.1 NOISE FUNDAMENTALS Noise is defined as unwanted or excessive sound. Sound (or noise) levels are measured in units of decibels (dB), which are measured on a logarithmic scale which condenses a large range of several magnitudes of sound pressure levels. For the purposes of highway traffic, an “A-scale” weighting is applied to noise levels because the human ear does not perceive all sound frequencies equally. These are referred to as A-weighted decibels (dBA). Because the sound intensity of highway traffic is not constant, a descriptor is needed to describe the source in a steady-state condition. The most common descriptor, which is used for CDOT projects, is the hourly equivalent sound level (Leq(h)). For highway traffic noise analyses, noise 18-1 Noise Guide April 2017 levels are expressed in terms of hourly equivalent A-weighted decibels and expressed in this manner: dBA Leq(h). Since noise levels in the decibel scale are logarithmic, they cannot be added arithmetically. For example, adding two 70-decibel sources results in a noise level of 73 decibels. Any doubling of a noise source, such as doubling the volume of traffic on a roadway or moving the existing traffic twice as close to a neighborhood, increases the overall decibel level 3 decibels. Studies have shown that a 3-decibel change in noise levels is barely detectable by the human ear, even though the overall sound energy has doubled. It normally takes a 5-decibel change in noise levels to be perceptible to most people. A 10-decibel change in noise levels is normally perceived as either a doubling or a halving of the perceived “loudness” of noise levels. Frequency changes, however, may be detectable by people even if the overall decibel levels are unchanged. For highway projects, the noise level of interest is the worst-hour noise equivalent level. This is the time of day when noise levels are highest. It is used for comparison with impact criteria to determine noise impacts. It is also when the highest number of vehicles is traveling at the highest possible speed. This is not necessarily the peak travel hour or rush hour, because there may be periods of congestion when traffic tends to slow, resulting in lower noise levels. For highways that tend to be congested at peak hour, the worst-noise hour is the period either just before or just after peak hour. 18.2 NOISE REGULATIONS AND ANALYSIS REQUIREMENTS The regulations that govern highway traffic noise for Federal-aid projects are contained in Part 772 of Title 23 of the Code of Federal Regulations (23 CFR 772) (1). Regulation 23 CFR 772 describes methods that must be followed in the evaluation and mitigation of highway traffic noise in Federal-aid highway projects. The FHWA will not approve plans or specifications for any federally aided highway project unless the project includes noise abatement measures, if the measures have been deemed to be feasible and reasonable to adequately reduce noise impacts. When warranted, noise mitigation is to be considered as an integral component of the total project development process and incorporated as such. Projects that fall under 23 CFR 772 are classified as Type I, Type II or Type III. 18-2 April 2017 Noise Guide The project type will be determined in conjunction with a CDOT noise specialist. Type I definitions are in 23 CFR 772 and CDOT Noise Analysis and Abatement Guidelines (2). Projects that are or may be Type I include but are not limited to: Constructing a new road on a new location Adding a lane, auxiliary lane, or ramp Changing the elevation of the road or ramp Moving the road closer to receptors Adding a new or substantial alteration of a weigh station, rest stop, ride-share lot, or toll plaza Type II projects are defined as the construction of noise abatement on existing highways (“retrofit” projects) in absence of major highway construction. State funding has been unavailable for this program since 1999. A Type III project is any project that does not meet criteria for either a Type I or Type II project. Noise analyses are not required for these non-noise sensitive projects. Examples of Type III projects include resurfacing, bridge rehabilitation including bridge reconstruction with minor non-capacity widening, and most shoulder and maintenance projects. A noise analysis study is required for all Type I projects if noise sensitive properties (receptors) are present in the project study zone, which is defined as a 500-foot halo from the proposed edge of the traveled lane(s). A noise sensitive receptor is any location for which highway traffic noise may be detrimental to the outdoor enjoyment and functional use of the property. Noise sensitive receptors include residences, parks, hotels, schools, and noise-sensitive businesses such as recording studios. A complete list of receptor types is in Table 1 of 23 CFR 772 and Table 18-1 of this document. The purpose of a noise analysis is to identify receptors that are impacted by noise. Noise is determined at existing conditions and is projected for the project design year, which is usually 20 years in the future. As defined in the regulations, a traffic noise impact occurs when projected noise levels approach or exceed the Noise Abatement Criteria (NAC) or when the noise from projected traffic levels substantially exceeds the existing noise levels. NACs are noise thresholds in units of dBA and vary by land use category. A substantial increase in noise level is defined as being 10 dBA or more. 18-3 Noise Guide April 2017 An impact due to a substantial increase in noise is rarely encountered in situations other than the construction of a new highway on a new location. Table 18-1 identifies the NAC levels for different land use categories. Table 18-1: CDOT Noise Abatement Criteria for Receptor Activity Descriptions Activity Activity Evaluation Activity Description Category Leq(h)2 Location Lands on which serenity and quiet are of extraordinary significance and serve an important A 56 Exterior public need and where the preservation of those qualities is essential if the area is to continue to serve its intended purpose. B1 66 Exterior Residential Active sport areas, amphitheaters, auditoriums, campgrounds, cemeteries, day care centers, hospitals, libraries, medical facilities, parks, picnic areas, places of worship, playgrounds, public C1 66 Exterior meeting rooms, public or nonprofit institutional structures, radio studios, recording studios, recreational areas, Section 4(f) sites, schools, television studios, trails, and trail crossings. Auditoriums, day care centers, hospitals, libraries, medical facilities, places of worship, public meeting D 51 Interior rooms, public or nonprofit institutional structures, radio studios, recording studios, schools, and television studios. Hotels, motels, time-share resorts, vacation rental properties, offices, restaurants/bars, and other E1 71 Exterior developed lands, properties or activities not included in A-D or F. Agriculture, airports, bus yards, emergency services, industrial, logging, maintenance facilities, F NA NA manufacturing, mining, rail yards, retail facilities, ship yards, utilities (water resources, water treatment, electrical), and warehousing. Undeveloped lands that are not permitted for G NA NA development. 1 Includes undeveloped lands permitted for this activity category. 2 Hourly A-weighted sound level in dBA; reflects values that are 1 dBA less than 23 CFR 772 values 18-4 April 2017 Noise Guide The NAC values in Table 18-1 are based on speech communication interference. These noise levels are not legal standards or mitigation design goals, but are the levels for which mitigation must be considered. The levels shown reflect the CDOT approach criterion, which are 1 dBA less than FHWA levels. The most common land use activity category included in noise analyses is Category B, residences, which has a NAC of 66 dBA. Noise regulations require that any receptor determined to be impacted by noise, based on modeling, is entitled to mitigation consideration. Mitigation must be provided if it is found to be feasible and reasonable. The feasibility determination considers the physical constructability of the abatement measure. Factors include construction complexity, required area needed for foundations or equipment, and compatibility with utilities and drainage. Complex construction techniques require more time to install, more cost in labor and equipment, and may cost more to maintain. For a mitigation measure to be feasible, it must be able to be constructible to normal engineering standards to provide a perceivable noise reduction of at least 5 dBA at a minimum of one receptor. Walls cannot be more than 20 feet in height.