DOCSLIB.ORG

Fact Or Fantasy? by Reuven Hammer the Book of Esther Is the Most Entertaining Book in the Bible – Especially If You Like Satire and Black Humor

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Fact Or Fantasy? by Reuven Hammer the Book of Esther Is the Most Entertaining Book in the Bible – Especially If You Like Satire and Black Humor Esther – Fact or Fantasy? By Reuven Hammer The Book of Esther is the most entertaining book in the Bible – especially if you like satire and black humor. But it is also a very problematic work from many points of view. As history, it seems to have no factual basis. The book begins like a historical chronicle – “It happened in the days of Ahasuerus..” (1:1) and later states that this story about Mordecai is “recorded in the annals of the Kings of Media and Persia.” (10:2). That may be, but we have yet to see them there. Are we to believe that these events took place as written when there is no historical evidence of it? There is no record in Persian history of any of the Jewish characters in the book or even of Haman, nor of the incidents that are recorded. The book does show a real knowledge of Persian society and its court, however, so it must be assumed that it was written by someone who lived there but it is more likely a historical novel than a work of history. From a religious point of view Esther is also problematic. There is no mention of God, no mention of prayer, no concern with observance of Jewish ritual. What did Esther eat in the royal court? Where did she worship? There is no concern about Esther’s conduct including marrying out of the faith. Later rabbinic texts seek to make up for all that, but the book itself ignores these questions. Yet somehow we manage to forget all of this and simply enjoy the story. Perhaps that is what we are intended to do – not to take this too seriously, but to see it for what it is – a black farce, making fun of our enemies and allowing us to enjoy the fantasy that Jews always come out on top. Indeed you can actually read Esther as the Holocaust with a happy ending since Haman’s desire and the king’s decree was no less than “to destroy, massacre, and exterminate all the Jews, young and all, children and women…” (3:3). No Nazi could have demanded more. My teacher, H.L Ginsberg, believed that this was a book written to be read in order to explain a Persian carnival holiday, in which Jews happily participated. They adapted a pagan story of the triumph of the good gods Marduk and Ishtar over the evil god Human, turning it into a human story depicting the triumph of Jews over their Persian enemies. Persian Jews wanted to enjoy this carnival and so retold the story in a Jewish way – but since it accompanied a carnival, it was never intended to be taken too seriously. Esther is unique in the Bible in that it takes place totally in the diaspora and was written there as well. With the exception of a few verses mentioning the destruction, Zion plays no real role. From a Zionist point of view the story is therefor quite problematic. Why does it never suggest that they move back to the land of Israel, something that was perfectly possible? Some scholars read it as justifying life in the diaspora, teaching that Jews will always be able to overcome their local enemies, no matter how difficult. Look at what they did to Haman – and his sons! See how they manipulated the King – who was, not so incidentally, a bit of a fool. On the other hand, Esther can be interpreted in the opposite way. Perhaps it is saying, can you really rely on such events as a Jewish girl winning a beauty contest to insure Jewish safety? If you really believe that things can happen in this way to assure Jewish existence – let me sell you the Brooklyn Bridge at a good price. Life in the diaspora is dangerous. You cannot depend on the proverbial man on a white horse to come and save the situation at the crucial moment. Read that way Esther is Zionist in a subversive way – actually saying “don’t ever depend on such things for your safety. It may be a good story but real life is not like that.” Many people also object to the book because of its exuberant depiction of Jews slaughtering Persians in huge numbers, as found in chapters eight and nine. “”They disposed of their enemies, killing seventy- five thousand of their foes” ((9:16). It should be remembered, however, that this was not gratuitous killing, but Jews defending themselves against enemies who had been given royal permission to exterminate them. Unfortunately some - like Baruch Goldstein - took this as giving permission to slaughter non-Jews just because they are non-Jews and therefore potential enemies even when they have done nothing. He and others have used these chapters as a source giving permission to simply slay any one considered a potential enemy. The fact that people meet at his grave every year on Purim to read the Megillah is enough to warn us that it can be misinterpreted and used to justify murder even though that is not inherent in the book. In Esther it is made very clear that the Jews are not out for revenge or killing for its own sake but were simply defending themselves by fighting back against those who had been given kingly permission to eliminate each and every one of them. However we interpret the book of Esther, it is important that we make it clear to all – especially the young – that Judaism does not permit killing others for any reason except to defend ourselves and others from immediate danger. So by all means enjoy the reading of the Megillah however you interpret it, but never forget that it is a fantasy meant to entertain and to give us much needed relief from the troubles of life but it does not teach us either to love violence or to ignore danger when it exists. We all need to be able to relax and to laugh even when there are troubles. Purim gives us that opportunity and the Book of Esther – for all its problems – is perfect for that. Hag Purim Sameah. .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • A REWRITTEN BIBLICAL BOOK the So-Called Lucianic
    CHAPTER THIRTY-SEVEN THE ‘LUCIANIC’ TEXT OF THE CANONICAL AND APOCRYPHAL SECTIONS OF ESTHER: A REWRITTEN BIBLICAL BOOK The so-called Lucianic (L) text of Esther is contained in manuscripts 19 (Brooke-McLean: b’), 93 (e2), 108 (b), 319 (y), and part of 392 (see Hanhart, Esther, 15–16). In other biblical books the Lucianic text is joined by manuscripts 82, 127, 129. In Esther this group is traditionally called ‘Lucianic’ because in most other books it represents a ‘Lucianic’ text, even though the ‘Lucianic’ text of Esther and that of the other books have little in common in either vocabulary or translation technique.1 The same terminology is used here (the L text). Some scholars call this text A, as distinct from B which designates the LXX.2 Brooke-McLean3 and Hanhart, Esther print the LXX and L separately, just as Rahlfs, Septuaginta (1935) provided separate texts of A and B in Judges. Despite the separation between L and the LXX in these editions, the unique character of L in Esther was not sufficiently noted, possibly because Rahlfs, Septuaginta does not include any of its readings. Also HR 1 Scholars attempted in vain to detect the characteristic features of LXXLuc in Esther as well. For example, the Lucianic text is known for substituting words of the LXX with synonymous words, and a similar technique has been detected in Esther by Cook, “A Text,” 369–370. However, this criterion does not provide sufficient proof for labeling the L text of Esther ‘Lucianic,’ since the use of synonymous Greek words can be expected to occur in any two Greek translations of the same Hebrew text.
    [Show full text]
  • For Such a Time As This 1 Introduction
    For Such a Time as This (Esther 4:7-17) To me, this is a very personal and a very touching moment, because twenty-nine years ago when I first arrived at the United States I had never dreamed that one day I would be standing here to preach in a language that is not my mother tongue. I am very thankful for having this opportunity. And thank you for bearing with me. 1 Introduction The Book of Esther is a very peculiar book in the Bible. So eccentric is the book that there are many debates among Bible scholars on whether this book should have been included in the old testament in the first place. After all, the keyword “God” or “Lord” which should be of such paramount significance has never occurred even once in the entire writing, not to mention the absence of other spiritual activities such as “worshiping,” “praying,” or “offering.” It has been argued that the form of the story seems closer to that of a romance than a work of history, that the chronicle is a charming love story indeed, with exciting plots, but of few true spiritual values. Maybe those scholars do have their points which cannot easily be com- prehended by lay-persons such as you and me. But if we put ourselves in the story and think about it for a moment, then it is not difficult to dis- cover that it is precisely under such an environment of “Godlessness” that this book brings forth a powerful message. The message is this — Yes, darkness is around us! Yes, enemies are amassing and prevailing! Yes, the surroundings of us are full of dangers and evils.
    [Show full text]
  • THE KING of the BOOK of ESTHER Personal Bodyguard to Cyrus’ Son, Cambyses II
    the Persian army, as well as spear-bearer2 and THE KING OF THE BOOK OF ESTHER personal bodyguard to Cyrus’ son, Cambyses II. The Book of Esther begins with a great feast “in Cambyses had contracted the murder of his the 3rd year of the reign of Ahasuerus” (Esther brother, Smerdis, to secure the throne. Leaving 1:3). Although at one time or another nearly Patizithes in control of the government, he every monarch from Cyaxares (624–586 BC) to embarked on a campaign into Egypt and Artaxerxes III Ochus (358–338 BC) has been succeeded in conquering that empire in the fifth declared as the Medo-Persian ruler in question, year of his reign (525 BC). He then invaded in nearly all theological circles today it is Ethiopia, but the swamps, deserts, etc. frus- conceded almost beyond question that the man trated his attempts for its complete annexation. is Xerxes I of Thermopylae (486-465 BC). This identification was initially offered by Scaliger, (1) Achaemenes the first modern chronologer. (2) Teispes The proofs offered are: (1) a supposed congruity of the character of Ahasuerus with that of Xerxes as portrayed by Herodotus and other (7) Ariaramnes (3) Cyrus I classic writers and (2) a philological conjecture. These will be examined in that which follows, comparing secular data with Scripture. The (8) Arsames (4) Cambyses I secular will not be taken as judge but merely as a witness. If the secular fits, it will be incorpo- rated, but the framework will be based upon the Hystaspis (5) Cyrus II the Great Scriptures which, in context, are the only and final authority on the matter, not the reverse.
    [Show full text]
  • The Book of Esther Cambridge University Press Ware House
    '!'HE CAMBRIDGE BIBLE FOR SCHOOLS AND COLLEGES GENERAL EDITOR FOR THE OLD TESTAMENT:­ A. F. KIRKPATRICK, D.D. DEAN OF ELY THE BOOK OF ESTHER CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS WARE HOUSE, c. F. CLAY, MANAGER. U.onl:lon: FETTER LANE, E.C. 4illasgabJ: 50, WELLINGTON STREET. l.eip)ig: F. A BROCKHAUS, j4cb; liort.: G. P. PUTNAM'S SONS. Jilomua~ anb Qt:alcutta: MACMILLAN AND CO., Lw. [All Rights reserwd] THE BOOK OF ESTHER With Introduction and Notes by THE REY. A. w. STREANE, D.D. Fellow of Corpus Christi College, Cambridge CAMBRIDGE: at the University Press r907 Qt11mbtibgt: PRINTED BY JOHN CLAY, M.A. AT THE UNIVERSITY PRESS. PREFACE BY THE GENERAL EDITOR FOR THE OLD TESTAMENT. THE present General Editor for the Old Testament in the Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges desires to say that, in accordance with the policy of his predecessor the Bishop of Worcester, he does not hold himself responsible for the particular interpreta­ tions adopted or for the opinions expressed by the editors of the several Books, nor has he endeavoured to bring them into agreement with one another. It is inevitable that there should be differences of opinion in regard to many questions of criticism and interpretation, and it seems best that these differences should find free expression in different volumes. He has endeavoured to secure, as far as possible, that the general scope and character of the series should be observed, and that views which have ·a reasonable claim to consideration should not be ignored, but he has felt it best that the final responsibility should, in general, rest with the individual contributors.
    [Show full text]
  • Hanukkah and Purim: Similar Yet Different
    Mon 7, 14, 21, 28 Nov 2016 / 6, 13, 20, 27 Heshvan 5777 B”H Dr Maurice M. Mizrahi Course for Jewish Community Center of Northern Virginia Hanukkah and Purim: Similar yet Different Introduction -Hanukkah and Purim, the next two holidays, are not in Torah: Both are rabbinic. -Torah only has Rosh Hashanah, Yom Kippur, and the three pilgrimage festivals – Pessah, Shavuot and Sukkot. -Both colorful – stay in mind of kids. -Both celebrate Jewish victory over persecution. -Both miraculous: We recite Al HaNissim on both. -Both so important rabbis turned their observance into post-Torah (rabbinic) commandments. YET: -The story of Purim has a book in the Bible (Esther), a tractate in the Talmud (Megillah) and a volume in the Midrash (Esther Rabbah). Hanukkah has none of them. It rates only a few mentions in Talmud [Shabbat 21a-24a], as an appendage to a discussion of what wicks and oils one can use for Shabbat lights. -The Book of Esther does not mention God, yet is in the Bible; the Books of Maccabees do, yet are not in the Bible. -The story of Purim is not known outside the Bible, yet is in the Bible. The events of Hanukkah are known outside the Bible, yet are not in the Bible. -Hallel (psalms of praise for God) recited on Hanukkah, but not Purim. -Hanukkah began with the physical (armed rebellion) and ended with the spiritual (rededication of the Temple). Purim began with the spiritual (prayer and fasting) and ended with the physical (armed resistance to killers). -On Purim, persecutors wanted to kill ALL the Jews.
    [Show full text]
  • ANOINTING OIL DYNAMICS LTD Training Platform Mobile: 1-868-334-AODL / 345-AOIL H.E
    ANOINTING OIL DYNAMICS LTD Training Platform Mobile: 1-868-334-AODL / 345-AOIL H.E. Dr. Isaac Shadrack (CDKA, DCPC) 1-868-683-9883/394-9029 Menorah Castle, Debe e-mail: [email protected] TRINIDAD, West Indies [email protected] Website www.anointingoildynamics.com By Isaac Shadrack (Dip Theo, BA, MA, DD, PhD.) (Ps 119:98-100) Book of Esther Introduction and Title—The story of Esther’s life fits between chapters 6 and 7 of Ezra, between the first return led by Zerubbabel and the second return led by Ezra. It provides the only biblical portrait of the vast majority of Jews who choose to remain in Persia rather than return to Palestine after the Exile. God’s hand of providence and protection on behalf of His people is evident throughout the book, though His name does not appear once. Haman’s plot brings grave danger to the Jews and is countered by the courage of beautiful Esther and the counsel of her wise cousin Mordecai, resulting in a great deliverance. The Feast of Purim becomes an annual reminder of God’s faithfulness on behalf of His people. Esther’s Hebrew name was Hadassah, “myrtle” (2:7), but her Persian name Ester was derived from the Persian word for “star” (Stara). The Greek title for this book is Esther and the Latin title is Hester. Author—While the author’s identity is not indicated in the text, the evident knowledge of Persian etiquette and customs, the palace in Susa, and details of the events in the reign of Ahasuerus indicate that the author lived in Persia during this period.
    [Show full text]
  • The Rest of the Chapters of the Book of Esther, Which Are Found Neither in the Hebrew, Nor in the Chaldee
    Additions to Esther 10:4 1 Additions to Esther 10:13 THE REST OF THE CHAPTERS OF THE BOOK OF ESTHER, WHICH ARE FOUND NEITHER IN THE HEBREW, NOR IN THE CHALDEE. 10 PART OF THE TENTH CHAPTER AFTER THE GREEK. 4 Then Mardocheus said, These things are of God. 5 For I remember the dream * which I saw concerning these matters, and nothing thereof hath failed. 6 As for the little fountain that became a river, and there was light, and the sun, and much water, the river is Esther, whom the king married, and made queen: 7 and the two dragons are I and Aman: 8 and the nations are those that were assembled to destroy the name of the Jews: 9 and my nation, this is Israel, which cried to God, and were saved: for the Lord hath saved his people, and the Lord hath delivered us from all these evils, and God hath wrought signs and great wonders, which have not been done among the nations. 10 Therefore hath he made two lots, one for the people of God, and another for all the nations. 11 And these two lots came at the hour, and time, and day of judgement, before God among all the nations. 12 So God remembered his people, and justified his inheritance. 13 Therefore these days shall be unto them in the month Adar, the fourteenth and fifteenth day of the month, with an assembly, and joy, and with gladness before God, throughout the generations for ever among his people Israel. * 10:5 See ch.
    [Show full text]
  • The Information Structure of the Book of Esther in the Septuagint by Ken
    The information structure of the book of Esther in the Septuagint by Ken Chan A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR of PHILOSOPHY at the SOUTH AFRICAN THEOLOGICAL SEMINARY in October 2010 PROMOTERS: Dr Kevin Smith and Dr Frank Jabini The opinions expressed in this dissertation do not necessarily reflect the views of the South African Theological Seminary. DECLARATION I hereby acknowledge that the work contained in this dissertation is my own original work and has not previously in its entirety or in part been submitted to any academic institution for degree purposes. _________________________________ Ken Chan October 2010 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I thank my wife who encouraged me throughout the writing of this dissertation. Thanks to Dr Kevin Smith, who trusted me and invited me to go further. He is a good writer, and he taught me what it means to write. Thanks to Dr Frank Jabini for giving me valuable input as my second supervisor. Thanks to my external examiners for contributing their valuable time to review my work. Thanks to all the authors whom I cited (whether it was for or against) because scholarship is a collective effort. Thanks to the financial support of all my supporters during this study period. Thanks to my mission board, which allowed me to take this time to deepen my understanding of God’s word. Thanks to the Chinese University of Hong Kong Library for letting me use their excellent facilities. To God alone be the glory. Ken Chan October 2010 ABSTRACT A comparison of studies on the book of Esther shows that there are diverse opinions of what constitutes (a) the purpose, and (b) the discourse boundaries of the book.
    [Show full text]
  • Additions to Esther
    University of Nebraska - Lincoln DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln Faculty Publications, Classics and Religious Studies Department Classics and Religious Studies January 2000 Additions to Esther Sidnie White Crawford University of Nebraska-Lincoln, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/classicsfacpub Part of the Classics Commons Crawford, Sidnie White, "Additions to Esther" (2000). Faculty Publications, Classics and Religious Studies Department. 53. https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/classicsfacpub/53 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Classics and Religious Studies at DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. It has been accepted for inclusion in Faculty Publications, Classics and Religious Studies Department by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. The purpose of the Additions in the Septuagint Esther is straightforward. Masoretic text Esther is notorious, both to- day and in the past, for its lack of religious language, particu- Additions to Esther larly its omission of any mention of God. The Additions sup- ply this lack, containing prayers and a prophetic dream, and giving credit for the salvation of the Jews entirely to God. Fur- ther, the Additions heighten the dramatic interest of the story he book of Esther is unique in the Old Testament for by emphasizing the emotions of the characters. T having three distinct literary editions. Most familiar is Addition A contains a prophetic dream of the chief male that of the Masoretic text (MT), 10 chapters in Hebrew found character, Mordecai. In the dream, Mordecai sees two drag- in all Hebrew Bibles and most English translations.
    [Show full text]
  • A 10-Day Esther Bible Study This Study Guide on the Book of Esther Was Written by Thomas Klock of Harvest Christian Fellowship in 2005
    Finding your purpose A 10-Day Esther Bible study This study guide on the book of Esther was written by Thomas Klock of Harvest Christian Fellowship in 2005. It was shared with Crosswalk.com in 2008. Introduction to the Book of Esther During the seventy years the Jews suffered their Babylonian exile, God raised up several people to faithfully guide and direct His fallen people back to Himself. Among these were Zerubbabel, Ezra, Nehemiah, and a young woman named Esther. The actions and examples of these four people are worthy to be included in the Hall of Faith of Hebrews 11, yet none of them were. In fact, the only one of these four even mentioned in the New Testament is Zerubbabel, who led the initial return of some of the Jews to their homeland. Ezra became the spiritual leader of the people, and he and Nehemiah led the reconstruction of the city and the temple, and the revival of their lives to once again be who God called them to be. Yet none of this would have been possible apart from the courageous stand and intervention of the young woman Esther, who found herself in a unique place of influence with the King. The examples of Esther and her cousin Mordecai can teach us much, as can other principles we can draw from their experiences, and help us to make a difference for God in our world. The Book of Esther The Book of Esther is unique. It reads much like a novelette, and its story is as gripping as any novel one would read today.
    [Show full text]
  • LESSON 1 – the BOOK of ESTHER MINI-STUDY Esther Is Crowned; Jewish Destruction Planned DAYS 1 & 2 – ESTHER (NAB A:1-17; 1:1-22) (RSV 11:1 – 12:6; 1:1-22) 1
    LESSON 1 – THE BOOK OF ESTHER MINI-STUDY Esther is Crowned; Jewish Destruction Planned DAYS 1 & 2 – ESTHER (NAB A:1-17; 1:1-22) (RSV 11:1 – 12:6; 1:1-22) 1. a. Who was Mordecai and how did God choose to communicate with him? b. From Sirach 34:1-7, why is discernment important in interpreting dreams? c. How do today’s verses describe Mordecai’s process of discernment? 2. What plot did Mordecai discover and what was his reward for saving the king? (This is a preview of what happens later in the book of Esther.) 3. Chapter one opens with two feasts lasting over three months. What seems to be the king’s motive for hosting these banquets? 4. a. Why did the king want the queen brought into his presence? b. Why do you think the queen refused to comply with the king’s request? c. List some ways women are “displayed” in our culture today. (See CCC 2523) 5. a. How did the king react to the queen’s refusal? b. Why do you think he reacted in this way? 6. a. What recommendation did the king’s advisors give him to deal with the queen and what was their reasoning? b. Your friend comes to you complaining and angry at his/her spouse. What response by you would help to: • Tear down the marriage? • Build up the marriage? c. Contrast the officials’ recommendation with Paul’s exhortation in Ephesians 5:21-33. 7. The king’s advisors were more interested in winning his favor than in doing the right thing.
    [Show full text]
  • ESTHER and JUDITH: CONTRASTS in CHARACTER Sidnie White Crawford
    University of Nebraska - Lincoln DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln Sidnie White Crawford Publications Classics and Religious Studies 2003 ESTHER AND JUDITH: CONTRASTS IN CHARACTER Sidnie White Crawford Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/crawfordpubs This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Classics and Religious Studies at DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. It has been accepted for inclusion in Sidnie White Crawford Publications by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. ESTHER AND JUDITH: CONTRASTS IN CHARACTER Sidnie White Crawford The books of Esther and Judith are often paired with one another. For example, in the arrangement of the books of the Septuagint the book of Judith follows Esther. In the comments of Church Fathers such as Clement of Rome, Clement of Alexandria, Athanasius of Alexandria and Augus­ tine, as well as in modern commentaries, the books of Esther and Judith are often grouped together, compared and contrasted. This pairing occurs even in the world of art, for example in the work of the Renaissance painter Artemesia Gentileschi, who uses both women as subjects. The reason behind this pairing is clear: both are books which take their name from their female heroine, and in both books it is the Jewish heroine who saves her peop Ie from imminent destruction at the hands of the Gentiles by her courage and resourcefulness. The book of Esther is part of the canon of the Hebrew Bible/Old Testament, in which it is part of the Writings or Ketubim. It tells the story of a young Jewish orphan named Esther and her cousin and guardian Mor­ decai, who are residents of the Persian capital of Susa.
    [Show full text]