HAROLD MEISLER U. S. Geological Survey, 100 North Cameron St., Harrisburg, Pa
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
HAROLD MEISLER U. S. Geological Survey, 100 North Cameron St., Harrisburg, Pa. Origin of Erosional Surfaces in the Lebanon Valley, Pennsylvania Abstract: Summit elevations in the Lebanon creeks—in which streams and interfluvial areas Valley, part of the Great Valley, range from 440 were in a state of erosional equilibrium. The land to 720 feet above msl (mean sea level). This range surface in equilibrium with the ancestral Quit- cannot be accounted for adequately by the pene- tapahilla Creek lies at a higher elevation than plain concept. Although accordant summits, the adjacent land surfaces that were in equilibrium chief evidence for peneplains, occur over large with Swatara Creek. areas, summits are not accordant between adjacent The land surface on the carbonate rocks, which areas within the valley. is in the ancestral Quittapahilla Creek system, lies The Lebanon Valley is underlain in the south by at a lower elevation than shale within the same carbonate rocks and in the north by shale. The system, but it commonly lies at a higher elevation major stream valley in the carbonate area is now than shale in adjacent parts of the Swatara Creek partly occupied by segments of two streams, but system. at one time it was the location of one major stream Accordance of summits is the result of uniform —the ancestral Quittapahilla Creek—which was erosion of uniform rocks in basins whose discharge beheaded by a tributary to Swatara Creek. points are at the same elevation. Lack of accordant Landforms of the Lebanon Valley are probably summits on uniform rocks is the result of erosion the result of erosion within two separate stream in basins whose discharge points differ in elevation. systems—Swatara and ancestral Quittapahilla CONTENTS Introduction . 1071 Geomorphic history 1080 Purpose and scope . 1071 Conclusions 1082 Area location . 1072 References cited 1082 Historical background . 1072 Methods of investigation . 1073 Figure Acknowledgments . 1073 1. Map of southeastern Pennsylvania showing lo- Geologic features . 1073 cation of Lebanon and Great valleys . 1072 Erosional features . 1073 2. Map of Lebanon Valley showing geomorphic Description . 1073 subdivisions and drainage pattern .... 1074 General statement . 1073 3. Topographic profiles across Lebanon Valley 1075 Shale areas 1, 2, and 3 . 1075 4. Hypsometric curves of areas within Lebanon Shale area 4 . 1076 Valley 1077 Carbonate area . 1076 5. Stages in development of drainage pattern in Hypsometric curves . 1076 Lebanon Valley 1081 Origin . 1076 General statement . 1076 Table Peneplain concept . 1077 1. Elevations of shale areas 1075 Erosional-equilibrium concepts . 1078 2. Elevations of carbonate area 1076 INTRODUCTION bonate rocks on the south and the shale on the north sides of the valley. The difference in ele- Purpose and Scope vation is commonly attributed to one of two Classical interpretations of the geomorphol- causes: (1) the existence of two peneplains—the ogy of the Lebanon Valley have been concerned Harrisburg peneplain, which developed on chiefly with describing real or supposed pene- shale, and the younger and lower Somerville plain levels within the valley and explaining peneplain, which developed on limestone, or the difference in elevation between the car- (2) the existence of only one peneplain, the Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 73, p. 1071-1082, 5 figs., September 1962 1071 Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/gsabulletin/article-pdf/73/9/1071/3442172/i0016-7606-73-9-1071.pdf by guest on 28 September 2021 1072 HAROLD MEISLER-EROSION SURFACES, LEBANON VALLEY, PA. Harrisburg, which was lowered differentially on physiographic province in Pennsylvania, few the soluble limestone. detailed studies have been made of the Lebanon The author believes that peneplains never Valley. Papers on the Lebanon Valley have developed in the Lebanon Valley. The major been concerned chiefly with the identification geomorphic features of the valley are inherited of peneplains and the levels of accordant ele- from a time before the capture by Swatara vations. Creek of Quittapahilla Creek when the streams Campbell (1903, p. 287) thought that the and interfluves were in equilibrium in each of meanders of Swatara Creek indicated a wide- these two basins. There is no evidence that the spread peneplain developed on the shale in the carbonate rocks have been eroded significantly Great Valley near Harrisburg. Presumably this lower than the shale. surface was younger than the Schooley pene- plain and more extensive than the Somerville Area Location peneplain. He named it the Harrisburg pene- The Lebanon Valley is defined in this report plain. In the Lebanon Valley it ranges from 500 as the part of the Great Valley in southeastern to 600 feet above msl. Campbell (p. 283-28 EXPLANATION Great Valley Lebanon valley Figure 1. Map of southeastern Pennsylvania showing location of Lebanon and Great valleys Pennsylvania that lies within the drainage area also thought a lower peneplain, the Somerville, of Swatara Creek. It includes most of the drain- was developed on limestone near the major age area of the Susquehanna River in the Great streams at an elevation of 400 feet and stated Valley east of the Susquehanna River (Fig. 1). that in the Lebanon Valley the Somerville plain The Lebanon Valley is bounded on the north was slightly developed along Swatara Creek. by Blue Mountain, a ridge formed by the re- Knopf (1924, p. 658) recognized remnants of sistant Tuscarora Sandstone of Silurian age, and two erosion surfaces on the Martinsburg Shale on the south by a series of hills formed by of Ordovician age north and east of Harrisburg. Triassic conglomerate and diabase. The valley One of these, at 520 feet above msl, is the Har- is approximately 30 miles long. Its width ranges risburg peneplain. The other, consisting of from 14 miles near Lebanon to 9 miles near isolated monadnocks at 660 feet, she called the Hummelstown. Sunbury peneplain. The lowlands below the Harrisburg peneplain were called the Lancaster Historical Background subcycle rather than the Somerville peneplain, Although a great deal has been written about because the Somerville includes several different the geomorphology of the Valley and Ridge surfaces (Knopf, 1924). Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/gsabulletin/article-pdf/73/9/1071/3442172/i0016-7606-73-9-1071.pdf by guest on 28 September 2021 INTRODUCTION 1073 Hickok (1933, p. 114) believed that the the topographic maps and the elevations of over Martinsburg Shale is slightly more resistant to 2000 points were interpolated, from 20-foot erosion than the carbonate rocks so that contour lines, to the nearest 10 feet. erosion surfaces generally occur at lower eleva- tions on the carbonate rocks than on the shale. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Three extensively developed erosion surfaces Appreciation is expressed to Mr. John T. are preserved on the Martinsburg Shale in the Hack of the U. S. Geological Survey and Mr. Lebanon Valley, at 500, 550, and 600 feet Alan R. Geyer of the Pennsylvania Geological above msl. A few monadnocks at 660 and 700 Survey for critical reading of the manuscript. feet suggest additional older erosion surfaces. Other surfaces developed on the Martinsburg GEOLOGIC FEATURES (Hickok, p. 115) are terraces at 360, 400, and The southern part of the Lebanon Valley is 450 feet above msl. underlain by alternating beds of Cambrian and Ashley (1935, p. 1398) maintained that the Ordovician limestone and dolomite, and the present topographic surface in the Appalachian northern part is underlain by the Martinsburg region reflects a single old peneplain (Schooley Shale of Ordovician age. The Martinsburg con- peneplain) that has been differentially lowered. sists chiefly of shale, but it contains minor Ver Steeg (1942), in answer to Ashley, sug- amounts of limestone, sandstone, andesite lava, gested that the widespread, broad, flatfish and diabase. remnants of the Harrisburg peneplain could not The rocks in the valley strike generally east- have been so excellently preserved if the sur- northeastward, and progressively younger for- face had been greatly lowered as Ashley claimed. mations crop out northward. The oldest and Bethune (1948, p. 17) stated that the summits southernmost band of rocks consists of lime- underlain by Martinsburg Shale represent stone and dolomite of the Conococheaque lowered traces of the Schooley peneplain. Limestone of Late Cambrian age. The Beek- Fenneman (1938, p. 234) thought that in the mantown Group of Ordovician age, consisting Lebanon Valley the surface on the Martinsburg of limestone and dolomite, crops out north of Shale was 100 feet above that of the limestone. the Conococheaque. Cropping out northward He believed there was at least one peneplain in from the Beekmantown Group, in order of de- the valley, as indicated by the level of the shale creasing age, are the Annville, Myerstown, and hilltops, but acknowledged that the lower sur- Hershcy Limestones of Prouty (1959) of face on the limestone was commonly consid- Middle Ordovician age, and the Martinsburg ered by some writers to be a later (Somerville) Shale of Late Ordovician age. peneplain. Because the sequence of formations is over- Macar (1955, p. 259) conceded that the for- turned, individual beds generally dip to the mation of several different levels on the shale south, and the older formations overlie the may possibly have been caused by differential younger ones. These rocks appear to be part of lowering of a single surface. However, he indi- the overturned south limb of a recumbent cated that this hypothesis would not be ap- synclinorium (Gray and others, 1958). plicable on a large scale and was convinced that there were more levels than the Somerville and EROSIONAL FEATURES Harrisburg peneplains. He cited levels at 400- 440, 500-520, and 600 feet above msl as ex- Description amples. General statement. The Lebanon Valley has been divided for the purpose of study and Methods of Investigation analysis into six areas called shale areas 1, 2, 3, The geology of the area was determined 4a, and 4b, and the carbonate area (Fig.