DOCSLIB.ORG

The Anti-Self-Help Project: Existential Suffering in Neonihilism Patric Plesa a Dissertation Submitted to the Faculty of Graduat

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Anti-Self-Help Project: Existential Suffering in Neonihilism Patric Plesa a Dissertation Submitted to the Faculty of Graduat THE ANTI-SELF-HELP PROJECT: EXISTENTIAL SUFFERING IN NEONIHILISM PATRIC PLESA A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED TO THE FACULTY OF GRADUATE STUDIES IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY GRADUATE PROGRAM IN PSYCHOLOGY YORK UNIVERSITY TORONTO, ONTARIO April 2020 © Patric Plesa, 2020 ii ABSTRACT The Anti-Self-Help Project is foremost a critique of neoliberalism, but more specifically, a reassessment of the neoliberal self-help industry. Relying on a Nietzschean/Foucauldian genealogical reassessment, the focus is on the neoliberal self-help industry and its subjectifying power in shaping identity, particularly through the commodification of existential constructs such as freedom, authenticity, angst, and alienation as sites of meaning-making. These existential constructs are also reassessed with a focus on intersectionality to decolonize, reinterpret, and propose multifarious ways to create meaning, co-construct subjectivity, and consider the conditions for the possibility of liberation from oppression for systemically marginalized groups. Meaninglessness is also reconceptualized here as a coping-mechanism in response to the pressures of neoliberalism, theorized as the combination of suffering and humour (or tragicomedy) that I have called neonihilism, which I historically situate in a lineage of nihilism in Western consciousness. Solidarity and collective action are then integrated as a descriptive model for re- envisioning the possibilities for existential constructs to become intersectional sites of meaning- making and understanding subjectivity, which deliberately contests the individualized and universalizing approach of the neoliberal self-help industry and further creates the possibility for overcoming neonihilism. iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to thank everyone involved with the History, Theory, and Critical Studies in Psychology Department, particularly the faculty, adjunct faculty, and my cohort for helping me grow intellectually and more importantly, ethically. I am especially indebted to the kindness and patience of my supervisor, Thomas Teo, and my friend and colleague, Shayna Fox Lee, not nearly as much for what I have learned from them as for what they have helped me unlearn. This project would have been impossible without their support. Thank you! iv TABLE OF CONTENTS Abstract……………………………………………………………………………………ii Acknowledgements……………………………………………………………………….iii Table of Contents…………………………………………………………………………iv Introduction………………………………………………………………………………..1 Chapter Sections…………………………………………………………...............5 Contextualization…………………………...……………………………..............8 Methodology………………………………………….…………………..............11 What I mean by Self-Help………………………………………………………...11 The Self-Help Industry at the Neoliberal turn: Inscriptions on Subjectivity…...………...14 Enter Neoliberalism: Exit Liberation……………………….…………….............19 What of Subjectivity in the Post-neoliberal World?………………………………29 Neoliberalism’s Broken Promises: A Conclusion………………...………………39 v Reassessing Existential Constructs and Subjectivity: Old Views on a New World………44 Freedom, Authenticity, Angst, and Alienation: An Origin Story…………………47 Do we still have Freedom, Authenticity, Angst, and Alienation?: A Reassessment…………………………………………………………………..54 What’s left to Reassess: A Conclusion…………………………..……………….73 Neonihilism: A Neoliberal Tragicomedy…………………………….……......................78 The Tragicomedy in Neonihilism…………………………………………….......82 The Meaning of Meaninglessness……..…………………………………………90 Neonihilism………………………………………………………………………102 Post-Neonihilism?: A Conclusion……….……………………………………….117 The Anti-Self-Help Project: A Reassessment of Self, Freedom, Authenticity, Angst, and Alienation…………………………………………………….……...........................122 Identity and the Real Self: Fictions of a Prediscursive You……………...………133 Determinism and the Freedom to Construct a Self in Neoliberalism…................148 Authenticity in Intersectional Bodies…………………………………………….154 Angst and Alienation in Intersectional Bodies…………………………………...171 vi A Reminder about Undecidability: A Conclusion………………………………..179 Conclusion…………………………………………...….....…………………………..…184 References…………………………………………………………………………...……189 1 INTRODUCTION The Anti-Self-Help Project is a work of the psychological humanities that include philosophy, art, media, current affairs, autoethnography, and pop culture to understand psychological matters (see also Teo, 2017). I deliberately focus on understanding1 over knowledge production throughout this work as a Foucauldian-inspired methodology, which aims to interrogate what have historically come to be held as truths rather than an attempt to produce or vindicate truths. Foucault (1977/1980) is skeptical of Truth2 (and knowledge3) because it is created and sustained in social environments under the influence of power relations that are formed by institutions and then upheld by their authoritative power (e.g., science has long held that biological sex is dichotomous and this is now being challenged, see Montañez, 2017). This makes Truth powerful and dangerous, especially if that Truth is laden with historical errors that maintain oppressive power relations with individuals based on their “race,” class, gender, sex, or sexuality. Part of this work is then a resistance to oppression through understanding. This project comes about as an exercise in interdisciplinary understanding with the aim of exceeding the confines of a body of knowledge itself by liberating ourselves4 from the power- knowledge relation through understanding (see Foucault, 1982). I follow Foucault (1975/1995) here in conceptualizing power-knowledge relations as fields of knowledge, often institutional, that create, support, and sustain, power relations between and among individuals and groups in delimiting their possibilities through the endorsement of knowledge about identity, gender, bodies, 1 I italicize theoretical constructs throughout to disambiguate them from the general use of the terms. 2 Capital “T” Truth indicates a type of truth sustained by institutional power, which is the aim of Foucault’s (1977/1980) critique. 3 Foucault (1977/1980) treats knowledge as the institutional body of work that sustains Truth. 4 For disambiguation, throughout this project any use of plural terms like “we,” “us,” “ourselves,” “our,” or the like are meant to be taken in the generalized sense. Singular uses of “I,” “me,” “my,” or “myself” and the like refer to the author unless otherwise specified. 2 psychology, and biology, among other things that affect behaviour and subjectivity. What understanding then aims at is a genealogical interrogation of ideas that have gained the authoritative aura of Truth and inscribed themselves in our subjectivity. What genealogical refers to is a Foucauldian method developed from Nietzsche’s (1987/1969) genealogy where ideas are studied as sociocultural practices arising in context and having a historical lineage—as opposed to the assumption that ideas have universal foundations (see Foucault, 1977/1980). For Foucault (1977/1980) knowledge itself is dangerous, whereas understanding liberates us from the power- knowledge relations through an analysis of the conditions for truth and knowledge and a reassessment of those conditions that segregate, marginalize, and oppress. My aim is to reassess bodies of knowledge, ideas, politics, and sociohistorical relations as they pertain to subjectification—the process by which people become subject to available discourses or institutional powers, and how these shape their possibilities and identities (see, Foucault, 1982). Within this reassessment, I focus on neoliberalism as a primary power-knowledge relation as it gives rise to a commodified version of self-help. Neoliberalism here is treated first in its historical context as an economic policy (see Harvey, 2005); however, the focus is particularly on how the imaginary (see Sartre, 1940/2010; Taylor, 2007) of neoliberalism as an ideology becomes embedded in our ways of thinking and doing; in other words, how neoliberalism becomes a subjectifying power with institutional bodies of knowledge stemming from economic policy and branching out into institutional practices in general (see Brown, 2015). Next, I talk about neoliberal ideology as it occupies the self-help industry, by which I mean particular texts (and practices) focused on self-improvement, self-governance, resilience, self-reliance, and other technologies of the self (see McGee, 2005). 3 Many of the neoliberal technologies of the self, found in self-help literature, were influenced and sustained by a body of knowledge produced by positive psychology. Here I refer to the inception of the field of positive psychology by Martin Seligman (1942-) and Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi (1934-), and their bodies of work on character strength, resilience, flow, and self-actualization, along with other techniques aimed at self-improvement (see, Seligman, 1999; Seligman & Csikszentmihalyi, 2000). With the support of positive psychology, self-help in neoliberalism has become exceedingly popular and influential. I want to interrogate the intersections of neoliberalism, positive psychology, and the self-help industry, as a potential genealogical framework for the subjectifying discourses available to us today. Using a Foucauldian methodology of understanding this power-knowledge relation, I hope to discuss conditions for the possibility of liberation from the constrictions placed by the self-help industry on subjectivity. Simultaneously,
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Quining Qualia
    Dennett, Daniel C. (1988) Quining Qualia. In: Marcel, A. & Bisiach, E. (eds.) Consciousness in Modern Science, Oxford University Press. Quining Qualia in A. Marcel and E. Bisiach, eds, Consciousness in Modern Science, Oxford University Press 1988. Reprinted in W. Lycan, ed., Mind and Cognition: A Reader, MIT Press, 1990, A. Goldman, ed. Readings in Philosophy and Cognitive Science, MIT Press, 1993. 1. Corralling the Quicksilver "Qualia" is an unfamiliar term for something that could not be more familiar to each of us: the ways things seem to us. As is so often the case with philosophical jargon, it is easier to give examples than to give a definition of the term. Look at a glass of milk at sunset; the way it looks to you--the particular, personal, subjective visual quality of the glass of milk is the quale of your visual experience at the moment. The way the milk tastes to you then is another, gustatory quale, and how it sounds to you as you swallow is an auditory quale; These various "properties of conscious experience" are prime examples of qualia. Nothing, it seems, could you know more intimately than your own qualia; let the entire universe be some vast illusion, some mere figment of Descartes' evil demon, and yet what the figment is made of (for you) will be the qualia of your hallucinatory experiences. Descartes claimed to doubt everything that could be doubted, but he never doubted that his conscious experiences had qualia, the properties by which he knew or apprehended them. The verb "to quine" is even more esoteric.
    [Show full text]
  • Privileged Access and Qualia
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by European Scientific Journal (European Scientific Institute) European Scientific Journal December 2015 edition vol.11, No.35 ISSN: 1857 – 7881 (Print) e - ISSN 1857- 7431 PRIVILEGED ACCESS AND QUALIA Thomas W. Smythe Retired Associate Professor, North Carolina Central University Abstract In this paper I shall examine some recent literature that purports to show that sensations or qualia are not real psychological phenomena, and that we do not have privileged access to our psychological states. In particular, I shall criticize some work by Daniel C. Dennett, who has argued against the existence of qualia and privileged access to the mental. I will maintain that Dennett has not made a convincing case for eliminating qualia, and has not shown that we do not have privileged access to psychological phenomena from a first-person point of view. Keywords: Qualia, Privileged Access, Self-Warranting Knowledge Introduction I will defend the view that certain criticisms of what has been called self-justifying or self-warranting knowledge of our psychological states have not succeeded. I will do this by arguing that attempts by Dennett and others to undermine self-justifying knowledge are unsuccessful. I begin by examining a paper by Dennett where he attempts to eliminate qualia. In a notable paper called ”Quining Qualia,” Dennett explains that he uses the verb ‘to quine’ in honor of W. V. O. Quine. It means to deny resolutely the existence or importance of something seemingly real and significant, for example, the soul. Quining qualia means saying there is no such thing as qualia.
    [Show full text]
  • To Download The
    FREE EXAM Complete Physical Exam Included New Clients Only Must present coupon. Offers cannot be combined Wellness Plans Extended Hours Multiple Locations www.forevervets.com4 x 2” ad Your Community Voice for 50 Years PONTEYour Community Voice VED for 50 YearsRA RRecorecorPONTE VEDRA dderer entertainment EEXXTRATRA! ! Featuring TV listings, streaming information, sports schedules, puzzles and more! December 3 - 9, 2020 Sample sale: INSIDE: Offering: 1/2 off Hydrafacials Venus Legacy What’s new on • Treatments Netflix, Hulu & • BOTOX Call for details Amazon Prime • DYSPORT Pages 3, 17 & 22 • RF Microneedling • Body Contouring • B12 Complex • Lipolean Injections • Colorscience Products • Alastin Skincare Judge him if you must: Bryan Cranston Get Skinny with it! (904) 999-0977 plays a troubled ‘Your Honor’ www.SkinnyJax.comwww.SkinnyJax.com Bryan Cranston stars in the Showtime drama series “Your Honor,” premiering Sunday. 1361 13th Ave., Ste.1 x140 5” ad Jacksonville Beach NowTOP 7 is REASONS a great timeTO LIST to YOUR HOMEIt will WITH provide KATHLEEN your home: FLORYAN List Your Home for Sale • YOUComplimentary ALWAYS coverage RECEIVE: while the home is listed 1) MY UNDIVIDED ATTENTION – • An edge in the local market Kathleen Floryan LIST IT becauseno delegating buyers toprefer a “team to purchase member” a Broker Associate home2) A that FREE a HOMEseller stands SELLER behind WARRANTY • whileReduced Listed post-sale for Sale liability with [email protected] UNDER CONTRACT - DAY 1 ListSecure® 904-687-5146 WITH ME! 3) A FREE IN-HOME STAGING https://www.kathleenfloryan.exprealty.com PROFESSIONAL Evaluation BK3167010 I will provide you a FREE https://expressoffers.com/exp/kathleen-floryan 4) ACCESS to my Preferred Professional America’s Preferred Services List Ask me how to get cash offers on your home! 5) AHome 75 Point SELLERS Warranty CHECKLIST for for Preparing Your Home for Sale 6) ALWAYSyour Professionalhome when Photography we put– 3D, Drone, Floor Plans & More 7) Ait Comprehensive on the market.
    [Show full text]
  • Maquetación 1 04/08/14 10:23 Página 47
    Secuencias, 38 (p. 47-64):Maquetación 1 04/08/14 10:23 Página 47 EL ESPEJO TELEVISIVO DE CLAUDE. ESTÉTICA, CIENCIA Y FICCIÓN EN BLACK MIRROR Claude’s Television Mirror. Aesthetic, Science and Fiction in Black Mirror LAURA PoUSAª CES Felipe Segundo - UCM RESUMEN A través del estudio de la primera temporada de la serie televisiva Black Mirror (Charlie Brooker / Zeppotron, 2011-) exploramos una tipología de ficción contemporánea que, desde su particular e identificable definición británica, crece en modos y se expande convirtiéndose en un nuevo referente de creación audiovisual internacional. Asimilados los límites dramáticos y estéticos de la era del drama y de la post-televisión, y superada la vinculación cine / videoarte, televisión / publicidad, Black Mirror adopta una perspectiva cultural del progreso científico y tecnológico que determina su drama. El análisis específico de sus tres dispares capítulos –«The National Anthem», «Fifteen Million Merits» y «The Entire History of You»– nos llevará por un camino comparativo con el objetivo de identificar su valor narrativo y su aportación artística, desde una metafórica vinculación conceptual con el espejo oscuro y el clasicismo pictórico de Claude Lorrain. Palabras clave: Black Mirror, ciencia, ficción, drama, televisión, pantallas, realidad virtual, futuro, «The National Anthem», «Fifteen Million Merits», «The Entire History of You». ABSTRACT Through the study of the first season of the TV series Black Mirror (Charlie Brooker / Zep- potron, 2011-) we explore a typology of contemporary fiction that develops from its particular and identifiably British definition into a new referent for international audiovisual creations. Assuming both the dramatic and aesthetic boundaries of the era of drama and of post-televi- sion, and the established connections between film / video-art, television / publicity, the plot of Black Mirror is determined by its adoption of a culturally-specific perspective on scientific and technological progress.
    [Show full text]
  • Ligotti, Pizzolatto, and True Detective's Terrestrial Horror
    e Interdisciplinary Journal of Popular Culture and Pedagogy More Than Simple Plagiarism: Ligotti, Pizzolatto, and True Detective’s Terrestrial Horror Jonathan Elmore Ph.D. Savannah State University Savannah, Georgia, USA [email protected] ABSTRACT Of course, True Detective is neither a philosopher’s bedtime story nor supernatural horror, and yet there remains a productive affinity between Ligotti’s work and the HBO series. Where Ligotti provides substantial portions of the hallmark character’s identity and dialogue, True Detective puts Ligotti’s thought experiment to far more practical uses than does Ligotti himself. By intertwining hurricanes and flooding alongside industry and pollution into the background and negative space of the setting, the series implicates the urgent material reality of climate change and environmental collapse into the setting: “all of this is going to be under water in thirty years” (“Long Bright Dark”). In doing so, the series employs Southern gothic conventions to look forward rather than backward in time. Rather than the decay and degeneration of the landscape as reflective of the past, such squalor points forward to a time, rapidly approaching, when the setting will itself be swallowed by the sea. Hence, True Detective enacts a more practical approach to Ligotti’s horror, one I’m calling terrestrial horror. Keywords: True Detective, Terrestrial Horror, Thomas Ligotti, Pessimism, Ecocriticism, Cosmic Horror 26 Volume 4, Issue 1 More Than Simple Plagiarism It is no secret that Nic Pizzolatto, the writer of True Detective, “borrowed” sections of Thomas Ligotti’s The Conspiracy Against the Human Race. Whether this use of Ligotti’s text constitutes plagiarism or merely allusion caused a minor furor in the media during the first season.
    [Show full text]
  • Black Mirror, Un Espejo Oscuro De Nuestro Aquí Y Ahora
    Revista de Culturas y Literaturas Comparadas, volumen 10, diciembre 2020. ISSN: 2591-3883 Nuevas subjetividades, continuidades y rupturas en las tendencias distópicas en el siglo XXI: Black Mirror, un espejo oscuro de nuestro aquí y ahora Valeria Engert, Eugenia Marra y María Luz Revelli [email protected] Universidad Nacional de Río Cuarto Córdoba, Argentina RESUMEN Las obras distópicas forman una larga tradición de continuidades, con sus oscuros universos que escenifican futuros de pesadilla en los que protagonistas infelices se ven atrapados en sistemas de poder extremadamente agobiantes. Dichos universos ficcionales se erigen como espacios fundamentales de exploración profunda de los grandes cambios sociales y políticos del devenir del hombre. Desde la transformación industrial y el impacto del mundo fabril a los grandes cambios tecnológicos del siglo XXI, cada época ha soñado sus propios mundos utópicos y distópicos. Con el cambio de milenio, la revolución 2.0 ha marcado una nueva era que impacta en la manera de vernos, ver al otro y ver el mundo. La serie británica Black Mirror problematiza las nuevas subjetividades, exteriorizadas, influenciadas por el uso de dispositivos digitales (Sibilia 1999, 2008, 2012) y hace de la reflexión en torno a la cuestión hombre-tecnología un oscuro espejo donde mirarnos, en nuestro aquí y ahora. Palabras clave: distopía- nuevas subjetividades del siglo XXI- Black Mirror ABSTRACT Dystopian works have a long-standing tradition in our culture. Their gloomy universes are persistent scenarios for the nightmarish stories they tell, where unhappy protagonists are caught in extremely suffocating power systems. Such fictional worlds stand as fundamental domains to explore the greatest social and political changes experienced by men.
    [Show full text]
  • Review of "Intuition Pumps and Other Tools for Thinking"
    Essays in Philosophy ISSN 1526-0569 Volume 18, Issue 2 (2017) Book Review Intuition Pumps and Other Tools for Thinking Ian O’Loughlin Pacific University Intuition Pumps and Other Tools for Thinking Daniel C. Dennett, New York: W.W. Norton, 2013, xiv + 496 pp., $16.95 pbk. ISBN 978-0-393-34878-1 Essays Philos (2017)18:2 | DOI: 10.7710/1526-0569.1587 Correspondence: [email protected] © 2017 O’Loughlin. This open access article is distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) Essays in Philosophy Volume 18, Issue 2 Daniel Dennett is among the most preeminent and influential living philosophers, and his book, Intuition Pumps and Other Tools for Thinking, encapsulates several of his ma- jor contributions to the field, his approach to philosophy and other domains of inquiry, and his account of the role of philosophy in human intellectual endeavors. The book is written for a curious and attentive lay audience; Dennett takes himself to be instructing the reader in the use of tools for thinking that he has found particularly helpful, using examples—case studies in thinking about difficult problems—from philosophy and sci- ence to demonstrate the operation of these thinking tools. He is largely successful in this aim, introducing and deftly wielding a number of conceptual tools that are both broadly applicable and important, while at the same time giving concise presentations of several loci of discussion and inquiry in the philosophy of mind and science. In Dennett’s presentation of his project, he cites the autobiographical work of Richard Feynman—Surely You’re Joking, Mr.
    [Show full text]
  • El Imaginario Social De La Democracia En Black Mirror the Social Imaginary of Democracy in Black Mirror
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Repositorio da Universidade da Coruña Cigüela Sola, Javier y Martínez Lucena, Jorge (2014): “El imaginario social de la democracia 90 en Black Mirror” El imaginario social de la democracia en Black Mirror The social imaginary of democracy in Black Mirror Javier Cigüela Sola Universitat Abat Oliba CEU [email protected] Jorge Martínez Lucena Recibido 20-06-2014 Aceptado 23-11-2014 ABSTRACT RESUMEN Our collective imaginary of democracy is Nuestro imaginario colectivo de la eminently positive and usually connected to democracia es eminentemente positivo y other imaginaries such as transparency, suele estar conectado a otros imaginarios technology or entertainment, which we also como el de la transparencia, el de la tend to imagine as positively linked. tecnología y el entretenimiento, que Anyway, facts on democracy are themselves también tendemos a imaginar vinculados paradoxical, and paradoxical is also its positivamente entre sí. Sin embargo, la relation to those other imaginaries. In this realidad de la democracia en sí misma, así article we show how the english TV series como su relación con los imaginarios a los Black Mirror, a product of pop que ésta está conectada, es paradójica. En entertainment, allows a critical reflection on este artículo queremos mostrar cómo la the paradoxes that democracy entails. We teleserie inglesa Black Mirror, un producto will do so by showing how the episodes 1.2 de entretenimiento pop, permite una ("Fifteen Million Merits") and 2.3. ("The reflexión crítica acerca de las paradojas que Waldo Moment") allow to understand, ésta misma entraña.
    [Show full text]
  • Pete Gustavson Abby Perer Contemporary Philosophy Professor Marcus September 23, 2008
    Pete Gustavson Abby Perer Contemporary Philosophy Professor Marcus September 23, 2008 Against Qualia Qualia so far: Qualia has posed a problem for many positions we have studied thus far. For instance, physicalists have been criticized for leaving qualia out of their picture (recall Mary in the black and white room). Similarly, the Functionalists fail to account for qualia (recall the Homonculi-headed robot). Dennett’s Objective: In “Quining Qualia,” Dennett wants to refute the existence of qualia, thus leading us into Eliminativism and the denial of mental states all together. Dennett’s Argument: Dennett begins his argument by giving a definition of qualia. This definition attributes four main properties to qualia. Dennett then uses “intuition pumps” to show that no such thing with those four properties exists, and thus qualia do not exist. Dennett’s Account of Qualia: - Ineffable - Intrinsic - Private - Directly or Immediately Apprehensible Against Ineffability: - Intuition Pump #14: The Jello Box - Instead of just indicating the matching torn edge of the box, our language could develop such that we could explain the phenomenal information properties of one torn edge by itself, and in essence we could “eff the ineffable.” Against Intrinsicality: - Intuition Pump #9: The experienced beer drinker - Tastes can change or be acquired, and so our experience of taste is relational (depends on outside factors). There is nothing intrinsic (inherent regardless of outside factors) about the quale. Against Privacy: - Intuition Pump #4: The Brain-storm machine - First-person assessments of qualia are not very reliable due to potential lapses in memory. Against being Directly Apprehensible: - Intuition Pump #11: The guitar string (and wine tasting) - We can be trained to hear subtle differences in the harmony of the guitar string, and so the auditory quale is not directly or immediately apprehended.
    [Show full text]
  • Gender, Society and Technology in Black Mirror
    Aditya Hans Prasad WGSS 7 Professor Douglas Moody May 2018. Gender, Society and Technology in Black Mirror The anthology television show Black Mirror is critically acclaimed for the manner in which it examines and criticizes the relationship between human society and technology. Each episode focuses on a specifically unnerving aspect of technology, and the topics explored by it range from surveillance to mass media. These episodes may initially provide a cynical perspective of technology, but they are far more nuanced in that they provide a commentary on how human technology reflects the society it is produced for and by. With that in mind, it is evident that Black Mirror is an anthology series of speculative fiction episodes that scrutinizes the darker implications of these technologies. Often, these implications are products of particular social constructs such as race, socioeconomic class and gender. It is particularly interesting to analyze the way in which Black Mirror presents the interaction between gender and technology. Many of the television show’s episodes highlight the differences in the way women interact with technology as compared to men. These intricacies ultimately provide viewers with an understanding of the position women often hold in a modern, technologically driven society. Black Mirror is renowned for the unsettling way it presents the precarious situations that come up when technology begins to reflect the flaws of a society. The episode “Fifteen Million Merits” explores, among other things, the hyper-sexualized nature of modern mass media. The episode takes place in a simulated world, where humans exist inside a digital world where all they do is cycle to earn credits, spend credits on products of the media and sleep.
    [Show full text]
  • True Detective and the States of American Wound Culture
    True Detective and the States of American Wound Culture RODNEY TAVEIRA “Criminals should be publically displayed ... at the frontiers of the country.” Plato (qtd. in Girard 298) HE STATE INSTITUTIONS PORTRAYED IN THE HBO CRIME PROCEDU- ral True Detective are innately and structurally corrupt. Local T mayors’, state governors’, and district attorneys’ offices, city and county police, and sheriff’s departments commit and cover up violent crimes. These offices and departments comprise mostly mid- dle-aged white men. Masculinist desires for power and domination manifest as interpersonal ends and contact points between the indi- vidual and the state. The state here is a mutable system, both abstract and concrete. It encompasses the functions of the legal and political offices whose corruption is taken for granted in their shady rela- tions to criminal networks, commercial enterprises, and religious institutions. There is nothing particularly novel about this vision of the state. Masculinist violence and institutional corruption further damage vic- tims in the system (typically women, children, and disempowered and disenfranchised others, like migrant workers) who need a hero to solve the crimes committed against them—these tropes are staples of detective fiction, film noir, and many television crime procedurals. What then explains the popular and critical success of True Detective? Moreover, what does the show’s representation of the state—its aes- thetic strategies, narratives, and images—reveal about contemporary The Journal of Popular Culture, Vol. 50, No. 3, 2017 © 2017 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. 585 586 Rodney Taveira understandings and imaginings of the state, the individual, and the relations between them? While tracing the complex entanglement of the entertainment industries with femicidal and spectacular violence within a critical regionalism, carried out through digital modes of distribution, one can also see how government agencies shape content.
    [Show full text]
  • Analyzing Cultural Representations of State Control in Black Mirror Carl Russell Huber Eastern Kentucky University
    Eastern Kentucky University Encompass Online Theses and Dissertations Student Scholarship January 2017 A Dark Reflection of Society: Analyzing Cultural Representations of State Control in Black Mirror Carl Russell Huber Eastern Kentucky University Follow this and additional works at: https://encompass.eku.edu/etd Part of the Criminology Commons, and the Film and Media Studies Commons Recommended Citation Huber, Carl Russell, "A Dark Reflection of Society: Analyzing Cultural Representations of State Control in Black Mirror" (2017). Online Theses and Dissertations. 454. https://encompass.eku.edu/etd/454 This Open Access Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Student Scholarship at Encompass. It has been accepted for inclusion in Online Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Encompass. For more information, please contact [email protected]. A Dark Reflection of Society: Analyzing Cultural Representations of State Control in Black Mirror By CARL R. HUBER Bachelor of Science Central Michigan University Mount Pleasant, MI 2015 Submitted to the Faculty of the Graduate School of Eastern Kentucky University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF SCIENCE May, 2017 Copyright © Carl Russell Huber, 2017 All Rights Reserved ii ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I would like to thank my thesis chair, Dr. Judah Schept for his knowledge, guid- ance, and insight. I would also like to thank the other committee members, Dr. Victoria Collins and Dr. Travis Linnemann for their comments and assistance. I would also like to express my thanks to Dr. Justin Smith, who has mentored me throughout my academic career and has help shape my research.
    [Show full text]