DOCSLIB.ORG

Independent Review of the Effectiveness of ACT Police Powers

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Independent Review of the Effectiveness of ACT Police Powers INDEPENDENT REVIEW OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF ACT POLICING CRIME SCENE POWERS AND POWERS TO TARGET, DISRUPT, INVESTIGATE AND PROSECUTE CRIMINAL GANG MEMBERS 6 DECEMBER 2019 ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR TERRY GOLDSWORTHY AND DR GAELLE BROTTO BOND UNIVERSITY 14 University Drive, Robina Qld, 4226 ǀ P: 075595 3057 ǀ E: [email protected] ǀ www.bond.edu.au Independent review of the effectiveness of ACT Policing crime scene powers and powers to target, disrupt, investigate and prosecute criminal gang members © Copyright, Terry Goldsworthy and Gaelle Brotto This work is copyright, however material from this publication may be copied and published by State or Federal Government Agencies without permission of the authors on the condition that the meaning of the material is not altered and the authors are acknowledged as the source of the material. Any other persons or bodies wishing to use material must seek permission. Dr Terry Goldsworthy and Dr Gaelle Brotto Page i 6 December 2019 Independent review of the effectiveness of ACT Policing crime scene powers and powers to target, disrupt, investigate and prosecute criminal gang members ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The authors would like to acknowledge the staff at the Justice and Community Safety Directorate, ACT Government, and ACT Policing for their assistance in providing the necessary information and data, which add value to this review. We would also like to thank the stakeholders who took the time to provide submissions relating to numerous legislative issues. Without the valuable information you provided, we would not be in a position to comprehensively assess and report on the ACT crime scene’s powers and responses to organised crime. Dr Terry Goldsworthy and Dr Gaelle Brotto Page ii 6 December 2019 Independent review of the effectiveness of ACT Policing crime scene powers and powers to target, disrupt, investigate and prosecute criminal gang members CONTENTS ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ......................................................................................... II G LOSSARY ........................................................................................................ 5 L I ST OF TABLES ................................................................................................. 6 L I ST OF FIGURES ................................................................................................ 7 E XECUTI V E SUMMARY .......................................................................................... 8 SECTI ON 1—INTRODUCTION ................................................................................. 9 SECTI ON 2—METHODOLOGY ............................................................................... 10 2.1 The task ....................................................................................................................................................................... 10 2.2 Information from ACT Policing ........................................................................................................................... 12 2.3 Information from other government agencies ............................................................................................. 12 2.4 Consultations with key stakeholders ................................................................................................................ 12 2.5 Academic literature ................................................................................................................................................. 13 2.6 Parliamentary and public debate ....................................................................................................................... 13 2.7 Related laws ............................................................................................................................................................... 13 2.8 Conflict of interest ................................................................................................................................................... 13 SECTI ON 3—CONTEXT AND BACKGROUND OF CRI ME SCEN E P OWERS ............................. 14 3.1 Importance of crime scene powers in criminal investigation .................................................................. 14 3.2 The investigative process—a model ................................................................................................................. 15 3.3 Crime scene stage ................................................................................................................................................... 16 3.4 The international experience regarding crime scene powers ................................................................. 17 3.5 Crime scene powers in other states and territories .................................................................................... 20 SECTI ON 4—OVERVIEW: TH E OPERATION OF CRI ME SCEN E P OWERS ............................. 28 4.1 Increased concern about organised crime and criminal gangs .............................................................. 28 4.2 Immediate background to the new crime scene powers in 2017.......................................................... 28 4.3 The new division 10.4A .......................................................................................................................................... 29 4.4 A qualitative and quantitative analysis of the new crime scene powers ............................................. 34 SECTI ON 5—ORGANISED CRIME IN AUSTRALIA ........................................................ 37 5.1 Defining organised crime ..................................................................................................................................... 37 5.2 The international approaches to organised crime ...................................................................................... 38 a. The North American Approach .......................................................................................................................... 38 b. The European Approach ....................................................................................................................................... 40 c. The New Zealand Approach ................................................................................................................................ 44 d. Effectiveness .............................................................................................................................................................. 45 5.3 Legal approaches to defining organised crime ............................................................................................ 46 5.4 The future of organised crime ............................................................................................................................ 46 SECTI ON 6—OMCG S I N AUSTRALIA ..................................................................... 48 6.1 An examination of the criminality of OMCGs ............................................................................................... 48 6.2 How much crime do OMCGs commit? ............................................................................................................ 49 6.3 OMCGs and the drug markets ............................................................................................................................ 51 6.4 The role of the gang structure in criminal enterprises............................................................................... 52 6.5 Membership issues ................................................................................................................................................. 53 Dr Terry Goldsworthy and Dr Gaelle Brotto Page iii 6 December 2019 Independent review of the effectiveness of ACT Policing crime scene powers and powers to target, disrupt, investigate and prosecute criminal gang members 6.6 Media and OMCGs .................................................................................................................................................. 54 SECTI ON 7—CONSORTING LAWS IN AUSTRALIA ....................................................... 57 7.1 The history of consorting laws in Australia .................................................................................................... 57 7.2 Moral panic and the justification for consorting laws ................................................................................ 58 7.3 Not new—just previously unused ..................................................................................................................... 62 7.4 Consorting Laws, are they effective? ................................................................................................................ 65 7.5 Did anti-association laws already exist? .......................................................................................................... 69 SECTI ON 8—A CURRENT SITUATION REPORT OF OMCG ACTIVITY IN THE ACT ................. 72 8.1 ACT OMCGs memberships ................................................................................................................................... 72 8.2 An examination of OMCG criminality in the ACT ........................................................................................ 74 8.3 OMCGs’ involvement in organised and serious crime in the ACT ......................................................... 77 8.4 OMCGs and the media in the ACT ...................................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • ACT Policing Submission to the Inquiry Into Operational Response
    ACT Policing’s Submission to the Inquiry into the Operational Response to the January 2003 Bushfires May 2003 CONTENTS Preamble ...................................................................................................................3 The Role of Police Services in Emergencies ..........................................................5 Importance of preparation and training..................................................................7 ACT Policing responsibilities during the January ACT Bushfires .....................8 The January 2003 Bushfire emergency- a brief overview..................................10 ACT Policing’s Operational Response.................................................................23 Addressing the Terms of Reference .....................................................................26 1) the preparation, planning and response to the bushfires and of strategies for the evaluations and management of the bushfire threat and risk .........................26 2) ESB management structure, command and control arrangements, and public information strategy.............................................................................................29 3) the coordination and cooperative arrangements with other ACT and interstate, Commonwealth and non-government agencies, including utility providers, for managing such emergencies;.........................................................33 4) the adequacy of ESB equipment, communications’ systems, training and resources ..............................................................................................................33
    [Show full text]
  • AFP Platypus Annual 2019
    ANNUAL 2019 Contents Commissioner’s message The platypus has been adopted by the Australian 5 Federal Police as a symbol representing the diverse requirements placed on members in the execution of ANNUAL Keeping Australia Safe: Joint their duties. 2019 Counter Terrorism Team foil This unique and tenacious Australian animal is a Christmas plot 6 survivor against increasing pressure from today’s environment. It leaves no stone unturned in its daily pursuits and has equipped itself with a range of Keeping Australia Safe: Protecting features to adapt to changes over many years. children drives investigators 10 It is capable of passing unnoticed if required, yet it Cover images: Selected demonstrates an unfailing dedication to explore all photos from this edition. ACT Policing Snapshot 14 possibilities in an effort to maintain its special place in Australia’s environment. Busy 40th for AFP 16 Although generally a peaceful animal, the platypus is able to defend itself, if necessary, with a venomous The AFP 1979 - 2019 timeline 22 spur. This is done, at times, against larger and more powerful opponents—a quality admired and respected by members of the Australian Federal Police. Keeping Australia Safe: AFP tracks down financial fraudsters 26 Keeping Australia Safe: The largest meth seizure that almost never was 30 Surprise gift for the AFP’s 40th34 Edition 124 Editor: Dom Byrne Staying on track: AFP family Design: Metka Kosec AFP Media and Engagement honours Detective Sergeant Contributors: Alexia Boland, Gab Knowles, Mark Scott Dominic Lavers, Shelby Houghton & Joe 42 Marsden (AFP National Media). Terry Browne (AFP Museum). Emma Bailey (ACT Keeping Australia Safe: Policing) ISSN 1441-8061 Child protection team closes AFP Platypus Magazine is the journal of the Australian Federal Police.
    [Show full text]
  • AFP Annual Report 2019-20
    ANNUAL REPORT 2019–20 AFP Annual Report 2019–20 Ownership of intellectual property rights in this publication Unless otherwise noted, copyright (and other intellectual property rights, if any) in this publication is owned by the Commonwealth of Australia. Creative Commons Licence This publication is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Australia Licence, which allows you to copy, distribute, transmit and adapt this publication provided that you attribute the work. A summary of the licence terms is available from: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/au/ The full licence terms are available from: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/au/legalcode The Commonwealth of Australia’s preference is that you attribute this publication (and any material sourced from it) using the following wording: Source: Licensed from the Commonwealth of Australia under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Australia Licence. ISSN 0728–4691 (print) ISSN 2202-7491 (online) © Commonwealth of Australia, Australian Federal Police, 2020 Aids to access Annual report contact officer Manager Audit, Statistics and Performance Contact phone number (02) 5126 0000 Contact email [email protected] Manager Audit, Statistics and Performance Contact address Australian Federal Police GPO Box 401, Canberra ACT 2601 Entity website (URL) www.afp.gov.au for all general information Freedom of information requests [email protected] Electronic versions of this and previous annual www.afp.gov.au/annualreport reports Details of accountable authority during the
    [Show full text]
  • 100-Volunteer-Stories-Web-Version.Pdf
    100 Volunteer STORIES www.volunteeringact.org.au © Volunteering ACT Inc 2013. December 2013 Celebrating the contribution of Canberra’s Volunteers Proudly sponsored by Beyond Bank Australia FOREWORD BY MAUREEN CANE Chief Executive Officer of Volunteering ACT Australia’s capital has a proud record for volunteering since it was founded. Services to the swiftly growing population were often first provided by volunteers. Volunteering is now in Canberra’s DNA, with many of her citizens, young and old and from all walks of life, actively volunteering at any one time. This book tells some of their stories — of care for others, of courage, of generosity and of application of skills and expertise. The stories are a testimony to the excellent work of Canberra’s community-based organisations and to the selfless contribution of individuals towards the general good. One such story, of the generous application of expertise, is from Sarah Wilson, the volunteer who compiled this book for Volunteering ACT! All the stories are a fitting legacy for Canberra’s Centenary year and engender a sure and certain confidence that our Maureen Cane, Volunteering ACT CEO future is in good hands. AUSTRALIA’S CAPITAL has a proud record for volunteering since it was founded. Services to the swiftly growing population were often firstprovided by volunteers. FOREWORD BY MARY PORTER Member of the ACT Legislative Assembly and Founder of Volunteering ACT As we all know the ACT has one of the highest rates of volunteering in Australia. When I arrived in the ACT in 1977 I was introduced to the communities training program that was sponsored by the Mental Health arm of the, then, Health Commission and supported by ACTOSS & Lifeline ACT.
    [Show full text]
  • Evaluation of the Australian Capital Territory Drug Diversion Programs.Pdf
    Evaluation of the Australian Capital Territory Drug Diversion Programs Caitlin Hughes1, Marian Shanahan1, Alison Ritter1, David McDonald2, and Florence Gray-Weale1 1 Drug Policy Modelling Program, National Drug and Alcohol Research Centre, The University of New South Wales 2 Social Research and Evaluation Pty Ltd Feb 2013 Acknowledgements A project of this nature required a considerable commitment from a large number of people, over a very small space of time. It would not have been possible without all of the ACT stakeholders who gave their time so generously. Particular thanks are due to the ACT Health Directorate for providing the opportunity to examine the ACT drug diversion system and all the roundtable participants: 24 different individuals across 3 roundtables in all (see Appendix A for details). The commitment to give so much time and to engage fully in the process was truly appreciated, and is a reflection of the commitment in the ACT towards improving responses to alcohol and drug-related offenders. Thanks also to all those who provided data and/or more detailed descriptions of processes, particularly: ACT Government Health Directorate, Alcohol and Other Drug Policy Unit ACT Government Health Directorate, Alcohol and Drug Services ACT Policing, Alcohol and Drug Diversion Coordinators ACT Policing, Performance, Evaluation and Review team Finally, we would also like to acknowledge the assistance of Carrie Fowlie, Executive Officer, Alcohol Tobacco and Other Drug Association ACT (ATODA), for advice and critical reflections throughout this project. It should be noted that all conclusions and recommendations are attributable to DPMP and Social Research and Evaluation, not to ATODA, and that any mistakes are those of the research team.
    [Show full text]
  • Agreement Between the ACT Minister for Police and Emergency Services
    Agreement between the ACT Minister for Police and Emergency Services, Australian Federal Police Commissioner, and the Chief Police Officer for the ACT for the provision of policing services to the Australian Capital Territory 2017-2021 The relationship between the AFP and the ACT Government for the provision of policing services to the ACT is long standing and contributes to Canberra being one of the safest places to live in Australia. The AFP, through ACT Policing, will provide a professional, innovative and effective policing service to the people of the ACT, contributing to a safe and just community for all. To achieve this vision, the ACT Government and ACT Policing are committed to: • Whole of government collaboration • Community engagement • Working in partnership • Transparency and information sharing • Innovation ACT Policing reflects the values of the AFP when delivering policing services to the ACT: • Integrity • Commitment • Excellence • Accountability • Fairness • Trust • Respect 1. Definitions 1.1 Unless stated otherwise, definitions in this Agreement are the same as in the Arrangement commenced in June 2017, between the Minister for Justice of the Commonwealth and the ACT Police Minister for the provision of policing services to the ACT. 2. Purpose and Objectives 2.1 In accordance with clause 2.1 of the Arrangement, this Agreement details the policing services to be purchased by the ACT Government from the AFP, including ACT Government Ministerial support, reporting, performance expectations and financial arrangements. 2.2 This Agreement will be read in conjunction with the Arrangement and Ministerial Directions issued under section 7 of the Arrangement. 2.3 The ACT Government and the AFP seek from this Agreement: appropriate policing levels and services for the ACT community; sustained high quality of service provision; and provision of stable and effective policing services for the ACT community as well as the building and retention of corporate knowledge within ACT Policing.
    [Show full text]
  • Review of Police Pursuits Conducted by ACT Policing in the Australian
    Review of police pursuits conducted by ACT Policing Page 1 of 148 in the Australian Capital Territory CONTACT OFFICER FOR THIS REPORT Coordinator Ministerial, Policy & Performance ACT Policing GPO Box 401 Canberra ACT 2601 Telephone: (02) 6264 9480 Email: [email protected] GENERAL CONTACT DETAILS Post Written requests for information can be sent to: Coordinator Ministerial, Policy & Performance ACT Policing GPO Box 401 Canberra ACT 2601 Telephone For general information about the AFP, telephone AFP National Headquarters on (02) 6131 3000. People who are hearing impaired can contact the AFP through telephone typewriter facility on (02) 6256 7700. For general enquiries regarding the content of this report please contact (02) 6264 9460. Internet Information about ACT Policing can be found at the ACT Policing website www.police.act.gov.au where an electronic version of this report can be found. For Freedom of Information requests contact (02) 6131 6131, [email protected] or go to afp.gov.au. © Commonwealth of Australia (Australian Federal Police) 2015 This work is copyright. Apart from any use as permitted under the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth), no part may be reproduced by any process without prior written permission from ACT Policing. Review of police pursuits conducted by ACT Policing Page 2 of 148 in the Australian Capital Territory CONTENTS TERMS OF REFERENCE .............................................................................................. 6 ACRONYMS ............................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • ACT POLICING ANNUAL REPORT 2019 –20 © Commonwealth of Australia, 2020 This Work Is Copyright
    ACT POLICING ANNUAL REPORT 2019 –20 © Commonwealth of Australia, 2020 This work is copyright. It may be quoted or reproduced in part or whole for study or training purposes, subject to acknowledgement of source. Reproduction for any other purpose requires written permission from ACT Policing. Contact officer Inquiries about this document should be directed to: Coordinator Ministerial, Policy and Performance ACT Policing GPO Box 401 Canberra ACT 2601 Telephone: (02) 6256 7777 Email: [email protected] For an electronic version of this annual report and previous annual reports go to police.act.gov.au/about-us/publications/annual-reports General inquiries Written requests for general information can be sent to: Coordinator Ministerial, Policy and Performance ACT Policing GPO Box 401 Canberra ACT 2601 Information about ACT Policing can also be found at police.act.gov.au For general information about the Australian Federal Police (AFP), of which ACT Policing is the community policing arm, telephone AFP National Headquarters on (02) 5126 0000. Freedom of information Telephone: (02) 5126 9366 Email: [email protected] Website: afp.gov.au/about-us/freedom-information ANNUAL REPORT 2019–20 REPORT ANNUAL i Contents ACT POLICING ACT 1 Chief Police Officer’s Foreword 1 2 Ministerial Direction 5 Minister for Police and Emergency Services Ministerial Direction 6 3 ACT Policing at a glance 9 Our Role 10 Our Mission 10 Our Governance 10 Our Intent 11 Our Values 11 Our Budget 12 Our Approach 12 Our Performance 14 Our Challenges 15 Our People 16
    [Show full text]
  • 2019-04 Garran2
    Neighbourhood Watch Area Coordinator Nicky Simon - 0418285797 GARRAN [email protected] Mar – Apr 2019 www.nwhact.com.au Going on holidays over Easter • Lock away tools, ladders and anything Here are some useful home safety /ps if that could be used to get into your you plan to go away over Easter: house, garage or shed; • It’s a good idea to leave your • Ask a neighbour to park their car in houselooking ‘lived in’. Leave a key your driveway occasionally to give the with a trusted neighbour or friend and impression that someone is coming ask them to rearrange blinds etc.; and going; • If possible, get a friend or rela/ve to • Disconnect the electrical supply on house-sit for you while you are away; radio-controlled or electronic garage • Make sure all windows and doors are doors and use good quality locks; locked in your home/garage/shed; • Make sure all your valuables are • Have your mail collected by a friend or stored securely; neighbour, or have it held or • Close curtains and blinds; redirected by the post office; • Have your lawn mown while you are • Don’t leave a message on your away; and answering machine, or a note on the • Cancel paper delivery and ask a door that tells callers you are away; neighbour to collect your mail. • Turn down the volume on your phone s o i t c a n ’ t b e h e a r d r i n g i n g unanswered; • Ask a neighbour or friend to put your rubbish bins out and bring them in as usual; • Consider using automa/c /mers to turn on a light, television or radio at different /mes; Autumn is coming During Astronomy Nights, between 10 and 20 Lynne Bliss outreach telescopes are set up for viewing.
    [Show full text]
  • MEDIA RELEASE ACT Policing Traffic Operations Centre Served with Improvement Notice by Comcare
    18 NOVEMBER 2020 MEDIA RELEASE ACT Policing Traffic Operations Centre served with Improvement Notice by Comcare The Australian Federal Police Association (AFPA) welcomes Comcare issuing an Improvement Notice on ACT Policing’s Traffic Operations Centre (TOC) in Belconnen. The AFPA has been discussing the condition of the TOC with ACT Policing and the ACT Government for over 12 months now; until now, the Association’s questions and concerns have not been adequately addressed. AFPA President Alex Caruana welcomes Comcare’s move; with ACT Policing and the ACT Government now officially on-notice, he said that he expects the issue to be swiftly resolved. “Through all our discussions with ACT Policing and the ACT Government, all I have heard about is the Police Services Model (PSM) and Master Accommodation Plan (MAP). This excuse is getting tiresome; considering former Chief Police Officer Justine Saunders initiated these models in 2017 and we’ve seen very little delivered. “Why does it take three years to deliver a PSM and MAP, especially when ACT Policing has already been provided funding? In fairness to the ACT Government, they’ve guaranteed a budget for ACT Policing to work with - so where is that body of work and what is being delivered? This essentially is a member welfare issue combined with an accommodation issue - and neither are going away anytime soon,” Mr Caruana said. Accommodation across ACT Policing is a core focus for the AFPA, with a number of facilities having exceeded, or being at their end-life of functionality as operational police facilities. Mr Caruana said that ACT Policing’s accommodation is in a dire situation and has been poorly managed on all levels.
    [Show full text]
  • Audit of Initiatives Related to Police and Muslim Communities
    Audit of Initiatives Related to Police and Muslim Communities AGENCY PROJECT DESCRIPTION DURATION COMMONWEALTH COMMONWEALTH Commonwealt This manual is designed to help Commonwealth Governments promote 2006 SECRETARIAT h Manual for an understanding of and respect for human rights. The manual provides Human Rights strategies and training programs to equip and enable police services to Training of better deal with community policing. It addresses the tension between Police protecting human rights and counter terrorist measures emphasising the need to maintain a balance between these measures and human rights. Furthermore the manual provides for training methodologies to enable law enforcement officers to develop human rights standards, practices and approaches. NATIONAL DEPARTMENT OF A Good Responding to Diversity: Program Planning, Audit, Evaluation and 2006 IMMIGRATION AND Practice Guide Reporting Checklist. This guide explains how to integrate cultural MULTICULTURAL to Culturally awareness practices to facilitate the effective contribution of people from AFFAIRS Responsive diverse backgrounds in government services. The guide includes a Government checklist to assist Australian Public Service staff when considering issues Services of access and equality. AUSTRALIAN Islamic The AFP has held Islamic Awareness Workshops attended by AFP 2003 FEDERAL POLICE awareness members nationally. These workshops involved various members and (AFP) workshops leaders of the Muslim and Arab community speaking to police on topics including racial discrimination and Islam, its beliefs and customs. Activities included: • A speech by Mr Ali Roude, Chairman of the Islamic Council of New South Wales, in December 2003 at the Senior Executive Retreat about what it is to be an Australian Muslim (Published in Platypus No. 18 March 2004).
    [Show full text]
  • Download Essential Visitor Information
    STROMLO FOREST PARK – ESSENTIAL VISITOR INFORMATION CONTENTS General Information ............................................................................................................................... 2 Location ............................................................................................................................................... 2 Stromlo Forest Park Management ...................................................................................................... 2 Contact Us ........................................................................................................................................... 2 Opening and Closing ........................................................................................................................... 2 Entry and Exit ...................................................................................................................................... 2 Toilets, Showers and Bottle Filling Station ......................................................................................... 2 What to do if you get locked in? ......................................................................................................... 2 Closed Circuit Television (CCTV) surveillance ..................................................................................... 2 Security ............................................................................................................................................... 3 Emergency telephones ......................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]