Conference Report May 2005
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
IMPLEMENTING THE AGREEMENT: THE NORTH-SOUTH BODIES FIVE YEARS ON REPORT ON CONFERENCE HELD ON 27 MAY 2005 CON F E R E N CE R E P OR T 2 7 M A Y 2 0 0 5 IMPLEMENTING THE AGREEMENT: THE NORTH-SOUTH BODIES FIVE YEARS ON REPORT ON CONFERENCE HELD AT UNIVERSITY COLLEGE DUBLIN 27 MAY 2005 REPORT Institute for British-Irish Studies Institute of Governance Geary Institute for the Social Sciences Centre for International Borders Research University College Dublin Queen’s University Belfast CONTENTS Report ............................................................................................................................ 1 Theme......................................................................................................................... 1 Introduction ............................................................................................................... 1 The work of the North-South bodies ......................................................................... 2 Conclusion................................................................................................................. 5 Annex 1: Conference programme ................................................................................. 6 Annex 2: List of participants......................................................................................... 8 Annex 3: The “Mapping frontiers, plotting pathways” project.................................. 12 Annex 4: The Institute for British-Irish Studies ......................................................... 14 Annex 5: Contact details............................................................................................. 18 The support of the HEA and the EU PEACE II programme, funders of the North-South research project “Mapping frontiers, plotting pathways: routes to North-South cooperation in a divided island”, is gratefully acknowledged REPORT Theme This conference addressed the progress made under strand two of the Good Friday Agreement: the North-South dimension. It formed part of the project Mapping fron- tiers, plotting pathways: routes to North-South cooperation in a divided island. The political background since the creation of the North/South Ministerial Council (NSMC) and the implementation bodies in 1999 has been far from stable. The current suspension of the NSMC has left the bodies operating in an environment different to that envisaged in the agreement. The bodies (Waterways Ireland, SafeFood, InterTrade Ireland, the Special EU Programmes Body, the Language Body and the Loughs Agency) have nevertheless continued to carry out their mandated public functions, aimed at bringing benefits to both parts of the island, as has Tourism Ireland, a similar body established in 2000. They have faced unique challenges of administrative complexity and political sensitivity. This conference sought to take stock of the functioning of the implementation bodies in this context. The opening address was given by the Taoiseach, with the NSMC se- cretariat and all of the implementation bodies contributing. Speakers were invited to address the following questions, among others: • the extent to which island-wide or cross-border activity was proceeding in the sec- tor prior to the establishment of the body • the issues that arose as the body was being established • the principal difficulties that the body has so far encountered in meeting its objec- tives • how the body assesses its own contribution to the issue it was designed to tackle. The final session drew presented a more political perspective, examining how the bodies may proceed in the context of long-term suspension of the devolved institu- tions that make up the cornerstone of the Good Friday Agreement. Introduction The conference began with a presentation in which An Taoiseach, Mr Bertie Ahern, TD, assessed the future prospects for North-South cooperation from the Irish government’s perspective. In this he emphasised the central role of the Good Friday Agreement as the continuing blueprint for future political developments. The North- South bodies established under its auspices, he said, have worked quietly but effi- ciently for the good of all, North and South. Both parts of the island contribute to the CONFERENCE REPORT MAY 2005 work of the bodies, and both parts gain from it. The work of the bodies is complemented by other initiatives in North-South cooperation. Indeed, long-term economic planning implies the need to consider the whole island for infrastructural planning and other purposes. The Taoiseach noted that there have been difficulties in the political process, but he took the view that the common ground achieved by parties as diverse as the Democratic Unionist Party and Sinn Féin was more remarkable than the set of issues that divides them, suggesting a potential for positive political development in the longer term. An Taoiseach, Bertie Ahern, TD, addressing the conference The Taoiseach’s presentation was followed by one from each of the joint secretaries of the North/South Ministerial Council. Tim O’Connor’s paper set out the background to the new North-South institutional architecture contained in the Belfast or Good Fri- day Agreement—the negotiations themselves and the outcome. Given that much of the detail remained to be further worked out after Good Friday, it recounted the talks held in the Autumn of 1998 and in early 1999, culminating in the Agreement be- tween the two governments establishing the implementation bodies, signed in Dublin Castle on 8 March 1999. The paper outlined the main elements of that agreement, in- cluding the nature of the functions and structure of each of the implementation bod- ies, together with the common arrangements that were to apply to all of them. The story introduced by Tim O’Connor was continued by his colleague, Peter Smyth. He pointed out that because of the sensitivities associated with North-South co-operation, the initial meetings of NSMC were important as much for symbolism as practical outcomes. But as the implementation bodies established themselves, and government departments engaged in the areas of co-operation, the possibilities of- fered by co-operation for mutual benefit became more apparent, and NSMC meetings assumed a different and much more meaningful character. The paper looked at the impact of the Northern Ireland Assembly’s suspension in 2002, and offered a brief overview of the wider dimensions of cross-border co-operation. The work of the North-South bodies The second and third sessions of the conference looked at the work of seven imple- mentation bodies established after the agreement, and at the work of another body, Tourism Ireland, that resembles them in function. Aidan Gough reminded the con- -2- CONFERENCE REPORT MAY 2005 ference that InterTradeIreland was the body established “to exchange information and co-ordinate work on trade, business development and related matters in areas where the two administrations specifically agree it would be in their mutual interest”. Total North-South trade, he said, amounts to £2.4bn. However, the trade figures do not capture—nor are they an accurate measure of—the mutual benefits that are to be reaped from closer links and business collaboration on this island. “Mutual benefits” in economic terms can best be captured through increased competitiveness. Peter Smyth and Tim O’Connor, Since 2001, InterTradeIreland has invested joint secretaries, North/South £12m in all-island collaborative initiatives Ministerial Council designed to enhance the competitiveness of participating businesses. In 2003 and 2004 alone, these initiatives have generated business value in the region of £26bn. Clearly, all-island collaboration is good for business. The work of the Special EU Programmes Body was described by its chief execu- tive, Pat Colgan. This body is the managing authority and paying authority for the PEACE programme and the INTERREG programme and has become a centre of ex- cellence for the governance and management of EU funded programmes on a cross- border basis. It is also responsible for the Common Chapter and for the cross border dimensions of other Community Initiatives. He pointed out that the work of the body has resulted in the creation of significant cross border cooperation capacity. Through the PEACE Programme, a total of 6,000 projects have been implemented by 56 im- plementing bodies, involving a total investment up to the end of 2006 of 868 mil- lion. Through the INTERREG programme, a total of 250 projects have been imple- mented by 22 cross border implementing bodies involving a total investment up to the end of 2006 of 182 million. The chief executive of the Loughs Agency, Derick Anderson, offered an overview of the agency’s work. This reviewed the opportunities and problems associated with the transition from an original cross border body, the Foyle Fisheries Commission, established in 1952, to the Loughs Agency of the Foyle, Carlingford and Irish Lights Commission. Among the issues addressed was the extension of functions from the Foyle area to the Carlingford area and the addition of responsibilities for aquacul- ture, shellfisheries and marine tourism to the original role of fisheries conservation, protection and management. -3- CONFERENCE REPORT MAY 2005 Developments in Tourism Ireland, the body established under the framework of the Good Friday Agreement to market the island of Ireland overseas as a preferred tour- ism destination, were reviewed by Niall Gibbons. His presentation traced a journey in the evolution