The Barbara Johnson Reader a John Hope Franklin Center Book the Barbara Johnson Reader the Surprise of Otherness
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The Barbara Johnson Reader A John Hope Franklin Center Book The Barbara Johnson Reader The Surprise of Otherness Barbara Johnson edited by melissa feuerstein bill johnson gonzález lili porten keja valens With an Introduction by judith butler and an Afterword by shoshana felman Duke University Press Durham and London 2014 © 2014 Duke University Press Afterword © 2014 Shoshana Felman All rights reserved Printed in the United States of America on acid- free paper ∞ Designed by April Leidig Typeset in Minion Pro by Westchester Publishing Services Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data The Barbara Johnson reader : the surprise of otherness / edited by Melissa Feuerstein, Bill Johnson Gonzalez, Lili Porten, and Keja Valens, with an introduction by Judith Butler and an afterword by Shoshana Felman. pages cm “A John Hope Franklin Center Book.” Includes bibliographical references and index. isbn 978-0-8223-5419-2 (pbk : alk. paper) isbn 978-0-8223-5403-1 (cloth : alk. paper) 1. Johnson, Barbara, 1947–2009. 2. Feminist literary criticism. I. Feuerstein, Melissa. II. Johnson Gonzalez, Bill, 1970– iii. Porten, Lili. IV. Valens, Keja, 1972– pn98.w64b37 2014 801.'95092—dc23 2013045003 Contents Ac know ledg ments vii Editors’ Preface xi Personhood and Other Objects: The Figural Dispute with Philosophy by Judith Butler xvii Barbara Johnson by Barbara Johnson xxvii part i | Reading Theory as Literature, Literature as Theory 1 The Critical Diff erence: BartheS/BalZac 3 2 Translator’s Introduction to Dissemination (abridged) 14 3 Poetry and Syntax: What the Gypsy Knew 26 4 A Hound, a Bay Horse, and a Turtle Dove: Obscurity in Walden 36 5 Strange Fits: Poe and Wordsworth on the Nature of Poetic Language 44 6 The Frame of Reference: Poe, Lacan, Derrida 57 part ii | Race, Sexuality, Gender 7 Euphemism, Understatement, and the Passive Voice: A Genealogy of Afro- American Poetry 101 8 Meta phor, Metonymy, and Voice in Their Eyes Were Watching God 108 9 Moses and Intertexuality: Sigmund Freud, Zora Neale Hurston, and the Bible 126 10 Lesbian Spectacles: Reading Sula, Passing, Thelma and Louise, and The Accused 141 11 Bringing Out D. A. Miller 147 12 Correctional Facilities 155 13 My Monster/My Self 179 part iii | Language, Personhood, Ethics 14 Introduction to Freedom and Interpretation (abridged) 193 15 Muteness Envy 200 16 Apostrophe, Animation, and Abortion 217 17 Anthropomorphism in Lyric and Law 235 18 Using People: Kant with Winnicott 262 19 Ego Sum Game 275 20 Melville’s Fist: The Execution of Billy Budd 289 part iv | Pedagogy and Translation 21 Nothing Fails Like Success 327 22 Bad Writing 334 23 Teaching Deconstructively 347 24 Poison or Remedy? Paul de Man as Pharmakon 357 25 Taking Fidelity Philosophically 371 26 The Task of the Translator 377 27 Teaching Ignorance: L’Ecole des femmes 401 afterword | Barbara’s Signature by Shoshana Felman 421 Bibliography 433 Index 437 vi | Contents Ac know ledg ments “barbara johnson” chapter 3 by barbara johnson “Poetry and Syntax: What “Barbara Johnson Biography,” from the Gypsy Knew.” From The Norton Anthology of Theory and Critical Diff erence: Essays in the Criticism, edited by Vincent B. Contemporary Rhetoric of Reading, Leitch et al. Copyright © 2010, 2001 67– 75. © 1980 The Johns Hopkins by W. W. Norton & Company, Inc. University Press. Reprinted with Used by permission of W. W. Norton permission of The Johns Hopkins & Company, Inc. University Press. chapter 1 chapter 4 “The Critical Diff erence.” Diacritics “A Hound, a Bay Horse, and a Turtle 8, no. 2 (1978): 2– 9. Reprinted with Dove: Obscurity in Walden.” From permission of The Johns Hopkins A World of Diff erence, 49– 56. © University Press. 1987 The Johns Hopkins University Press. Reprinted with permission chapter 2 of The Johns Hopkins University From Jacques Derrida, Press. Dissemination. Barbara Johnson, trans. (1981), vii– xvii. Excerpts chapter 5 from “Translator’s Introduction” “Strange Fits: Poe and Wordsworth are reprinted by permission of on the Nature of Poetic Language.” the publisher © The University of From A World of Diff erence, Chicago 1981. 89– 99. © 1987 The Johns Hopkins University Press. Reprinted with permission of The Johns Hopkins chapter 10 University Press. “Lesbian Spectacles: Reading Sula, Passing, Thelma and Louise, and The chapter 6 Accused.” From Media Spectacles, “The Frame of Reference: Poe, Marjorie Garber, Jann Matlock, Lacan, Derrida.” Yale French Studies and Rebecca Walkowitz, eds. (New 55/56 (1978): 457– 505. Reprinted by York: Routledge, 1993). Reproduced permission of Yale French Studies. with permission of Taylor & Francis chapter 7 Group llc. Permissions conveyed “Euphemism, Understatement, and through Copyright Clearance the Passive Voice: A Genealogy Center. of Afro- American Poetry.” From chapter 11 Reading Black, Reading Feminist, “Bringing Out D. A. Miller.” Henry Louis Gates Jr., ed. © 1990 Narrative 10, no. 1 (January 2002): by Henry Louis Gates Jr. Used 3– 8. © 2002 The Ohio State by permission of Dutton Signet, University Press. Reproduced with a division of Penguin Group permission. (USA) Inc. chapter 12 chapter 8 “Correctional Facilities,” reprinted “Meta phor, Metonymy, and Voice by permission of the publisher from in Their Eyes Were Watching God.” Barbara Johnson, Mother Tongues: From Black Literature and Literary Sexuality, Trials, Motherhood, Theory, Henry Louis Gates Jr., 1– 25 (Cambridge, MA: Harvard ed. (New York: Routledge, 1984). University Press), © 2003 by the Reproduced with permission of President and Fellows of Harvard Taylor & Francis Group llc. College. Permissions conveyed through Copyright Clearance Center. chapter 13 “My Monster/My Self.” Diacritics chapter 9 12, no. 2 (1982): 2– 10. © 1982 “Moses and Intertexuality: Sigmund The Johns Hopkins University Freud, Zora Neale Hurston, and the Press. Reprinted with permission Bible.” From Poetics of the Americas: of The Johns Hopkins University Race, Founding, and Textuality, Press. Bainard Cowan and Jeff erson Humphries, eds. © 1997 Louisiana chapter 14 State University Press. Reprinted Introduction to Freedom and by permission. Interpretation: Oxford Amnesty viii | Ac know ledg ments Lectures of 1992 (abridged). chapter 19 Copyright © 1993 Barbara Johnson. “Ego Sum Game,” reprinted by Reprinted by permission of Basic permission of the publisher from Books Press, a member of the Barbara Johnson, Persons and Perseus Books Group. Things, 47– 60 (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press). © 2003 chapter 15 by the President and Fellows of “Muteness Envy.” From Human, All Harvard College. Too Human, Diana Fuss, ed. (New York: Routledge, 1995). Reproduced chapter 20 with permission of Taylor & Francis “Melville’s Fist: The Execution of Group llc. Permissions conveyed Billy Budd.” Studies in Romanticism through Copyright Clearance 18, no. 4 (1979): 567– 99. Reprinted Center. with permission. chapter 16 chapter 21 “Apostrophe, Animation, and “Nothing Fails Like Success.” sce Abortion.” Diacritics 16, no. 1 (1986): Reports 8 (fall 1980). Reprinted with 29– 39. © 1986 The Johns Hopkins permission of the University of University Press. Reprinted with Houston- Victoria. permission of The Johns Hopkins chapter 22 University Press. “Bad Writing.” From Jonathan chapter 17 Culler and Kevin Lamb, Just Being “Anthropomorphism in Lyric Diffi cult? Academic Writing in the and Law.” Reprinted by permission Public Arena. © 2003 by the Board of the Yale Journal of Law & of Trustees of the Leland Stanford Jr. the Humanities 10, no. 2 University. All rights reserved. Used (1998): 549– 74. with permission of Stanford University Press, www .sup .org . chapter 18 “Using People: Kant with chapter 23 Winnicott.” From The Turn to “Teaching Destructively.” From Ethics, Marjorie Garber, Beatrice Writing and Reading Diff erently: Hanssen, and Rebecca Walkowitz, Deconstruction and the Teaching eds. (New York: Routledge, 2000). of Composition and Literature, Reproduced with permission of G. Douglas Atkins and Michael Taylor & Francis Group llc. L. Johnson, eds. (1985), 140– 48. Permissions conveyed through Reprinted with permission of the Copyright Clearance Center. University Press of Kansas. Ac know ledg ments | ix chapter 24 publisher from Barbara Johnson, “Poison or Remedy? Paul de Man as Mother Tongues: Sexuality, Pharmakon.” Colloquium Trials, Motherhood, 40– 64 Helveticum 11/12 (1990): 7– 20. (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press), © 2003 by chapter 25 the President and Fellows Reprinted from “Taking Fidelity of Harvard College. Philosophically,” from Diff erence in Translation, Joseph F. Graham, ed. © chapter 27 1985 by Cornell University. Used by “Teaching Ignorance.” Yale permission of the publisher, Cornell French Studies 63 (1982): 165– 82. University Press. Reprinted by permission of Yale French Studies. chapter 26 “The Task of the Translator,” afterword reprinted by permission of the Copyright © 2014 Shoshana Felman. x | Ac know ledg ments Editors’ Preface Melissa Feuerstein, Bill Johnson González, Lili Porten, and Keja Valens The surprise of otherness is that moment when a new form of ignorance is suddenly activated as an imperative. —Barbara Johnson, “Nothing Fails Like Success” To encounter and propagate “the surprise of otherness”— the otherness of another gender, race, culture, or language, the irreducible otherness of another person, the contradictions within the self— this is the “impossible but neces- sary task” and guiding imperative of the work of Barbara Johnson, one of the most original and infl uential literary critics