Mixbury, Finmere, Westbury, Turweston, Evenley and Fringford
February 2020
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Wormleighton, Priors Hardwick, Byfield & Boddington
1 Introductions
2 Landscape Strategy
3 Operational Noise
4 Construction arrangements
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Introductions
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Overview & Context
Community Engagement Landscape approach London
Construction Arrangements Operational Noise
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Disclaimer
The following slides show our current proposals which are subject to further review, discussion and approval from consent granting bodies.
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Landscape Strategy Turweston, Westbury, Mixbury, Finmere, Evenley & Fringford
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Landscape Strategy 1. Landscape Approach - HS2 Vision 2. Landscape Character 3. Key Landscape Features 4. Landscape Vernacular 5. Driving the Vision 6. Landscape Planting Plans
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 1. Landscape Approach OUR Aims as designers HS2 Vision • Understanding the Vernacular • People • Understanding the local community • Adapting the design • Passenger Experience • Place • Re-engaging the countryside • Promoting Biodiversity • Time • Reinforcing planting
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 2. Landscape Character
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 3. Key Landscape Characteristics
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Landscape Character Clay Vale of Buckingham
Preston Bissett Plateau Edge & Hethe Wooded Estatelands
Recognise the importance and value of the historic hedgerow pattern and replace where it has been lost to enhance the landscape character and strengthen connectivity of habitats. Encourage the establishment of new hedgerow trees. Maintain and improve the condition of existing hedgerows through traditional cutting regimes
Recognise the importance of new woodland planting to minimise the impact of new infrastructure and manage using traditional techniques to create and manage a wide diversity of habitats.
Recognise the importance of neutral grassland
Recognise the importance of the character of minor roads by the planting and management of hedgerows and verges and limiting urbanising elements such as signs and kerbs.
Panorama Q
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Landscape Character River Great Ouse Claylands & Cotswolds (Brackley) & Writtlebury Ridge Westbury – Biddlesden Great Ouse Valley LCA & Oatleys Plateau LCA
Recognise the importance and value of the existing historic hedgerow pattern and plant up with new hedgerow trees. Seek to restore the historic hedgerow pattern where it has been lost to enhance the landscape character and strengthen the ecological diversity and implement management through traditional cutting regimes.
Recognise the importance of woodland and through planting and management using traditional techniques create and manage a wide diversity of habitats.
Recognise the importance of historic meadows and unimproved and semi-improved grassland close to watercourses and promote the use of permanent pasture, with low stocking density and flooding regimes to promote biodiversity and landscape enhancement.
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 5. Driving the Vision
• Turweston, • Westbury, • Mixbury, • Finmere & Evenley
Through successful design and delivery of enhancement measures, such as creating new public access, opportunities for education, art and interpretation of the landscape, biodiversity and heritage, handing back land for farming, or managing land for economic return such as woodland for fuel or opportunities for grassed areas to be opened up to grazing rights
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Landscape information
Turweston, Westbury, Mixbury, Finmere Evenley
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Landscape Boundary Treatment Concept
Characteristic regional hedges Any part of Britain which possesses hedges can be identified by them. Clues may be given by the way in which they are managed, the type of associated bank or ditch, the hedge plants, or the way in which the climate has influenced growth.
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Landscape Pond - Design Concept
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Landscape Planting
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Landscape Planting
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Increasing Biodiversity
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Landscape Planting Plan –Finmere
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Landscape Planting Plan –Finmere cont..
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Landscape Planting Plan - Mixbury
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Landscape Planting Plan – River Great Ouse (Westbury)
Culvert over river Great Ouse
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Landscape Planting Plan – Turweston Cutting (A422)
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Landscape Planting Plan – Turweston Cutting (Oatley Hall)
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Landscape Planting Plans – River Great Ouse & A43
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Operational Noise
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Operational Noise
Engagement Toolkit Noise Source Noise Modelling Information to be shared on: • Noise Source – where the noise will be generated from • Noise Modelling – how we have modelled it • Obligations – our obligations under the Obligations Mitigation Environmental Minimum Requirements and Information Paper E20 • Mitigation– how we will design and build the noise barrier, bunds Specific to the Local Area • Local Area – share a specific response to compare to the Environmental Statement noise maps
1MC071MC06-CEK-CEK-IN-SE-PRE-PRE-CS07_CL13-C002-000032-000001 Noise Source
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Noise Source
Ambient baseline Rail noise Altered Roads
Existing baseline from Assumed reasonable Assumed reasonable selected receptors worst case from train and worst case for changes to identified in the ES track roads projected to Opening Year
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Noise Source
Multi height/source method
Conventional Captive Compatible
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Noise Source
Train Types & Service Pattern
Classic Compatible • Runs on conventional lines (ECML / WCML) and HS2 • Standard rail gauge • Less aerodynamic shielding • Louder Captive • Runs of HS2 line only • Greater gauge clearance • More aerodynamic shielding Indicative Hourly Phase 2 HS2 Service Pattern • Quieter
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Track Types
ES based on ballasted track Current proposals based on slab track
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Noise Modelling
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Noise Modelling
Terms Used
Term Explanation Residential receptor Permanent residential building Non-residential receptor e.g. schools, hospitals, places of worship, and also commercial properties such as offices and hotels External Amenity Space relatively quiet outdoor areas: for sole use by residents as part of the amenity of their dwelling; protected for sole use by a limited group of residents as part of the amenity of their dwelling; or protected as publicly accessible for residents as part of the amenity of their dwelling that are nearby.
LpAFmax Maximum sound pressure at a point in time; ‘peak noise’
LpAeq,T Weighted equivalent continuous sound level measured over a defined period, T; it allows fluctuating noise levels to be described in terms of a single figure level LOAEL Lowest Observed Adverse Effect Level; established from WHO guidelines as the level at which adverse effects on health and quality of life can be detected SOAEL Significant Observed Adverse Effect Level; … the level at which significant adverse effects on health and quality of life occur
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Noise Modelling
Environmental Statement Stage
• Noise modelling undertaken by Arup based on HS1 model and further tested and validated across the a number of HSR projects • Based on reasonably foreseeable worst case, based on: • Assessment of train noise using ‘just TSI-compliant train’ • Train paths based on Phase 1, then Phase 2 operations including operating speed 330 kph in 90% cases • Terrain model based on existing surfaces • Uses alignment based on HS2 Act to profile viaducts, cuttings and embankments to derive noise impacts • Determined initial requirements for mitigation • Wayside barriers • Earthworks • Viaduct barriers
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Noise Modelling
MWCC Design Stage
• Noise model recreated by MWCC teams environment and validated by HS2 supported by Arup • Includes: • Updated assessment of train noise and track for noise source • Train paths based on Phase 1 and Phase 2 operations including operating speed 330 kph in 90% cases • Terrain model based on existing surfaces • Uses alignment based on MWCC Scheme Design to provide updated impacts • Determines updated requirements for mitigation • Mitigation proposals to be submitted to local planning authority through Schedule 17 • Including preparation of a Noise Demonstration Report to satisfy LPA
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Noise Mitigation – our obligations
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Noise Mitigation Obligations
Environmental HS2 Information Specific Minimum Paper E20 – Control Undertakings and Requirements of Airborne Assurances (EMR) Noise…
Overriding obligation to To reduce airborne noise May be required subject to mitigate any additional from the operational circumstances significant adverse effect railway as far as is … e.g. specific height reasonably practicable barriers
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Information Paper E20
Control of Airborne Noise
• The nominated undertaker will take all reasonable steps to design and construct altered roads, and to design, construct, operate and maintain the operational railway so that the combined airborne noise from these sources, predicted in all reasonably foreseeable circumstances, does not exceed the lowest observed adverse effect levels (LOAEL)
• Where it is not reasonably practicable to achieve this objective, the nominated undertaker will reduce airborne noise from the altered roads and the operational railway as far as is reasonably practicable
• Noise insulation will be offered with the aim that airborne noise from altered roads and the operational railway does not give rise to significant adverse effects on health and quality of life that would otherwise be expected when airborne noise exceeds the significant observed adverse effect levels (SOAEL)
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Environmental Statement
Scope & Methodology Report (SMR)
• Establishes the LOAEL and SOAEL • Further consideration for Community Effects e.g. number and grouping of dwellings, level and character of existing sound environment • Impact definition based on change to sound level: negligible 0dB to 3dB, minor 3dB to 5db, moderate 5dB to 10dB, major >10dB • Non-residential receptors also considered e.g. schools, hospitals, places of religious worship, museums, halls etc., but not external space
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Equivalent Sound Level
LpAeq,t
1MC061MC07--CEKCEK--INSE-PRE-PRE-CS07_CL13-C002-000029-000001 Noise Mitigation Design
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Noise Mitigation
Reduce noise created by Reduce noise by using Reduce noise using quieter train / shielding such as barriers or transmitted into track bunds (which would be houses by landscaped) installing sound insulation such as acoustic double glazing
Noise bund Landscaping to reduce visual Acoustic double- effects glazing*
Noise barrier Rolling Stock & Systems Eiffage Kier Noise Insulation
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Noise Barriers
Performance Requirements
• 120 yr design life • Includes absorptive layer on inside face • Designed to suit modular construction • Allow for response to local settings • Two styles; visible and non-visible
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Noise Barriers
Families
Non-visible noise barriers • Straight panels • Exposed posts • Modular panels • Plain finish
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Noise Barriers
Families
Visible noise barriers • Straight panels / cranked • Concealed posts • Modular panels • Plain or textured finish
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Noise impacts in the local area
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Environmental Statement Noise Maps
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Environmental Statement Noise Maps
Note: these maps are rail only and do not take into account altered roads
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Environmental Statement Noise Maps
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Environmental Statement Noise Maps
Note: these maps are rail only and do not take into account altered roads
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Environmental Statement Noise Maps
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Environmental Statement Noise Maps
Note: these maps are rail only and do not take into account altered roads
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Next Steps
Identify other mitigation Agree application Develop location Review outputs Update outputs measures; i.e. of CDE noise specific response with local of noise model landscape and barriers with LPA and prepare NDR communities visual
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Construction
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 1: As part of the enabling works, Fusion will 3 be upgrading junctions at the M40 Junction A43 N 10 and on the A43 to allow for the increase in traffic. Main Access Points 2: Construction Vehicles will not be able to access at this point. We will be using our Temporary Internal Access Road to access all sites Access Points within the area south of the A4421. A422 Construction A422 3: The A43 compound will be a primary Routes point of access heading north to the C3 HS2 Route section of the route. It will also be used as a primary access heading south once the overbridge has been completed. COMPOUND NAME
A421 A421
Denotes a Traffic Light Controlled Crossing A4421 for Construction Traffic
A43 Denotes a Temporary Overbridge for Construction Traffic
1 2 TRAFFIC ACCESS ROUTES 1 10
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Crown copyright and database right 2010-2019 1 Traffic Routes
HGV Routes
Entry to trace at the following intersections
1. A43 to do work north from here 2 2. A422 Brackley / Buckingham road 3. A421 by Warren farm
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL133 -000001 1 Construction Sequence
1 A43 Area
Compound and Road reconstruction
2020 1. Access from highway 2. Set up works compound 3. Site access road heading north
2021 3. A43 reconstruction
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Construction Sequence
2 A422 Area
Compound and Road reconstruction 2020 1. Access from highway 2 2. Set up works compound 3. Vegetation clearance 4. Site access road 5. Fusion demolition 6. Western Power 2021 7. Structures – Viaduct starts 2021 8. Topsoil strip & earthworks
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Construction Sequence
3 A421 Area
Compound and Road reconstruction 2020 1. Fusion scope & Western Power 2. Ground Investigation 3. Access from highway 4. Set up works compound 5. Bailey Bridge 6. Borrow Pit activity 7. Site access road heading north & South 2021 8. Start overbridge, topsoil strip, earthworks
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL133 -000001 Construction Sequence
4 A4421 Area
2020 1. Fusion scope – archaeology, ecology, fencing 2. Temporary access from highway 3. Localised vegetation clearance 4 4. Temporary bridge (Bailey) 5. Utilities / service diversions 6. Site access road 2021 7. Earthworks, start of bridge structure
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 C2 Enabling Works
Enabling works programme diagram to release assets
Ecol & veg General Temporary clearance Clearance drainage
Access Start date Asset
Temporary Access fence Road • Consents • Permanent W Design • Design of enabling W • Temp W Design Utilities Works • Procurement
63 1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Finmere Borrow Pit
Location Plan
1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Earthworks : Mass-Haul C2 – GW6
C2 – GW6 Main Direction Material from Cutting to Embankment Material from Borrow Pit (Cl1 / Cl2 / Cl2 Lp Stabilized / Cl3 / Cl3 Stabilized) (Cl1 / Cl6)
Material to landscape All materials accommodated on site Average Haul Distance 3,18 km
66 1MC07-CEK-IN-PRE-CS07_CL13-000001 Oxford canal Viaduct, Architects Impression