Tracing the Blues Metaphor in Alternative Forms of Music

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Tracing the Blues Metaphor in Alternative Forms of Music CHAPTER 4 TRACING THE BLUES METAPHOR IN ALTERNATIVE FORMS OF MUSIC INTRODUCTION Since their inception, the blues have powerfully influenced and shaped the direction of music in our country, and, it could be argued, in other countries as well. The following sections will highlight musical forms/genres through which I sense elements of the blues run strongly. These themes are part of the blues metaphor, which I will more fully describe and develop in the following sections of this chapter. I acknowledge that it may be argued that blues elements are most likely present in musical forms that I have not mentioned; I am focusing on genres wherein I perceive the blues themes and the blues metaphor as clearly resonating. THE BLUES METAPHOR IN COUNTRY MUSIC Every time I see that lonesome railroad train, It makes me wish I was going home again. (Rodgers, 1930, track 5) At the height of the popularity of the blues, a phenomenon was occurring in the field of music especially among poor White in the South, which could be described as the beginning of the musical genre I will refer to as country music. Issues concerning class were being openly brought forth with the emergence of country yodelers, such as Jimmy Rodgers. While recorded musical history tends to frame this almost exclusively as a White form of musical expression, there are indications that yodeling as a form of music was not exclusive to White Southerners in our country, but reached a universal core of humanity. Plantanga (2004) comments about yodeling as a broad musical genre, suggesting its ability to assist the yodeler in transcendence from the concerns of his life. He describes its universality in reaching the spiritual side of yodelers regardless of their geographical location, allowing the yodelers to find a sense of their geographical location, and allowing the yodelers to attain inner harmony through the musical expression of harmony through the yodel. Yodeling has precedents in not only in European mountainous regions, but also in Africa. Indeed, yodeling is incorporated into performance of the Baka in present day Africa (Bundo, 2001). The connections between yodeling and its popularity as a White form of music and connection with Black forms of music can be exemplified by examining the works of popular White country singers in the early twentieth century. 61 CHAPTER 4 Jimmie Rodgers was well known for his blue yodels and country songs, but he also sang blues songs as well. Despite an early death from tuberculosis, a disease from which he suffered throughout most of his career, he was prolific with regards to the number of songs and recordings that he produced. In addition, he was the first country singer to make a recording with a Black instrumentalist as a backup; these were extremely segregated times, yet his work includes Louis Armstrong playing cornet on Rodger’s song “Blue Yodel Number 9,” and the Black Mississippi bluesman, Clifford Gibson (Mcwhiney & Mills, 1983). Even the popular representation in images and photographs of Jimmie Rodgers crossed between those of popular Black male blues singers to the railway man that he was in his twenties. In the one popular photograph, he was dressed quite sharply, as were the Black bluesmen so often in their publicity photographs. However, in other shots, he is dressed in a railway worker’s uniform, matching the subject matter of many of his songs. Still others show him in a broad brimmed cowboy hat, matching another description of him as the singing cowboy. Black singers who were known for their blues singing were also known to yodel. Tommy Johnson, a well-known Delta bluesmen, made a test pressing for Paramount records that consisted of two versions of a cowboy yodeling song, complete with the flat picking style typified by Jimmie Rodgers (Wald, 2004). While recording studios generally reserved recording these Black artists as blues singers only (Wald, 2004), some White artists were advertised as yodelers in the Black newspaper, The Chicago Defender. Interestingly, the depictions of these artists in the advertisements in Black newspapers were as Black men, either in Black face, or sketched as Black men (Vocalion, 1929). This was most likely connected to the marketing strategies of the White record producers trying to glean as much profit as possible from their race record market. Beyond the yodeling, country music also shared similar subject matter and themes with traditional blues. Bessie Smith was singing “Black Mountain Blues,” and suggesting violence as a way to resolve a broken heart, talking about using a razor or a gun against her unfaithful lover, noting I’m gonna cut him if he stands, I’m gonna shoot him if he runs. (Johnson, 1930) Jimmie Rodgers puts forth a similar sentiment in “T for Texas”, also known as Blue Yodel Number 1, singing about a disastrous relationship with Thelma, noting that he would Buy me a pistol, long as I am tall, Gonna shoot po’ Thelma Just to see her jump and fall” (Rodgers, 1927, Track 1) 62 .
Recommended publications
  • Million Dollar Quartet” by Colin Escott & Floyd Mutrux at the Hippodrome Theatre Through December 2
    “Million Dollar Quartet” By Colin Escott & Floyd Mutrux At the Hippodrome Theatre through December 2 By James Cooper MEMORIES ARE MADE OF THIS … PRODUCTION Flashing lights, shimmering jackets and long musical solos radiate through the production of “Million Dollar Quartet,” now at the Hippodrome Theatre. Though the special effects and costumes are beneficial in some instances, the show lacks emphasis in the one area it should stress the most: the music. The whole story focuses on the decisions of four major musicians from the 1950s: Carl Perkins, Johnny Cash, Jerry Lee Lewis and Elvis Presley. Music is the main concept within the script, but it certainly isn’t the main concept within the performance. The show focuses on a single event: the night that all four musicians of the “Million Dollar Quartet” were present in the same space at the same time, the Sun Records Studio in Memphis on December 4, 1956. Elvis (Cody Slaughter) used to be a member of the Sun Records family but then he switched to RCA, a bigger label. Since this change, Elvis has lost contact with his former producer, Sam Phillips (Vince Nappo). As Elvis returns with his girlfriend Dyanne (Kelly Lamont) he makes it clear to Sam that he wishes he had stayed at Sun. Sam too wishes that Elvis had stayed, but his main focus is now on producing Johnny (David Elkins) and the up-and-coming Jerry Lee (Martin Kaye). All the while Carl (Robert Britton Lyons) has to decide whether or not he wants to leave Sun Records or move on to Columbia.
    [Show full text]
  • Reporter 11 21.Indd
    November 21, 2005 SACS Liaison: Western is English Professor’s Passion for Animals Making Good Progress Recognized by State Volunteer Award Westernʼs reaccreditation The discovery of five puppies in a trash But the volunteer work takes up most efforts are on target and bin eight years ago sparked the passion for of Adamsʼ free time and can be draining. the university is making animal rescue that grips Mary Adams. “Thereʼs such a need,” she said. “Some good progress toward The young boxers abandoned on a tall placements fall through, and you have to reaffirmation in 2007. pile of debris went home with the associate take them back. Thatʼs always hard.” Thatʼs the word from professor of English and stayed until Whatʼs fulfilling, though, is seeing an Ann Chard, a vice permanent homes could be found. animal go to a good home. president of the Commission “They went very quick,” said Adams. Adams watched a dog make fast friends on Colleges for the Southern Association The puppies with a visiting of Colleges and Schools, after her Monday, were the first of Airedale and Nov. 14, visit to Cullowhee. about 500 cats and convinced the On campus to review the status of dogs that Adams has visitorʼs owner that Westernʼs reaccreditation efforts, Chard fostered and placed the pair should not met with Chancellor John W. Bardo, through the Humane be parted. Provost Kyle R. Carter, the universityʼs Society of Jackson “They just fell in executive council and the combined SACS County, or ARF. love,” said Adams of committees. She also heard from members For her service, the two dogs.
    [Show full text]
  • What the Experts Say About Mississippi Music
    What The Experts Say Blues in Mississippi *Alan Lomax in his book , The Land Where the Blues Began, said, AAlthough this has been called the age of anxiety, it might better be termed the century of the blues, after the moody song style that was born sometime around 1900 in the Mississippi Delta.@ Lomax goes on to credit black Delta blues musicians by saying, ATheir productions transfixed audiences; and white performers rushed to imitate and parody them in the minstrel show, buck dancing, ragtime, jazz, as nowadays in rock, rap, and the blues.@ *While there was indeed anxiety between blacks and whites in Mississippi, at least one venue demanded mutual respect - - - - music. Robert M. Baker, author of A Brief History of the Blues, said, A...blues is a native American musical and verse form, with no direct European and African antecedents of which we know. In other words, it is a blending of both traditions.@ However, there is no question that rhythmic dance tunes brought over by slaves influenced greatly the development of the blues. Blacks took the instruments and church music from Europe and wove them with their ancestral rhythms into what we know as the blues. *Christine Wilson, in the Mississippi Department of Archives publication, All Shook Up, Mississippi Roots of American Popular Music, said, A Music that emerged from Mississippi has shaped the development of popular music of the country and world. Major innovators created new music in every form - - - gospel, blues, country, R&B, rock, and jazz.@ *William Farris in Blues From the Delta wrote, ABlues shape both popular and folk music in American culture; and blues-yodeling Jimmie Rodgers, Elvis Presley, and the Rolling Stones are among many white performers who incorporate blues in their singing styles.@ For another example, Joachim Berendt=s book, The Jazz Book, outlines the development of jazz from its blues roots.
    [Show full text]
  • Stu Davis: Canada's Cowboy Troubadour
    Stu Davis: Canada’s Cowboy Troubadour by Brock Silversides Stu Davis was an immense presence on Western Canada’s country music scene from the late 1930s to the late 1960s. His is a name no longer well-known, even though he was continually on the radio and television waves regionally and nationally for more than a quarter century. In addition, he released twenty-three singles, twenty albums, and published four folios of songs: a multi-layered creative output unmatched by most of his contemporaries. Born David Stewart, he was the youngest son of Alex Stewart and Magdelena Fawns. They had emigrated from Scotland to Saskatchewan in 1909, homesteading on Twp. 13, Range 15, west of the 2nd Meridian.1 This was in the middle of the great Regina Plain, near the town of Francis. The Stewarts Sales card for Stu Davis (Montreal: RCA Victor Co. Ltd.) 1948 Library & Archives Canada Brock Silversides ([email protected]) is Director of the University of Toronto Media Commons. 1. Census of Manitoba, Saskatchewan and Alberta 1916, Saskatchewan, District 31 Weyburn, Subdistrict 22, Township 13 Range 15, W2M, Schedule No. 1, 3. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License. CAML REVIEW / REVUE DE L’ACBM 47, NO. 2-3 (AUGUST-NOVEMBER / AOÛT-NOVEMBRE 2019) PAGE 27 managed to keep the farm going for more than a decade, but only marginally. In 1920 they moved into Regina where Alex found employment as a gardener, then as a teamster for the City of Regina Parks Board. The family moved frequently: city directories show them at 1400 Rae Street (1921), 1367 Lorne North (1923), 929 Edgar Street (1924-1929), 1202 Elliott Street (1933-1936), 1265 Scarth Street for the remainder of the 1930s, and 1178 Cameron Street through the war years.2 Through these moves the family kept a hand in farming, with a small farm 12 kilometres northwest of the city near the hamlet of Boggy Creek, a stone’s throw from the scenic Qu’Appelle Valley.
    [Show full text]
  • Appreciation of Popular Music 1/2
    FREEHOLD REGIONAL HIGH SCHOOL DISTRICT OFFICE OF CURRICULUM AND INSTRUCTION MUSIC DEPARTMENT APPRECIATION OF POPULAR MUSIC 1/2 Grade Level: 10-12 Credits: 2.5 each section BOARD OF EDUCATION ADOPTION DATE: AUGUST 30, 2010 SUPPORTING RESOURCES AVAILABLE IN DISTRICT RESOURCE SHARING APPENDIX A: ACCOMMODATIONS AND MODIFICATIONS APPENDIX B: ASSESSMENT EVIDENCE APPENDIX C: INTERDISCIPLINARY CONNECTIONS Course Philosophy “Musical training is a more potent instrument than any other, because rhythm, harmony, and melody find their way into the inward place of our soul, on which they mightily fasten, imparting grace, and making the soul of him who is educated graceful.” - Plato We believe our music curriculum should provide quality experiences that are musically meaningful to the education of all our students. It should help them discover, understand and enjoy music as an art form, an intellectual endeavor, a medium of self-expression, and a means of social growth. Music is considered basic to the total educational program. To each new generation this portion of our heritage is a source of inspiration, enjoyment, and knowledge which helps to shape a way of life. Our music curriculum enriches and maintains this life and draws on our nation and the world for its ever- expanding course content, taking the student beyond the realm of the ordinary, everyday experience. Music is an art that expresses emotion, indicates mood, and helps students to respond to their environment. It develops the student’s character through its emphasis on responsibility, self-discipline, leadership, concentration, and respect for and awareness of the contributions of others. Music contains technical, psychological, artistic, and academic concepts.
    [Show full text]
  • MARCH 20, 2006 ARTIST GENE AUTRY TITLE That Silver Haired
    SHIPPING DATE: MARCH 20, 2006 ARTIST GENE AUTRY TITLE That Silver Haired Daddy Of Mine LABEL Bear Family Records CATALOG # BCD 15944 PRICE-CODE IL EAN-CODE 4000127 159441 ISBN-CODE 3-89916-180-7 FORMAT 9-CD Box-Set (LP-size) with 100-page hardcover book GENRE Western TRACKS 225 PLAYING TIME 659:06 SALES NOTES Very few people know that Gene Autry...America’s beloved Singing Cowboy, began his career as the writer and performer of authentic white country blues. While working as a telegrapher for the St. Louis and San Francisco Railroad - the Frisco Line - he used a railroad pass to travel to New York in 1929, hoping to follow his dream of competing with the top pop singers of the day. Instead, on the advice of Frankie and Johnny Marvin, and legendary producer Arthur Satherley, Autry used his talent to emulate Jimmie Rodgers. No other performer caught the essence of Jimmie Rodgers as Autry did. He could match Rodgers' yodel, Mississippi dialect and guitar runs so closely that it was often hard to tell the two apart. Yet, as he performed more and more original songs in the Rodgers style, he began to develop a sound of his own. Producing records for a variety of labels such as Gennett, Victor, and Columbia, as well as various low budget labels ('dime-store platters') owned by ARC, Gene sold lots of records during the Depression when people could least afford to buy them. In the early 1930s, Gene with the guidance of his mentor Jimmy Long and Art Satherley, moved from blues to the more traditional hillbilly music of the time.
    [Show full text]
  • Exposing Minstrelsy and Racial Representation Within American Tap Dance Performances of The
    UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA Los Angeles Masks in Disguise: Exposing Minstrelsy and Racial Representation within American Tap Dance Performances of the Stage, Screen, and Sound Cartoon, 1900-1950 A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree Doctor of Philosophy in Culture and Performance by Brynn Wein Shiovitz 2016 © Copyright by Brynn Wein Shiovitz 2016 ABSTRACT OF THE DISSERTATION Masks in Disguise: Exposing Minstrelsy and Racial Representation within American Tap Dance Performances of the Stage, Screen, and Sound Cartoon, 1900-1950 by Brynn Wein Shiovitz Doctor of Philosophy in Culture and Performance University of California, Los Angeles, 2016 Professor Susan Leigh Foster, Chair Masks in Disguise: Exposing Minstrelsy and Racial Representation within American Tap Dance Performances of the Stage, Screen, and Sound Cartoon, 1900-1950, looks at the many forms of masking at play in three pivotal, yet untheorized, tap dance performances of the twentieth century in order to expose how minstrelsy operates through various forms of masking. The three performances that I examine are: George M. Cohan’s production of Little Johnny ii Jones (1904), Eleanor Powell’s “Tribute to Bill Robinson” in Honolulu (1939), and Terry- Toons’ cartoon, “The Dancing Shoes” (1949). These performances share an obvious move away from the use of blackface makeup within a minstrel context, and a move towards the masked enjoyment in “black culture” as it contributes to the development of a uniquely American form of entertainment. In bringing these three disparate performances into dialogue I illuminate the many ways in which American entertainment has been built upon an Africanist aesthetic at the same time it has generally disparaged the black body.
    [Show full text]
  • “I Want to Be a Cowboy's Sweetheart”—Patsy Montana (1935)
    “I Want to Be a Cowboy’s Sweetheart”—Patsy Montana (1935) Added to the National Registry: 2011 Essay by Cary O’Dell Patsy Montana Early label Modern country music is usually considered to have three queens, each easily identifiable by just one name: Loretta, Tammy and Dolly. But as impressive as this trinity is, one has to wonder where that leaves some other notable musical ladies of the open plains such as Patsy Cline, Kitty Wells, and Emmylou Harris. Similarly, certainly, the great Patsy Montana is no pretender to any throne. Too often dismissed as a “one hit wonder,” due to her most famous tune, the self-penned “I Want to Be a Cowboy’s Sweetheart,” Patsy Montana actually contributed numerous songs to the country and western lexicon: “My Song of the West,” “Back on Montana Plains,” “Rodeo Sweetheart,” “When the Flowers of Montana Were Blooming,” “I Love My Daddy Too,” “That Silver-Haired Daddy of Mine,” and “I Want to Be a Cowboy's Dream,” among others. But it is her “Cowboy’s Sweetheart” for which she’s most renowned. It is believed to be country music’s first million-selling single by a female artist. A product of Hot Springs, Arkansas, the only girl of 11 children, Patsy Montana (nee Ruby Rebecca Blevins; b. 1912) started singing early and often. She also early on mastered the violin, organ and guitar. Near college age, she left Arkansas for California where enrolled in the University of the West (later renamed UCLA). Quickly though, her musical gifts began to pay dividends—she won an area talent contest and it quickly lead to regular radio appearances singing as part of an ad-hoc girl trio, the Montana Cowgirls.
    [Show full text]
  • 02. Mai 2008 KÜNSTLER VERSCHIEDENE TITEL Let Me Be Your Sidetrack the Influence
    LIEFERBAR: AB 17. März 2008 VERÖFFENTLICHUNG: 02. Mai 2008 KÜNSTLER VERSCHIEDENE TITEL Let Me Be Your Sidetrack The Influence of Jimmie Rodgers LABEL Bear Family Records KATALOG # BCD 16863 PREIS-CODE FH EAN-CODE 4000127 168634 ISBN-CODE 978-3-89916-376-6 FORMAT 6-CD Mini Box mit 188-seitigem Booklet GENRE Country / Oldtime ANZAHL TITEL 159 SPIELDAUER ca. 475 INFORMATIONEN Legenden der Country Music gibt es viele, doch keine erwies sich als so einflußreich wie Jimmie Rodgers. In weniger als sechs Jahren (1927-1933) nahm Rodgers 110 Songs auf. 108 (!) dieser Titel wurden in der Folgezeit auch von anderen Künstlern eingespielt – es begann Ende der 20er Jahre und hält noch heute an. Diese Tradition des Coverns gilt für keinen anderen historischen Country-Star, auch nicht für Hank Williams. Rodgers' Bedeutung geht weit über sein Songschreiben hinaus. Der 'Singing Brakeman' ließ in seine Interpretationen auch ein bluesiges Element einfließen – etwas, das auf die Karrieren unzähliger anderer Country-Sänger nachhaltig einwirkte. Rodgers' Aufnahmen sind Beweis dafür, daß es musikalische Stilverschmelzungen auch schon vor Elvis Presley bzw. Sun Records gegeben hat. Zum Gedenken an Jimmie Rodgers' 75. Todestag dokumentiert Bear Family die Bedeutung dieses Künstlers in Form einer eindrucksvollen Zusammenstellung mit Cover-Versionen – von Country-Ikonen wie Gene Autry, Jimmie Davis, Hank Snow, Lefty Frizzell, Willie Nelson, Johnny Cash, Marty Robbins, Bill Monroe, Merle Haggard und Ernest Tubb bis hin zu Pop- und Rock-Größen wie Bob Dylan, Van Morrison, Rick Nelson, Jerry Lee Lewis und Jerry Garcia. Eine solche Compilation – mit 159 Titeln auf 6 CDs – gab es noch nie: Sie ehrt auf angemessene Weise das beeindruckende musikalische Erbe des Jimmie Rodgers.
    [Show full text]
  • Cowboys and Indians: the International Stage the International Stage the International Cowboyscowboys and Indians: and Indians: the International Stage Craig D
    Hillis: Cowboys and Indians: The International Stage The International Stage Cowboys and Indians: Cowboys and Indians: The International Stage Craig D. Hillis 16 Bob Livingston in his A Photo by Bruce Jordan Bruce Photo by ustin office surrounded by instruments collected fr om around the world. Produced by The Berkeley Electronic Press, 2002 1 Journal of Texas Music History, Vol. 2 [2002], Iss. 1, Art. 3 The International Stage Cowboys and Indians: Cowboys There are countless cultural innovations and popular products recognized around the world as uniquely American. Whether with the blues, the Big Mac, tailfins on Cadillacs, or the legacy of space travel, the United States continually astounds and, from time to time, confounds the world with its prolific cultural productivity. Things American are everywhere, at least anywhere a radio wave can reach a receiver or a satellite signal can touch a television set, and two of the most ubiquitous Yankee exports are the mythical cowboy of the Wild West and country music. Bob Livingston, an accomplished Austin musician, has helped to shape these singular institutions into an effective tool of American diplomacy. Since 1986, Livingston has toured extensively in South Asia and the Middle East as an emissary of the State Department of the United States presenting a musical program he calls “Cowboys and Indians.” He describes his mission (with his tongue only partially in his cheek) as an attempt “to achieve world peace through cowboy songs and yodeling.”1 Livingston’s ambitious crusade has touched the lives of thousands around the world by offering a refreshing and holistic view of American culture.
    [Show full text]
  • RADIO and TELEVISION MIRROR, Published Monthly by MACFADDEN PUBLICATIONS, INC., Washington and South Avenues, Dunellen, New Jersey
    k MACUODIN runic ATION MAY M/RRORMID TELEVISION l-CRET ROMANCE -The Radio Star in ALICE FAYE'S Life F ,s LIFE CAN BE BEAUTIFUL ^a,g IkeLe smoke ol Olower-JJurningOlower-iji LameLCamels gives you EXTRA MILDNESS, EXTRA COOLNESS, EXTRA FLAVOR am LESS NICOTINE than the average of the four other largest-selling cigarettes tested — less than any of them — according to in- dependent scientific tests of the smoke itself. THE SMOKE'S THE THING! A LL that you get from a cigarette — you ./jLget in the smoke itself. And here's what you get when you smoke slower-burn- ing Camels. More mildness where you want mildness. ..in the smoke. More flavor where you want flavor . .in the smoke. More coolness, too! In the same slow smoke of a Camel cig- arette, you get less nicotine. Yes, 28% less nicotine than the average of the four other largest-selling brands tested... less nicotine than from any of them. Dealers feature Camels by the carton. For convenience — for economy — get your Camels by the carton. K. J. Reynolds Tobacco Company, Winston-Salem, North Carolina 'Camels taste like the cigarette they are ... a finer BY BURNING 25% cigarette of real mildness, wonderful flavor!" SLOWER than the average of the 4 other MRS. EDWARD M. McILVAIN, Jr., of New York largest-selling brands • A lover of home life, Mrs. Mcllvain furniture and silver. She also likes tested . slower than enjoys running a household. ..enter- candid photography. movies . .con- any of them . Camels also give you a smoking taining small groups of friends.
    [Show full text]
  • Whither Cowboy Poetry?
    University of Nebraska - Lincoln DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln Great Plains Quarterly Great Plains Studies, Center for 1999 WHITHER COWBOY POETRY? Jim Hoy Emporia State University Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/greatplainsquarterly Part of the Other International and Area Studies Commons Hoy, Jim, "WHITHER COWBOY POETRY?" (1999). Great Plains Quarterly. 902. https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/greatplainsquarterly/902 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Great Plains Studies, Center for at DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. It has been accepted for inclusion in Great Plains Quarterly by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. WHITHER COWBOY POETRY? JIM HOY As a cultural phenomenon the explosion in high-heeled boots, silk neckerchief, leather popularity of cowboy poetry in the past dozen chaps-has long since become an icon that years has been nothing short of spectacular. represents the very nation: wear a cowboy hat Until the first full-scale cowboy poetry gath­ and you will be taken for an American any­ ering at Elko, Nevada, in late January 1985, where in the world. The two essential working poetry was arguably the one aspect of cowboy skills of the cowboy-roping cattle and riding culture that had not been expropriated into bucking horses-long ago have been trans­ American popular culture. Certainly the men­ formed from actual ranch work into one of the tal picture of the cowboy himself-big hat, nation's largest spectator and participant sports: rodeo. And the idealized, romanticized image of the cowboy (certainly far removed from the low-paid, hard-working hired man on horseback who actually works with cows, horses, and four-wheel-drive pickups) has be­ come, through pulp fiction, television, and James F.
    [Show full text]