Crystal Engineering Rescues a Solution Organic Synthesis in a Cocrystallization That Confirms the Configuration of a Molecular Ladder
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Crystal engineering rescues a solution organic synthesis in a cocrystallization that confirms the configuration of a molecular ladder Manza B. J. Atkinsona, S. V. Santhana Mariappana,b, Dejan-Krešimir Bučara, Jonas Baltrusaitisa, Tomislav Friščića, Naif G. Sinadaa, and Leonard R. MacGillivraya,1 aDepartment of Chemistry, University of Iowa, Iowa City, IA 52242-1294; and bCentral NMR Facility, University of Iowa, Iowa City, IA 52242-1294 Edited by Jack Halpern, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL, and approved May 19, 2011 (received for review March 19, 2011) Treatment of an achiral molecular ladder of C2h symmetry com- posed of five edge-sharing cyclobutane rings, or a [5]-ladderane, with acid results in cis-totrans-isomerization of end pyridyl groups. Solution NMR spectroscopy and quantum chemical calcula- tions support the isomerization to generate two diastereomers. The NMR data, however, could not lead to unambiguous configura- tional assignments of the two isomers. Single-crystal X-ray diffrac- tion was employed to determine each configuration. One isomer readily crystallized as a pure form and X-ray diffraction revealed Scheme 1 the molecule as being achiral based on Ci symmetry. The second isomer resisted crystallization under a variety of conditions. Con- 2 þ 2 sequently, a strategy based on a cocrystallization was developed assemblies for [ ] photocycloadditions that generate [3]- and [5]-ladderanes (12). Cocrystallization of 5-methoxyresorcinol to generate single crystals of the second isomer. Cocrystallization trans of the isomer with a carboxylic acid readily afforded single crystals (5-OMe-res) with either an all- -4-pyridyl-substituted 1,4- that confirmed a chiral ladderane based on C symmetry. The chiral butadiene or 1,6-hexatriene yielded assemblies of composition 2 2ðtemplateÞ · 2ðpolyeneÞ. UV-irradiation produced the corre- ladderane and acid self-assembled to generate a five-component n hydrogen-bonded complex that packs to form large solvent-filled sponding end-functionalized C2h-symmetric ladderane 4-pyr[ ]- homochiral channels of nanometer-scale dimensions. Whereas co- lad stereospecifically, in quantitative yield, and in gram amounts. The ladderanes we generate in the solid state are cumbersome to crystallizations are frequently applied to structure determinations make using conventional solution methods of organic synthesis. of proteins, our study represents the first application of a cocrys- Difficulties are evidenced by the fact that ladderanes lacking in- tallization to confirm the relative configuration of a small-molecule ternal functional groups, such as those in the natural products, diastereomer generated in a solution-phase organic synthesis. are rare, with exceptions being ladderanes derived from intramo- lecular reactions of cyclophanes (14, 15). Recent reports by Corey supramolecular synthesis ∣ solid-state reactivity ∣ hydrogen bonding and coworkers on the first total and enantioselective syntheses of ladderane lipids in the form of (Æ)-pentacycloanammoxic acid, rystal engineering involves the rational design of solids with as well as attempted syntheses from polyenes in solution and the Cpredictable and/or tunable properties (1, 2). During the past solid state, highlight these difficulties (19–21). two decades, crystal engineering has undergone remarkable In this paper, we report an application of a cocrystallization to growth with applications in areas such as catalysis (3), energy sto- determine the relative configuration of a chiral ladderane gener- rage (4), electronics (5, 6), and pharmaceutics (7, 8). A burgeon- ated in a solution-phase isomerization. Our interests lie in using ing area in the field of crystal engineering involves the design and ladderanes synthesized in the solid state as precursors to the – properties of cocrystals (7 11). Cocrystals are multicomponent natural lipids. During experiments to treat 4-pyr-[5]-lad with solids with organic compounds assembled in combination to form acid, the terminal pyridyl groups were determined to undergo a a crystalline solid with properties different than the individual cis-totrans-isomerization that generates two isomers. Multidi- components (9–11). A cocrystal typically consists of a target mensional solution NMR spectroscopy—a tool commonly used molecule crystallized with a second molecule, or cocrystal former to elucidate the structures of organic molecules—supported the (CCF), employed to influence properties of the target (e.g., isomerization, along with quantum chemical calculations, to solubility, conductivity). The CCF interacts with the target via produce two diastereomers; namely, achiral 1a and chiral 1b intermolecular forces (e.g., hydrogen bonding) that serve to unite (Scheme 2). The NMR data, however, could not be used to un- and hold the components together. ambiguously determine the relative configuration of each isomer In this context, we have described a cocrystal approach to owing to close structural similarities of the two molecules. synthesize [n]-ladderanes (where: n ¼ 3 or 5) in the solid state (12, 13). The [n]-ladderanes are rod-shaped molecules composed of n edge-fused cyclobutane rings that define a molecular equiva- Author contributions: M.B.J.A., S.V.S.M., D.-K.B., J.B., and L.R.M. designed research; M.B.J.A., S.V.S.M., D.-K.B., J.B., and N.G.S. performed research; M.B.J.A., S.V.S.M., D.-K.B., lent of a macroscopic ladder (14, 15) (Scheme 1). Ladderanes J.B., T.F., and L.R.M. analyzed data; and M.B.J.A. and L.R.M. wrote the paper. are promising building blocks in optoelectronics and have been The authors declare no conflict of interest. recently discovered as building blocks of natural products, being This article is a PNAS Direct Submission. present as lipids in anammox (anaerobic ammonium oxidizing) – Data deposition: The crystallography, atomic coordinates, and structure factors have been marine bacteria (16 18). The ladderane lipids serve a structural deposited in the Cambridge Structural Database, Cambridge Crystallographic Data Centre role of providing extraordinary rigidity to internal membrane (CCDC), Cambridge CB2 1EZ, United Kingdom (CSD reference nos. 768180 and 768181). components. More specifically, we have shown that a CCF based 1To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail: [email protected]. on 1,3-dihydroxybenzene, or resorcinol (res), acts as a template This article contains supporting information online at www.pnas.org/lookup/suppl/ to assemble polyenes via hydrogen bonds into supramolecular doi:10.1073/pnas.1104352108/-/DCSupplemental. 10974–10979 ∣ PNAS ∣ July 5, 2011 ∣ vol. 108 ∣ no. 27 www.pnas.org/cgi/doi/10.1073/pnas.1104352108 Downloaded by guest on September 23, 2021 are difficult to obtain and structure cannot be confirmed using spectroscopic methods alone. Results and Discussion Our study begins with achiral C2h-symmetric 4-pyr-[5]-lad, which is obtained using 5-OMe-res as a template. Treatment of a related rctt-monocyclobutane was reported (28) to result in a cis-totrans- isomerization of pyridyl groups to give the rtct-stereoisomer in quantitative yield. Our goal was to determine if treatment of 4-pyr-[5]-lad with acid could generate more complex ladderanes as products. When 4-pyr-[5]-lad, upon removal from the template, was reacted with glacial acetic acid (AcOH) for 12 h at 50 °C, a 1H NMR spectrum suggested that the ladderane underwent an iso- Scheme 2 merization (Fig. 1). An isomerization was evidenced by the dis- appearance of peaks of 4-pyr-[5]-lad and multiplication of the 1H resonances in the pyridyl (7.00–8.50 ppm) and polycyclobutyl Thus, to confirm the structures of the two ladderanes, we turned (2.40–4.50 ppm) regions (Fig. 1A). A 1H-1H COSY spectrum of to single-crystal X-ray diffraction. Moreover, whereas one isomer the reaction mixture revealed 12 groups of resonances in the poly- readily crystallized and was confirmed as achiral 1a, the second cyclobutyl region with two sets of six groups being of the same isomer resisted crystallization under a variety of conditions. To relative intensity and correlated as two separate J-coupling net- circumvent difficulties to obtain single crystals, we revisited prin- works (Fig. 1B). The two coupling networks suggested the reac- tion generated two isomers in a 1∶1 ratio. When the reaction was ciples of crystal engineering by employing a cocrystallization 1 (Scheme 3). Cocrystallizations are often used to determine struc- conducted at 25 °C, the H NMR spectrum was more complex tures of biomolecules (e.g., proteins) (22), yet applications to par- with additional resonances in both the pyridyl and polycyclobutyl SI Text allel problems involving small molecules have been less explored, regions ( ). Collectively, our observations are consistent with absolute structure determinations of steroids (23, 24) and, with the terminal 4-pyridyl groups of 4-pyr-[5]-lad undergoing an acid-catalyzed cis-totrans-isomerization that initially generated more recently, separations and structure determinations of natur- partially isomerized unsymmetrical ladderanes that converted to al products (25, 26) and a bicyclobutyl being the only examples two symmetrical isomers in equal amounts. (27). Here, a cocrystallization of the second isomer with 3,5-dini- In principle, a cis-totrans-conversion of the end groups of trobenzoic acid (3,5-DNBA) readily afforded single crystals that 4-pyr-[5]-lad can generate two stereoisomers. One isomer 1a enabled the relative configuration of chiral 1b to be confirmed. contains pyridyl groups that point in opposite directions at the The isomer 1b details a unique case wherein chirality of a ladder- top and bottom halves of the molecule. The isomer 1a is achiral, ane is generated from the dispositions of identical end substitu- being based on inversion symmetry (Ci symmetry). The second CHEMISTRY ents. The components of the cocrystal form a hydrogen-bonded complex that packs to give a homochiral solid with solvent-filled channels of nanometer-scale dimensions. We expect the cocrystal approach described here to be applicable to similar problems of structure determination in organic chemistry where single crystals Fig. 1. NMR spectra of reaction of 4-pyr-[5]-lad with AcOH.