The Freddie Gray Uprising: Persistence and Desistance Narratives of Community-Engaged Returning Citizens
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
City University of New York (CUNY) CUNY Academic Works All Dissertations, Theses, and Capstone Projects Dissertations, Theses, and Capstone Projects 2-2020 The Freddie Gray Uprising: Persistence and Desistance Narratives of Community-Engaged Returning Citizens Maurice Vann The Graduate Center, City University of New York How does access to this work benefit ou?y Let us know! More information about this work at: https://academicworks.cuny.edu/gc_etds/3588 Discover additional works at: https://academicworks.cuny.edu This work is made publicly available by the City University of New York (CUNY). Contact: [email protected] THE FREDDIE GRAY UPRISING: PERSISTENCE AND DESISTANCE NARRATIVES OF COMMUNITY-ENGAGED RETURNING CITIZENS by MAURICE VANN, SR. A dissertation submitted to the Graduate Faculty in Social Welfare in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy, The City University of New York 2020 ii © 2020 MAURICE VANN SR. All Rights Reserved iii The Freddie Gray Uprising: Persistence and Desistance Narratives of Community-Engaged Returning Citizens by Maurice Vann, Sr. This manuscript has been read and accepted for the Graduate Faculty in Social Welfare in satisfaction of the dissertation requirement for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. Vicki Lens Date Chair of Examining Committee Harriet Goodman Date Executive Officer Supervisory Committee: Full Name: Vicki Lens Full Name: Harriet Goodman Full Name: Lila Kazemian THE CITY UNIVERSITY OF NEW YORK iv Abstract The Freddie Gray Uprising: Persistence and Desistance Narratives of Community-Engaged Returning Citizens by Maurice Vann, Sr. Advisor: Vicki Lens This study explored how selected returning citizens in Baltimore who experienced the Freddie Gray Uprising of 2015 quelled community violence, stopped looting, and cleaned up the community in the aftermath made meaning of their experiences of the unrest. The central purpose of this study was to collect and analyze the life stories of returning citizens in Baltimore who experienced the Uprising. These men who had been incarcerated for between 5 and 20 years responded to government officials who called on them to quell violence in their neighborhoods that stemmed from the in-custody homicide of Freddie Gray. The informants provided narratives that expressed how they made meaning of their experiences during and after the Uprising. One way this occurred was through their experience of community divisions, which validated the long-standing tensions between the police and community members in the Penn-North and Sandtown-Winchester neighborhoods. These men reported both short-term and long-term benefits the Uprising had on community unity despite the turmoil. For some, the unrest that harmed the community also served as a catalyst for the community to heal, come together, and become the caring community they recalled from their childhoods. In addition, participants described how helping during and after the Uprising shaped their self-narratives and how different forms of helping influenced their growth/ transformations. v The actions of the informants in this study spanned the spectrum of helping through relational actions such as normal mentoring to helping through political action, advocacy, or civic actions such as cleaning up the neighborhood. There were differences in arrests following the Uprising for those who helped through relational actions, political actions, and civic actions. Participants who helped through relational actions and political actions were more likely to report reoffending post-Uprising than those who helped through civic actions. vi TABLE OF CONTENTS CHAPTER I: INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................... 1 Conservative Frontlash and the Carceral State ........................................................................... 8 White Liberal Contributions to the Carceral State .................................................................... 11 Black Middle-Class and the Carceral State ............................................................................... 13 Decarceration Policies ............................................................................................................... 15 CHAPTER III: BALTIMORE - BACKGROUND AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT ................ 20 Racial Hostilities and Segregation ............................................................................................ 20 Race and Class .......................................................................................................................... 22 Policing, Corrections, and Baltimore Street Gangs................................................................... 25 Black Masculinity ..................................................................................................................... 27 Summary……………. .............................................................................................................. 30 CHAPTER IV: REOFFENDING, RECIDIVISM, AND REENTRY .......................................... 31 Incarceration and Reoffending .................................................................................................. 32 Reentry…… .............................................................................................................................. 33 Healthcare…….......................................................................................................................... 34 Education/Employment ............................................................................................................. 37 Housing…… ............................................................................................................................. 40 Conclusion…………….. ........................................................................................................... 42 CHAPTER V: THEORETICAL LITERATURE REVIEW......................................................... 43 Stigma…………….................................................................................................................... 43 Moral Exclusion ........................................................................................................................ 45 Class Conflict/Conflict Theory ................................................................................................. 48 Black Baltimore Communities and Class Conflict ................................... 48 Conflict Theory and Police Violence ........................................................ 49 Growth and Transformations .................................................................................................... 50 Identity Theory of Desistance (ITD)......................................................................................... 52 Change in Self-Narratives ......................................................................................................... 53 Trends in Research on Desistence Narratives ........................................................................... 56 Generativity…………………................................................................................................... 57 vii Conclusion… ............................................................................................................................. 59 CHAPTER VI: METHODOLOGY .............................................................................................. 61 Narrative Tradition of Qualitative Research ............................................................................. 61 A Narrative Study of Lives Approach....................................................................................... 62 Study Site……….. .................................................................................................................... 63 Informant Recruitment and Sampling ....................................................................................... 64 Data Collection .......................................................................................................................... 66 Credibility and Trustworthiness ................................................................................................ 68 Data Analysis ............................................................................................................................ 69 Summary………….. ................................................................................................................. 71 CHAPTER VII: LAW ENFORCEMENT, REOFFENDING, AND GROWTH ......................... 72 Correctional Officer Indifference .............................................................................................. 76 Correctional Officers Complicity .............................................................................................. 80 Correctional Officers Abuse...................................................................................................... 85 Probation/Parole Officers and Narratives of Growth ................................................................ 87 Summary………….. ................................................................................................................. 94 CHAPTER VIII: DESISTANCE AND TRANSFORMATIONS ................................................ 97 Civic Engagement/ Helping .................................................................................................... 100 Relational Actions and “Informal” Mentoring