Dynamics of Intimacies in Alice Munro’s ‘Runaway’
A
Dissertation Submitted to Department of English
For the complete fulfilment of the degree of
Master of Arts
in
English
Submitted by: Supervised By:
Rimsy Ms. Priyanka Sharma
Registration No:11605805 Assistant Professor
Department of English
Lovely Professional University
Punjab
2017
DECLARATION
I hereby declare that this dissertation entitle ―Dynamics of Intimacies in Alice Munro‘s
Runaway‖ is a record of first hand research work done by me during the period of my study in the year 2017 and that this dissertation has not formed the basis for the award of any other
Degree, Diploma, Associate ship, Fellowship, or other similar title.
Place: Jalandhar Signature of the Candidate
Date:
ii
CERTIFICATE
I hereby certify that this dissertation entitle ―Dynamics of Intimacies in Alice Munro‘s
Runaway‖ by Alice Munro for the award of M.A. degree is a record of research work done by the candidate under my supervision during the period of her subject (2017) and that the dissertation has not formed the basis for the award of any other Degree, Diploma, Associate ship, Fellowship, or other similar title and that this dissertation represents independent work on the part of the candidate.
Place: Jalandhar Miss Priyanka Sharma
Date: Supervisor
iii
ABSTRACT
Alice Munro is regarded as Canadian pure short story writer. Her writing can help enlightening man centric structures which entangle women in traditional gender roles. This dissertation deals with well know work of Alice Munro that is Runaway Stories. This dissertation represents the Dynamics of Intimacies in the relationships in the Runaway
Stories. The introduction parts represent the brief introduction of Alice Munro with brief information of her work, brief plots of her stories, scope of study and objectives of this dissertation. First chapter includes intimacies between Mothers and Daughters, Juliet trilogy.
It also includes the quest of women for their identity.
The second chapter include struggle of women to move beyond traditional gender roles: to leave and to return. It also informs about the insurmountable female quest, Struggle for their selfhood, Low-lying temptation of Runaway or Envisioning a female quest. Last chapter is conclusion which gives a discourse about how desires, put upon ladies by a male centric culture, influence sex development.
iv
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
My sincere gratitude is to my supervisor Miss Priyanka Sharma under whose expert guidance, I completed this dissertation. It would have been very difficult to complete the project without her valuable support and guidance. She had been very helpful to me in giving suggestion in my research project.
I would also like to thank Dr. Ajoy Batta, Head of the Department of English for his support and valuable advice.
I owe my greatest dept to my parents who encourage me to work hard. I also put on my record my thanks to my family and friends for their love, affection, support and encouragement.
v
Dedication
―To my beloved parents and My Dear Friends‖.
vi
Table of content
S. no Title Page no
1 Introduction 1-11
2 Chapter 1 12-16
3 Chapter 2 17-25
4 Conclusion 26-29
5 Bibliography 30-32
vii
Rimsy 1
INTRODUCTION
In the month of July of 1931, Alice Munro was born in Canada. Reading is her passion from an early age. She is entitled as Canadian short story writer. She began writing at age of 11. In
1950, while she was studying in the University of Western Ontario, Munro aired a sale of her first short stories. Governor General‘s Literary Award was the result of this. Her novel ‗Lies of Girls and Women‘ was published in 1971. Canadian Booksellers Association Book Award also went to her hands. She published her second collection of stories in 1974.Alice Munro was born as Alice Ann Laidlaw. Alice Munro‘s father was a poultry man and her mother was teaching in a local school. In 1949, for the completion of degree in English, she enrolled in the University of Ontario but could not complete her degree and left it in mid-way. After that, she married in 1951.
Short story writing is the specialty of Munro and she is also famous for her common and mobile style which illuminates human intricacy effortlessly. She keeps a remarkable position among other contemporary writers of fiction. She gave prime attention to her native place; Southwestern Ontario in her short stories. She used to describe the local people, their desires and their lifestyles in her writings. She started writing at her adolescent age and published her first story as a student. Her firm holds on regional and perplex female characters are the features of her writings. Southern Ontario Gothic is a literary genre and most of her writings are related to it.
Dilemma of the girls of coming of age was her prime theme in her initial days of writing. With the attainment of maturity, her arena broadens to elderly and middle-aged women. Main themes of her stories are very evident from her early stories. Complexities and Rimsy 2 confusion of a matured girls and her growing relation with their family have been the prime concern of her stories. Mainly, her books contain the collections of short stories and one book grew up in the form of a novel. That novel is basically mingling of many short stories which came into the two different genres. Her available stories has the sites of native Canada in small provincial towns in which she grew up and it tells the human bonding by daily regular events. Her stories are not necessarily but directly autobiographical they reflect the author's own life experiences and are concerned with women's lives and are 'probably unrivalled in their fullness' (Washington Post 1998).
Post 1977, the New Yorker magazine became the first magazine which had first publication rights for her short stories. She published her story collections after short intervals. Her works got immense popular and got appreciation with many literary awards. Munro got the Man Booker International Prize in 2009 and the supreme award in the field of literature Nobel Prize in 2013.After that she is considered as one of the world‘s very best living writers of short fiction in English. Ontario and Western Canada are the most preferable destinations for her stories and many deals with the relationships of men and women. Her stories have representation of both past and present. Her stories have been said to ―embed more than announce, reveal more than parade‖.
Alice Munro writes many Plays, Books, Teleplays like Dance of the Happy Shades,
1969, Lies of Girls and Women, 1971 (only novel published), Something I've Been Meaning to Tell You, 1974, Who Do You Think You Are?, 1978, The Moons of Jupiter, 1982, The
Progress of Love, 1986, Friend of My Youth, 1990, Open Secrets, 1994, Selected Stories,
1996 (28 of Munro‘s previously published stories, including many of her best known to that point), The Love of a Good Woman, 1998.Hateship, Friendship, Courtship, Love ship, Rimsy 3
Marriage Stories, 2002, Runaway: Stories, 2004The View from Castle Rock, 2006, Away
From Her, 2007, courting Johanna, 2009, new selected stories, 2011,dear life, 2012.
Munro‘s teleplays are "Thanks for the Ride," in To See Ourselves, CBC, 1973, How I Met
My Husband, (broadcast in The Play’s the Thing, CBC, 1974), Macmillan (Toronto, Ontario,
Canada), 1976.Munro wins many Prizes like National Magazine Awards Foundation Gold
Medal award, 1977, 1982, Foundation for the Advancement of Canadian Letters and
Periodical Distributors of Canada Author's award, 1980, Marian Engel award, 1986, Canada-
Australia Literary Prize, 1994, Canadian Booksellers Association Author of the Year award,
1995, Giller Prize, 1998, 2004 etc. She is known as the architecture of short stories, especially in its tendency to move forward and backward in time. Her stories have been said to "embed more than announce, reveal more than parade."
Munro is marked for her long-life connection with editor and publisher Douglas
Gibson. Munro wanted to work with Gibson therefore she has to break her contract with
Macmillan. She did this with returning of money to Macmillan. Gibson became important in life of Munro as represent in public on the behalf of Munro.
However one can reach to Munro with the help of internet. Munro‘s work deals with affection, work and the Indio syncracies of both. In the year 2003, her 16 stories have been incorporated in Munro's own collection more than twice with two of her works: "Carried
Away" and "Hateship, Friendship, Courtship, Loveship, Marriage".
A new collection from Alice Munro one of our era's true maestros of the short story is always causing for celebration. Unlike many writers, whose short-story writing is an add-on to more well-paid novel-writing, Munro has focused almost entirely on the form she has published only one novel, but 10 volumes of stories. She has proved in her genre and despite Rimsy 4 its limitations, can accomplish more in a single story than most writers achieve in hundreds of pages. Every one of her stories offers a fully realized world unto itself as an ocean in a pot.
As Robert Thacker wrote “Munro's writing creates...an empathetic union among readers, critics most apparent among them. We are drawn to her writing by its verisimilitude
– not of mimesis, so-called and... Realism– but rather the feeling of being itself... of just being a human being. Munro's stories reflex emotional and literary depth of novels. Some have asked whether Munro writes short stories or novels. Alex Keegan writing in Eclectica gave a simple answer: "Who cares? In most Munro stories there is as much as in many novels."
Research on Munro's work has been taken on in the early 1970s with the first PhD thesis published in 1972. The first book length volume collecting the papers presented at the University of Waterloo and the first conference held in 1984, The Art of Alice Munro:
Saying the Unsayable. In May 2012 an issue of the journal Narrative focussed on a single story by Munro, "Passion" (2004), with an introduction, a summary of the story, and five essays of analysis. Alice Munro publishes alternative versions of her stories, sometimes within a short period of time. Her works "Save the Reaper" and "Passion" came out in two different versions in the same year one in 1998 and second in 2004 .At the other end, two stories were republished in a variant version about 30 years later, "Home" in (1974/2006) and
"Wood" in (1980/2009).
Ann Close and Lisa Dickler Awano stated in 2006 that Munro had not wanted to re- read the vines of Runaway (2004):"No, because I‘ll rewrite the stories." Awano writes that
"Wood" is a good instance of how Munro being "a tireless self-editor‖ rewrites and revises a Rimsy 5 story. Awano writes that Munro exactly "refinishes" the first take on the story with an ambivalence that is like copyright of Munro‘s endings. Also the author‘s re-imagination of her stories throughout her work ventures out with a variety of ways. Munro‘s several stories were re-published with considerable variation .This can be seen in many of her stories for instance, in "Home", "The Progress of Love", "What Do You Want to Know For?", "The
Children Stay", "Save the Reaper", "The Bear Came Over the Mountain", "Passion", "The
View from Castle Rock", "Wenlock Edge", and "Deep-Holes.
Runaway is a collection of unique story in the shade of good plot structure. These stories has element of suspense which can be seen in the story. This suspense is not shown till the time action is already done. The final action can be considered as very real and this can be seen as the achievement of woman because they make their way to their desire. Thus, it satisfies readers. Munro has presented the unique combination of emotions, feelings and desire and journey of woman to achieve."Runaway tells the story of a young woman who refuses to have a chance to escape a bad marriage. The story debuted in the August 11,
2003, issue of The New Yorker.
Runaway is the opening story in Alice Munro's collection of the same title, concerns two runaways. This story represents a lady who is petrified living with her proud husband and Flora the pet goat. They live in country side where they work with tourists. She is unhappy in her life because her husband does not take care of her and ignore her. Due to this reason she has relationship with her neighbour Sylvia. This all she did only to make a relationship with her neighbour. She always dreams of such things that she is living far away from this land and living with her neighbour. Her husband makes her to run from home and at the end of the story she does run away far from home. The starting of this book is a good Rimsy 6 initiation for Munro‘s book. At the start when the characters are shown they are living full life but suddenly saw downfall in their characters and then at the end rising again with the help of their dream and desire.
‘Chance ‗is a story about a girl named Juliet who is a bright student of Classics which deals with study of language, history and culture of ancient Rome and Greece. Juliet is teacher in the British Columbia which is a private school. On her way to school she falls in love with a man before anyone could make any idea that what is happening. It is a very heart touching and optimistic story of a couple‘s growing relationship. All character of the story is reappearing. This story ‗Chance‘ ends with the note of Juliet‘s and Eric‘s successful love story. The actual end of the story is not an image of Juliet and Eric together in each other‘s arms but maybe the more interesting mentioning of the ―submerged rivalry‖ of Juliet and
Christa, Eric‘s former lover.
‗Soon‘ is the story that succeeds ‗Chance‘ which tells the story of Juliet who is coming back to home to give a visit for her parents after a short span of time from the incidents of the story‘s frame. It is not the previous story from ‗Chance‘. ‗Soon‘ focus more on family relationships particularly mother and daughter relation. ‗Soon‘ came into the light after many years. It intrigues the feelings of the first story ‗Chance‘ with the growth that cannot be escaped and the change in the characters that spends their lives together.
In ‗Silence‘ story it still follows Juliet. Now in this story she is narrating the story of
Juliet and her distorted bonding with her daughter. In "Silence" a mother Juliet, who has come late to her profession and whose daughter has run away to some kind of alternative Rimsy 7 spiritual retreat and punishing her mother with discontinued contact, begins a life of loneliness.
The three stories Chance, Soon and Silence are interconnected with each other. They revolve around the same character named Juliet. The stories draw Juliet‘s life when she meets her soul mate and her relationship with her parents and finally with her daughter. The third story is about Juliet and her daughter Penelope. These three stories that follow “Chance”, “Soon” and “Silence” are a set that represents cherry-picked points in one woman‘s life. ―Chance‖ is a love story we meet for first time, while ―Soon‖ and ―Silence‖ focus more on family relationships particularly mother and daughter. Family and Romantic relationships are central in Alice Munro‘s Runaway
‗Passion‘ is a story about a girl named Grace, who meets a boy during her summer job. She decides to marry him and a few incidents thereafter make her change her mind.
Alice Munro's short story, "Passion‖ is about allowing others to make all of the decisions.
She's a poor girl who loves learning. A rich boy, Maury falls in love with her .All along the only time Grace has taken charge of her life was in her early education but everyone told her how it was crazy and not useful. However we know that in the prevailing forty years, Grace has travelled to Australia and turned into an "engaging talker." But we never learn exactly what, how or when Grace took her life into her own hands.
‘Trespasses‘ is the story about an intelligent young girl. Her parents think that she is matured human being who is able to behave like adult human being. This story shows that how that young girl has an unusual friend who is worker in the local hotel who‘s name is
Delphine. That relationship of two ladies put an adverse effect on a family secret. Munro, Rimsy 8 throughout the story, does not break the secret that Lauren is only the age of ten. In
―Trespasses,‖ a young girl new in town befriend an older woman who has dark secrets that threaten everything about the girl‘s very life.
A story titled ―Passion‖ could feel so cold. The title ‗Passion‘ is meant to be ironic. I get that Mr. and Mrs. Travers are meant to parallel their son Maury and his new girlfriend our protagonist Grace. In ‗Trespasses‘ I can appreciate the themes of memory and looking back in both ―Passion‖ and ―Trespasses.‖ But these two stories felt pointless.
Tricks are a story about a frustrated spinster. She is on a solo trip to the Stratford
Shakespeare Festival there she meets and falls in love with a Montenegrin clock maker.
Tricks are about a girl named Robin and a guy whom she meets accidentally. They decide to meet the same day a year later. When she goes to meet him he refuses to recognize her. The ending was predictable. Tricks felt hopeful and romantic story. Even if things did not end happily but it still had a sweet note to it.
Powers is the most awful story of the book. It is the story of girl named Nancy and her grossly friend Tessa who could make the prediction of things. The story is narrated from alternate points of view. It is widely said from the angle of a egocentric woman who knows how to do the ostentation to a friend, a neighbourhood woman with her psychical powers.
This story is written in various artistic styles of a writer. The story starts with the introduction from a few pages from Nancy‘s diary. Later the narration of the story suddenly changes to the third person. The ending of ‗Powers‘ is the most puzzling. It doesn‘t shows that whether the last few paragraphs actually took place or it was just Nancy‘s dream. Rimsy 9
The final two stories ‗Tricks‘ and ‗Powers‘ were the clearest stories in Runaway.
‗Tricks‘ is hopeful and romantic story. Even if things did not end happily but it still had a sweet note to it. ‗Powers‘ is a wonderful story. The main character is very good who at times draws it altogether and tried to do the right things but she gets failure every time into due to her personal judging‘s while other people get hurt. The story plays around with different structures. It starts from a diary format and then moves to third-person narration to epistolary form. Then again it goes back.
Ultimately, I think that the main theme in ‗Runaway’ is that there are no easy answers in life.
There are a lot of the turning points in life these all are just chances of life.
What most people suspect is true? Such performances are full of tricks. Full of fakery,
full of deception. Sometimes that‘s all it is. But what people –most people- hope for
is occasionally also true. They hope that it‘s not all fake.
According to Malala Yousafzai Runaway is a great story when it comes to understanding that female victims can be perpetrators too. Malala Yousafzai asserting her right to be educated. We need to remember what real suffering looks like and acknowledge that calling the privileged countries we live in ―rape cultures‖ is a sign of neurosis, not truth.
Contrasting characters like Carla and Sylvia remind us that there are degrees of suffering and that not all pain is inflicted on us. What Munro also shows us is that some bad experiences are not down to masculine villains. They‘re simply down to the choices we make. Rimsy 10
Ali Smith, Scotsman writes Munro‘s stories enact a sort of magic. A beautiful collection of echoes and a demonstration of perfect and unflinch of form. She is a Scottish author play write and journalist. She is very famous for her short stories.
Alan Hollinghurst is an English novelist, poet, short story writer. He in the ‗Guardian‘ refers to that it is almost impossible to describe their unforced exactness; their unrushed economy...Munro has a genius for evoking the particular and peculiar atmosphere of relationships, their unspoken pressures and expectations.
Evening Standard noted that Alice Munro is one of the most consistently true writers of fiction working in the English language today. She is a sculptor of the human condition: nothing more and nothing less than an artist.
Helen Simpson is an English novelist and short story writer. She in the Guardian,
Books of the Year writes that these stories in the Runaway are breathtaking-they leave you winded with their toughness and brilliance.
Robert Thacker about her stories argues that the key to understanding her stories is the fact of her ―having grown up, and of having lived in, and of having left , and of having remembered, and of having left, and of having returned to, and above all of having made texts out of Huron Country, Ontario‖. According to him Munro‘s fiction is ―patently autobiographical and met fictional; it reflects the circumstances of Munro‘s return to
Ontario‖.
Jonathan Franzen‘s review performs the useful service of identifying a basic plot undergirding many Munro narratives; it also encourages the perception that Munro‘s plot is Rimsy 11 thinly veiled version of her life story. Franzen‘s piece has value as a general introduction to
Munro‘s writing. For example, his synopsis of Munro‘s plot accurately summarizes the mood, the locations the sequence of events and some of the characters in the trilogy of Juliet stories that comprise the bulk of Runaway.
Belinda Rule a Melbourne writer of fiction and poetry reviews that Munro diagnoses the profound disempowerment that the combination of poverty and patriarchy can produce in a young woman. She tracks with terrible clarity the cycle of appeasement and escalation in an abusive relationship, by which all compasses of normality, is lost. It is precisely the quietness of the prose that allows the emotion to land so hard -the way that the voice of the narrative disappears into character and situation, which is so easy to mistake artless, when in fact it is masterful.
Sigmund Freud mirroring the complexities of the human psyche, literature has received new comprehension through a psychoanalytic lens. Munro‘s Runaway is character- based and has the psychological analysis potential but it had never received such kind of study. The characters are driven by the Freudian mental agencies and undergo phases of psychic disorder. It is based upon Freud‘s theory of the Unconscious and its connection with the interpretation of dreams as well as the symbolization of the three main characters and the world of dreams indicates the artistic creation of Alice Munro in handling complex characterization.
Rimsy 12
CHAPTER-1
THE RELATIONSHIP OR INTIMACIES AMONG MOTHERS
AND DAUGHTERS
Dynamics of Intimacies in the relationships
Alice Munro always uses the relationship of daughter and mother in her stories. Alice mostly chose little girls as her heroines and all these heroines are always do things as per their mother‘s wish. This could be because Alice‘s mother and her relationship were troubled because her mother suffers from Parkinson disease when Alice was teenage. In some of
Munro‘s stories she represented the extraordinary relationship between mother and daughter.
In which she represented the fantasies and desires of mothers.
In Munro‘s Red Dress she gave solution to the problem between mother and daughter either by praising mother or by getting rid of her. Identity of her can be harmed if a girl adores her mother more than she should. The other connection between the mother and daughter can be their unity or their dependence on each other.
Trilogy of Juliet
In the Juliet set of three from Runaway (2004), Munro's never-ending worry in relationships is insightfully communicated with the connection amongst Juliet and Juliet‘s mother from one viewpoint and on the other side, amongst Juliet and her girl. Runway is conveyed through third person story teller and is in three joined stories which are Chance, Soon and
Silence. This gives us life story of hero. In the story of shot she meet a man who is going to Rimsy 13 be her husband in future, moreover in story of soon she is shown talking to her new born children and in the Quit she is depicted as an aged lady who don‘t want to have any connection with her little girl. Munro have depicted the daily story of a lady who suffer and fights with society on the regards of her relationship with her daughter and who always in the fear of being judged by the society. In the story Juliet is successful celebrity who have given many interviews and despite her success she feels like she is hopeless in the upbringing of her daughter and she is making her daughter hopeless. One can also see that nowadays idea of being as equal as men is prevailing therefore ladies want to give same time and energy in work as men which according to Chodorow is hazardous. Many argue that women should less involve in working and more in family because they have more responsibility than men to be there for family and support them emotionally. However, the sexual orientation is prevailing which does not come instantly but with time and ages. Juliet is represented as an alien among others. She was unique in her that she is not typical woman. In the Soon story she is seen paying visit to her family where she has found her with heart disease. At this point Juliet was unable to react upon this news.
Juliet has been maintaining a distance from her mother since she got close to her father. This depicts that fathers are responsible for the breakage in affection of mother and daughter. The reason can be that mother find her daughters same as them, so they show love which is selfish, but girls tried to find affection in their father because there they find themselves different.
In the stories Juliet find it difficult to connect with the girl Penelope. Therefore, she is unable to achieve what her mother did when she was girl. Sara on one hand had a Rimsy 14 supportive relation which Juliet can never have because of her busy schedule and profession.
She never fulfilled the needs and demands of her girl.
In the story Silence Penelope look upon her relationship with Juliet through
Flashbacks in which she found the reason behind her distorted bounding. However, Juliet does not want to claim any reason firstly and states that it is due to Penelope who did not motivated her to make their relationship stronger. Many critics say that Juliet is not trustworthy that she cannot be trusted of her girl‘s requirements. When Juliet meet religious leader, she is unable to find the reason behind sadness and gloom. Later Juliet understands that she might be unable to recognize the needs of Penelope.
In the trilogy of Juliet, the conflict which happened can be seen in other stories. That represents the conflict between desire and dreams. In the later part of the stories Juliet is shown having unique set of thoughts in which represent her by not reacting on customary female requests. In story her sisters have lesser conscious situation than her.
In Runway Stories
The stories of Runway give readers a huge world which has some of similarities with the world of her previous book Dance of the Happy Shades. Juliet who was till the date was living in Ontario migrates to British Columbia in the story Chance. Moving to the next story
‗Soon’ she returned to homeland to meet her parents. This time she is not a child but an adult woman. However, Munro in the previous stories does not show much of trilogy in relationship. Juliet met her future husband Eric in British Columbia in story of Chance. The significant of living far from homeland is that both can talk anything which otherwise they will never be able to do. Juliet was good in her studies and was pursuing Greek and Latin. Rimsy 15
She told Eric that she has a wish to do well in her studies and not to be ordinary housewife.
She was though aware that her being woman restrict her energy in work despite. Juliet picked her career in the field of arts and thus she cannot be known as typical woman and does not fit in this area.
Juliet was always contradicting and got criticize due to her lack of interest in feminine chores. When in story ‗Soon’ she visits her family with her daughter everyone criticizes her for same. She has been a person who people made fun of due to her inabilities as woman. She was often known as girl who talks Latin. Juliet can have praised if she became good mother and everyone doubt on this idea. By and by, because of her non-customary calling and family circumstance, she gets herself addressed and not completely acknowledged by her condition.
Quest for Identity and Freedom
In every Munro‘s Fiction She has the stable interest in Feminism topic. Munro‘s every topic shows the struggle of the females from their male counterparts. Every female in her stories fight for their identity. Struggle for selfhood becomes the most recurring theme in all of her past as well as present stories. In Runaway, the most social thing is the fight for self identity. Contrasting her written work after some time, look for women‘s activist self-realization is common, but less obvious in her later stories. The girls of adolescence age want to live their lives as they want but due to the pressure of society and gender barrier they are unable to live their lives as they want. These changes like change in the mentatility of society about the female as a weaker sex in the society all are seen in the Munro‘s writing. In her latest stories her hero‘s are more developed in contrast to her predecessors. Munro‘s latest stories are told from different perspective of all the young girls while story of Juliet trilogy is told through third person perspective. In Rimsy 16
Runaway, the plot is based on time and flashbacks .Her stories are very long, it takes the shape of novel. The problem of present days is portrayed where the confusions and conflicts among mothers and daughters are shown.
In Munro‘s successive stories, both Juliet and her daughter Penelope acts independently but they are responsible towards their lives. From the first eye, Juliet acts independently and she wants to fulfill her sexual desires. In this 21st century, Juliet is independent to make her own decisions. Society's desires upon ladies, fortified by moms upon little girls, make ladies in charge of the passionate welfare of their friends and family and ladies considerably more than men are anticipated that would locate their essential character in the family. Chodorow contends that this sex distinction is created due to family association and belief system regardless of the way that present day ladies spend as quite a bit of their life as men in work drive .She in her stories shows the male dominated society that can‘t be changed unless the men wants. All the stories of Munro aim to contradict old traditions and norms. Munro's heroes don't arrange noisy or oral challenges against the conventional development of kids into men and ladies. Rather, the young ladies imagine elective anecdotal universes. Munro gives and outlook to the reality of Female‘s life. The status of women‘s is very low their financial and social freedom both are bounded by the men‘s, this is shown through the character of Juliet in Runaway. Due to sociological pressure
Juliet throughout her whole life changes her decision and all her desires were repressed.
Rimsy 17
CHAPTER-2
STRUGGLE TO MOVE BEYOND TRADITIONAL GENDER
ROLES: TO LEAVE AND TO RETURN
Struggle for Selfhood
In the whole world, the gender of feminine is regarded as the originator of every human being but she never gets a respectable status from her opposite gender. A sense of inferiority always remained prevalent on the personality of a woman. The quest of woman for identity and their struggle for selfhood is portrait through her works. The cast of Munro‘s writings are very much inclined to the rustic lifestyle of the whole world and every relation and person is surrounded by his own boundaries mingled with others. Though Munro never considered her a feminist writer but her writings and works clearly states her feminism in the roles of the novels. Because of the unique writing style and themes, her short stories are considered as the novels or novellas. Her short stories are rewarded as the ―long short stories‖. She never followed the style of short stories and length of these never remained in the parameters of this genre. The stories she wrote aftermath were based on her own life and the loneliness of aged people.
Alice Munro kept the mentality throughout her life that women is always remained an object to the man. She faced the same difficulty in her characters especially in the women to explain the degradation in the society. Her efforts for the self-discovery of the women could be discovered in her works. She gave her female characters an essence of male powers. The Rimsy 18 beings of her novels specifically females grow from the soil to the sky. She excellently wrote about the women sufferings in the male dominant society.
The titles of her stories are very centric to the plots. ‗Runway‘ is the perfect example of it. The story starts not with the escapism but with the returning to the home. Carla heard the car coming before it topped the little rise in the road that around here they called a hill.
It‘s her, she thought Mrs. Jamieson-Sylvia-home from her holiday in Greece.
Munro‘s stories are mainly oriented to the town of Ontario which makes everyone else and every other place a stranger or alien. However, Munro always makes her heroine want to migrate or run from her original place which can be seen in the Rose who is character of her Munro‘s story, ―Who Do You Think You Are”? She enjoyed being migrated even though it was temporary.
She has a window seat, and was soon extraordinarily happy. She felt Flo receding,
West Hanratty flying away from her, her own wearying self discarded as easily as everything else. She loved the towns less send less known.
In her story, Munro explained the struggle of a woman who is suppressed by her husband, her daily household chores and is disturbed by the mind-set of her neighbors. She tried the method of escapism which is not fruitful. The use of fence is very much important in these stories. Fence in the house is predicted as the shackles of the woman in which she is surrounded. ‗Runaway‘ story propagates two main themes: one is the quest of the woman‘s identity and secondly the burden of family and relations either with children or neighbors.
‗Runaway‘ is story which just increases the burden of the difficulties in the voyage which is somewhat easy and comprehensive. Rimsy 19
In ―Runaway‖ Story three different runaways are shown first one is about Carla who wants to get away from bad relationship. Second is about the neighbor Sylvia and third is about the white Goat. There is noteworthy cover in the utilization of the expressions "female journey" and "female mission" in the writings talked about in this article, and both are utilized as other options to the customary, manly mission. Thusly, I don't make a specific qualification between the two terms. As history repeats itself, after few years same thing happens in these three Runaways repeats. The arrival might be better comprehended not as a disappointment, but rather as the purpose of fruitful consummation of the story design get under way. In ―Runaway‖ stories Journey of Carla is balanced and it slows down in the beginning. It is like three towns far from home and feels like hazards from life. She first runs from her home and after some time she realizes and came back.
In correlation, the sudden abbreviation of Carla's adventure proposes a quintessential disappointment of will, a disappointment intensely underlined with the setting in "Runaway".
The story of gathering of departures and the unmistakable and unexpected motioning of the account to chivalrous mission theme and Heroic motif.
The main characters of Munro‘s stories are basically not more than a puppet that is completing their responsibility in the story and in the journey of their life in the story. Many critics assumed that Munro‘s characters have choice either to go with the journey or to protest it. One can also look upon the character of Salvia as a person who has lost her identity in long go. She wanted other to be charge of her life and to fulfill this she chose Carla. On the other hand, Clark husband of Salvia believed that she gone insane because she was living with him. Critic Campbell believed that Clark is playing a vital role in this journey he is same as that old men one meet during journey who tells tales of beasts and help passenger pass Rimsy 20 their time but have no other significance when the journey finishes. Salvia mostly tried to provide Carla with money and clothes and make sure that she does her work properly. Saliva also represented herself as sharp minded middle-aged lady. Munro in the later part of the story depicted Salvia as positive side or as light with her silver blonde hair and her being in the warmth of Greece and on other hand Clark is represented as hazard with the dark hair. In all these contrast and contradiction Munro always establishes a third character that stands out different among other two. In many cases critics comment upon Munro‘s stories that the character that stand out in front of ethical barriers and prove themselves as courageous to do what they want are spirits near to nature. These characters speak of all those things which are closer to nature and of free mind. Their world is just the world one can witnessed but never can be observed because it is all hallucination and drawn oneself nearer to nature.
Like other character Flora the goat who in term of relationship is out of bounding with other characters but have similar tendency to get away. Carla always fantasies about many things in one of the incident she has seen Flora the goat flying. She depicts the incident that Flora climbed on fence like an eel and vanished into thin air. These all illusion are the symbolists as the inner desire to run away. From the all symbols and motif, one can assume that Munro tries to give the idea of a land which is land with no man. This land can be called as no man land.
Munro‘s ideas can be depicted as the waters which are flowing back to the channel and reaching there where there is no water and where water is need. This can be known as relation with atmosphere of Canada. When the story of Carla starts there is no water there is just only land which is dry but as readers witnessed the conclusion it is seen that there is rain and more rain. The dry land is not dry anymore. Rimsy 21
The mission might be a conspicuous and repetitive example in the writings of Munro, which is basically a challenged plot to bind female characters. Experience and achievement can be appear to be implausible or outlandish for Munro‘s heroes, for instance, Ascended fantasizes about change and rescue: ―To challenge it: to escape with it, to enter without anyone else, be that as it may, recently named, skin‖. Howells recommends the Canadian title for the main title of that same story. Various heroes in the story met the same fate of abuse. In the prime story, the subject of questing, sociological forbiddance and grammatical gender of the script are designed to strike the likelihood of the female quester.
In many forms of life, the quest of women‘s is still bound up with males. American journey, for instance, is portrayed by the liberal conviction that the saint can escape society and discover definition in isolation. Many critics portray the custom as established in the conviction "in this new land, unencumbered by history and social mishap, a man will have the capacity to accomplish finish self-definition". Defeating ladylike traps is a urgent part of this manly account of self-revelation. As progressively "Clark's mind-set weighted down all their inside space" (9), Carla retreats to incrementally far off peripheries of the claustrophobic residential focus that Clark speaks to. All the females want to escape from home to live their lives and they wants to escape from the male dominated world where they all were fighting for their Identities.
An escape does not promptly compare to a journey (in spite of the fact that
Macpherson attempts to permeate the expression "escaper" with intensity, understanding it, rather than the more uninvolved "escapee," as a term suggestive of "dynamic protection" and Rimsy 22 oftentimes connected with the journey for self-character [4]). The idea of escape holds its essential noteworthiness of constrained flight instead of meaning a voyage of enterprise and pick up, in this way barring this abstract inclination from the mission convention.
Macpherson, as per Atwood, likewise finds the topic of escape as noticeable in the Canadian scholarly cognizance.
Alice Munro in all her stories uses the theme that is used by the Margret Atwood in her works. Her themes are still available in the content of Munro‘s stories of 2004.In
Runaway stories Carla‘s escape is breakdown by her fear from the society and she have a fear of running away from her home. As she Runaway from her home her fear increases. Her fear is described in the story that she started to cry quietly, she also begun to shake, she was badly. In the other story character named Carla calls Cark: ―Come and get me. If it‘s not too much trouble Come and get me‖. Munro‘s themes and ideas were similar to that of Margret
Atwood‘s thinking.
Runaway depicts that Carla comes back home without her victory because she is unable to escape from her home and come back again to her home. Some critics describe that female‘s quest for their identity requires an option. Christ one of the famous critic explain that "women‘s‖ battle to pick up regard, fairness, and flexibility in the public arena" – what's more, an otherworldly mission: "a lady's enlivening to the profundities of her spirit and her position in the universe" (8). These two undertakings, she contends, are not elite, in any case, bolster and advance each other. As indicated by Christ's contention, ladies' missions are transformative and informative. In her short story ―Soon‖ Munro quickly depicts an excursion that seems to evade both the customarily manly, liberal mission for self-disclosure Rimsy 23 through separation, and the option, "ladylike" journey for character through group talked about by Christ.
In "Runaway," home life is, for Carla, a joy as opposed to a persecution: "she loved the musicality of her general tasks" (5). Mulling over the workmanship of other manufactured home proprietors, She could barely hold up to get at such enhancements herself. Carla's flight isn't provoked by imprisonment to the local schedule. With the passage of time Clark‘s behavior affects on happiness of Carla and on all her dreams that she wants to be fulfilled. Her In "Runaway," home life is, for Carla, a joy as opposed to a persecution:
"she loved the musicality of her general tasks" (5). Carla's flight isn't provoked by imprisonment to the local schedule. Her developing, misery is presented as: ―"Once in a while she could choose the course of action effortlessly and once in a while she needed to work to see it"."Once in a while she could choose the course of action effortlessly and once in a while she needed to work to see it".
Alice Munro presents this new imaginary female that is less idealistic than others.
Carla has fled from home some time recently, murmuring "She's leaving home, bye-bye" while "putting the note on the table and slipping out of the house at five o'clock in the morning" (32). Carla departs with a steady hand, except the "man from the engine exchange" of the reviewed Beatles melody; by the by, her activities are not unique, yet rather repeat prior accounts. The Shift from father to spouse is, moreover moderate. The voyages she and
Clark at first attempt, "similar to voyagers," soon offer approach to balance– "They were what individuals did before they comprehended the substances of their lives" (33).One of the critic calls ―Munro's inclination to defeat get away" (104) is obviously apparent, as Carla's call to enterprise settle into "an enlivening to limit " (Rosowski 49). Rimsy 24
In "Runaway, ―she had utilized the word bona fide. I have felt the need of a more valid sort of life" (33). However this idea of "legitimacy" is attached with a conventional setup. Furthermore, individualistic confidence in the true self that Carla can't manage. After leaving Clark, she reviews that how she considered him to be the engineer of the life in front of them, herself as hostage, her accommodation as both legitimate and choice. At the point when Carla wants to takeoff from Clark, then it is stated that he runs away by her. In
Runaway every female traveler comes back without victory because they all are unable to run away from their homes. By this Munro shows that their life is bounded within the four walls of the house. Their destiny is only related with the household things and she explains that these Women‘s are bounded in all these activities throughout their Lives and this leads to stay deficient in their life.
Low-lying temptation of Runaway
Sylvia always likes to visit her friend who is Maggie and Soraya because they helped Carla to live with them when she had nowhere to go in Greece. Carla always finds a good companion in Sylvia. In this Munro tried to build one very important relation of both female companion and to establish woman power or mission. In the Runway Munro tried to establish a structure which is very steady from inwards and which tried to prove that men are hinders towards females. The group of ladies in Greece is shown as the finest example of being companion and helping each other when needed. However, Munro also tried to give idea that not only help is not essential substance between the bounding of woman that can be seen at the end of story when Carla refuse to have any help of Salvia clear this point. Reader at this time was assuming the character of Carla as that spouse which Salvia has always imagined.
In Munro‘s stories one can feel that the idea of sentiment which is presented very carefully Rimsy 25 depicted. The participation and admiration of Salvia for Carla be important factor among their relationship and readers can witnessed the running away of Carla as breaking all the boundaries and fulfilling her own desires. However, her desires do not have anything feminist but are self-centered.
The other significant motif is of Flora the goat with red apple in her mouth and her death. Here Munro tries to represent the views of Carla who have red apple means her desires in her heart and unable to fulfill them and the murder of Flora signifies that despite Carla running away there is still bound to her. She is unable to accomplish woman mission
Munro keeps on stating the need of endeavor the journey, notwithstanding when it seems unsafe or inconceivable. Runaway is a mission; however it is baffled mission which still got permeated its energy. Therefore, is the restricted however huge capacity to envision the travel still to come
Rimsy 26
CONCLUSION
Feminist prospective was considered after the year 1960s. After this year, the law managed to give right to women. In any case, desires and preferences concerning ladies' duties may remain profoundly established in our psyches and in this way difficult to overcome, in spite of a more equivalent society. Social and societal medicines upon ladies on the most proficient method to carry on and what to grasp still today show themselves both in the public eye and also in the lady herself. The present paper gives a discourse about how desires, put upon ladies by a male centric culture, influence sex development. Munro‘s stories depicted the condition of woman in after year 1960 as well as in her stories of 1990.
After this dissertation, one can come up to the conclusion that literature depicts social issues more precisely than any other mean. It is evident that literature helps woman to question and change patriarchal society. Readers can observe that Munro‘s writings are somewhat her life experience which she put into words.
Alice Munro in her works highlights the contemporary Canadian culture by giving stress on sociological factors. By declining to acknowledge conventional sex parts, the youthful heroes question the request between the genders and henceforth societal disparities and shameful acts are made unmistakable. The reason for this exposition is to enlighten the suggested components of sex development and henceforth make them noticeable and ideally variable. By concentrate the relations amongst moms and little girls, I have reached the conclusion that sexual orientation is duplicated by the way that ladies are moms and essential guardians and accordingly the social association of sex is passed on. Munro's unpredictable mother-little girl relations depict little girls who battle their fights with a specific end goal to abstain from being the redundancies of their mothers. In her stories male part, Father Rimsy 27 provides the escapism to the young girl in search for her self-identity. In this research, Quest for identity there is representation of male dominated society that is shown both physically and mentally strong. Munro‘s central idea of female‘s quest for their identity is still prevalent in all her later stories. Her later stories points out the condition of women. Munro‘s works shows the varieties of male dominated society.
The narrating technique of the collection is not straightforward which tells us the complexities of Juliet. She is fighting for an explanation which would define her mental status whether she is physically supportive and stable. On the other side, in ‗Dance of Happy
Shades‘, combat is mostly with physicality which is against the sociological architect which prohibits females from making their own preferences. The exposure of this research concentrates only on the short stories which set in the contemporary Canada of 60‘s.
Consequently, my examination discoveries can't be summed up to hold a more extensive comprehension of sexual orientation development. All through my perusing of
Alice Munro's short stories, her impeccable and inconspicuous portrayals of the connection amongst moms and girls have pulled to my advantage. To encourage the comprehension of this essential component in sex generation, it would hold any importance with devote a more significant examination later on, developed simply on Alice Munro's "fixation" with the mother-little girl connection. Munro moves her point of view to another period of female experience, that of menopause and maturing. This period, like the beginning of adolescence is another attempting stage, as the female body now experiences passionate, mental, and physical change. Be that as it may, the mission for character proceeds, however the circumstance now is very extraordinary. Munro looks at top to bottom, the female cognizance at this point of life—wants, states of mind towards sex and men, and in addition Rimsy 28 their position in family and society. Having a place either to the poor provincial or to the white collar class society, these ladies' lives are molded by their declining physical qualities, social standards and traditions. The mission for character still remains an imperative power as these ladies disregarding their declining physical capacities stay bright and acknowledge the difficulties of life. Munro records the whole ancestry of female voice, comprising of old house keepers, aunties, moms, grandmas, and cousins who have perceived their positions and have acknowledged with quiet self-restraint their evolving conditions. Here, Munro additionally attracts our consideration regarding the inverse sex and says that men however are detached and even derisive towards ladies at this phase of life. Munro demonstrates that womanliness and parenthood are inborn in female nature. Parenthood gets prime criticalness in "Mile City Montana", where the storyteller, when her kid slips into a pool, shouts out in urgency "Where are the children?"(Program: 104). This episode brings out fundamental female sensibility that qualifies a woman. Munro joins periods of youthful age, and development in a lady's life. Male strength, shameful acts, social disparities are for the most part present as Munro over and again investigates ladies' encounters in different circumstances of life. The mission for self-element remains an inescapable power, which impels the heroes to confront the substances of life. Double dealing, claims, false expectations and guarantees, unfulfilled wants and longings, male pettiness and desires over and again baffled, are a portion of the certainties of presence, taken up by the creator in these collections. In every one of her works Munro, calls attention to that in demonstrate hatred for o f the foes of life, her heroes don't surrender their distinction, the soul to oppose the powers that attempt to enslave them. The mission for the exploration self-character relentlessly inspires them for the duration of their lives. One imperative element that women's activist Rimsy 29 scholarly commentators have brought up is that, Women‘s essayists have over and over depicted disturbed ladies with a specific end goal to voice their challenge male centric request and predominance .Munro too takes up the subject of female madness in her art.
Munro has additionally demonstrated that ladies are not generally cowed around male mastery. They too have their individual say in each familial issue and on occasion apply their personality. Although Munro can't be named as a women's activist essayist in the feeling of
Margaret Laurence and Margaret Atwood are, she is on a basic level a craftsman profoundly worried for ladies. Her works are expected to animate social awareness, so ladies' conditions might be enhanced, and they may not be subjected to exploitation. Really, Munro's fiction, explains the inward voice of ladies, their unheard cry against shameful acts inside the familial and the social structure. Ladies' stories voice the noiseless dissent and trusts in change in the male centric outlook, ruling the socio social standards and traditions. Society has subjected them to provocation, on grounds of sexual orientation builds. Munro's supplication is one of helpful thought of female issues. Through her stories, Munro has carefully dug into the deepest
Opening of a lady's heart, its mental ramifications, and has articulated, the layers of untold stories of torment and sufferings. No other essayist in Canada has ever discussed the issues of ladies in such a way, uncovering the better sensibilities of women‘s feelings, covering the whole traverse of a lady's life from youth. In this lies her most noteworthy accomplishment as an imaginative author. In reality, she is a woman, thinking for all women‘s, and expounding on ladies, a field she gets it best.
Rimsy 30
Bibliography
Alice Munro‘s ‗Boys and Girls‘. Studies in Canadian Literature 15:1 (1990): 62-75. Print.
"Alice Munro (AUTHOR PROFILE) (achievements and awards)", World Literature Today,
May-August 2005 .Web.
Atwood, Margaret. Survival: A Thematic Guide to Canadian Literature. Toronto: Anansi,
1972.
Birbalsingh, Frank. ―Women in Alice Munro‘s Lives of Girls and women.”
Chodorow, Nancy, and Judith Thurman.‖Breaking the Mother-Daughter Code: An interview with Nancy Chodorow‖. Ms 11.3(1982):34-38,138-39.Print.
Chodorow, Nancy. The Reproduction of Mothering. Berkeley & Los Angeles: University of
California Press, 1978.Print.
Dakin, Kymberly, ―Runaway by Alice Munro‖indiebound.org, 26 Oct 2009. Web .16 April
2009.
De Beauvoir, Simone .The Second Sex.1949.New York: Alfred A. Knopf.2009.Print.
Franzen, Jonathan.‖Introduction: Runaway.”Alice Munro. London: Vintage, 2006.Print.
F. Tolan • Frustrated Departures and Female Quest in Alice Munro‘s Runaway at Australian
Catholic University on August 2, 2015 http://cww.oxfordjournals.org/. 1971.
Harmondsworth: Penguin, 1982. Rimsy 31
Gadpaille, Michelle. The Canadian Short Story. Toronto: Toronto University Press, 1988.
Print.
Hateship, Friendship, Courtship, Loveship, Marriage. Toronto: McClelland & Stewart,
2001. Print.
Munro, Alice. ―Boys and Girls‖, ―Red Dress-946‖, ―Walker Brothers Cowboy‖. Dance of the
Happy Shades. London: Vintage Books, 1968. Print.
Munro, Alice. ―Chance‖, ―Soon‖‘ ―Silence‖. Runaway. London: Vintage Books, 2006 .Print.
Munro, Alice. Lives of Girls and Women. Toronto: McGraw-Hill Ryerson, 1971 Print.
Moore, Lorrie. "Leave them and love them: in Alice Munro's fiction, memory and passion reorder life. (Runaway)(Book R", the Atlantic Monthly, Dec 2004 Issue.
Munro, Alice. ―Short Stories of Alice Munro, ―gradesaver.com Issue. 2004):n.pag. Web .7
Sep 2009.
Novels and the Nation: Essays in Canadian Literature. Toronto: TSAR publications,
1995.124-31.Print.
Redekop, Magdalene. Mothers and Other Clowns: The Stories of Alice Munro. London:
Routledge, 1992.
Runaway. London: Vintage.2004.Print.
Thaker, Robert. Alice Munro: Writing Her Lives. A Biography. Toronto: McClelland
&Stewart, 2005.Print. Rimsy 32
Weston, Jessie L. From Ritual to Romance. New York: Doubleday Anchor, 1957Chapter
One: The Relationship between Mothers and Daughters.
.