THE AMERICAN ECCLESIASTICAL REVIEW

Editor-in-Chief JAMES P. CLIFTON

Associate Editors MARY CHARLES BRYCE FREDERICK R. MCMANUS

MICHAEL J. SCANLON JAMES J. WALTER Business Office MARIAN E. GOODE

Volume 168 Number 1 January 1974

Articles Divorce: Catholic Theory and Practice in the United States Charles E. Curran 3

Psychoanalysis: The Future of an Illusion Leo M. Croghan 35

Discernment of Spirits: A Theological Reflection Philip S. Keane, S.S. 43

Worship and Religious Experience Charles W. Gusmer 62

Book Reviews Worship and Witness by C. J. McNaspy 70

Protestantism by Martin E. Marty 71

Time Invades the Cathedral by Walter H. Capps 71

Reality and Faith by Heinrich Ott 72

Published monthly, except July and August, by The Catholic University of America Press, Washington, D. C. 20017. Subscription price in U. S. currency or equivalent: United States, Canada, $10.00. Foreign, $10.00, $1.00 per copy. Second class postage paid at Washington, D.C. Business communications, including subscriptions and changes of address, should be addressed to The American Ecclesiastical Review, 620 Michigan Ave., N.E., Wash­ ington, D. C. 20017. Please address all manuscripts and editorial correspondence to The Editor, The American Ecclesiastical Review, 620 Michigan Ave., N.E., Washington, D. C. 20017. Copyright 1974 by The Catholic University of America Press. r THE AMERICAN ECCLESIASTICAL REVIEW

Editor-in-Chief JAMES P. CLIFTON

Associate Editors • MARY CHARLES BRYCE FREDERICK R. MCMANUS

MICHAEL J. SCANLON JAMES J. WALTER Business Office MARIAN E. GOODE

I Volume 168 Number 2 February 1974

Articles K>rce: Catholic Theory and Practice in the tfr. United States—Part Two Charles E. Curran 75

foe Spread of the Bible and the n_ Economy of Salvation Bertrand De Margerie, S.J. 96

fowards the Catholicization of the Church Eugene Hillman, C.S.SP. 122

>k Reviews ! Theology of Original Sin by Edward Yarnold, S.J. 135 IMarriage* : For and Against edited by Harold Hart 136 fhe Apostolic Scriptures by David P. Scaer 137

[tooounte r by Martin Buber 137

Published monthly, except July and August, by The Catholic University of America l Press, Washington, D. C. 20017. Subscription price in U. S. currency or equivalent: limited States, Canada, $10.00. Foreign, $10.00, $1.00 per copy. Second class postage fcpia at Washington, D.C. t ™*'ness communications, including subscriptions and changes of address, should be ^.addressed to The American Ecclesiastical Review, 620 Michigan Ave., N.E., Wash- rfcgton, D. C. 20017. ?,nease address all manuscripts and editorial correspondence to The Editor, The s. American Ecclesiastical Review, 620 Michigan Ave., N.E., Washington, D. C. 20017. L Copyright 1974 by The Catholic University of America Press. And the Two Shall Become One Flesh: A Study of Traditions in Ephesians by J. Paul Sampley 138

This is the Word of the Lord. A Promise Fulfilled. by John F. Craghan, C.Ss.R. 138

The Inside Story of Jehovah's Witnesses by W. C. Stevenson 139

Pray to Live. Thomas Merton: A Contemplative Critic by Henri J. M. Nouwen 140 Conscience versus Law: Reflections on the Evolution of Natural Law by Jeremiah Newman 141

Spirit and Sacrament: The Humanizing Experience by Joseph Powers 141

Divorce and Remarriage edited by Lawrence G. Wrenn 143

The Catholic Historical Review Official Organ of the American Catholic Historical Association A QUARTERLY JOURNAL Founded in 1915

JOSEPH N. MOODY Associate Editor ROBERT F. TRISCO Managing Editor • Articles By Leading Scholars • Historical Miscellany • Book Reviews • Notes and Comments * Periodical Literature Annual Subscription: $900, U.S., Canada and Foreign

The Catholic Historical Review THE CATHOLIC UNIVERSITY OF AMERICA PRESS Washington, D. C. 20017 THE AMERICAN ECCLESIASTICAL REVIEW

Editor-in-Chief JAMES P. CLIFTON

Associate Editors MARY CHARLES BRYCE FREDERICK R. MCMANUS MICHAEL J. SCANLON JAMES J. WALTER Business Office MARIAN E. GOODE

Volume 168 Number 3 March 1974

Articles Religion Study and the Public School William Cenkner, O.P. 147

jleligious Experience: Public Utterance and Dogma Development Alfred McBride, O.Praem. 162

Integration and Christian Sacramental Experience David Michael Thomas 177

Eucharistic Prayer for Children Laszlo F. Ranch, O.S.P. 185

The Greatness of John England Richard W. Rousseau, S.J. 196

Review-Article

Morning Praise and Evensong 207

Book Reviews

• Catechetics and Prejudice by John T. Pawlikowski, O.S.M. 216

i Published monthly, except July and August, by The Catholic University of America i Press, Washington, D. C. 20017. Subscription price in U. S. currency or equivalent: United States, Canada, $10.00. Foreign. $10.00. $1.00 per copy. Second class postage paid at Washington, D.C. Business communications, including subscriptions and changes of address, should be addressed to The American Ecclesiastical Review, 620 Michigan Ave., N.E.. Wash­ ington, D. C. 20017. Please address all manuscripts and editorial correspondence to The Editor, The American Ecclesiastical Review, 620 Michigan Ave., N.E., Washington, D. C. 20017. Copyright 1974 by The Catholic University of America Press. THE AMERICAN ECCLESIASTICAL REVIEW

Editor-in-Chie] JAMES P. CLIFTON

Associate Editors MARY CHARLES BRYCE FREDERICK R. MCMANUS

MICHAEL J. SCANLON JAMES J. WALTER Business Office MARIAN E. GOODE

Volume 168 Number 4 April 1974

Articles Conflict and Reconciliation in the Thought of Reinhold Niebuhr Frederick W. Gunti 219 Change in the Church Robert B. Eno, S.S. 236 Abortion: Legal and Philosophical Considerations Donald DeMarco 251 Von Htigel's Idea of Ecclesiastical Authority Lawrence F. Barmann 268

Book Reviews Christ and the Universe. Teilhard de Chardin and the Cosmos by Robert Hale, O.S.B.Cam. Edited by Michael Meilach, O.F.M. 283 The Call of the Desert by Peter Anson 283 Method in Theology by Bernard J. F. Lonergan 284 The Creeds of the Churches edited by John H. Leith 287 Caring: A Biblical Theology of Community by Thomas Dubay, S.M. 287

Published monthly, except July and August, by The Catholic University of America Press, Washington, D. C. 20017. Subscription price in U. S. currency or equivalent: United States, Canada, $10.00. Foreign, $10.00, $1.00 per copy. Second class postage paid at Washington, D.C. Business communications, including subscriptions and changes of address, should be addressed to The American Ecclesiastical Review, 620 Michigan Ave., N.E., Wash­ ington, D. C. 20017. Please address all manuscripts and editorial correspondence to The Editor, The American Ecclesiastical Review, 620 Michigan Ave., N.E., Washington, D. C. 20017. Copyright 1974 by The Catholic University of America Press. THE AMERICAN ECCLESIASTICAL REVIEW

Editor-in-Chief JAMES P. CLIFTON

Associate Editors MARY CHARLES BRYCE FREDERICK R. MCMANUS

MICHAEL J. SCANLON JAMES J. WALTER Business Office MARIAN E. GOODE

Volume 168 Number 5 May 1974

Articles

The Place of Mary in Luke: 291 A Look at Modern Biblical Criticism Robert L. Humenay 304 i Mariology: A Protestant Reconsideration Charles Dickson 309 Is the Fetus a Person? Albert R. Dilanni, S.M. q Archbishop Kenrick of Baltimore: 327 Preface to Infallibility? Robert F. lppolito, MS. Interreligious Relations: A Key Confrontation John Moffitt 341

Review-Article

* The Virginal Conception and Bodily Resurrection of Jesus by J. A. T. Robinson 352

Published monthly, except July and August, by The Catholic University of America Press, Washington, D. C. 20017. Subscription price in U. S. currency or equivalent: United States, Canada, $10.00. Foreign, $10.00, $1.00 per copy. Second class postage paid at Washington, D.C. Business communications, including subscriptions and changes of address, should be addressed to The American Ecclesiastical Review, 620 Michigan Ave., N.E., Wash­ ington, D. C. 20017. Please address all manuscripts and editorial correspondence to The Editor, The American Ecclesiastical Review, 620 Michigan Ave., N.E., Washington, D. C. 20017. Copyright 1974 by The Catholic University of America Press. Book Reviews

Religion in Radical Transition edited by Jeffrey K. Hadden 356

In Man We Trust: The Neglected Side of s

Biblical Faith by Walter Brueggemann 355

The Mystery of Christ and the Apostolate by F. X. Durwell 357

Ecclesial Cybernetics: A Study of Democracy in the Church by Patrick Granfield 358 Christ and the Church. Signs of Salvation by Rene Latourelle, S.J. 358

Contemplative Community: An Interdisciplinary Symposium edited by M. Basil Pennington, O.C.S.O. 360

Reprinted by popular request— Newly Reprinted! Why THE CATHOLIC HOSPITAL Brothers Don't FACES ABORTION Become Priests by Thomas M. Durbin by Quentin Hackeneworth, S.M. This article was originally pub­ This article was originally published lished in October 1970 issue of in the January 1961 issue of The The American Ecclesiastical Review. American Ecclesiastical Review * * * * • Single copy 40^ 12 pages plus cover—5'/2 x 8'/j In lots of 25 35«J Sample copy 25f In lots of 100 Z24 In lots of 25 20< e*. In lots of 100 16< ea. Prices Postpaid * * * * Prices Postpaid • The American Ecclesiastical Review The American Ecclesiastical Review The Catholic University of America The Catholic University of America Washington, D. C. 20017 Washington, D. C. 20017 THE AMERICAN ECCLESIASTICAL REVIEW

Editor-in-Chief JAMES P. CLIFTON

Associate Editors MARY CHARLES BRYCE FREDERICK R. MCMANUS

MICHAEL J. SCANLON JAMES J. WALTER Business Office MARIAN E. GOODE

Volume 168 Number 6 June 1974

Articles

Pre-Ministry to the Dying and Bereaved Jerome P. Theisen, O.S.B. 363

Methodology and McCormick David W. Blanchfield 372

Theological Positions and Philosophy of Life Pierre Hegy 390

Catholic Faith as Ultimate Concern John R. Connolly 404

Consultative Process in the Church Robert G. Howes 422

Published monthly, except July and August, by The Catholic University of America Press, Washington, D. C. 20017. Subscription price in U. S. currency or equivalent: United States, Canada, $10.00. Foreign, $10.00, $1.00 per copy. Second class postage paid at Washington, D.C. Business communications, including subscriptions and changes of address, should be addressed to The American Ecclesiastical Review, 620 Michigan Ave., N.E., Wash­ ington, D. C. 20017. Please address all manuscripts and editorial correspondence to The Editor, The American Ecclesiastical Review, 620 Michigan Ave., N.E., Washington, D. C. 20017. Copyright 1974 by The Catholic University of America Press. Book Reviews

Mark and Matthew: Scripture Discussion Commentary, 7 by Sean Freyne and Henry Wansbrough 431

An Appreciation of Eastern Christianity by Clement Englert, C.Ss.R. 432

We're All in This Together. Issues and Options in Education of Catholics by Mary Perkins Ryan 432

Firms With Episcopal Institute of the Authorization To Replate Heart of Jesus And Repair Sacred A secular institute for diocesan priests Vessels committed to friendship, prayer. sim- plicity, celibacy and listening.

NEW YORK: RAMBUSCH DECORATING CO., 40 West 13th St. Write: REV. STEWART J. PLATT 124 Keystone Avenue

OMAHA: KOLEY PLATING Campbell, Ohio 44405 CO., 2951 Harney St. THE AMERICAN ECCLESIASTICAL REVIEW

Editor-in-Chief JAMES P. CLIFTON

Associate Editors MARY CHARLES BRYCE FREDERICK R. MCMANUS

MICHAEL J. SCANLON JAMES J. WALTER Business Office MARIAN E. GOODE

Volume 168 Number 7 September 1974

Articles

"Like Us in All Things, Except ..." Donald P. Gray 435

Pluralism in Catholic Moral Theology George M. Regan 448

Buddhism: Progress or Regression? William P. Frost 469

Faith in Dialogue with Secular Humanism Mary I. Buckley 482

Book Reviews

Scripture Discussion Commentary. Paul II: 1 Corinthians, 2 Corinthians, Philippians, Philemon; Scripture Discussion Commentary, 9 by Laurence Bright, Henry Wansbrough and Jerome Murphy- O'Connor 499

Published monthly, except July and August, by The Catholic University of America Press, Washington, D. C. 20017. Subscription price in U. S. currency or equivalent: United States, Canada, $10.00. Foreign, $10.00, $1.00 per copy. Second class postage paid at Washington, D.C. Business communications, including subscriptions and changes of address, should be addressed to The American Ecclesiastical Review, 620 Michigan Ave., N.E., Wash­ ington, D. C. 20017. Please address all manuscripts and editorial correspondence to The Editor, The American Ecclesiastical Review, 620 Michigan Ave., N.E., Washington, D. C. 20017. Copyright 1974 by The Catholic University of America Press. Telepolitics: The Politics of Neuronic Man by Frederick D. Wilhelmsen and Jane Bret 499

The Mission of the Church by Edward Schillebeeckx, O.P. 500

The Future Significance of Civilization, Nature and Religion by William P. Frost 501

Catechetics in Context by Berard L. Marthaler, O.F.M. Conv. 502

The Threshing Floor by John F. X. Sheehan, S.J. 504

A Sftecial ReftAitd— 2nd Printing Natural Law Morality Today* BY CAHAL B. DALY

* This article was originally the text of a lecture delivered at the Christus Rex Congress, Cahir, Co. Tipperary, in April 1965. It was first published in the July issue of Christus Rex Journal of Sociology published from St. Patrick's College, Maynooth, Ireland, and is here reprinted with the kind permission of the Editor. (The article appeared in the December 1965 issue of The American Ecclesiastical Review) (40 pages) Partially outlined as follows: • Pope John and Natural Law • Natural Law and Human Progress • Natural Law and Moral Progress • Traditional Attitudes to Sex • The Morality of the Situation • Law and Love Special Prices: PRICES Single copy $ .25 25 copies 5.00 POSTPAID 100 copies 15.00 A The American Ecclesiastical Review The Catholic University of America Washington, D.C. 20017 THE AMERICAN ECCLESIASTICAL REVIEW

Editor-in-Chief JAMES P. CLIFTON

Associate Editors MARY CHARLES BRYCE FREDERICK R. MCMANUS

'MICHAEL J. SCANLON JAMES J. WALTER Business Office MARIAN E. GOODE

Volume 168 Number 8 October 1974

Articles

Charism and Institution Edward D. O'Connor, C.S.C. 507

Biblical Pedagogy of Evangelization Virgilio Elizondo 526

The New Testament: Pacifism and Non-Violence Robert J. Daly, S.J. 544

The Challenge of Liberation Theology Daniel Di Domizio 563

Book Reviews

\ The Trinity and the Religious Experience of Man by Raimundo Panikkar 568

Philemon's Problem. The Daily Dilemma of the Christian by James Tunstead Burtchaell, C.S.C. 569

Published monthly, except July and August, by The Catholic University of America Press, Washington, D. C. 20064. Subscription price in U. S. currency or equivalent; United States, Canada, $10.00. Foreign, $10.00. $1.00 per copy. Second class postage Paid at Washington, D. C. Business communications, including subscriptions and changes of address, should be addressed to The American Ecclesiastical Review, 620 Michigan Ave., N.E., Wash­ ington, D. C. 20064. Please address all manuscripts and editorial correspondence to The Editor, The American Ecclesiastical Review, 620 Michigan Ave., N.E., Washington, D. C. 20064. Copyright 1974 by The Catholic University of America Press. 12th Century Europe: An Interpretive Essay by Sidney R. Packard

Theological Investigations. Vol. IX by Karl Rahner, S.J.

The Proclamation of the Gospel in a Pluralistic World: Essays on Christianity and Culture by George W. Forell

What Difference Does Jesus Make? by F. J. Sheed

A Sufi Saint of the Twentieth Century: Shaikh Ahmad al-'Alawi by Martin Lings

Medical Ethics by Bernard Haring

Jesus and the Gospel. Vol. I by Pierre Benoit

Maturing the Spirit by Dominic M. Hoffman, O.P.

A Special HefxM*U— 2nd Printing Natural Law Morality Today* BY CAHAL B. DALY

* This article was originally the text of a lecture delivered at the Christus Rex Congress, Cahir, Co. Tipperary, in April 1965. It was first published in the July issue of Christus Rex Journal of Sociology published from St. Patrick's College, Maynooth, Ireland, and is here reprinted with the kind permission of the Editor. (The article appeared in the December 1965 issue of The American Ecclesiastical Review) (40 pages) Partially outlined as follows: • Pope John and Natural Law • Natural Law and Human Progress • Natural Law and Moral Progress • Traditional Attitudes to Sex • The Morality of the Situation • Law and Love Special Prices: Single copy $ .25 PRICES 25 copies 5.00 POSTPAID 100 copies 15.00

• * The American Ecclesiastical Review The Catholic University of America Washington, D.C. 20064 THE AMERICAN ECCLESIASTICAL REVIEW

Editor-in-Chief JAMES P. CLIFTON

Associate Editors t MARY CHARLES BRYCE FREDERICK R. MCMANUS

{ MICHAEL J. SCANLON JAMES J. WALTER Business Office MARIAN E. GOODE

Volume 168 Number 9 November 1974

Articles Thomas Merton: Growth in Compassion Charles J. Healey, S.J. 579 The Eucharist in the Gospel of Mark Joseph A. Grassi 595 The Metaphysics of Idolatry: An Existential Approach to Tertullian Patrick Henry Reardon 609 Death as Religious Experience Paul Marceau, C.S.C. 625 Vatican II: Protestant Communions as "Churches" David M. Murphy 632

I Book Reviews Women Priests in the Catholic Church? by H.vander Meer, S.J. 635 The English Bishops and the First Vatican Council by Frederick J. Cwiekowski, S.S. 637 Francis Xavier: His Life, His Times. Vol. I. Europe (1506-1541) by Georg Schurhammer, S.J. 639

Published monthly, except July and August, by The Catholic University of America Press, Washington, D. C. 20064. Subscription price in U. S. currency or equivalent; United States, Canada, $10.00. Foreign, $10.00. $1.00 per copy. Second class postage paid at Washington, D. C. Business communications, including subscriptions and changes of address, should be addressed to The American Ecclesiastical Review, 620 Michigan Ave., N.E., Wash­ ington, D. C. 20064. Please address all manuscripts and editorial correspondence to The Editor, The American Ecclesiastical Review, 620 Michigan Ave., N.E., Washington, D. C. 20064. Copyright 1974 by The Catholic University of America Press. Bernard of Clairvaux: Studies Presented to Dom Jean Leclercq edited by M. Basil Pennington, O.C.S.O. 640 Truth and Certainty. Concilium 83. edited by Edward Schillebeeckx and Bas van Iersel 641 Discernment of Spirits by Viet Penning De Vries, S.J. 641 The Mystery of Suffering and Death edited by Michael J. Taylor 643 A Harsh and Dreadful Love by William D. Miller 644 In Tune with the World by Josef Pieper 645 Introduction to a Theological Theory of Language by Gerhard Ebeling 646 The Priesthood by Karl Rahner 646 Christ and Revolution by Marcel Clement 647

The Catholic Historical Review Official Organ of the American Catholic Historical Association A QUARTERLY JOURNAL Founded in 1915

JOSEPH N. MOODY Associate Editor ROBERT F. TRISCO Managing Editor

• Articles By Leading Scholars • Historical Miscellany • Book Reviews * Notes and Comments • Periodical Literature Annual Subscription: $9-00, U.S., Canada and Foreign * * » The Catholic Historical Review THE CATHOLIC UNIVERSITY OF AMERICA PRESS Washington, D. C. 20064 THE AMERICAN ECCLESIASTICAL REVIEW

Editor-in-Chief JAMES P. CLIFTON

Associate Editors MARY CHARLES BRYCE FREDERICK R. MCMANUS

MICHAEL J. SCANLON JAMES J. WALTER Business Office MARIAN E. GOODE

Volume 168 Number 10 December 1974

Articles The Trouble with Pastoral Theology Gerald D. Coleman, S.S. 651 Integration in Educating for Ministry Ladislas Orsy, S.J. 668 People of God and Men of Good Will Raymond Beaudry 681 The Beginnings of the CCD in Europe and Its Modern Revival Joseph B. Collins, S.S. 695

Review-Article The Seduction of the Spirit. The Use and Misuse of People's Religion Donald P. Gray 707

Index to Volume 168

Published monthly, except July and August, by The Catholic University of America Press, Washington, D. C. 20064. Subscription price in U. S. currency or equivalent: United States, Canada, $10.00. Foreign, $10.00. $1.00 per copy. Second class postage paid at Washington, D. C. Business communications, including subscriptions and changes of address, should be addressed to The American Ecclesiastical Review, 620 Michigan Ave., N.E., Wash­ ington, D. C. 20064. Please address all manuscripts and editorial correspondence to The Editor, The American Ecclesiastical Review, 620 Michigan Ave., N.E., Washington, D. C. 20064. Copyright 1974 by The Catholic University of America Press.