In Respect of the Draft Vale of White Horse Local Plan 2031 Inspection (Stage Two)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
IN RESPECT OF THE DRAFT VALE OF WHITE HORSE LOCAL PLAN 2031 INSPECTION (STAGE TWO) ___________________________________________________________________ FURTHER REPRESENTATION ON BEHALF OF EAST HANNEY PARISH COUNCIL IN RESPECT OF MATTER 8.1: THE STRATEGIC HOUSING ALLOCATIONS ___________________________________________________________________ INTRODUCTION 1. This representation on behalf of the East Hanney Parish Council (“Parish Council”) relates to a discreet point in respect of Matter 8.1 (e): is Strategic Housing Allocation Site 6 (South of East Hanney) soundly based and deliverable? 2. This document should be read alongside the previous lengthy Representation dated 15 December 2014. 3. The Parish Council accepts the housing requirement figure of 20,000 homes over the plan period. There is plainly an urgent need for significant new housing, but the Parish Council remains firmly of the view that Site 6 is inappropriate and unacceptable. MERITS OF SITE 6 Where East Hanney Sits in the Hierarchy of Villages of the District 4. The 2011 Census showed that the village held 334 occupied households and a recorded population of only 748. 5. East Hanney was defined as a “larger village” by the skin of its teeth: the minimum threshold was 14 points and it scored 14 points. In fact, it obtained a point for having a mobile library service. Given that this service has now ceased, East Hanney only scores 13 and no longer meets the threshold for being characterised as a “larger village”. Oxfordshire County Council removed the mobile library facility from the village of East Hanney following their 2014 consultation as per their initial plan (appendix 1). In the table (annexe 1) of the Summary of the Outcome (appendix 2) of this consultation, it can be seen that East Hanney will no longer be visited. 6. Accordingly, it can be seen that Site 6 has been promoted and included as a Strategic Housing Allocation on a false prospectus. It is difficult to see how a settlement which is so small and inadequate in its provision of facilities should be considered an appropriate candidate as a Strategic Housing Allocation. 7. It is the smallest of the “large villages” defined by policy H11 of the adopted Local Plan. 8. It is noted that there are 10 villages which are larger (ie have bigger populations and a facilities score equal to or greater than East Hanney) which have not been earmarked for Strategic Housing Allocation. These include: Wootton (24) Watchfield (22) Steventon (20) Drayton (20) Cumnor (17) Blewbury (16) East Hendred (16) Marcham (15) Uffington (14) East Challow (14) (with their facilities rating in brackets) 9. Further, there are 4 other villages with populations far greater than East Hanney that have not been earmarked for development with or immediately adjacent to their village edge, it is however noted that Chilton is immediate to a strategic site: North Hinksey (4,535) Appleton (915) Sunningwell (904) Chilton (894) (with their populations in brackets) Other alternative candidates are the larger settlements of Wantage or the expansion of Didcot that lies within he Vale of White Horse district or even areas closer to the Oxford fringe villages of North Hinksey or Cumnor. Please also consider the following chart below which is derived from data contained in the 2011 census.+! ! ! o North!Hinksey!(4,535)! o Appleton!(915)! o Sunningwell!(904)! o Chilton!(894)! ! • Note!that!the!parish!of!“St!Helen!Without”,!which!includes!the!villages!of!Shippon!and!Dry! Sandford,!has!a!population!of!3,165!and!has!also!NOT!been!earmarked!for!development.! ! • As!a!comparison!example!T!!Sutton!Courtenay!received!a!facilities!score!of!21!and,!according! to!the!2011!Census,!had!1,007!homes.!!It!has!been!allocated!a!development!site!for!220! houses!which!increases!Sutton!Courtenay’s!total!number!of!homes!by!22%.!!Compare!this! with!the!60%!homes!increase!for!East!Hanney.! ! Please!also!consider!the!following!charts!which!are!based!on!data!from!the!2011!census.! ! 12,000! Number%of%Residents% 10,000! 8,000! 6,000! 4,000! 2,000! East!Hanney,!748! 0! Hazord! Garford! Drayton! Ashbury! Wytham! Baulking! Lockinge! Woowon! Wantage! Buckland! Sparsholt! Uffington! Steventon! Watchfield! Woolstone! Liwleworth! Shellingford! Sunningwell! East!Hanney! East!Hendred! Great!Coxwell! South!Hinksey! North!Hinksey! Letcombe!Regis! Hinton!Waldrist! Charney!Bassew! Great!Faringdon! Letcombe!Bassew! St.!Helen!Without! Fyfield!and!Tubney! Stanford!in!the!Vale! Kingston!Bagpuize!with!Southmoor! ! ! This!chartThe,!which!does!not!include!Abingdon, colours indicate whether!illustrates!where!East!Hanney!sits!in!terms!of!its!size! a settlement has been identified for based!on!the!spread!of!population!across!the!Vale.!East!Hanney!is!clearly!the!smallest!settlement!development in this phase of the Local Plan 2031 (in red) or not (in green). allocated!for!development,!and!there!is!clear!water!between!the!next!largest!and!East!Hanney.!Why! has!Hanney!been!chosen?!It!does!not!seem!appropriate!that!East!Hanney!should!be!selected!for! housing!development,!when!there!are!bigger!villages!nearer!to!and10. It can be seen that this element of the proposed spatial!better!connected!with!Science! strategy for the district Vale!which!are!not!being!developed!such!as!Steventon!and!East!Hendred.is skewed. Put simply, East Hanney has been “over-promoted”!Please!consider!whether! far out of scale to its size, population and range of facilities. There are a number of other larger villages (without the constraints of biodiversity and historic heritage) 59! ! which should be allocated in preference to Site 6. 11. Prime alternative candidates are the villages Steventon and East Hendred, the larger settlements of Wantage or the expansion of Didcot that lies within he Vale of White Horse district or even areas closer to the Oxford fringe villages of North Hinksey or Cumnor. In sustainability terms they are to be preferred over East Hanney to accommodate the much needed Strategic Housing Allocation. 12. The allocation of Site 6 is perverse and irrational. Certainly, if the unusual step is taken to select this small village as a Strategic Housing Allocation over many other larger and more suitable villages, proper and convincing reasons should be given. 13. Lest it be thought that East Hanney has not expanded at all, it is noted that it has undergone considerable development pressures recently. Planning permission has been granted for around 120 homes in the last couple of years. Indeed applications for 195 have been approved with another 10 currently in the consultation process since April 2011 (see the table below). Clearly, this is a village which has already made a significant contribution to the housing needs of the district. Additional Date VWHDC Ref Location Description number of Comments Registered Houses 20 The Outline application for P14/V1498/O Causeway East erection of a detached 03-Jul-14 0 Refused Hanney dwelling. Half Acre Main Proposed development of P15/V2200/FUL Street East 16-Sep-15 1 two dwellings Hanney Kings Farm Cottage Ebbes P14/V1633/FUL Erection of new dwelling. 14-Jul-14 1 Lane East Hanney Kings Farm Cottage Ebbs P13/V2708/FUL Erection of Three Dwellings 03-Jan-14 3 Lane East Hanney Land adj 1 P14/V1455/O Ashfield Lane Proposed new dwelling. 02-Jul-14 0 Refused East Hanney Land adj Yew Erection of nine dwelling Application Tree Barn The (including affordable P15/V1379/FUL 17-Jun-15 (9) under Paddocks East housing) with associated consideration Hanney parking and amenity space. Proposed 4 bedroom detached dwelling with associated landscaping(as Land adjacent to amended by the agents Varlins Halls P15/V1065/FUL email dated 16 06 2015 and 12-May-15 1 Lane East updated tree report and plan Hanney 13070-P10b which shows a revised driveway layout to retain T3). Land north of Residential development Junction of A338 comprising the erection of up P13/V1960/O and Steventon 06-Sep-13 0 Refused to 3 dwellings, associated Road East amenity space and access. Hanney A residential development for Land North of up to 55 dwellings, including P15/V0343/O Summertown 23-Feb-15 55 site access, public open East Hanney space and landscaping Outline application for 35 Land off A338 P13/V2266/O houses and new access to 06-Nov-13 35 East Hanney Steventon Road + Land South Of 26- Alfreds Place East Erection of 15 dwellings with associated P11/V2103 Sep- 15 Hanney Wantage access roads, garages and open space. 11 Oxfordshire Land South of 04- Outline application for the development of P15/V1846/O Steventon Road Aug- 0 Refused up to 200 homes East Hanney 15 Land south of Erection of 79 affordable dwellings and 03- Summertown East 118 open market dwellings, with P15/V1616/FUL Jul- 0 Refused Hanney Wantage associated access roads, landscaping 15 OX12 0JQ and public open spaces Land to east of A338 Erection of 25 dwellings with associated 21- P13/V0381/FUL Crown Meadow East access roads, garages/car ports and Feb- 25 Hanney open space 13 Part retrospective application for erection Land to rear of The of one detached dwelling with associated 04- Bungalow Snuggs access and parking (As amended by P13/V2171/FUL Oct- 1 Lane East Hanney drawing number 1202-01 Rev C 13 OX12 0HU accompanying email from agent dated 1 December 2013). land to the rear of Erection of 16 dwellings with associated 16- P13/V2608/FUL Saxon Gate East access, public open space and Dec- 16 Hanney OX12 0FA landscaping 13 Land West of Residential development of 37 dwellings 18- Nursery Steventon on land off Steventon Road (As amended P15/V2175/FUL Sep- 37 Road East Hanney by House type plans accompanying 15 OX12 0HS agents email of 21 October 2015) Philberds Bungalow 06- Halls Lane East To convert the outhouse building into a P13/V1915/FUL Sep- 1 Hanney Wantage dwelling 13 OX12 0HJ The Bungalow Revised Proposals for a new dwelling 05- Snuggs Lane East P10/V2197 adjacent to the bungalow.