Item 8 North York Moors National Park Authority Planning Committee

14 May 2015

Miscellaneous Items

(a) Appeals

(i) The Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government has determined the following appeals made to him against decisions of the Committee:-

Location of Site/Appellant Decision (Inspector) Stables at The Gate House, Hutton Gate, Decision: Appeal dismissed Guisborough, TS14 8EG Inspector: Graham M Garnham

Background Documents for This Item

1. Inspector's letter attached at Appendix A

(ii) Set out below is information on dates/venues of inquiries/hearings:-

Appellants Name Method of Date of Local Venue and Location Determination Inquiry/Informal Hearing NYM0003/2014 Hearing – The N/A N/A Mr Lee White Planning Lockerice Hole, Inspectorate has Swainby deemed this now to be determined by the Written Representations Procedure

(iii) Appeals received:

Ref Number Appellants Name and Description Location NYM/2014/0531/FL Mr Christopher Bateson Conversion of store to Fisherman's Store, Beckside, form holiday letting unit Staithes

(b) Planning Applications Determined by the Director of Planning

A list of planning applications determined by the Director of Planning in accordance with the Scheme of Delegation is attached at Appendix B

[NB: Members wishing to enquire further into particular applications referred to in the Appendix are asked to raise the matter with the Director of Planning in advance of the meeting to enable a detailed response to be given].

(d) Enforcement Action Progress Report

Report attached at Appendix C

[The individual files will be available for Members to inspect at the meeting].

Andy Wilson Chief Executive (National Park Officer)

Chris France Director of Planning

Appeal Decision Site visit made on 24 June 2014 by Graham M Garnham BA BPhil MRTPI an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government

Decision date: 14 April 2015

Appeal Ref: APP/W9500/A/14/2216583 Stables at The Gate House, Hutton Gate, Guisborough, TS14 8EG  The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against a refusal to grant planning permission.  The appeal is made by Mr Jeff Granger (Executor of Mr Brian Garnett deceased) against the decision of North York Moors National Park Authority.  The application Ref NYM/2013/0600/FL, dated 14 August 2013, was refused by notice dated 7 October 2013.  The development proposed is to replace existing timber shed & stables and block built barn with new single storey dwelling.

Decision

1. The appeal is dismissed.

Procedural Matter

2. The details of the appellant in the summary above reflect the fact that the applicant for planning permission, Mr Brian Garnett, had died before the appeal was made.

Main Issues

3. I consider that these are whether the proposal would, firstly, be an acceptable form of development within the countryside outside an established settlement; and secondly, be compatible with the character, appearance and quality of its historic setting.

Reasons

4. The appeal site is part of a considerable land holding that now goes with The Gate House. This is a detached house and garden, a development that, according to the appellant, dates back to the 1920s. The proposal would involve demolishing a run of storage and stabling buildings; erecting a single storey dwelling on part of their footprint; removing an area of hard standing; and creating a residential curtilage that would also include and retain a number of mature trees.

www.planningportal.gov.uk/planninginspectorate

Appeal Decision APP/W9500/A/14/2216583

First main issue – the acceptability of development in the countryside

5. The appeal site is located in an area of open land just south of Guisborough. The area is defined by Core Policy B of the North York Moors Core Strategy and Development Policies document (2008) [the CSDP] as being part of the open countryside. Core Policy J indicates how a mix of housing types and tenures will be sought to maintain the vitality of local communities. It says that new housing in the open countryside will be restricted to that which is proven essential for farming, forestry or other essential land management activities, replacement dwellings and conversion of traditional rural buildings for residential letting for local needs.

6. The proposal would not satisfy any of the exceptions allowed by Core Policy J. The personal requirement for a manageable home for Mr Garnett in familiar surroundings no longer exists. Although in the open countryside, the site is quite close to services and facilities in the urban area of Guisborough. However, this relationship would not normally justify the encroachment of built development into countryside around a settlement. The appellant says that there is an absence of a 5 year supply of housing land. According to the National Planning Policy Framework, this means that the relevant policies for the supply of housing should be considered out of date. However, this is not a matter addressed by the Authority and I have seen no evidence to support the appellant's assertion. Thus I can give it little weight. Consequently I find there are no material considerations of significant weight to set against the policy context relied on by the Authority.

7. I conclude that the proposal would not be an acceptable form of development within the countryside outside an established settlement. It would be contrary to the CSDP policies referred to above. There is an insufficient weight of material considerations to indicate a decision otherwise than in accordance with the development plan.

Second main issue – effect on historic character and appearance

8. The Gate House and its land holding is within what was originally 113 hectares of parkland surrounding Hutton Hall. This is described as being a large country mansion in a landscaped park that was designed by Alfred Waterhouse for Sir Joseph Pease. It is dated 1866 and was listed Grade II in 1984. At the same time, the nearby complex comprising the former stable block, stable house and Cleveland House was also listed Grade II, being important for group value. This complex is now largely in residential use, and is known as The Stable Block. The whole area was designated the Hutton Lowcross Conservation Area in 2005, in recognition of the historical importance and interest of the buildings and the openness of their overall setting.

9. The appeal site itself is on the eastern edge of a roughly oval area of open pasture land, that was originally created from farmland to form an open parkland setting on the northern side of Hutton Hall. It served both to separate the Hall from Guisborough and to provide a pastoral setting for the main approach drive from the settlement, which took a scenic route along the western side of the parkland. The parkland was largely surrounded by a border of what are now mature trees. The new dwelling would be seen clearly across the open area from Hutton Village Road, close to the original driveway

2 Appeal Decision APP/W9500/A/14/2216583

at its north west edge where there is a gap in the trees. The dwelling would have the tree border as its immediate backdrop. Perhaps more importantly, it would be seen within the same vista as one of the very few public viewpoints of Hutton Hall, part of which can also be seen to the west of the tree border. From this viewpoint, the new dwelling would appear as being about midway between The Gate House and the Hall, as a further domestic intrusion into the original parkland between the Hall and Guisborough.

10. I consider that a new dwelling and its domestic curtilage in this sensitive and prominent position would appear as a significant incursion of built development into an area of open land of considerable historic interest. I recognise that The Gate House already forms a larger scale incursion into this open area, and that the removal of the rather ramshackle existing buildings and hard standing on the site would be an improvement. However, the existing buildings are of a relatively low key appearance and have a rural function, while the introduction of further permanent residential development would be quite contrary to the historical purpose, character and appearance of the appeal site and its setting.

11. The new dwelling would also be close to the front of The Stable Block and, although separated from it by the tree border, the close proximity would be evident from both buildings and the service road that would run between them. The Stable Block is sited to one side of and behind Hutton Hall, just outside the tree border but close enough to the Hall to be readily accessible from it. This relationship expresses its subservient role to the Hall, while being integrated into the overall layout of the estate, and functionally connected by the service road directly to the town of Guisborough and its former railway station. I consider that the siting of the proposed dwelling close to and prominently in front of The Stable Block would materially detract from the planned spatial arrangement of Hall, Stable Block and grounds that are an important part of both the setting of these listed buildings and the character and appearance of the conservation area.

12. The Authority further objects to the design of the new dwelling, on the grounds that it would detract from the distinctive and elaborate Victorian architectural character of The Stable Block. I consider that the design would be generally in keeping with that of the more minor ancillary buildings associated with and close to The Stable Block. However, these buildings are more appropriately sited in secondary locations to the side or rear of the main building, while the appeal proposal would be sited directly in front of its imposing main façade. I consider that the incongruity of the design in this location would further detract from the setting of the listed building.

13. I understand the desire of the appellant (now deceased) to live in familiar surroundings that he had cared for over many years and close to neighbours who, through negotiation, have come to support the planning application. However, I consider that personal matters such as these should not outweigh the very considerable harm I have found with respect to the historical nature and landscape setting of the proposal. This harm would long outlast the personal circumstances.

14. Overall and on balance, I conclude that the proposal would significantly detract from and be incompatible with the character, appearance and quality of its historic and landscape setting. It would fail to preserve, and would not

3 Appeal Decision APP/W9500/A/14/2216583

enhance, both the character and appearance of the setting of important listed buildings and their spatial relationship, and the character and appearance of the Hutton Lowcross Conservation Area. These outcomes would be contrary to Core Policy G in the CSDP, which seeks to conserve and enhance the landscape, historic assets and cultural heritage of the National Park. There would be further conflict with Development Policy 4, that would only permit development that would preserve or enhance the character and appearance or setting of a conservation area; and with Development Policy 5, which resists any development that would have an unacceptable impact on the setting of a listed building. The siting of the proposal would be contrary to Development Policy 3, concerning design.

Overall conclusion

15. I have found against the proposal with respect to both main issues. I consider that these findings and the shortfall with respect to development plan policy indicate that the proposal would be in conflict with one of the purposes of National Parks, namely to conserve and enhance their natural beauty, wildlife and cultural heritage. Decision makers have a statutory duty to have regard to this purpose. In addition, the Framework makes clear that “great weight” should be given to conserving landscape and natural beauty in National Parks, where development is typically to be restricted. I have identified no material considerations of sufficient weight to override or offset these findings and conclusions against the proposal.

16. Overall, therefore, I conclude that planning permission should be withheld and I dismiss the appeal. G Garnham

INSPECTOR

4

Appendix B

List of Planning Applications Determined by the Director of Planning for the Period from 01/04/2015 to 29/04/2015 in the Following Order and then by District: Delegated Planning Applications; Post Committee Applications; on Expiration of Advertisement; on Receipt of Amended Plans and Further Observations; Approval of Conditions; Applications Adjacent to the Park (3024); Notifications Under Schedule 2, Part 6/7, of The Town & Country Planning (General Permitted Development) Order 1995

NYM/2015/0070/FL Approved 09/04/2015 variation of condition 2 (material amendment) of planning approval NYM/2014/0093/FL to allow alterations to approved internal layout, relocation of door to north west elevation and insertion of additional windows and door to south west elevation at Faceby Manor, Faceby for Mrs Paula Scott

NYM/2015/0087/LB Granted 09/04/2015 variation of condition 2 of Listed Building consent NYM/2014/0098/LB to allow alterations to approved internal layout, relocation of door to north west elevation and insertion of additional windows and door to south west elevation at Faceby Manor, Faceby for Mrs Paula Scott

NYM/2015/0092/FL Approved 13/04/2015 construction of conservatory to front elevation following removal of porch at 75 South End, Osmotherley for Mrs Bland

NYM/2015/0104/FL Approved 14/04/2015 installation of 3 no. antennas and 3 no. remote radio units following removal of 4 no. existing antennas at BT High Tower, Arncliffe Wood RS, Osmotherley for Cornerstone Telecommunications Infrastructure Limited / Telefonica UK Limited

NYM/2015/0108/FL Approved 15/04/2015 variation of condition 1 of planning approval NYM/2014/0418/FL to allow a further 6 months to complete the works to the stoned hard standing at The Barn, Whorlton, Swainby for Mr Howard Tribick

NYM/2014/0430/FL Refused 20/04/2015 installation of replacement of bay window with uPVC (retrospective) together with replacement of first floor timber windows with uPVC at 14 Roxby Terrace, Thornton le Dale for Miss Elizabeth Kendrew

NYM/2015/0051/FL Approved 28/04/2015 installation of replacement uPVC double glazed windows to front elevation at Croft Corner, 6A Prospect Place, Thornton Dale for Mr and Mrs Leadley

NYM/2015/0052/FL Approved 13/04/2015 conversion of section of outbuildings to form residential annexe accommodation/holiday letting cottage with associated parking and amenity area at Glebe Farm, Levisham for Mr and Mrs Tweddell

NYM/2015/0069/FL Approved 01/04/2015 rebuilding of dwelling and construction of extensions together with bio fuel generator and fuel store approved under NYM/2008/0560/FL at Dale Head, Hawnby for Mexborough Estate

NYM/2015/0080/FL Refused 09/04/2015 construction of 1 no. open market dwelling with attached garage and associated access and parking area following removal of workshop/garage at land adjacent Waingate Farm, Fadmoor for Mr Robert Ibbotson

NYM/2015/0091/FL Refused 09/04/2015 conversion of redundant barn to form 1 no. open market dwelling with associated parking, access and amenity space at Waingate Farm, Fadmoor for Mr Robert Ibbotson

NYM/2015/0105/FL Approved 10/04/2015 installation of 8 no. solar panels to front facing roofslope at 1 The Close, Thornton le Dale for Mr Brian Walker

NYM/2015/0109/FL Approved 15/04/2015 variation of condition 3 of planning approval NYM/2007/0804/FL to allow the approved annexe accommodation to be used for holiday letting purposes at Baillie Close, Bickley, Langdale End for C Thornton & B Mattinson

NYM/2015/0142/FL Approved 28/04/2015 construction of part two storey, part first floor side extension at Third Acre Wass Bank Wass for Mr Mick Bradley

NYM/2015/0193/NM Approved 17/04/2015 non material amendment to planning approval NYM/2014/0444/FL to allow change from conservatory to sunroom including a solid (grey fibreglass) roof, reduction in the size of windows and insertion of a window in place of door to gable end elevation at 14 The Rise, Thornton le Dale for Mr Alex Preston

NYM/2012/0644/FL Approved 28/04/2015 variation of condition 2 of planning approval NYM/2011/0667/FL to allow alterations to and insertion of 2 no. additional roof windows together with installation of 1 no. flue and septic tank at Coombs Farm, Ainthorpe for Mr Mike Dowson

NYM/2014/0778/FL Approved 14/04/2015 conversion of and rebuilding works to barn to form 1 no. local occupancy dwelling to let with associated parking and amenity space at Barn to rear of 5 High Street, Hinderwell for Mr William Barker

NYM/2014/0804/LB Granted 14/04/2015 Listed Building consent for conversion of and rebuilding works to barn to form 1 no. local occupancy dwelling to let with associated parking and amenity space at Barn to rear of 5 High Street, Hinderwell for William Barker

NYM/2014/0814/FL Approved 28/04/2015 erection of a conservatory to rear at 6 Dreaken Fold, West Ayton for Mrs E Sleightholme

NYM/2014/0822/CU Approved 22/04/2015 change of use from a holiday letting cottage to office (no external alterations) (retrospective) at Fowl Green Farm, Commondale for Mr Donald Muir

NYM/2015/0018/FL Approved 01/04/2015 construction of extension to existing garage at Windy Ridge, 31 Briar Hill, Danby for Mr Philip Jackson

NYM/2015/0045/FL Approved 13/04/2015 construction of 1 no. dormer window to rear and installation of replacement window to front dormer at Auburn Cottage, Tommy Baxter Street, Robin Hoods Bay for Mr Rob Heath

NYM/2015/0047/LB Granted 13/04/2015 Listed Building consent for construction of 1 no. dormer window to rear and installation of replacement window to front dormer at Auburn Cottage, Tommy Baxter Street, Robin Hoods Bay for Mr Rob Heath

NYM/2015/0063/FL Approved 01/04/2015 alterations and construction of single storey extension, construction of domestic garage, conversion of and extension to shop/studio to form Tearoom together with associated access and parking (revised scheme to NYM/2014/0663/FL) at Nestling House, Littlebeck for Mr Trevor Allen & Ms Nicola Willis

NYM/2015/0064/FL Approved 15/04/2015 construction of building to house 3 no. industrial units (Use Class B2) at Eskdale Engineering Co Ltd, Sneaton Lane, Ruswarp for Mr Paul Wharrick

NYM/2015/0075/FL Approved 08/04/2015 construction of workshop building at Lealholm Auto Services, Lealholm Bank, Lealholm for Mr D Raw

NYM/2015/0078/LB Granted 02/04/2015 Listed Building consent for installation of replacement double glazed timber windows and 1 no. lintel at 43 Main Street, East Ayton for Coast Cottages

NYM/2015/0088/FL Approved 15/04/2015 construction of single storey extension at East Coast Lodge, Staithes for Mr R Champion

NYM/2015/0089/FL Approved 01/04/2015 variation of condition 4 of planning approval NYM/2014/0709/FL to allow the use of wood grain effect uPVC framing at Highgate Howe Holiday Home Park, Hawsker for Highgate Howe Holiday Park

NYM/2015/0090/FL Approved 08/04/2015 construction of 2 no. dormer windows to front elevation at Roxby Lodge, Roxby, Staithes for Mr & Mrs Ken Barber

NYM/2015/0094/FL Approved 22/04/2015 erection of 1 no. flue pipe at The Gatehouse, Newlands Road, Cloughton for Mr David Marsden

NYM/2015/0100/FL Approved 15/04/2015 alterations and construction of part single/part two storey side extension at 30 Cliff Road, Staithes for Mr M Jefferson

NYM/2015/0102/FL Approved 29/04/2015 construction of single storey sun room extension, installation of replacement front door and alterations to barn to form residential annexe at Grange Farm, Houlsyke for Mr Richard Blindell

NYM/2015/0103/LB Granted 29/04/2015 Listed Building consent for construction of single storey sun room extension, installation of replacement front door and alterations to barn to form residential annexe at Grange Farm, Houlsyke for Mr Richard Blindell

NYM/2015/0110/FL Refused 15/04/2015 erection of extension to existing agricultural storage building at Ellers Cottage, Fryup for Mr Kenneth Knight

NYM/2015/0117/FL Approved 15/04/2015 variation of condition 2 (material amendment) of planning approval NYM/2014/0833/FL to allow the raising of eaves and ridge height of extension by 350mm and alterations to roof of link section between house and garage at 4 Tinsley Close, East Barnby for Mr Michael Forster

NYM/2015/0124/FL Approved 27/04/2015 erection of timber building and decking together with creation of new vehicular access at Wykewood, Downdale Road, Staintondale for Hollowgate Farms LTD

NYM/2015/0130/FL Approved 28/04/2015 variation of conditions 3 and 4 of planning approval NYM/2010/0659/FL to allow the retention as holiday cottages or sale as local occupancy dwellings at Thirley Cotes Farm, Harwood Dale for Mrs Melanie Shephard

NYM/2015/0134/FL Refused 24/04/2015 erection of Dutch barn for agricultural storage purposes at Beacon Cottage Farm, Barmoor Lane, Scalby for Mr Brian Thompson

NYM/2015/0135/FL Approved 24/04/2015 variation of condition 3 of planning approval NYM/2011/0205/CU to allow the holiday let to be occupied for 11 months at The Old Cottage, Suggs Passage, 66 High Street, Staithes for Mr Adrian Hunter

NYM/2015/0139/CU Approved 27/04/2015 change of use to holiday cottage together with insertion of French doors and alterations to first floor window to west elevation to form Juliette balcony at Cottage Two, Dunsley Hall, Dunsley for Mr Stephen Brear

NYM/2015/0159/FL Approved 10/04/2015 installation of 3 no. rooflights and change of use of building to Use Class B1 (furniture restoration business) together with creation of 3 no. openings to existing stable block and erection of timber stable building at Vale View, Main Street, Sawdon for E & S Gott

NYM/2015/0119/LB Granted 15/04/2015 Listed Building consent for erection of entrance gate at The Coach House, 6 Pease Court, Guisborough for Mrs Samantha Bedford

NYM/2015/0120/FL Approved 27/04/2015 construction of first floor extension at 10 Scholars Gate, Guisborough for Mrs Gemma Humble

Notifications

NYM/2014/0826/AGRP Approved 01/04/2015 erection of agricultural storage building at Scotland Farm, Snilesworth, Hawnby for Mr Kenneth Sayer

NYM/2015/0079/AGRP Approved 02/04/2015 erection of agricultural machinery shed at High Farm, Ugglebarnby for Messrs R & A Harland

NYM/2015/0099/AGRP Approved 09/04/2015 siting of welfare and larder units and storage container within fenced compound at Forestry Commission, Pry Rigg, Sproxton for Forestry Commission

NYM/2015/0106/AGRP Approved 09/04/2015 erection of agricultural storage building at Scawton Moor House, Scawton for MJ & RM Dickinson

NYM/2015/0114/AGRP Approved 10/04/2015 erection of agricultural storage building at Warren House Farm, Lockton for Mr Brian Brown

NYM/2015/0123/AGRP Approved 17/04/2015 proposed resurfacing works at Kale Pot Hole to Rhumbard Cottages, Newtondale for Forestry Commission

Applications Determined by the Director of Planning on Expiry of Advertisement, Receipt of Further Amended Plans and Observations

NYM/2014/0612/CU Change of use of agricultural store to joinery workshop and store (retrospective) at store adjacent Kirkdale Cottage, Egton for J Hallam Joinery (Mr Jack Hallam)

The application was approved subject to Director of Planning clearing the decision on receipt of no adverse comments from the Environmental Health Officer and removal of condition 1 to allow a permanent consent.

Since the Committee Meeting, the Environmental Health Officer’s comments have been received. They state that the data from the recordings made indicates that there is likely to be a statutory nuisance from noise from the woodworking workshop to the annex at Kirkdale Cottage where their equipment was set up. This noise was made up of a combination of noise from the use of woodworking machinery, from hammering and from music from a radio. They would need a bit more evidence to pursue the matter further, just to bring it up to date, but they don’t think they would have too much trouble getting that if the use of the workshop is the same now as the Authority has observed and no works of insulation have been carried out.

Additionally, they go on to state that as harm to amenity would normally encompass statutory nuisance then that also must be occurring and so they have stated that sound insulation to the workshop needs to be installed to prevent any further problems.

As the Environmental Health Officer was happy with the conditions, the application was approved with the removal of condition 1.

NYM/2015/0093/FL creation of front parking area at Nun Cottage, 78 High Street, Hinderwell for Mr Mark Stephens

The application was approved, contrary to the Officer’s recommendation, with the following conditions and informative:

1. TIME01 Standard Three Year Commencement Date 2. PLAN02 Strict Accordance With the Plans/Specifications or Minor Variations 3. HWAY00 Details of the means of opening of the proposed gates shall be submitted to the Local Planning Authority for approval in writing prior to any works beginning on site. 4. HWAY06 Discharge of Surface Water 5. HWAY00 Unless otherwise approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority, there shall be no excavation or other groundworks, except for investigative works, or the depositing of material on the site until the access(es) to the site have been set out and constructed in accordance with the published Specification of the Highway Authority and the following requirements: i)The crossing of the highway verge and/or footway shall be constructed in accordance with the approved details and/or Standard Detail number E6 in the NYCC Specification for housing and Industrial Estate Roads and Private Streetworks, 2nd Edition. ii)The gates hereby approved shall not be able to swing over the existing highway. iii)The final surfacing of the private access shall not contain any loose material that is capable of being drawn on to the existing or proposed public highway. All works shall accord with the approved details unless otherwise agreed in writing by the Local Planning Authority. 6. LNDS11 Details of Access Surfacing to be Submitted

1. In relation to condition 5 you are advised that a separate licence will be required from the Highway Authority in order to allow any works in the adopted highway to be carried out. The ‘Specification for Housing and Industrial Estate Roads and Private Street Works’ published by North Yorkshire County Council, the Highway Authority, is available at the County Council’s offices. The local office of the Highway Authority will also be pleased to provide the detailed constructional specification referred to in this condition.

Applications Adjacent to the National Park (3024)

R/2015/0144/RS Erection of 3 two storey dwellings at land off Church Lane, Newton under Roseberry

The Authority assessed the details of the proposed development and made the following comments:

No objections.

R/2015/0173/FF Installation of single 20kw wind turbine (maximum height 27.131m) on land at Barnaby Grange Farm, Middlesbrough Road, Guisborough

The Authority assessed the details of the proposed development and made the following comments:

No objections.

15/00096/FUL Erection of a storage and distribution building (Use Class B8) erection of 1.6m high boundary fence and alteration to existing entrance and parking/turning areas at Forward Developments Ltd, Station Road, Helmsley

It is not considered that the proposed development would have a detrimental impact on either the character or setting of the National Park and is on land allocated for employment/business use in the Helmsley Local Plan and consequently this Authority has made no objections.

Background Documents to this report File Ref: 1. Signed reports - dates as given 3022/1 2. Signed letter - dates as given 3024/1

Location North York Moors National Park Authority

North York Moors National Park Authority Appendix C Planning Committee

Position as of 21 April 2015

Enforcement Action Progress Report

The following table provides an overview of the current enforcement caseload.

Year 2003 - 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Number of complaints 2301 230 245 227 228 22 Resolved cases 2222 (97)% 180 (78%) 208 (84%) 178 (78%) 130 (57%) 7 (32%) Number of Enforcement 1 ------11 8 9 11 Notices Served Number of Appeals against 0 ------5 2 6 6 Enforcement Notices Number of Appeals dismissed/allowed/varied/ ------3/0/2/0 (0) 2/0/0/0 (0) 2/1/1/2 (0) 2/0/1/0 (3) 0/0/0/0 (0) withdrawn (undecided)

Site File No Breach Compliance Date Current Action Land at Blowgill Farm, 006/2013 Installation of 2 no flue pipes to listed 1July 2015 Flue pipe removed, retained flues to be Snilesworth, Hawnby building painted black. Land at Saltersgate Inn, 002/2014 Untidy Site 16 November 2014 Property remains unsold matter to be Saltersgate referred to legal services Land at Lockerice Hole, 003/2014 Change of Use of Ancillary Utility 14 August 2014 Appeal Lodged-Public Inquiry Date Swainby Building to Separate Dwelling Awaited Spring House, Sleights 04/2014 Dog Grooming Parlour and Rescue 17 August 2014 Public Inquiry held on 14-16 April 2015 Centre Awaiting decision South View, Westgate, 007/2014 Installation of UPVC Windows and 11 February 2015 Appeal Dismissed enforcement notice Thornton Dale Door to front elevation upheld. New compliance date 26 (Conservation Area) September 2015 Old School, Back Lane, 10/2014 Change of Use of Dr’s Surgery and 15 February 2015 Appeal Dismissed enforcement notice Thornton Dale Car Park to Salvage/Reclamation upheld. New compliance date 17 Yard September 2015. Lockerice Hole, Back Lane, 0011/2014 Change of Use of Land and 14 June 2015 Appeal Lodged-Public Inquiry Date Swainby Unauthorised Works Awaited.

Enforcement Action Progress Report May 2015