Papal Infallibility
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THE POPE AND THE OOUNOIL RIVINGTONS DO" ............ WntwZ# PLur e&rn ............ ffrkhsned. m&tQr ........... TI*g Sfnrl. THE POPE AND THE COUNCIL BY JANUS AIJI'HORUED 'T-SLATION SROM THE OBRUAX TXlFtD EDITION REVISED RIVINGTONS %OYIbinI, @xkrb, anb &ambriagc 1870 TABLE OF CONTENTS. NWKCEBY TB~KJLATOR,. P-A%. I~~DUCTION- Jemit Programme for the Conncil, . Recent Provincial Synoda on Papal Infallibility, Method of Proceedings pre-arranged, . - CHAPTER L XAKIAR TEE SYLLABUS DOOMATTO. Sohrader'a affirmative Statement of the Propositions, . (1.) Caercive Power of the Church, (2.) Political Supremacy of the Pop, . (3.) Revision of History, . (4.) Freedom of Conscience and Persecution, . (5.) Modern Civilisation snd Constitutionalism condemned, CHAPTER IL TEE AEW DWBIA ABOm HABY, . Table of Contents. CHAPTER IIL PAPAL ILIPALLIBILITY. P*eI Sscr. 1.-Ulhammtaniam. 37 Seor. 2.-Cbnaequencea of Qe Dogma of InfaULility, . 45 Sxm. 3.-Ems and ContradietiDna of the Pop, 51 Sm.4.-Tha Venlict of Hiatmy on the Poaitim qfBishp8 qfRmin the Ancient Church . 63 Smr. 5.-T& Pvinzaey in the Ancient Conslitvtion of the Chwch, . 77 SECT. 6.- Tlre Teaching of the Pathera or tie Prinurcy, . 86 Slrcr. 7.-Forgeriep- The Isidorian Deeretals, . 94 Forgeries of the Hildebrssdine Ers, . 100 Earlier Bornan Fabrications, . 122 The LOW Pont$ealis, . 128 Tbe Donation of Constantine, . 131 Donstions of Pepin and Charlernape, The Dewetum of Gmtian, . Sea. 8.-Progress of Papal Power in the Twelfth and Thir- teenub Centu-, . Sam. 9.-Papal Enwoacl~rnmlaon .hpiseopal Rights-- Legates, . Exemptiana and Dispensations, . The Pallium, . Pl~nitudoPolcatutis, . Appeals to Rome, . Papal Petranage, . Table of Contents. vii Reseryationa, . 176 The Oath of Obedience. 176 Interference with Diocesan Administration and its Results, . 177 S~cr.10.-Prreonel Attitude of the Pop, . 181 SECT11.-Relation of Popra to Councile in me Middle Agu, 190 SECT.If-Neglect of Theolo~yat Rome, . 199 SECT. 13.-The Collcgc of Cadinds, . 205 8~1.14-The " Cwia," . 215 SEUT.15.-The Judpenta qf Cmtemporaries, . 223 Sm. 16.-The Inpisitiom, . 235 SECT. 17.-Trials for WilchW,. 249 Sm18.-Dmninican Fo'orgeriea and tkt Results, . 261 SECT.19.-Papal Infallibility Disputed, . 271 SB~.20.-~7mh ~orgh, . 278 SECT.21.-It&terdicts, . 289 SECT.22,-The Seniam of the Antippw . 292 Sm. 23.-The Covmit of Coonetame, . 298 Sm. 24-The Coztncil of Bask, . 308 SSCT.25.-The Union with Ue Greek Church, . 319 SECT.26.-TIw Papal Rwtiom, . 327 Sam. 27.-Temper and Circumtall~dsof the FVtmtlr Century, 337 SEUT.28.-The Opening of the Sizkmth Cenlury- The Ftfth Lateran Synod, . 347 Security of the Curia, . 349 The Proman Chancery, . 361 Conecte and Saronamla, . 353 Sm. 29.- The State qf Conlen~paeyOplnbn, . 366 ... vl11 Tabk of Contents. Sm. 30.-The Council of Trent and ita Rcaults, . Sm.31.-Papal InfoUililUily fmulized into a Dodrie Itsli Theolo~.. Admisaiona msde by Infdlibilistq . Bull of Paul m., Omez ApostohtEa ojih, . Bull, In Oan& Dmini, . The Jeanit Divines, . Bellannine, . Corrnptians of the Breviary, The Romn Martyrology corrupted, . The Isidorian Forgeries maintained, DeKtions w: cathedrd, . Paor. 32.-The InfaUibility of the Chwch and qf the Pow capred- Infallibility of the Church, . Infallibility of the Pope, . Mod EEeot of the Theo~on the Popea, . Sm. 38.- What ie mmt by a Fw CMLndS . NOTICE BY THE TRANSLATOR. T will be obvious at a glance to the reader, that this I work emanates from Catholic authorship, and dis- cusses the great religiooua crisis thmugh which thecburch and the world are now passing from a Catholic, though a "liberal Catholic," point of view. That it bears evi- dence of no common attbents and grasp of mind a very cursory examination will suflice to show. An English translation is offered to the public under the belief that there are very many in this country, as wen Protestants as Catholics, who will gladly avail them- selves of an opportunity of learning,'on the most direct authority, how the grave questions which just now sitate the Church are regarded by the members of a school, mody if not numericdy strong, within her pale, who yield indeed to none in their loyd devotion x Notice by the TransZaalor. to Catholic truth, but are unable to identify its interests with the advance of Ultramontanism, or rather, who cannot but recognise between the two an antithesis which the Church history of the last thousand years too eloquently attests, and to which present facts, no less than past experience, give all the significance of a solemn warning it would be worae than unwisdom to ignore. Two rival tendencies, alien alike in their principles and their aims, which have long been dently develop- ing themselves, are now contending for the mastery within the bosom of the Church, like the unborn babes in Rebekah's womb, and it is simply a truism to assert that every section of our divided Christendom is inter- ested in the result of the atruggle. We live in an age powerful beyond all that have gone before for good and for evil, penetrated perhaps more deeply than controversial- ists are willing to admit by Christian sentiment, but aIso presenting in too many quarters a spectacle unprece- dented in modem history, of fixed and deliberate anta- gonism to the dogmas of the Christian creed. Not only the world of sense, but of supernatural revelation, is Notice by the Translator. xi delivered over to the disputations of men. At such a moment, it is proposed, amid the fervid acclamations of one party, the earnest and sorrowful protests of another, the careless acquiescence or sullen indiffer- ence of a host of nominal believers, and the triumphant sneers of an amused but unbelieving outside world, to erect Papal Infallibility into an article-and therefore inevitably the cardinal article-of the Catholic faith. Under a profound sense of the range and gravity of the issues involved this work was written, and with a simi- lar feeling, which each day's experience only deepens, it has been translated Man's necessity, we know, is God's opportunity, and even at the eleventh hour He may stretch forth His arm to save His menaced and afflictedChurch. "Oculi omnium in Te sperant, Domine, et Tu das escam illorum in tempore opportuno." We cannot, indeed, forget that two years elapsed before the cecnmenical pretensions of the Latrmnium of Ephesus were formally superseded, and that for more than twenty the Church lay, technically at least, under the reproach of heresy inflicted on her by the Council of Rimini, to which St. Jerome gave expression in the Notice 6y the Translator. well-known words, "Ingemuit totus orbis et Arianum se esse miratus est." Meanwhile, it behoves us to possess our souls in patience, as knowing that the Church is greater than any parties or individuals who for the moment may usurp her functions and prostitute her awful name, and that, come what will, truth must ultimately prevaiL It may be well to add that the substance of the earlier portion of this volume appeared in a series of articles on "The Council and the Civilt&,"published during last March in the Allyemeins Zeitung,' which attracted very general attention on the Continent. But the whole subject is here worked out in detail, and with constant reference to the original authorities for every statement that is dwelt upon. 1 See AUp. 2. for Waroh 10-16,1889. Sept. 10, 1869. NOTICE TO THE THIRD EDITION. SEVERALverbal changes have been introduced into the present edition, with a view to greater clearness and accuracy of rendering, besides the correction of misprints both in the Original and the Translation, and some additional footnotea Dee. 8. 1869. PREFACE. HE immediate object of this work is to investigate T by the light of history those questions which, we are credibly informed, are to be decided at the CEcu- menical Council already announced. And as we have endeavoured to fuMl this task by direct reference to original authorities, it is not perhaps too much to hope that our labours mill attract attention in scient3c a circles, and serve as a contribution to Ecclesiastical History. But this work aims also at something more than the mere calm and aimless exhibition of histori- cal events ; the reader will readily perceive that it has it far wider scope, and deals with ecclesiastical politics, -.in one word, that it is a pleading for very life, an appeal to the thinkers among believing Christians, a protest based on history against a menacing future, against the programme of a powerful coalition, at one time openly proclaimed, at another more darkly insi- xiv Preface. nuated, and which thousands of busy hands are daily and hourly employed in carrying out. We have written under a deep sense of anxiety in presence of a serious danger, threatening primarily the internal condition of the Catholic Church, and then- as is inevitable with what affects a corporation includ- ing 180 millions of men-destined to assume vaster dimensions, and take the shape of a great social pro- blem, which cannot be without its influence on eccle- siastical communities and nations outside the Catholic Church. This danger does not date from yesterday, and did not begin with the proclamation of the Council. For some twenty-four years the reactionary movement in the Catholic Church, which is now swollen to a mighty torrent, has been manifesting itself, and now it is pre- paring, like an advancing flood-tide, to take possession of the whole organic life of the Church by means of this Council. We-and the plural must not here be understood figuratively, but literally-we confess to entertaining that view of the ~athokChurch and her mission which its opponents designate by that much-abused term, so convenient in its vagueness for polemical pur- Preface.