arXiv:0905.1355v2 [gr-qc] 4 Sep 2009 edrt 1 o ealdrve) nti otx,re- context, been has as this collapse In denoted gravitational of review). proposed, state final detailed the new a refer a for cently ambigu- (we [1] solution certain Schwarzschild to ex- a the reader as the in well literature inherent as the ity misconceptions, in of encounters istence still spacetimes. curved one in However, theory field quantum of in- singularitie aspects for and spacetime beyond, horizons, event and regarding relativity, stance, general in role conceptual nitro eSte odnae oendb nequa- by an given by governed state with condensate, of object Sitter compact tion a de of inves- interior consist extensively an models been These have properties tigated. their and holes, stars ‡ † ∗ lcrncades fl[email protected] address: Electronic [email protected] address: Electronic lcrncades [email protected] address: Electronic h cwrshl ouinhspae fundamental a played has solution Schwarzschild The 2,wihrpeetaval lentv oblack to alternative viable a represent which [2], ) a crto ikpoete itnus rvsasfrom gravastars distinguish properties disk accretion Can ASnmes 45.d 47.w 97.10.Gz 04.70.Bw, 04.50.Kd, numbers: PACS h sign black observational Kerr-type these effi from gravastars Thus, less rotating a holes. distinguishing provide black gravastars radiatio than i.e., into radiation holes, mass black accreting for the efficiency of diffe efficiency conversion signatu are observational the Due clear spectrum) giving velocity. consequently radiation angular objects, equilibrium the and in properti distribution electromagnetic order and second thermodynamic the the gravastargeometry, to rotating up slowly holes around estimated th black disks through Kerr-type accretion is and consider gravastars holes axiall rotating black and around stationary from geometr disks of gravastars exterior context the distinguishing the expec reg distinguish of in the stability However, to difficult to large hole. black be close gravastars would sufficiently static it are in that Ob that that exist fact relativity. challen configurations) major the general h a of to matter, is gravastars picture due anisotropic and hole holes of black black shell astrophysical standard thin the correlated to strongly a by eateto xeietlPyis nvriyo Szeged, of University Physics, Experimental of Department etod ´sc eoiaeCmuainl audd eCi de Faculdade Computacional, F´ısica Te´orica e de Centro rvsas yohtcatohsclojcs consistin objects, astrophysical hypothetic Gravastars, a-lnkIsiuefu aiatooi,AfdmH¨uge dem Auf f¨ur Radioastronomie, Max-Planck-Institute .INTRODUCTION I. eateto hsc n etrfrTertcladComput and Theoretical for Center and Physics of Department gravastars p = vnd rfso aaPno2 -6903Lso,Portuga Lisboa, P-1649-003 2, Pinto Gama Professor Avenida h nvriyo ogKn,PkF a od ogKong Hong Road, Lam Fu Pok Kong, Hong of University The − ρ ace oaselof shell a to matched , ( grav itational Dtd etme ,2009) 4, September (Dated: rnic .N Lobo N. S. Francisco va iei Harko Tiberiu ota Kov´acsZolt´an cuum s, nt hcns iha qaino state of equation an with thickness finite we w nt ai.I oeohrcsste collapse they cases other be- some oscillating In is radii. shell finite thin two tween the excursion” “bounded where represent gravastars, they stable cases gravastars, other stable in represent models while the prototype found cases was of some It in [5]. that models studied and dynamical constructed Recently, were gravastars Reissner-Nordstr¨om and or interior [4]. Sitter Sitter exterior de (anti)-de or Schwarzschild Sitter a anti-de furth an was physically analysis to stability some generalized latter that gravastar are This layer transition stability. the there to the of lead for that state features found of equations key was reasonable the It constructing shares by scenario. that [3], model in considered a was layer perturbations symmet transition ric spherically the against of shell) thin stability infinitesimally slightly view. dynamic (an of the radius point of a thermodynamic issue config- a The at These from stable located [2]. are radius is urations Schwarzschild surface the hori- event than rigid no greater its and origin as the at zon, singularity gravastar no the Sitter has de therefore, model the horizons, Schwarzschild both replaces vac- the Schwarzschild shell and thick exterior The an solution. to uum matched then is latter e.I diint hs ti losonthat shown also is it this, to addition In res. fadr nrycnest surrounded condensate energy dark a of g ∗ † oles. ,wt l h erctno components tensor metric the all with s, efrti atrtertclmdl This model. theoretical latter this for ge in ehns o ovrigms to mass converting for mechanism cient so h ik eeg u,temperature flux, (energy disks the of es trspoietepsiiiyo clearly of possibility the provide atures epciey ntepeetppr we paper, present the In respectively. , sawy mle hnteconversion the than smaller always is n ymtia emtis possibility a geometries, symmetrical y etfrteetocasso compact of classes two these for rent oprtv td fti accretion thin of study comparative e os(ftetasto ae fthese of layer transition the (of ions ‡ e oiino h vn oio,so horizon, event the of position ted fgaatr rma astrophysical an from gravastars of y v enpooe sa alternative an as proposed been ave 9 32 on emn and Germany Bonn, 53121 69, l ´ mTe ,See 70 Hungary 6720, Szeged D´om T´er 9, evtoal itnusigbetween distinguishing servationally e ca aUiesdd eLisboa, de Universidade ˆencias da otedffrne nteexterior the in differences the to toa Physics, ational l lc holes? black p = ρ The . er - 2 until the formation of black holes. without the presence of exotic fluids or modifications of In addition to this, gravastar models that exhibit the Friedmann equations. continuous pressure without the presence of infinitesi- However, observationally distinguishing between astro- mally thin shells were introduced in [6] and further an- physical black holes and gravastars is a major challenge alyzed in [7]. By considering the usual TOV equation for this latter theoretical model, as in static gravastars for static solutions with negative central pressure, it large stability regions exist that are sufficiently close was found that gravastars cannot be perfect fluids and to the expected position of the event horizon. The anisotropic pressures in the ‘crust’ of a gravastar-like constraints that present-day observations of well-known object are unavoidable. The anisotropic TOV equation black hole candidates place on the gravastar model were can then be used to bound the pressure anisotropy, and discussed in [15]. The heating of neutron stars via ac- the transverse stresses that support a gravastar permit cretion is well documented by astronomical observations. a higher compactness than the Buchdahl-Bondi bound A gravastar would acquire most of its mass via accre- for perfect-fluid stars. A wide variety of gravastar mod- tion, either as part of its birth (e.g., during core collapse els within the context of nonlinear electrodynamics were in a supernova explosion followed by the rapid accretion also constructed in [8]. Using the F representation, spe- of a fallback disk), or over an extended period of time cific forms of Lagrangians were considered describing after birth. Similar heating processes have not been ob- magnetic gravastars, which may be interpreted as self- served in the case of black hole candidates. However, gravitating magnetic monopoles with charge g. Using the the absence of a detectable heating may also be consis- dual P formulation of nonlinear electrodynamics, electric tent with a gravastar, if the heat capacity is large enough gravastar models were constructed by considering specific that it requires large amounts of heat to produce small structural functions, and the characteristics and physical changes in temperature. Nevertheless, some level of ac- properties of the solutions were further explored. Gravas- cretion heating is unavoidable, and provides some strong tar solutions with a Born-Infeld phantom replacing the constraints on the gravastar model. The large surface de Sitter interior were also analyzed in [9]. redshifts employed in gravastar models implies that the It has also been recently proposed by Chapline that internal energy generated per unit rest mass accreted is 2 this new emerging picture consisting of a compact ob- very nearly c , and that the radiation emitted from the ject resembling ordinary spacetime, in which the vacuum surface of the object should be an almost perfect black energy is much larger than the cosmological vacuum en- body. The energy evolution of an accreting gravastar is determined by the equation dU/dt = Mc˙ 2 L, where ergy, has been denoted as a ‘dark energy star’ [10]. In- − deed, a generalization of the gravastar picture was con- U is the internal energy, M˙ is the mass accretion rate, sidered in [11] by considering a matching of an interior and L is the luminosity. Assuming that the gravastar solution governed by the dark energy equation of state, is the result of a BEC-like phase transition induced by ω = p/ρ < 1/3, to an exterior Schwarzschild vacuum strong gravity [10], the gravastar which starts at zero − solution at a junction interface. Several relativistic dark temperature and rapidly accretes a mass ∆mMSun will energy stellar configurations were analyzed by imposing be heated to a temperature as observed at infinity of specific choices for the mass function, by assuming a con- T 3.1 106m−2/3ξ1/3 (∆m/m)1/3 K, where m is the h ≈ × stant energy density, and a monotonic decreasing energy mass of the gravastar in solar mass units, and ξ = l/lPl is density in the star’s interior, respectively. The dynamical the length scale in Planck units at which general relativ- stability of the transition layer of these dark energy stars ity fails to adequately describe gravity. In the case of slow to linearized spherically symmetric radial perturbations accretion, the temperature is given by the equilibrium about static equilibrium solutions was also considered, 1/4 value T 1.7 107 M/˙ M˙ m−1/4 K, where and it was found that large stability regions exist that eq ≈ × Edd −9 are sufficiently close to where the event horizon is ex- M˙ Edd =2.3 10 mM⊙/yr is the Eddington mass accre- pected to form. Evolving dark energy stars were explored tion rate. By× comparing these theoretical predictions on in [12], where a time-dependent dark energy parameter the temperature with the upper limits of the temperature was considered. The general properties of a spherically of the black hole candidates, obtained through observa- symmetric body described through the generalized Chap- tions, one can find some limits on ξ. Two black hole lygin equation of state were also extensively analyzed in candidates, known to have extraordinarily low luminosi- [13]. In the context of cosmological equations of state, ties, namely, the supermassive black hole in the galactic in [14] the construction of gravastars supported by a van center, Sagittarius A*, and the stellar-mass black hole, der Waals equation of state was studied and their re- XTE J1118 + 480, respectively, were considered in the spective characteristics and physical properties were fur- analysis [15]. For XTE J1118+480, due to the low mass ther analyzed. It was argued that these van der Waals and low heat capacity, the value of ξ is constrained to quintessence stars may possibly originate from density ξ 5 103, while for Sagittarius A* values for ξ in the fluctuations in the cosmological background. Note that range≈ × 104 and 1011 are excluded. Therefore the length the van der Waals quintessence equation of state is an scale for the considered gravastar models must be sub- interesting scenario that describes the late universe, and Planckian. Thus, if any significant fraction of the mass of seems to provide a solution to the puzzle of dark energy, the gravastars is due to accretion, we should see the ther- 3 mal emission associated with that phase, which is ruled the equation of state, the speed of sound and the surface out for Sagittarius A* and XTE J1118 + 480. redshift were calculated for both models. The dipolar The question of whether gravastars can be distin- magnetic field configuration for gravastars was studied guished from black holes at all was also considered, from in [21], and solutions of Maxwell equations in the inter- a theoretical point of view, in [16], where two basic ques- nal background spacetime of a slowly rotating gravastar tions analyzed were: (i) Is a gravastar stable against were obtained. The shell of the gravastar where the mag- generic perturbations and, (ii) if it is stable, can an ob- netic field penetrated was modeled as a sphere consisting server distinguish it from a black hole of the same mass? of a highly magnetized perfect fluid, with infinite con- A general class of gravastars was constructed, and the ductivity. It was assumed that the dipolar magnetic field equilibrium conditions in order to exist as solutions of of the gravastar is produced by a circular current loop the Einstein equations were obtained. It was found that symmetrically placed at radius a at the equatorial plane. gravastars are stable to axial perturbations, and that The mass accretion around rotating black holes was their quasi-normal modes differ from those of a black hole studied in general relativity for the first time in [22]. By of the same mass. Thus, these modes can be used to dis- using an equatorial approximation to the stationary and cern, beyond dispute, a gravastar from a black hole. The axisymmetric spacetime of rotating black holes, steady- formation hysteresis effects were ignored in this study. state thin disk models were constructed, extending the In addition to this, sharp analytic bounds on the surface theory of non-relativistic accretion [23]. In these mod- compactness 2m/r that follow from the requirement that els hydrodynamical equilibrium is maintained by efficient the dominant energy condition (DEC) holds at the shell cooling mechanisms via radiation transport, and the ac- were derived in [17]. In the case of a Schwarzschild exte- creting matter has a Keplerian rotation. The radiation rior, the highest surface compactness is achieved with the emitted by the disk surface was also studied under the stiff shell in the limit of vanishing (dark) energy density in assumption that black body radiation would emerge from the interior. In the case of a Schwarzschild-de Sitter ex- the disk in thermodynamical equilibrium. The radiation terior, it was shown that gravastar configurations with a properties of thin accretion disks were further analyzed in surface pressure and with a vanishing shell pressure (dust [24, 25], where the effects of photon capture by the hole shells), are allowed by the DEC. The causality require- on the spin evolution were presented as well. In these ment (sound speed not exceeding that of light) further works the efficiency with which black holes convert rest restricts the space of allowed gravastar configurations. mass into outgoing radiation in the accretion process was The ergoregion instability is known to affect very com- also computed. More recently, the emissivity properties pact objects that rotate very rapidly, and that do not of the accretion disks were investigated for exotic cen- possess an horizon. A detailed analysis on the relevance tral objects, such as wormholes [26], and non-rotating or of the ergoregion instability for the viability of gravas- rotating quark, boson or fermion stars and brane-world tars was presented in [18, 19]. In [18], it was shown that black holes [27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32]. The radiation power ultra-compact objects with high redshift at their surface per unit area, the temperature of the disk and the spec- are unstable when rapidly spinning, which strengthens trum of the emitted radiation were given, and compared the role of black holes as candidates for astrophysical with the case of a Schwarzschild black hole of an equal observations of rapidly spinning compact objects. In mass. The physical properties of matter forming a thin particular, analytical and numerical results indicate that accretion disk in the static and spherically symmetric gravastars are unstable against scalar field perturbations. spacetime metric of vacuum f(R) modified gravity mod- Their instability timescale is many orders of magnitude els were also analyzed [33], and it was shown that partic- stronger than the instability timescale for ordinary stars ular signatures can appear in the electromagnetic spec- with uniform density. In the large l = m approximation, trum, thus leading to the possibility of directly testing suitable for a WKB treatment, gravitational and scalar modified gravity models by using astrophysical observa- perturbations have similar instability timescales. In the tions of the emission spectra from accretion disks. low-m regime gravitational perturbations are expected to It is the purpose of the present paper to consider have shorter instability timescales than scalar perturba- another observational possibility that may distinguish tions. In [19], the analysis shows that not all rotating gravastars from black holes, namely, the study of the gravastars are unstable, and stable models can be con- properties of the thin accretion disks around rotating structed also with J/M 2 1, where J and M are the an- gravastars and black holes, respectively. Thus, we con- gular momentum and mass∼ of the gravastar, respectively. sider a comparative study of the thin accretion disks Therefore, the existence of gravastars cannot be ruled around slowly rotating gravastars and black holes, respec- out by invoking the ergoregion instability. The gravas- tively. In particular, we consider the basic physical pa- tar model was extended by introducing an electrically rameters describing the disks, such as the emitted energy charged component in [20], where the Einstein–Maxwell flux, the temperature distribution on the surface of the field equations were solved in the asymptotically de Sit- disk, as well as the spectrum of the emitted equilibrium ter interior, and a source of the electric field was coupled radiation. Due to the differences in the exterior geome- to the fluid energy density. Two different solutions that try, the thermodynamic and electromagnetic properties satisfy the dominant energy condition were given, and of the disks (energy flux, temperature distribution and 4 equilibrium radiation spectrum) are different for these ∆ < 0 indicates that pr >p⊥. Note that ∆/r represents two classes of compact objects, thus giving clear obser- a force due to the anisotropic nature of the stellar model, vational signatures, which may allow to discriminate, at which is repulsive, i.e., being outward directed if p⊥ >pr, least in principle, gravastars from black holes. We would and attractive if p⊥
<<