VC Support for Top-Up Fees Threatens Rift In
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Issue 590, 28 Nov 2003 THE INDEPENDENT CAMBRIDGE STUDENT NEWSPAPER www.varsity.co.uk OPINION ARTS RUGBY Tom Lane takes The three great lessons of SPECIAL on mediocracy daytime television Varsity Match preview PAGE 10 PAGE 17 PULL OUT Out of the shadows VC support for top-up eton im Mor fees threatens rift in uni T posals in this letter may have sparked a major rift Tim Moreton and Tom Cahill within the University. She wrote that “the The University yesterday formally unveiled Government’s proposals for a new approach to the scheme of bursaries that was revealed student fees…are right in principle” and that bur- by Varsity last week. The scheme seems set saries should be funded “from the increase in fee to spearhead the Government’s arguments income”. that their controversial Higher Education Ben Brinded told Varsity, “The letter is not funding proposals will not damage access. representative of the students or of the colleges At a press conference in Westminster the Vice- and will affect access.” Similarly, Professor Chancellor, Alison Richard said that the pro- Gillian Evans said, “We [fellows] have not been posals, under which grants of £4,000 will be of- asked for our view. The Vice-Chancellor of fered to students whose parents earn less than Cambridge does not have authority to make £15,000, would make Cambridge “more af- policy for the university.” fordable than it is now” for the poorest students. Yesterday, Professor Richard distanced the She estimated that one in ten students would be University from her comments, saying that she eligible for the full £4,000, but that up to a third was “speaking on [her] own behalf”. She told of students – those with parental incomes as high reporters that University Council had given as £35,000 – would also receive some support. only “informal consideration” as to whether to But the announcement was met in part with support higher fees. dismay from those who accuse Cambridge of con- Since Monday’s letter, Homerton has set it- flating the issues of paying for teaching and pro- self at odds with the Vice-Chancellor and an- viding maintenance. Ben Brinded, President of nounced its opposition to top-up fees, a position Cambridge University Student’s Union (CUSU), already shared by Downing and Churchill. The said that, although the bursaries on offer were College governing body approved a motion put “excellent and comprehensive”, there were oth- forward by students to register its objection. er ways of funding them than through top-up The Government’s proposals, which headed fees. He argued fees would “damage the princi- the list of new bills in the Queen’s speech on ple of equality of opportunity” and would Wednesday, are likely to be met by a backbench “thwart the aspirations of future generations”. revolt by Labour MPs. An early day motion tabled He argued, “It is widely accepted that full stu- on Wednesday has already received 128 Labour dent loans are not enough to cover students’ signatories. It asks for the Government to “pub- basic maintenance costs, but the University’s im- lish full details of alternative [models of funding] plicit support for the White Paper in these pro- to facilitate proper, informed debate.” posals helps the government in shirking its re- CUSU will next week attempt to step into the sponsibilities in providing this to all students.” breach when they release their ‘Alternative White Varsity’s exposure of the scheme last week Paper’ to the national press. The paper will call seems to have caused a rushed response from the for an increase in top-bracket income tax to fund Vice-Chancellor. She wrote a letter to The Times higher education. In its support, Brinded argued on Monday that, while not admitting the de- “Universities and students deserve better than tails of the scheme, justified its need by saying what the Government is offering them. Bursaries “[Our] commitment to access to higher educa- are important to cover students’ living costs but tion…is at risk unless universities become suffi- it’s the fees and the debt that will deter most of ciently well funded to be able to offer bursaries.” the people we are targeting.” But her support for the Government’s pro- Alison Richard Interview p4 “I’m still a millionaire- they’re not” “Various guinea pig parts were seen every day” Pete Waterman on one hit wonders PAGE 14 Zoe Organ on her time in Peru PAGE 12 The region’s best guide to what’s on – see next Thursday’s Cambridge Evening News NEWS EDITOR: JONATHAN WOOD, LAURA-JANE FOLEY, BENJAMIN BLAND 02 Nov 28, 2003 www.varsity.co.uk What’s inside... News pg2 Monkey labs approved Peterhouse bans kettles, col- lege wine for sale, where have Aisleigh Sawyer all the masters gone? Deputy Prime Minister John Prescott granted the University Alex Steer Comment pg5 permission to go ahead with a mul- Top-up fees in the Queen’s ti-million pound primate research Speech... a terrible fudge? centre at 307 Huntingdon Road last week. However, financial problems may still cause the University to abandon the plans it fought five Features pg9 years to get approved. MoJoW unites Jewish and Overruling previous decisions by Muslim women. South Cambridgeshire District Council and the government planning inspectorate, John Prescott stated in Editorial pg10 his report last Friday that “the pro- Varsity’s view posed development is regarded by the Government as being of national im- portance and that it is fully in line with Travel pg12 government policy”. The centre would be one of the largest animal testing lab- Brixton in a day and the oratories in Europe. South Mountains of Peru Cambridgeshire Council had initially rejected the planning application for the PRC as protestors could cause 307 Huntingdon Road- site for the proposed primate research centre Listings pull out chaos and disturbance to locals. Nonetheless, the University re- this is not the right site.” The more ex- islation of its type in the world”. Your four-page guide to what’s However, Pro Vice-Chancellor mains officially committed to the proj- treme group, SPEAC, even warned Minson argued, “everyone who joins on this week Tony Minson admitted that the centre ect and is still in discussion with fund- that they are prepared to bring the the protest will be marching against looks set to be so expensive that it may ing partners and agencies. Minson University to its knees, saying, “Every some of the most fundamental med- be axed. A University spokesperson argued, “We want to do the science brick laid will be contested”. ical breakthroughs that have kept added that delays had made things and… if we can manage the finances Cambridge admits that already “re- them…safe over the years.” Rugby Special worse, saying, “Each month that pass- we will do it.” searchers, scientists, vets and admin Andrew Tyler, Director of Animal Varisty match preview es means a significant amount of mon- Reaction to the Deputy Prime staff have all been the target of threats.” Aid, believes that “pulling the plug on ey added to the capital costs of the proj- Minister’s decision was divided. However, a recent MORI Poll the project due to lack of finances ect in inflation.” Animal rights protestors were out- showed that more than 80% of the would give Cambridge a face-saving The centre is likely to cost £30 mil- raged by the “grotesque and as- population recognizes the need for the way out of the controversy”. Interview pg14 lion to build and involve running costs tounding” development and South use of animals in biomedical research. Cambridge responded, “The of £1.5 million. Shortfalls in the proj- Cambridgeshire MPAndrew Lansley Meanwhile, the University maintains University is not bowing to pressure.” Music impressario Pete ect have been reported as between said, “It is unwise on John Prescott’s that testing is carried out in accordance Yet, despite their professed resilience Waterman £7 million and £9.6 million. part. We have argued all the way that with “the most rigorous piece of leg- the question of costs still remains. The Ordinary pg15 Your fun is their challenge Live don and prosper graduates at Caius who also died aged The national average for males was lifestyle might well explain why dons Jonathan Wood 60 or over. The second group was the 15.3 years. live longer, “such features might in- Fashion pg16 Living amongst ivory towers real- wider UK population. Dr Brooke said, “it seems unlike- clude a secure job, accommodation Dressing to impress for the ly can do wonders for your health. Copas described her methodology ly that the enhanced longevity of and pension, a supportive commu- party season A new study based on an under- to Varsity more succinctly, explaining Fellows is due to childhood back- nity and the esteem of one’s peers. grauate dissertation has shown that they relied heavily on obituaries ground, because the undergraduates They are features shared with a that Cambridge dons have life ex- in the University Reporter and then live no longer than the national pop- monastic lifestyle, and earlier work pectancies that are on average lives “put it all into a big statistical model”. ulation”. One suggestion is that it has demonstrated enhanced life Arts pg17 for four years higher than the gen- At the age of 60 the median expec- “could be due to the [assumed] spans among monks.” eral population. tation of further life of Fellows was 19 greater intelligence of Fellows, if there Copas added, “It is about the Christmas TV Alife of formal halls, expensive col- years.