Jews, by Choice Conversion and the Formation of Jewish Identity by Jeffrey Spitzer
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Jews, by Choice Conversion and the formation of Jewish identity by Jeffrey Spitzer A curriculum for the Hartman Tichon Fellows Curriculumguide130416v7.56 Jews By Choice curriculumguide151020v7.57, Jeffrey A. Spitzer Jews, by Choice: A Teacher's Guide Table of Contents A Rationale for Jews, by Choice: Conversion and the formation of Jewish identity .........1 Student learning goals ..........................................................................................................3 Syllabus ..............................................................................................................................10 1. Course Introduction .....................................................................................................14 2. On the Boundaries of Israel: the Biblical ger...............................................................27 3. The Origins of Conversion: Proselytes in the Hellenistic period ................................42 4. “For the Sake of Heaven”: the convert’s motives in Talmudic literature ....................63 5. The Rabbinic Conversion Ceremony ...........................................................................82 6. The Rituals of Conversion: Circumcision and Immersion (optional) ........................112 7. Conversion, Rebirth, and Kinship ..............................................................................137 8. Conversion and Covenant ..........................................................................................166 9. Midrash and Ambivalence about Conversion ............................................................188 Acknowledgements I would like to thank the Hartman Institute for their support in producing this curriculum. Special thanks to Donniel Hartman, Tzvi Zohar, David Ellenson, and Shaye Cohen whose scholarship and gracious gifts of time motivated and informed my own research. Noam Zion and Alick Isaacs offered valuable comments along the way, as did my colleagues among the TICHON fellows. My dear friends Daniel and Dafna Pedersen and their children repeatedly and graciously extended their hospitality during my study in Jerusalem. My head of school, Marc Baker, and the associate head, Susie Tanchel, have always been enthusiastic supporters of this curriculum. The members of the Rabbinic literature department at Gann Academy have each given me feedback on different aspects of this curriculum and its pedagogy. Tina Kasimer and Arlene Seidman helped me recognize that my learning about conversion had a practical outlet in my home community of Sharon, MA. My wife and teacher, Rabbi Miriam Spitzer, as an educator of Jews-by-choice, has been for me and for her students a model for what it means to draw near while maintaining the integrity of Jewish tradition. My wife and my children, Rafi, Gabriella, Leora, and Arielle, each supported me in this project even though it meant I was in Israel without them for several summers. I am so deeply grateful to them for their love and encouragement. Finally, I thank my students at Gann Academy and the American Hebrew Academy who studied this topic with me since 2007. .I have learned most from the interactions with my students מתלמידי, יותר מכולם I have learned from each of my teachers, but of course, any errors remain my own responsibility. Jews, by Choice: A curriculum guide © 2017 Jeffrey A. Spitzer, v. 7.6 Goals and Rationales Jews, by Choice page 1 A Rationale for Jews, by Choice: Conversion and the formation of Jewish identity “Mashal: A young boy was moving to a new school. The principal sat with him and explained the rules of the school to him for three hours. When he agreed to follow all the rules, the principal sent him to his classroom. On the way to class, he met a little girl who said to him, ‘If you will steal some candy from the cafeteria for me, I will be your friend.’ So the boy stole the candy.” --Ben, Gann Academy ‘08 In this startling mashal, Ben ironically reflects on the gap between traditional rabbinic expectations concerning the convert’s commitment to Jewish law and his own experience that many Jews are not so concerned about Jewish observance. At another level, Ben was also describing his own ambivalence about traditional observance. And at yet another level, Ben was demonstrating his deep involvement with the ongoing conversation of Torah she’b’al Peh by expressing himself through the medium of the rabbinic mashal. Although born Jewish, Ben, like most modern Jews, is a Jew by choice. This course provides students like Ben an opportunity to articulate their own Jewish identities through the study of how Jews have understood conversion throughout Jewish history. In many ways, all modern Jews are Jews by choice. Jews choose how and when--or if--to affiliate with a Jewish community. Jews choose what kinds of Jewish behaviors they want to engage in and which they do not, and what meanings they attribute to those behaviors. The convert also chooses his/her Judaism, but once part of the Jewish people, the conversion is irrevocable. The primary goal of this course is to make the Jew-by- choice a viable, personal metaphor for students in Jewish community high schools who are in the process of shaping and choosing their Jewish identities. Whatever the outcome of that process, it is our hope that they will find their connection similarly irrevocable. Jews, by Choice, will allow students in community Jewish high schools to explore the components of their own Jewish identities in conversation with classical texts about conversion. Jewish values are forged through the productive tension of different Jewish concerns, and the topic of conversion allows the student to explore those tensions. This course, however, is not simply a course in modern Jewish dilemmas concerning the status of converts; it is, instead, a structured, historical inquiry into the different ways Jews have described their interaction with the people at the borders of Jewish society and how different conceptions of conversion to Judaism reflect different models of Jewish identity. Metaphorically, conversion raises a wide range of issues relevant to Jewish identity, such as what does Jewish peoplehood mean, how does one relate to mitzvot and to the State of Israel, and how have Jews tried to balance conflicting Jewish values. In real terms, conversion also forces students to confront the fact that “the Jewish community” does not share a common definition of or criteria for Jewishness. The lack of a shared conception of what it means to be Jewish is a source of deepening and broadening rifts in the Jewish people. The students of our community high schools Jews, by Choice: A curriculum guide © 2017 Jeffrey A. Spitzer, v. 7.6 Goals and Rationales Jews, by Choice page 2 are trained to engage Jewish difference pluralistically, and as such, will be the natural leaders of the Jewish community in trying to heal those rifts. Jews, by Choice will empower these students to confront these issues in creative ways that are mindful of the Jewish past, present, and future. Although this discussion can potentially be uncomfortable, it can also provide an invaluable opportunity for students to address the values they hold and the commitments they are willing to make. This curriculum provides that opportunity. Jews, by Choice traces classical sources in historical sequence. Claims about history are used by contemporary writers both to justify and to suppress changes in Jewish policy, that is, conversion can be said to have a usable history. Consequently, it is worthwhile for students to understand both the history of conversion as well as the ways in which history has been used to influence communal policy. The breadth of historical approaches can both expand the student’s imagination and provide perspective on the challenges facing the Jewish world. Torah she’b’al Peh, or “Conversational Torah”, is an ongoing process that shows both fidelity to tradition and a startling ability to transform tradition through reinterpretation. As such, Torah she’b’al Peh manifests the same commitment to the Jewish past, present, and future which is the hallmark of a strong Jewish identity. Over the course of study, students explore a broad range of rabbinic texts: Talmud, Midrash Halakhah, Midrash Aggadah, codes and responsa. Students engage these texts both as sources for historical data and as voices in an ongoing conversation of Torah in which they learn to participate. The course sets a high standard for text study with the intent to expose students to the differences between the various kinds of Biblical and Rabbinic literatures, and, in the case of the Talmud, the various genres of Talmudic literature. The multiple voices that emerge across time (or even within a particular period and sometimes from the works of a single author) expose the student to the richness and complexity of Torah she’b’al Peh. The way later rabbis read earlier sources, for example, in evaluating what is a legitimate motivation for converting, demonstrates for students the extent of rabbinic creativity and the limits of rabbinic discretion. By emulating the rabbinic forms of midrash and resaponsa, students participate in the ongoing process of Conversational Torah. These activities can contribute to Jewish identity formation and will train the students to think traditionally and creatively about the challenges facing the Jewish people. Jews, by Choice: A curriculum guide © 2017 Jeffrey A. Spitzer, v. 7.6 Goals and Rationales Jews, by Choice page 3 Student learning goals The