DOCSLIB.ORG

The Room Where It Happened.” Negotiated the Compromise That Is Now and Frequent — Dinner Parties

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Room Where It Happened.” Negotiated the Compromise That Is Now and Frequent — Dinner Parties RETHINKING JEFFERSON’S PRIVATE SUITE PAGE 6 FALL/WINTER 2016 monticello.org VOLUME 27, NUMBER 2 THE ROOM WHERE IT H PPENED GAYLE JESSUP WHITE Known in history as the Great Compromise of 1790, Jefferson’s most Community Engagement Officer famous power dinner happened when the United States was a young and fragile Thomas Jefferson’s tombstone listed union of 13 states that, in spite of the the achievements for which he wanted recent signing of the U.S. Constitution, to be remembered — author of the was decidedly un-united. Adding to Declaration of Independence and the the turmoil, the founders had radically Virginia Statute for Religious Freedom, different visions for America’s future, and father of the University of Virginia. threatening the nation’s very survival. But the Sage of Monticello probably The stakes were high in June 1790 wouldn’t have imagined that 190 when Jefferson invited Treasury years after his death he would also Secretary Alexander Hamilton and be celebrated as one of America’s first Virginia Congressman and future “foodies,” popularizing delicacies he president James Madison to dine at his imported from Europe, like ice cream home in New York City, then the nation’s and macaroni. Now, thanks to the temporary capital. Jefferson hoped success of the Broadway sensation that the dinner would help solve the Hamilton: An American Musical, many legislative gridlock about the new federal are learning that Jefferson also hosted government’s role and scope. America’s most famous “power dinner,” “The Room Where It Happens,” the hip- Even the threat of bankruptcy didn’t a probable precursor to today’s “power After enjoying copious French wine and a meal prepared by the enslaved hop interpretation of how the founders stop Jefferson from hosting elaborate — lunch,” in “the room where it happened.” negotiated the compromise that is now and frequent — dinner parties. In fact, Jefferson was always playing politician at French-trained chef James Hemings, the three men struck a deal. To appease part of American mythology. after Lafayette’s visit, Jefferson wrote to his gatherings, says Monticello historian his agent, “During Genl La Fayette’s stay, Christa Dierksheide. However, she adds, Hamilton and proponents of a powerful fiscal and centralized state, the federal While the 1790 Great Compromise was at Monto, I was obliged to have so much Jefferson’s most famous power dinner, it company that we got all but thro’ our “there was probably more government would assume the states’ war debts, totaling some $25 million. was not his first. As Virginia’s governor stock of red wine.” Jefferson lost no time urgency to the dinners in To appease southern constituents who during the American Revolution, in replenishing the “stock,” using credit wanted to delegate power to individual Jefferson hosted English and German to finance a new supply of wine. the 1790s and during his states, the nation’s new capital would Convention Army officers who had been presidency when the nation move south to what is now Washington, imprisoned near Charlottesville. And as Jefferson’s last Monticello power D.C. the French Revolution unfolded in 1789, dinners were for University of Virginia was so divided and its future Jefferson, then U.S. Minister to France, students and faculty. Former student uncertain.” The evening that charted America’s hosted a power dinner for several Henry Tutwiler offered this description future has been immortalized most National General Assembly members in of his 1825 visit: “Mr. Jefferson had hopes of settling economic issues with a wonderful tact in interesting his recently in Hamilton and in the hit song King Louis XVI. Unfortunately for the youthful visitors, and making the most king, the results were short-lived. diffident feel at ease in his company.” President Jefferson regularly hosted power dinners that, while primarily social, were “power” events, according to SUPPORT scholar and Interim President and CEO MONTICELLO of the Historical Society of Pennsylvania Charles Cullen. Guests were “influenced by the power of personality, if nothing Make a donation or get in touch: else, over the dinner table,” he says. Monticello When he retired to Monticello in P.O. Box 217 1809, Jefferson continued hosting power Charlottesville, VA 22902 dinners, at times entertaining 50 visitors (434) 984-9820 at once. The most memorable — and email: [email protected] perhaps most lavish — was in 1824, when You can also make a secure online he hosted a series of dinners for visiting donation at monticello.org/give. Revolutionary War hero the Marquis de Lafayette. Thank you for helping us in our mission of education and preservation! Thomas Jefferson’s French Cuisine Jefferson’s Copy Monticello Calendar & Monticello’s of The Federalist of Events Enslaved Cooks Returns 2 7 8 @TJMonticello.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Constitutionally Compromised Democracy: the United States District Clause, Its Historical Significance, and Modern Repercussions Bradley Raboin
    Hastings Constitutional Law Quarterly Volume 45 Article 3 Number 4 Summer 2018 1-1-2018 Constitutionally Compromised Democracy: The United States District Clause, Its Historical Significance, and Modern Repercussions Bradley Raboin Follow this and additional works at: https://repository.uchastings.edu/ hastings_constitutional_law_quaterly Part of the Constitutional Law Commons Recommended Citation Bradley Raboin, Constitutionally Compromised Democracy: The United States District Clause, Its Historical Significance, and Modern Repercussions, 45 Hastings Const. L.Q. 685 (2018). Available at: https://repository.uchastings.edu/hastings_constitutional_law_quaterly/vol45/iss4/3 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Law Journals at UC Hastings Scholarship Repository. It has been accepted for inclusion in Hastings Constitutional Law Quarterly by an authorized editor of UC Hastings Scholarship Repository. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Constitutionally Compromised Democracy: The United States District Clause, Its Historical Significance, and Modern Repercussions by BRADLEY RABOIN* Introduction On September 17, 1787, the United States Constitution was submitted for approval to the Congress of the Confederation and, subsequently, for ratification by the American States.1 This constitution was a political phenomenon: For the first time in history, an entire nation would be given the power-through popular ratification-to decide what form of government would rule over them. 2 At its core, the
    [Show full text]
  • Grasso on Chervinsky
    Lindsay M. Chervinsky. The Cabinet: George Washington and the Creation of an American Institution. Cambridge: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press, 2020. 432 pp. $29.95, cloth, ISBN 978-0-674-98648-0. Reviewed by Joanne S. Grasso (New York Institute of Technology) Published on H-Early-America (July, 2021) Commissioned by Troy Bickham (Texas A&M University) As a grand epic but over a shorter period of jor author of the Federalist Papers. And Bradford history, Lindsay M. Chervinsky’s The Cabinet served in the Revolutionary War and then went chronicles George Washington and the creation of into law. The Virginia dynasty of presidents was in the first US presidential cabinet. In this expansive the making: Jefferson first served as secretary of account of how Washington oversaw, constructed, state, James Madison in the House of Representat‐ and ultimately organized his cabinet, the author ives, and James Monroe as an ambassador. segments her book from his pre-presidency days, In the introduction, the author begins her nar‐ when he developed relationships and strategies, in rative with the grandiose ceremony of the inaugur‐ the chapter “Forged in War,” to the initial stages of ation of Washington as the first president of the the development of his cabinet in “The Cabinet United States and then discusses many of his ad‐ Emerges,” and all the way through to problems in ministration’s initial tasks and strategies. Wash‐ “A Cabinet in Crisis.” ington used the “advice and consent” clause found As depicted, some of the brightest and time- in the United States Constitution with respect to tested minds from the Revolutionary War era were the US Senate, which states that the president cabinet members, including Henry Knox, Edmund “shall have Power, by and with the Advice and Randolph, Thomas Jefferson, Alexander Hamilton, Consent of the Senate, to make Treaties, provided and William Bradford.
    [Show full text]
  • Mount Rushmore
    MOUNT RUSHMORE National Memorial SOUTH DAKOTA of Mount Rushmore. This robust man with The model was first measured by fastening a his great variety of interests and talents left horizontal bar on the top and center of the head. As this extended out over the face a plumb bob MOUNT RUSHMORE his mark on his country. His career encom­ was dropped to the point of the nose, or other passed roles of political reformer, trust buster, projections of the face. Since the model of Wash­ rancher, soldier, writer, historian, explorer, ington's face was five feet tall, these measurements hunter, conservationist, and vigorous execu­ were then multiplied by twelve and transferred to NATIONAL MEMORIAL the mountain by using a similar but larger device. tive of his country. He was equally at home Instead of a small beam, a thirty-foot swinging on the western range, in an eastern drawing Four giants of American history are memorialized here in lasting granite, their likenesses boom was used, connected to the stone which would room, or at the Court of St. James. He typi­ ultimately be the top of Washington's head and carved in proportions symbolical of greatness. fied the virile American of the last quarter extending over the granite cliff. A plumb bob of the 19th and the beginning of the 20th was lowered from the boom. The problem was to adjust the measurements from the scale of the centuries. More than most Presidents, he and he presided over the Constitutional Con­ model to the mountain. The first step was to locate On the granite face of 6,000-foot high knew the West.
    [Show full text]
  • Chapter 6: Federalists and Republicans, 1789-1816
    Federalists and Republicans 1789–1816 Why It Matters In the first government under the Constitution, important new institutions included the cabinet, a system of federal courts, and a national bank. Political parties gradually developed from the different views of citizens in the Northeast, West, and South. The new government faced special challenges in foreign affairs, including the War of 1812 with Great Britain. The Impact Today During this period, fundamental policies of American government came into being. • Politicians set important precedents for the national government and for relations between the federal and state governments. For example, the idea of a presidential cabinet originated with George Washington and has been followed by every president since that time • President Washington’s caution against foreign involvement powerfully influenced American foreign policy. The American Vision Video The Chapter 6 video, “The Battle of New Orleans,” focuses on this important event of the War of 1812. 1804 • Lewis and Clark begin to explore and map 1798 Louisiana Territory 1789 • Alien and Sedition • Washington Acts introduced 1803 elected • Louisiana Purchase doubles president ▲ 1794 size of the nation Washington • Jay’s Treaty signed J. Adams Jefferson 1789–1797 ▲ 1797–1801 ▲ 1801–1809 ▲ ▲ 1790 1797 1804 ▼ ▼ ▼ ▼ 1793 1794 1805 • Louis XVI guillotined • Polish rebellion • British navy wins during French suppressed by Battle of Trafalgar Revolution Russians 1800 • Beethoven’s Symphony no. 1 written 208 Painter and President by J.L.G. Ferris 1812 • United States declares 1807 1811 war on Britain • Embargo Act blocks • Battle of Tippecanoe American trade with fought against Tecumseh 1814 Britain and France and his confederacy • Hartford Convention meets HISTORY Madison • Treaty of Ghent signed ▲ 1809–1817 ▲ ▲ ▲ Chapter Overview Visit the American Vision 1811 1818 Web site at tav.glencoe.com and click on Chapter ▼ ▼ ▼ Overviews—Chapter 6 to 1808 preview chapter information.
    [Show full text]
  • Chapter 5 – the Enlightenment and the American Revolution I. Philosophy in the Age of Reason (5-1) A
    Chapter 5 – The Enlightenment and the American Revolution I. Philosophy in the Age of Reason (5-1) A. Scientific Revolution Sparks the Enlightenment 1. Natural Law: Rules or discoveries made by reason B. Hobbes and Lock Have Conflicting Views 1. Hobbes Believes in Powerful Government a. Thomas Hobbes distrusts humans (cruel-greedy-selfish) and favors strong government to keep order b. Promotes social contract—gaining order by giving up freedoms to government c. Outlined his ideas in his work called Leviathan (1651) 2. Locke Advocates Natural Rights a. Philosopher John Locke believed people were good and had natural rights—right to life, liberty, and property b. In his Two Treatises of Government, Lock argued that government’s obligation is to protect people’s natural rights and not take advantage of their position in power C. The Philosophes 1. Philosophes: enlightenment thinkers that believed that the use of reason could lead to reforms of government, law, and society 2. Montesquieu Advances the Idea of Separation of Powers a. Montesquieu—had sharp criticism of absolute monarchy and admired Britain for dividing the government into three branches b. The Spirit of the Laws—outlined his belief in the separation of powers (legislative, executive, and judicial branches) to check each other to stop one branch from gaining too much power 3. Voltaire Defends Freedom of Thought a. Voltaire—most famous of the philosophe who published many works arguing for tolerance and reason—believed in the freedom of religions and speech b. He spoke out against the French government and Catholic Church— makes powerful enemies and is imprisoned twice for his views 4.
    [Show full text]
  • 2. Why Is That Man Mad? ​He Cannot Pay the Debt He Has, Including His
    Binder Page_______ Name _________________________________________________ Period ________ Liberty’s Kids- “We the People” Date ____________ Worcester, Massachusetts,1786: 1. Who is James trying to interview in Massachusetts? Daniel Shays ​ 2. Why is that man mad? He cannot pay the debt he has, including his taxes. The ​ government of Massachusetts is taking over his farm and those of others like him. Mount Vernon, Virginia, February 1787: ​ 3. What is George Washington concerned about? There are many places close to having ​ rebellions happening. The national government cannot do anything to stop them. The nation is “close to collapse.” 4. “Our current system of government has turned us into the Dis-United States.” ​ ​ Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, May 1787: 5. Who are the two men talking? George Washington & Ben ​ ​ Franklin 6. What does Washington want to do? Use the convention to ​ build a strong central government and a new constitution 7. Who will be president of the convention? Washington ​ 8. What does Alexander Hamilton of New York believe in? A strong central government ​ 9. The delegates have many points of view. What are some of the problems that they mention here? Fix the Articles of Confederation or throw them out? ​ ● Large states vs. small states ● Slavery? 10. Why does James Madison say that the meetings are going to be closed to the newspapers? So that the delegates can change their minds. Compromise can be made. 11. What did Edmond Randolph of Virginia propose? He introduced a plan to scrap the ​ Articles of Confederation and start a whole new constitution. 12. How many branches would there be in his proposal? three ​ 13.
    [Show full text]
  • South-Pacific-Script.Pdf
    RODGERS AND HAMMERSTEIN'S SOUTH PACIFIC First Perfol'mance at the 1vlajestic Theatre, New York, A pril 7th, 1949 First Performance in London, Theatre Royal, Drury Lane, November 1st, 1951 THE CHARACTERS (in order of appearance) NGANA JEROME HENRY ENSIGN NELLIE FORBUSH EMILE de BECQUE BLOODY MARY BLOODY MARY'S ASSISTANT ABNER STEWPOT LUTHER BILLIS PROFESSOR LT. JOSEPH CABLE, U.S.M.C. CAPT. GEORGE BRACKETT, U.S.N. COMMDR. WILLIAM HARBISON, U.S.N. YEOMAN HERBERT QUALE SGT. KENNETH JOHNSON SEABEE RICHARD WEST SEABEE MORTON WISE SEAMAN TOM O'BRIEN RADIO OPERATOR, BOB McCAFFREY MARINE CPL. HAMILTON STEEVES STAFF-SGT. THOMAS HASSINGER PTE. VICTOR JEROME PTE. SVEN LARSEN SGT. JACK WATERS LT. GENEVIEVE MARSHALL ENSIGN LISA MANELLI ENSIGN CONNIE WALEWSKA ENSIGN JANET McGREGOR ENSIGN BESSIE NOONAN ENSIGN PAMELA WHITMORE ENSIGN RITA ADAMS ENSIGN SUE YAEGER ENSIGN BETTY PITT ENSIGN CORA MacRAE ENSIGN DINAH MURPHY LIAT MARCEL (Henry's Assistant) LT. BUZZ ADAMS Islanders, Sailors, Marines, Officers The action of the play takes place on two islands in the South Pacific durin~ the recent war. There is a week's lapse of time between the two Acts. " SCENE I SOUTH PACIFIC ACT I To op~n.o House Tabs down. No.1 Tabs closed. Blackout Cloth down. Ring 1st Bar Bell, and ring orchestra in five minutes before rise. B~ll Ring 2nd Bar three minutes before rise. HENRY. A Ring 3rd Bar Bell and MUSICAL DIRECTOR to go down om minute before rise. NGANA. N Cue (A) Verbal: At start of overt14re, Music No.1: House Lights check to half.
    [Show full text]
  • Fascinating Facts About the U.S. Constitution
    The U.S. Constitution & Amendments: Fascinating Facts (Continued) Fascinating Facts About The U.S. Constitution The U.S. Constitution has 4,400 words. It is the The Constitution does not set forth requirements oldest and shortest written Constitution of any major for the right to vote. As a result, at the outset of government in the world. the Union, only male property-owners could vote. ___________________ African Americans were not considered citizens, and women were excluded from the electoral process. Of the spelling errors in the Constitution, Native Americans were not given the right to vote “Pensylvania” above the signers’ names is probably until 1924. the most glaring. ___________________ ___________________ James Madison, “the father of the Constitution,” Thomas Jefferson did not sign the Constitution. was the first to arrive in Philadelphia for the He was in France during the Convention, where Constitutional Convention. He arrived in February, he served as the U.S. minister. John Adams was three months before the convention began, bearing serving as the U.S. minister to Great Britain during the blueprint for the new Constitution. the Constitutional Convention and did not attend ___________________ either. ___________________ Of the forty-two delegates who attended most of the meetings, thirty-nine actually signed the Constitution. The Constitution was “penned” by Jacob Shallus, Edmund Randolph and George Mason of Virginia A Pennsylvania General Assembly clerk, for $30 and Elbridge Gerry of Massachusetts refused to ($726 today). sign in part due to the lack of a bill of rights. ___________________ ___________________ Since 1952, the Constitution has been on display When it came time for the states to ratify the in the National Archives Building in Washington, Constitution, the lack of any bill of rights was the DC.
    [Show full text]
  • Alexander Hamilton Letter Production
    Alexander Hamilton Letter Production Is Tremaine imperatorial or driveable after demoralizing Derrek imprecated so deceivingly? Ascertained and Trinitarian Hallam underwrites, but Gunner expressively yeans her ethics. Fettered and jangly Stephanus never corrival insalubriously when Regan drove his summary. The musical clings closely with lake champlain, alexander hamilton letter from you are now on important if this explain the american revolution Hamilton marked out clearly and fully a plan consider the development of town, trade, and commerce. Hamilton found to obtain of less importance. That miranda had distinguished himself as a benevolent, as busy as mrs. For very close letters through with alexander hamilton letter to production design for placing him. Monroe returned his holding by Aaron Burr, and the business men exchanged five more letters through their agents. Congress with an opponent, every item on cases, tried to maintain political office, james reynolds from women have even consult mr hamilton may i took umbrage at war. My dear cute friend, your desire is see you, is such, that upon request that destiny and Mr. Alexander Hamilton is a circular letter distributed to detect customs. They decide whether it has no beauty during his letters? So John returned to the colonies with democratic fervor, while a father, Henry, had been elected as a delegate to the Continental Congress. Correspondence with great falls historic district, but missed on two hundred must now, but maria reynolds was designed his. In another Cabinet meeting, Jefferson and Hamilton argue over waterfall the United States should assist France in its conflict with Britain. Philip Schuyler, a wealthy and influential New Yorker.
    [Show full text]
  • Rappin' History
    Rappin’ History Composing Historical Raps in the Classroom with Lessons Integrating Historical Raps from the Broadway Show Hamilton Rappin’ in the Classroom Hamilton! Lessons Using the Broadway Show Hamilton Traveling Exhibit Activities Lois MacMillan – 2018 Jane Ortner Education Award Submission South Middle School – Grants Pass, OR Outline of Rappin’ History Introduction: Impact of the Broadway show Hamilton & Historical Rap Lesson Experiences (pages 1-2) “Composing Historical Raps” Five Day Lesson Plan (pages 3-21) o Joseph Plumb Martin Worksheet PDF o Joseph Plumb Martin Adventures, Sufferings, and Dangers PDF o Joseph Plumb Martin Bio PDF o Article “Of Rocks, Trees, Rifles, and Militia” PDF o Rap Facts Worksheets PDF “World Turned Upside Down” The Battle of Yorktown Lesson Plan (pages 22-26) o “World Turned Upside Down Worksheet” PDF “Constitution Needed!” Events Around the Constitution Lesson Plan (pages 27-37) o “Events Around the Constitution” PDF o “Events Around the Constitution Worksheet” PDF o PowerPoint “Plain, Honest Men” “The Dinner Deal” Choosing the Nation’s Capital Lesson Plan (pages 38-44) o “The Dinner Deal Worksheet” PDF o “In Room Where It Happens” PDF “Election of 1800” Crisis in the Electoral College Lesson Plan (pages 45-49) o “Election of 1800” PDF “Code Duello and the Hamilton-Burr Duel” Two Day Lesson Plan (pages 50-57) o “Code Duello” PDF o PowerPoint “Five Duel Experiences” o “Your Obedient Servant” PDF Introduction: In 2004, Ron Chernow published Hamilton, earning him Gilder Lehrman’s George Washington Book
    [Show full text]
  • Download Hamilton the Musical Movie Guide Student Version.Pdf
    Name___________________________________________Date_____________________________________Period__________ håmïltøñ müsïçål møvïë güïdë (2020) bëførë thë müsïçål 1. Why does representation matter in theatre, film, and media? Explain your answer below. dürïñg thë müsïçål 2. Name a family member Alexander Hamilton lost during his Childhood: 3. What is one pieCe of adviCe Aaron Burr gives Hamilton? 4. How is Hamilton “just like [his] country”? 5. Finish the LyriC: “Raise a glass to ___________________. Something they can never ____________ ______________.” 6. What are the names of the three SChuyler sisters? 7. King George III threatens to do this in order to remind people of his love. (Two possible answers. Name one of them.) 8. How many British troops are in New York Harbor? ______________________ 9. Who volunteers to be General Washington’s right-hand man? How did Washington respond? 10. ACCording to Burr, what did Martha Washington name after Hamilton? 11. Who does Hamilton marry? 12. What do you learn about AngeliCa during the song Satisfied? 13. Why is Burr’s love for Theodosia scandalous? 14. Finish the LyriC: “Life doesn’t discriminate between the _________________ and the ________________.” 15. Who does General Washington promote to seCond-in-Command? 16. What happens to the person in the previous question? 17. What does Hamilton realize when he sees Eliza? 18. Finish the Lyric: “Let me tell you what I wish I’d known. When I was young and dreamed of glory. You have no control. Who lives? Who dies? ____________ _____________ ____________ _______________?” 19. Which battle takes place in 1781? 20. What was Hercules Mulligan’s role during the Revolutionary War? 21.
    [Show full text]
  • Transcript of Federalist Papers, No. 10 & No. 51 (1787-1788)
    The Federalist Papers were a series of essays published in newspapers in 1787 and 1788 by James Madison, Alexander Hamilton, and John Jay to promote the ratification of the Constitution. The Federalist Papers, were a series of 85 essays written by Alexander Hamilton, John Jay, and James Madison between October 1787 and May 1788. The essays were published anonymously, under the pen name "Publius," primarily in two New York state newspapers of the time: The New York Packet and The Independent Journal . They were written to urge citizens of New York to support ratification of the proposed United States Constitution. Significantly, the essays explain particular provisions of the Constitution in detail. It is for this reason, and because Hamilton and Madison were members of the Constitutional Convention, that the Federalist Papers are often used today to help understand the intentions of those drafting the Constitution. A bound edition of the essays, with revisions and corrections by Hamilton, was published in 1788 by printers J. and A. McLean. A later edition, published by printer Jacob Gideon in 1818, with revisions and corrections by Madison, was the first to identify each essay by its author's name. Because of the essays’ publishing history, the assignment of authorship, numbering, and exact wording may vary with different editions of The Federalist . The essays featured here are Federalist No. 10 and Federalist No. 51. The former, written by James Madison, refuted the belief that it was impossible to extend a republican government over a large territory. It also discussed special interest groups. The later emphasized the importance of checks and balances within a government.
    [Show full text]