Noqvtates PUBLISHED by the AMERICAN MUSEUM of NATURAL HISTORY CENTRAL PARK WEST at 79TH STREET, NEW YORK, N.Y
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
AMERICAN MUSEUM Noqvtates PUBLISHED BY THE AMERICAN MUSEUM OF NATURAL HISTORY CENTRAL PARK WEST AT 79TH STREET, NEW YORK, N.Y. 10024 Number 2828, pp. 1-24, figs. 1-11 October 21, 1985 Stethacanthid Elasmobranch Remains from the Bear Gulch Limestone (Namurian E2b) of Montana RICHARD LUND' ABSTRACT Four chondrichthyan species assigned to the atoquadrate and mandible, numbers oftooth fam- cladodontid genus Stethacanthus are described ilies and pectoral prearticular basals, morphology from the Bear Gulch Limestone ofMontana. Spec- ofthe pelvic girdle and areas ofsquamation. Com- imens are referred to Stethacanthus cf. S. alto- parison with other Bear Gulch stethacanthids nensis and S. cf. S. productus. Two other species strongly suggests that the presence of specialized are too immature to assign with certainty to known cranial and first dorsal fin squamation, with the stethacanthid spine species. The histology and presence of the first dorsal fin and spine, are sec- morphology ofthree isolated cladodont tooth types ondary sexual characters ofmature males. Clado- is described, one of which is referred to Cladodus selache is indicated as the sister group of the Ste- robustus. The species of Stethacanthidae are dis- thacanthidae, with the "Symmoriidae" being the tinguishable on the shapes and proportions ofpal- sister group of Stethacanthus altonensis. INTRODUCTION The Upper Mississippian marine Bear taxa have also provided excellent data on the Gulch limestone member of the Heath For- relative values of the spines and other mor- mation has yielded approximately seven phologicalparameters forgrossdiagnostic dif- species ofcladodont elasmobranchs referable ferentiation, and have particularly demon- to the family Stethacanthidae (Lund, 1974). strated that striking sexual dimorphism within Several ofthese have been found in sufficient the family may pose insurmountable diffi- abundance or completeness to allow ade- culties in the recognition and diagnosis of quate holomorphic diagnosis and description incomplete or inadequately represented (Lund, 1974, 1984, 1985, in press). These forms. Causing particular difficulty are the ' Professor, Biology Department, Adelphi University, Garden City, N.Y. 11530; Research Associate, Department of Ichthyology, American Museum of Natural History. Copyright K American Museum of Natural History 1985 ISSN 0003-0082 / Price $2.25 2 AMERICAN MUSEUM NOVITATES NO. 2828 observations that only males may possess the The specimen CM 23654 was originally characteristic first dorsal spines and fins, and referred to as a female S. altonensis (Lund, only at sexual maturity (Lund, 1984; Fal- 1974). The spine ofthe specimen is immature catus falcatus, Lund, 1985; probably and therefore proximally incomplete. The Stethacanthus altonensis, Lund, 1974 and apical angle ofthe spine is approximately 240 below; S. cf. S. productus, below). In one oth- and the structure of the spine suggests that er, "Physonemus" attenuatus (Lund, in press) the apex was a posterodorsal continuation of there is considerable change of form of the the base (fig. 2D). The apical angle of the first dorsal spine and braincase with growth, spine of S. altonensis is 340 and the apex but females are not known for this species. projects dorsally in relation to the base (New- Additionally, marked differences occur in the berry, 1889, 1897; Lund, 1974). No traces of abundances of males versus females in all dorsal fin elements are preserved. groups with striking sexual dimorphism In dorsal view, the neurocranium is pro- (Ghiselin, 1974; also see Lund, 1982). Fur- portioned essentially as in S. altonensis, but ther, sexually dimorphic living elasmo- with broader supraorbital crests. The pala- branchs ofdifferent sexes may occupy differ- toquadrate has grooves for 6-8 tooth fami- ent ranges at different times (Branstetter, lies, as in S. altonensis, but the palatine por- 1981), suggesting that there may be difficul- tion is dorsally concave and the postorbital ties in locating or recognizing fossil chon- expansion is rounded posterodorsally. There drichthyans ofthe sex opposite to that of the is no visible extension of the palatoquadrate type specimen. Following from this infor- anterior to the mesially inturned ethmoid mation, the purported absence of claspers in process. A quadrate shelf is absent, and the Cladoselache, for instance, may more rea- quadrate condyle extends below the level of sonably be attributed to either an absence of the tooth row. Meckel's cartilage is unknown, mature males at the localities searched or an but clearly had relatively few tooth families inability to recognize males than to the re- and an anteriorly placed coronoid process. mote possibility that this rather specialized The hyomandibula is stout and held in close chondrichthyan lacked claspers (Harris, 1938, association with the palatoquadrate, partic- 1951; Zangerl, 1981; Rosen et al., 1981). ularly near the quadrate condyle (fig. 1). This report will describe Bear Gulch shark "Stemmatodus"-type branchial denticles are specimens that are too rare or too incomplete evident. to assign with certainty to a previously named The pectoral fin is supported by 12 or 13 species, but that are critical to understanding prearticular basals, and eight radials are sup- the morphological differences between species ported on the metapterygial plate. The me- within the Bear Gulch Stethacanthidae. tapterygial axis is poorly preserved. The pel- ABBREVIATIONS: Specimens have been de- vic girdles are triangular, with six conspicuous posited either with the Section of Vertebrate diazonal foramina, and a very small metap- Fossils, Carnegie Museum of Natural His- terygial plate. Each girdle supports at least 12 tory, Pittsburgh, Pa. (CM), or with the Geo- single-jointed radials. Clasper elements are logic Museum ofthe University ofMontana, unknown. Missoula, Montana (MV). The second dorsal fin consists of a mini- mum of 19 separate but closely spaced, one- DESCRIPTIONS jointed radials, the distal segments of which are quite elongate. The posterior portion of Stethacanthus cf. S. productus the fin is followed by a thin triangular plate, Newberry, 1897 but it cannot be determined whether this plate Figures 1, 2, 7F supported fin radials as in Falcatus falcatus PREvIous REFERENCES: Stethacanthus al- (Lund, 1985). The caudal fin, as illustrated tonensis Lund, 1974, fig. 10, CM 23654. in Lund (1974), is heterocercal, and of rela- Stethacanthus cf. S. productus Lund, 1984. tively high angle, with separate neural arches REFERRED SPECIMENS: CM 23654, whole, and spines and discrete dorsal and ventral immature, disturbed specimen; CM 35695, lobes. Precaudal neural arches are paired, long palatoquadrate; CM 37669, palatoquadrate; and thin, and lack median neural spines. MV 6160, pectoral and pelvic girdles. Squamation is unknown, although loose 1985 LUND: STETHACANTHID REMAINS 3 denticles are present in MV 6160. Although no specimen is complete, and therefore no accurate length measurements can be made, the length ofCM 23654 approaches 1 m, and the palatoquadrate is 11.6 cm in length. The palatoquadrate CM 37669 is 24.5 cm long, suggesting a total length of around 2 m for an intact individual. S. cf. S. productus is thus significantly larger than S. altonensis, and the largest known vertebrate in the Bear Gulch Limestone. This size differential is re- flected in the sizes ofknown spines ofthe two species (Newberry, 1889, 1897). Stethacanthus cf. S. productus differs from S. altonensis in the shape of the pterygoid portion of the palatoquadrate, the higher number of prearticular basals of the pectoral fin, the morphology of the pelvic girdle and fin, and in the relative length of the radials ofthe second dorsal fin, as well as in the shape LI and size of the first dorsal fin spine. The two FIG. 1. Stethacanthus cf. S. productus New- species are significantly similar, however, in berry, 1897. CM 23654. Neurocranium, palato- braincase shape, general plan of the pectoral quadrate, and hyomandibular, mesial view. Scale fin, and particularly in lacking a large metap- in cm; hyo, hyomandibular; sn, spiracular notch. terygial plate of the pelvic fin. The imma- turity ofthe first dorsal fin spine ofCM 23654, a moderately large specimen, is striking, sug- The contents of the digestive tract consist gesting that as in Falcatus falcatus (Lund, of an entire, although fragmented, conodon- 1985) the first dorsal fin spine is a secondary tochordate (Melton and Scott, 1973; Scott, sexual character present only in mature 1973). (probably male) individuals. The neurocranium has broad supraorbital crests and a very strong postorbital arcade. Stethacanthus cf. S. The otic region is broad and flat ventrally, altonensis narrower and rounded dorsally, with prom- Figures 3 and 4 inent ridges for anterior and posterior vertical REFERRED SPECIMEN: CM 37680. semicircular canals. Serial supraorbital fo- This specimen consists of jaws, eye pig- ramina for Ramus Ophthalmicus Superfici- ments, branchial and pectoral skeleton, ver- alis fibers supplying the supraorbital lateral- tebral axis with 54 segments, dislocated line canals are present dorsally, and a median braincase, and digestive tract contents. Cal- basal foramen, probably for the hypophysis cification ofthe neurocranium ofthe 10.8 cm and internal carotid arteries (Jarvik, 1977), fossil is incomplete anteriorly. The specimen is present midventrally. is referred to S. altonensis on the basis ofthe The mandible has a high coronoid process following: palatoquadrate has