Deliverable D2.3 Automotive Use Cases and Connectivity Challenges, Business Models and Spectrum Related Aspects Version: V1.1
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Fifth Generation Communication Automotive Research and innovation Deliverable D2.3 Automotive use cases and connectivity challenges, business models and Spectrum related aspects Version: v1.1 2019-07-22 This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 761510. Any 5GCAR results reflects only the authors’ view and the Commission is thereby not responsible for any use that may be made of the information it contains. http://www.5g-ppp.eu Document: 5GCAR/D2.3 Status: Final Version: v1.1 Dissemination level: Public Date: 2019-07-22 Deliverable D2.3 Automotive use cases and connectivity challenges, business models and Spectrum related aspects Grant Agreement Number: 761510 Project Name: Fifth Generation Communication Automotive Research and innovation Project Acronym: 5GCAR Document Number: 5GCAR/D2.3 Document Title: Automotive use cases and connectivity challenges, business models and Spectrum related aspects Version: v1.1 Delivery Date: 2019-07-22 Editors: Antonio Fernandez Barciela (PSA groupe), Per Lindberg (VCC), Mikael Fallgren (Ericsson) Authors: Antonio Fernandez Barciela, Alain Servel, El Khamis Kadiri, Luis Fernández Ferreira, Olivier Sancier (PSA groupe), Per Lindberg, Björn Bergqvist (VCC), Jose León Calvo, Andrés Laya, Mikael Fallgren, Wanlu Sun (Ericsson), Guillaume Vivier (Sequans), Marc Bouillon (Orange), Ricard Vilalta (CTTC), Konstantinos Manolakis, Mohamed Gharba (Huawei), Erik Ström (Chalmers), Zexian Li (Nokia), Nadia Brahmi (Bosch), Diego Bernardez (CTAG), Luis Siqueira (KCL), Kai Cordes (Viscoda) Keywords: Use case roadmap, Market opportunities, Spectrum, V2X, ITS Status: Final Dissemination level: Public Document: 5GCAR/D2.3 Status: Final Version: v1.1 Dissemination level: Public Date: 2019-07-22 Disclaimer: This 5GCAR D2.3 deliverable is not yet approved nor rejected, neither financially nor content-wise by the European Commission. The approval/rejection decision of work and resources will take place at the next Review Meeting, after the monitoring process involving experts has come to an end. Document: 5GCAR/D2.3 Status: Final Version: v1.1 Dissemination level: Public Date: 2019-07-22 Executive summary In this deliverable, an overall V2X use case roadmap has been built together between the automotive and the connectivity industry. Beyond some predictions exposed, a detailed analysis of the current 4G situation is explained, providing also the main advantages of 5G compared to 4G and its current limits for a successful deployment. A business section is included where a summary of the new version of the automotive working group is analysed, deriving important conclusions both for the automotive and telecom industry. In the same section, 2 cost vectors are studied: security cost of the current pseudonym strategy proposed in the Delegated Act (DA) and Over The AIR (OTA) market size. Both can be seen as business opportunities for actors in the connectivity value chain as well as cost penalties for a V2X deployment in the automotive industry. In the same section, all the new features provided in 5GCAR are analysed under a business perspective, providing a qualitative vision of the technological components and remarking the value chain, the customer value and the business possibilities of each. Finally, the current status of 5G new spectrum bands auction is provided with a comparison between different countries and how they have evolved. The frequency refarming is explained as one the future trends and the important event of the WRC2019 is described. The 5GCAR features spectrum impact is also studied as well as the spectrum used in the demonstration. Document: 5GCAR/D2.3 Status: Final Version: v1.1 Dissemination level: Public Date: 2019-07-22 Contents 1 Introduction ......................................................................................................................... 9 1.1 Objective of the document ........................................................................................... 9 1.2 Structure of the document ...........................................................................................10 2 Automotive use cases and connectivity challenges ............................................................11 2.1 Use case roadmap in the 2020-2030 time horizon ......................................................11 2.2 4G current situation .....................................................................................................16 2.2.1 Performance limits ...............................................................................................16 2.2.2 V2X ITS services supported by 4G ......................................................................17 2.3 5G advantages ...........................................................................................................18 2.3.1 Performance ........................................................................................................18 2.3.2 New architecture paradigms ................................................................................19 2.3.3 5G roadmap .........................................................................................................20 2.4 Show stoppers ............................................................................................................21 2.4.1 Lack of deployment, coverage, and road infrastructure upgrades ........................21 2.4.2 Complex status of regulation ................................................................................22 2.4.3 Lack of automotive industry adoption ...................................................................23 2.4.4 Missing automotive standardization .....................................................................23 2.5 5GCAR KPIs in the context of 5G ...............................................................................23 2.5.1 Performance KPIs ................................................................................................24 2.5.2 Societal KPIs .......................................................................................................26 3 Market opportunities and 5GCAR contribution to V2X business .........................................28 3.1 Business market opportunities for V2X .......................................................................28 3.1.1 Automotive whitepaper V2.0 ................................................................................28 3.1.2 Security ................................................................................................................32 3.1.3 Over the air ..........................................................................................................36 3.2 Business model analysis of 5GCAR technical components .........................................41 3.2.1 Positioning ...........................................................................................................42 3.2.2 V2X radio design .................................................................................................44 3.2.3 Network procedures .............................................................................................49 3.2.4 End to end security ..............................................................................................55 Document: 5GCAR/D2.3 Status: Final Version: v1.1 Dissemination level: Public Date: 2019-07-22 3.2.5 Edge computing enhancements ...........................................................................56 3.2.6 Summary and conclusion .....................................................................................57 4 Spectrum ...........................................................................................................................60 4.1 Spectrum auctions and regulation ...............................................................................60 4.1.1 Europe .................................................................................................................61 4.1.2 United States .......................................................................................................76 4.1.3 Asia .....................................................................................................................78 4.1.4 Summary of auctions and cost comparison worldwide .........................................81 4.1.5 Spectrum regulation in Europe and DSM .............................................................85 4.1.6 WRC 2019 agenda ..............................................................................................87 4.2 Spectrum considerations and impact from the technical components .........................89 4.2.1 Technical components from a spectrum perspective............................................89 4.2.2 Spectrum usage and limitations in demonstrations ..............................................92 5 Conclusions .......................................................................................................................93 6 References ........................................................................................................................96 Document: 5GCAR/D2.3 Status: Final Version: v1.1 Dissemination level: Public Date: 2019-07-22 List of Abbreviations and Acronyms 2G 2nd Generation of Mobile CAPEX Capital Expenditure communication technology standard 3G 3rd Generation of Mobile CEPT Conférence Européenne des communication technology Postes et standard Télécommunications