DOCSLIB.ORG

What Are the Institutional Implications of Co-Production As a Strategy for Development?

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
What Are the Institutional Implications of Co-Production As a Strategy for Development? What are the institutional implications of co-production as a strategy for development? A Thesis Submitted to the University of Manchester for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Faculty of Humanities 2014 WAYNE JON SHAND SCHOOL OF ENVIRONMENT, EDUCATION AND DEVELOPMENT, FACULTY OF HUMANITIES CONTENTS Page List of Figures 5 List of Tables 5 Abbreviations 6 Shona Terms 7 Abstract 8 Declaration 9 Copyright Statement 9 Acknowledgement 10 The Author 11 1. Introduction 1.1 Introduction 12 1.2 Conceptual Framework 15 1.3 Research Approach 20 1.4 Key Concepts 21 1.4.1 Defining Co-production 22 1.4.2 Defining Institutions 25 1.4.3 Locating Institutional Change 29 1.4.4 Terminology Used 33 1.5 Thesis Structure 35 2. Co-production and the Conditions for Institutional Change 2.1 Introduction 37 2.2 Conceptualising Co-production 39 2.2.1 Creating Objects of Development 42 2.2.2 Generating Benefits for Citizens and the State 46 2.2.3 Mobilising Co-productive Inputs 48 2.2.4 Releasing Resources for Co-production 50 2.2.5 Sufficiency 52 2.3 Co-production and Institutional Change 54 2.3.1 Adaptive Institutional Change 56 2.3.2 Creating New Spaces for Dialogue 59 2.3.3 Co-production as Change Function 64 2.4 Conclusion 70 3. Researching Co-production and Institutional Change in Urban Zimbabwe 3.1 Introduction 73 3.2 Methodological Approach 73 3.3 Research Questions 77 3.4 Conceptual Challenges 78 3.5 Research Frame 81 3.6 Study Area and Approach 84 3.6.1 Primary Data Collection 86 3.6.2 Stakeholder Interviews 91 3.6.3 Community Interviews 93 3.7 Data Analysis 95 - 2 - 3.8 Research Ethics 96 3.9 Conclusion 97 4. Zimbabwe – Historical and Political Context 4.1 Introduction 99 4.2 Independent Nation 100 4.2.1 Combative Politics 102 4.2.2 Land Reform 106 4.2.3 Operation Murambatsvina 109 4.2.4 Economic Collapse 112 4.2.5 Global Political Agreement 115 4.3 Harare 118 4.3.1 Urbanisation 118 4.3.2 Relationships with Communities – Institutional Frameworks 121 4.3.3 Discursive Representation of Poverty 123 4.3.4 Political Relations – City and National Government 124 4.4 Changing Approaches to Informal Settlements 126 4.4.1 Shack / Slum Dwellers International 127 4.4.2 International Policy Priorities 130 4.5 Conclusion 132 5. Research Background to the Case Study Area and Communities 5.1 Introduction 134 5.2 Zimbabwe Homeless People’s Federation 135 5.2.1 Structure and Membership 136 5.2.2 Savings Schemes 140 5.3 City of Harare – Mapping Informal Settlements 142 5.3.1 Informal Settlements in Harare 142 5.4 Moments of Change 145 5.5 Formation of ZHPF and Dialogue 148 5.6 Mbare Toilets 150 5.7 Crowborough North 153 5.7.1 Development of Crowborough North 155 5.8 Dzivarasekwa Extension 159 5.8.1 In-situ Housing Development 161 5.8.2 Co-productive Approaches 165 5.9 Finance Facility 169 5.10 Conclusion 173 6. Communities Working Together Toward Co-production 6.1 Introduction 176 6.2 Defining Mobilisation 179 6.2.1 Collective Action Frames 180 6.2.2 Mobilisation Creating Social Infrastructure 182 6.3 Mobilising for Co-production 185 6.3.1 Building Scale 186 6.3.2 Reciprocity – Releasing Human Capacity 188 6.3.3 Creating Financial Resources 190 6.3.4 Mobilising for Delivery 192 - 3 - 6.4 Dealing with Collective Action Problems 193 6.4.1 Mobilisation and Maintaining Engagement of Communities 194 6.4.2 Free Riding 199 6.5 Conclusion 200 7. Governance and Governmentality 7.1 Introduction 203 7.2 Challenges of Urban Governance 207 7.2.1 Urban Governance in Context – Harare 209 7.3 ZHPF and Dialogue – Strategy of Engagement 213 7.4 City of Harare – Identifying Partners in Development 220 7.5 Urban Governance 224 7.5.1 Hybrid Governance 225 7.5.2 Funding Urban Infrastructure 228 7.6 Conclusion 229 8. Tracing the Processes of Institutional Change in Harare 8.1 Introduction 232 8.2 Discursive Representations of Low Income Communities 234 8.2.1 Representations of Poverty in Zimbabwe 235 8.2.2 Changing Discourse? 237 8.2.3 Wider Implications 242 8.3 Adapting Bureaucratic Processes 246 8.3.1 Housing Waiting Lists – Documenting Identity 247 8.3.2 Planning and Upgrading Settlements 248 8.3.3 MOU – Articulating Co-production 253 8.3.4 MOA – Financing Incremental Development 258 8.4 Conclusion 261 9. Conclusions and Policy Implications 9.1 Overview 264 9.2 Mobilisation – Creating the Conditions for Co-production 265 9.2.1 Limits to Mobilisation? 267 9.2.2 Mobilisation – Policy Implications 269 9.3 Urban Governance 270 9.3.1 Substantive Change? 271 9.3.2 Governance – Policy Implications 272 9.4 Institutional Change 273 9.4.1 Institutional Transition 275 9.4.2 Institutions – Policy Implications 277 9.5 Conclusions and Further Research 278 9.5.1 Further Research 280 References 283 Appendices Appendix 1 – Summary of Co-production Case Studies Analysed 314 Appendix 2 – Community Interview Schedules 325 Appendix 3 – Construction Costs for 2 Room House – Harare 327 WORD COUNT: 86,200 - 4 - FIGURES Title Page 1.1 Conceptual Framework 18 1.2 Williamson’s Institutional Hierarchy 28 2.1 Idealised Process of Engagement Leading to Institutional Change 62 2.2 Co-production and Williamson’s Institutional Hierarchy 64 2.3 Institutional Transition 66 3.1 Location Map of Crowborough North and Dzivarasekwa Extension 86 4.1 GDP and GDP per Capita, Zimbabwe 1980 – 2012 113 4.2 Percentage Urban Population, Zimbabwe 1980 – 2025 119 5.1 ZHPF – Cities and Towns with a Federation, Zimbabwe 136 5.2 Organisational Structure of ZHPF with Dialogue on Shelter Trust 139 5.3 Location Map of ‘Slum’ Settlements in Harare, 2013 144 5.4 Timeline of Key Events 146 5.5 Mbare Pay Toilets 152 5.6 Selected Images of Crowborough North 154 5.7 Selected Images of Dzivarasekwa Extension 160 5.8 Map of Dzivarasekwa Extension Development Site 162 5.9 Dzivarasekwa Extension, Showing Development of Stands 163 5.10 Incremental Housing Construction Process 164 5.11 Typology of Co-productive Inputs, Dzivarasekwa Extension 168 5.12 Signing of the Finance Facility MOA, 2 May 2014 170 8.1 Press Reports on Planned Demolition of Illegal Settlements 245 8.2 Procurement Processes for Formal and Informal Housing 252 8.3 Shared Principles Identified in the MOU 255 8.4 Spaces of Action: Contributions to Co-production 256 TABLES Title Page 1.1 New Institutionalist Theories 26 2.1 Co-production Articles Analysed 40 2.2 Necessary Conditions for Co-production 42 3.1 Interview Participant Groups 90 5.1 ZHPF National Savings Data by Region, 2012 141 5.2 Dzivarasekwa Extension - Meeting Necessary Conditions? 166 8.1 Dzivarasekwa Extension Project - Meetings, Attendance 239 8.2 MOU and MOA – Institutionalising Partnership Working 260 All photographs are taken by the author, unless otherwise credited. - 5 - ABBREVIATIONS AU Africa Union B&MGF Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation CABS Central Africa Building Society Dialogue Dialogue on Shelter Trust ESAP Economic Structural Adjustment Programme GDP Gross Domestic Product GNU Government of National Unity (Zimbabwe) GPA Global Political Agreement HSUFF Harare Slum Upgrading Finance Facility HSUP Harare Slum Upgrading Programme IIED International Institute for Environment and Development MDC Movement for Democratic Change MDG Millennium Development Goals MOA Memorandum of Agreement MOU Memorandum of Understanding NGO Non-Governmental Organisation NSDF National Slum Dwellers Federation (India) OGHK Operation Garikai / Hlalani Kuhle OPP Orangi Pilot Project PB Participatory Budgeting PMC Project Management Committee RSDF Railway Slum Dwellers Federation (India) SADC Southern Africa Development Community SDI Slum / Shack Dwellers International SPARC Society for the Promotion of Area Resource Centres (India) UCAZ Urban Councils Association of Zimbabwe UN United Nations WOZA Women of Zimbabwe Arise ZANU - PF Zimbabwe African National Union - Patriotic Front ZAPU Zimbabwe African People’s Union ZBS Zimbabwe Building Society ZCTU Zimbabwe Congress of Trade Unions ZHPF Zimbabwe Homeless People’s Federation ZIPRA Zimbabwe People’s Revolutionary Army - 6 - SHONA TERMS Chimurenga Liberation war – first being 1896-87; second refers to the 1970s war of liberation; it’s was also used as a political rallying call - the third Chimurenga to describe the land invasions. Dombo Stone. Refers to the practice used during hyperinflation of repaying loans in-kind: ‘dombo for dombo’. Dzivarasekwa Residential area 20km east of Harare City Centre. The word is Shona for ‘duck pond’. Garikai / Hlalani Operation ‘Live Well’ the proposed housing and infrastructure Kuhle construction programme to follow Murambatsvina. Gukurahundi Literally means the whirlwind / rains that cleanse the crop by blowing away the chaff. Refers to the Fifth Brigade massacres of Ndebele peoples in Matebeleland between 1983 and 1986. Gungano Name of the urban poor fund. The meaning in Shona is a ‘coming together of many people’. Jambanja Refers to land invasions also more literally means chaos or mayhem. Kukiya-kiya Refers to the growing informal economy and ‘making-do’ to meet basic needs. Kutamura Defined as ‘striving, a ZHPF savings group in Harare. Murambatsvina Refers to operation ‘restore order’ / ‘clean away the trash’. Musika Market area – used to refer to Mbare in Harare. Nhamoya Pera Defined as ‘poverty being alleviated / overcome, a ZHPF savings group in Harare. Pungwe Political gathering or celebration where nationalistic songs are sung and stories told. Shingi Rirai Defined as ‘perceiver’, a ZHPF savings group in Harare. Ta Fara Defined as ‘we are happy’, the name of a ZHPF savings group in Harare.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Minister of Local Government's Intrusions in Urban Councils
    Public Policy and Administration Review 1(1); June 2013 pp. 26-48 Jonga The Minister of Local Government’s Intrusions in Urban Councils’ Administration Wellington Jonga (Mr) Lecturer University of Zimbabwe Zimbabwe Open University and Ethiopian Civil Service University Zimbabwe Introduction The article discusses a number of issues that The political setup in addition, violets all makes the Minister of Local Government a principles of human rights. Where politicians liability in the administration of local become bandits they formulate policies that governments. He is basically a political bandit enrich themselves, their families and friends. In because whatever he does in the Ministry is Zimbabwe, policies like the indigenization, meant to benefit ZANU-PF and never the urban economic empowerment, land and many others or rural communities. The Ministry of Local fit the banditry policies. The ordinary (povo) are Government has been used over now a long not benefiting from any of such policies. The period of time by ZANU-PF political prostitutes povo is used to support the policies but the to fight influential progressive parties like the politicians how have political power and support Movement for Democratic Change. of the security sectors corruptly and aggressively or hawkishly grabs the benefits. A political bandit like Chombo is a person who even if he/she knows very well that whatever The failure of ZANU-PF to garner support in he/she is doing is wrong but for the of politics, urban areas has often left the ZANU-PF support of his/her party or for the sake of Governments housed especially in Harare by acquiring naked power he/she will adopt and MDC urban councils.
    [Show full text]
  • 4 Bulawayo Decent Work Indicators
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK/UKS QC: SFK/UKS T1: SFK provided by Oxford Brookes University: RADAR BLBK177-Werna May 30, 2009 16:13 Bulawayo 4 Beacon Mbiba and Michael Ndubiwa 4.1 Introduction This chapter presents the case study of Bulawayo, Zimbabwe. It begins with an overview of the political context and an examination of economic development at both the national and local levels. Qualitative information, mainly derived from interviews with key actors from different institutions involved with the construction sector, has been analyzed. The fieldwork also examined efforts made by the local authority to promote employment in the construction sector and related services, and to assess how the city of Bulawayo has been able to apply the principles of decent work through examples of best practice. 82 P1: SFK/UKS P2: SFK/UKS QC: SFK/UKS T1: SFK BLBK177-Werna May 30, 2009 16:13 Bulawayo 83 4.2 National, regional and local context 4.2.1 The national context Map of Zimbabwe: Regional Location of Bulawayo City Change and continuity: beyond colonial heritage Although at independence in 1980, Zimbabwe adopted a socialist policy outlook, it remained a fundamentally capitalist economy (GoZ, 1982). It has achieved world acclaim in smallholder food production (Eicher, 2003; Gabre-Madhin & Haggblade, 2004; Rukuni & Eicher, 1994), education and health (Raftopolous, 2004), infrastructure and decent work provision for the previously marginalized majority of black Zimbabweans (LEDRIZ, 2005). Zimbabwe was also applauded globally for its ‘national reconcili- ation policy’ adopted in 1980, its role in brokering peace in Mozambique, its SADC leadership and its leading role to end apartheid in Namibia and South Africa.
    [Show full text]
  • Rundbrief 57
    Vereinigung Schweiz-Zimbabwe Swiss-Zimbabwean Friendship Association Rundbrief / Newsletter Nr. 57, Mai 2011 Editorial Zur Erinnerung Im letzten Editorial im November-Rundbrief schrieb ich, dass die Bevölkerung aufatme, weil die Gewalt weg sei - Jahresversammlung 2011: ein erfreuliches Resultat der gemeinsamen Regierung von Samstag, 25. Juni, in Luzern (s. Einladung) Zanu-PF und MDC. Die relativ friedliche Phase dauerte lei- der nicht lange und heute ist die Gewalt wieder zurück. Friedliche Demonstranten werden von der Polizei ausei- Der Diskussionsprozess zur Erarbeitung einer neuen Ver- nandergetrieben; Leute werden verhaftet und im Gefäng- fassung, auf den die Bevölkerung so grosse Hoffnungen nis gefoltert; Versammlungen werden von der Polizei ge- setzte, ist nie richtig in Gang gekommen und von Zanu- stört und die TeilnehmerInnen verhaftet. PF sogar aktiv behindert worden. Viele Organisationen der Zivilgesellschaft verlangen nun die Aufnahme dieses Nach zwei Jahren gemeinsamer Regierung ist die Ernüch- Prozesses. Und für alle ist klar, dass Wahlen erst nach terung gross. MDC-Führer und Premierminister Morgan Abschluss der Verfassungsreform durchgeführt werden Tsvangirai sagte in einer Rede am 15. Februar, dass kein dürfen, auch wenn Mugabe auf die rasche Durchfüh- einziger der 23 Punkte der gemeinsamen Regierungser- rung von Wahlen drängt. Dieser Ansicht ist auch Südaf- klärung bis jetzt umgesetzt wurde. Trotzdem sieht er rikas Präsident Jacob Zuma, von der SADC eingesetzter auch positive Seiten der gemeinsamen Regierung. Diese Vermittler zwischen MDC und Zanu-PF. Viele hoffen, habe Stabilität gebracht, die Wirtschaft sei angekurbelt dass SADC und Zuma einen Weg aus der verfahrenen Si- worden, Schulen, Spitäler und Verwaltung hätten die Ar- tuation finden. beit wieder aufgenommen und in die Infrastruktur sei wieder investiert worden.
    [Show full text]
  • Weekly Media Review 2011-17
    Defending free expression and your right to know The Media Monitoring Project Zimbabwe Monday April 25th – Sunday May 1st 2011 Weekly Media Review 2011-17 State media abuse Workers’ Day to vilify ZCTU, MDC-T AS Zimbabwean workers gathered at several venues across the country to commemorate International Workers’ Day last Sunday, their activities received low-key publicity as the media appeared preoccupied with the MDC- T national congress, held on the same weekend. The official media devoted their 12 stories on the occasion to blaming the MDC-T and its allies for workers’ plight, while presenting ZANU PF as the only party interested in the workers’ welfare. They reported workers as having “snubbed” celebrations organized by the country’s main labour body and a key ally of the MDC-T, the Zimbabwe Congress of Trade Unions (ZCTU) but provided no information on the activities of the smaller Zimbabwe Federation of Trade Unions (ZFTU), affiliated to ZANU PF (ZBC 1 & 2/5, 8pm). In the past, the ZFTU used to receive widespread favourable publicity in the state media, including live coverage of its May Day celebrations on national television. No attendance figures were given to support assertions by the government media that the ZCTU’s functions were poorly attended. In one of the reports, ZTV (1/5, 8pm) reported Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai as having “surprised” a “small crowd” gathered at White City Stadium by attributing Zimbabwe’s current economic problems to ZANU PF’s indigenization programme. Instead of providing detail and context of Tsvangirai’s speech, the station reported “analysts” dismissing his remarks as public posturing meant to please donors.
    [Show full text]
  • Building and Urban Planning in Zimbabwe with Special Reference to Harare: Putting Needs, Costs and Sustainability in Focus
    Consilience: The Journal of Sustainable Development Vol. 11, Iss. 1 (2014), Pp. 1–26 Building and Urban Planning in Zimbabwe with Special Reference to Harare: Putting Needs, Costs and Sustainability in Focus Innocent Chirisa, PhD Department of Rural & Urban Planning University of Zimbabwe Abstract This article examines construction and its relationship with urban planning in Zimbabwe. Urban planning has been blamed for making the building process cumbersome, thereby raising transaction costs. Such transaction costs include planning and associated bureaucratic processes, which are often underestimated by construction investors. Although planning is critical for the sustainability of buildings in Zimbabwe, it still relies heavily on outdated building standards set by the British. The social, economic, and physical environment in which construction takes place has greatly changed. Issues concerning costs, investments, building materials, planning laws, and climate change play a key role in shaping urban environments. They are thus examined in the context of sustainable construction, a field of science that addresses relevant societal needs and issues of technology. This article is a theoretical and empirical review of the present needs and costs characterizing the construction industry. It examines both micro and macro-scale building processes and issues raised by different players in the industry. Can sustainability be achieved with the current mantra of building operations, guided by the present planning diktats and procedures? Keywords: town planning, standards, transaction costs, urban policy, economic meltdown, sustainability 2 Consilience 1. Introduction This article examines construction and its relationship with urban planning in Zimbabwe. Urban planning has encumbered the building process, elevating the costs of development in the form of transaction costs.
    [Show full text]
  • Pathway to Prosperity Zimbabwe Case Study Part II: Open Economies
    GLOBAL INDEX OF PROSPERITY INDEX ECONOMIC OPENNESS Pathway to Prosperity Zimbabwe Case Study Part II: Open Economies 2021 CREATING THE PATHWAYS FROM POVERTY TO PROSPERITY ABOUT THE LEGATUM INSTITUTE The Legatum Institute is a London-based think-tank with a bold vision to create a global movement of people committed to creating the pathways from poverty to prosperity and the transformation of society. We seek to do this by raising up leaders of character, restoring an ethical vitality to all sectors of society, and developing the practical solutions and data tools that will help build inclusive and peaceful societies with open economies and empowered people. • Our Centre for Metrics creates indexes and datasets to measure and explain how poverty and prosperity are changing. • Our Research Programmes analyse the many complex drivers of poverty and prosperity at the local, national and global level. • Our Practical Programmes identify the actions required to enable transformational change. ABOUT THE AUTHORS Dr. Stephen Brien is Director of Policy at the Legatum Institute. Preksha Dugar is a Research Analyst at the Legatum Institute. Daniel Herring is a Senior Analyst at the Legatum Institute. Ed King is a Research Analyst at the Legatum Institute. Carlos Montes is a Fellow at the Legatum Institute. Alistair Morrison is a Fellow at the Legatum Institute. The authors would also like to thank Ernest Moyo and Rebecca Mwabvu, both of the Higher Life Foundation, for their contribution to this work. The views expressed in this report are those of the Legatum Institute and do not necessarily reflect those of HLF. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS A diverse range of experts were engaged in this work.
    [Show full text]
  • An Opposition Newspaper Under an Oppressive Regime: a Critical Analysis of the Daily News
    An opposition newspaper under an oppressive regime: A critical analysis of The Daily News Pedzisai Ruhanya* Zimbabwe Democracy Institute Abstract This study focuses on the unprecedented ways in which newspaper journalism helped the cause of democratisation at the height of the economic and political governance crisis, also known as the ‘Zimbabwe Crisis’, from 1997 to 2010. The research is designed as a qualitative case study of The Daily News, an independent private newspaper. It was based on semi-structured interviews with respondents, who were mainly journalists and politicians living in Zimbabwe. The analytical lens of alternative media facilitates a construction of how The Daily News and its journalists experienced, reported, confronted and navigated state authoritarianism in a historical moment of political turmoil. The study discusses the complex relationships between the independent and privately owned press, the political opposition and civil society organisations. The research provides an original analysis of the operations of The Daily News and its journalists in the context of a highly undemocratic political moment. Some journalists crossed the floor to join civic and opposition forces in order to confront the state. The state responded through arrests and physical attacks against the journalists; however, journalists continued to work with opposition forces while the government enacted repressive media and security law to curtail coverage of the crisis. Keywords Alternative media, activism, cross-membership, urgency, radical, social change, opposition, advocacy, Zimbabwe Introduction This research focuses on the role played by an independent newspaper in opposition politics in Zimbabwe, at the height of the ‘Zimbabwe Crisis’ from 1997 to 2010. It was a time when, among other things, the Zimbabwe government tightened its grip on the media in order to influence and maintain its dominant position in defining and articulating the crisis, ‘both at home and in the Diaspora, as well as its critics abroad’ (Chiumbu and Moyo, 2009: 180).
    [Show full text]
  • Weekly Media Review 2010-30
    Defending free expression and your right to know The Media Monitoring Project Zimbabwe Monday August 2nd - Sunday August 8th 2010 Weekly Media Review 2010-30 Contents 1. The top stories 2. Missing stories 3. Most popular voices The weeks’ top stories Harare City Council’s defiance of a government directive to reduce salaries for council senior management added spice to an otherwise quiet week in which the government-controlled media flooded their audiences with news on Heroes’ and Defence Forces’ Day commemorations. While the government media were engrossed in these festivities, they paid scant attention to warnings of imminent hunger in Zimbabwe and human rights violations, the majority of which were related to the Constitutional Parliamentary Committee (Copac)’s consultative programme. Fig 1: Top stories in the media Media Heroes’ Municipal Constitutional Food Human Day issues reforms security rights Public 111 27 14 4 3 Media Private 14 9 20 13 32 media Total 125 36 34 17 32 Govt, Harare City Fathers cross swords over salaries Clashes between government and the Harare City Council over alleged hefty salaries being paid to council executives, reported to be around $20 000 per month, dominated the media’s coverage of local government issues. These comprised 17 (47%) of the media’s 36 stories on the local government’s operations. Four were on a row between Harare Council Mayor Muchadeyi Masunda and Mashonaland Central Governor Martin Dinha over the governor’s alleged resistance to the council’s acquisition of 26 farms from his province for expansion purposes. The remaining 15 highlighted symptoms of poor service delivery by local government authorities around the country.
    [Show full text]
  • Mayoral Elections and Zimbabwe's Legislative I Ching
    MAYORAL ELECTIONS AND ZIMBABWE’S LEGISLATIVE I CHING Derek Matyszak, Senior Researcher, Research & Advocacy Unit [RAU] October 2013 Abstract. In recent years, Zimbabwe’s legislation has been characterised by poor drafting. The resultant difficulty in determining the intention of the legislature has been exacerbated by the introduction of a new constitution for the country, which renders many laws unconstitutional. The hermeneutic conundrums presented by lacunae in legislation and conflicting provisions opens the door, to political, rather than legal, considerations playing a role when ascribing meaning to various statutes. This situation obtained in the recent election of mayors for the municipalities in Zimbabwe. The Ministry of Local Government decided that section 265(2) of the new constitution was clear and unambiguous. The section provides: “All members of local authorities must be elected by registered voters within the areas for which the local authorities are established.” The argument is that, since the mayor is a member of a local authority, he too must be elected by registered voters within the areas for which the local authorities are established, and, in the absence of the direct election of the mayor, this means that the mayor must be a councillor, as all councillors are elected by registered voters within the areas for which the local authorities are established. However, the article shows that this provision is not the only, or even the best, interpretation of section 265(2), and all indications are that the meaning placed upon this provision by the Ministry is not the one intended by the legislature. This being the case, the election of mayors in all municipalities as directed by the Minister in September 2013, should be held to be unconstitutional.
    [Show full text]
  • Participatory Budgeting in Zimbabwe
    British Journal of Physical and Human Geography Vol.1, No.1, pp.1-44, March 2014 Published by British Research Institute UK (www.gbjournals.org) PARTICIPATORY BUDGETING IN ZIMBABWE: EXPERIENCES AND REFLECTIONS FROM HARARE CITY COUNCIL Tawanda Zinyama Department of Political and Administrative Studies, University of Zimbabwe ABSTRACT: Participatory budgeting (PB) presents a direct-democracy approach to budgeting. It offers residents an opportunity to learn about Harare City Council operations and to debate and influence the allocation of public resources. PB incontrovertibly strengthens all-encompassing governance by giving marginalised and excluded groups the chance to have their voices heard and to influence public decision making vital to their interests. Therefore, PB remarkably promotes good governance. PB faces a lot of challenges in local authorities in Zimbabwe. There is serious lack of residents’ participation in policy and decision making in council budget formulation. The residents are marginalised. The study found that there are massive institutional capacity, financial and human resources capacity gaps at Harare City Council. The policy, legal and institutional frameworks do not support PB. The study recommends that the legal instruments be amended, e-governance system be installed and the councillors should be capacitated through capacity building programmes KEYWORDS: Participatory budgeting, Governance, Budgeting, Participation, Harare City Council THE PROBLEM AND ITS CONTEXT Habitually in representative democracies, the supposition has been that citizens express their preferences through electoral politics and in turn, it was the job of the elected representatives to make policy and to hold the state accountable. In both North and in the South, new voice mechanisms are now being explored which argue as well for more direct connections between the people and the bureaucracies which affect them.
    [Show full text]
  • HRT Position on the Debt Cancellation Directive from Minister Chombo
    HRT Position on the Debt Cancellation Directive from Minister Chombo 23 July 2013, Harare- The Harare Residents’ Trust (HRT) receives with caution the decision by the Minister of Local Government, Rural and Urban Development Ignatius Chombo to direct that all local authorities in Zimbabwe cancel all debt accrued by residents from February 2009 to 30 June 2013. Minister Chombo’s approach is similar in nature to the directive issued by the then Minister of Energy and Power Development Engineer Elias Mudzuri in April 2009 directing that residents in low density areas should pay US$40 for electricity consumption while those in the high density should pay US$30 per month, his solution to the exorbitant bills that residents were getting from the Zimbabwe Electricity Supply Authority (ZESA). Still, ZESA went on to disconnect all defaulters three months down the line. Engineer Mudzuri was commended by the residents, because he immediately responded to the calls for a review of bills by electricity consumers. To residents, leadership must timeously respond when consumers of services raise legitimate concerns. While residents across Harare welcome the principle of debt cancellation, as provided by legislation, the timing of the action remains suspicious. As the citizenry celebrate this belated victory on debt accumulated by residents, mostly unjustified, and unrelated to services rendered, it is important to acknowledge that the HRT mobilised plus three thousand Harare residents to sign a petition on 19 October 2012, handed to the Deputy Mayor Emmanuel Chiroto and copied to the Minister of Local Government, Rural and Urban Development among other stakeholders. Residents are demanding the cancellation of all debt accrued from February 2009 to 31 December 2010, a period when the City of Harare evidently did not provide essential refuse and water services to the majority of the citizenry.
    [Show full text]
  • Contracting-Out Public Services in Local Authorities in Zimbabwe: The
    Contracting - Out Public Services In Local Authorities In Zimbabwe: The Case of Harare City Council By Tawanda Zinyama A Thesis Submitted in Fulfillment of the Requirements of the Doctor of Philosophy Degree in Public Administration Department of Political and Administrative Studies Faculty of Social Studies University of Zimbabwe June 2016 i Abstract Contracting - out has become a central feature of modern government and one of the key institutions to deliver public services to the citizens. While arguments have and continue to be made in favour of contracting - out the provision of public services to private agents, little is known about the merit s and shortcomings; factors that promote or obstruct effective and successful contrcating - out. The guiding research question was: What are the experiences of Harar e City Council with contracting - out the provision of public services between 1995 and 2014? The study sought to explore contracting - out experiences of Harare City Council in order to provide a source of valuable information for local government managers to ameliorate the contracting - out process es . The principal objective of the study was to inve stigate and describe Harare City Council’s experiences with contracting - out the provision of public services in order to better appreciate the factors that make or break the contracting - out proce ss. The study included a qualitative sample of 52 participan ts pu rposively selected. In addition to these participants, the researcher attended four local government conferences and workshops where nine local experts were interviewed. The study also used a que stionnaire of 45 questions to a survey sample of fifty ( 50) respondents from Harare City Council.
    [Show full text]