Lesbian Deliberation:The Constitution of Community in Online Lesbian Forums Rebecca Walker University of Wollongong, [email protected]
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
University of Wollongong Research Online University of Wollongong Thesis Collection University of Wollongong Thesis Collections 2010 Lesbian deliberation:the constitution of community in online lesbian forums Rebecca Walker University of Wollongong, [email protected] Recommended Citation Walker, Rebecca, Lesbian deliberation:the constitution of community in online lesbian forums, Doctor of Philosophy thesis, School of Social Sciences, Media and Communications, University of Wollongong, 2010. http://ro.uow.edu.au/theses/3635 Research Online is the open access institutional repository for the University of Wollongong. For further information contact the UOW Library: [email protected] Lesbian Deliberation: The Constitution of Community in Online Lesbian Forums A thesis submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the award of the degree Doctor of Philosophy from University of Wollongong by Becky Walker, BCA (hons) School of Social Sciences, Media and Communications 2010 1 CERTIFICATION I, Becky Walker, declare that this thesis, submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the award of Doctor of Philosophy, in the Arts Department, University of Wollongong, is wholly my own work unless otherwise referenced or acknowledged. The document has not been submitted for qualifications at any other academic institution. Becky Walker 31st March 2010 2 Refereed publications in support of this thesis: Deliberative Democracy in Online Lesbian Communities, International Journal of Feminist Media Studies, 8:2, 2008, pp. 202-206. Imagining the Future of Lesbian Community: The Case of Online Lesbian Communities and the Issue of Trans, Continuum: Journal of Media and Cultural Studies, 2009, 6:23, pp.921-936. 3 Table of Contents !"#$%&'(#)%"********************************************************************************************************************************** +! ,*,-The L Word ./$)/0************************************************************************************************************************ ,,! ,*1-2/#3%&-4"&-5#3)(0 ********************************************************************************************************************** ,6! ,*7-!"#$%&'(#)%"-#%-8/9):/$4#);/-8/<%($4(=**************************************************************************** 1+! ,*>-8/9):/$4#);/-8/<%($4(=-4"&-5<?)$)(49-5;)&/"(/ *********************************************************** 7@! ,*@--A%<</$()49)04#)%"-4"&-B%;/$"4"(/-%C-D"9)"/-E/0:)4"-B$%'?0********************************* 7F! ,*G-E/0:)4"-H/<)")0#-!"C9'/"(/0-%"-A%"#/<?%$4$=-E/0:)4"-B$%'?0******************************** >,! ,*F-D'#9)"/******************************************************************************************************************************************** >7! A34?#/$-1-E)#/$4#'$/-I/;)/JK-E/0:)4"-A%<<'")#=L-8/9):/$4#);/-8/<%($4(=-4"&- M9'$49)0<-D"-4"&-DCC9)"/* *******************************************************************************************************>F! 1*,-N)0#%$=-%C-BEOP-P4(#)(0-%C-Q)0):)9)#=-4"&-I/?$/0/"#4#)%"********************************************* >F! 1*1-I/?$/0/"#4#)%"0-4"&-#3/-H%$<4#)%"-%C-M':9)(-D?)")%" ************************************************* @,! 1*-7-P3/-E/0:)4"-!<4R)"4$= ************************************************************************************************************ @7! 1*>-8/9):/$4#)%"-)"-M':9)(0 ************************************************************************************************************* @@! 1*@-E/0:)4"-A%<<'")#)/0-%$-A%'"#/$?':9)(0S ************************************************************************* @F! 1*G-8/9):/$4#)%"-4"&-.%()49-A34"R/ ********************************************************************************************* G1! 1*F-./T'49-A)#)U/"03)?-4"&-#3/-E/0:)4"-M%9)0**************************************************************************** G7! 1*6-E/0:)4"-A%<<'")#=K-M%J/$-4"&-!"/V'49)#)/0 ******************************************************************* G>! 1*+-P3/-8/;/9%?</"#-%C-#3/-!"#/$"/#-4"&-!&/490-%C-M4$#)()?4#%$=-8/<%($4(=-4"&-./9C- B%;/$")"R-A%<<'")#)/0****************************************************************************************************************** FW! 1*,W-!"#/$"/#-A%<<'")#)/0-4"&-#3/-X//&-C%$-B%;/$"4"(/ ************************************************** F1! 1*,,-A%"(9'0)%" ********************************************************************************************************************************** FF! A34?#/$-7-Y-2%$/-!"(9'0);/-A%<<'")#=S-O)0/T'49-4"&-N/#/$%0/T'49-Z%</"-)"- #3/-E/0:)4"-H%$'<0******************************************************************************************************************F+! 7*,-D"9)"/-A%<<'")#=-H%$<4#)%"************************************************************************************************ 6@! 7*1-X4$$4#)"R-E/0:)4"-4"&-O)0/T'49-!&/"#)#)/0-)"-#3/-H%$'<0 ******************************************** +>! 7*7-A%"(9'0)%"***********************************************************************************************************************************,W>! A34?#/$->-B%;/$"4"(/-4"&-A%<</$()49)04#)%"-%C-#3/-B$%'?0********************************,WF! >*,-8/()0)%"-24[)"R-)"-D"9)"/-B$%'?0**************************************************************************************,W6! >*1-DJ"/$03)?-4"&-A%<</$()49-!00'/0 ************************************************************************************,,1! >*7-I/4&)"R-H%$<4#)%"0-)"-D"9)"/-B$%'?0 ******************************************************************************,,G! >*>-H94</-Z4$0-%;/$-A%<</$()49)04#)%"-%C-H4"-B$%'?0 ****************************************************,1>! >*@-D"9)"/-B%;/$"4"(/-A%"(9'0)%"0 ******************************************************************************************,7@! A34?#/$-@-8/9):/$4#)%"0-)"-#3/-H%$'<0K-H9403?%)"#0-%;/$-P$4"0R/"&/$-Y(#);)0<0- 4"&-.4</\./T-Q)%9/"(/*********************************************************************************************************,7+! @*,-M$%\-4"&-Y"#)\-P$4"0R/"&/$-Y(#);)0<-4"&-8)0(%'$0/0 *************************************************,>W! @*1-P$4"0-8/9):/$4#)%"-)"-#3/-H%$'<0***************************************************************************************,>G! @*7-8/:4#)"R-!"#)<4#/-M4$#"/$-Q)%9/"(/ **********************************************************************************,@,! @*>-A%"(9'0)%"***********************************************************************************************************************************,G>! 4 A34?#/$-G-H4"-H)(#)%"-4"&-The L Word*****************************************************************************,G6! G*,-H4"-H)(-.#'&=-2/#3%& **************************************************************************************************************,FW! G*1-8/9):/$4#)%"-4"&-H4"-H)( ********************************************************************************************************,FG! G*7-!"#)<4#/-M4$#"/$-Q)%9/"(/-)"-#3/-H)( **********************************************************************************,F6! G*>-MZML-2%"%R4<=-4"&-./T-I4&)(49-M4$%&)/0 *********************************************************************,6G! G*@-P$4"0-H4"-H)( ******************************************************************************************************************************,+>! G*G-N/#-H)(*******************************************************************************************************************************************1WW! G*F-H94</-Z4$0-4"&-8/9):/$4#)%"-%;/$-Y'#3/"#)(-E/0:)4"-H)(#)%" *********************************1W,! G*6-H4"-H)(-A%"(9'0)%"0******************************************************************************************************************1,W! A%"(9'0)%" ********************************************************************************************************************************1,G! 5 ABSTRACT Lesbian Deliberation: The Constitution of Community in Online Lesbian Forums This thesis analyses the constitution of, and interactions within, five online lesbian fan groups devoted to the United States television series The L Word over a six year period, 2004-2009. This thesis is essentially an audience studies and new media thesis. I draw upon theories of community formation and deliberative democracy, particularly those espoused by John Dryzek (2000) and Seyla Benhabib (1996). I argue that the fan groups studied engage in debates that are indicative of shifting normative discourses in lesbian communities. My argument has implications for the theorisation of lesbian community and the theorisation of online community, and I consequently engage with a wide range of scholarship on both online and offline communities, including that of Henry Jenkins (1992) Shane Phelan (1989, 1994), and Howard Rheingold (1993, 2000). In order to elaborate on my central claim about fan sites as spaces of deliberation, I focus on flame wars as well as more benign interactions around key topics. These deliberations were provoked by plot elements in The L Word such as the constitution of lesbian communities, including the presence of bisexuals, transgenders, and heterosexuals. Another plot element that provoked discussion was same-sex intimate partner violence. The potential for deliberation in the forums is often affected by the commercialisation of some of the fan forums, and I explore how the fan forums were governed in order to ascertain to what extent this is the case. The L Word fan forums also offer a manifestation of “the lesbian imaginary,” through the posting and sharing of fan fiction in which lesbian communities, identities, bodies, sexualities