Rare Earth Element Geochemistry of the Sediments, Ferromanganese Nodules and Crusts from the Indian Ocean
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
RARE EARTH ELEMENT GEOCHEMISTRY OF THE SEDIMENTS, FERROMANGANESE NODULES AND CRUSTS FROM THE INDIAN OCEAN SUBMITTED TO THE GOA UNIVERSITY FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY BY BEJUGAM NAGENDER NATH NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF OCEANOGR RESEARCH GUIDE I „ R.R. NAIR \ 111 DEPUTY DIRECTOR AND HEA 0 A ..30"" GEOLOGICAL OCEANOGRAPHY DIVISION- 5-5 1 .46 N f / RAd NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF OCEANOGRAPHY DONA PAULA, GOA - 403 004, INDIA. OCTOBER, 1993 "THESE ELEMENTS (REE) PERPLEX US IN OUR RESEARCHES, BAFFLE US IN OUR SPECULATIONS, AND HAUNT US IN OUR VERY DREAMS. THEY STRETCH LIKE AN UNKNOWN SEA BEFORE US - MOCKING, MYSTIFYING AND MURMURING STRANGE REVELATIONS AND POSSIBILITIES" SIR WILLIAM CROOKES, 1887 (as quoted in Elderfield, 1988) CERTIFICATE Mr. B. Nagender Nath has been working under my guidance since 1991. The Ph.D. thesis entitled "Rare earth element geochemistry of the sediments, ferromanganese nodules and crusts from the Indian Ocean", submitted by him contains the results of his original investigation of the subject. This is to certify that the thesis has not been the basis for the award of any other research degree or diploma of other University. ____.---,_ --- 0 ".„..--,.... ., o. ( :At \ / ( R. R. NAIR ) \\N \s \ ." ..„_. __- -*/ Research Guide ,,, G_ 0 puty Director and Head, Geb j eanography Division National Institute of Oceanography Dona Paula, GOA - 403 004. CONTENTS CONTENTS Page No. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS LIST OF FIGURES iv-xi LIST OF TABLES xii-xiii CHAPTER 1 1-23 INTRODUCTION 1.1. Occurrence and abundance 2 1.2. Historical aspects 3 1.3. General chemistry of REE 5 1.31. Electronic configuration 5 1.32. Ionic radii and lanthanide contraction 6 1.33. Oxidation states 7 1.4. Mineralogy of the rare-earth elements 8 1.41. REE bearing mineral groups 8 1.42. Co-ordination numbers 10 1.43. Isomorphic / elemental substitution 11 1.5. Presentation of REE data 11 1.6. Distribution of REE in marine environment 13 1.61. REEs in oceans / seawater 13 1.62. REE in sediments 15 1.7. Objectives of the work 17 1.8. Details of the samples studied 20 TABLES 23 CHAPTER 2 24-47 RARE EARTH ELEMENTS IN THE NEARSHORE SEDIMENTS SEDIMENTS OF INDIA 2.1. Introduction 24 2.2. Study area 27 2.21. Geology of the Hinterland 28 2.22. Index of geoaccumulation (I geo) / Degree of pollution in sediments 29 2.3. Sample selection criteria 30 Page No. 2.4. Materials and methods 31 2.5. Results and discussion 32 2.51. Filtering effect of Estuaries on the geochemistry of marine sediments 32 2.52. Cerium anomalies 33 2.53. Diagenetic effects 33 2.54. REE fractionation and its origin 34 2.55. REE fractionation related to changes in mineralogy 36 2.56. Fractionation related to physico-chemical condition of the Environment 37 2.57. Control of adsorption / coagulation and complexation processes on the fractionation 38 2.58. Significance of HREE depletion in the nearshore sediments compared to shales 39 2.59. How do these REE values reflect the composition of the average upper continental crust? 40 2.6. Conclusions 42 TABLES 44-47 CHAPTER 3 48-61 RARE EARTH ELEMENTS IN THE DEEP-SEA SEDIMENTS OF CENTRAL INDIAN BASIN 3.1. Introduction 48 3.2. Details of the study area 49 3.21. Tectonic setting 49 3.22. Sample description 50 3.3. Materials and methods 51 3.31. REE determination 51 3.4. Results 52 3.41. REE in terrigenous clays 53 3.42. REE in siliceous clays (nodule free) 53 3.43. REE in siliceous oozes / clays associated with manganese nodules 54 3.44. REE in calcareous oozes / clays 54 3.45. REE in pelagic / red clay sediments 55 3.46. Fractionation indices 55 56 3.47. LaeXOBSS Page No. 3.5. Discussion 56 3.51. Lithological control of REE patterns 56 3.52. Relation between REE patterns and diagenetic processes 57 3.53. Ce fractionation related to bottom water hydrography 58 3.6. Conclusion 60 TABLE 61 CHAPTER 4 62-106 RARE EARTH ELEMENTS IN THE FERROMANGANESE DEPOSITS OF THE INDIAN OCEAN 4.1. Introduction 62 4.2. General features of the study area 65 4.3. Material and methods 67 4.4. Results and discussion 70 4.41. Top-bottom fractionation or REE zonation 70 4.42. Interelement relations and their implications 73 4.43. Cerium anomaly variations 78 4.431. Variation of cerium in oxide and nucleating material 78 4.432. Cerium in nodule nuclei and their implications 80 4.433. Cerium in aluminosilicate phase (2M HCI leach) 82 CERIUM IN BULK NODULES 4.434. Mineralogical control 83 4.435. Diagenetic effects on Ce anomalies 85 4.436. Cerium relationship with Fe and P and their implications 86 4.437. Cerium anomaly variation in the light of nodule forming processes 87 4.44. Gadolinium-terbium anomalies 89 4.45. HREE enrichment in sample 320 A 91 4.5. Summary 93 TABLES 94-106 CHAPTER 5 107-135 RARE EARTH ELEMENTS IN HYDROTHERMAL CRUSTS 5.1. Introduction 107 5.2. Description of the study areas and samples 112 5.21. Hydrothermal Crusts 113 5.211. Southeastern seamount, East Pacific Rise (EPR) 113 5.212. Valu Fa Ridge, Lau Basin 114 5.213. Galapagos Spreading Center 115 5.214. Indian Ocean Triple Junction 116 Page No. 5.22. Hydrogenous crusts 117 5.221. Central Pacific 117 5.222. Central Indian Basin 118 5.3. Analytical methods 118 5.4. Results and discussion 118 5.41. REE contents 118 5.42. REE patterns 120 5.43. HREE enrichment 121 5.44. Cerium anomalies 122 5.45. Significance of Eu anomalies in hydrothermal crusts 123 5.46. REE and other geochemical constraints on the hydrothermal mineralization in the Indian Ocean area 124 5.47. REE - major element associations - discrepancy in the sorption experiment results 129 5.5. Summary 131 TABLES 132-135 CHAPTER 6 136-139 COMPARISON OF THE REE UPTAKE BEHAVIOUR BY VARIOUS AQUEOUS SEDIMENTARY PHASES IN THE INDIAN OCEAN 6.1 Enrichment Factors 136 6.2 Cerium as an additional resource from manganese nodules 138 CHAPTER 7 140-149 SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS REFERENCES 150-173 LIST OF AUTHORS PUBLICATIONS 174-176 Bebirateb In mu Mauro parents tutlo gam, me life nub g000 eburation 8c to mu Kate &nth gabn Elamobar for tlis tlelp During mg tligtler eburation ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The work presented in this thesis is carried out under the guidance of Shri. R.R. Nair. I am indebted to him for his guidance and sustained encouragement throughout the course of this work. My sincere thanks are also to him as the Head of the Geological Oceanography Division and also to the Director, NIO for providing facilities and allowing to me pursue this topic. I record a deep-sense of gratitude to Late Padmashri Dr. H.N. Siddiquie for insisting me to undertake a geochemistry topic. Thoughful and constructive comments by my chemical oceanography division colleague Dr. M. Dileep Kumar are very much appreciated. Much of the data used in this work has been generated during my stay in Germany on a DAAD fellowship. And for a successful stay at Germany, the credit goes to Dr. Walter L. Pluger, Privat Dozent, my German supervisor. He was generous enough to provide facilities which are very expensive at Europe. Prof. G. Friedrich has kindly provided a placement in his institute. During my stay, Neef, Frau Wiechowsky, Frau Siebel and Deissman have run their instruments for hundreds of my samples. Graduate students Thomas Bohm, Christopher Mamet, Ralf Buffler, Sabina Lange, Sven Petersen have spent many hours either in the laboratory helping me with my analyses or drawing my figures. Many thanks to them. Dr. I. Roelandts, University of Liege, Belgium and Dr. H. Kunzendorf of Riso National Laboratory, Roskilde, Denmark have generated high quality REE data in their laboratories. My profound thanks to II both of them for showing keen interest in the topics suggested by me. Dr. P. Herzig has been a source of encouragement for me who always has a scientific atmosphere around him. I thank DAAD for providing the fellowship and CSIR for a deputation. My sincere thanks to Shri. N.P.C. Reddy and Prof. Y.L. Dora for my Kerala coast sampling and geologists, geophysicists, marine surveyors, electronic and mechanical engineers of the PMN Project for the deep-sea sampling. Thanks are also due to Dr. U. von Stackelberg (BGR, Hannover), E. Fouquet (IFREMER), Dr. K.P. Becker (Aachen), Prof. G. Friedrich who have provided me the ferromanganese crusts from the Pacific. Constant encouragement and help rendered by my colleagues Mr. M. Sudhakar, Mr. M. Shyam Prasad, Dr. V. Purnachandra Rao, Shri. K.A. Kamesh Raju, Dr. B. Chakraborty and Dr. V.N. Kodagali is gratefully acknowledged. My roommates Dr. R. Mukhopadhyay and Mr. N.H. Khadge always had a word of appreciation for the scientific progress in our room. Dr. V. Balaram, Scientist at NGRI has kindly allowed me to use their ICP-MS facility. Much of sampling and laboratory work has been carried out under the financial support from the Department of Ocean Development, Government of India under their programme 'Polymetallic Nodule Surveys'. I could not have brought out the thesis in this shape but for the untiring help rendered by my colleague Shri. S. Jai Shankar. His skill with the computer was most useful and beneficial to me. Mrs. Alison Sudhakar typed some parts of this thesis and my thanks to her. iii Back at home (Warangal), my parents, brother, maternal uncles (Late Yada Damodar, Vaikuntam and Krishna Murthy), cousins (Madan, Shyam and Srinivas) and my childhood friend Kedareshwar have always taken interest in my adventures with sea and boosted my morale.