Viśvarūpa – Book by Prof

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Viśvarūpa – Book by Prof Viśvarūpa – Book by Prof. T. S. Maxwell. Viśvarūpa T.S. MAXWELL This volume is sponsored by the Inter-Faculty Committee for South Asian Studies University of Oxford Contents This work is dedicated to my twin sons. • Foreword • Preface eṣo uṣā apūruyā vy ucchati priyā divaḥ • Abbreviations THE EXPERIMENTAL PHASE - Unitary Multiple stuṣe vām aśvinā bṛhat Icons of the Kuṣāṇa Period and Related Works of the Early Gupta Period yā dasrā śindhumātarā monotarā rayīṇām THE 'CLASSICAL' PHASE - Developments in the Gupta Period dhiyā devā vasuvidā THE ŚAMALĀJĪ Viśvarūpa - A Major Contribution to the Development of Multiple Iconography in Western vacyante vāṃ kakuhāso jūrṇāyām adhi viṣṭapi India THE PAREL HEPTAD - A Complex Śaiva Experiment yad vāṃ ratho vibhis patāt in Western India THE DEOGARH Viśvarūpa KANNAUJ - The Decline of Creativity in the Design of Multiple Brahmanical Sculpture in North India Select Bibliography Prof. T. S. Maxwell, Director, Department of Oriental Art History, University of Bonn, Regina- Pacis-Weg 1, D-53113 Bonn, Germany Oxford University Press, Walton Street, Oxford OX2 6DP New York Toronto Delhi Bombay Calcutta Madras Karachi Petaling Jaya Singapore Hong Kong Tokyo Nairobi Dar es Salaam Melbourne Auckland and associated in Beirut Berlin Ibadan Nicosia © Oxford University Press 1988 All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording or by any information storage and retrieval system, without prior permission in writing. © Oxford University Press 1988 Viśvarūpa – Book by Prof. T. S. Maxwell. Foreword To enable him to behind and bear the sight of his boundless divinity, Kṛṣṇa his charioteer gave divine vision to the hero Arjuna who saw the god's boundless form: Viśvarūpa the universe with all its shapes. The image of Viśvarūpa, 'God as the Universe' given form in Indian sculpture, is the them of T.S. Maxwell's book. Knowledge of Indian sacred art was only slowly resuscitated in this century after the decline of its practice in India. Its otherness from Western standards, at first badly tolerated, gradually won acceptance. It demanded a new insight, for its anthropomorphic images could not be seen as rendering nature. They neither copied nor interpreted nature as Indian art did not take its stand outside nature, but conformed with nature, with the powers and rhythms that give shape to its forms and creatures. Once the hegemony of and comparisons with Western art had fallen to the ground and the autonomy of Indian art was recognized, in its plasticity visualizing a continuum as of breath and pulsation, a fulness with the stream of life, another factor of Indian sacred art was recognized, different from and complementary to its plasticity; it was acknowledged together with the awareness in the West of the practice of yoga underlying the ritual of worship. The yantra, a geometrical device used as a tool to conjure the presence of deity within the symmetry of its limits, was contemplated as coinciding with the anthropomorphic image- though as a reflex only of the unearthly perfection of the transcendent reality of the envisioned deity. Going beyond both these approaches, the vitalistic and the tantric, the text of Viśvarūpa constructs and comprises the being and becoming as well of early Brahmanical sculpture. A deeper understanding, unachieved hitherto, of Indian sacred imagery, and transcending in its scope all previous modes of approaching the Indian sacred image as work of art and at the same time as thought construct, is substantiated in the pages of Viśvarūpa. © Oxford University Press 1988 Viśvarūpa – Book by Prof. T. S. Maxwell. The book treats of the beginning of Brahmanical figures in Northern India. They are seen as visual images of cosmogonic theory. Their anthropomorphic figures are emanatory, they issue from a central figure and represent, not a group of figures, but a process of cosmic becoming in its continuity. They form 'multiple icons' as phases of the process of creation. It is shown as an ongoing, uninterrupted whole, the phases together with the source whence they proceed. Sculpture rendering a process, creating in its static three-dimensional form an ongoing progression, conveys this continuum by an assemblage of emerging anthropomorphic figures emanating from one central body. Such a multiple shape, iconogonic and 'icontological' at the same time, presents the virtual correspondence to a theological thought-structure created in the Pāṇcarātra system to celebrate Viṣṇu as the universe. The system had its support in the mythical transfiguration of four heroes, members of one family. Their presence was envisaged branching out and forming a family tree. This arboreal image sustained the unified presence of the hero-gods issuing from the towering figure of the principal image. In the conception of this theophany anthropomorphism was combined with the arboreal concept. The branching tree coalesced with the vision of the emanations, the correlated hero gods emerging from the image from which they stemmed. A theological system was given sculptural form. The concept of emanation was translated into the composite figure of an anthropomorph, having a sustaining middle and main figure from whom sprang forth, laterally and on top, the emanating figures like branches of a tree. The anthropomorphic corporeality of these figures carved in the front view of the total three-dimensional image is-when seen in back view- 'supplemented' by the likeness of a tree, carved in low- relief, its curving branches and leaves aquiver with vital linear motion. The multiple image of deity incorporates a theological framework within its conceptual structure. Its three dimensional sculptural equivalent 'embodies' in fulsome anthropomorphic shapes a metaphysical reality. Boldly the shape of the human body is © Oxford University Press 1988 Viśvarūpa – Book by Prof. T. S. Maxwell. made part of a coherence that belongs to thought and not to corporeal possibility. It ramifies from the region of the shoulders of the main image. The emanating figures, visible from the hips, form an aureole around and above the head of the central figure whence they emanate. The unitary multiple icon seems to have been created in about the first to second century. It visualized theological thought and was capable of creating works of art attaining, in terms of form, the depth of thought of Upaniṣadic God- realization. The unitary multiple image stands at the beginning of Brahmanical sacred sculpture. Gradually it lost its inherent emanatory, cosmogonic power. The full-bodied figures, issuing laterally and apically from their source, became reduced to their heads only, inaugurating the subsequent multi-headed image of the gods of Hinduism. Cosmogonic sacredness henceforward had as its support the icon of one or the other god manifesting in this world. The whole of manifestation was seen embodied in one icon in particular, that of Viśvarūpa, 'the form of the Universe', the ancient Ṛg Vedic 'Urgod' whose unfolding is the cosmos. The icon Viśvarūpa, as the many headed, many armed pivotal figure of a stele, is surrounded by a carved tapestry of figures of the many gods and powers that have issued from and are the ambiance of Viśvarūpa manifestation. The contiguity of their figures suggests the overwhelming vision of boundless form of boundless deity described in the Bhagavad Gītā ( 11.16). Discipline, following complex planning. saturated with iconographical knowledge, matured in a total mythical/metaphysical recall of Viśvarūpa, as manifested in the Bhagavad Gītā and even more ancient tradition. The planning of the lay-out of the Viśvarūpa vision in each one of the few extant relief sculptures follows a definite scheme whose essentials allow variations from sculpture to sculpture according to the particular vision incorporated in each single work of art. The planning of the sculpture obeyed a geometry that focused on the centres of meaning and linked them in a web supporting the entire composition and carrying the © Oxford University Press 1988 Viśvarūpa – Book by Prof. T. S. Maxwell. total weight of its meaning. The method of planning devised by T. S. Maxwell applies not only to Vaiṣṇava themes. Śaiva sculptures as well were based on 'form thoughts' like the tree and the egg; they are augmented by that of the Linga. This seminal Śaiva theme penetrates the extent of the created cosmos of Śaiva God-realization. It structures the image under the aspect of time that subsumes all existence as it leads from now to eternity in cycles within the fathom of mortal man and those beyond it. Supported by the Liṅga construct, one of India's greatest sculptures, hitherto unidentified, the Śaiva image at Parel, yields its meaning in the pages of Viśvarūpa. Consciously and subconsciously the entire world of traditional sacred knowledge was at the command of the sculptor, he activated the ancient cosmogonic symbols, such as the branching tree or the cosmic egg, subjacent to the ordering of the figures, and even more elementary and imperative elements of visualization, the vertical that traverses and connects the planes of the cosmos, the horizontal that divides above from below. T. S. Maxwell has resuscitated the cooperation of priestly knowledge and the sculptor's competence. By his insight he has located the centres of meaning and planning in each composition. The reconstructing of the planning of the sculptures considered in Viśvarūpa is tantamount to discovering in their form the significance, the thought construct, that hitherto has awaited clarification. With the work of T. S. Maxwell the knowledge and understanding of Indian sacred sculpture has been given focal orientation. The very essence of each sculpture has been revealed, the cosmogonic aspect of the image of deity has come alive in the form of the image. Its form carries a depth and range of meaning that hitherto has lain unsolved. Viśvarūpa has created the frame and foundation of a new understanding of Indian sculpture in its most creative centuries.
Recommended publications
  • Rule Breaches in NUS Referendum Spark Controversy
    !ZPSLOPVTFt ZPSLOPVTFt @yorknouse twww.nouse.co.uk Meet the Ready for the Ball? new socs Get inspired for the Summer Ball with The Shoot M.10 From drones to Game of Thrones M.4 Shortlisted for Guardian Student Publication of the Year 2015 Est. 1964 Sponsored by Nouse Tuesday 07 June 2016 Rule breaches in NUS Referendum spark controversy The NUS has come under fire for 3rd party campaigning student members.” Amy Gibbons and Ben Rowden Campaigners on both sides DEP EDITOR AND NEWS EDITOR have taken starkly opposing views on the matter, with ambiguity about whether the email counted as ‘third party campaigning’ proving a con- THE NATIONAL UNION of Stu- tentious issue. Such ambiguity has dents has been accused of unau- left questions open as to how clearly thorised third party campaigning rules have been established between in the NUS Referendum at York stakeholders in the campaign. following an email that was sent out Lucas North, on behalf of ‘York to NUS Extra customers last week, Says Yes to NUS’, told Nouse: “‘Yes urging them to vote Remain. to NUS’ do not consider the email The email, which was sent on sent to students a breach of the Wednesday, listed eight reasons campaign rules, this is because they why customers should vote to re- are an external party who are not main in the NUS, in addition to the bound by the rules, and students benefits assumed from owning an who received it opted in to receiving NUS Extra card. communication from NUS Extra. It read: “NUS is more than just “To my understanding, person- a discount card, it is an organisation ally, both the ‘Yes’ and ‘No’ cam- dedicated to making a better life for paigns were made aware of the cam- all students [...] Make sure you vote paign rules.
    [Show full text]
  • CEU Department of Medieval Studies
    ANNUAL OF MEDIEVAL STUDIES AT CEU VOL. 18 2012 Central European University Budapest Annualis 2012.indb 1 2012.07.31. 15:59:40 Annualis 2012.indb 2 2012.07.31. 15:59:42 ANNUAL OF MEDIEVAL STUDIES AT CEU VOL. 18 2012 Edited by Judith Rasson and Marianne Sághy Central European University Budapest Department of Medieval Studies Annualis 2012.indb Sec1:1 2012.07.31. 15:59:42 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means without the permission of the publisher. Editorial Board Niels Gaul, Gerhard Jaritz, György Geréby, Gábor Klaniczay, József Laszlovszky, Marianne Sághy, Katalin Szende Editors Judith Rasson and Marianne Sághy Technical Advisor Annabella Pál Cover Illustration Labskhaldi Gospel, 12th century, 29×22 cm, parchment. Canon Table, detail (4 r) Georgian National Museum. Svanety Museum of History and Ethnography, Mestia. www.museum.ge. Reproduced by permission Department of Medieval Studies Central European University H-1051 Budapest, Nádor u. 9., Hungary Postal address: H-1245 Budapest 5, P.O. Box 1082 E-mail: [email protected] Net: http://medievalstudies.ceu.hu Copies can be ordered at the Department, and from the CEU Press http://www.ceupress.com/order.html ISSN 1219-0616 Non-discrimination policy: CEU does not discriminate on the basis of—including, but not limited to—race, color, national or ethnic origin, religion, gender or sexual orientation in administering its educational policies, admissions policies, scholarship and loan programs, and athletic and other school-administered programs. © Central European University Produced by Archaeolingua Foundation & Publishing House Annualis 2012.indb Sec1:2 2012.07.31.
    [Show full text]
  • Spawn Origins: Book 4 Pdf, Epub, Ebook
    SPAWN ORIGINS: BOOK 4 PDF, EPUB, EBOOK Todd McFarlane,Alan Moore | 325 pages | 27 Sep 2011 | Image Comics | 9781607064374 | English | Fullerton, United States Spawn Origins: Book 4 PDF Book Spawn Origins TPB 1 - 10 of 20 books. Dissonance Volume 1. I love seeing Malebolgia and listening to Count Cogliostro. Includes the classic "Christmas" issue as well as the double-sized issue 50! Revisit stories of deception and betrayal,with Al's former boss, Jason Wynn, in the center of it all. Jun 08, Julian rated it it was ok Shelves: comic-books , spawn. Average rating 3. I was aware of Neil Gaiman's legal battles over Angela, Cogliostro and Medieval Spawn but I had no idea the extent to which later issues would continually refer back to ideas which were outsourced. View basket. Showing I dunno they don't tell you much and it's a odd place to start. Another darn good volume of Spawn. Spawn: Origins, Volume 9. United Kingdom. And for years, the passengers and crew of the vessel Orpheus found the endless void between realities to be a surprisingly peaceful home. Spawn: Hell On Earth. Then the last one is kind of a weird one about Spawn seeing a different outlook on things and maybe not being a complete dick to everyone he meets all the time. Anyway next 4 issues begin the "Hunt" which has basically put Terry, Spawn's friend, in the middle of a all out war and everyone wants him done. Brit, Volume 1: Old Soldier. Seller Inventory ADI The guest writers on the early Spawn titles Moore, Morrison and Gaiman really hit it out of the park by establishing interesting lore that had implications for the whole Spawn universe.
    [Show full text]
  • Club Add Form
    O GUARDIANS OF THE GALAXY: EARTH O CAPTAIN TRIPS PREMIERE HC SHALL OVERCOME PREMIERE HC Collects Collecting THE STAND: CAPTAIN TRIPS #1-5. MARVEL SUPER-HEROES #18, MARVEL TWO-IN- 160 PGS...$24.99 ONE #4-5, GIANT-SIZE DEFENDERS #5 and DE- O MARVEL MASTERWORKS: FANTASTIC FENDERS #26-29.176 PGS./Rated A ...$19.99 FOUR VOL. 1 TPB Collecting THE FANTASTIC O MARVEL ADVENTURES THE AVENGERS STAR WARS ADVENTURES VOL.1 Digest on-going FOUR #1-10. 272 PGS...$24.99 VOL. 8: THE NEW RECRUITS DIGEST O MARVEL MASTERWORKS: GOLDEN AGE Collecting MARVEL ADVENTURES THE AVEN- Before they ever met Luke Skywalker or Princess Leia, Han Solo and Chewbacca had MARVEL COMICS VOL. 4 HC Collecting MARVEL GERS #28-31. 96 PGS./All Ages ...$9.99 already lived a lifetime of adventures. In this action-packed tale, Han and Chewie are MYSTERY COMICS #13-16. O SKRULLS VS. POWER PACK DIGEST caught between gangsters and the Empire, and their only help is Han's former partner- 280 PGS ...$59.99 Collecting SKRULLS VS. POWER PACK #1-4 O MARVEL MASTERWORKS: THE INCREDI- 96 PGS./All Ages ...$9.99 -who may be worse than either! This is a new series of GNs designed for of all ages! BLE HULK VOL. 5 HCCollecting THE INCREDIBLE O MINI MARVELS: SECRET INVASION DIGEST HULK #111-121.240 PGS..$54.99 96 PGS./All Ages ...$9.99 SOUL KISS #1 (of 5) O WOLVERINE OMNIBUS VOL. 1 HC Collecting O SECRET INVASION: FRONT LINE TPB $14.99 STEVEN T. SEAGLE comes to Image for SOUL KISS - the story of a woman with MARVEL COMICS PRESENTS #1-10, #72-84; IN- O SECRET INVASION: BLACK PANTHER $12.99 vengeance on her mind and damnation on her lips.
    [Show full text]
  • United States District Court for the Western District of Wisconsin
    UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF WISCONSIN NEIL GAIMAN, et al., Plaintiffs, v. Case No. 02-CV-00048-bcc TODD McFARLANE, et al., Defendants. THE McFARLANE DEFENDANTS’ BRIEF IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFF’S MOTION FOR ORDER DECLARING GAIMAN’S INTEREST IN CERTAIN COMIC BOOK CHARACTERS Defendants Todd McFarlane and Todd McFarlane Productions, Inc. (together, the “McFarlane Defendants”) submit this brief in opposition to plaintiff Gaiman’s motion for an order declaring that he has a copyright interest in the following three comic book characters: Dark Ages Spawn, Tiffany and Domina (the “Pending Accounting Motion”). INTRODUCTION As more fully discussed below, there are three distinct and fully sufficient grounds on which to deny the Pending Accounting Motion: 1. Mr. Gaiman is improperly attempting, through a post-judgment accounting procedure, to expand the judgment in this action to grant him an ownership interest in three additional copyrights despite having never asserted any such claim in the lawsuit. In particular, the three characters at issue in his motion were never raised in any fashion whatsoever—or even mentioned—in his pleadings or at trial in this case. Now, after judgment, Mr. Gaiman seeks improperly to supplement the record with hand-selected images that are misleading in their appearance. Due process requires that any adjudication of these new claims concerning additional characters be one in which the evidence can be tested, authenticated and explained to a trier of fact. A quasi-administrative, post-judgment accounting procedure is not the proper time or place, and this Court should reject Mr. Gaiman’s effort to obtain by way of motion what he has never sought by way of trial.
    [Show full text]
  • Cagliostro and His Egyptian Rite of Freemasonry
    CAGLIOSTRO AND HIS EGYPTIAN RITE OF FREEMASONRY By HENRY RIDGELY EVANS, 'Litt.D., 33° Hon. Gra nd Tiler of the Supreme Council, A.'. A... S.·. R:. of Freemasonry for the Southern Jurisdiction of the United States. TOGETHEI! WITH A N EXPOSITION OF' THE FIRST DEGREE OF' THE EGYPTIAN RITE Translated from the French by HORACE PARKER McINT03R, 33° Hon. (Reprinted from the New Age Maga.zine.) WASHINGTON, D. C. 1919 COUNT CAGLIOSTRO CAGLIOSTRO AND HIS EGYPTIAN RITE OF FREEMASONRY~ INTRODUCTION "Unparalleled Cagliostro! Looking at thy so attractively decorated private theater, wherein thou aetedst and livedst, what hand but itches to draw aside thy curtain and, turning the whole inside out, find thee in the middle thereof ?"- CARLYU, : J\lJ isc ella.neo1ts Essays. N the Rue de Beaune, Paris, a few doors from the house where Voltaire died, is a shabby genteel little hostelry, dating back to pre-revolutionary I times; to the old regime of Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette. You ring the bell of the concierge's office, and the wrought-iron gates open with a clang. Mine host welcomes you at the portal and, with the airs and graces of an aristocrat of the eighteenth century, ushers you up to the state bedroom. Ah, that bedroom, so old and quaint, with its huge four-post bed, garnished with faded. red curtains and mounted upon a raised dais. The chimney-piece is carved and bears the half-obliterated escutcheon of the builder of the man­ ~ion-a noble of the old regime. Over the mantle hangs a large oval mirror set in a tarnished gilt frame.
    [Show full text]
  • Spawn Comics Checklist (USA)
    Spawn Comics Checklist (USA) Last Updated: 06/18/2011 Title Issues Current Series Spawn (standard covers only) 1-207 Former Series Curse of the Spawn (standard covers only) 1-29 Spawn: The Dark Ages (standard covers only) 1-28 Sam & Twitch 1-26 Sam & Twitch: Case Files 1-25 Hellspawn 1-16 Mini-Series and One-Shots Spawn: Godslayer (1-shot) Spawn: Godslayer 1 (standard cover) Spawn: Godslayer 2 Spawn: Godslayer 3 Spawn: Godslayer 4 Spawn: Godslayer 5 Spawn: Godslayer 6 Spawn: Godslayer 7 Spawn: Godslayer 8 Spawn: The Undead 1 Spawn: The Undead 2 Spawn: The Undead 3 Spawn: The Undead 4 Spawn: The Undead 5 Spawn: The Undead 6 Spawn: The Undead 7 Spawn: The Undead 8 Spawn: The Undead 9 Spawn: The Impaler 1 Spawn: The Impaler 2 Spawn: The Impaler 3 Spawn: Blood Feud 1 Spawn: Blood Feud 2 Spawn: Blood Feud 3 Spawn: Blood Feud 4 Sam and Twitch: The Writer 1 Page of Spawn Comics Checklist (USA) Last Updated: 06/18/2011 Sam and Twitch: The Writer 2 Sam and Twitch: The Writer 3 Sam and Twitch: The Writer 4 Angela 1 Angela 2 Angela 3 Cy-Gor 1 Cy-Gor 2 Cy-Gor 3 Cy-Gor 4 Cy-Gor 5 Cy-Gor 6 Violator 1 Violator 2 Violator 3 Spawn: Blood & Shadows (Annual 1) Spawn Bible (1st Print) Spawn Bible (2nd Print) Spawn Bible (3rd Print) Spawn: Book of Souls Spawn: Blood & Salvation Spawn: Simony Spawn: Architects of Fear The Adventures of Spawn Director’s Cut The Adventures of Spawn 2 Celestine 1 (green) Celestine 1 (purple) Celestine 2 Spawn Manga (Shadows of Spawn) vol1 (1st Print) Spawn Manga (Shadows of Spawn) vol1 (2nd Print) Spawn Manga (Shadows of Spawn)
    [Show full text]
  • Image United Image United Marca Un Cambio Muy Grande En La Ma- Finales
    inter medios Medios Urbanos HÉROES LA RED de tinta de la web (Por Daniel Pizarro) (Por Urbana) El cómic se dibujó de una E-mail: [email protected] forma muy particular. E-mail: [email protected] Image United Image United marca un cambio muy grande en la ma- finales. Una manera poco ortodoxa de trabajar, pero nera de crear crossovers en el mundo del cómic, ya que visualmente debe ser impresionante. que aunque hemos leído otras historias que juntan a La historia nos presenta a Fortress, personaje todos los personajes de una compañía (sobre todo en creado por Portacio, un hombre normal atrapado en este año), esta es la única que puede presumir de tener un traje del que no puede salir que le otorga poderes tanto talento en cada página. Con un guión de Robert que no sabe controlar, quien empieza a tener visiones Kirkman (Invincible) y el dibujo de de una guerra próxima donde todos los casi todos los miembros fundadores héroes del Universo Image son derro- Bienvenidos a la de Image: Erik Larsen, Todd McFarla- tados. Esto hace que nuestro protago- ne, Marc Silvestri, Rob Liefeld, Whilce nista se lance a reunir a los personajes falsa ubicuidad Portacio y Jim Valentino (faltando Jim principales de la compañía (Savage Lee, por obligaciones contractuales Dragon, Spawn, Shadowhawk, Witchbla- Todos los fans y curiosos que entraron a YouTube el domingo con DC), Image United promete ser de, entre otros) para poder hacer frente 25 de octubre por la noche pudieron ver (y no todos disfrutar) uno de los grandes eventos de lo que a la amenaza llamada Dark Spawn, que un concierto en vivo de U2.
    [Show full text]
  • Magazines V17N9.Qxd
    SEP09 COF C1:COF C1.qxd 8/13/2009 2:03 PM Page 1 ORDERS DUE th 12SEP 2009 SEP E E COMIC H H T T SHOP’S CATALOG COF C2:Layout 1 8/12/2009 10:32 AM Page 1 COF Gem Page Sept:gem page v18n1.qxd 8/13/2009 2:11 PM Page 1 AGE OF REPTILES: THE JOURNEY #1 DR. HORRIBLE ONE-SHOT DARK HORSE COMICS DARK HORSE COMICS BATMAN/DOC SAVAGE SPECIAL #1 DC COMICS BLACKEST NIGHT #5 DC COMICS IMAGE UNITED #1 IMAGE COMICS MAGAZINE GEM OF THE MONTH DARK X-MEN #1 MARVEL COMICS PILOT SEASON: MURDERER WIZARD MAGAZINE #218 IMAGE COMICS WIZARD ENTERTAINMENT COF FI Page Sep:COF FI Page December.qxd 8/13/2009 2:13 PM Page 1 featuredfeatured itemsitems PREMIER (GEMS) TOYS & MODELS Dr. Horrible G Dark Horse Comics Voltron 25th-Anniversary Metallic Lion Gift Set G Age of Reptiles: Journey #1 G Dark Horse Comics Animation Blackest Night #5 G DC Comics Thundercats: Lion-O Statue G Cartoons Batman/Doc Savage Special G DC Comics The Maestro Statue G Marvel Heroes Image United #1 G Image Comics Pilot Season: Murderer #1 G Image Comics DESIGNER TOYS /Top Cow Productions Dark X-Men #1 G Marvel Comics Bunk Bots Plushes G Designer Toys Wizard Magazine #218 G Wizard Entertainment Hello Kitty mimoBot 4-Gigabyte USB Flash Drives G Designer Toys COMICS Sweet Meat Plushes G Designer Toys SuperGod #1 G Avatar Press IMPORT TOYS & MODELS Female Force: Stephenie Meyer G Bluewater Productions Marvel Comics: Scarlet Witch Bishoujo Statue G Farscape Ongoing #1 G BOOM! Studios Kotobukiya The World of Cars: Radiator Springs TP G BOOM! Terminator 2: T-800 Endoskeleton Die-Cast Figures G Studios
    [Show full text]
  • Holy Fandom, Batman! Commercial Fan Works, Fair Use, and the Economics of Complements and Market Failure
    THIS VERSION DOES NOT CONTAIN PAGE NUMBERS. PLEASE CONSULT THE PRINT OR ONLINE DATABASE VERSIONS FOR PROPER CITATION INFORMATION. NOTE HOLY FANDOM, BATMAN! COMMERCIAL FAN WORKS, FAIR USE, AND THE ECONOMICS OF COMPLEMENTS AND MARKET FAILURE Christina Chung* INTRODUCTION The average American spent $2,504 on media and entertainment in 2010.1 In addition to spending money, the average American spends about 2.7 hours per day watching television—and countless hours more reading, playing video games, and engaging in other forms of entertainment.2 Given the significant time and money that Americans spend on entertainment, it should come as no surprise that popular culture constitutes a major component of modern American life. For many consumers, passively engaging in entertainment— watching television, reading books, listening to music—is sufficient. Other consumers feel compelled to discuss their reactions to media with other entertainment consumers, whether they do so in person with friends and family, or online through message boards and forums.3 For many entertainment consumers, however, simply experiencing and discussing popular culture works is unsatisfactory. This particular subset of consumers known as fans—a term derived from the term “fanatic”4—often feels such an affinity to popular culture works that they respond to them with their own creative expression.5 The product of this expression can manifest in a wide variety of forms, including literary works such as fan fiction, audiovisual works such as fan videos, and pictorial works such as fan art.6 * J.D. 2013, Boston University School of Law; B.A. English 2010, Cornell University. I would like to thank Professor Wendy Gordon for serving as a spirit guide in the crazy mixed up world of copyright, Jen Neubauer for her keen editing and guidance, and Eric Auerbach for his love of economics—without them, this note would not have been possible.
    [Show full text]
  • 07/30/2010 Page 1 of 14
    Case: 3:02-cv-00048-bbc Document #: 323 Filed: 07/30/2010 Page 1 of 14 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF WISCONSIN - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - NEIL GAIMAN, OPINION AND ORDER Plaintiff, 02-cv-48-bbc v. TODD McFARLANE, TODD McFARLANE PRODUCTIONS, INC., and TMP INTERNATIONAL, INC., Defendants. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - This long-running copyright case is almost at a close. The one remaining matter for the court’s determination is plaintiff Neil Gaiman’s motion to compel defendants to turn over all documents in their possession relating to income attributable to three characters known as Domina, Tiffany and Dark Ages Spawn, featured in a series of comics written and published by defendants Todd McFarlane, McFarlane Productions and TMP International, Inc. The issue in dispute is whether the three characters are derivative of two characters known as Angela and Medieval Spawn that are subject to the parties’ joint copyright interest. The parties agree that they are co-owners of Angela and Medieval Spawn. Defendants 1 Case: 3:02-cv-00048-bbc Document #: 323 Filed: 07/30/2010 Page 2 of 14 do not contest plaintiff’s right to an accounting and division of profits for the posters, trading cards, clothing, statuettes, animated series on HBO, video games, etc. that feature those characters. The dispute is limited to information about the profits earned from Dark Ages Spawn, Tiffany and Domina, which defendant has refused to provide to plaintiff. Defendants contend that these characters are not subject to plaintiff’s copyright because they were based solely on plaintiff’s ideas and not on any physical expression of those ideas.
    [Show full text]
  • (35045 Plymouth Road, Livonia MI 48150) Or Live Online Via Proxibid! Follow Us on Facebook and Twitter @Back2past for Updates
    2/27 - Holly Collection Comic Books, Part One 2/27/2019 This session will be held at 6PM, so join us in the showroom (35045 Plymouth Road, Livonia MI 48150) or live online via Proxibid! Follow us on Facebook and Twitter @back2past for updates. Visit our store website at GOBACKTOTHEPAST.COM or call 313-533-3130 for more information! (Showroom Terms: No buyer's premium! Get the full catalog with photos, prebid and join us live at www.proxibid.com/backtothepast (See site for terms) LOT # LOT # 1 Auctioneer Announcements 17 Amazing Spider-Man #602/Pin-Up Cover A short address from auctioneer emeritus Andy Cirinesi. NM condition. 2 Amazing Spider-Man #363 CGC 9.8/Key 18 Amazing Spider-Man #553/Classic Cover 3rd appearance of Carnage. CGC graded comic. NM condition. 3 Amazing Spiderman #299/Key Issue 19 Amazing Spider-Man #543/Classic Cover 1st brief appearance of Venom in NM condition. NM condition. 4 Incredible Hulk #181/Marvel Milestone ED 20 Amazing Spider-Man #540-541 Lot of (2) NM condition. NM condition. 5 Image United #1/2009/Variant Spawn "C" 21 Amazing Spider-Man #497/Classic Cover NM condition. NM condition. 6 Incredible Hulk #34/2002/Key Issue 22 Amazing Spider-Man #496/Classic Cover NM condition. NM condition. 7 Alias #4/2002/Bendis 23 Amazing Spider-Man #495/Dodson Cover NM condition. NM condition. 8 Deadpool #51/2001/Detective Cover Swipe 24 Amazing Spider-Man #489/Cho Cover NM condition. NM condition. 9 Superman #204/2004/1st Jim Lee 25 Amazing Spider-Man #491/Campbell Cover Sharp VF/VF+ condition.
    [Show full text]