Report Summary Property Information & Applicable Criteria

"At-a-Glance" Report Summary Property Information & Applicable Criteria

Resource Address: 2528 Island Ave, San Diego CA 92113 APN: 535-272-26-00 Resource Na111e (per HRB naming policy): ______

Resource Type: Building/Single Family Will you be Submitting a Mills Act Application Following Designation? Y □ N Iii

Architect/Builder: None Discovered/None Discovered Date of Construction: ------1 904 Prior Resource Address (ifrelocated): ______Date of Relocation: ______

Applicant's Name: _S_t_e_v_e_N_u_r_d_in_g______Owner's Name: Paula Development, Inc. Address: 812 F Ave. Address: 1206 10th St. Coronado CA 92118 Coronado, CA 92118 Phone#: 619.993.7665 Phone#: 619.721.3431 Email: [email protected] Email: [email protected]

The resource is being nominated for designation as a historical resource under:

□ HRB Criterion A as a special element of the City's, a community's or a neighborhood's D historical development D archaeological development □ cultural development D social development D economic development D political development D aesthetic development D engineering development D landscaping development D architectural development for the following reason(s): _N_IA______

□ HRB Criterion B for its association with _N_/_A______who/which is significant in local, state or national history for the following reason(s): ------~------

D HRB Criterion Casa good/excellent exarhple of _N_/_A______

□ HRB Criterion Das a notable work of_N_/_A______~ a Master ______□ Previously established as a Master □ Proposed as a Master

D HRB Criterion E as a property which has been determined eligible by the Nation;:tl Park Service for listing on the National Register of Historic Places or is listed or has been determined eligible by the State Historical Preservation Office for listing on the State Register of Historical Resources. □ HRB Criterion F as a contributing resource to the N/ A Historical District.

Are interior elements/features included in the nomination and proposed for designation? □ Yes ii No If Yes, list elements and location: ______"At-a-Glance" Report Summary Required Forms and Documentation

Circle Yes or No, indicating whether or not the following required documentation has been provided:

Rep01t Copies Y N Provide one copy of the Historical Resource Research Rep01t, double sided and stapled

Depaitment of Parks and Recreation Fo1111s Y N Primary Record (523a) Y N BSO Record (523b) y N Archaeological Record (523c) (if applicable) y N District Record ( 523d) (if applicable) y N Locational Map (523j) (if applicable) y N Sketch Map (523k) (if applicable) y N Continuation Sheet (5231)

Attachment A Attachment B y N Assessor's Record Y N Chain of Title y N Notice of Completion y N Directory Search y N Water Sewer Records y N Deed from the Date of Construction y N Building Pennits y N Site Plan with Footprint y N County Lot & Block Book y N Previous Survey Fonns

Attachment C Attachment D y N City SD 800 Scale Eng Maps y N Historical and Transitional Photos y N USGS Maps y N Current Photos ofN01th Elevation y N Original Subdivision Map y N Current Photos of East Elevation y N 1886/1887 Sanborn y N Cunent Photos of South Elevation y N 1906 Sanborn y N Cunent Photos of West Elevation y N 1921 Sanborn y N Photos with a key floor plan y N 1940 Sanborn (for interiors under consideration) y N 1950 Sanborn y N 1956 Sanborn Attaclm1ent E y N Criterion A Documentation y N Criterion B Documentation y N Criterion C Documentation y N Criterion D Documentation y N Criterion E Documentation y N Criterion F Documentation

State of California  The Resources Agency Primary # DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION HRI # PRIMARY RECORD Trinomial NRHP Status Code

Other Listings Review Code Reviewer Date

Page 1 of 1 *Resource Name or #: (Assigned by recorder) P1. Other Identifier: ____

*P2. Location: Not for Publication I Unrestricted *a. County San Diego and (P2c, P2e, and P2b or P2d. Attach a Location Map as necessary.) *b. USGS 7.5' Quad Point Loma Quadrangle Date 2018 T ; R ; of of Sec ; B.M. c. Address 2528 Island Ave. City San Diego Zip 92113 d. UTM: (Give more than one for large and/or linear resources) Zone , mE/ mN e. Other Locational Data: (e.g., parcel #, directions to resource, elevation, decimal degrees, etc., as appropriate) This property is located on the USGS CA_Point_Loma_20180918 topographical map, 7.5-Minute Series. The street address is 2528 Island Ave in San Diego, California. The tract is San Diego County Assessor’s Map book 535, page 27, Map 56, block 272, lots 33, 34, and half of lot 35. It lies on the North side of Island Avenue, between 25th and 26th Streets. It is identified as Tax Assessor’s Parcel Number 535-272-26-00.

*P3a. Description: (Describe resource and its major elements. Include design, materials, condition, alterations, size, setting, and boundaries) The subject house is a “Folk Victorian” style single family residence, with the original structure built in 1904. It is a one story cross-gabled house with concrete block foundation, 3 tab shingle composition roof on the original roof gables, and “torch-down” composition material on a large flat-roof addition. The house is covered with 7” wide wood tongue and groove siding. There are no fish-scale shingles present on the upper walls at the gables. A 45% increase in building footprint occurred before 1920 with the addition of a massive flat-roofed addition in the back yard. See Continuation Sheet.

*P3b. Resource Attributes: (List P5a. attributes and codes) HP2 Single Family

Property *P4. Resources Present: I Building Structure Object Site District Element of District Other (Isolates, etc.) P5b. Description of Photo: (view, date, accession #) View of Southwest elevation, taken Oct 26 2019 *P6. Date Constructed/Age and Source: I Historic Prehistoric Both 1904, County Assessor Residential Building Record

*P7. Owner and Address: Paula Development, Inc. 1206 10th St. Coronado, CA 92118

*P8. Recorded by: (Name, affiliation, and address) Steve Nurding Researcher 812 F Ave Coronado, CA 92118

*P9. Date Recorded: *P10. Survey Type: (Describe) Intensive *P11. Report Citation: (Cite survey report and other sources, or enter "none.") None _ *Attachments: NONE Location Map IContinuation Sheet IBuilding, Structure, and Object Record Archaeological Record District Record Linear Feature Record Milling Station Record Rock Art Record Artifact Record Photograph Record Other (List):

DPR 523A (9/2013) *Required information State of California ~ Natural Resources Agency Primary# DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION HRI# Trinomial CONTINUATION SHEET Property Name: --~2=5=2~8=ls=la=n=d ~A~ve=·~·S=a~n~ □~ie~g-o~C~A~9=2~1~13 Page _2_ of _g

P3a. Description:

The subject house is a "Folk Victorian" style single family residence, with the original structure built in 1904. It is a one story cross-gabled house with concrete block foundation, 3 tab shingle composition roof on the original roof gables, and "torch-down" composition material on a large flat-roof addition. The house is covered with 7" wide wood tongue and groove siding. There are no fish-scale shingles present on the upper walls at the gables. A 45% increase in building footprint occurred before 1930 with the addition of a massive flat-roofed addition in the back yard.

The style of the house, as originally built, would best be classified as "Folk Victorian", but of a simple vernacular-built variety. Research revealed no recorded architect or builder. Comparison of home styles of the era in "A Field Guide To American Houses" (Virginia Savage McAlester, 2013) shows Folk Victorian to be the best style fit, being a one story cross-gabled residential house with tall and narrow 1/1 double hung windows, and remaining door and window trim consistent with Victorian detailing.

The street address is 2528 Island Ave in San Diego, California. Block 272, lots 33, 34, and half of lot 35. It lies on the North side of Island Avenue, between 25 th and 26th Streets. It is identified as Tax Assessor's Parcel Number 535-272-26-00. The neighborhood is largely residential, located in the Grant Hill area, and as would be expected is hilly in nature.

Windows consist of an assortment of sizes and styles. Only two original Victorian tall and narrow 1/1 double hung windows remain, both on the west fac;:ade. These have heavy headers and detailed trim boards. Cut marks in the tongue and groove siding show that many other original windows have been either replaced with simpler windows of different proportions, or converted into a doorway, or completely removed and patched over. All replacement windows are wider, and not as tall as the original.

All doors have been removed and replaced with hollow-core doors, all of which are in bad condition. The original front door location is on the east fac;:ade, and is now a "side door". The frame around this door contains the Victorian heavy header and elaborate trim. A new front door was added to the south fac;:ade, replacing an original window there. The window next to it was also replaced with a shorter, wider window. So the apparent front door of the house was originally not a door at all. There are two doors into the back of the house, on the north fac;:ade. Trim around these doors is simple. One of the door, to the east under a gable, may be in an original location. But the door to the flat-roofed addition would not have been original to the structure.

Trim, fascia, and corner boards are largely intact and are useful for determining original footprint and identifying additions. These boards are all simple, with the exception of the handrail "half-posts" set against the wall. These half-posts are true 4 x 4's and have beveled edges. Careful examination of paint ghosts revealed no outlines of previous gingerbread on the porch fascia.

The condition of the building is poor. Significant wood rot is present at the siding of the flat roofed addition, and siding replacement is the only recourse. Other rot spots correspond to paint coating failure. Most window and door trim boards are in need of replacement. Foundation seems intact, and from the outside the roof shows no obvious flaws other than a need for re-roofing. All windows have been covered with OSB sheets to keep out animals and weather at broken glass. All windows have had heavy iron gratings added for security, and even though these gratings can be removed the current conditions in the neighborhood prohibit this.

DPR 523L (Rev. 1/1995)(Word 9/2013) State of California ti Natural Resources Agency Primary# DEPARTMENT OF P!\RKS AND RECREATION HRI# Trinomial CONTINUATION SHEET Property Name:~·•-:~~=-=~~='-='-~'--'=--'-== :Page _2_ of ---2.. ···

The house was placed on a concrete block foundation sometime after original 1904 construction. Wood skirting would likely have hidden wood post supports, but the wood skirt has been replaced by the concrete block foundation.

Roof material in 1920 was shingle on both the main structure and the front porch as indicated by two "X" marks on the 1920 Sanborn Map. A large flat-roof addition to the back of the house was composition as indicated by a solid dot on that portion of the roof. The 1921 Sanborn Map shows both areas of shingle roof were changed to composition roof (three tab asphalt) that is in place today.

There are no interior elements that should be considered for historic designation. The interior has been remodeled several times, and room uses changed.

DPR 523L (Rev. 1/1995)(Word 9/2013)

State of California Χ The Resources Agency Primary # DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION HRI#

BUILDING, STRUCTURE, AND OBJECT RECORD

*Resource Name or # (Assigned by recorder) *NRHP Status Code Page 1 of 1

B1. Historic Name: None B2. Common Name: B3. Original Use: Single Family Residential B4. Present Use: Single Family Residential *B5. Architectural Style: Folk Victorian *B6. Construction History: (Construction date, alterations, and date of alterations) The building was constructed in 1904 per the County Residential Building Record. There are no permits older than 1965 (electrical only) so construction history must be derived from other sources. The 1906 Sanborn Map ends one block away from the house. A 1920 Sanborn Map shows that a flat roof addition was in place in 1920, increasing square footage by 45%. This addition is confirmed by a 1930 aerial photo. A 1921 Sanborn Map update shows that by 1921 the house and front porch roof was revised from shingle to composition. With the absence of permits the date of conversion of windows, doors, foundation, and porch posts/railing/spindles are all speculative. The County Residential Building Record shows no significant change in footprint since the first year of assessment in 1961. At that time the building was estimated to have 20 years of life remaining. This has been exceeded by 38 years. See Continuation Sheet. *B7. Moved? I No Yes Unknown Date: Original Location: *B8. Related Features:

An additional small house was built in 1904 (same as current house) in the northwest corner, but this house (2528½ Island Ave) was demolished by 1966.

B9a. Architect: Unknown. None determined. b. Builder: Unknown. None determined. *B10. Significance: Theme Residential Architecture Area Grant Hill

Period of Significance 1900-1910 Property Type Single Family Residential Applicable Criteria None (Discuss importance in terms of historical or architectural context as defined by theme, period, and geographic scope. Also address integrity.)

Originally called Mount Gilead, the area was subdivided in 1887 by Mrs. W.E. Daugherty. Sparse development in the area indicates that this was a predominantly rural area of small houses and orchards. There was little construction in the area until 1906 when Ulysses S. Grant Jr. purchased a major portion of the subdivision, including the top of the hill, and re subdivided it, renaming it U.S. Grant’s Hill.

The Sherman Heights and Grant Hill Park Historic Districts were established in 1990. The subject property does not lie within either of these districts. See Continuation Sheet.

(Sketch Map with north arrow required.)

B11. Additional Resource Attributes: (List attributes and codes) N/A *B12. References: See Continuation Sheet B13. Remarks: None

*B14. Evaluator: Steve Nurding *Date of Evaluation: 11/13/2019

(This space reserved for official comments.)

DPR 523B (9/2013) *Required information 1-

State of California ~ Natural Resources Agency Primary# DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION HRI# Trinomial CONTINUATION SHEET Property Name: 2528 Island Ave., San Diego GA 92113 Page_1_of____ll__

B6. Construction History: The following Building Permit Records were located for 2528 Island Ave. at the City of San Diego Operations Building at 1222 1st Ave., and are included as Attachment A.4

► E04605 Electrical Permit, New Service, to Fernandez by Allied Electric, Issued 2-19-1965 ► E39088 Plumbing and Gas, Water Heater, to Fernandez, C., by Lattman & Pflaux, issued 4-7-1971 ► E39088 Field Inspection Record (for above Water Heater), issued ?-9-1971 ► M46899 Plumbing and Gas, Water Heater, to Rudy Fernandez by A-Ames South Inc., issued 1-26-1979 ► M46899 Field Inspection Record (for above Water Heater), issued 2-1-1979

Per the Planning department, records older than around 1955 were destroyed in a fire. No Building Permits were issued for this property after 1979.

The Assessor's Residential Building Record described the property as a single family dwelling constructed in 1904, with a footprint sketch drawn in 1961. At that time a second dwelling was located in the rear of the property, but was unoccupied and on the verge of collapse. Phone and occupancy records indicate that this rear dwelling was demolished by 1966. The Record is included as Attachment A.1

A Notice of Completion was not located through research.

The Water Department and Sewer Department Records for the City of San Diego indicate that sewer was connected in 1921 and renewed water service connected in 1953.

The Lot and Block Book Page shows a 1903 construction year instead of the 1904 year indicated by the Residential Building Record. A copy of this and subsequent years are included in Attachment A.6

The San Diego phone directories list the occupants from 1914 through 2018. Directory result is included in Attachment 8.2

The Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps were found for 1920, 1921, 1940 update, and 1956 update. These are included as Attachment C.4

Footprint The original structure was 624 square feet of dwelling space. However, a flat-roof addition of 252 square feet was added by 1930. Other minor bulge-outs to the northern wing added 26 square feet. Thus the current building is 902 square feet of habitable space, representing a 45% increase in size over the original building footprint. ------

The 252 square foot addition was visible in a 1930 aerial photograph and was present when the County Residential Building Record was created in 1961. However, no permits or documentation of this addition, or the two minor 26 square foot bulge-outs exist. The 252 square foot addition is of crude construction, poorly blended into the original structure, and has a flat roof instead of the gabled roofline of the original building. This large addition is inconsistent with the proportions, shape, and style of the original Folk Victorian house, and detract from any remaining architectural value of the building.

DPR 523L (Rev. 1/1995)(Word 9/2013} State of California ~ Natural Resources Agency Primary# DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION HRI# Trinomial CONTINUATION SHEET Property Name: 2528 Island Ave .• San Diego CA 92113 Page_._1_of__J_;L_

Conclusion: The building footprint has been increased by 45%, significantly altering the building footprint with a flat-roof addition and bulge-outs inappropriate to the original Folk Victorian design.

Windows The original windows were very tall and narrow 1/1 double hung windows with classic Victorian headers and trim. Only 2 of the original windows remain. At least 5 other original window locations, as evidenced by clear patch marks in the siding, have either been completely filled in or replaced with windows of a much squatter proportion and lacking the original Victorian header and trim boards. It is likely that even more original windows were lost when the additions to the house were added.

Photos in Attachment D show patch marks in the siding of the west and east fac;ade, showing location and proportion of original windows.

Original windows were tall and narrow 1/1 double hung with heavy headers and detailed trim, typical of the Victorian style. Front fac;ade (south) had two tall 1/1 double hung windows, and no door. Porch posts had true 4 x 4's with bevel edges. An alley retaining wall was added, partially blocking the west facade, and the back flat-roofed addition was built. A bulge-out has been added to the back north wing, which likely filled in an original window with a newer window of different proportions.

Conclusion: Key windows of the original structure have been filled in or replaced with windows of different proportions inappropriate to the Folk Victorian style. Important windows have been significantly modified or eliminated.

Doors The house currently has two front doors. The door on the east fac;ade is the original front door location. This is apparent when looking at the Victorian header and trim boards, and integration with the overhead porch. The actual door at this location (and all door locations) has been replaced with a modern hollow core door in very poor condition. The "front door" on the south fac;ade is an addition. It replaced an original tall and narrow 1/1 double hung window. So, when walking up to the front of the contemporary structure a person is misled to believe that they are coming upon an original front door, when in fact they are entering through an apparent window location.

Conclusion: All doors are replacements. Only 1 door location has original trim and header. Doors have been significantly modified.

Roof The 1920 Sanborn Map (oldest that shows the property) originally had an "X" on the main house roof, indicating a shingle roof. The 1921 Sanborn Map was changed to a solid Dot, indicating a change from shingle to composition roof on the main building (excluding the 252 sq. ft. flat roof addition).

Conclusion: The original roof material of the main house was wood shingle. After 15 years of aging this was replaced with a composition 3-tab asphalt shingle roof as seen today. Also a terra cotta chimney, as shown on all Sanborn maps toward the back of the house, is no longer present.

DPR 523L (Rev. 1/199S)(Word 9/2013) State of California.~ Natural Resources Agency Primary# DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION HRI# Trinomial CONTINUATION SHEET Property Name: 2528 Island Ave., San Diego CA 92113 Page_1_of__J_;L_

Front Porch The front porch wraps around the east and south fac;:ade of the southernmost wing of the house. The porch roof itself appears to be original, judging by the True Dimension lumber used (real 2" x 4" lumber) and the bead board soffit. However, the porch posts have all been replaced by modern dimension 4 x 4's, (3 ½" x 3 ½") without beveled edges. Original post details can be determined by comparison with an original posts next to the real front door. Original posts were true 4" x 4", with beveled edges. All porch handrails and handrail spindles are currently deteriorated modern 2 x 4's and 2 x 2's, with dimensions of 1 ½" x 3 ½" (2x4) and 1 ½" x 1 ½" (2x2). Some rails are pressure treated. Clearly the original rails were a full 2" thick because coping in the original post by the front door is 2" wide, not 1 ½".

When the house was raised and a foundation installed it is likely that the flooring of the original front porch, which should have been wood, was replaced with the current concrete flooring present today.

The 1920 Sanborn Map (oldest that shows the property) originally had an "X" on the porch roof, indicating a shingle roof. The 1921 Sanborn Map was changed to a solid Dot, indicating a change from shingle to composition roof.

Conclusion: All front porch posts, rails, and spindles have been replaced with lumber of modern dimensions and lack all signs of beveled edge craftsmanship. The porch roof was originally shingle, but has been change to composition (3-tab asphalt shingle). Roof material, concrete floor, posts and spindle changes constitute a significant revision of the material and visual impact of the porch, thus changing a key feature of the house primary fac;:ade.

Foundation The foundation that most of the house sits upon is 4" x 16" hollow concrete block. Originally the house did not sit on this block foundation because equipment for mass production of concrete foundation block was first revealed at the 1904 St. Louis Louisiana Purchase Exposition. With the house being constructed in 1904, it is almost impossible that the blocks used in the 2528 Island Ave foundation were produced in 1904, the year of construction. Other evidence of the foundation being a revision remain underneath the house. Looking into the crawlspace you can plainly see a large pile of dirt centered under the floor. This is consistent with manual excavation for foundation under an existing house resting on piers.

There is a trim board at the top of the concrete block foundation on the east fac;:ade. Both ends of this trim board have a 45 degree miter cut on the end, implying that the house was wrapped by this trim board which was largely removed when the foundation was installed.

The back 252 square foot addition is not on a concrete block foundation, and appears to be built slab-on-grade.

Conclusion: The original house has been raised, and any original wood skirt replace with concrete block.

DPR 523L (Rev. 1/199S}(Word 9/2013) State of California ~ Natural Resources Agency Primary# DEPARTMENT Of: PARKS AND RECREATION HRI# Trinomial CONTINUATION SHEET Property Name: 2528 Island Ave .. San Diego CA 92113 Page _1_ of __

B10 Significance:

Near the end of the Mexican Period, 48,000 acres around San Diego were granted pueblo status, with the right of self-government. These Pueblo Lands were divided into 1,350 parcels. At the end of the Mexican-American war, California was ceded by Mexico to the United States. Land speculators settled in San Diego. Southeastern San Diego was a patchwork of subdivisions. One of these subdivisions, the Sherman Addition, is bounded on the east at 24 th Street. The property containing the structure in question, 2528 Island Avenue, was first defined in the 1873 creation of the LW Kimballs subdivision of the Northwest quarter of Pueblo Lot No. 1154. As empty lots (33, 34, ½ of 35), pre-construction Chain of Title indicate that the lots exchanged hands several times before structures were erected, a reflection of the typical San Diego land speculation occurring at the end of the 19th century.

Partially fueling land speculation in San Diego was the coming of the railroad. City leaders first tried to attract a railroad line as early as 1860. Several unsuccessful attempts were made until 1885, when the California Southern Railroad connected San Diego to National City and soon to San Bernardino, providing a transcontinental connection. By 1889 a trolley line ran along Commercial Street, 5 blocks from the 2528 Island property. This transcontinental rail link was one factor helping San Diego to grow. Trolley line extensions into more distant neighborhoods allowed working people to live further from the downtown core of jobs. The time frame of 1868 to 1916 is referred to as the era of "Building Southeastern San Diego" (Page & Turnbull, Aug 2014), Arrival of railroad and streetcar system is one of six factors cited for this period of growth, which also included subdivision and land speculation, booming residential development, municipal services, farms in Encanto, and growth of San Diego city limits.

The subject property lies just to the east of the Sherman Heights Historic District Boundary, and just north of the Grant Hill Historic District boundary. At the time of the home's construction in 1903 or 1904 San Diego was continuing to expand eastward from new downtown, fueled by population growth, public transport, and infrastructure. This was a time of an expanding middle class. A city living working man who owned a home could expect a modest, modern building that had running water, sewer, and possibly electrical service. Construction from standard milled lumber was the norm, and the extravagance of the Victorian home style was beginning to lose its appeal to the Craftsman style which better reflected the realities of family living without the aid of a servant class. 2528 Island Ave reflects this transition.

In the early 1900's, a number of homes were built by a family named Berger. This family worked as Stone Masons and owned their own firm called Berger Brothers. Their profession may be responsible for the many cobblestone retaining walls in the area, a unique and consistent design feature of the Grant Hill neighborhood. These masonry features are not present at 2528 Island Ave.

As a Victorian style home 2528 Island Ave. barely qualifies. As a Craftsman it does not. No architect or builder could be found in the records. But owing to the simplicity of the original design and the lack of ornamentation this house was likely a "design-build" where a local builder was hired to "build one of those houses" without the involvement of a Master Architect. As times changed and families grew a large and inappropriate addition was constructed on the back, increasing the building footprint by 45%, The tall and narrow Victorian 1/1 double hung windows were replaced with shorter windows, allowing furniture such as couches and beds to be against a wall while remaining hidden from outside. A

DPR 523L (Rev. 1/1995){Word 9/2013) State of California ~ Natural Resources Agency Primary# DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION ·.·. HRI# Trinomial 'CONTINUATION SHEET •Property Name: ':2528 Island Ave:. San DiegoCA92113 Page _f_ of __

foundation was added, A new front door was substituted for a window, reflecting departure from Victorian standards of entry and entertaining. Built at the end of the Victorian era, the floorplan was inadequate for modern living and was soon revised.

San Diego continued to grow, particularly at the end of World War 1 in 1918. Like many homes this one had its heyday early on. But as the neighborhood slipped into deterioration so did this house, A second house on the lot, 2528 ½ Island, was so close to collapse that it was demolished by 1966, When the Sherman Heights and Grant Hill Historic Districts were established the block that the subject property sits on was not included in either Historic District. There is no evidence of a large investment in this house after World War 2, and it continued to deteriorate with the minimum of maintenance to allow habitation. Today the window glass has been covered with OSB boards to keep out animals and weather. All windows are covered with heavy iron gratings to keep out squatters, and doors are all chained shut.

Application of the San Diego Historic Resources Board (HRB) Significance Criteria:

The Historical Resources Guidelines of the City of San Diego's Land Development Manual (LDM) identifies the criteria under which a resource may be historically designated, It states that any improvement, building, structure, sign, interior element and fixture, site, place, district, area, or object may be designated a historical resource by the City of San Diego Historical Resources Board (HRB) if it meets one or more of the following designation criteria:

Criterion A: Exemplifies or reflects special elements of the City's, a community's or a neighborhood's historical, archaeological, cultural, social, economic, political, aesthetic, engineering, landscaping, or architectural development.

RESOURCES NOT ELIGIBLE UNDER CRITERION A It is important to note that Criterion A states that a resource must exemplify or reflect special elements of development. Special elements of development refer to a resource that is distinct among others of its kind or that surpass the usual in significance. It is not enough for a resource to simply reflect an aspect of development, as all buildings, structures and objects do. Special Elements shall be described by the applicant and discussed in the narrative statement of significance within the context of Aspects of Criterion A. ·

No historical evidence was identified which would support the contention that the house at 2528 Island Ave. exemplifies or reflects special elements of San Diego's or the surrounding neighborhood's historical, archeological, cultural, social, economic, political, aesthetic, engineering, landscaping or architectural development. The structure in no way exemplifies or reflects "special elements" of City, community, or neighborhood development any more than other structures on Island Avenue or the nearby Grant Hill or Sherman Heights neighborhoods of San Diego,

Under the Guidelines for the Application of the Historical Resources Board Designation Criteria, the 2528 Island Ave residence does not possess special elements of development which is distinct among others or of its kind that surpasses the usual significance. The structure was originally constructed in 1903 or 1904 in the Folk Victorian style, single level, cross-gabled, with steeply sloped roofs, tall and narrow 1/1 double hung windows, wrap-around front porch, and a front door set to one side. As originally constructed this was a very typical house for the emerging middle class, and is the sort of structure that would nowadays be referred to as a "design-build" that a skilled contractor could erect without assistance from an architect. Structure, layout and details were generic to the day, and used features found in typical

DPR 523L {Rev, 1/1995)(Word 9/2013) State of California ~ Natural Resources Agency Primary# DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION HRI# Trinomial CONTINUATION SHEET Property Name: 2528 Island Ave., San Diego CA 92113 Page _1_ of __

houses middle class San Diego houses erected at the end of the Victorian era, and prior to the Craftsman style. Many of these simple homes were in the area.

2528 Island was constructed during the development period identified as "Building Southeastern San Diego 1868-1916" (Page & Turnbull Aug. 2014). This Folk Victorian house was constructed during this timeframe, and there is little doubt that many of the reasons cited by Page & Turnbull for the rapid expansion of San Diego at this time were contributing causations for the construction of this particular home. Certainly subdivision had occurred, railroads arrived, others were building homes in the neighborhood, municipal and social services were provided, farms sprang up in Encanto, and the San Diego city limits grew. This property reflects aspects of development, as all buildings constructed at that time in that region do. However, per the Historical Resources Guidelines of the City of San Diego's Land Development Manual (LDM) a resource must be distinct among others of its kind or that surpass the usual in significance to be considered to be considered special elements of development. The 2528 Island Ave building does not reflect an aspect of development any more than other contemporaneous structures. The property does not reflect an element of development which maintains an established precedent, and is not a model of "special elements" of development in the Grant Hill and Sherman Heights area.

• Historical Development - In order to be significant for Historical Development, a resource shall exemplify or reflect a special or unique aspect of the City's general historical development, or shall exemplify or reflect a unique aspect of the City's history. No historical evidence was identified which would support the idea that 2528 Island Ave exemplifies or reflects a special or unique aspect of the City's general historical development, or exemplifies or reflects a unique aspect of the City's history. Although build during the development period referred to as "Building Southeastern San Diego 1868-1916", a time of great expansion of San Diego due to railroad, utilities, subdivision and development, the research found no information that would support a claim that "special elements" of historical development are present. Per the Historical Resources Guidelines of the City of San Diego's Land Development Manual (LDM) a resource must be distinct among others of its kind or that surpass the usual in significance to be considered to be considered special elements of development. This house was typical, not distinct among others of its kind.

• Archaeological Development - In order to be significant for Archaeological Development, a resource shall be prehistoric or historic in nature but must exemplify archaeological development through subsurface deposits and may include associated surface features. 2528 Island Ave is not a prehistoric or historic archaeological resource, with no evidence of either. Therefore the building or site does not exemplify archaeological development.

• Cultural Development - In order to be significant for Cultural Development, a resource shall exemplify or reflect development that is associated with a group of people linked together by shared values, beliefs, and historical associations or are properties associated with significant achievement in the visual and fine arts (painting, sculpture, architecture, theater, dance, music), literature, philosophy, religion, science, mathematics, social studies, or any of the disciplines that are commonly associated with public and private institutions of higher learning and/or academic inquiry. An examination of the list of owners and occupants of 2528 Island Ave reveals no persons that can be associated with any specific or general Cultural Development, nor does the physical structure reflect development associated with Cultural Development. Therefore this property is not significant with respect to any form of Cultural Development.

• Social Development - In order to be significant for Social Development a resource shall exemplify or reflect development that is associated with relations and interactions with others.

DPR 523L (Rev. 1/1995)(Word 9/2013) State of California ~ Natural Resources Agency Primary# DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION HRI# Trinomial CONTINUATION SHEET Property Name: 2528 Island Ave., San Diego CA 92113 Page _1_ of __

No historical evidence was found which would support the idea that 2528 Island Ave exemplifies or reflects development that is associated with relations and interactions with others. Therefore this property is not significant with respect to any form of Social Development.

• Economic Development - In order to be significant for Economic Development a resource shall exemplify or reflect development associated with the local, regional, state or national economy or economics, including manufacturing, labor and agriculture, maritime, and transportation industries. No historical evidence was found which would support the idea that 2528 Island Ave exemplifies or reflects development that is associated with economics or any industries. Therefore this property is not significant with respect to any form of Economic Development.

• Political Development - In order to be significant for Political Development, a resource shall exemplify or reflect development associated with politics or the political atmosphere, including women's suffrage, neighborhood activism, labor organizations and the Civil Rights Movement associated with ethnic and gay/lesbian issues. An examination of the list of owners and occupants of 2528 Island Ave reveals no persons that can be associated with any specific or general Political Development. Therefore this property is not significant with respect to Political Development. This was just a home, owned and occupied by a typical cross section of San Diego citizens. Research revealed no elected officials or political activists.

• Aesthetic Development - In order to be significant for Aesthetic Development a resource shall exemplify or reflect development associated with artistic arrangement in theory or practice. No historical evidence was found which would support the idea that this property exemplifies or reflects development that is associated with Aesthetic Development. Therefore this property is not significant with respect to Aesthetic Development.

• Engineering Development - In order to be significant for Engineering Development a resource shall exemplify or reflect development associated with engineering. Engineering development may include professionally applied standards or design ingenuity within engineering disciplines. Engineering solutions may be applied within individual buildings, structures and objects, or be associated with large scale infrastructure development like ports, railroads, roads and freeways, dams and flood control, electrical transmission and water systems. As a structure 2528 Island Ave does not exemplify or reflect development associated with Engineering. This was a normal 2 x 4 framing single level home construction typical of the day and region, showing no particular applied standards or design ingenuity.

• Landscape Development - In order to be significant for Landscape Development the resource shall exemplify or reflect development associated with garden and park design, subdivision design, or ecosystem/habitat restoration and may include professionally applied standards or design ingenuity within landscape disciplines. This property has had any landscaping neglected to the point that, if there was originally some landscaping of note, it has been decimated or gone to weed. A modern cinder block wall with iron spike fencing surrounds most of the property, and is inconsistent with fences build in the area during Victorian times. Original concrete paths in the back yard have been increased in area by the addition of more concrete paths and pads. No historical evidence was found which would support the idea that this property exemplifies or reflects development that is associated with Landscape Development. Therefore this property is not significant with respect to Landscape Development.

• Architectural Development - In order to be significant for Architectural Development the resource shall exemplify or reflect development associated with the city's built environment, especially that designed and

DPR 523L (Rev. 1/1995)(Word 9/2013~ State of California ~ Natural Resources Agency Primary# DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION HRI# Trinomial CONTINUATION SHEET Property Name: 2528 Island Ave., San Diego CA 92113 Page _1_ of __

constructed by non-architects, including real estate developers, contractors, speculators, homeowners and others associated with the building industry. No architect or builder has been identified by the historic research. An examination of the scale (small) and simplicity of the building makes it quite possible that a developer or contractor erected this house as one of many. However within a few blocks radius there are no other structures showing similar footprint or detail sufficient to show a common lineage attributable to one particular builder. This house at 2528 Island is typical of what was being constructed in the area at the time, but does not exemplify or reflect Architectural Development associated with the city's built environment, especially that designed and constructed by non-architects, including real estate developers, contractors, speculators, homeowners and others associated with the building industry. The property does not qualify under Architectural Development.

Criterion B: Is identified with persons or events significant in local, state, or national history. Resources associated with individuals whose specific contributions to history can be identified and documented may qualify under HRB Criterion B for persons significant in history. Persons significant in our past refer to individuals associated with San Diego whose activities, achievements and contributions are demonstrably important within the City, state, or nation. Resources associated with historical events are those associated with a single event such as the place where an important battle occurred, a building in which an important invention was developed, or a factory district where a significant strike occurred.

An examination of the list of owners and occupants of 2528 Island Ave reveals no persons that can be associated with any person that made specific contributions to history, either of San Diego, California, or the United States. Also, historic research revealed no events associated with the property.

The property does not qualify under Criterion B.

Criterion C: Embodies distinctive characteristics of style, type, period, or method of construction or is a valuable example of the use of indigenous materials or craftsmanship. Criterion C applies to resources significant for their physical design or method of construction. To embody the distinctive characteristics of a style, type, period or method of construction refers to the way in which a property was conceived, designed, or fabricated by an individual, a group of people, or a culture. Distinctive characteristics are those physical features or traits that commonly recur in individual styles, types, periods or methods of construction. A valuable example of the use of indigenous materials or craftsmanship means an important use of naturally occurring materials in construction of the resource or an important example of a skilled craftsperson. In order to qualify under Criterion C the resource must embody distinctive characteristics of an architectural style, a type of construction, a recognized construction period, or an identifiable method of construction, as established through accepted bodies of scholarly and professional work. Comparison to other resources of the same style, type, period, or method of construction is not required unless scholarly work has not been done on a particular property type or unless surviving examples of a property type are extremely rare.

This house best fits a "Folk Victorian" style single family residence, with the original structure built in 1903/04. It is a one story cross-gabled house with concrete block foundation, 3 tab shingle composition roof on the original roof gables, and "torch-down" composition material on a large flat-roof addition. The house is covered with 7" wide wood tongue and groove siding. There are no fish-scale shingles present on the upper walls at the gables. A 45% increase in building footprint occurred before 1930 with the addition of a massive flat-roofed addition in the back yard.

The style of the house, as originally built, would be classified as "Folk Victorian", but of a simple vernacular-built variety. Comparison of home styles of the era in "A Field Guide To American Houses" (Virginia Savage McAlester, 2013) shows Folk Victorian to be the best style fit, being a one story cross-gabled residential house with tall and narrow 1/1 double hung windows, and remaining door and window trim consistent with Victorian detailing. Windows consist of an assortment of sizes and styles. Only two original Victorian tall and narrow 1/1 double hung windows remain, both on the west fac;ade. These have heavy headers and detailed trim boards. Cut marks in the tongue and groove siding show that many other original windows have been either replaced with simpler windows of different proportions, or converted into a doorway, or completely removed and patched over. All replacement windows are wide, and not as tall as the original Victorian windows.

All doors have been removed and replaced with hollow-core doors, all of which are in bad condition. The original front door location is on the east fac;ade, and is now a "side door". The frame around this original front door location contains the Victorian heavy header and elaborate trim. A new front door was added to the south fac;ade, replacing an original window there. The window next to it was also replaced with a shorter, wider window. So the apparent front door of the house was originally not a door at all. There are two doors into the back of the house, on the north fac;ade. Trim around these doors is simple. One of the door, to the east under a gable, may be in an original location. But the door to the flat-roofed addition would not have been original to the structure.

No use of indigenous materials is evident beyond milled lumber readily available in "civilized" San Diego. Use of cobblestone retaining walls typical in the neighborhood is absent, being either concrete or concrete block at this property.

It is important to note that, when built, the house would be easy to classify as a Folk Victorian. However, as the house sits today with significant footprint, roof, window, door, and trim revisions, it takes a trained eye to determine the stylistic heritage underlying the modifications that overwhelm the structure today. Much of the original fabric of this once Folk Victorian house has been lost.

The Southeastern San Diego Historic Context Statement states that registration requirements for 1868- 1916 residential cottages and bungalows lists the following character defining features:

DPR 523L (Rev. 1/1995}(Word 9/2013} State of California ~ Natural Resources Agency Primary# DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION HRI # Trinomial CONTINUATION SHEET Property Name: 2528 Island Ave., San Diego CA 92113 Page _1_ of __

Gable roof on original house, flat roof on addition. • Wood cladding (shingles or horizontal siding) Wood horizontal shiplap siding • Wood sash windows (double-hung or casement) Wood sash double-hung windows at 2 remaining locations, and at all replacement locations. • Wood door (glazed or paneled) All doors are replacements, and are modern hollow-core or metal clad.

Minimum Integrity Threshold In order to be eligible for listing in the local, state or national historical register, a property of this type and from this period must retain sufficient integrity to convey its significance. The minimum features required to retain integrity are as follows: • Clear example of residential architecture from this period This house was a typical residential structure of its day. • Retains original form and roofline Footprint has been increased by 45% with a large addition topped with a flat roof instead of the gabled roof of the original structure. • Retains most of its original ornamentation, if applicable (The retention of entry, window and/or roofline ornamentation should be considered most important). Original front door retains its original trim. Other doors added over time have different trim, not matching the original trim in style or quality. Only 2 original windows remain. These 2 windows retain their original trim. All other windows, added later, have different trim, not matching the original trim in style or quality. Roofline ornamentation was never present. Front porch handrails and posts have been replaced with modern dimension 4 x 4's and 2 x 2's. • Retains original cladding (no stucco) Original shiplap cladding is present. • Retains original windows and doors (or match in location, pattern, size, and materials) Only 1 door location is original (with modern door installed). Only 2 windows are original. Most windows were replaced with windows of completely different proportions, or removed and covered over entirely. Siding was used to fill in abandoned locations. One window on the front far;ade was converted into, and replaced with, a door. • In historic districts, at least two-thirds of the properties must qualify as contributors in order for the district to retain integrity. 2528 Island Ave does not lie within the Sherman Heights or the Grant Hill Historic Districts.

Additional Integrity Considerations Additional items to consider when evaluating the integrity of a property of this type and from this period include the following: • Stairs & Porches: It is generally acceptable for entry stairs and porch features to have been replaced, as these are subject to greater deterioration from weathering and use. However, replacement porches should substantially conform to the original configuration. Incompatible porch replacement would likely jeopardize a residence's eligibility for listing. All front porch posts, rails, and spindles have been replaced with lumber of modern dimensions and lack all signs of beveled edge craftsmanship. The porch roof was originally wood shingle, but has been changed to 3 tab composition shingle. Porch roof material, concrete floor, post and spindle changes constitute a significant revision of the material, and add up to form an incompatible porch replacement on the primary far;ade facing Island Avenue.

DPR 523L (Rev. 1/1995}(Word 9/2013) State of California ~ Natural Resources Agency Primary# DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION HRI# Trinomial CONTINUATION SHEET Property Name: 2528 Island Ave., San Diego CA 92113 Page _1_ of __

• Additions: Rear additions that have respected the scale of the original building are generally acceptable. However, additions that compromise a building's form and scale are not acceptable. A large addition has been added to the northwest corner, visible from the rear, side, and front Island Avenue point of view. This 252 square foot addition increased the footprint of the house by 45%. The scale of this addition is too large to respect the scale of the original building's form. The flat roof of the addition is not compatible with the gabled roof of the original building, nor is it consistent with the Folk Victorian style. This large addition compromises the building's form and scale, and is not acceptable per the Southeaster San Diego Historic Context Statement.

There is little value remaining for the study of the Folk Victorian style. The property has undergone significant modifications and does not qualify as historic under Criterion C.

Criterion D: Is representative of the notable work of a master builder, designer, architect, engineer, landscape architect, interior designer, artist or craftsman. A resource associated with the work of a master refers to the technical or aesthetic achievements of a builder, designer, architect, engineer, landscape architect, interior designer, artist or craftsman. A master is a figure of generally recognized greatness in a field, a known craftsman of consummate skill, or an anonymous craftsman whose work is distinguishable from others by its characteristic style and quality.

The Historic Research for 2528 Island Ave revealed no record of any architect or any builder associated with the property. The simplicity of the design and detailing suggests a vernacular interpretation of a common Folk Victorian style, and could easily have been constructed without the involvement of any master or less prominent architect. But even if this property could be attributed to a master builder, designer, architect, engineer, landscape architect, interior designer, artist or craftsman, this house has been significantly modified to the extent that it would no longer be representative of a notable work of that master. This property does not qualify under Criterion D.

Criterion E: Is listed or has been determined eligible by the National Park Service for listing on the National Register of Historic Places or is listed or has been determined eligible by the State Historical Preservation Office for listing on the California Register of Historical Resources.

This property is not listed or been determined to be eligible by the National Park Service for listing on the National Register of Historic Places and is not listed or been determined eligible by the State Historical Preservation Office for listing on the California Register of Historical Resources. This property does not qualify under Criterion E.

Criterion F: Is a finite group of resources related to one another in a clearly distinguishable way or is a geographically definable area or neighborhood containing improvements which have a special character, historical interest or aesthetic value or which represent one or more architectural periods or styles in the history and development of the City.

2528 Island Avenue does not fall within any of the nearby historic districts (Grant Hill, Sherman Heights, or Golden Hill Historical Districts. It has not been inventoried and identified as Primary or Contributing to any historic district. Further, the residence is not a finite group of resources related together in a clearly distinguishable way, nor is it related together in a geographically definable area or neighborhood containing improvements which have a special character, historical interest or aesthetic value, nor does it represent one or more architectural periods or styles in the history and development of San Diego. This property does not qualify under Criterion F.

DPR 523L (Rev. 1/1995)(Word 9/2013} State of California ~ Natural Resources Agency Primary# DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION HRI# Trinomial I CONTINUATION SHEET Property Name: 2528 Island Ave., San Diego CA 92113 Page _1_of __

Integrity Evaluation: In addition to determining the significance of a property under local, state and federal criteria, it is necessary to assess whether the property has integrity. Integrity is the ability of a property to convey and maintain its significance. A property must not only be shown to be significant under the established criteria, it must also have integrity. In order to retain historic integrity, a property must possess several, and usually most, of the seven key aspects of integrity, which are location, design, setting, materials, workmanship, feeling and association.

1. Location: Location is the place where the historic property was constructed or the place where the historic event occurred. The subject building remains at its original location at 2528 Island Avenue. It has been raised upon a foundation, but no evidence suggests that the house was moved in any direction at this time. As such, the property retains its location element for integrity purposes,

2. Design: Design is the combination of elements that form plan, space, and style of a property. Substantial alterations have occurred, including an overwhelming addition, removal of windows, replacement of windows with windows of different shape and proportions, conversion of a front fac;:ade window to a door, original panel doors replaced with hollow core doors, bulge-outs, foundation addition, and revision of roof from shingle to composition. As a result the building does not retain its design element for integrity purposes.

3. Setting: Setting is the physical environment of a historic property. When originally subdivided in,1873, the neighborhood was hills, pasture, and orchards. Upon subdivision it became a neighborhood of single family homes on regular size lots. Infill of multi-family homes and schools has occurred, but the immediate vicinity is still largely single family residential. Therefore the property retains its physical environment for integrity purposes.

4. Materials: Materials are the physical elements that were combined or deposited during a particular period of time and in a pattern or configuration to form a historic property. The siding of this house appears to be the original 7" tongue and groove wood siding, and was also used on additions and for window infill, suggesting a long term of availability. The original roof was shingle (per 1920 Sanborn Map), but this had been replaced by 1921 with a composition roof. One could consider this a good revision for reasons of durability and fire resistance, but nonetheless it was a significant revision. When the house was raised for a concrete block foundation addition, the front porch floor became concrete, replacing a likely (rotted?) original wood floor. Revisions use materials suited to their time, but were in fact a revision of the original materials. Therefore the property does not retain the Materials element of integrity.

5. Workmanship: Workmanship is the physical evidence of the crafts of a particular culture or people during any given period in history or prehistory. Workmanship on the original structure is good, with beveled porch posts, ornate moldings on door and window headers, and vertical trim pieces containing elaborate "notchings". However, few of these examples remain since window modification or fill-in. Replacement windows and doors have much simpler trim, not displaying the workmanship present during initial construction in 1903104.

DPR 523L (Rev. 1/1995}(Word 9/2013} State of California t> Natural Resources Agency Primary# DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION HRI# Trinomial CONTINUATION SHEET Property Name: 2528 Island Ave., San Diego CA 92111 Page _1_of __

Newer porch posts are of modern 3 ½ x 3 ½ dimensions, and have no beveled edges typical of the workmanship of the original porch posts. All revisions appear to be of a "lowest cost" type, lacking the workmanship evident in the original construction. As a result, the property does not retain the Workmanship element of integrity.

6. Feeling: Feeling is a property's expression of the aesthetic or historic sense of a particular period of time. Significant modifications to footprint, materials, and important door and windows leave the observer with a different impression than one would have gained after original construction. Besides the issues of condition, the house would have originally have conveyed a feeling of graceful success, showing affordable Victorian style adapted for the new middle class. But with modifications and deterioration there is no sense of middle class pride remaining, and the feeling conveyed is now one of "it's just a run-down old house". Therefore the property does not retain the Feeling element of integrity.

7. Association: Association is the link between an important historic event or person and a historic property. The property has not been determined to be directly linked to an important historic event or person regarding local, State, or National history. Therefore the property does not retain an Association element for integrity because it never had one.

B12. References:

City of San Diego, Building Permit files at Development Services Department, 1222 1st Ave.

City of San Diego Public Utilities Department, GIS Section Chollas Facility

San Diego County Assessor's Office records for parcel map, original subdivision map, Lot Block book page, and Residential Building Record.

San Diego Central Library

San Diego Public Library online electronic collections for Sanborn Maps

San Diego Central Library 9th floor special collections for Sanborn Maps

Phone Directories of San Diego Central Library 9th floor special collections

San Diego History Center, Balboa Park, for historic photos

Steve Nurding for contemporary photos

Google.com

Paula Development, Inc. for site plan

A Field Guide to American Houses, Virginia & Lee McAlester

California Design 1910, Anderson, Moore, Winter 197 4

San Diego Union Tribune

USGS for maps

Fidelity Title for Chain of Title and Deeds

Ancestry.com

Southeastern San Diego Historic Context Statement, Page & Turnbull 2014

City of San Diego Historical Resources Board, Guideline for the Application of Historical Resources Board Designation Criteria Land Development Manual Appendix E, Part 2.

DPR 523L (Rev. 1/1995)(Word 9/2013) Attachment A Building Development Information

A.1 - Assessor's Building Record A.2 - Notice of Completion A.3 - Water/Sewer Records A.4 - Building/Construction Permits A.5 - Site Plan with Footprint Showing Additions A.6 - County Lot and Block Book Page A.7 - Previous Survey Forms Attachment A.1 - Assessor's Building Record

The following 3 pages from the San Diego County records show the Residential Building Record for 2528 Island Ave.

Summary: This "Residential Building Record" was first produced in 1961, and states that in 1904 two buildings were constructed on the lot. This differs from the County Lot and Block Book Page that indicates construction in 1903. Field measurements by the Assessor show that the 252 square foot flat roof addition was in place by 1961, but gives no date as to when it was constructed.

Conclusion: The initial home construction (2528 and 2528 ½?) is the year 1903 per County Lot and Block Book Pages, but is the year 1904 per County Residential Building Record. No major changes in footprint have occurred since 1961. ;r:~~~;:~,:·,co.:i;~;;o;-;;..-- R~SIDE f/TIAL BUILDING RECORD SHEET...,! __ OF....__ __ SHEETS PARCEL 1 f" - 1-, .i;; !:e ... · :~;rc' ,: . 5-. · .. ,.: ·· · ,· ·. · . . ADOR(SS '"' tr• .;S:._3 S--~,7.,2-.2~- ...... DESCRIPTION OF BUILDING $T.IIUt:TION ·STRUCTURAL EXTERIOR ROOII AND FINISH D£TAlt.. /Ji bf . Fra-. St11eco OIi OftlS FLOORS LOOR FINISH TRIii INTERIOR FINISH B I Z Maltrlaf Grad• Wof/$ All' )( Of A

a,Jc* Shi11 le Shalt, Floor Jo,'$1, saa. 7.46. 1n, .. JI' ,_~ 'l. aricll r. JI /Jricll ,,ood S11... Flt,0r s,.,,. Jltou Oll8urner Piv-s Cone,.,. hoar WINDOWS Tilt Lo,1ndry M-6.T. I/..

Dr11in 8d. Mole rial: BATH DETAIL

" For

Sl'ECIAL. FEATURES /Ju,/J ,,, Re,r-1q. V..nelion tJ/indz

Appraiser a Unit -·__,· . . ~ .. I MISCELLANEOflS.· ~RIJCTURES ' I ,_ _, .. ,.- ,:-.. I, "' ... Structur• Cons. E1t t. Roof Floor Int Sin.etc. I -· .. : l ; I . .· - :

' I I '

n;::;,r-.,,,.,; . COMPUTATIONS P~. l3~ ./ z. K:LZ. -= ~£:..Z::.. E.~ ~-- io ,.Fi z ZXZ.f,( - 6¥? -/-.t.,IC!,s_,c;J,,o 2.: +al!_ ,, L-!L. t1 - !:Z. ~8: 8 7/4 ' - .

,, - ..

Rernarhlj} o td .... II} ) I -' 1:. d',,iid!:~.d '3:t: <~c.olr-a, ' ~·.!d:t: l ~~ ; r ~ ,~ A .,. lu,. s,.. "r/.J.-. ·6YO~- f ,<><; .J.,,, /,.,a er /...,,. .. 'f v~,, J., .J_" r,-, 1f ,.,-:,.~.., {jJ a. A c'",-• • A ',~r f. \ t/ /, '.) /,1,,. IJ~M-- . '- ,., ,.J - .• I I • ...,.,, £.C -A ,. tcJ,..J -4 ~ ~ 1.-· I•"\ /"t'-~4- t , ;n_~e:J -..., ,, (J ..

• '

,.-: " ,~ ·' l,o ,, '" ., "· ., l ·.,. .: , ,,. ' -· .· :;," ~ I ·. .,,.,,, ,. " -~ .,:; .,,, .. :r. ~ I "' - - l~\.CLLl'IITCVO-....,. n"'-, ""'"' ·- found - Structur• Con£ ext. Roof Floor Int Sin1 etc.-~

2 ~ --- ...... COMPUTATIONS ,... = ·' ...

1, Remarks.: -- . .. Attachment A.2 - Notice of Completion

No Notice of Completion could be found at either the San Diego County records office or the San Diego City Hall Operations records Attachment A.3 - Water/Sewer Records

City of San Diego Public Utilities Department, GIS Section Chollas Facility was contacted to obtain water and sewer records for 2528 Island Ave. These records show that sewer service was connected in 1921, and a new replacement water service was connected in 1953. Both of these hookups were many years after construction. ..

0 ERA ING CO NECTION 0

ill ma

t abo 1 locaiion~-Pa

mar ► •

1.i 0~ U ______.... MA ERf L

._ ... _....

...... ~.,....- Chy of S■ n Diego, Calrfatni1 WAlER DEPARTMENT ~.tY • WOJtK ASSIGNMfNT ORDER NO. INriTAl l SER\llCe AND l~ANSl'E MET REN~~•~ $£RVICE □ GATE li'AlVE MAIN □ Fli!e t-lYDRJ\~T MAINTEN □ if-r,JI\NCE □ ANCE □ OJttER ------i

ISSUED ,U51GNE-C

10, Lac:a, 1tm ·Approvll!I (Slgnature-Pro?t>rty wne• Attachment A.4 - Building/Construction Permits

City of San Diego Operations Building at 1222 1st Ave was visited to obtain building and construction permit records for 2528 Island Ave, No building permits were available at the San Diego County records department.

Only some minor electrical and water heater permits were on record. Most records before 1955 were destroyed by fire.

The following pages contain these permits:

Conclusion: No major footprint additions to the building have happened since before 1930. Window and door modifications are undocumented and could have happened at any time or times.

Attachment A.5 - Site Plan with Footprint Showing Additions

The following sheets shows the Site Plan with Footprint, showing additions.

Conclusion:

When initially built the building footprint was 624 square feet. But an aerial photograph shows that a 252 square foot flat roof addition was in place by 1930. At some point two more bulge-outs were added (also undocumented) that added an additional 26 square feet. Current square footage footprint of habitable space is 902 square feet, representing a 45% footprint increase over original 1903/1904 construction. _L_ ------·

ALLEY EL. 133))0' EL 125.00' •

TY Ll~E 62.5'

L _

2!1-0'

EXISTING BUILDING

I ,

DIRT ij i!,

OIRT .!1 IiI!/ I OIRT ~ I __ _J I ------+ -- '------· 01RT ------.I - ----,, ------

EXISTING SlOEl\'AUI rn

- - --<-(i------1 AVE -- - (i Nll!l'S1'19'Vl(BASISOFBEAR!N SJ ·, - - - - - 5 SQ. FT. ADDITION

21 SQ. FT. ADDITION

ORIGINAL FOOTPRINT: 624 SQ. FT.

ORIGINAL FOOTPRINT·. OR,G\N L 624 SQ. FT. FRONT DOOR ADDITIONS: 278 SQ. FT.

CURRENT FOOTPRINT: ADDED 902 SQ. FT. FRONT N DOOR 902 I 624 = 1 .45 FOOTPRINT HAS INCREASED BY 45% COVERED PORCH

2528 ISLAND AVE. BUILDING FOOTPRINT CHANGES Attachment A.6 - County Lot and Block Book Pages

The following 3 pages from the San Diego County records show the available County Lot and Block Book Pages for L.W Kim balls Addition, map page 56, block 22, lots 33, 34, and west half of 35.

Summary: 1896 - 1899 show W. L Tibbals as the owner, matching the Chain of Title records. Values to the land are recorded, but "Improvements to Houses, Barns, etc." show zero during 1896 to 1899. The lot was empty of houses at this time.

1903 - 1907 show a progression of owners, from Tibbals to Field to Shoudel, matching the Chain of Title records. 1903 shows a $120 value of "Houses, Barns, etc." 1904, 1905, 1906, 1907 show no further construction value. Conclusion: A house or houses were constructed in 1903,

1915 - 1919 shows ownership by the Thorpes, matching Chain of Title records. 1915 shows a continued value of "Houses, Barns, etc," at $120. No new construction is therefore apparent since 1903, and 1916 through 1919 shows no additional construction.

Conclusion: The initial home construction (2528 and 2528 ½?) is the year 1903 per County Lot and Block Book Pages, but is the year 1904 per County Residential Building Record. • 0 Index to Property in • 0 1!.. W. KlMBALl..'S AOO. Addition : . fBq'7-1g9q • T?wnship South, Range See Map Book No. Page :t- nm:m=o-:rntOFRECDICI I ,,....,,.. ... """""""''" - ~ Dlt ~ J 1 · I

•, ·-

-~ -~~.~~1- d'b~/rl#. ~ ,,

.-- t Id,.,: ,'."- li;0

-l Addition. Index to Property in San Diei,i Ct;unty, California: See liap Boak No. .Page No.,

m...1 'JJ,., G. t.tZ:. · .,!,.t,,A JJ,,.. a.. 13_ i I t- -· fT·--· L,;,.~~-- ,I

•r - -~·- • ; 0'.,;.._::l,; , • •_ - ;,J..(..2,:2.. H,•J -e7.,,- !-"7.20.. h;;:---::!'---'li':-;7,::-'fil=~".-'""c:...!..~:,_.:f.IJl!!YL.:a!!L§!::!c,______"111,r,..l:._:~z.....jL'e...J~&J~-----l-..c...'.:______-"' ii;,2-,· ?ri~ r:: S~ Diego County, California.

TSE LAST X.-\.i"\lE: Gl.V:ENJS nm·oNE TO \\'l:IOM PROP.ER.TY IS ASSESSED. THE I..."\ST V.~ GIVEN IS TEE ASSESSED if.::...IZE FOR THE Plls:Ei\T i"E..ut..

I, Attachment A.7 - Previous Survey Forms

There were no Previous Survey Forms discovered. Attachment B Ownership and Occupant Inforn1ation

8.1 - Chain of Title 8.2 - Directory Search of Occupants 8.3 - Deed from the Date of Construction Attachment B.1 - Chain of Title

The following shows the Chain of Title.

Summary: This "Chain of Title" shows a clear progression of owners from before construction in 1903/04 up until current ownership. Chain of Title was identified by examination of all deeds, and no gaps in ownership were found.

Conclusion: The Chain of Title· is accurate.

1903 William L & Lidia E Tibbals 1904 Tibbals sold to Ralph Elliot & Marguerite Field 1905 Field sold to Abertina Shoudel 1915 Shoudel sold to Beade R. & Lizzie Thorp 1938 Beade R. & Lizzie Thorp grants to Howard C. Thorp 1942 Thorp sold to Abelino Fernandez 1963 Abelino Fernandez grants to Juanita Petra Fernandez 1968 Juanita Petra Fernandez adds Cruz Fernandez 2000 Cruz Fernandez sold to Francisco Banuelos 2009 Francisco Banuelos adds Antonia Zesate 2018 Banuelos sold to Paula Development, Inc. (current owner) Attachment B.2 - Directory Search of Occupants

The following shows the Chain of Occupancy.

Summary: This Chain of Occupancy shows the occupants from before construction in 1903/04 up until current ownership. Directory of Search Occupants was identified by examination telephone directories at the San Diego Library 9th Floor San Diego History Collection and from internet phone directory records of the San Diego library.

Conclusion: The Chain of Occupancy is accurate.

2528 Island Ave 2528 1/2 Island Ave Year Occupants per Phone Directories Occupants (rear home, demolished) 1903 1904 1905 1906 1907 1908 1909 1910 1911 1912 1913 1914 Thorp, Stephen R (Helen) 1915 Thorp Rowland C (laborer) Thorp, Stephen R (Helen) 1916 Thorp Rowland C (Marine)& Vernah Thorp, Stephen R (Helen) 1917 Thorp Rowland C (Sailor)& Vernah Thorp, Stephen R (Helen) 1918 1919 1920 1921 1922 1923 1924 1925 1926 Kissinger, Thos & Angelina 1927 Schumacher Fred W & Maude Stork Minnie Mrs, Thorp Helen Mrs 1928 Warburton CD Stork Minnie Mrs, Thorp Helen Mrs 1929 Warburton CD, Warburton LS Starke Minnie Mrs, Thorps Helen Mrs 1930 Jeffries CB Starke Minnie Mrs, Thorps Helen Mrs 1931 McNea Leslie Stark Minnie Mrs 1932 McNea Leslie & Mabel (Chauf) Thorp Helen Mrs 1933 McNea LA Thorp Helen Mrs 1934 Kohler Jacob Thorp Helen Mrs 1935 Lewis JG Vacant 1936 Lewis JG Thorpe Helen Mrs 1937 Lewis JG Thorpe Helen Mrs 1938 Bigbie AL Thorpe Helen Mrs 1939 Bigbie AL Cheeney Jack 1940 Jacobs WE Vacant 1941 Jacobs PF Mrs Vacant 1942 Jacobs PF Mrs Connett WW 1943 No phone book No phone book 1944 Fernandez Avelino 1945 No phone book No phone book 1946 No phone book No phone book 1947 Fernandez Avelino 1948 No phone book No phone book 1949 No phone book No phone book 1950 Fernandez Avelino Fernandeg Tomasita 1951 No phone book No phone book 1952 Fernandez Avelino Florez Rita R, F 1953 Fernandez Avelino Vacant 1954 No phone book No phone book 1955 Fernandez Avelino Vacant 1956 Fernandez Avelino Vacant 1957 Fernandez Avelino Vacant 1958 No phone book No phone book 1959 No phone book No phone book 1960 Fernandez Avelino Vacant 1961 Fernandez Avelino Vacant 1962 Fernandez Avelino Vacant 1963 Fernandez Juanita 1964 No phone book No phone book 1965 No phone book No phone book 1966 Fernandez Juanita Demolished? No further mention 1967 Fernandez Juanita 1968 Fernandez Juanita 1969 Fernandez Juanita 1970 No phone book 1971 Fernandez Cruz 1972 Fernandez Cruz 1973 Fernandez Cruz 1974 Fernandez Cruz 1975 Fernandez Cruz 1976 Fernandez Cruz 1977 No phone book 1978 Fernandez Cruz 1979 Fernandez Cruz 1980 Fernandez Cruz 1981 No phone book 1982 xxxx 1983 xxxx 1984 xxxx 1985 xxxx 1986 xxxx 1987 xxxx 1988 xxxx 1989 xxxx 1990 xxxx 1991 No phone book 1992 xxxx 1993 xxxx 1994 xxxx 1995 xxxx 1996 xxxx 1997 Fernandez Juanita P 1998 Fernandez Juanita P 1999 2528 Not listed 2000 No phone book 2001 Fernandez Juanita 2002 Banuelos Francisco 2003 Banuelos Francisco 2004 Banuelos Francisco 2005 Banuelos Francisco 2006 Banuelos Francisco 2007 Banuelos Francisco 2008 Banuelos Francisco 2009 No phone book 2010 Banuelos Francisco 2011 No phone book 2012 Banuelos Francisco 2013 No phone book 2014 Banuelos Francisco, Zesati Antonia 2015 Banuelos Francisco, Zesati Antonia 2016 Banuelos Francisco, Zesati Antonia 2017 Banuelos Francisco, Zesati Antonia 2018 Banuelos Francisco, Zesati Antonia 2019 Vacant Attachment 8.3 - Deeds from Date of Construction

The following pages are the Deeds from the Date of Construction, 1903.

Summary: The Deeds were used to develop the Chain of Title. There are no gaps in the Deeds.

Conclusion: The Deeds from the Date of Construction is complete. RECORDING REQUESTED BY: DOC# 2018-0257740 Corinthian Title 111111111111 lllll 111111111111111 lllll lllll lllll lllll lllll lllll llll llll ANO WHEN RECORDED MAIL TO: Jun 25, 2018. 04:32 PM OFFICIAL RECORDS 1206 10th Street Ernest J. Dronen burg, Jr., SAN DIEGO COUNTY RECORDER Coronado, CA 92118 FEES: $692.50 (SB2 Atkins: $0.00) PCOR: YES PAGES:2

THIS SPACE FOR RECORDER'S USE ONLY: Title Order No.: 97865-PD Escrow No.: 001515-TH AP#: 535-272-26-00 GRANT DEED . . THE UNDERSIGNED GRANTOR(S) DECLARE(S) DOCUMENTARY TRANSFER TAX is $665.50 [X] comput~d on full value of property conveyed, or [ ] computed ori full value less value of liens or encumbrances remaining at time of sale. [X] Unincorporated area [ I City of AND FOR A VALUABLE CONSIDERATION, receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, Francisco Banuelos and Antonia Zesati Banuel0s, who acquired title as Antonia Zesate Banuelos, Husband and Wife as Joint Tenants ··

hereby GRANT(s) to: Paula Development, Inc., a California Corporation

the real property in the County of San Diego, State of California, described as: LEGA~ -DESCRIPTION ATTACHED HERETO AS .EXHIBIT "A" AND MADE A PART HEREOF Also Known as: 2528 W. Island Avenue, San Diego, CA 92102

Dated June 21, 2018 ~a1cls:t:r> Ba&°u e /~J' Francisco Banuelos Ao'!on,~ -Z.e.$0.\i Bo.'C\"'-e.\os Antonia Zesati Banuelos

A notary public or other officer completing this certificate verifies only the Identity of the individual who signed the document to which this certificate is attached, and not the truthfulness, accurac , or validit of that document.

STATE OF C.,l,IFORNIA COUNTY OF ~V'\ o,~o On~N -Z.,\ LO\~ before me, M\'®e\k ½1i"'l\. ±y)~l°t_\D A Notary Public personally appeared~QCiSco ~~..,u~\05 ~tli""- 2.-t'ti~"'" '\og.v'lcJe.\05 who proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence to be the person(s) whose name(s) is/are subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged ·tome that he/she/they executed the same in his/her/their authorized capacity(ies), and that by his/her/their signature(s) on the instrument the person(s), or the entity upon behalf of which the person(s) acted, executed the instrument. I certify under PENALTY OF PERJURY under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing paragraph Is true and correct. WITNESS my hand and official seal.

s;gnatu¥jY\ ltkJ&.~QL'.'. (Seal) •••••••••••• i MAIL TAX STATEMENTS TO PARTY SHOWN BELOW; . MICHELLE LYNN AGUAYO Notary Publfc - California IF NO PARTY SHOWN, MAIL AS SHOWN ABOVE: J.@,· ,,.· z "' • ~; oi' San Diego Coonty ~ 11 . . • Comml55lon # 2201557 My Comm. ExplresJun 17,2021

Order: QuickView_ Page 1 of 2 Requested By: , Printed: 10/28/2019 12:33 PM Doc: 2018-257740 EXHIBIT A LEGAL DESCRIPTION

The land referred to heretn below Is situated in the County of SAN DIEGOJ State of CALIFORNIAJ and Is described as follows:

LOTS 33, 34 AND THE WEST HALF OF LOT 35, IN BLOCK 22, OF L.W. KIMBALL'S SUBDIVISION OF THE NORTHWEST QUARTER OF PUEBLO LOT 1154, IN THE CITY OF SAN DIEGO, COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO, STATE OF CALIFORNIA, ACCORDING TO THE MAP THEREOF NO. 56, FILED IN THE OFFICE OF THE RECORDER OF SAID SAN DIEGO COUNTY, MARCH 31, 1873,

Assessor's Parcel Number: 535-272-26-00

Order: QuickVlew_ Page 2 of2 Requested By: , Printed: 10/28/2019 12:33 PM Doc: 2018-257740 DOC tt 201 0~027 4050 I 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 IIIII 111111111111111111 JUN 02, 2010 8:00 AM OFFICIAL RECORDS Recording requested by: \_ SY SAN DIEGO COUNTY RECORDER'S OFFICE t DAVID L. BUTLER , COUNTY RECORDER And when recorded, mail FEES : 22.00 OC: DC this deed and tax statements to: PAGES: 2 Francisco Banuelos 863 Antonia Zesate Banuelos 2528 West Island Avenue 1111111 lllll 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 San Diego, CA, 92102

(X) This transfer is exempt from the documentary transfer tax. □ The documentary transfer tax is$ 0.00 and is computed on: GRANT DEED □ the full value of the interest or property conveyed. Order No. 8462313 □ the full value less the liens or encumbrances remaining thereon at the time of sale, APN; 5352722600 The property is located in ~ □ An unincorporated area □ The city of San Diego ~

For a valuable consideration, receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, Francisco Banuelos, a married man as bis sole and separate property hereby grant(s) to Frandsto Banuelos and Antonia Zesate Banuelos, husband and wife as joint tenants the following real property in the City of San Diego, County of San Diego, State of California and described as follows See Exhibit A legal description attached hereto and made a part hereof: Recording Requested By: Commonly known as: 2528 West Island Avenue San Diego, CA, 92102 LSI

Date: April 16, 2010

State of California .... County of S:l.l"'\ CA ~~O

On ~ 20 , 20 \0, before me, Pw,,+a ?Gt.~ $'.'Mdlo 1 ~1~personally appeared Franclscoanuelos, who proved to me on the basis of sathlry evidence to~ e'person(s) whose name(s) is/are subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that he/she/they executed the same in his/her/their authorized capacity(ies), and that by his/her/their signature(s) on the instrument the person(s), or the entity upon behalf of which the person(s) acted, executed the instrument. I certify under PENAL TY OF PERJURY under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing paragraph is true and correct.

WITNESS my hand and official seal.

Sigbature~AA~~S;,Q ofN~ _.

Order: QuickView_ Page 1 of 2 Requested By : , Printed: 10/28/2019 12:34 PM Doc: 2010-274050 ORDER N0:8462313 .. • , . 8G4

LEGAL DESCRIPTION

Exhibit A

The following described property:

Lots 33, 34 and the West half of Lot 35, in Block 22, of L. w. Kimball's Subdivision of the Northwest Quarter of Pueblo Lot 1154, In the City of San Diego, County of San Diego, State of California, according to the Map thereof No, 56, flied in the Office of the Recorder of said San Diego County, March 31, 1983,

Being the same parcel conveyed to Francisco Banuelos, a married man as sole and separate property from Juanita Petra Fernandez, an unmarried woman, by virtue of a Deed dated 12/15/1999, recorded 1/21/2000, as Instrument No, 2000·0033646, County of San Diego, State of California.

Assessor's Parcel No: 5352722600

Order: QuickView_ Page 2 of 2 Requested By: , Printed: 10/28/2019 12:34 PM Doc: 2010-274050 , ' . . •,,,.----:--···------. ~~ ,. . 1ecordi.ng requested by First American Title av: 77.93 DOC# 2000-0033646 Jan 21~ 2000 4:55 PM Escrow No. 1328MV Title Order No. OFFICIAL RECORDS When Recorded Mail Document SAN DIEGO COUNTY RECORDER'S OFFICE and Tax Statement To: GREGORY J. SMITH, COUNTY RECORDER Mr. Francisco Banuelos FEES: 146.50 2528 Island Avenue OC : OC San Diego, CA 92102 ,-IDIWll 11~ II Ill ~n r 2000-0033646 I APN: 535-272-26-00 SPACE ABOVE THIS LINE FOR RECORDER'S USE GRANT DEED tn 0\Y . fry The undersigned grantor(s) declare(s) /\\ Documentary transfer tax is $ 126.50 \\ [ X ] computed on full value of property conveyed, or [ J computed on full value less value of liens or encumbrances remaining at time of sale, [ ] Unincorporated Area City of San Diego FOR A VALUABLE CONSIDERATION, receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, Juanita Petra Fernandez, An Unmarried Woman

hereby GRANT($) to Francisco Banuelos, A Married Man as Sole and Separate Property

the following described real property in the City of San Diego County of San Diego, State of California:

As more particularly described on Exhibit "A" attached hereto and made a part hereof.

DATED: December 15, 1999

STATE OF CALIFORNI COUNTY OF-.---"'~:.!..",,~~~.,______0

....p.ersonally kno'J'JA to ~(o, proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence) to be the person(s) whose name(s) is/are subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that he~they executed the same i~~~heir authorized capacitv(ies), and that by his~their signature(s) on the instrument the person(s), or the entity upon behalf of which the person(s) acted, executed the instrument.

MAIL TAX STATEMENTS AS DIRECTED ABOVE

FD-21 :3 (Rev 9/94) GRANT DEED

Order: QuickView_ Page 1 of 2 Requested By: , Printed: 10/28/2019 12:34 PM Doc: 2000-33646 ORDER NO. 1233076~4

LEGAL DESCRIPTION

THE LAND REFERRED TO HEREIN IS SITUATED IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO, AND IS DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS:

NOVEMBER 18, 1999 4:32 PM MB PAGES

Order: QuickVlew_ Page 2 of 2 Requested By: , Printed: 10/28/2019 12:34 PM Doc: 2000-33646 ------R~cording requested by First American Title RECORDING REQUESTt.u DT; BOC# 2000-0033645 Netwotk Escrow Services . ?791 ~ Jan 21~ ?000 4:55 PM Title Order No. When Recorded Mail Document To: OFFICIAL RECORDS Francisco Banuelos SAN DIEGO COUNTY RECORDER'S OFFICE 2528 Island Avenue GREGORY J. SMITH, COUNTY RECORDER San Diego, CA 92102 FEES: 20,00 --,m m1i 11~H 1rn~m1~ OC: NA 2000-0033645

I SPACE ABOVE THIS LINE FOR RECORDER'S USE / APN: 535-272-26-00 \~ 1)/< INTERSPOUSAL TRANSFER DEED p (Excluded fr~m reapprai~al under California Constitution Article 13 A Section 1 et seq.) ~ Documentary transfer tax 1s $ 0.00 City tax $ 0.00 - is exempt from imposition of the Documentary Transfer Tax pursuant to Revenue and Taxation Code 11927(a), on transferring community, quasi-community, or quasi-marital property, assets between spouses,puruant to a judgement, an order, or a written agreement between spouses in contemplation of any such judgement or order.

This is an lnterspousal Transfer and not a change in ownership under Section 63 of the Revenue and Taxation Code and Grantor(s) has (have) checked the applicable exclusion from reappraisal: A creation, transfer, or termination, solely between spouses, of any co-owner's interest.

FOR A VALUABLE CONSIDERATION, receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, Antonia Zesati Banuel'os hereby GRANT(S) to Francisco Banuelos ll ~i,~ l'1.CU1 fJA kJt ~ ~ ~ the real property in the City of San Diego, ~ · County of San Diego, State of Californi1:i': , SEE EXHIBIT "ONE" ATTACHED HERETO AND MADE A PART HEREOF

DATED: December 8, 1999

s Antonia Zesati Banuelos

~~...:::~.=:.=;...,:..._~_J_._..L....t.,__,___ before me, ersonally appeared · 1),10,., e1::>a· , OMe I o'S-'

personally known to me (or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence) to be the person(s) whose name(s) is/are subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that he/she/they executed the same in his/her/their authorized capacity(ies), and that by his/her /their signature(s) on the instrument the person(s), or the entity upon behalf of which the person(s) acted, executed the instrument.

Witness my h~~

Signature-~----~------+------

MAIL TAX STATEMENT AS DIRECTED ABOVE

UD-13C (Rev 12/95) INTERSPOUSAL TRANSFER DEED

Order: QuickView_ Page 1 of 2 Requested By : , Printed: 10/28/2019 12:34 PM Doc: 2000-33645 ORDER NO. 1233076~4

LEGAL DESCRIPTION

THE LAND REFERRED TO HEREIN IS SITUATED IN THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF SAN DIEGO, AND IS DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS:

NOVE:MBER 18, 19994:32 PM MB PAGES

Order: QuickView_ Page 2 of 2 Requested By: , Printed: 10/28/2019 12:34 PM Doc: 2000-33645 ·". 88 187628 I': ,:; ,: AND WMIN ...COAOID MAIL ?.-ale o••D AMO UNL.1 ■• OTHlfl w1•1 •HOWN IILOW. MAU. •fAJI .,"t1MINTI --ro G' f 1::lt,!. I ·-•.- 7 I • ''1 1: ' . ' N••• lcRUZ FERNANDEZ 7 °?r:--~·-- AoD•r ■■ 2528 Islal"ld Avenue AR I c~~:,: S11n Diego, CA 92102 • : ·, :, I MG I •, ' : I ' J•• L _J UF --~- · '·· _oc '? . ➔ Ti1lo Or,ltr :-,;,, , TXPO ------'--- ■ P'AC.E ABOVI THIii LINI P'OII IIICOll0111' ■ U ■ I TAX ROLL PARCEL N01 535-272-26 Quitclaim Deed I AFNF I

Tho undert1gn1ddecl1rt1 lhallhodocumonta,y lranafor lu IS$ -o- Interfami ly transfer and 11 :J compulod on lht full valutof tt,11n11re"'I or pr<,perty conv ■ y•d. or 11 .. l corTipuled on 11"11 lull value 1e•1 th1 v11u1 ot liens or 1ncumbr1ncH remn1n1n; 1:11110n al lhtllrnt ot 1at1 Thi land. t1n•m1n11 or really ,11ocated ,n :·1 un,nco,·porarodaru XX crryol San Diego

FOR A VALUABLE CONSIDEFIATION , re r. 01p1 at which II ho,oby acknowledged. JWANITA P&TM FERNANDEZ, an unmarried woman

dOti;) a , httrlby 11m11• , ,.,• .,, ind to11v11 Qu1lcla1m 10 JUANJTA PETRA FERNANDEZ, an unmarried woman, and CRUZ FERNANDEZ, an unmarried man, in joint tenancy

th1lollow1ngdesc11bodrHlproper1y,nlht City of San Dit"gO counlyol S.in Diego stale ol C111f0,n10 Lots JJ, 34 and the West Half of Lot JS, in Block 22 of L.W. iimball's Subdivision of the Northwest Quarter of Pueble Lot 1154, in the City of San Diego, County of San Diego, State of California, accordinq to the Map thereof No, 56, filed in the office of the Recorder of said San Diego County, March 31, 1983. Grantors declare that this conveyance is freely and fairly made, grantors having sold said land to gnntee for a conaidera tion equal to the fair value of grantorff' interest in said land1 and grantors further declare that there are no a~rccments, oral or written, other than this deod botwocn granter~ and grantees with respect to said land,

Oared January 29, 1986

STATE OF CALIFORNIA

COUNTY OF San Diego Onrh,srne i 9th davor JanuaLY 198 8. :.,10111N lllo unde1s,gnod. • Nol•!'(_Pub"< 1n •nd lot $aid Count'/ /o.'>Purea JUAtHTA PETRA FERNANDEZ ,o" NOTA"'f SIAL OR STAMI'

, pe,wnaUy 11,no,...,n to mo

f)f p,~od lo n\\l 0f1 the t:-111s ol HIIIIKlory crwidenu lo be lhl person whQslt n~ I'S tub~ub!KJ lo lhe v.11t11n ins1,umen1 and acknowt&dged 1ha1 She ,uecultd the HrM · ;\ / ,.,

IAAIL TAX STATEMENTS TO PART WN ON FOLLOWIN/l LINE , IF NO PART'!' SO SHOWN . MAIL AS DIRECTED ABOVE

Strael Adr1,e1 ■ c,ry a Star ■ II 11l, I )'I"' or lnr~or ~~'\~N~~~"'\\\\\\\\~/.1.IIIIF~\\\\\\\..~/A\\.\.~ffeA\\.\'\\~m'&'u~ 'RECORDING JiEQUESTED BY --tg A ~28 1 ,., ~ ~ FILE/ PAGE UO; .1. ~1...,. , f , ;i ~ ~ _, /RECORDED R.EQJJJST.Jlf. , , fa ,,; 00 /-Y /Vl,._1 /J, 1,,,,d,,c_c ~ ~ r J;::;;:N ;:::; ;:;~:ndezl Ocr I?11 29 AM'~ . ~ 3 ~ :::Addrcu 2528 Island Ave. _.5gf~Al&f/[ok5i ~ is: ~lrto &: SAN DJ.Etrt.tl//}11) Y, CALIF. ~ ~ L San Diego' Calif. . _J ,.A · s. 011(<)',~.l:CORO,ER $2.00 ff§

~ ------SPACE ABOVE THIS LINE FOR RECORDER'S USE---- ~ ~ ~ ~ QUITCLAIM DEED ~ ~ ~ ~ ~- ; fORA VAWABLE CONSIDERATION, ""'" ol ,o;~ ;, h•,eby ,.,,.,1,a,,a Tomasi ta Or ttz , Angelina C as tro •~ ~ Caroline Shields, Alfred Fernandez, Rudy Fernandez, do ltcroby ~

~ REMJSE, RELEASE ANO FOREVER QUITCLAIM to Juanita Petra Fernandez , an unmarried ~ woman, ~ > ~ ~ ~ the real property in the ci· ty of San Diego County of San Diego ;?. ~ State of California, described as: ~ ~ Lots 33, 34 and the West Half of Lot 35, in Block 22 of § ~ L. W. Kimball's Subdivision of the Northwest Quarter of Pueblo ~ ~ L,Jt 1154 1 in the City of San Diego County of San Diego State of § §: California, according to the Map t~ereof No. 56, filed in the office ~ ~ of the Recorder of said San Diego County, March 31, 1873. ~ ~ Grantors declare that this conveyance is freely and fairly ~ ~ made, grantors having sold said land to grantee for a consideration ~ ~ equal to the fair value of grantors 1 interest in said land; and ~ ~ grantors further declare that there are no agreements, oral or ~ ~ written, other than this deed between grantors and grantees with J ~ respect to said land,. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ \~~~ I 0/J,~t , / ~ ----'='-=~-=-.,~~----- omasta rttz ~ 'Dated August 2. 1963 ~ I =E~L i ~ Stale of California, l · ~ ?~-~ County~ San Diego f ss ~ • tobe:~o,1963 ~ ~ On 11 n:;J' , before me, I he undersigned, a Notary Public in and for said County and Stale, ~ ~ pcrsonally.agpe;ircd. Tomasi ta Ortez. Angelina Castro. Caroline Shields. ~ ~ Altred Fernandez I Rudy Fernandez ____ ~ ~ ' ~ ~ known '4lffltlli,b42~e person.s... whose name s s11bscribed_lo the wilhin lnslrument and acknowledged thaL they § ~ exe,~~qlhe '. sa'l)l,o..:~11 ~ ~ ~11n·~s ~*hand _,pt'.'o.iucl,il_seal . ~ ,e /2 ~ ~ ... · ':.· -~_;) ·' ; ~ : (Sea· • ~ g:r;;,:i::;./ ~ ~~ ~ ...... :. :·•.. .. '/5 : ~B.7sANTOS ~ 1• . " • • •• ,.., . ~ ------~ ~"1 ••• •••• : : u •• ••• NAME (TYPED OR PRINTED) ~ ,.. ·. 11 'l-"' ..,-:~ ~ 11 o, ell -~ ,,,, • My Commission Expires July , Notary Public In and for uld Collnty 1n1I stat,. ~ 000 11 22 1964 r 11 1 ~ Title Order·• · 1111«NO •" • • ' Escrow or Loan No______~~-~ ~~\~ai\.~~\\.~/!\\\\\\~~\\\\\\\~/./'J'l/1~\\\\\~'8~.A~ 11 ~~~~~::~J-6-IM-WOLCOTTa FO,tM 790 ';:; :1:~~,!:1 P:Vx!~ ~;'!uu,~~~~ !~~~!'ua~~u ~t~ it~",:',:,, O~c~!' I~~ :~~ ~~:

Order: QuickView_ Page 1 of 1 Requested By: , Printed: 10/28/201912:37 PM Doc: 1963-184528 REC ALL p~FICIAL RECOltDS _BOOK

11)'

- ))Ano: Thiu )Oth: day or J1mA, 1942, PAUL J, MC C'JllMlCK Unitod Stoto~ Oiotriot Jud~n Presented by: VIM.Fl.El'!' PALM~;n I United Stot~~ AttornAy OEO!lCl!: F, HUHU.Y C. H, SCIIAHNlKOW GEORGE A, LJ\ZAA 1 Jll. Special Attorney~ LandEI Divlelon De~nrtment or Juotioe ll:,, C. H, SO!lAJ\NlKO\'/ 2.:.J!.,.. Soharnikow Attorneys ror Plaintiff · ..... ___AppNY.eLE'..S __t _o_.. form and. s uti s t en oe .end ..o.:msent .. L-~-thu ent1-y. .. .ot. ..tll e .. foregoing J·adgament, la heroby · gtven: -JAGOB _. J., .. .-.1',E.UUSEkOtR, City, Atty., By JAiiES J. L,RJ,CKl:NRI_DOE, Deputy City Attorney Attorneys tor City ot Sen Diego J/J.lER G. PFANSTrEI. J.AllES G. PFi.NG1'lEL, Attorney fo1• SA/,\ ~J;iffH COMPANY HIGGS, F'L.t.."l'Cl!ER A.'W GLEN , l)y FERDJ:N.IJW 'l'; ~'LliTOHER -At torniiy a for c~QSSY.0N1' P.lillK COM PAl'lY

JuJbmen.t-: 1inta1•ed· Jun :,o 19~ ~ -Doul\'eted Jim ;JO 1942 I Bool<: C.O. i, Pug~ -,~.t,.8 -Ecm11nd r.. Smitll; Glerk ~,Y B. B, Hem1en, Deputy A Tr,.i"., co·py , ·Atte"t, . 'Et.o' , '· Juh :'.)O 1942 :Ed!hund L-. ·am1~11, :Clerk_ u_.s. Diatrict Court· /:lo\J"tharn Diatrlot or Cali1'ornia B:; J. M. HOR~, :Doputy -. J , ll. f;o:m ·•- Reco:rd~d. ·e't Request 01' sbutb·ern Titte e,_ Tr,l"st Co.· Oct l:l 194_, at 9 A.M. ROO:ER . N. ·HOWE, . County RiMordsr By Doputy D, Colt! . ·3.00 / 21.· '61879 ~

. . . GRANT DEED

. HQWARD 0, THO~, a "1tlglti ·IJli,n in oondd.eration of T:i:li Al'lC N0/100 DOLLAHl'l, to . litm i!l .hand ,ie {d; roo~lpt, _of w\Jich ls hP-:reby _acJrnowlodgedicioefl hercb:( GRANT 1'0 JtBELlNO F¥RllAI-l.LliZ• a widower· the :r~nl pr~perty in the City of. Sari I:1egb, I _County of' Sen Diego, State of Oalifornie, ·denorlb!!d 1u, fqllow·s: . Lotu Th,lrt~•-three (J ; ), Thlrty.~fqu·r ( ;34) eud the \',eat Helf of _Lot.-:· •fhfr~- fin (:H)', in b1ook Twenty-two (~2), ·or L. W. Xlmb!.'ll 1 e Subdivis.to~ -ot the Northwest Qunter. of Pueblo I,ot· l,1~4, ooo_ordi!Jg to Ma·p thareof lio, - 56 1 __ filed· in_ the··office of the Recore er ,of s~to. San -DiegQ_Co\lnt.y l,l"e:rch Jl, 1873, -TO HAVF. AI.O ·io HOLD to eaid ·Grant•~ _hio" he1ri3 or 6881-gnB, W~T~ ESS my .hand -th1"e 29th _dey or '~epteinb er.-. 191,2, .. . -·aowAi

neoorded et Request ot• Southern 'l'i tle & Tr-.int, Co . Oot 10 194~ et 9 A,M, . ROGER N, HOWE, County Rooorder By_ Deputy H, Zerv,rn ---000--- , _ '. -i

Order: QuickView_ Page 1 of 1 Requested By: , Printed: 10/28/2019 12:38 PM Doc: 1942-62361 RECBCK OFFICIALBCK !HOWARD C, '.rfiOAP 1 a single mM, the real property in· the City of San ~iego County of San • ln1ego,ot11te of Ca11fom1a, dascrit~:' ao follows:

Lots Thirty three tZ3) 1 Thirty fOUt' (M) 8Jld the West. Half of Lot Thirty five (35) in Block henty two (!l2) of L.'li,Kimball 1 s Subdlvision of the Northwest Ciuarter of Pueblo tot 1154 according to Map~ theroof :lo. :56 imd 08, rn,_ti in the otfioe of the C-:>unty Recorder of said San liiego Cowity Llarch n, 1873, TO HAVE AJH, TO HOLD tu said lorantee his heit-s or assigns. l WI'INE~S our. hands thi~ ii-Mde ti. Thorp ; . liinie Thorp 'STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) . ~OS ANOELBS COUNT~, CALIFORNIA) ss, . , on thia 18th day ol' October 1.938, b~fore me, R11th N,Oitt:ens ~ Notriry PubHc in :and for said Countr,personally appe&t•ed B"ade R,1'horp and Lizzie 'rhorp, husband 3Ild wife, )mown to me to be the persons whose nam"'~ ,i.ra • subscr11:ied to 'the for~golng .instrument 1ant1 a ckJ'lowledged to me that they aitecuted the ~ame. WITIIESS my Ruth N ,Gittens Notari P,,u11c in and for . said l'.,os Angeles, County of Los Ar.gales, State of' California, My commission expires June~, 194'l, UNION TITLg INSURANCE CO. OCT r:t?, 19~8 at 9 A,!L _ COMPA~E;;D ROGl!:R l'l, HOVIE, COUNTY RECORDER ~.,_-~, -~ ... \',,·a,~ By Deputy D,Cole, PJW'\IH O?I ~ 1 !' i,:,~;tAQS'f (\ ---000000000---

OSPART!tl:.NX OF HEAL:l'H crn OF PASAD&NA,CALIF0RNIA DIVI°SION OF VITAL S'l'ATISTICS. No . 629

, THIS IS TO CERTIFY THAT the attached is a full, t,rue and correct. copy of or1g1rrnl

!cer-tiflcate No. 98'/ o.r Dest.h of Conr-arl J\11w; ·!-'l!'!.t:'h 1 s ')n !!l~ 1~ th!w cf!"!c;;. =;! v~· n:·l:t\:~1 ;I am the legal custodian, i IN TJ<:STIMONY YiHJ!.REOF, Witness my hand aud seal of the City of Pnsndena, &t l'asad~a, i falifom:1a, October 18, A, p. 1938. Furnlshod Milton L,Halverson M,D, Registrar Vital Statistics, Pasadena, California i By Merlan G,l!olland Deputy Registt'e'r Vi t11l St.at1 sth·s,Pasadena, Calif.

i b'TATH: OF CALIFORNIA D.EPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HE:ALTR I VITAL BTATIBT!CS STANDARD CERTIFICATE OF DRATH, i 11, Place of Death: Di st No, 1904. Local Registered No. 987 ~aunty o_f Los Angeles, City Town or -- P asaciena Street and. No. 1900 E,MoWlt.ain, Pasadena, ! 12. Full Nama Conrad Auw R~si denca: No. lBOO · J,;;.1.!ouritain St • ~• , 4 C.:olor or Race 5 Single married , widowed or divorced sex. l.lale Wh1t6 ~idower +a. ·If li!arrtect, Widowed or DivOl'ced, Name cf !insband <>r "'ife. Unknown '1• Date or ilirth October a, 11161 'I, Age 81 yr, 2 I.lo, 20 Da:,s. I CCUPATION 8, trade .p~ofession or kind of ~ork done eto. Bookbinder i I J 9, In:lustry or business 1n wl'lich ~ork was done, etc. Book Bind

-FATHfR, 13, N(Ulle John Ai.iw 14, Bii:thplace (.city or town) un!

' l•lali& II'. •nlT, O••· 81Nrhr, ,: Br•· o. hl'aa1, IIQl.t,, .. --- ;~ , ' .,.. I I ,. r •

,.r ... 1a ..alibratl•• ot !ID Doll.art, I:•• •o_, , ~ umr OtiH m ...,, a... .,. •• Z. ■■t. • a..,, 11u•• •• •it• ; ll I O , ill. mu DAL 1»:nnr 11tu.te4 1a ~• ou,r ot 1a lli•P , oou'7 ot a.a I I I' .."' I '• l>ie,O, lltau Of DaUfn11.b, 'bo'U.4ol ... loecrlhl •• follow•: I o . Lot, tlliri)'-throo CH), !ll1rtr tou Ck) al tilt l'Ht Balt (I, t) ot Lot! 1·,.• 'fhlr$7•tlYt (16) us Bloolr: fftat7•two (II) ot i.. •• J.'.:luaU.• • 1111-HlTillon o-t the 1ntlur~•t 1•' ... 'C Qurte&' <•, Ir, ¼l ,, Pu'll.9 Let .lln.. bui'lt Htt,r•f• (UN) , aeonUag to MJI tlloroof lo ■, ff •• H, fll.. la tllo ottloe of ~• Ooutr 1eool'dor of All I• Di•,. Oout, •ru ll ■ t 18TB, ii} Klfi ilii i() 11'>.t.D tile ....,.. si-ut.t ...- lo ■orlht :,rtaiHI ato the .... I Qrut•! tha1P h•ir• ... a11ip.1 flNTOI' l'I!QII -, Mal aat , ..1 th.11 lHJa l&7 of Deo•bor ltl.6

, , ..:i tel 111 :,r•••o• of B, •• Sliodol \•' ' ' ..i" ho~ l, ...q

ri.1-.~----11..M" 11() t 11&!1 01 CilIJOlllU,

COUii ff 01 SU JIUQO. Oa 'ilil lUJa lat et »Heuer'-· D. 11.ntffeil DUHi _. flf~ befOH ... II Qoo, :. ~ • lot1U7 hl>llo la ad tu 11&11 Coat,r &Ill& llt.t., Ndliq tlloN~, 11l1;r: I o•am.•U-« ut woa, :,erlOJl&ll,r aJ,.arol :B, •• lllsov.dtl, • "14ower llllon to • to N ~ ~ro@ tHoribfl illl •• 0.011 .... 11 ftbHribod to tll1 1'1i:111Jl illl•t~t, eD4 •llkN•l~.. •• I to u tllat ho a.out•• the ..... II 1'11!088 IIBUI01, I llaYO Jaor1nto Nt -, ll&lll all alfml -, Offioilll IJNl, at 97 otfio1, ill a.. l>ie,o Onat7 If laa Jli.,., state tt califnllia, tu w .nl 70a, ta thi1 01rt1,1oate fir1t alloTe •l'itt•• ,,:..-;~, a...1. -.1' , llH .. 1. \ ' I Jlac:11' , '. lotat7 hblio ill u4 tor tlat ooav ot 11f,D ,\ / ') l>iep, ltato of OalU-.aia, 8-0.,.,11 at a.tu•t~~. !bq •••· U, 19&1 at U lfia. JHt I o 1eleoll: !. II, ·-- , ...... l'F, Cna1i, IIOH4er, n /:lr,O..-----◄ B7 I. C. ha-NH, ~'7.

John D, Cortro7 and :a.•.coa ;. Oortrq hll.1baa4 -.nd 11'lt• JI l'ol' Y4 la ooa1i111eatio• ot 1;1ae ■u of Qae •r.t.Ul• JJO nan aaiaa, ..,... il1I Qlll!OUJII to lrfC :&. ro ...... a.rn.o~ A, TOUI, uaNd •• nt., .. ~sat._,, ilL Sf 111,U, I'-~ dh&W ia • ClQ' of 8U ~ Oout7 of a.a ~IP, a~t, ot C&Ufe:m.ta, 111..._...... l'i1'N aa r.u...1 , ~ .... hl'Q' (Ir .0) foet ef r.ta atrt,-.... (Ill t. !llirt,r-11s (16) ~ olUi'ro 1n :ai.u: l'o1ll' C•I ot Jul.J'• Uliti• 1lo NU 01t7 ot ~ Dlep uoe.,.lJIS ti ...,

thereof Jo 6& til.el 111 t!ao Oftl.ot of tu Oo•f'T JINodw tf -11 Saa J)1op ooutT ApPll 1,t 18'73,

Order: QuickView_ Page 1 of 2 Req uested By: , Printed: 10/28/201 9 12:40 PM Doc: 882-46 RECBCK DEEDBCK \ ' . , ...... •• ...... ,, ..... ,.T"-"O!• ..••• .. ··•,•.w ~--· ...... '

Prank A. S&lmon•, Oounty Olerk

By Walter 8, BuohP\l'llVlj Ileput.y E, w. Peterson uun l 1905, at!:$ min past 2 o'clock P, M, ooi..,..ey Reoord r Pee t1.60 Deputy

We, Ralph Elliot Jl'te]ld and 11M'gUel'1t.e Pleld1 hust,,md e.nd wire, ui i,he 011,.r

i.na ,Jount;y of San Diego1 State of 0al1forn1a, tor and 1n conc111erat;l.on of the sum of One

thousand three hunctred (J1,oo.J Dolla.re 1 do hereby grant to Abnt:lna Shoudel of Heaperie.1

' San BeM1ardino oounty1 State of Oal1t'orn111 1 all that real prop ert;y dtue.tocl 1n K1mba.J.l '•

, addition to San Diego Oity, Oounty of San Diego, State of Oaliforn1e., bounded and deaorib

a11 followe:

Lota numbertd thirty-three (3.3) 8,1lQ thirt.1-four (:,4) and weet one nair of lot thirt;y-f1Te (~) block tw8'lty-two (22) of' L. w. K1mbe.ll 1s &c!dition or the city or San

•Di~o, Ste.te Of California, aocordins to map of eaid addition on rile in the office of

1 the County Recorder of said San Dieso Oount;y, subject to a certain mortg.. ge or t600 .oo de. eel

July 2.3 1 19041 due three ;ye<1ra art.er d&te with interest a.t the rate or lo% per ann\l!!I p~f-

11.bl e II em.1-annue.ll.y 1 To have and to hold the above granted and de9crribed prem1eee unto the u1

1gra.nteeher heirs e.nd e.e11igna forever, I Witness their hands and see.h thia thirt;y.. ril'llt da)r or Ma,y 1905, ' Signed and executed. in pres me e of Ralph Elliot Pield (S 1 • : £, L, R1ohe.rda 1 Wm G. He.naon. Ke.rguerit e Field (8 , Shte or Oalitornit., count,>' of San Diego, ss.

On this t.hirt:,•firat day ot Kay A, D, nineteen hundred a.nd five before m

, E, L, Rioha?-d1 a llot&I')' P\lblio 1n and tor ■ aid oount:,, residing therein, dul7 o0111111aa1on

and sworn, peNonall:, appeared Jl&lph Elliot Pield known to me to be the person deeoribed n

anq whoe e na111e 1a aub,or1b ed. to the within iru;tl'\IDlent and acknowledged to 1111 that Pe er outed the e&me,

In witne,111 whel'eot' I have herEtlnto eet, ,q h&nd and attized 111¥ ortioial II l

at my office 1n San Diego 11t;y, Oountir of San Dieso, State ot Oaliforn1& the day and 7ear in thie oertiftoate first above writtm,

E, I., Rioh&l'd11

~?'~-~-0?\:, ~/ State or Oalit'onu.a, ~;-- , State of' California, )

' oounty ot r,o, Angele11, ) SS,

On thil .3l•t day of ...., A, D, ninet.em hundred and five betou ae Win G,

eon a Notary Public in and for aa1d Oount.:,, rea1ding therein, d\11¥ oommiuioneu and ,wo

, personally appeared Ke.rguer1t.e Field kno,m to ae to be the penon dea,;il'ibed in r.nd who ■ e

: n&111e 1a oub11oribed to the within iutl'\llent. and and aoltno"lledged to •e that 1hi, neouted I t.hi, eam11,

In witness wherl!Ot' J: n.•e heMmto aet, 111 hill\4 111111 &f1'1zed a, notarial

'h Bt.&h rot O&Ufotn.1a1 the day 1111d .., i , r ! Order: QuickView_ Page 1 of 2 Requested By: , Printed: 10/28/2019 12:43 PM Doc: 363-419 RECBCK DEEDBCK ll

L <.., ' : tui~ or C11liforn1,.,) ) · •;urty Of' .. ,m !11-.~o. l On tnin l!Otll d11~• of ,July, l')

lio t·1 ·1ri<"l ""1' +,J,,. l'l•ttrl. ~ounty o' r,,1:. Ptrip:o, nerrionnlly ur>1>0Hrec1 Anna n. ',/,il'-:t~r. :,r.:i,m '·" 1,c.

to be ilw ,',1.•, r.,itll''lt o!' 1.1 ,, P""'' lel,t -- 0 •,nto -:onpnny, the Co"!'rorution t,nnt BX'lmltP<"l •,Ji" ,,\ ·,., L;1 M instrtunent, 1.r.c, uo)...no,·t~,,r,.it +,o n0 tl1F1t, n•11J): co1~·,, ·,•:,t,~on ry~l'ut"t\ tll'l r• ,tlio, . •"' ...,- o<'<'ir:•i 111 •.1, "ltl' ?!' ,'1\11 1 ter:o, 'lriunt:, o-r :rnn 111ep;o, i·tate o:r cr1l1"""nt11, ti\'! d.fllf nnd ~•1:iru• in t,hia Ge!'ti{'io-1te rtret nlJove vt)•!tten, .:<"' I C, ~111rn aent11el, '( ~:,;·;., ';o~a.,..~, Pul.lic ln rin

·r:u:, L::i ·;i: 7,, 1tv. na.,le t,1~ \ t:; tJ. rta- , of' Ju.ly, in tt.o year rf our Lord nin-=-t~en lLUTJoJ'P<\ 1\nt

f'our, 11!:i l' ;Ji , 1ll11~ • I, •11.'bo11la a:;,L 1,:·.i u1 F. , -r .t.l: 1:11la, ,:,111 ,· a:-.,l rl'"

f\llGeles, :::ount}~ of' J.OF .'•n,:-::1,.n, •t,:1te o!~ CRllfO.rJliH 1 !V} !}rt~tteij ,.,,. t., hr ,..tr-nt.. r,nrt1 Aln1 H:slph

;;1110,.~ "ioln.. or t,ne :iit-Y o'C ~nn Tt'-'t:", "oun•,y or r.nn 1 iP.C", ~tc1tc I')<" ,~rtlif'rr•"lia, t,hc r,Hrt!'

( o-r tllr-. f'JeiJ")rrt . •,•".,,

. [1',l!':S <1 ,T•[: Th•tt the n••l i r,11,•t,t,i•J or t.he f'irijt, p,1rt, fO!' 1,,t tn Ol'.l:1"311~-:-·1•.to•· Of' tho

11\JM Of' T• ·:1 llo"llarri, 1.,1111't1l l1'lll<'IV o-<' t,lon 1 1nlto,1 r,t •,•, e11 or A11P.rica, to +,) ,Pl'" itl , n~d r•~1t1 t--:· tie

, l ,r.1., blll'.~llin ,,n,t FJOll, O?nlft".Y an,t oont'il'l~, until t,1,,. a~.L•l r11rt,:· a~ Li lC (J8COn1l I 1:•t,, fl II, to liill

i.r Lt•• .,,.,it ·woi••n:i -ro2:e"0!' 1 11ll tl.er.c <'<,!'ta!n lotn, pir,oe~ or pm•Gct~ of lanc1, 11 t.inte, 1:,,11:

. •11t •:1:!.n1; t"1 t,;,,:- 1r,•ir..t~• of f;an )lif!CO, Stntv 01" ,;ult .. Ql'l\i 1, 11 1\ CJO Ullt\C'rl flll~L J',.art,i t1· 1lurly clescrib~ l

; •, fOll017'l 1 to-Yli t:

J,ots 1:1m1:>,;;r -1i1!"t,·-tl1ree (; > l, "'111l•t,-rour ( 31,) and thr ,mt 11111!' O" Tulrty- five ( ;:,; ) 1n niocK liu1nber T111;r1ty-twc ( ::!~) o~ J , 'I', f 1t'lbll.ll' B r-ub<1.i11inion Of' the J,ortnwcat r,111;,;ote:r I'!,,'/.:.)

{ lil'3!l0 county, Clllii'Ornia,

~011 ,:·:H::1! ,,t th all nit ~1ngalnr t,,e tenem!!nte, he!'et11 tane!ltll 1mJ. 11r1ni~•.cno·,11es 1 t .. ere u•• to belon1;1nu or ir, 1l!,r11ine n: Jle!'t,l1'lill ;, r,•r, •I'~ rr,v0r11lon nn<1 rev111•r t<,,ir~, l'ei~n1n<1.er or,c1 N •-

1'1111 llI"I ),. '"j1.b,J.u ,

Ly<:111 Ji, "Jhlmtn, :;tote of C:a1:!.1'crnin 1 ) ) AA, C Jt,un~y or !,on J\n~,.. 1,,,,,) On th1o l!.3t,. d«~' o"!' ,ru1y, in tJ!ll YF.lB!' on,; tllOUEIL"\ll nine il:tl'drr.

• •1 w•, bc1f1.ll'•J 11e, Frn,'"lK C, ~o.llier, ri • otcu'1( P..iiili,1 J.r · 11,t ror na1--L ~,:,11nt:,, "e'lirl.in~ tlier,.in,

Order: QuickView_ Page 1 of 2 Requested By: , Printed : 10/28/2019 12:44 PM Doc: 346-267 RECBCK DEEDBCK Attachment C Maps

C.1 - City of San Diego 800 Scale Engineering Map C.2 - Current and Historical USGS Maps C.3 - Original Subdivision Map C.4 - Sanborn Maps 1886/1887 1906 1921 1940 1950 1956 Attachment C.1 - City of San Diego 800 Scale Engineering Map

A City of San Diego 800 Scale Engineering Map follows, showing the property and a North arrow. This was obtained from the City of San Diego Development Services building records. 1737 202

- 4 •

' > -:11t• -.

194

I .J CITY OF SANt:f'-4 EGO, CALIF ORNIA /\0D11 107~ 194-1737 194-1725 Attachment C.2 - Current and Historical USGS Maps

Current USGS Map follows, with site location identified and North arrow. Also attached is a close-up of the neighborhood that better identifies the site location. A Historic map was located, but it is post-WW 2. U.S. DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR POINT LOMA QUADRANGLE ID..$. GE

• 15

NA.TIONALCI ,.

1J '\···-.,

COR.ONADO

10 .., Tl "'' ....

Attachment C.3 - Original Subdivision Map

Attached is Subdivision Map, showing L.W. Kimball's subdivision of Northwest¼ of Pueblo Lot No. 1154 in San Diego, 1871, recorded in 1873. This was obtained from the San Diego County records office. ... . - .... . , 1 • . ·, ,.', ,•. .. _. ..,, ...... • ·- · .... x.

t J j

•

.. l ' ~

2 .f ~ ' •r a1 : 9 1U ,JI ,JS II .,, J; ' JAi '' JI If ,, ., fl Ml Ail" -f,t.r ~ , .M7 ,.,, St. ,. L II ,, f ,. -~ I 7 • .r I # ' . Jo Lit-NO J( -:: .. a,, ~ ,q L'"J1 ,,. ,,, ,.,. ~ -~ I .,,•• I ,, I ~ ~""' ,, I ~ ~ I ~ I Ji .. . . JJ ~« J4 ,H .J7 JI J '6. /,/I ~ J -t'J ,(N,/ .~ti NI ,l/_? "' ' .,~., ! ; I .I_= /5lAND J · St . ! ,, -~ / I 1r 11.1 11 '' fl 111 f I 7 o

~-,,, . ,.

•J ,4 ;. ; 4f!,I ,,. ~ '1 ;$1, ' i~ 'S!-t ~ •r I ,i ~ : .-'. ,,

1J' 1& t?,' 1/ ~ , ),, .11 .u _,.,, ~'•I" J d ' JJ' .,, J~ """ .tj ") ~J 1, "'- •• 'I I » .,. ·•1 St ., .. ,, ,, /,r II IP , , ,, -~ ' "' /J /!I, 1 u,, ,,,. .i 1 , .1 :"u✓~.'"-'.'-J.---'"7'"'-..1.....J...... l!;u:..·.1_..1...... L....L,tl,-t--!--''--llll"--..L...L....L--.l-.l_1-_,,,:e,~, ,.,., .J J J4 ,. ..,. i«<:t...... l...... L-1--1-:M---'-'-'-'-~-'-~~~-:--'-~'~~- U~ ✓ ~ ~ ,..C.,--,--.~,....i½-,-r-,-,--.-,-,-,-r7" ..,,., : :,J.·:•, ~f 'I .I ,, •.·. ~}f ,:L. .: ,: .. ,,,,,,,,,, ~-· ..., ... ··~·· ~ ~ .J ~ J? JI J9 ,,. _j'..______'.'...._ ___~_,j_~ _,."-'-~- ...... t~-.~~ ~~;;:·;;it ~r _: ·_ ~ --_--_---_-_-_-_-_-____~_-_, ___ _; _,r =----- Attachment C.4 - Sanborn Maps

Sanborn Maps for 1906 and earlier (1886/87) end at least 1 block to the West of 2528 Island Ave, so are not included because they don't show the property in question. Sanborn Maps have been obtained from the San Diego Library on-line collection, and the San Diego History Center. "J I MARKET

,.l.J.:. ~-- .. ' .1) .... ·, i:1 f ;,; INIQ Lill~ 1090

r ..I} I 'fEJ'_.- x I •• 't

r~-:-. H<,,O ,. { 7;' c:~ ,1 ,_., !J ?=--.... I II -:-r'V! I , X ~ · J .I~ 2?' : I ~j G;] .fl ~I .Jq' ,. J} I ~ ~ (£J I G.] ' 1:_ ... ;.a . ~~

I ~ I. "BfJ ;j:;1 I I • 6'! ~ ST. ~~~ (1920 Sanborn Map CloJeup ...... a. :I"'• ~ ' LUI J'!x}f '• ~, l l f7~~ , I- ' - • t I r ~ I i

-1.-..--.l...... -- □ ~-.t.._.:.' ______.,I_____.· ______-- ~ 1090 ------~--i______,_ r·• ., 1 ------r-11·~~- - • • ~ I I • ,r j • t ·1

-~1 '-t ~,.-... r--- + .. _ ... l I,~ '.· -" l ' I l p . , l I ~ l!.r-.. '--____. ;-.r-,-~ rl ,..,- 11...... r'J I -· t Llj I _t ,:.- l ...' -. ;;. _,. . ;.--=-=-.: ~ ;!:_~ t.. _11 i? - -1 t ...... : ".9 ,T ! ..0 I .I i, f: i ---·· t!_ _J ~ G : L ~j .... t I .~7JJ" - ,_.,._ .-:-.~ =,~ -

I 1921 Sanborn Map Closeup ~~§==E.

2.177 .';".!.-?.~.-"' ~·· .15tJ7 _;-·--:.~ .. . I i -l I i I ' , :r.~ ,.,· ... I • I • t 0 lJ ~,,., .·• ,,, l -1 ' I I ,;: i_. J-. - - -- ..;

nborn Map Wi dates 1921 Sanborn Map with 1940 Updates San Diego History Center, Balboa Park Attachment D Photographs

D. t - Historical Photographs D.2 ~ Current Photographs Attachment D.1 - Historical Photographs

Summary: Extensive research was undertaken at the San Diego History Center archives. Two photos of the property were found.

A 1930 aerial photo was located, but it encompasses a wide area. Included is a blowup focusing on a 6 block area. Also included is an extreme close-up, showing the property in greater detail but less clearly.

A 1956 aerial photo of the neighborhood is included, but 2528 Island Ave is indistinguishable among the rooftops due to the angle of the photographer.

Conclusion: The 1930 aerial photo shows that the 252 square foot flat roof addition was in place by 1930. 1930 Aerial View Courtesy San Diego History Center photo archives s 1956 Aerial Photo Courtesy San Diego History Center Photo Archives Attachment D.2 - Current Photographs

Summary: Photographs were all taken in November 2019. Attached are photos showing all 4 elevations, in addition to relevant details.

Conclusion: Photographs show clear evidence of major additions, revisions, door and window changes and deletions. South Elevation (Front of House) 2528 Island Av,e

South Elevation Details . ~ ...... $,,;6..'t.:~·-.":.- '.7,.~~oe-;, .. North Elevation 2528 Island Ave West Facade, viewed from across alley

_:_.._..----~,.:::...._,,. ' - - East Elevation

Original Victorian trim Window on east facade, Window on east facade, to and header front door on to left of front door, has right of front door, has been east facade been filled in. filled in and replaced. Attachment E HRB Criteria Supplemental Documentation

E.1 - Criterion A E.2 - Criterion B E.3 - Criterion C E.4 - Criterion D E.5 - Criterion E E.6 - Criterion F Attachment E.1 - Criterion A

Summary: The house at 2528 Island Ave was typical of the construction happening at the turn of the 20 th century in San Diego. It does not reflect special elements, only typical elements.

San Diego was continuing to expand, and this home was built in the eastward expansion from the downtown core. Land speculators had bought up large tracts and subdivision had occurred in anticipation of the population growth. This house was built on a parcel intended for a single family home, and was built in the style typical of a working man's home. The style of the home, Folk Victorian, was a reflection of what a normal design-build contractor could erect without the aid of an architect, and was based on simple modern (1903) floorplans. Ornamentation was minimal and included modest trim boards and beveled porch posts, most of which have been removed.

Landscaping consist of a few remaining bushes, cactus, and a tree, and are clearly not the result of a planned landscaping scheme.

The property itself is not remarkable because it is a normal assemblage of lots in a subdivision on a planned grid of streets. The house itself does not exemplify special elements of either the neighborhood, cultural, social, economic, architectural, etc. It is just a normal 1903 house that, even if it retained its original architectural configuration, would do little or nothing to contribute to our understanding of the time and place of its construction.

Conclusion: The property does not qualify under Criterion A. Attachment E.2 - Criterion B

Criterion B: Is identified with persons or events significant in local, state, or national history.

Summary:

The research discovered no historical events associated with the property, either significant or not. This was a house built on the east side of downtown San Diego during a period of expansion.

The persons (residents and owners) of 2528 Island Ave. were typical of San Diego. Many of them led interesting lives, but their stories are anecdotal in nature, yet not reached the level of "significant". Attached is the research showing what information could be found on each of them, starting with the earliest and proceeding up through the last occupant. Also included are the residents of the rear house, 2528 ½ Island Ave, which was demolished by 1966. The research shows normal people leading typical lives owned and/or occupied 2528 Island Ave. These were machinists, carpenters, waiters, sailors, mechanics, laborers, wives, daughters and sons, Caucasian and Hispanic.

Conclusion: The property does not qualify as historic under Criterion B. 2528 Island Ave., San Diego CA Ownership and Occupancy

2528 Island Ave 2528 1/2 Island Ave Year Ownership Occupants per Phone Directories Occupants (home demolished) 1903 William L & Lidia E Tibbals 1904 Ralph Elliot & Marguerite Field 1905 Abertina Shoudel 1906 II 1907 II 1908 II 1909 II 1910 II 1911 II 1912 II 1913 II 1914 B.F. Shoudel, widower Thorp, Stephen R (Helen) 1915 Beade R. & Lizzie Thorp Thorp Rowland C (laborer) Thorp, Stephen R (Helen)

1916 II Thorp Rowland C (Marine)& Vernah Thorp, Stephen R (Helen) 1917 II Thorp Rowland C (Sailor)& Vernah Thorp, Stephen R (Helen) 1918 II 1919 II 1920 II 1921 II 1922 II 1923 II 1924 II 1925 II 1926 II Kissinger, Thos & Angelina 1927 II Schumacher Fred W & Maude Stork Minnie Mrs, Thorp Helen Mrs 1928 II Warburton CD Stork Minnie Mrs, Thorp Helen Mrs 1929 II Warburton CD, Warburton LS Starke Minnie Mrs, Thorps Helen Mr~ 1930 II Jeffries CB Starke Minnie Mrs, Thorps Helen Mr~ 1931 II McNea Leslie Stark Minnie Mrs 1932 II McNea Leslie & Mabel (Chauf) Thorp Helen Mrs 1933 II McNea LA Thorp Helen Mrs 1934 II Kohler Jacob Thorp Helen Mrs 1935 II Lewis JG Vacant 1936 II Lewis JG Thorpe Helen Mrs 1937 II Lewis JG Thorpe Helen Mrs 1938 Howard C. Thorp Bigbie AL Thorpe Helen Mrs 1939 II Bigbie AL Cheeney Jack 1940 II Jacobs WE Vacant 1941 II Jacobs PF Mrs Vacant 1942 Abelino Fernandez Jacobs PF Mrs Connett WW 1943 II No phone book No phone book

Page 1 2528 Island Ave., San Diego CA Ownership and Occupancy

1944 II Fernandez Avelino 1945 II No phone book No phone book 1946 II No phone book No phone book 1947 II Fernandez Avelino 1948 II No phone book No phone book 1949 II No phone book No phone book 1950 II Fernandez Avelino Fernandeg Tomasita 1951 II No phone book No phone book 1952 II Fernandez Avelino Florez Rita R, F 1953 II Fernandez Avelino Vacant 1954 II No phone book No phone book 1955 II Fernandez Avelino Vacant 1956 II Fernandez Avelino Vacant 1957 II Fernandez Avelino Vacant 1958 II No phone book No phone book 1959 II No phone book No phone book 1960 II Fernandez Avelino Vacant 1961 II Fernandez Avelino Vacant 1962 II Fernandez Avelino Vacant 1963 Juanita Petra Fernandez Fernandez Juanita 1964 II No phone book No phone book 1965 II No phone book No phone book 1966 II Fernandez Juanita Demolished? No further mention 1967 II Fernandez Juanita 1968 Juanita & Cruz Fernandez Fernandez Juanita 1969 II Fernandez Juanita 1970 II No phone book 1971 II Fernandez Cruz 1972 II Fernandez Cruz 1973 II Fernandez Cruz 1974 II Fernandez Cruz 1975 II Fernandez Cruz 1976 II Fernandez Cruz 1977 II No phone book 1978 II Fernandez Cruz 1979 II Fernandez Cruz 1980 II Fernandez Cruz 1981 II No phone book 1982 II xxxx 1983 II xxxx 1984 II xxxx 1985 II xxxx 1986 II xxxx

Page 2 2528 Island Ave., San Diego CA Ownership and Occupancy

1987 II xx.xx 1988 II xx.xx 1989 II xx.xx 1990 II xxxx 1991 II No phone book 1992 II xx.xx 1993 II xxxx 1994 II xx.xx 1995 II xxxx 1996 II xxxx 1997 II Fernandez Juanita P 1998 II Fernandez Juanita P 1999 II 2528 Not listed 2000 Francisco Banuelos No phone book 2001 II Fernandez Juanita 2002 II Banuelos Francisco 2003 II Banuelos Francisco 2004 II Banuelos Francisco 2005 II Banuelos Francisco 2006 II Banuelos Francisco 2007 II Banuelos Francisco 2008 II Banuelos Francisco 2009 II No phone book 2010 Francisco & Antonia Zesate Bi Banuelos Francisco 2011 II No phone book Year Ownership 2528 Island Ave Occupants 2012 II Banuelos Francisco 2013 II No phone book 2014 II Banuelos Francisco, Zesati Antonia 2015 II Banuelos Francisco, Zesati Antonia 2016 II Banuelos Francisco, Zesati Antonia 2017 II Banuelos Francisco, Zesati Antonia 2018 Paula Development, Inc. Banuelos Francisco, Zesati Antonia 2019 II Vacant

Page 3 10/28/2019 Ancestry Person - Print ~ancestry·

William ~uther lii6bals 1872-1951

When William Luther Tibbals was born on November 30, 1872, in Valley Falls, Kansas, his father, Joseph, was 39 and his mother, Serena, was 34. He married Lydia E. Hall and they had two children together. He then married Mary Eilzabeth Paul on October 30, 1925, in Los Angeles, California. He died on July 9, 1951, in Los Angeles, California, at the age of 78, and was buried in Glendale, California.

LI. j Joseph Henry Tibbals

1.fJ Serena Victoria (Rena) L Holloway

'-"'·Y -,,. • Denver 0 Nevada Utah Colorado United States:. Kansas · ~issot Wichita• ·Ca lifornia •St.George 0

0 La's Vegas I' 0 Oklahoma Santa Fe 1 0 0 Albuquerque; Oklahoma , Arkan City I • New Mexico i Arizona . - ,_ , t-'"..: ~ _.,. .·. ' .1... •Phoeplx I ·•Dallas . :---- I •Tucso~ ' ~ Paso _Texas

Birth

William Luther Tibbals was born on November 30, 1872, in Valley Falls, Kansas, to Serena Victoria (Rena) Holloway, age 34, and Joseph Henry Tibbals, age 39.

30 Nov 1872 • Valley Falls, Jefferson, Kansas, USA

Death of Sister

His sister Florence Ann died on January 2, 1877, in Atchison, Kansas, when William Luther was 4 years old.

'a Florence Ann Tibbals I 1..&. ' 1857-1877

2 Jan 1877, Atchison County, Kansas, USA

https ://www.ancestrylibrary.com/family-tree/person/tree/15204 94 79/person/27201504 7 583/story 1/4 10/28/2019 Ancestry Person • Print

Residence William Luther Tibbals lived in Baxter Springs, Kansas, in 1880. Marital Status: Single; Relation to Head: Son 1880 • Baxter Springs, Cherokee, Kansas, USA

1s94 Residence

William Luther Tibbals lived in San Diego, California, in 1894. 1894 • San Diego, California, United States

Birth of Son

His son Walter Marvin was born on March 31 1895, in San Diego, California. !-• l Walter Marvin Tibbals ,IL 1895~ 1950

3 March 1895 • San Diego, San Diego, Callfo.rnla, USA

Marriage ~il_liam -~uther Tibbals married Lydia E. Hall in 1895 when he was 23 years old. Lydia E. Hall 1874-1925

1895

1s91 Birth of Son His son Robert Hall was born on January 18, 1897, in San Diego, California. 1 • l Robert Hall Tibbals i,IL, 1897~1971 18 Jan 1897 • San Diego, San Diego, California, USA

Death of Father

His father Joseph Henry passed away on April 25, 18981 in San Diego, California, at the age of 64. I• I Joseph Henry Tibbals .,&. , 1833-1898 25 April 1898 , San Diego, San Diego, California, USA

Residence William Luther Tibbals lived in San Diego, California, in 1900,

Marital Status: Married; Relation to Head: Head Occupation: Proprietor of bicycle shop 1900 • San Diego Ward s, San Diego, California, USA

https:/fwww.ancestrylibrary.com/famlly-tree/person/tree/1520494 79/person/27201504 7583/story 2/4 10/28/2019 Ancestry Person • Print

1910 Residence WIiiiam Luther Tibbals lived in San Diego, California, in 1910.

Marital Status: Married; Relation to Head of House: Head

1910 • San Diego Ward 11 San Diego, California, USA

Residence William Luther Tibbals lived in San Diego, California, in 1914. 1914 • San Diego, California, USA

1916 Death of Mother His mother Serena Victoria (Rena) passed away on June 14, 1916, in San Diego, California, at the age of 78. ' a 1 Serena Victoria (Rena) Holloway IJI...\ 1838-1916 14 June 1916 • San Diego, san Diego, California, USA

Residence William Luther Tibbals lived in Oakland, California, in 1920.

Relation to Head: Head; Residence Marital Status: Married 1920 • Oakland, Alameda, California, USA

Death of Brother His brother Laten Semore died on December 12, 1922, in Sacramento, California, when William Luther was 50 years old.

.• 1 Laten Semore Tibbals I..&.J 1855-1922 12 Dec 1922 • Sacramento, Sacramento, California, USA

Marriage William Luther Tibbals married Mary Elizabeth Paul in Los Angeles, California, on

October 301 19251 when he was 52 years old. r

1•·. • Mary Ellzabeth Paul 1£ 1889-1977 1

30 Oct 1925 • Los Angeles, California, USA

https://www.ancestryllbrary.com/famlly-tree/person/tree/1520494 79/person/27201504 7583/story 3/4 10/28/2019 Ancestry Person - Print

Death of Wife His wife Lydia E. passed away in 1925 in Los Angeles, California, at the age of 51, They had been married 30 years. ,[: a 1 Lydia E, Hall .....1 1874-1925

1925 • Los Angeles, Los Angeles, Callfornh:\ 1 USA

Death of Son His son Walter Marvin passed away on March 14, 1950, in Bishop, California, at the age of 55. ia·i Walter Marvin Tibbals IA.I 1895-1950

14 Mar 1950 • Blshop1 Inyo, California, USA

Death

William Luther Tibbals died on July 91 1951, in Los Angeles, California, when he was 78 years old. 9 July 1951 • Los Angeles, Los Angeles, caUfornla, USA

Burial Glendale, Los Angeles County, California, United States of America

https://www.ancestryllbrary, com/famlly-tree/person/tree/152049479/person/272015047583/story 4/4 -=-- ""?"""" I • _...,_ .-. • --. '"" ~ ,_ • .., ... , ••, :,;,;. . DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE ANO LABOR BUREAU OF THE CENSUS 10·-- · .. ..,, . ••·. ,... ··. . " -~ > ···' , .... I ( SUPCIIVISOll"S 1'1STR1CT No / SH(Cl No /t -0 1 A VISION or COUIITY 1:1STITU"T10N _ J~~~~:;: ,~~~su~ ~'.~ ;'.~~~~-~:::::.,~:.~;~~~~~~:Hc~:f:-:f f.:. '"""/i£i1:ffilf2.:· :"';:,~:~. 1:f.J.1Tl1J'.". -r ...,.._ l""r- •'-- tl.ww- •r a ..... -a .1atrf.l t;.. C,IQ,. •.&• la l.ll.l• Caall7.

. , -~. ~, r #. If IL ~ :z )1~~~ . l(!:1:',.;, :-~/u,.,.,,.•~ -- tti:i .. -1.~"----·· ' · ··- -·····-- - ~ £ - - 1.. . _. 71« ~ - - 7 -· - . : 3 :i~ }rt(_ ·· - · ' u-wi--:.. . . /e, v . .. ,. . · ·- · .. l!111.J.. -r., ------1---+----'--'----h,f-----4..---1---.1 • W.J....i I i-;~~r, r. ~ j,M, ~ .J.,,vi,," , • -· ·_ 13..,,.,.../_(_ - Jy - U,., ·' ~ , i . · i,,v.,_ . · lu» . -Jr .. )!a. : (, . ~ 6 iuu .,,;,, .... k". .. . -t.;(Zdd'-"'="'--+--1.,.:,~~~+'~~=~-_,1:~.,,.___ .LL~m...;:,,:,_.tzt.~:L!.-µ..£1L.5:...!,;l.~-J:2'..=-I~ ". - ~ r___ " --==:::::J:~~~'----l--~&...--IC!e...Lf..__iL....t:!.,._~-~~~=,-. ~T{P - r.==---j---j-----'----f--lf""-=c«___:______1---.+-__:_....::!...... -+----+-+c.:....J--t 1: ~~ I_·_ ~ ~ - . =~_1-r.-vi-c . . ' - _ttt'- lle=;;""~~-.t- ---J~f"fl~~-+1~-d&,.i,:::__...... :;:r;c,~,1----'l~../JJ!...&!..-t;,::l!.!,;,:l!-+:...._-_.t,2;+::c.i:?~-I ::,, ]',.' ~/t,i~-~L ~ :~ ✓v' -,--;====~*~::.,l...--c-:-l-~~-~(dl.:.....i.4--:-_+-_--I_ )M~~rit,"(~rµ;};.~~ -""=<-~fi :..___L'-:"'_.~--"'=~""'==-it---l-"7"~~-t-=~=--:______;1-----4?'::!LJ.,~rp~,-----,=4-=-"h+, ,~ $11 ;;;a 2l, ,, r.,~ l : / l M

- - !--!,,&:~~~- -~~~s...J-...,-Ji--z,L..,...... ,,....+__.[££IL~....,,...... ---+----t.~~:t.J---1-~--t---1: I Cf. ,,.1.. .. -~ - ,: ' t ' --~- ~ ,J,,,,. ~~~(i__j,~_. ·,-: IJ LOANS 13241 It. E. J. SWAYNE & CO. INSURANCE Sumet'140 Real Estate ln All Branches CONVEY ANONG Clift of PN,oan NCICI•--.. h~b!~mi::. Bome7»60 •= ~m: ____rw_N_D1EOO __ c_ITT __ o_1RECT __ oa_T_. ___s~19 UNT 518 SA."l DIEGO ClTT DIRECTORY. Tim Hopkins, rest 1424 I. Tibbals Rena V (wid Joseph H), h 3422 I. Timerman Harriet I (wid Geo W), h 1870 4th. UTO• Tibbals Wm L, mgr New Pedrara ~lcxic.an Onyx Co, Timken Henry, h 3430 4th. h \\-S 2d 2 N of Quince. T!mm J T, butndr Anton Mayrhofer, res 511 9th. IOBILE Store Tibbetts Mrs Della ~I. deaconess Helping Hand Timms Frank, dairyman Allen & Son. Home, res 1335 J. Tingley Katherine, pub and editor New Century Path For Tibbetts Fannie M. res 3304 H. res Point Loma. . ' 0 Your TIBBETTS H R PAINT CO, T!nkcr Edga~ C, h ns Webster av I W of 29th. • laltlq Frederick H Jones mgr, NO\· Era paints, \"2.f Tinkham Edith E, elk S D Tent & Awning Co, res Carda, nishes, "'-all paper, glass and painters' supplies 1141- 224 Beech. .... WeddlnC 1145 4th. (Sec front edge). T!nkham Mary L (wid David R), h 224 Beech. 111111 AID I Invludon-. Tibsini Mary, res 1104 3d. Tinkham Wm D, drh-cr, res 224 lkech...... Fin• Statlonay Tichbomc Chas T, plumber, res 1041 6th. Tinsley John S, cash Sher\\;n Williams Co, res 751 or th• Tichbomc l\lrs Margaret J, res 1041 6th. 6th. Latatt Tichenor Norwood D, h 757 8th. Tirrell Cecil E, with Marston Store, res 30th nw cor E Popular Tichenor Norwood G, elk J W \Vesoott. res 757 8th. Tirrell Mrs \VG, musician. h 1719 B. looll Tichenor Stephen L. slsmn Russ L & M Co, h 3874 3d flPTI ST Ticknor W Bert. mill hd Rus.~ L & l\l Co. h 24o8 C. .._____ Tidcombc Mrs Eliza A. h ns J 1 E of yd. SOUTHERN ELECTRICAL C-0. 1 . ELECTRICAi. OONTflAOTO ... Ticmay Elizabeth. drcssrilkr. res 1313 6th. LEROY A. WRIGHT, Pru., CARL H. HEJLIRON. TIFFANY'S CARRIAGE SHOP. Vice PN9. and Cent. Mane~ AUGUST BIEWENEa. (John N and John B Tiffany) manufacturers of s-. and Treaa. ...._.._ ;m--H-o rm 81...a2I 5th. carriages, wagons. buggies. etc., bladcsmithing and ro■ TH• Tischer Dennis E, mach Howard Iron Wies, h 713 hone-4loeing a. spcriahy I 111 H, phones Sunset Franklin a.v. Yacht 1894; Home 2016. Ti9Chcr Leah S (wid John J), h 3232 Tiffany John B (Tiffany's Carriage Shop), res 1714 B J. Tischer Philip P, cup, h 382o N. Tiffany John N (Tiffany's Carriage Shop), h 1714 B. Dolphin Tischhauser John. baker, res 6.Jo E,'aDS. Tight Joseph T, dk C F Mone & Co, res 'JOO Beech. Tischhauser John U, b 64o Evans. For Tighe Thos, broom mlcr Stf'ffl Dept. h 700 Beech. Tisdale Julia A (wid Aaron E), h 3623 3d. ~~ Tilcstoa Fred L, h 3527 4th. T!sd_ale I..awa J (wid Geo M), tchr, res 3623 3d. FlahlnC Tileston Mrs Kate N, res 3527 4th. TISSter Lea M, elk Colwell & Wright. res 56o 4th. Tripa Tillapaugh Geo W, asst mgr S D Colin Co, h 4177 Title Building, 841 5th. TJU University blvd. TITLE GUARANTY & SURETY CO, STAR Tillinghast David W, clk. h 1223 Front. (Scranton), Nason & Oesting agts D cor 5th under BOAT Tilti900 Larry, carp, res 717 4th. Merdiants N at1 BanJc. Tillman Mrs Eliza. res :z6th sw cor·F. TITLE INSURANCE & TRUST CO, ff ~E Tillman Peter, lab. h :z6th sw a,r F. Wm H Allen j~ (LA) pres. Amasa P Johnson jr, ~ a •- Tillman Robt \V, gardener, res 368o N. sec, Robt Bla.ir asst sec 903 4th. Warf Tillot.9on Emma M, tchr Lowell Sch, res 1950 D. J Titus Aime B. student, res 3576 4th. Ftlf If H Tilton Martha J (wid Newdl G), res 2~37 AlbatrosL .. ft ,,...,...l'IIMt ...... A. llav·Ja lmtr .__... "ELITE STUDIO... Cor. f1ttll and F SCNeta GEO. B. KEITH&. CO. :::.:: Abstract Title & Trust Co. of San Diego BROKERS. REAL ESTATE AND INSURANCE 1515 E Street, Tunken Building Telepbonea: Samet Main 30Z, Home ZOSl IIICPIIE+■ l:NTUIQ IIICIN ouea OOIIPANt•• INaUMNOI: THAT P'IIOffOTe 529 528 IAX maoo an DlllaCIOaY. ______&u1_DDIQO __ an_D_ ..._mm_~_. ______ftlONal: Western HOMS - bbals Wm L, Tibbals-Gavin Co, h 4078 Utah. Tinsley Edwd C, drug& 601, 5th, r same. 1 ts Ila M, nurse, h 1335, 18th. TinaJey Wm, _granitectr Fred Fickas, r 11th ne cor M. -- TIBBE!fS HK PAINT CO. Fredk H Jones mgr, New Era paint.a, Tirrell Cecil E, with Manton Store, r 3846 E. G. C. Tinell Mrs E A, b 1646, lsL vamish(Seef es, walled paper, gws and paint.en' supplies 1261-1257, 4th Tischer P Peter, ClllP, b 3920 N. I ront ge and classified Paints). Arnold T!chbome Chas T, special po}ke. r La Jolla. Tischbauser Geo, bottler S D Soda Wks, h 550 Evans. ~ Tichenor Norwood De W, pres Snowflake Baking Co, h 732. 10th. Tischbauser John; baker, h 1541 National av. & Son 1!cknor W Burt, eng Rua L & M Co, h 4332, 4th. Tisdale Gertrude A (wid Henry B) h 463, 20th. ~ T!dball Albt J, slsmn_ Chas F O'Neall, h 448 Irving av. Tisdale Henry B, aged 69 died May 14th 1910. T!dball Jasper, r Pacific Beach. Tisdale Isabel A, steno Union Title & Trust Co, r 463, 20th. Tidcombe Mrs Eliza A, h es 31st nr Beech Titcombe, see Tidcombe. ~ Real Estate T!emey Lizzie T, r 1313, 6th. · TITLE GUARANTY AND SURETY CO (Scranton, Pa) Wanlrow ski-Reynolds Co district agts 306-310 Scripps Bldg 6th cor C. AHi> Tiffany John B, blkamith Tiffany's Carriage Shop, r 651 Logan av Ag,ncy Insurance ~Jfl'any, John N, h 651 Logan av. TITLE INSURANCE AND TRUST CO, W H Allen jr (Loa T!ffany s ~ Shop, F C Marston prop 1031 H. . Angeles) pres, Jaa D Forward -asat aec, R J Blair asst sec, 903, 8W1ine•• Tighe Anme, chocolate dipper lngenioll Candy Co r 706 Beech. 4th. Chances Tighe Thos. h 706 Beech. ' Titus Anson, b 804 Irving av. Tighe T Jos, watchmn Russ L & M Co, r 706 Beech. Titus A B, student, r 3471, 3d. 8", 4tb Sl 936 T!leston Kate M (wid Fredk L) h 3527, 4th. TITUS HARRY L, see-treas and atty Spreckela Companies 209 Nim. T!llapaugh Geo W, real est 4177 Univendty av, h same. Union Bldg, r Coronado. ... Fifth St. T!llman Peter, }'al"dmn Rusa L & M Co, h 770, 26th. TITUS NAT R. real estate suite 423 Union Bldg 1185 D, b 8471, ...... T!llman Robt, fab, r 29th nw cor N. 3d. ____ Tilton Martha ~ Cwid Newell G) aged 81 died Feb 5th 1910. Tober Homer G, h ns Betta nr 29th. 1 1!merman Hamet I (wid Geo W) h 1070 Laurel Tobey H P, r 920, 5th. Tunerman Helen, r 1070 Laurel. Tobin Timothy J, h 32d se cor Elm. lllrrl■..._ Timerman Philip, r 1070 Laurel. Todd Chas F, pwtering contr, h 4057 Milailsippi. 1111 Yalltr Times The, see Los Angeles Times. Todd Homer L, lndymn, r 3238 L. Todd Martha J (wid Robt N) r India ne cor Olive...... Timken Building, 6th se cor E. ... Cnlll Timken Cora B, r 3430, 4th. Todd Wallace J, barber 2426 K. h 3370 same. T!mken Investment Co, A S Bridges aec, 815 Timken Bldg. Todd Ward W, mgr Cal Bldrs Supply Co. r 1831 D. Tindall Helen V, r 1147 Logan av. Todd Willia T, lab city water dept, r India ne cor Olive. 1!ndall Henry F, osteo 317 Timken Bldg, h 1147 Logan av. Toews Max J, emp Ingle & Gamble. r Coronado. Tindall Herbert F, student, r 1147 Logan av Togo & Co, curios 1518 H. Tindall Mrs Viola C, oeteo 317 Timken Bldg. r 1147 ~ av Toler Edwd W, slamn Gordon Goodwin & Co, r 1210 Cedar. HarryS. Tingey C Hyde, elk Knight & Hyde Const Co, r Colonial Inn: Toler Elizabeth W. r 1210 Cedar. TJNCLEY KATHERINE, leader and official head Univmial Bro Toliver Aerial Navigation Co, C H Toliver pres, 1519 D. pres Putnam therhood and Theosophical Society throughout the world, r Point Toliver C H, Toliver Aerial Nav Co. Loma. Toll .Florence Wataon (wid Abel ff) h 461, 20th. Tingley Phoebe N (wid John M) r 565 16th Tolle Clifford L, yardmn Rua & L M Co. c,11,1 Tinker Edgar C, cook, b 3681 N. ' • Tom Gick Hin, mgr Wah Young Herb Co, r 1071, 7th. Tinker Wm D. printer, b 521, 18th. Tom J S, laidea' underwear 1219 J, h aame. Ptrtland Tom Yee, rest 420, 3d. ..,...... 1 Tinker W H, surveyor, r 761, 6th. Tomas Marco J, chef Podesta & Kerber, b 2119 G. c, ■ eat Tinkham Edith, elk S D Tent & Awning Co r 325 Logan av Tomkina Saml A, ahoemkr 1328 H, h 1834, lat. Tinkham Mary L (wid David R) h 325 av • .... Lonn Tomlinaon Fenton, pattemmkr S D Iron Wb, b 1910 India. Tinkham Wm D, sawyer Benson Llnbr Co, h 325 ·Logan av N••• Tomlinson Frances E, r La Jolla...... ,.., IHI C St. Tinn Ole, lab, r 611, 5th. • Tomlin.son Jas W, r 1436 F...... Tinaler Chas, auto opr San Diego Taxicab Co . ....ZIii 1256 The Thiel Detective Service Company F. ~ Draper, Stone & Goold .!!°!!11~ LOS ANGEi.BS OfflCB, 801 illDICAN BANI BUILDING c.11 U7 ElemW ...... llalaJNI ...... 8-.l"" QUALITY ELECTRICIANS u. ,_,...,_ ~ .,._.'IIIClllfftnawe "" x.., .._ :·Index to Great Register of San Diego County, Cal., 1st Ward, 1st Precinct

~ NO,OP ~ Votinll' NAME AGS Occupation and Addre11 Party Afflll1II BALLOT o No. I

...... 272 TURNER., EUGENE O. . • . . . . • ...... 83 Real E8tat.c, 8721> Indiana St •••••••• Republlcn I I ...... 273 THOMPSON, ADAM F ...... ,. 30 Plumbc1•, 4021 Idnho St •.•••••.••••••. Refuse .

...... 274 TUTTLE, GLENN V •••••••••••• , • • • • 158 Poultey IlaJscr, N. E. Cor. La. & El Ca.Jon, ..• Rei

Jeweler, Mission Ave., bet. Park Blvd & Gn . • Rei

l\Ierchn.nt, 4078 Utah •••• , , ••••••••• Rc1mbllca

Wine Merchant, 30f10 Hamilton •••.•.. Re1>ubllca

...... •.. 278 TRACHSEL, WILLIAM R. • • . • • • . • . • • 40 D1•ugglst1 3-1415 Sherman ....•...••.. Ilcpubllcu

...... 270 VINNEDGE, WILLIAM A!IDROSE • • • • 62 Lnthc1•, Arnold ....•....•....••.... Republlca

...... 280 VALENTINE, ALBERT R. • . • • . • • • • • • 41 Artist, 3003 Georgia ..•.•.. , .••.•.• Republlcn

...... 281 WIEDENHOFF, ERNST • • . . . . • . • • . • 01 Retired. 4343 Georgia. •••...•....•.• ---

...... 282 WELSH, JOHN G •.••...... , ..• , . . . . 4G Cari1ct l\lnn, 4143 Georgia St .•....•. Republlcn

...... , ...... 283 WHIGHMI, FERDINAND 0 .•...... 21 l\Iuslcillll, 4020 Hamilton, St ...... Repnbllca

...... 284 WHIGHMI, ARTHUR N ••••••..•.•• , 42 l\luslc.lan, 4020 lulmllton St .•...... Re1ml.Jllcn

...... :?Su WALLACE, HUGH E .••.•.•••••• , ••. 43 Pnintcl', 3002 Georgia St ••••••••••• ~p11hl le11 I ...... 286 WHIGHAM, THOMAS J...... 70 Carpenter, 4020 lfumilton St ••••••••• llcpul>llcn

...... 287 WHIMS, JOSHUA K...... 72 Retired, 45~ Georgia St ...•...... Rcpubllcn

...... , ...... 288 WALKER, JAMES A. • . • • . . . . . • • • . . • 48 Lnboro1·, Iown, bet. Univ, & Lincoln .. Re11ubllcn

...... ~ o WIEDENHOFF, ERNEST ...... , •... 01 Rcth-ed Soldier, 4343 ~rgln St .... RcpubU

...... 1_ 00 \V ALKER, WILLIAM P...... • 20 Ji'urmer, i\llseom•I, bet. Lincoln & Univ Rt>tmblicn

...... 201 WHITE, ROY R ...... •... 28 Ilontmnn, Cor. Polk & Oh.lo ..•...... Rcpubllet .

...... 202 WILSON, WILLIAM A ...... 43 Curpcntor, 4400 AJnbnmn ...... Soclnll '

...... ·1203 WETZLER, LEWIS ••...... •• • ... 60 Gtwdcner, 4127 Florida .•....•..•... llr.mocrntl

...... 204 WIENER, EDWARD O. . . . . • . . . . • . • . 00 Sollcltol•, 424u Gt..'<>l'gln ..••.... , .....•. Soclnlls

· ······· · · .... ·203 \VOLFF, ROBERT ..•..••. • ....•..• 3-t Curpcnl.cl', 43iS3 Louisiana •..•...... Soclnlls

·········· . ... 1200 WELUEN, JACOB HENRY ••..•.••.• 33 Pulntm•, 4030 Oco1•gln ...... •...... Ht•Jmllllcu , RctJrod, 4riri3 Pm•k Blvd .....•. . .. . , Il

.. , ....••. . ... 208 WELDEN, JAMES ALFRED •.•.••••• 4G PniutN•, 4030 Go01·gln ...•..... , .... Il<'pnbllcn

2!)0 WASHBURN, HARUY ••••.••. , •• , , . 30 • If t •I ti •I I I ti J>rlvm·, 2:lOO Bpnuldlng Pineo . • •••... 1topubJ1 ! \VOOI>, JOHN ...... •• ' ' • ' ••••••..• no Il11lhlc1•, Pui-k Blvd., bet, Univ. & Pna•k. , • , •. R<•

\VOUKS, 'fHOMAS I.. EONARD , . , , , . . . 38 Rm1chci1•, AdnmR Ave., bet. Jclnho & Utnh . . . , Ro1 l ll 10/2812019 1910 United States Federal Census - Ancestrylibrary.com cf)l ancestry· William LTibbals in the 1910 United States Federal Census ------. - -,1\.-i.l • ' ·1:I 1' - ·11 View j

~ View blank form

Age in 1910:

Birth Year: abt 1872

Birthplace: Kansas

Home in 1910: San Diego Ward 1, San Diego , California

Street: Utah St

House Number: 4078

Race : White

Gender: Male

Relation to Head of House: Head

Marital status: Married

Spouse 's name:

Father's Birthplace: United States

Mother's Birthplace: United States

Native Tongue: English

Occupation: Machinist

Industry: Store

Employer, Employee or Other: Employer

Home Owned or Rented : Own

Home Free or Mortgaged: Mortgaged

Farm or House: House

Able to Read : Yes

Able to Write: Yes

Years Married: 16

Neighbors: View others on page

Household Members: Name Age William L Tibbals 38 Lidia E Tibbals 36 Walter M Tibbals 15 Robert H Tibbals 13

Source Citation Year: 1910; Census Place: Son Diego Ward 1, San Diego, California; Roll: T624_94; Page: lOA; Enumeration District: 0140; FHL microfilm: 1374107 https :1/search.ancestrylibrary.comlcgi-binlsse.dll? _phsrc=Hdg6&_phstart=successSource&usePU BJs=true&qh=nlNdvl sALdyH7 J UoODPEFg%3D%3D .. . 112 D sr. 11 ,w E • J • Sw-~e_., ...... "Clh'°' Co• tousIISURUCE F. w. BRADLEY am;!.:=.:mwty no:n Real :r..tate ln All Branch- CII WHOLESALE AND RETAIL WINES AND LIQUORS &D 11119 can •I p,_rt7 for !(on-Rftldcat&. COIVEYAI 6 lol.o--otU.. ..&abrale4BN4JeyllprtJIC a. W. Cor. r-ni. &Dd C .n.. i 5 ii · _rao____ BAN__ D_IBGO __ c_,T_t_D_JllEC'l'O ___n_. ___ _ SAN DIEGO CIT!' DIRECTORY. 181 t .e ... ~ Miss • !i ': .I~ . F cgan Francis M, bkkpr India-St Mill, h 3327 L Ferris Beulah (wid Samuel), h 1224 xotb. ~i ;,. '5; !< Fegley Edward, inmate SD Co Hospital. Ferris Carl I (Ferris & Ferris), h 156o 3d. E. M. t. :::,;.tis E F ~~~~.t-: 0 chlmann Henry, h 64,4 Logan ave. Ferris Charles J, 2d Lieut Arti11cry Corps, res Fort o=.!!!!• .:. :; Fehlmann Henry Jr. bds 644 Logan ave. Rosecrans. Richardson 0 : =X ":" ~ FEIL JOHN, propr Mercantile Restaurant 854 5th, h Ferris David M, painter, bds 1224 10th. .:s-;,; o.;!, 1157 B. Ferris Elizabeth C, drcssmkr, bds 1224 1oth. ►•~ c:1- u :f'I ... • FelchCT James A, tailor, nns 868 3d. Ferris Francis C, cigannlcr August Sensenbrenner, Photos ~t- -gtii::;;N Feld Eva C, dom 1418 2d. bds 1224 10th. ~: 5~ t# ~ Feld Ida. waitress Mrs Barbetta Hcnko, nns 1116 D. Ferris Iris M, elk Marston Store, bds 1224 Iotb. ELITE STUDIO . 0 0 ti ,;t ~ Feld Valentine, h 913 F. FERRIS & FERRIS (Alda M and Cart I), druggists, 603 oli'~O,.; •.5'ii5 Fc:ldhackCT Frederick C, tinsmith, h 2816 F. 5th ne cor H. Cor. Q,I;:~.s~~1i ="":" ..g Feldmann Harrgy J. h Upas nw cor Dove. Ferron Existc, cabinctmkr 3232 K. h same. .:; :. r.H;c-f Fellows Bert L, hamcssmkr W C Topping, h 667 Ferron Peter N, inmate SD Co Hospital. fifth ~.!h:•g u57 B. Fesler Frank. reporter, h I 133 15th. •~: =~?: G Fels Lena, dom 2240 5th. Fetty Merta. fruit packer, bds 27th ne cor and . ::•-~:;;::~ . J. ~~= •ijuS Fetty Mrs Susan A., h 27th nc cor J. ,...!i o.,_ O F('Utrier Frank, laundryman French Laundry, rms F t i! ~tf,. 1231 Plaza. ~ ii< t.:1.~ Fcwcl John B, h 37 18th. Sts. 1111111111 Fickas Adam R. carp, h 413 Newton ave. C ■ NIHl9e Fickas Fred, monuments 546 6th, h 215 nth. TlU.ZPJIOD HSTIEEf Fickas Onnic elk, bds 413 Newton ave. STATE SI Fickus Mrs Catherine, furn rms, I 539 E. filJN Felsenthal Matilda (wid August), bds 734 IsL FIDELITY MUTUAL LIFE INSURANCE CO, C H Bald .POil THE Felt George B, bds 869 11th. win dist mngr, 911 5th, nns 7-8. ISTOKE Fenn Albert W, printer \V F Hutton, h 1332 10th. FIDELITY TRUST CO, Sam F Smith pres, Wm E Bud• Best Milk B. J. Peters Fenn Charles M, phys 651 7th, h 665 same. long sec, real estate 1047 5th. Propr. Fennell Frank M, barber Joseph Rhodes, h 1170 9th. Field Carl S, elk, bds 429 Julian ave. and Cream Field Edward C, salesman Western Metal Supply illK AND Fenton Edward, lab, rms 1140 G. Ferguson Allen R. rancher, h 155 Ida. Co, h 950 11th. UCISIITII Ferguson Charles, bds n27 6th. Field Estella, student, bds 950 I 1th. ill.EN'S Sun Filed Ferguson Edward, bds 1233 12th. Field EH, nns 1321 E. 8ciAon Fc:-guson Fidelia W, printer Evening Tribune, h Field George H, janitor, h 429 Julian ave. GN111Dd Field Herbert D, elk S G Ingle, bds 857 Irving ave. DAIRY Umbttllu 1233 12th. !!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Rep&in,d it--Put-rui.m_pRnt«.-J.911 3d, h ~7 Irvini ave. Ruon Ferguson Ollie, bds 155 Ida. AU.DI I IOIII Honed Ferguson R L, yardman Hotel Robinson. ~ LD RALPH ELLIOTn editor of Wealth, a week P&OnJCl'DU Fcrlin Daisy, dom 1054 24th. ~ r-h"'"~~ilding of San Diego, 1433 F, l"uatl7 Tr.de • AUlOOl10M '--.;./ ti3410 I. Bpedal•J Ferrari David, rancher, res Mission Valley. 11a1,,..x1a1nava1. COTUiY Field Wm, h 1945 State. lq,li&A l>l.... Ferrer Manuel, h 402 F. .1.44,- 1804 M 11:rNt Ferris Alda M (Ferris & Ferris), h 1245 12th. Fielding Robert. nns 1036 3d. c.r. 71111 ,. I. la 110 nc New IJ■iycrsa) ZON-0-PIIONE raru.r ladii■c ml Disc: Records M. L. BLACK CARRIAGE WORKS SAN DlECO SEWING MACBINr. CO. Caniagel, Wagona, ud General Repairing. mwmitlw ud Roneahoen. 11. 11. C&A&G. Proprietor US FOUR.TH ST. • • • TELEPHONE BLACK 71 ••o ruu. .._ TeL a.. 18ft 10/28/2019 U.S. City Directories, 1822-1995-Ancestrylibrary.com

Ralpl'i Elliott Field in the U.S. City Directories, 1822-1995

View

Name: Ralph Elliott Field

Residence Yea r: 1904

Residence Place: San Diego, California, USA

Occupation: Editor

Publication Title: San Diego, California, City Directory, 1904

Source Information Ancestry.com. U.S. City Directories, 1822-1995 [database on-line]. Provo, UT, USA: Ancestry.com Operations, Inc., 2011 .

Original data: Original sources vary according to directory. The title of the specific directory being viewed is listed at the top of the image viewer page. Check the directory title page image for full title and publication information.

Description This database is a collection of city directories for various years and cities in the U.S. Generally a city directory will contain an alphabetical list of its citizens, listing the names of the heads of households, their addresses, and occupational information. Lea rn more .. .

Send Your Find Home!

Enter your email address and we will send you a link to your personalized Discovery Page where you can view and download all of the great finds you make while here.

I Send document

We value your privacy. Read our Privacy_ Statement

~ View Rrinter-friendlY.

Distributed By Pro~:5.r Powered By ~ ancestry-

https ://search. ancestrylibrary.com/cgi-bin/sse .dll? _phsrc=Hdg 18&_phstart=successSource&usePUBJs=true&qh=UsB BfzvpNrti2XRb 7xN2GA %3D%3D ... 1/1 ------·------·------

Geo. T. Vernon H10 FIFTH STREET SEPTON Bl.OCK •.TAILOR.. . Telephone 1912 Black

CLASSIFIED BUSINESS DIRECTORY

PRECIOUS STONES FRYE, OARRE1T & SMITH, Mexican lmportJns Co, Albatron IOJI 6th (see page 7 and ne cor Thornton. opposite). NAYLOR K C, 950 5th (see SAN DIEOO DIRECTORY left side lines). CO, 1031 6th (see page 14). SAN DIEOOUNION CO THE, PRINTERS - BOOK AND sw cor 3d and D ( see back JOB fty leaf). Baker Bros, 1326 C. Bikes G P, 1529 E. Spencer \V S, Ocun1lde. COOKE & CHRISTIANCE, TRIBUNE PUBLI.SHINO CO, 1128 D (see opp page 104). Field Putnam, 915 4th. sw cor 3d and D (see back FRYE, OARRETT & SMITH, fly leaf). 1031 6th (see page 7 and opposite). PUBLISHERS-MAP Gould, Hutton & Co, 1320 E. Grandler Frank & Co, 844 8th. .SAN DIRECTORY CO, 1031 Harb• J H, 862 4th. 6th (see page 14). Heath A H, 930 Ith. Hildreth H w, m llb. Sikes G P, 1529 E. ---- Spencer W S, Oceanalde. *PUMPS KESSLER• PAR"ISON, 727 PRODUCE-\VHO£4ESALE 7th. Uelzen Henry, aw cor 1th and I. .STERNE BRO.S CO, nw cor Nye & Nluen. aw cor K and 4th. H and Union (see back paster). * PROPRIETARY MEDI- CINES *PUMP REPAIRERS Chlllan Remedy Co, 101% 6th. SANDROCK \V C, Mission FERRIS & FERRIS, 603 5th, (see right side lines). Valley (see adv at \Veil STARKEY J B, 5th and D Drillers) (see adv at Index Letters in Alphabetical). *QUARTZ MILLS TRIPLET KEYS CO-OPER• CALIFORNIA QUARTZ ATIVE MEDICAL CO, 751 MILL CO THE, 858 4th (see 7th (see page 366). Vlavl Co The, 843 5th. page 495 and on map). PUBLISHERS *RAGS COOKE & CHRISTIANCE, ). 11 ~ 0 p page 104 FREY BRO.S, 566 to 572 4th led Ralph Elllo 3410 I. (see page 489).

Sheppard Cycle Co.cttt THE BEsT Bicvm 958-960 SIXTH ST, P•ane Rd 1733 * £1¢0eland 1noex 10 breat neg1ster 01 ~an u1ego uo,, ua1,, lStn waro, 1s1 rreouua

KO. OP IVOTINOI ADDRESS AGU BALLOT I ~o !lo, NAME I :> ...... ,. I 5 I Casty, Bart ...... • . . 323 I J st ...... • . • . • . . . • . 53 . . 52 Chase, Benjamin F ...... 33 16th st ...... • . . 43 53 De Frate, F A ...... , ...... 245 27th st .. , ...... , ...... 42 . . 54 Davis, Thomas M ...... 2638 N st .. , ...... • . . • . • • • • . 22 55 Dithlefsen, Paul A ...... •... 27th st, bet I and J sts...... • . 64 56 Divoort, Eugene C ...... 3434 J st ...... • ...... •• , 48 ...... 57 Davis, Theodore J ...... 3702 M st ...... 28 58 Dunn, James P ...... 3212 J st ...... •.. 40 .. 59 Davis, Chas H ...... 3155 J 3t ...... 65 ...... 6o Daily, Aaron ...... •... 429 17th st ...... • . •...... 6o ...... 61 Damarus, A Rudolph ...... 3722 M st ...... 37 ...... 62 Ellison, Fred Oliver ...... , ?626 N st ... , ...... • • ...... 3 I 63 Emerson, Luther G ...... 230 21st st ...... • . . 76 64 Ecker, Frank S ... , ...... 3753 L st , . • .. , , , • • • , • , • , , • , , • • 44 65 Evans, Wm F ... ., , ...... 3712 M st ... , ...... •. 34 66 Eichenlaub, Ivfartin ...... : .. 440 I 7th st ...... • ...... • 46 67 Ferron, Launcelet ...... 3232 K st ...... 30

······\"I...... 1 68 Fleishman, Moritz H ...... 2727 H st ...... 28 ...... 1 .. 1 69 Fickas, Fred ...... 22nd and M, s s of M. bet 22nd, 23d 28 ...... I . · \ 70 Frasier, Stanfield B ...... , . 2940 J ~~t , , , .. , . , . , . . . . , .. • , , . . . 50 ...... I .. 71 Fchlmann, Sr Henrx ...... 261 19th st ...... , ...... 70 ...... I .. 72 ..... 1e o:-Rat h .. El 1ot ...... 3410 I st ...... 35 ...... I .. 73 Fran , olin ...... 283 I J st ...... • . . 37 ...... 74 French, Asaph K ...... 3128 I st ...... 6o 75 Fewell, John B ...... 37 18th st ...... 73 76 Freeman, Jarod A ...... · \30th and M sts ...... , • . . 34 77 Foster, Charles E ...... 2723 H st ...... 42 .. I 78 Frcnnett, Lewis N ...... 9 18th st .. , ...... 50 79 Fairbanks, Albert F ...... 118 20th st ...... 6o . ' .... 80 F rencl1, Stephen ...... , .... 3423 L st .. , ...... , ...... • • , .. , 6o . . 81 Fegan, Francis 1\1 ...... 3327 I st ... , ...... 40 82 Friend, John ...... 151 16th st ...... 64 83 Flint, Herbert D ...... 1109 17th st ...... 25 84 Gregg, F M ...... End of M st ...... •. 56 85 Gylling, Ole ...... 245 18th st ...... 41 I I I I I I .. I .. I 86 Groves, Scott ...... 3405 K st ...... 21 87 Griswold, William ...... 246 I 7th and L sts ...... 32 ..... 88 Groves, Samuel L ...... 3405 K st ...... • • • • • • • • • • , • • • • 47 ...... 89 Gregg, Jr, R J ...... 541 17th st ...... , ...... 26 90 Gower, :Marshall 1' ...... I 3 I I 7th st ...... 24 ' ... '...... 91 Goodrich, Almon G ...... 19th and N sts ...... 71 92 Gibbons, Philip J ...... 346o J st .... , .... • • • • , • • • • • • • • • • 39 93 Grosvenor, Royal W ...... 447 22nd st ...... , ..... , . , . . 58 ...... , I 94 Gainder, Edwin ...... 3427 L st ...... , , .. , .. , ...... 35 ...... I 95 Gray, James W ...... 146 18th st ...... , .•..•.. , ...... 32 ...... I g6 Green, Francis l\'l ...... 245 17th st ...... 62 ...... I 97 Gregg, Robert J ...... 465 18th st ...... 6o . , I 98 Gauteraux, Francis ...... , .. 3435 L st . , . , ...... , .. , • .• , . 63 I I I I I , · 1 99 Goetze, William ...... 2624 L st ...... 68 .... ' •• 100 Greus, Julius ..... , ...... 535 I 7th st . , ...... 6o 10/28/2019 1940 United States Federal Census - Ancestrylibrary.com cf)j ancestry·

Ralpli E Field in the 1940 United States Federal Census ------

~ View blank form Name: Ralph E Field

Age : 59

Estimated birth year: abt 1881

Gender: Male

Race: White

Birthplace: Iowa

Marital status: Married

Relation to Head of House: Head

Home in 1940: Oakland, Alameda, California

Map of Home in 1940: View Map

Street: Rhoda

House Number: 3896

Farm: No

Inferred Residence in 1935: Oakland, Alameda, California

Residence in 1935: Same Place

Sheet Number: 15B

Number of Household in Order of Visitation: 298

Occupation: Salesman

House Owned or Rented : Rented

Value of Home or Monthly Rental if Rented: 42

Attended School or College: No

Highest Grad e Completed: College, 2nd year

Hours Worked Week Prior to Census: 44

Class of Worker: Working on own account

Weeks Worked in 1939: 52

Income: 0

Income Other Sources: Yes

Neighbors: View others on page Household Members: ------"'--Name Age Ralph E Field 59

Angelena Judith Field 51

Frances Edith Field 27 https ://search .ancestrylibrary.com/cg i-bin/sse .dll?db= 194 0usfedcen& indiv=lry&h= 73546838 1/2 10/28/2019 1910 United States Federal Census - Ancestrylibrary.com · cf)J ancestry·

Belthasar F Shoudel in the 1910 United States Federal Census ------·------

f . I -

View

0 View blank form ..------Name : Belthasar F Shoudel [Be t "asarFS ondel) [Belthasor F Shoudel)

Age in 1910: 57

Birth Year: abt 1853

Birthplace: Germany

Home in 1910: San Diego Ward 8, San Diego, California

Street: 25th Street

House Number: 419

Race : White

Gender: Male

Immigration Year: 1868

Relation to Head of House: Head

Spouse's name:

Father's Birthplace: Germany

Mother's Birthplace: Germany

Native Tongue: English

Occupation: Fireman

Industry: Bakery

Employer, Employee or Othe r: Wage Earner

Naturalization Status: Naturalized

Years Married: 21

Out of Work: N

Number of we eks out of work: O

Neighbors: View others on page Household Members: Name Age Belthasar F Shoudel 57

Albertina Shoudel 52

Mary A Shoudel 19

Bertha F Shoudel 14

Frank F Shoudel 12

https ://search.ancestrylibrary.com/cgi-bin/sse .dll? _phsrc=Hdg49&_phstart=successSource&usePUBJs=true&q h=0v5wDWH ILX2gogRg 1T uS2w %3D% ... 1/ 2

1 STATE f:.P.LfD=i..=----, .... ui DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE-BUREAU OF THE CENSUS 1°••- ISUPERVlSOR'S DISTRICT No 'I . j ~~~ No: · cou,;;_~~&tA·- - - . . ,.,. FOU~EENTH CENSUS OF THE UNITED STATES: 192

~o. ot NAME Sex Occupation and Addrea ■ 0 Rallot Party Affiliation

··· ····· ·•·"··· ...... 12-10 ltANDAIJIJ, 1-'RANCIS 1'1, •••. , , , , .Mnle Pennuts, 3·1'12 1{ •••• , •••• , , , , , • Republican I 12-1 I U.AXHON, CHAlH,f~!il , ••...... , . ,l\lnle , JJlnemnn, 3lS10 M , • , .• , ..•. , • , , .Democratic ·· ·••···•··r ...... 12 .. 2 Ill Jt.A \', Uf~ORGR 'N, ••..••..... , . , l\lalc Bookkeeper, :Jl',26 I , , ••• , , , , .•• , Democrntlc

Ill RlJiJS,' l\lAUD W •. , , ..... , l•'emnle Housekeeper, 3404 I •... , , . , , , .. Republican .. . ·· ······· ·· ·· ····

I I 12.ar, UHOAJ>RS, THO!\IAS C...... , .- , l\lnle Cle1•k, 340-1- I. .. , ...... Republican

Ill 2-16 HHOAnS, l\111.,DRED .•...... • , l<'cmale Housewtrc, 3474 M • , , .. , , •...•.• , . , •• , No

Ill RHOADS, \\'lLl,IAl\1 T ...... ,l\lale Cont:ra<'tor, :J-174 l\l • , ••...••. , , . nepubllcan

Ill 2-1-ff IUCHF.Y, J,'J,ORA G •.. , . , , . , , .. l<'emnle Hommkecpcr, 3417 H ... ,.,.,,,,, .Republican

Ill 2-1-0 RICHEY, '.JAY H. . .. , .•.....•... Mnle 1'~ai·mer, 3-117 H ..•. , ...•..•.•. Republican

2u0 RIORDAN, l\llCHAF.I, ,J, ...... i\11110 Tenmstcr, 3."522 I .•• , , , , , , ..•.. Democratic

Ii 2;;1 HOUJ<--:U-TS, EUl,IA 8, .. , , . , , ... 1''emule ' Ten<•her, :l-1»1 K .. , .. , .• , ..... Democratic "' HOUIXSON, CF.GIi, H, .••.I\, .... Mule Clerk, 3401 L .... , , , .. Socialist IU 21'\:J HOOT, Jo'RANCES A, .• , .•.. , .. 1''emale Housek('('per, 007 23th, •. , , ..•... RepubJlcnn

Plm,te1-er, 205 26th , •••... , , •.. Democratic ...... 2:i-1 Hl"X\"O~. XATH.\XIAL .. , ...... l\l1lle

H\"AX, l<~LLA S, ...... Femnle HouRekeepe1•, 3lS70 J . , , . , ••..... Republican

J>1'El!ilsmnke1•, ars70 J ..•...... Republicnn ...... 2ri0 lt\"AN, ETHEi, M, .. , .. , , ..... l<'emnle

~n-; RYAN, THO~l:\R ...... l\lnle l,awyer, 3.~70 ,J • , •..• , •.• , , , • , . Rep~bHcan . . : ...... T<•umste1·, :J»:12 L . , •. , ...... , . ReJ>UbHcnn ...... ········J2l'iH RA l'Jo~R, CHAR...... , .. , ... l\lule

...... 12:iO SCH1\ll1Clmnle Housekeepea•, 3G75 L .. , ...... Re1mbltca11

...... 2(10 SCHMUCIOm, JOH;s N•... , ...... Male Cm•11ente1•, 3575 L . , • , ...• , ..•.•. Socialist

...... 261 SCHUl,ZJ<~, GRORGR \\'...... l\lnle Plumber, 3-1-00 1\1 .•••••••••• , ••. Republican

202 SJ~:liSRNR\', ADDII<~ P. . . , ..... l<'emale Housekeeper, !1604 I .. , , , , , . , , , , Republican ti 20:J Hl'1NS1<:11mY,

I\ s1

lwHtnurunt, :J-103 K , . , .. , , , , . , , , , ••. , . No ti Lnboa·e1•, 4-1-0 :.?!Sth , • , . , , .. , , , , , , Republican

II 1'1otm·m11n, 21 21'Sth , , , . , •. , .•.. , Republfoan

200 Hl\ll'fH, J<~l,IZABRTH T, , , , • , .. Pemul~ Housekee1>er, 3424 K , , , , , , , , • , ,_, Republlr.an 10/28/2019 Ancestry Person - Print ~ancestry·

Beade R (Bert) fihorpe (carpenter) 1873-1957

II When Beade R (Bert) Thorpe was born on August 15, 1873, in Mundy, Michigan, his father, Stephen, was 35 and his mother, Helen, was 20. He married Louise (Lizzie) Stark on May 20, 1895, in Genesee, Michigan. They had three children during their marriage. He died on August 30, 1957, in Los Angeles, California, at the age of 84.

,i Vernah Carol Thorpe !al Stephen Rowland ,,&. Smith 1.Z.J Thorp

[.f J Helen H Bigelow

Minn

t. ltJ11ho Orn. Wyo. (-- - _,

,, NP.hr. Iowa ... Cheyenne• . • Ill . Ir.ct. u 1at-. folo, United Stat~s st.- Louis 1, l(an~. Mo. .,0 I 1 . ', . Ky. I .. I I Okla. • / Te 1111. l . N.M...... --.... Atlanta• • Dallas Ala. ' G~ .

•Chi~

1873 Birth

Beade R (Bert) Thorpe was born on August 15, 1873, in Mundy, Michigan, to Helen H Bigelow, age 20, and Stephen Rowland Thorp, age 35 .

15 Aug 1873 • Mundy, Genesee, Michigan, USA

1880 Residence

Beade R (Bert) Thorpe lived in Mundy, Michigan, in 1880.

Marital Status: Single; Relation to Head: Son

1880 • Mundy, Genesee, Michigan, USA

https://www.ancestrylibrary.com/family-tree/person/tree/53967731/person/172088015433/story 1/3 10/28/2019 Ancestry Person • Print 1s9s Marriage Beade R (Bert) Thorpe married Louise (Lizzie) Stark in Genesee, Michigan, on May 20, 1895, when he was 21 years old. ~--- . ------Louise (Lizzie) Stark 1876-1945

20 May 1895 • Genesee, Michigan, USA

Birth of Daughter His daughter Vern ah Carol was born on January 27, 1896, In Flint, Michigan. - -I Vernah Carol Thorpe Smith [.l ' 1896-1973 27 Jan 1896 • Flint, Michigan

Birth of Son His son Rowland Clarence was born on May 2, 1897, in Flint, Michigan, im Rowland Clarence Thorpe (auto repair) ~1:!~ 1897-1964 2 May 1897 • Flint, Genesee, Michigan, USA

Birth of Son His son Clifford Frederick was born on January 23, 1899, in Flint, Michigan. Jil:!11 Clifford Frederick Thorpe (university police officer; electrician) · ' 1899-1952 23 Jan 1899 • Flint, Genesee, Michigan, USA

1910 Residence Beade R (Bert) Thorpe lived in San Diego, California, in 1910,

Marital Status: Married; Relation to Head of House: Head

1910 • San Diego Ward 81 San Diego, California, USA

Death of Father

His father Stephen Rowland passed away on April 181 1918, in San Diego, California, at the age of 79, : riiil; Stephen Rowland Thorp ·!.'!!II 1838-1918 18 Apr 1918 • San Diego, California USA

https://www.ancestryllbrary.com/famlly-trae/person/tree/53967731/person/172088015433/story 2/3 10/28/2019 Ancestry Person • Print

Death of Mother His mother Helen H passed away on September 2, 1938, In San Diego, California, at the age of 85. . Helen H Bigelow 11].. - 1853-1938 2 Sep 1938 • San Diego, California USA

Death of Wife

His wife Louise (Lizzie) passed away on October 181 1945, in Los Angeles, California, at the age of 68. They had been married 50 years. jffll, Louise (Lizzie) Stark :Jr~_I 1876-1945 18 Oct 1945 • Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California, USA

Death of Son

His son Clifford Frederick passed away on August 18, 1952 1 in Ashland, Oregon, at the age of 53. 'g· Clifford Frederick Thorpe (university police officer; electrician) '--- _j 1899-1952 18 Aug 1952 • Ashland, Jackson, Oregon, USA

Death Beade R (Bert) Thorpe died on August 30, 1957, in Los Angeles, California, when he was 84 years old. 30 Aug 1957 , Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California, USA

Residence Beade R (Bert) Thorpe lived in Flint, Michigan. Flint, Michigan

https://www.ancestryllbrary.com/famlly-tree/person/tree/53967731/person/172088015433/story 3/3 10/28/2019 Ancestry Person - Print ~ancestry·

Beade R (Bert) Thorpe (carpenter) BIRTH 15 AUG 1873 • Mundy, Genesee, Michigan, USA DEATH 30 AUG 1957 • Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California, USA

Facts Family

Age 0- Birth Parents 15 Aug 1873 • Mundy, Genesee, Michigan, USA Stephen Rowland Thorp 1838-1918 Age 7 - Residence 1880 • Mundy, Genesee, Michigan, USA 1·1 ·1 Helen H Bigelow 1 1853-1938 Marital Status: Single; Relation to Head: Son · '1J

Age 21 - Marriage Spouse & Children 20 May 1895 • Genesee, Michigan, USA 11!J1J. Louise (Lizzie) Stark 1111 1 Louise (Lizzie) Stark IJI '~ 1876-1945 If'~ (1876-1945) , • j Vernah Carol Thorpe Smith Age 22 - Birth of Daughter Vern ah Carol Thorpe ,IL 1896-1973 Smith (1896-1973) iJ_Rowland Clarence Thorpe (auto repair) 27 Jan 1896 • Flint, Michigan 1897- 1964

Age 23 - Birth of Son Rowland Clarence Thorpe (auto '■ , M• Clifford Frederick Thorpe (university police •-· officer; electrician) repair) (1897-1964) 1899-1952 2 May 1897 • Flint, Genesee, Michigan, USA

Age 25 - Birth of Son Clifford Frederick Thorpe (university Sources police officer; electrician) (1899-1952) Ancestry Sources 23 Jan 1899 • Flint, Genesee, Michigan, USA

Age 37 - Residence 1880 Un ited States Federal Census 1910, San Diego Ward 8, San Diego, California, USA

Marital Status: Married; Relation to Head of House: Head 1 Age 44 - Death of Father Stephen Rowland Thorp (1838- r- -~~fll1910 United States Federal Census 1918) 18 Apr 1918 • San Diego, California USA I I cftt Ancestry Family Trees Age 65 - Death of Mother Helen H Bigelow (1853-1938) I 2 Sep 1938 • San Diego, Cal ifornia USA Ir LJ'""" ,I California, Death Index, 1940-1997 I Age 72 - Death of Wife Louise (Lizzie) Stark (1876-1945) - __ / 18 Oct 1945 • Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California, USA Michigan, Marriage Records, 1867-1952 Age 79 - Death of Son Clifford Frederick Thorpe (university [J police officer; electrician) (1899-1952) ~ Web: Genesee County, Michigan, Marriage 18 Aug 1952 • Ashland, Jackson, Oregon, USA ' I LJ ! Index, 1836-1934 Age 84 - Death 30 Aug 1957 • Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California, USA

Residence Fl int, Michigan

https ://www.ancestrylibrary.com/family -tree/person/tree/53967731/person/1720880154 33/facts?ssrc=&ml_rpos=2 1/1 Index to Great Register of San Diego County, Cal., 8th Ward, 2nd Precinct

NO. OP Voting BALLOT o~ No. I NAMm AOU Ooc:upatlon and Addre11 Party ~fflllatfon I> I I ...... "i423 SELWYN, GBORGE 1\1, ••• , •• , , , , , , , , . 40 Butchc1·, 410 Seventeenth St .••••••. Republican ...... ,424 SIJ\IMONS, DYRON CHARLES . , , •. , , 32 Electrlclnn, 3822 L St ••••• , , , ••••• Republican ...... -i4~ SCALI~Y, THOJ\IAS .....•....••.•.•. 33 Clerk, 400 Sixteenth St. , ••.••••••• Democratic ...... -i420 SGHJ\'111), WM. O . .•.•....•.•...... 2o . Butcher, 3338 I St ..•.. • • ,.,.,,, •• Republican

.... , ...... 427 SETTJ~J

,. , , , , , .. , .. , }2• SCHMTI>, CHAllLES H...... no Dutcher, 3340 I St .• , ••..•• , . , •. ' .•• Republican

. , , ...... • 430 SPROTT, ADSAWJ'II n .. , , ...... , , . , GO Stockman, 3329 IC St .•..•..••••• , , Democratic I ...... , 431 SHEPARJJ, AUSTIN •...... , . . S6 Carpenter, 22G Twenty-sixth St .••••. Republfcnn I , ...... 432 Sl\lITH, FRlER, NELSON S ... , . , ..... , , .. , 33 Laundryman, 2228 J St, ...•..•• ,, .Republican

...... 1435, Sl\lITH, J. RUSSl

430 STRIJCE, FRI

4:JR TELSON, JOHN W ... • , . • . . • • ...... 37 Engineer, u21 Nineteenth St ...... , . Republican ...... 14:JO ...... ,.. u TULl,AR, GEORGE W .. , ..... , . • . . . !Sri D1·ive1•, 8121 I{ St •••...••••.•... , .Democratic

) . T , , , , , •, •, , ,, 72 t i t t t O t fl IO ♦ t t Portc1•, 424 Seventeenth St ..••••..•. Republican

.~ ...... so Policeman, 424 Seveuteenth St •••••• Republican

, , ...... , , , 44:J THORNJHKE, MAYO W .. , .. , ... , ... 47 l\lcl'chnnt, 403 Nineteenth St .•...•• . Democratic

...... , . .. 444 TYJ,Im, GEOHGE W ... , , , , . , ...... 23 El'nngelist, 3108 I St ....••• , ..•• , .Republican

...... -U~ THOMPSON, JAl\lES s ...... I'S-I ncth·ed, 3108 K St ...... Republican

...... -HO THOI\IPSON, FJLJ,TS HOWARD ... , .. , 2:J Dentist, 3108 I( St ... , .•.. ,, .. , ... Republican

...... -l-17 Tonn, WALLAOE J ...... rsrs Dnrber, 3378 JC St ...... nemocratlc

-t-J.H THOJ\IPSON, SILAS O, •..•...... , l'SO Ilookkeepel', l524 Twenty-second St. , . nc1mbllcan

:: :::: ::::1:::: HO TYl,FJR, LI~Vl E ...... l'SO Couh•nct01•, 3108 I St .••.•• , •• , .•• Democratic . . , , , .. . , , .... .u;o TIU

... , . , , , . , . , . , ,l!H ')'J\'l'J,;, JES!U~ , . , ..•.. , .. , , , , . , , , .. rso l\lc1•cl11mt, 8300 L Bt, , . , • , •. , , • , • , . Republlcnn

. , •• , , • , , , • , • . 4.l'S2 TIBUALR, HENRY H.,, .•.... , , , • , . OD noured, 403 Twentieth St., ••• , , , ••• Republlcnn

, , , , , , • , .. , , , . -1rs:1 THOJ\IAS, GJOORGlij R, . , .. , . • ..•. , . :m Uutchc1•, l533 Blxtcouth St ••.• , •• , •. Rc1mbllcnn 115 a111111rs a ■ d M11afaot11nn Hartwell Electric Co. ARTISTIC 640·644 BROADWAY 955 SIXTH STREET ELECTRIC FIXTURES NEAR SEVENTH IT,

1120 SAN DIEGO CITY DIRECTORY-1915. SAN DIEGO CITY DIRECTORY-191S. .1121 An ------·------· Accident Thompson Walter, lab. r 1207 G. Thorne Ilarry (Emily), r l0-12, 11th. Who's Thompson Walter C (llattie) carp, h 3852 Beta. Thorne John A (lfary A) cigars 511 F, h 615, 13th. is not Thomp,<0n Walter 1-:, r ~r,2 Bet.a. Thorne lfary B, tchr Cal Com! College, r 1-1-1-1 Lincoln av. Thornp,ion Walter J. lab Wakr o.. pt, r 120i G. Thorne Hose B, h 1-1-1-1 Lincoln a,•. Always ThompHOn Warren A (Dorothy )l) stock dlr, h 2.1il ColumbiL Thome Wm E (E.,;tella lf), h i53. 19t11. Walsh Thompson Wm, mtnnn S lJ Elec II~-. r 213" In;ng a,·_ Thonihill .\nu G (wid John). r 716 Barr. a Thompson Wm (llaud L) C'BMhr. h :Jil!a Boundary, 1,;_ S. D. Thornhill Stanley (Clara A) papcrhgr, h i16 Barr. Disaster Thompson Wm A (Alice), h -12:J.j Eugene pl. Thornhill Wilbur 1.. hldi: eontr 4020 Jaekda\\·. Thompson Wm L (Laura P ) .-iv t'ng. h 2Jf,:J Brant. Thorn.1 ,Johanna, Heam l(ilton Tailol"!I, r 16:12. 4th. If you bavt Thomp,ion Wm )[ (Hattie U), mfr,; agt, h 1:na State. Thornton Andw .r ( (Ada C) phys 520.E rm 1000 and ph,'S Board or Thomson Alexandt'r D. <'Brp. h :J.:;s;J llenlo av, E. 8. D. Education, h 1612, 30th. • flRST Thomson Chas P. h t:!6 W Fir. Thornton ll..xsit• f'. t,·hr Washington Sch, r 342, 20th. called on Thomson Ern R (wid W I-') dn·,annkr 2021 (),iborue. Thornton Edgar It (Alice) carp, h :lii6i Sierra av. E. S. D. • Thomson Glad~·11 E. waiter, r :J8i5, 5th. THORNTON JACK E (Julia) adn•rti11ing 416 Granger Bldg 96-l Thomson ,Ja11 (Sadie) rest 38ia. 5th. ;;th. h 18-16 I. ' NEAL& ThomROn ,Ju (Emma) ltldg t•ontr. h 1:r.!, 25tfi. Thornton J,.,,die \' (J,;lla lf) f1111,lr. h 3103 J,. ThomllOn ,J&11 A Olartha) ~ -1(1()() Adams a.-, h 4006 same. Thomton lfart.'1 A (wid l..c,·i). r ,.- 1142d het G and l(arket. OUR Thomson ,Jilli A jr, sl11ntn, r -11100 •.\dams av. TI1ornton lf11rtin. h 648, 1:1t11. HOMf Thomson llargt, maid F S Grant Hotel. Thomtnn liar~· l( llni, h :u2., 20th. AGT. 625 f Sl Thone. Chat1 1-' (Anna )[) brewer )fi1111ion Brewing Co, h 3862 Reed Thon1tun ThoH I>, lah. r lo:tO, 1;,th. a,·, E. S. D. Thornton ThOll J-: ()let.. n W) hkpr C F O'Xeall, h 4938b Santa Thone Wm II (,Jennie). h 2602 K. lloniea a,·. 0.-ean Reach. ThorhUJ< Apts. lfni. lf E Hig~ prop 14.10, ith. Thomton \•e11nru1. r :liib7 ~ierra a,·, E. S. D. Thorhu11 llalph 11 (Floren<"e C) prop Ilotel Polhemus, and Hotel Thorold [.ila r.. mgr c-onet'llllion Pan Cal E:tpo, r 1319, 5th. 1''ord, b 6:J6 C. Thorp Bea,le H( J,j7.zie} hlkmnth Water Dept, h 2528 I. Thoren Alice ll, steno Ramey, llcKic & Rife, r 3702 Siaon av, Thorp Clifford ·F, student. r 2.'>28 I. ~ Pfahler E. S. D. an-e,· · r. r 80a 22d frye Buelow Thoren Jean E, <"lk W U Tel Co. r 3i02 SiBIIOn n, E. S. D. Thorp Ci1.1.i e. ·a1te -~ , Thoren ,John J. bldg contr, h 3i02 SiaRon a,•, E. S. D. KB 1ella e 1e ep ily at y, h 3563, 4th. & & Thoren :Mary, dorn 154-1. 7th. · Thorp Percy C. mu11ic tchr. r t:J56, 6th. Thoren liar;-· E, llleno Fred O'Farrell, r 3i02 SifillOn av, E. S. D. - Thorp Howland C, lob. r 2528 I. Smith fisher Thoreson Thore (Sophie) mach S D Elec Ry. h 4027 Utah. Thorp Stephen R (llclen). h rear 2:i28 I . Thorley Stephl'n W (Eli7.aheth) lah Water Dept, h 3i46 .Acacia. Thorp Willard B Re"", p811tor Fim Congregational Cb, r 344 A. Thonuodson Ole S (Wead.'10D) !ah, b 3826 )larine View av• . Thorpe Catherine (wid V P) tehr, r 4i96 IIamilton. Print Thom, see also Thorne. Thorpe Edmond C (Rose H) bldg contr 1981 Lin-wood. Thorn Lueile. student, r 1Si6 Eber, Ocean Beach. Thorpe Edmund L (Mary) carp, a ea Woodlane nr Conaty blvd, S This Commercial Thornberry Will, demonstrator concC11t1ion Pan Cal Expo, r 1170 F. Cbollas Valley. Directory Thornburgh Harry A. cook David Ilerah, r 5-t2, 6th. Thorpe Ethel, packer Izer Davis Co, r Eneanto. Linotype Thornbury Edwd A. r lliO Front. Thorpe Howard, appr I A Scribner. r E L Thorpe. Compositors Thorndike Alfd W (Amanda) (Thorndike & Son), h 656, 22d. Thorpe John (Anna) barber A W lloak, h H ,'33 B. Thorndike •.\lfd W jr. alsmn Studebaker Agency, r 656, 22d Thorpe Roae Hartwick, author, r 1981 Linwood. Thorndike llayo W (Lizzie) (Thorndike & Son), h 405, 19th. Thorpe Verna, r 2528 I. 856 Thorndike & Son (AW and lf W) 2d hand goods 657, 6th. Thorson Earl R (May) window trimmer Owl Drng Co, h 3470 Na Thorne Betsy O (wid ED). r 75.'J, 19th. tional av. Third St. 860 3RD Thome Christine A lira. h 2602 K. Thorson T T, b rear 7813 Silverado, La Jolla. Thome Fannie A (wid Francis). r 1"44 Lincoln av. Tboratenberg l(arie. maid 402 Spruce. San Diego

PHONES C LIGHT LUNCHES HOME 1929 ooAS MAIN 1211 5 10/28/2019 San Diego, California, Compiled Records From San Diego Genealogical Society, 1887, 1913 -1919-Ancestrylibrary.com <½)I ancestry· •

Stephen Rollancl Tliorp in the San Diego, California, Compiled Records From San Diego Genealogical Society, 1887, 1913 -1919 ------

View

Name: Stephen Rolland Thorp

Gender: Male

Death Age: 79

EventType: Burial

Birth Date: 28 Jul 1838

Death Date: 18 Apr 1918

Death Place: San Diego , San Diego , California, USA

Burial Date: 1918

Burial Place: San Diego , California

Description: Burial and removal permits from Bradley & Woolman Mortuary. Permits for the period Jan 1917 through September 1919.

Source Citation San Diego Genealogical Society; San Diego, California; California Burial Permits, Bradley& Woolman

Source Information Ancestry.com. Son Diego, California, Compiled Records From San Diego Genealogical Society, 1887, 1913 -1919 [database on-line]. Lehi, UT, USA: Ancestry.com Op erations, Inc., 2017 .

Original data: Compiled Records from San Diego Genealogical Society. San Diego, California.

Description

This database consists of various records that were provided by the San Di ego Gen ealogical Society in San Diego, California. Learn more .. .

Send Your Find Home!

Enter your email address and we will sen d you a link to your personalized Discovery Page where you can view and download all of the great finds you make while here. I Send document

We value your privacy. Read our Privacy_ Statement

~ View Rrinter-friendly

Distributed By Pro~~-( Powered By oi)I ancestry-

© 1997-2019 Ancestry • • https ://sea rch.ancestrylibrary.com/cgi-bin/sse .dll? _phsrc=wSH35&_ phstart=successSource&usePU BJ s=true&qh=8P 1 cpXSjBfTEptWU4iW4eg%3D%3 .. . 1/2 C!taltfnrnta iitau ilnarh nf 1!;.ralttJ BUREAU OF VITAL STATISTICS LOCAL REGISTRAR'S PERMIT FOR BURIAL OR REMOVAL N. B.:--Th1s permit can be signed only by the Local Registrar (Deputy or Subregistrar) of the Primary Registration District (Freeholders' Charter City, or other City or Incorporated Town, or Rur-ai Registration District) i,1 which the death occurred after the FILING and acceptance of, a CORRECT AND COMPLETE CERTIFICATE OF DEATH, LEGIBLY WRITTEN IN DURABLE BLACK INK. CE OF DEATH. DIST. No. ______Local Registered No. ___455 ______. (To be inserted bl' Registrar) • [If death occurred in a Co~ty of SA~ DIEGO hospital or institution, give its NAME instead of street City of SAN DIEGO ( N o. ___. _2_528- __ :'_I_t! ______St. ; ______Ward) and ·number.] Or Rural Regis- Date of death ____ April __ ..1B.:th.------19L.8. tration District ______(Month) (Day) (Year) FULL NAME (of Deceased) _____ S.t.ephe.n__Ro.l1and __ Tho.rp ______Sex---~~~~~------Color or race ______lTh_~-t~ ______Age _____ 7!J ______years ____ fl ___ months __ _21 ___ days

Cause of death I11a11i ticn ------Attendin~Yzj,cian,. . :r ... . · Proposed date of crilb-s -ti.oll 20 , ~ __D ...__Ji. __ !~~-thru.p..,__ fil ... _...U..T- lii~•Xlrot: ltmffll------J:;£.i______th..---:------191.8a, Place of rnt>CX.:._C.:rema ~n--~-Gree·m i:r.ooa------eerrietery ---San--D-iege-.----Ca-li~Nl-ia------Place of removal ______· ______via ______

Undertaker--·---, Br_a n· e;J'__- · & _~ -QO_m~.- l · · ______- Address------· · San . Diego.- __ ..______California .a. ______•• A CERTIFICATE OF DEATH having been presented to me containing the above stated particulars, and after examination the same ·appearing to be COMPLETE, CORRECT AND SATISFACTORY AS REQUIRED BY LAW (Statutes or California, 1915, Chapter 378, page 575, as amended, Statutes 1917, Chapter 548, page il'i), I ba\'e filed it with ove stated Local Registered Number,* and on the basis thereof I HEREBY GRANT A PERMIT to the above named undertal.-er for tbe ___ ._c,reJBa tiOD ___ _ (Burial, Removal or other Disposition-State how) • body .or said deceased person as stated• above. In the case or death from a dangerous, communica~~~;1-al or re.71 must be conducted according to the rules of R1e,._S_tate,_~d. l~~al boards or he~lth. -- o _r-~ ~ ~ - Dated ____ .Anr.i.l____ 2_Q.tll... ___ ~-~--i9i __8. ______:_~-~------~~--- -~~...... ---- / By______C::___ ~~ - ...,_:Brp tlt& or i'JhtA1T ist1r ; This permit is sufficient for the removal (and interment and cremation) of a body to any part of the State (subject to local cemeten· or other regulations), pro\ided that where removal is by common carrier, the above Permit must be included in the official Transit Perm.it prescribed by the State Board of Embalmers. • *Local registered number may be omitted from Permit fo;.• cert11lcate filed only w1 th Subreglstrar at pince distant t-rom county cent. or headquarters of Local nei:l.strar specially appointed ror Rural Registration District, but permit m~t then show name or Local Registrar by whom Subregtstrar was appointed and to whom certUlc:i.te, oiiu;t he forthwith forwarded. 10/28/2019 1910 United States Federal Census -Ancestrylibrary.com ~ ancestry·

Helen Thorpe in the 1910 United States Federal Census

I View I

~ View blank form Name: Helen Thorpe

Age in 1910: 57

Birth Year: a bt 1853

Birthplace: Michigan

Home in 1910: San Diego Ward 8, San Diego, California

Street: 17th Street

Race: White

Gender: Female

Relation to Head of House: Mother

Marital status: Married

Spouse's name: Stephen R Thorpe

Father's Birthplace: New York

Mother's Birthplace: France

Native Tongue: English

Able to Read : Yes

Able to Write: Yes

Years Married: 39

Number of Children Born : 2

Number of Children Living: 2

Neighbors: View others on page Household Members: Name Age Beade R Thorpe 36

Lizzie Thorpe 33 Vernah Thorpe 14 Roland Thorpe 12

Clifford Thorpe 11

Stephen R Thorpe 71

Helen Thorpe 57

Source Citation Year: 1910; Census Place: San Diego Ward 8, San Diego, California; Roll: T624_95 ; Page: 17A; Enumeration District: 0161; FHL microfilm: 1374108

Source Information Ancestry.com.1910 Un ited States Federal Census [database on-line). Lehi, UT, USA: Ancestry.com Operations Inc, 2006. https://search.ancestrylibrary.com/c9i-bin/sse.dll?_phsrc=wSH32&_phstart=successSource&usePUBJs=true&qh=/15pnjspeBlihjgpzklUuQ%3O%3D&g... 1/2 10/28/2019 1930 United States Federal Census - Ancestrylibrary.com ~ ancestry·

Helen H Thorpe in the 1930 United States Federal Census I View

~ View blank form Name: Helen H Thorpe

Birth Year: abt 1853

Gender: Female

Race : White

Birthplace: Michigan

Marital status: Widowed

Relation to Head of House: Head

Home in 1930: San Diego , San Diego, California, USA

Map of Home: View Map

Street address: Island Avenue

House Number: 2528 Rear

Dwelling Number: 13

Family Number: 15

Home Owned or Rented : Rented

Home Value: 10.00

Radio Set: No

Attended School : No

Able to Read and Write: Yes

Father's Birthplace: New York

Mother's Birthplace: France

Able to Speak English: Yes Household Members: ------=-Name Age He I en H Thorpe 77

Minnie Stark 85

Neighbors: View others on page

Source Citation Year: 1930; Census Place: San Diego, San Diego, Co/ifornia ; Page: lA; Enumeration District: 0174; FHL microfilm: 2339928

Source Information Ancestry.com. 1930 Un ited Stotes Federal Census [data base on-line]. Provo, UT, USA: Ancestry.com Operations Inc, 2002.

Original data: United States of America, Bureau of the Census. Fifteenth Census of the United States, 1930. Washington, D.C. : National Archives and Records Administration, 1930. T626 , 2,667 rolls.

Description https://search.ancestrylibrary.com/cgi-bin/sse .dll? _phsrc=wS H 30&_phstart=successSource&usePUBJs=true&qh =/15pnjspeBlihjgpzklUuQ%3D%3 D&g ... 1/3 10/28/2019 Ancestry Person - Print 4)1ancestry·

Minnie Thorp BIRTH APRIL 1881 • Youngsville, Franklin, North Carolina, USA DEATH 6 MARCH 1931 • Raleigh , Wake, North Carolina, USA

Facts Family

Age 0- Birth Parents

April 1881 • Youngsville, Franklin, North Carolina, USA ■ j Frank Hayes ,6,,. 1860- Birth (Alternate) I abt 1876 • North Carolina • I Ann Kearney 1.&. _ 1865- 1915 Age 2 - Birth (Alternate) abt 1884 • Granville County, North Carolina, USA Spouse & Children

Age 2 - Birth (Alternate) [f'"JRobert W Thorpe 1874-1939 abt 1884 • North Carolina Lucinda Thorp Age 4 - Birth (Alternate) 1.1 0 1895- abt 1886 • Granville County, North Carolina, USA Lonnie Thorp Residence 1.I.: 1897- 1880 • Fishing Creek, Granville, North Carolina, USA Luta Thorp Marital status: Single; Relation to Head of House: Daughter :.1~1898 - Age 2 - Birth of Sister Victoria Hayes (1884-) Mary Thorp Jan 1884 • North Carolina 'i7 1899- Roberta Thorp Age 6 - Birth of Sister Laura Hayes (1887- ) 1.tl 1902- Oct 1887 • North Carolina Chester Thorp Age 7 - Birth of Brother Bennie Hayes (1889-) 1.l.11904 - 1971 Feb 1889 • North Carolina Robert Connell Thorpe 1906- 1971 Age 13 - Birth of Daughter Lucinda Thorp (1895-) Ella Thorp abt 1895 • North Carolina 1907- Age 15 - Birth of Son Lonnie Thorp (1897-) '.l .1 Lee Zelbe Thorp abt 1897, North Carolina 1907-2003

Age 16 - Birth of Daughter Luta Thorp (1898-) Margorie Virginia Thorpe 1909- 2002 abt 1898 • North Carolina Eva May Thorpe Age 17 - Birth of Daughter Mary Thorp (1899-) 1910- abt 1899 • North Carolina 1■ '. Paul Andrew Thorpe Age 20 - Birth of Daughter Roberta Thorp (1902-) ,6,,. 1 1910- 1973 abt 1902 • North Carolina I ■ ] Sidney Thorp ,,JI,. ; 1913- 1930 Age 22 - Birth of Son Chester Thorp (1904-1971) Lizzie Thorp 2 Jan 1904 • North Carolina 1915- 1998 Age 24 - Birth of Son Robert Connell Thorpe (1906-1971) I .~ .J.. Private 6 March 1906 • North Carolina 1 Sources https://www.ancestrylibrary.com/family-tree/person/tree/42412151/person/7200104 7810/facts 1/2

10/28/2019 Ancestry Person - Print ~ancestry·

Rowlancl Clarente Thor:pe {auto repair) 1897-1964

When Rowland Clarence Thorpe was born on May 2, 1897, in Flint, Michigan, his father, Beade, was 23 and his mother, Louise, was 20. He married Ruth Elisabeth Baker on August 22, 1919, in Los Angeles, California. They had one child during their marriage. He died on December 14, 1964, in Los Angeles, California, at the age of 67.

1·•· Lois Lorraine I• j Beade R (Bert) Thorpe '.&.J Thorpe Wilsey .C. (carpenter)

i.fJLouise (Lizzie) Stark

s o w,s l:h1rm C re.

,; ~ . Cheyenne• . ' . \ . i It Ind. Ohio Nev. Ulah Cnlo. United States st: Louis , K,10,s . Mo . •. ; _·' . . Ky. a1or. Ok la. ,J Te nn. Ar k. ,' Anz. N.M. .. , Atlanta 0 ' • Da llas ) Mi1-s. AIJ. , G".

...... ,...... ,...... __=.u,_....,_...... _~ '&

Birth

Rowland Clarence Thorpe was born on May 2, 1897, in Flint, Michigan, to Louise (Lizzie) Stark, age 20, and Beade R (Bert) Thorpe, age 23.

2 May 1897 • Flint, Genesee, Michigan, USA

Birth of Brother

His brother Clifford Frederick was born on January 23, 1899, in Flint, Michigan, when Rowland Clarence was 1 year old. l]3 Clifford Frederick Thorpe (university police officer; electrician) • 1899- 1952

23 Jan 1899 • Flint, Genesee, Michigan, USA

https://www.ancestrylibrary.com/family-tree/person/tree/53967731 /person/1 72088016813/story 1/3 10/28/2019 Ancestry Person - Print

1910 Residence

~ Rowland~------;_ Clarence Thorpe _____lived in San Diego, _:;:...:_ California,______in 1910. ~ Marital Status: Single; Relation to Head of House: Son 1910 • San Diego Ward 8, San Diego, California, USA

1019 Marriage Rowland Clarence Thorpe married Ruth Elisabeth Baker in Los Angeles, California, on August 22, 1919, when he was 22 years old. ,· ·,

i ;I I_ Ruth Elisabeth Baker ! i 1897-2002 t i 22 Aug 1919 • Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California, USA

1922 Birth of Daughter His daughter Lois Lorraine was born on November 10, 1922, in Los Angeles, California. !Bl! Lois Lorraine Thorpe Wilsey ilW, 1922-1998 10 Nov 1922 • Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California, USA

1942 Residence Rowland Clarence Thorpe lived in Los Angeles, California, in 1942.

Relation to Head: Self 1942 • Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California, USA

Death of Mother His mother Louise (Lizzie) passed away on October 18, 1945, in Los Angeles, California, at the age of 68. ,ffllj Louise (Lizzie) Stark ,F~ 1876-1945 18 Oct 1945 • Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California, USA

Death of Brother His brother Clifford Frederick died on August 18, 1952, in Ashland, Oregon, when Rowland Clarence was 55 years old. 'm' Clifford Frederick Thorpe (university police officer; electrician) • 1 1899-1952 18 Aug 1952 • Ashland, Jackson, Oregon, USA

11ttps://www.ancestryllbrary.oom/family-tree/person/lree/53967731 /person/172088016813/story 2/3 10/28/2019 Ancestry Person • Print

19s1 Death of Father His father Beade R (Bert) passed away on August 30, 1957, in Los Angeles, California, at the age of 84. 1•] Beade R (Bert) Thorpe (carpenter) I.ti 1873-1957 30 Aug 1957 • Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California, USA

Death Rowland Clarence Thorpe died on December 14, 1964, in Los Angeles, California, when he was 67 years old, 14 Dec 1964 • Los Angeles, California

https://www.ancestryllbrary.com/famlly-tree/person/tree/53967731 /personl172088016813lstory 3/3 10/28/2019 Ancestry Person - Print 4)1ancestry·

Rowlancl Clarence Thorpe (auto repair) BIRTH 2 MAY 1897 • Flint, Genesee, Michigan, USA DEATH 14 DEC 1964 • Los Angeles, California

Facts Family

Age 0- Birth

2 May 1897 • Flint, Genesee, Michigan, USA Beade R (Bert) Thorpe (carpenter) Age 1 - Birth of Brother Clifford Frederick Thorpe 1873- 1957 (university police officer; electrician) (1899-1952) Louise (Lizzie) Stark 1876-1945 23 Jan 1899 • Flint, Genesee, Michigan, USA

Age 13 - Residence Spouse & Children 1910, San Diego Ward 8, San Diego, California, USA • -I Ruth Elisabeth Baker Marital Status: Single; Relation to Head of House: Son I,;,&. 1897-2002 Age 22 - Marriage "11 Lois Lorraine Thorpe Wilsey 22 Aug 1919 • Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California, USA 1\1 1922-1998 a Ruth Elisabeth Baker ,;,&. (1897- 2002) Sources

Age 25 - Birth of Daughter Lois Lorraine Thorpe Ancestry Sources Wilsey (1922-1998) 10 Nov 1922, Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California, USA j; •,- l/1 1910 United States Federal Census Age 45 - Residence 1942, Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California, USA Relation to Head: Self ; cB-1 Ancestry Family Trees

Age 48 - Death of Mother Louise (Lizzie) Stark (1876-1945) ' 18 Oct 1945, Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California, USA ' r'i.LJ , U.S. WWII Draft Cards Young Men, 1940-1947 Age 55 - Death of Brother Clifford Frederick Thorpe (university police officer; electrician) (1899-1952) 18 Aug 1952, Ashland, Jackson, Oregon, USA

Age 60 - Death of~ Beade R (Bert) Thorpe ) (carpenter) (1873-1957) ______,,,..--- 30 Aug 1957, Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California, USA

Age 67 - Death 14 Dec 1964, Los Angeles, California

https ://www.ancestrylibrary.com/family-tree/person/tree/53967731/person/172088016813/facts 1/1 Dul111n Hd MIHfHflrtl'I Hartwell Electric Co. ARTISTIC ~ .. ; _ _ff.._1-•-~~. 640·644 BROADWAY 955 SIXTH STREET ELECTRIC FIITURES ~ V~ l.7~ NEAR SEVENTH IT, An 1120- -- - =~N DIEGO CITY DIRECTORY~/ SAN DIE~ CITY DIRECTOR(-191y . 1121 Accident Thompson Wnlter, lab. r 1207 G. Thome Harry (Emily), r 1°'2, 11th. Who's Thompson Walter C (llHttie) c.'1lrp, b 3852 Beta. Thorne John.-\ ()lary A) cigan 511 F, h 615, 8th. is not Thomp,con Walter 1-:, r ai;;;z Beta. Thorne llary B. tchr Cal Coml College, r 1-Ul Lincoln av. Tbomp,con Walter J, lab Water Dt-pt, r 1207 G. Thome Hose B. h J-Ul Lincoln a,·. Always ThompHOn Warr.-n A (Dorothy ll) stock dlr, h 2.'Jil Columbia. Thome Wm E (Estella ll), h i53. 19th. Walsh Thomp,,on Wm, mtmm S 1) :t-:tec II~·. r 213., ln·ing av. Thornhill Ann O (wid John), r il6 Barr. a Thompson Wm (lland L) ea.~hr. h :17t!a Boundary, E. S. D. Thornhill Staole)· (Clara ,\) papcrhgr, h 716 Barr. Disaster Thompson Wm A (Alice), h -12:la Eugene pl. Thornhill Wilbur Z. hldg eontr 4020 Jaekdaw. Thump,ion Wm L (Laura P) ,·iv ,•ng. h 216:1 Brant. Thorns .Job11nna, seam llilton Tailors, r 1632. 4th. If you havt Thump,con Wm l( (Uatlic R), mfn. agt, h 1:115 State. Th~rnton Andw .J ((Ada C) phy11 520.E rm 1000 and phys Board of Thomson Alexaml .. r V. carp. h :l,'iS:I llenlo av, E. 8. D. Education, h 1612, 30th. flRST Thomson Chas P. h J:16 W Fir. Thornton n...... ie C. t<·br Wuhington Sch, r 342, 20th. called on Thomson E,·a R (,nd W I-') dn-AAmkr 2021 Oiihorne. Thornton E,l1,mr It (Alice} carp, h :l;'j6i Sierra av. E. S. D. • Thomson Glad~-11 F,. waiter, r :1875, 5th. THORNTON JACK E (Julia) acln•rtising 416 Granger Bt.lg 964 Thomson J1111 (Sadie) rest 3875. 5th. ->th. h 18-'6 I. ' NEAL& Thom11on ,Ja11 (Emma) lildg rontr. h 132, 25th. Thornto11 r~.'!llie ,. (Ella l() hm1tr. h 3103 L. Thom!IOn ,fas A /llartha) frrO 4000 Adams av, h 4006 same. Thor11to11 llan.'I ,\ (wid l..e,·i). r w 11 -12d bet G and llarket. OUR Thomson .Ja11 A jr, shmm, r ,Ill()() Adams av. TI1omton llartin. h 6-18, J:ltt,. HOME Thomson :"llargt, mai1l F S Grant Hotel. Thornton llary ll llt11, h :1-12. 20th. AGT. 625 f SL Thone. Chn,i I-' (Anna ll) brewer lliuion llrewing Co, h 3862 Reed Thon1ton Th011 D. lab. r 10:IO. lath. 8\·,E. S.D. Thornton Titos E (Helen W) hkpr C F O'Xeall, h 4938b Santa TI,one Wm II (,Jennie). h 2602 K. )Ionic-a a,·. < Apts. lln. ll E Hig~ prop 14-'J0, ith. Thornton \'e1111111t. r :l567 :--ierra a,·, E. !.. D. Thorhu11 llalph U (1'1orenl'e C) prop Ilotel Polhemus, and Hotel Thorold Lila I,. m,:r ronc:CAAion 1'1111 Cal Expo. r 1319, 5th. Ford. h 6:16 C. Thorp lka1le I(( Li7.zie) hlksmth Water Dt•pt, h 252S L Thoren Alice ll, steno Barney, lleKie & Rife, r 3702 Sisson av, Thorp Clifford ·F, student. r 2a28 I. Pfahler E. S. D. Thorp Ilarny, janitor. r 80.'i, 22d. frye Thoren Jean E, elk W U Tel Co. r 3i02 SiMOn av, E. S. D. Thorp Cizzil'. waiter l(anhattan rest, r 2528 I. Buelow Thoren ,John J, bldg contr. h 370-2 Simlon a,·, E. S. D. THORP-MILTON R (l,iahella G) chit>f dep city atty, h 3563, 4th. & & Thoren Mary, dom 15". 7th. Ib.u[p Perc~•!i.l:-tehr .r 1:156, 6th. ~ Thoren l(ary E, irteno ¥red O'Farrell, r 3702 Siqon u, E. S. D. - T11orpRowlin11C,-lah. r 2528 T. . Smith fisher Thoreson Thore (Sophie) mach S D Eltt Ry. h 4027 Utah. Thorp Skphen ..R (Ilelen), h rear 2-'i28 I Thorley Stephl'n W (Elizabeth} lab Water Dept, h 3i46 .Acacia. - WilliY

PHONES LIGHT LUNCHES HOMf 1929 50oAS MAIN 1211 REAL ESTATE John Burnham & Company LOANS lfit'~abu~~t~::uw THE DIXIE LUMBER AND SUPPLY GO. 212-214 TIMKEN BUILDING IND INSURANCE WE SELL EVERYTHING TO BUILD ANYTHING BOTH PHONES UNIVE~Y AVE. AND OHIO ST, 1050 1916-S.-\N DIEGO CITY DIRECTORY,1916 ') The Thorp Elizabeth llrs, waiter llanhattan Rtist, r 2528 I:---' ,=,-- - ~ 1916-SAN DIEGO CITY DIRECTORY,f-1916) 1051 Thorp 1-•~•I. hamm. r 469. 7th. Th11111ton llax, elk lloosios Branch 3, r 501, 14tii_= Campbell THORP MILTON R (Isabella G), chief dep city atty, h 356.1, 4th. Thwaites Robt (Zeta ::\lay), fmit dlr, h 1672 Union. Barney Tia Juana, ;oee also Tijuana. & Machin Thorp Rowland C, marinr, r 25ll8~ Tia Juana ,·allt'). Oil Co, J F Scott pres, .A J Razeto sec, J F Dehm Thorp Stephen·"·c~~h.t R (Helen)_h 2508 I. mgr, 861 , 6th. rm 326. Barney OIJ) Y ernah. r ~ I . · Tibbals Rt>na Y (wid ,Tos H), h 2542 I. Co. Co gregational Ch, h 1808.3d. Tibbals Robt II, student Kelsey.Jenney Coml Coll, r 3211, 31st. -mThorpe Edm1,1nd C (Rose II). hldg eontr 1981 Linwood. Tihhals Thos J (Nancy L), candymkr. h 230-l. 30th. .• AUTO Thorpe F..dmund L (llnry). earp. hf' K Woodlane 1 S of County blvd, Tibbals Walter ll (llild~ ll), clk Western .Auto Supply Co, h 1627 lnsuraau S Chollas Valley, RFD :J. Bx 9&.H. Lincoln av. · , Bonds, loaas MARINf Thorpe Ethel. elk. r E L Thorpe. TihbalK Wm L (Lydia 1-:). pres Western Auto Supply Co, h 3211, 31st liability AN8 . Thorpe Howard. jeweler I .A &-rihnrr. r E Z Thorpe. Tibbetts, see also Tebbetts. Compensation Thorpe John (Anna C)-. barber A W )1011k. It 1232: 11th. Tibbetts Bt•atriee llrs, confy 23"261/:: Julian av, r 2:15-1 same. Thorpe Ro.4 _.Tulian.av. GtNfRAl Thorsburg Rev. pastor SwcdiKh Salem Church. h HU. 5th . . Tibbetts Della l[ l[rs. mu·sP., h 1521 F... PAOflC IIUTUAl RfPAIRS Thol"llOn T T. r rear 7S13 Sih·erado. La ,Jolla. · Til,beits Rliz.al~th ll :\I~. dl't'Smkr 40:lS Sierra&\", E. S. D., r same. Uft INS.CO. Thou~mpe Wm. w-R.Sher Cnunty Tlosp. Tibbetts. llorace ll (Eli7.11heth h 4038 Sierra av, E. S. D. . :m, t. P. llfClll. AIL feetef Thrall Edith E. r 41-H Eairk Tihhi~ Ooh T. C!reo SO llnion. h 1915 Kearney av. Tibemed IIarry W. elk Piano Clearinl? Ho1111e, r 316 C-edar. Thresher Isahella A ("·id WT), r :ti38 Fairmount av. E. S. D. Tice Adeline ll (,rid ~ C). h 36-IO, 6th. Throp Ree alao Thorp. Tice Paul. Pn:ssmn, r 3<»0 India. · Throp Aaron D (Adaline). h 13.1-1 Cnion. Tichhome Chu T, insp City Operating Dept. h 929 Ocean blvd, La . Throp .Adalint- llns, prop .-\dalint- Apta. r 1:l.1-1 ( nion. .Jolla. Palace Thrower Frank. helpr A W JohMOn. r 9-13. -4th. . Tichenor llaud ("·id N D), h 732. 10th. Dry Thudiehum Carl L (Roberta), phys 102.'l, 4th. rm -111, h 1228 .fAigr.- Ticht>nor Xorwood G (Rose), h 1938 Columbia. mont. Tickl!ll Geo W (lfor;y), al~mn Fttvert-Bleruroe Furn Co. h 2218 Alb& Oeaning Thuland Conrad ll Dlarthn) atty. h lit 6. 30th. tl'Ollll. and Thurber Carrie E (,_;d ~ T) •.r 3330 .AlbatNIIIII. . .Tickham F.dwd, prop Bway Skatinl? Rink. b ~. 11th. Thurman Allen L, hillianl11 50-_~q Xe,.·port u·, h -1665 Saratoga a,·, Tkknor W H11hert (Helt?n C}, mill Coremn RnR. hkpr. r lfi.'16. 2d. Tit!d('mann & Allgoe,rer (TI O Tiedemrum, Ricbd Allgoewer) real est HATS Instructor Thumaond llarguerite R llrs. h ]5t,G. 2d. 344 B. or Thumt'II David N, tilei,etter S lJ Tile & Woodstone Co, r 815; 3d. -. Tiella Thos. Jab, h K11rtz. Old Town. Tlmmes llatthins (Nellie J:,'). eondr SD Elec Ry Co, h 908, 24th. Tierney Eli~th L. r 38f'3, 3d. PIANO THURSTON CLARK, pres Point Loma llomrstntl. r Point Loma Tierne~· Walter P (Elizabeth), agt :Met Life Im Co, h -ll89 Wabash n-,~101, llom.-sh•:td. · av, E. S. D. ,-J=~ ... ..•. .. Thur,-ton .John C ( Eliz .J l. h ~-l-16. 28th . Tiex.iera "..\larion A. elk .J A Gardner, r 1331, -Ith. ,ze...... , Titfan~· Cl(•aoen;, Arval Wallll~t? prop. H17 t"niversity nv. MIi NW. CAL CONTRACTORS Wall P•,..-. PP!b, Oils, Art Crafts Wall Paper&Paintco~ YUMSIIU, ffC. COMfORT a,cct•tCAT•o••• eca,c.•• •• coc.o• aCMc••• LIVE WITH US IN a•o caT1aaTca •v•••••t• M~• 1316 1224 fourth St., San Diego, ul. .... •rs AT FIRST .AND ,. &TS• 8ENERAL INSURANCE, BONDI H. A. CAMERON CO. LOllll, RENTALS, REAL ESTATE THE OFF ICE OF EFFICIENCY NEARPASS' SEED STORE ::~~a: 531 UNION BLDG. NIIII Ill.II ..a.. IIMI ITII 801H PHONfS 522 SIXTH STREET ~b hrCYPtlfRS ~ 1917-SAN DIEGO CITY DIRECTOR\;::!V 1025 Johnson Thorp Rowland •, sailor. r 2528 I. Tibbits Dob T (Pearl C). corp US A, r 1071, 26th. Thorp Stephen R ( llt-leo), h 2521:! I. Tibbits Fannie l[, r 240-l llarket. Saum rP Vernah phone OP,.t~1' ~ r 2528 I. Tibbot Ernest G (Ida R), tel opr Santa Fe. h 2-16 Cedar. Tho I a tf'"ReF"'(.rosejihirae llT.paitllr-Fi 'ongregatioual Tiht-rend Ambrose C, vulcanizer H F Bittaker, r 18-18. 4th. Company Church, b 16-&0. 3d. Tiberend •.\nu (wid A E) .(Huella & Tiberend), h 18-18, 4th. Thorpe Edmund J. (lfary), carp, h e • Woodlane 1 a Imperial av Tilw.-ttnd Harry W, elk Hamiltoos, r 1848, 4th. S Chollas Valley R D 3 Bx 96-IL Tit-hbome Chu T, r Ocean View Hotel. La Jolla. Thorpe Helen l(ni, r 2140 K. • ftJNfRAl Ti,·henor llaud (\\·id X De Witt), h 732. 10th. fut Thorpe Rose Hart\l"ick (wid EC). author. h 198) Linwood. Ti,•henor Xorwood G (Rose). b 1746 Columbia. DIRfCTO Thonen Alfd B (Elizabeth), b :uu F1orence. Ti,•kell Geo W (l[ary P), ahnnn Frevert Bledaoe Furn Co, h 2218 Thrall Edith E. r S:JO, 20th. A.ellll-izM + .\lhatro&K. IY UDY ASSIST4tn Threlfall Earl l( (Ruth), atereo S D ·won. h 10-l2, 26th. Ti,·kham Edwd, prop Broadway Skating Rink, h 935 Bway. Thresher Isabella A (wid W I), librarian County Free Library, E. Ti1•knor W Hubert (Helen C), foremn Ru• Lmhr & lfill Co, h 4232, GIST + S. D., h :J7&J \'an Dyke a,·, E. S. D. -'th. N. w.c.r. Throckmorton Benj P, r 4075 lioivenrity blvd. Tic:o Ralf'h R, carp. h 399..5 Louiaiana. INSURANCf Throp Aaron D (Adaline), carp. h 1145. 11th. Tid1-on1be Elisa A lfffl, h 1:J.17 Gregory. f..-tll & Asia Thrower Frank G. waiter J lf B Andencon. r ~ Front. Tidball .\lht J (l,uella R). pharmacist l[onarch Drug Co, h 3786 SOMa + Tlmdichum Carl I. (Roberta). pb~·s, b "662 Ivanhoe. La JollL Colonial 11,·, E. S. D. • Tlmland Conrad. ll (llartba), au~·. h 1716, 30th. Tidu-ell Silas E (J..ouiae C) (Homer & Tidwell) and auto opr S D QlUIIA.QII TWNIICS Thurber Carrie E (wid ~athan T), r 3330 AJbatro.. SUIISO.IMIIIISI f'itt Dt-pt, h 29"22 Clay u·. mo.c-. -IISI Thurman Ephraim W (Nellie P), b 4879 Newport av, Ocean Beach. Tie.-rnl'y Eli7.aheth L. r 386:J, 3d. Tbunnan John (.\nna E), carp. h 3185 Imperial u •. Til'me~· Walter P (Elizabeth) aolr llet Life Ins Co, b 4189 Wabash Thurman Raymond (Georgia), bartndr J H Foley, h 1619 J. a,·, E. RD. . Thurmond Clara B. steno. r 1655, 4th. -- Tiffan~· Cleaners, _.\rval Wallace prop 1417 University av. Thnnnood Ethelin E. hkpr, r 165.'i, 4th. Tiffan,r G Stanton. capt ~ S A. h 3366 Park"av. Thurmond llargaretta A (wid DD), b 1655, 4th. Tiff'any John H (Helle), earriage mkr, b 3185 J•• Tburnell Dand l(, tile setter S D Tile & Woodatone Co, r 815, 3d. Tiff'11ny .John X (Emma A), b 312:J L. Thnme11 lfatthias (:\'ellie 1-'), cond SD Elec.• Ry Co, b 8'0, 2laL Ti'ithe llaggie (wi,1 Thoa). b :uo W Beech: frye THUUTOR CLAllK, pres Point Loma Homestead, r Point Loma TiKtlP Jos (Ray), h 314 n. Homestead. Tijuana Fair. Antonio Elo11ua gen m,.'T, office 1007, 5th no 102.'i. Tbnnrton Beaie. student State. ·ormal Sch, r 4560 Campus av. & ,., "': . ' ' Tijuana Joek1w Club, see Lower Cal Jockey Club. t..-.. -~-1:. Tbnmon Hannah E lln, r 3d se cor A.sh. TI.JUANA & TECATE KAILWAY CO 6:33 Spreckela Bldg. •...... , Tbunton John C (Elizabeth ,J), b 34-16, 28th. Tilden Craig L (Xella ll), 1d111Dn. b 4:J68 Selma pl. Smith -..... Thuniton l(ax (F..eonomy Fruit Co), r 860, 20th. Tilden Frank O (Fay I,) (Thomp,ion & Tilden). h 518, 26th. Thunrton Motor Fut.>1 Gaaifier Co. o{ Cal, II I, Titua see 235 Bway Tilden Katie lln1, h 1229, 8th. HEBRON rm 310. Tilden ll11ry J (wid Austin), b .U:12 Reed pl. Print Thurston ll Loine-. r 3d ae cor ."-h. Tillap,m~h Sarah J (11"id Geo W). h 4085 lTnivel'llity bh·d. HOME THURSTON WM G (Cornelia II), v-prea Cannichael-Thunton & Co Tille~· Chu ll lf1orence), h 9:JS Ash. This ferACUl'IQI II (Inc), r 3NI lie eor Ash. , Tilley ,foe .A (llariraret), cook Glasford &: l[alin. h 718, 12th. Oiredoly u-.-...... Thwaitea Robt (Zeta), ■lama Davie■-0,·erland Co, h 1672 t:nion. Tille~· llargaret )(111. cook Glasford & l\faJin. r 718, 12th. t.:~w·· TihbaJa Laton S (Clara V). carp, h 2542 I. 1 Tillinghast Amy R, tchr, r 1:J45 Torrey rd. La Jolla. ~ll,-!" Tibbals Robt, student, r 3211 Ray. Tillin,rhast Ralph W (Alice H), bldg contr 73-16 Girard, La Jolla. c::2.:..... Tibbals Ruth \ r, salea agt 1025 -Ith rm 228, r 25-12 I. l Tillnum Peter, lmhrmn Ruaa l..mbr &: llill C-o, h 1651 Gro,·e. 1825 Tibbals Then J (Xancy), candy mkr, h 2.104. 30th. Tillman Robt, r 442, 18th. 856 NfWTONAVf; TIBBBTTB see ablo Tebbetts. Tillman Wm G (Kittie), filter opr S D Co1111 G & E Co, b 49 Loe PMOIII: ■ Tihhetts Della ll lll'II. nunie. h 1521 E. Pio011 a,·. Sierra ViMta. Third St NOMI: 32■8 Tibbetta Elizabeth lira, dreamkr -I038 Sierra a'", E. S. D. MAIN-9 Tilll!On Estella C. steno t.:'nion Title Co. r 1422 Fem. Saa Diego SAIIDGO.CAL Tibbetts Horace _ll (Elizabeth ll), b -I038 Sierra av, E. S. D. Till110n Geo l( (Coral(), painting_~ntr 1422 Fern.

IT'S OUR BUSINESS TO MIND YOUR BUSINESS 9"l\~X"Tt:,lJ:EET MASTEN & KENDALL 5"'-,~l ... :f"~l"'-5 ccna1•, an ,,.., 11 msr _,.n ,ua 1111 auua■ PJ " - -.m 11 • uu 10/28/2019 Ancestry Person - Print ~ancestry·

1 Aoward Carson Thorp BIRTH 6 JUN 1898 • Flint, Genesee, Ml, USA DEATH 2 AUG 1977 • Rancho Santa Fe, San Diego, CA, USA

Facts Family

Age 0- Birth Parents 6 Jun 1898 • Fl int, Genesee, Ml, USA ,. Edmond Lucian Thorpe 1~•.,r.J 1871- 1958 Age 52 - Death of Sister Ethel H. Thorpe (1896-1950) 1950 • San Diego, San Diego, CA, USA Mary S Stark 1872- 1964 Age 60 - Death of Father Edmond Lucian Thorpe (1871- 1958) Spouse 11 Sep 1958 • San Diego, San Diego, California, United States Sources Age 65 - Death of Mother Mary S Stark (1872-1964) 9 Apr 1964 • San Diego, San Diego, California, United States Ancestry Sources Age 79 - Death r -, 2 Aug 1977 • Rancho Santa Fe, San Diego, CA, USA I ~ ! Ancestry Family Trees

https://www.ancestrylibrary.com/family-tree/person/tree/51061206/person/1620 7 4 230984/facts?ssrc=&ml_rpos=3 1/1 -· ;rt Mortgage . lnsurancffi .:;;:·j: ilo~--E·:·-sERT Ex·p·fftsnebaacb J B 8232 W-alaon Ellen Mn, Uth 2461 Briaa F H 3236 Picco Dio~o Kitahner Mari.ha 1466 ~11.;tmi Co 2462 Hunter F H 82«7 Chamberlin Eli9 Miw 292D Youns. Iaabol Mn, 1469 Gatewood Geo 2464 Baker C N 3267 White Wm ...... ,, ProuCop dfoot R H 4 • ..,. pedgoGW 1480 Eleatiia Laundty 24M Gerlach Anna Mra 3260 Monmo Antone 14.n Masconi Lollie 2468 Rotering Bernard 3260 (reAr) Rase J C 15th 24n Brooks &m1 3263 Cluk M C Mre 1602 Budhl Felli; 24741-c,yBC 3272 Olatcn J H 2476 !,yna1i L F 3274 Vacant =~~Jeaua 2f77Krolll'rMo.z 3276 Sumler J L ms Mariano o~ Mrs 2f7981miWC SlllDilet Lathnn PAeJs Jo:, 2480 Weber Mlcbl 8279 Vacant Ui30 Fawrt E M 2481 Dllvq Varnor• 3284WylloWA lM2Bmlth OE 2482 Meilleur Chu 3291 McCall C R 16th 09terman.i, M D 3296 Trivoli Do~_, __ 1614. ~ Bolla Mru 2486 Roberti! J A Mn, 3296 (ttar) Arev,,clo ...... v 1616 Edlaoa Grant 2'91 Cliae M111Y Mn, 3297 W"UlSCOtt J C 1619 Moon; R R 24116 Andoraon C o ?daaon 3311 Withcll HanY 3312 LnosloY J H =~f: 17 3819 HWDphreY E F 3347 Allen Fmnk 3403 Poienc>D Alld.v U36 SulliTIID E E 3"2BoloombRE 26th 8468 PellWoi~ to 815th)

3602 Beudcrooia Wm ISLAND AV

7809 Youna J A: ==vs7824 Coseml .H 8 7832Zc>derWE~ 7830 ThoUlllOD StoJJhoD· :llldi 7847 Stratton Olular°· . 7B63 Grimm Bo ~ PGrker T ~ 7862 Do.vd.Y L :S: 78e8 Rowell ll L 7864 81rl CE 7866 Da:J7DC9 R A -70ma,~cD-- a..-ouii o~~ · 7902 l!eQWI L H 7912 .Gib~ 'Re4 M< ~lt~· I 7922 ,Li,tliroP J 11! . ,,' 796&I)ralmltNMi!I I ·: -: 7990 e,;o,,,t A'V""'d.t~'l ~ ,,·t, xv:y,...'E & la~ ·1~~ -~~ 108 por,ward,J ]j' . i/ ' ..p~J ,C . \, 2GHJililar. ~-~ . :' I\ 220 BrouihtaD•ifiei'· .. , . 2ll7 IRailf:J IS• . ; ,, 2211 -11~ f'loie!!•P __ ,.;uni!.'s 11 280 •Mi-T~~tto-~ ~-- -g~1ijf'IJ~~;' ;\ )\l.,, .. COLEMAN .MORT&-AGE CO. INC. lflT'SlNSURANCE IGILMAN A. GIST AGENCY • ,J "insures Everyching .Rga;mt .Rnytlrir.g·· MO!Tl!J8E tOA11S AJIB TRUST DEEDS • IEAL ESTJ.U • 1lffli[MEll1S • INSUBAIICE 11 214 c STREET PHONE -3-5998 Remember Gist Telephone 3-5546 44-1 Spreckels Building 604 SAN DIEGO CITY DIRECTORY (1926) SAN DIEGO CITY DIRECTORY (1926) 605 Klrkaeter' J"oh'D B capt F1re Dept r I226 24 Kitto W :a: nocar;y JJUblfc 11 %S9S :t,o.p.n: &Y c.w. mtSEPJIC Xlr- :smm. r llG8S :Bancrott Kltt:red,;e Lewn T (LeI& S) tclxr Blcb Scl:I ,. - <:o:ru, X ('Will 3 'W) h as:8S Bancroft 31-&5 .,AJba1ro9S •Fnmkblpr~Balcer,s'r'10:l.2Sth •l?a>,l:S:<1edcbdSD&:<:or=aFe Xlncl:I :&ma Mz:s "1a14Y ~" Cone< SboP • Gei-tnlde K l&s r 3628 Stb. Jcu W. lmlJ r Slmd1'on1 Hotel • Klamaa Walter Vegetable "Union) r PAOOSmf X!raber Ve:rnc:m T r ::n:l. 29th %'l46 Lop.n &'V' XIn:aer :Nathan r 1"628: Fens X1zer Chas E auto- tap& Sl'O li!arket r 614 .za.me- VAIOOSHfS • PblDlp ;,: ai=,,aJ,. S) (Jtellal>le ;,:m,11: Co) h • .:i.,p...,. T a 3481 1m Fem Kjbaug ,earl o,;e,nQ &laa11, h DH 334 lOratlae BUDard (Holen) ma.ch .. ms - Klala lWDDk (wfd Wm) b "526 Ore,;on &emwDemmlic NatiolatA.ve. IOrt. :Ji.farlc ecp. Wu:tcm. Lmbr Co r :t2S C - Wnz ..?r 1D&Ch 11.::don on Co r fS26 ~ Xll'tJand Fnmk (Be&U'lce), ahop :Co=n L lt Klaman :i&x emi, C S :B:atdY r 1401 G ailt'Mlliilc D&~ ,. :mo Co1mabtnc KJamer ~ l< ("'1d B E) h = Um • Ban7 :S (Louise) blbmth h •o'ZS ◄- Klamm Hem:,- r 589 llfh ' cormw:roR := =.:.--~... ?'Ina Co r 10111 '1Qh KJ.a;Jp:: (w!d ~ llbrarlJm h <= CC- _,___ ~II.3588 ~ Ed- B (Bentleo- &'lilrtk:r) h 47.S< B:Ja,o,en Geo T ~ T) {Q=lltr - Kenmore ter • Co) r nu ll1h • Ellis I l&b r E T Kl~CY • Per.er D lab b. 3S'iS- ◄9th hf,rllaapic • =- B lab r •= :S:e,m,oze """ Xladnsb" 'PIPII (Dorathy) r 1f!i1 State • El:eldel T (Sqnlb :I) :r-ancber h D- ffl' Xl&uber Alice h 26%9 M Fresc:oWodr. s .f1Ch. • Alla-n ttUdt r 3060 Park a.v - Kcne:1:b. D l&b r .f%3I Xenmore 'ter KLAUSER EDGAR E Y-.Pra Ktaiuber W.angett- Klrm Adolph :S Ti:llc b. 2115 ffth bolm co r Lea An;.cies "Semi finish"' XlrVen C!b:ltoo boteI cllc :r S09 ll:th KLAUSER LAWRENCE N {Grace Gl ,,ci supt 3918 fad St. ad • Do=s ('wld Brla1ow) (C) b :1568 l,{etllo ,._.. :sa.; Diego eo,,sou- ·- &. Electric • H~in!,. ~") ~er h 2'MG Co h 2569 FN>nt • u.- ~ llill<:ret145' "Raicflllry" • Von,on E (Helen 1<) adv :mgr~ 0, b KL.AUBER MELVILL!a (Amy S) ,,,_ >u- JSSO Alta .Mlt:& pl W.angenbetm. co office ,co.c. $oUtMrrl nt1o • Wm T (Frances F) U S ?,;" 11 250{ lndla. bldg 948- 3d :It S060 P.aric av Xll-wfn .A!bt J.t bl4r :t' UM Xamiaa • Stelk h m7 M - Garrett K (B'.tamah .r) h UZt Kama,, !herd -, Who!- - X!sbJmm: ltaade- blc:pr Earl C .)!yea,: Elec Co Clgan and T~ Te-.. Coffeu.. Ex- r <&100 Bawtes blvd 'tr.aC.ts... Splce:r. C.lffdy• era~ B&kcrS.. lOs)cadden. Wm E ('Emllle E) h 31!l8- L&un::l_ Swpptfca,. ~ Market. ne COt' 4th ltlslmdd- ....,,., Q Mn h m Unm,nlz)' av Xlaa8 Amold :J (Ilor<>thY) lCbr ft Loma H!sh IQssamXandc)(rsrT6Sloth SChh2'15Siodl& llJ.BselNormal>A-h-r 1434 F • Kie&verJ'obDF(LllllanB)audLC-h ~foY- moalder Barth Foancfm7 fflT .Arden ~ 2528 Islmld - , . K!eclcer .JOI! R (Louise G) driver Gas 0, h 3"G ·-•eo. XJstkr ~!:: N&t1 Bank r :90S S :ioec..!.~ L mech ll!il>'« &, :Bo:rce r :2520 F El- Theo C (Allee H) x:o;c:" T C XlstDer & Klee B: (Lois) me:ell w~ &. Xafell ~ ~ c:uti.rH- Kelle>' Lnd:r Co h -uzs Nes- Xleln L) l>llfr' h 36:14 LaD4ls - ~ ~~~- •TC&: Co Theo C :xi.mer m&:r &%Cbltects • Ber=~-- :~ .... cc~,;:'"M>~ l)b:!e L=b: - • ~:.,...- E W D_,,._ Sr r 4509 • lI!:,.~~ =~ ~ - Co r · ;...,~OF~~'~~---~ h - n:::.:!~:kceoor:.USlmpcxiQ1lLY - 3935 Center · • llerb't- W (Cortane) alsma' Worth Co l:t S8S1 Xlttd1Al>~ ~ ~ F:a:ak) (N....- Llncob:i: • ;,:,.~~ - 'Wbltlnc-Mead: Co r S6'0 :tt2lt .REALTOR :1050 9th Street Wl,a,,Each~&Aaa-..dc::....t.W,-., n,,, F....a,-n-tzeW--~Pictm:waM ~ Phone.. Main 1980 DRJ;VE J:N Camfartand PL.ame laO...-F...t~ Rao !t'lePric:a,~AHaw,-C r . .,

. '

• • t

10/28/2019 1920 United States Federal Census - Ancestrylibrary.com

Minnie Stark in the 1920 United States Federal Census

View

~ View blank form

Name: Minnie Stark [Mennie Stark] [Minnie Stork]

Age : 75

Birth Year: a bt 1845

Birthplace: Micklenburg

Home in 1920: San Diego , San Diego , California

Street: Ocean View Hughts

House Number: X

Residence Date: 1920

Race : White

Gender: Female

Immigration Year: 1880

Relation to Head of House: Head

Marital status: Widowed

Father's Birthplace: Germany

Mother's Birthplace: Germany

Native Tongue: German

Able to Speak English: Yes

Occupation: None

Naturalization Status: Naturalized

Able to Read: Yes

Able to Write: Yes

Neighbors: View others on page

Household Members: Name Age ------=-- Minnie Stark 75

Source Citation Year: 1920; Census Place: San Diego, Son Diego, California; Roll: T625_130; Page: 48; Enumeration District: 226

Source Information Ancestry.com. 1920 United States Federal Census [database on-line]. Provo, UT, USA: Ancestry.com Operations, Inc., 2010. Images reproduced by FamilySearch.

Original data: Fourteenth Census of the United States, 1920. {NARA microfilm publication T625, 2076 rolls). Records of the Bureau of the Census, Record Group 29. National Archives, Washington, O.C . For details on the contents of the film numbers, visit the following NARA web page: NARA. Note: Enumeration htlps ://search. ancestrylibrary.com/cgi-bin/sse .dll? _phsrc=wS H20&_phstart=successSource&useP UBJs=true&qh=cuMBkgcpR8jJ4QMs3rkS8A %3D%3 .. . 1/2 10/28/2019 1920 United States Federal Census - Ancestrylibrary.com

Helen Thorp in the 1920 United States Federal Census ------

I View

~ View blank form Name: Helen Thorp

Age: 66

Birth Year: abt 1854

Birthplace: Michigan

Home in 1920: San Diego, San Diego, California

Street: 1Street

House Number: 2528 Rear

Residence Date: 1920

Race : White

Gender: Female

Relation to Head of House: Grandmother

Marital status: Widowed

Father's Birthplace: New York

Mother's Birthplace: France

Able to Speak English : Yes

Occupation: Housekeeper

Industry: Apt house

Employment Field : Wage or Salary

Able to Read : Yes

Able to Write: Yes

Neighbors: View others on page

Household Members: Name Age ------='-- Marion Burns 27

Ethel H Burns 23 Vernon M Burns 1

Helen Thorp 66

Source Citation Year: 1920; Census Place: San Diego, San Diego, California; Roll: T625_132; Page: BB ; Enumeration District: 332

Source Information Ancestry.com . 1920 United States Federal Census [database on-line]. Provo, UT, USA: Ancestry.com Operations, Inc., 2010. Images reproduced by FamilySearch.

https ://search .ancestrylibrary.com/cgi-bin/sse .dll?_ phsrc=wSH23&_phsta rt=successSource&usePUBJs=true&qh=/15pnjspeBlihjgpzklUuQ%3O%3D&g ... 1/2 CALL OUR SALESMAN ·souLEVARD EXPRESS, INC. PHONE fRAllltLIN 2214 301 W- ■ t G St,.. t SAN DIEGO TO LOS ANGELES Phone. Franklla 1177 BAGGAGE, HOUSEHOLD GOODS, ETC., TRANSFERRED 1035SfCONOSTI!m' OPP. UNION Tmf CO. EASY PAYMENTS DAILY SERVICE "Authorh:ed Motor TN101E C.N'ler" SAN DIEGO CITY DIRECTORY 0928) 754 SAN DIEGO □TY DIRECTORY (1928) 7S5 Strac-han C..:ro •: K (liar)·) carp b 2.155 Union - J (tf' tThereA) h n%U IVth STOPHER CEMENT. STONE. BRICK & ROOF S tolt FNd "" (Ca.th) pdlr h %080 Jn·lnK a,· - 1-,o)·d ll (Winifred E) ■ at C1ty Plwnbtnc • JM O Jr (\.lrdnla G) fllHma b l7ll7' Rkhmnntl TILE FACTORY. (Frank D Stopher) STOTT K W (Dorothy C) S.C-Tre- CAMP Jrutpr b $1% Santa q..-ra pl Stra.thdtt Dougl&P s tntpt t.:alun l<-e Office and Factory 191D Logan av Phone r:■ 1"11Ke BELL CHEVROLET COMPANY. h 17:M - Wm J r tO'it 46th Cn h 935 8w'1l,.- · Main 1712 (See left aide llne ■ and page Oul:1.ot.. Ocean Be:ach su111c-k Helen ~,,. nu.--. h tu, Rua blvd Stratrnan Xar,- r 11 4◄ ?d 41) • ·wm O (Virginia )f) mac.h h ltl! Coplcw a,· • Hf'nry J (LUii.an H) aud Buulc:vard Exprctl8 Strounn Bert ll (Son.a D) pbiltr Ill! 'W Brouk~ STOPHER FRANK D (Christle: Stopher Ce S t.11tt• C LcR1J1· (E11ther) fllamn Quatlttt Vair) h %150 Pine •'" ment. Stone. Brick & Roof Tl1e Factory) .. J,_ r 111, Ruaa blvd • Chnfl R pt.tr r tlS1 f",e11r,da StadloCowu ProduclJI Cd h 3511 C olller kV h 11211 <:Roby - Mat¥1 hUOW'! )(eff')' H091> r , ]11' Rwat bl• d - Cha,i w (llanha R) carp h or. Dtftll& aT Htoudt Ann.a r 67'4 Brooklyn u· Ennnv, N..i. Stoppehnrth Fred (Hattie) h :i:i Cllntun • Karry (l!lnnlc) ftbT h G7'4 Brnol;lrn u,· Str11do. Loula: C CKath L : Pe,tiplc-N Yl•h Co) h • C"1audit R (Grace) 1'81 ~ DOl :':annal b Aatiqaeo 8toppleman J Htnr>· (Luth~) chaur r 4104. KM.n- Encanto 3735 Jndla 391K C"c•,ner Strudder Catherine dk r Y A • (·Ufford H chauf r ~cu Eui;:~ pl Fabrica • Leon A · r !otl W • C.haA E Jan :-:euncr 8"1'11 r 1!,0 Cnl\· ,._,. .. OUu E (Helen) en,: h 401! Alabama. • Rlc-hd F pl1ttr h 4~ f.,oullllan.a n'OYTIIIIIG -J@lper Stnthl.mann Edw (C hry11tal; Strahlmann-11a:rer • Rny o J::Jec lty Co • .Ju C (Ella F) carp h 4&.sC Sanah.!Ql av O B :-itralle,- EdnR ll (wid C t-!) r !,Ill lUth • J,1hn h 340C llounl.:aln \ "lew- dr .. J a,i (Rh~ld.tt H) n;x h z-n· AbhHffl,l W Ueut »41 n ~train &11& V ltni trhr C"ft,- .SCha r Sl.01 1-U.rk STRAUS S W A CO. H V Emtllett Mgr. lft'lfft- .. Jua us:,.; r Kan~ • llantt (wtd CJ C) h 4il0 Ha11•lc.-Y bh"d "' IA!"°ll A (Rath L) h ?4?G Wl~hlrnAn • Minnie L r ~11 Chamherlaln ct O B btvd ment • Bond ■ 210 .. 211 San Oleao Trust & WILBUR GUYC. • lilaurlce L (Clad)·1t H) 11l,.mn Ba)· l~lt}· Linen • .101' F bolltrmkr Kl ■ tulant lrun Wlot h li'i'! Saving• Bank Bldg 5,30 Broadway Cor Mh • \ \""m T (Allc-,,. )!) K1"0 35-411 t:nl'° a,· Su11p h 5147 HUltot> dr Enau,t,., Park blvd Phone FranltHn 410I (Se• pag■ 38) F. Stnute-nben: tBlancht') .meat· ctr- •· ~ f:"<'T'f1'"'· • Ray W (Wllff"Nla l,l) ,·-1n·-e11 Ottat.-r SN.n Ham· C :-;u•Jit Loubl s · o•:v .. l)'n) oCflcc-r Suu !ltr:n.,,.lwn: l,tax (Jflnct) a,;t Nitw Ynrk Ute Hardy h 1141 12th 'rru11t hr Dank of Italy h Ho«; A WARNER Diego Inv Corp h ◄ !ZS Jlllnnh• Jna l'· Co) r 3510 NIie uv · • llorrf11 G tn-ederlC'lca) h ◄ ta Palmetto ...,.. u OR TOD Stnrton Albt baker Continental Ba.kine Co r Stover Alla.n J • (llaud~ R) arth•t h 4%! Slh-itr • Ch.rtJIUne D h 35il 4th • R ProdlK"'C' C'u H StraUNI m«:r C03 Sth (w,d Autt) h ?lllJ -~ ◄ GJO Arlaona G11te a ,· Pt Loma - ,.~,. ·w • Sanford K al11mn r U19 Plllrnetto way ~ SMALL .. AJ)Artmcntll ()tr,i F B Stover) 40~ Center .. HelPn J:: r l5jl; ·Uh M • Arth .1 (Helen) mit<'h b SU 30th Straw••er Doi"& r 1,1s 8un ■-e:t blvd . • Fredk W b&rbcr 1061 Univ a,• r ◄ 530 Arizona ' • Burt W (Nell" B) d ePY Co Tax Collr h Gt - l MC& r h lll½, ?5th • Frank h 1'75 Suneec bh·d LICENSED B • Ja.clc: S ca.rp W .J Cl&Aon Ptanlnk l,1111 r Torn:nce STRAND RADIO & APPLIANCE CO (W W Stn.Ter ff C r ll11 F . REPlll 11! 30th • Fanny s---t\rld J \\· : Stu,·~r ,,\pta) h 4n,;4 Deuei). Radlola ■ • S911rton ~le:s and 5e,-..,. Straw 0.n.nla A (Emma) c:vrp b 4KZ ~th BROKER I WORI St.or,- Herman lab r tSl !nth eitntcr le■• 4991 Newport av. Ocean Be:ach; Phone • EJL& lln h JHZ B • Mary :Mn h 4U %0th • Gt'O J ..lL ~SJ Se11.11ldt O 0 Bayview C:212 - Roy T HC lnternatlonal Bibi« Stu6mta AJUl.n PROMmJ • Verne B (~uta.h) h 4til Hth • Ucu ~ (Olh·e ll) Curmn Shu•·ky Sn,,i h • Roy r rormn W J Ualle:r Co h -t t7 W l..aur.. r r 1:106 Torranc-e N aclE&m · tCS CUY■ maca "-". • The:atre F J Gruber m,:r rn<>t plct 05.l Xew-- • \1"rn C acct 'WhlUns-llnd Co r UN Tor• IAL ESTATE Sto.w ~1:0o:-~~~h~~ ::~ (;ara,:e~ h .. llaud ,111ten e S Xatl Bank r u, 811..-e:rsat,c in DDIE pon. av o B nnoo G Stotler Ed attdt M B Bath HouAe r 4t!ll :Gtb • Rlchd E (Della ) barber DH lith a,· h 1!%1 • l\' allac:e r Ht6:J l0tb • Wm F Ulartha ~) catttkr 8-t HaTrn INSURANl:E • Frank )( (Bertha) ln11 Og't h 19U 3.ld Arnold pl Strandlum Lc.anua h 4'51\.fi Alabama rre,·entor1um h 1~ !9th • Clad.Ta phone opr r 091 Uth Stowe EdW" ){ ( Flnrence) \ ~SX h !ill 1rith Strandlund Erk CChrl• tlne) r 4i37 <>n,gon • Wm X (Emma) lab C it)' ~ Oevt b !0.1 OFFICE • Helen V r 1'44 Ud • Frc-dk , . r t: S Grant Hotel • Paul \." (Kutc) p1trtr h 4Sl7 Orecun Franklla av LOANS • Sheldon C r 194◄1 J3d • • Grace lln mgr Ellabeth Apt.s r 1'4i C nlnn Strang )leni.U C CLucllr) ln.lnmn S U Elcc • Wm T (Ellen A) ca.rp b UOS: Tornlnc-e . 2117 • Thoa W (Anna C ) trucklQK 4S92 ~th • H S h WO 5th av · . Ry Co h !14' lladboo av S tra•-n Allee E r i5,o Jd IITAIT PGIUG Stothard Ralph E (Ruth) US'- b !STTb L • Pau1 v.· (Grac:-e) chauf lntnl Exp &: A B C Strau«e Saml rutrWkr .J J Smith • .J Ulrta ( E'Vel)-11 A) IWlmn O.vlea llotc,n. LDlllllYL Stothc:n Harn· el111mn Or1KiD,al French Lndy Co Truck Co h 1645 \ : nlun Stnapko Frank (Ells) me-eh Stubt,tl .llotor t.!c.,rp b auo l4 418 BST. r CU A 8Lo¥>"CII Hel~n nunc ◄ IM Arlsoa& h 169G Guy • .JaC'Ob 8 rnan,:r S O It:; Aria R.,- Co r JS.to Sd P:;.t!>~f._-- Stoton Arnold B (X&r,rt) uncen.lncatcd archt • RUNICU s c HarTtitt: v..-ftltern Tranf'fer k Sua...bW"S OUo h n~ Alabama - .Ju .C b •ZfH Swift aT P"3!:~ 8322 12, E b toss !lat Storage Co: lnter•CIIJ' Parul Se~-tN-: Stra.Per Ha.rTy E (Je:Mle \ -) N""C Fine Oc:pt h Strayer C. 19x m' rf: 11. , . ,,,.,,. './,II tr,v,,,-,· I f,. ;:; "'' iv f-" :-. ht ,J, .I>,. .. • ~'."'~ ,., • , •• I (Uf,.,.;;,, u.. ,,,,. " I " --nt,JJ._-( u ,J, ✓ r+- fl( ~ l)n .... >11.,u:0. ... 12. - v.- w, •. ~ . I ~- r.,,,, • "&1" I"'-. 9-910<1 ~..... ,. ~ 1:u_ 'l...t J o ~ 1,,, ~f I~ .. "'' /111 .'Ll,I~ Iii, • 1:1.· _ _,,, . ., u~ --.LF.r::., i,J, ., I rdl/Jl1:flf~ !J..-•·-- ,,... ,

tn ....::.l1a,l ✓-u r,,.-,1 ,. ~-1...... l..£. ,0 • , :..1,1. ~L. Ill! a:._ ~,,3~,,1 .-f,.f,_.;,.,. <,.. · ··,. ., _. .. , r .. ,.- .. , ;, I ,,. n ' 111 , ,1, (( •. 'lh,..v-.- .; G:i--:....lh, • ., ,;; _,. ·, :iA ~ ,-.u.~.. li-'t-

~ (Ju IIL t, ,tr.,~,-,. 1112 ;,. .,.,., ,,~1... If ,' 1,J 'h n;;,...77_~ !I HJ.., 1/, ,1_,,,'.f_~... • (1 ,, +'u.- :,:,..,. ()t; • " :/(I,:,. t,y V.1,Ai ✓ :1

Leslie A .Mcnea in the 1930 United States Federal Census

View j

~ View blank form Name: Leslie A Mcnea

Birth Year: abt 1898

Gender: Male

Race : White

Birthplace: Canada

Marital status: Married

Relation to Head of House: Head

Home in 1930: San Diego , San Diego , California, USA

Map of Home: View Map

Street address: Georgia

House Number: 1919

Dwelling Number: 200

Family Number: 204

Home Owned or Rented: Rented

Home Value : 30

Radio Set: No

Lives on Farm : No

Age at first Marriage: 18

Attended School: No

Able to Read and Write: Yes

Father's Birthplace: New York

Mother's Birthplace: New York

Ab le to Speak English: Yes

Occupation: Metal Finisher

Industry: Auto

Class of Worker: Wage or salary worker

Employment: Yes

Veteran: Yes

War: WW

Household Members: Name Age ------=- Leslie A Mcnea 32

Mabel G Mcnea 38

htlps://search. ancestrylibrary.com/cgi-bin/sse .dll? _phsrc=wS H 123&_phstart=su ccessSource&usePUBJs=true&qh=LXlh K6sF 1FLI 5e0BzbVw5Q%3D% ... 1/2 "FROST OAK FLOORING IS BEST" FROST HARDWOOD LUMBER S. R. FRAZEE COMPANY= :;:.,:~-~~ Co. Skerwin.)Wdll'ams Pain.ts an.cf. Varnishes .,, Opex and Rogers Lacquers Mal'ket at State Tels. Main 4888 and 4663 Phone Franklin. 6207 1045 Tenth Avenue 418 0932) SAN DIEGO . DIRECTORY co•s ADVERTISING SAN DIEGO CITY DIRECTORY THE CITY BARNEY & BEYOND BARNEY ITS GATES INSURANCE • l&c,r.F-m)

Copiesof tbisDirec toryare PHONf available Main 2143 in Saipps Bldg. Directory (21,d flao<} Libraries incities allover MAYER the &. Country BOYCE • ELEVATORS TheCity ARD MACHINERY Directory SUPPLIES 1s a Catalog of 644 7th Av. YourCity PHONE Main 18§3 R=~ I Vol~d J N.unt, RltSIDltNCK, 0cCUPATION AND PARTY ·------Jefferson, Mrs, Isabelle-241'7 l\lnrkct, Hw. Rep,

Johnston, George G,-441'5 23th, Mach, Mate. Dem,

Jones, Charles L,-2426 Island, Mech, Dem,

Jones, M1•s, Edna P,-2426 lslnnd, Hw. Rep,

Jones, Lconill'd P.-336 20th, Retcl, Dem.

Kelsey, Leroy B.-2452 J, Engineer. Dem ,

l{elsey, Mrs. Marguerite P.-2432 J, Hw. R~p.

Kelsey, Mrs, Minnie E.-23-12 lslnnd, Hw. Prob,

Kern, Bernnrd \\',--533 24th, Fireman. Rep.

Kern, Mrs. Genevlevt---ri38 24th, Hw. Dem.

J{illeen, Davitl-2453 Islam], Rtd. Dem.

Killeen, Mrs. Minnle-2-133 Island, Hw. Dem.

]{ipf, E, Tcd-2443 Island, Salesman, Rep,

IUpf, Mrs, Rilln-2445 Island, Hw, Dem.

Kipp, Mrs. Alma M.-2508 Island, Saleslady. Rep.

l{ipp, Mrs, Anna-2508 Island, Hw. Dem.

Kipp, Oliver-2508 Island, Fireman. Dem.

J{lelnschmiclt, M1'8, Irene-2437 Island, Minister. Prob,

Kleinschmidt, Louis H.-243'7 Island, Dcpty. City Audtr. Rep.

Knapp, llert-480 25th, Batteryman. Dem,

]{uapp, Frank 1\1,-2437 Market, Rtd, Rep,

Knapp, Mrs, Gel'trude S.-2437 Ma1•ket, Hw. Rc1>,

Kio~ --~ __ Dem,

J{ohlel', Jilcob-2528 Isluml, U.S,N. Dem.

J{oke, Mrs. Mnry-2478 J, Hw. Rep.

Jfrcbs, l\liss Alberta--li2l'S 2lSth, Hskpr, Rep,

...... K1•onebusch, Mrs. BarbiU'n C.-2460 Islan(l, Hw, Dem. -··········· ········•·· J{1•oncbusch, John 13,-2460 Island, Rtd. Dem. ------10/28/2019 1910 United States Federal Census - Ancestrylibrary.com <>»I ancestry·

Abelino Fernandez in the 1910 United States Federal Census

0 View blank form Name: Abelino Fernandez [Abstone Fernandez) Age in 1910: 22

Birth Year: abt 1888

Birthplace: Mexico

Home in 1910: Otay, San Diego, California

Race: Indian (Native American)

Gender: Male

Immigration Year: 1905

Relation to Head of House: Trock Hand (Hired Hand)

Marital status: Single

Father's Birthplace: Mexico

Mother's Birthplace: Mexico

Native Tongue: Spanish

Occupation: Shoveler

Industry: SDDA RR

Employer, Employee or Other: Wage Earner

Able to Read : Yes

Able to Write: Yes

Out of Work: N

Numberofweeksoutofwork: O

Neighbors: View others on page Household Members: ------=-Name Age Ma rt in Lanede 39

Cerilo Fernandez 28

Eframerino Greya 24

Enrique Castro 25

Ferdinand Guiterrez 25

Urbano Lozano 21

Amulio Bertierrey 40

Atanacia Guiterrez 15

Jose Nahamete 19

Jose De Da Floya 20 https://search .ancestrylibrary.com/cgi-bin/sse.dll?_phsrc=Hdg79&_phstart=successSource&usePUBJs=true&qh=jZsCZPeFxuWihRklWttcvQ%3D%3D ... 1/3 10/28/2019 Ancestry Person • Print Age 25- Birth of Daughter Ella Thorp (1907-) Ancestry Sources abt 1907 • North Carolina 1910 United States Federal Census Age 26 - Birth of Daughter Lee Zelbe Thorp (1907-2003) 17 Jul 1907 • Loulsberg, North Carolina Age 27 - Marriage 1920 United States Federal Census 22 Aug 1908 • Franklin, North Carolina, USA

,J.···· - Robert WThorpe 1 l 1 (1874~1939) l 1930 United States Federal Census Age 28 - Birth of Daughter Margorie Virginia Thorpe (1909- 2002) [-~ lAncestryFamilyTrees 3 May 1909 • Oxford Gramu, North Carolina

Age 28 - Birth of Daughter Eva May Thorpe (1910-) North Carolina, Death Certificates, 1909-1976 abt 1910 • North Carolina Age 29 - Birth of Son Paul Andrew Thorpe (1910-1973) North Carollna, Death Certificates, 1909-1976 25 Dec 1910 •, North Carolina, United States Age 29 - Residence 1910, Brassfield, Granville, North Carolina, USA North Carolina, Deaths, 1906-1930 Marital Status: Married; Relation to Head of House: Wife Age 31- Birth of Son Sidney Thorp (1913-1930) ! D ! U.S., Find A Grave Index, 1700s-Current abt 1913 • Granville Co,, N. c. --- ______) Age 33 - Birth of Daughter ~~~(1915-1998) I D. ·· 1 U.S., Social Security Applications and Claims t ____ .J Index, 1936-2007 abt 1915, North Caro a•--~_,) Age 33 - Death of Mother Ann Kearney (1865-1915) 31 Mar 1915 • Youngsville, Franklin, North Carolina Age 39 - Residence 1920, Brassfield, Granville, North Carolina, USA Marital Status: Marrledi Relationship: Wife Age 49 -- Death of Son Sidney Thorp (1913-1930) 25 Aug 1930 , Brasfield, Granville, North Carolina Age 49- Residence 1930, Brassfield, Granville, North Carolina, USA Marital Status: Married; Relation to Head of House: Wife Age 49 - Death 6 March 1931 • Raleigh, Wake, North Carolina, USA Burial Grissom, Granville County, North Carolina, USA

hllps://www.ancestryllbrary.com/famlly-tree/person/tree/42412151/person/7200104 7810/facts 2/2 --· I ut:.t'AN I Mt:.r< 1 ur- uuMMt:.NUt:. Al'IU LADUN--.:,unc.Au ur- 1 nt:. ucm:suo lSUPCRVISO'irs ' DISTRICT No. _ _ £ / , --~, Ht['' 't ~ _r ..... _.::.=~=~~- 1 THIRTEENTH CENSUS OF THE UNITED STATES: 1910- PQPULATION ENUMERATION D1sTR1c1 No_1-4:--_. ; __:q_ ·_· B i[R DIVISION OF COUH1Y __Q/.,.g;;F~=;;;=:-.;;;;::;;-;,;-;;;;...,;.;,;,;,;;;.;.,,-;;:·.:=~, NAM[ OF IIICORPORAl[O PLACE ... ,...... ;;, = ·;;;:""-..-..~---·..;:-;~=;;;=--,,;·... __ I _ .... . _ WA?.0 OF OTY __~------

'-'E. o;:- W,S'iriUTION--;-_.-:·_.;,;~ ;::v.;;;.-_£~•:u...1~; ,._ , ·u:,."~--;;:-....-~ -· •::· ;:.·..,;_.,.;;.1-· . ·- ENUt.lEiUTEO ev J.1E ON THE _ - ,1.._ __'f:-. __ 1,._~_1>_ 01.Y OF aL.:L_ }910. .,,,,M p-. a_~--e__ £.st.:l..·E~i,P?~ ntL\TlOJ'• l'DLSOSlL nc..... t·m1"T10S. .,. ...~ rn-e ...... pill"f',., 11-budt - .1,.r0 ~ Ua.Q,11taalatkl•r.a.u1.

I ~ '& ·,.,. - - J,- f ,._, .. .! .. ~ _.f_ _ - - ,.../.. ~, . ,,- _J_ - -.r -L I 10/28/2019 1920 United States Federal Census -AncestryLibrary.com ~ ancestry·

Avelino Fernandez in the 1920 United States Federal Census

View

~ View blank form Name: Avelino Fernandez

Age: 33

Birth Year: abt 1887

Birthplace: Mexico

Home in 1920: San Diego, San Diego , California

Street: Newton Av

House Number: 2110

Residence Date: 1920

Race: White

Gender: Male

Immigration Year: 1905

Relation to Head of House: Head

Marital status: Married

Spouse's name: Della Fernandez

Father's Birthplace: Mexico

Mother's Birthplace: Mexico

Native Tongue: Spanish

Occupa tion: Laborer

Industry: Working out

Employment Field : Wage or Salary

Home Owned or Rented : Rented

Naturalization Status: Alien

Able to Read : Yes

Able to Write: Yes

Neighbors: View others on page Household Members: ------~-Name Age Avelino Fernandez 33

Della Fernandez 26

Alfred Fernandez 4

Rosa Fernandez 2

Tomiasita Fernandez 1

https://search.ancestrylibrary.com/cgi-bin/sse.dll ?_phsrc=wSH125&_phstart=successSource&usePUBJs=true&qh=2FbDDhoB4ohyUPvBzBtxLA%3D ... 1/3 10/28/2019 1920 United States Federal Census - Ancestrylibrary.com ~ ancestry·

Tomiasita Fernanaez in the 1920 United States Federal Census

~ View blank form Name: Tomiasita Fernandez [Tomasita Fernandez]

Age : 1

Birth Year: abt 1919

Birthplace: California

Home in 1920: San Diego, San Diego, California

Street: Newton Av

Residence Date: 1920

Race : · White

Gender: Female

Relation to Head of House: Daughter

Marital status: Single

Father's name: Avelino Fernandez

Father's Birthplace: Mexico

Mother's name: Della Fernandez

Mother's Birthplace: Mexico

Neighbors: View others on page Household Members: ------='-Name Age Ave Iino Fernandez 33

Della Fernandez 26

Alfred Fernandez 4

Rosa Fernandez 2

Tomiasita Fernandez 1

Source Citation Year: 1920; Census Place: San Diego, San Diego, California; Ro ll: T625_132 ; Page: SA; Enumeration District: 344

Source Information Ancestry.com . 1920 United States Federal Census [database on-line]. Provo, UT, USA: Ancestry.com Operations, Inc., 2010. Images reproduced by FamilySearch.

Original data: Fourteenth Census of the United States, 1920. (NARA microfilm publication T625, 2076 rolls). Records of the Bureau of the Censu s, Record Group 29. National Archives, Washington, D.C. For details on the contents of the film numbers, visit the following NARA web page: NARA. Note: Enumeration Districts 819-839 are on roll 323 (Chicago City).

Description

https://search .ancestrylibrary.com/cgi-bin/sse .dll?db= 1920usfedcen&indiv=try&h=5681971 1/2 ., -~~L~~~~~~~Q.....-..:.-1-1~...... ~Y."~~:4--l~f=~~~e?.~~~e,~~~;"':--+------,-+--i"

\a" 47 • ~~-=-=-~ttu.r~ -~.A;~'--= +-if~~=";'~~~~;~~':::. 2.d.'-:!:. ..,'::.~;= ..!2.!~ ~~ --~~r~ ..f±-=4'-!::kt;= ~=~= =-=-;±:====::::!==!:::I= 10/28/2019 1930 United States Federal Census • Ancestrylibrary.com ~ ancestry·

Juanita Fernandez in the 1930 United States Federal Census ~I------

0 View blank form Name: Juanita Fernandez

Birth Year: abt 1922

Gender: Female

Race : Mexican {Latino)

Birthplace: California

Marital status: Single

Relation to Head of House: Daughter

Home in 1930: San Diego, San Diego, California, USA

Map of Home: View Map

Street address: Newton Avenue

House Number: 2072

Dwelling Number: 144

Family Number: 162

Attended School: Yes

Father's Birthplace: Mexico

Mother's Birthplace: Mexico Household Members: ------=~Name Age Della Fernandez 36

Alfred Fernandez 13

Thomasita Fernandez 11

Juanita Fernandez 8

Angelita Fernandez 6

Caroline Fernandez 5 Rudolph Fernandez 3 Robert Fernandez 1

Neighbors: View others on page

Source Citation Year: 1930; Census Place: San Diego, San Diego, California; Page: 6A; Enumeration District: 0189; FHL microfilm: 2339928

Source Information Ancestry.com . 1930 United States Federal Census [database on -line). Provo, UT, USA: Ancestry.com Operations Inc, 2002 .

Original data: United States of America, Bureau of the Census. Fi~eenth Census of the Un ited States, 1930. Washington, D.C.: National Archives and Records Administration, 1930. T626, 2,667 rolls. https:l/search.ancestrylibrary.com/cgi-bin/sse.dll?_phsrc=wSH136&_phstart=successSource&usePUBJs=true&qh=feORtfN7MPidHkj8YWLNg%3O %3... 1/2 "' ,,II I II I II &.L-- ~ -"· 1 ,,. i I I "' I IHi, I ".c ,:,- ,I,,,' - -• :~,

,,,

.., 10/28/2019 1940 United States Federal Census -Ancestrylibrary.com ~ ancestry·

Juanita Fernandez in the 1940 United States Federal Census ------

View

0 View blank form Name: Juanita Fernandez

Age: 18

Estimated birth year: abt 1922

Gender: Female

Race: White

Birthplace: California

Marital status: Single

Relation to Head of House: Daughter

Home in 1940: San Diego, San Diego, California

Map of Home in 1940: View Map

Street: Franklin Avenue

House Number: 2184

Inferred Residence In 1935: San Diego, San Diego , California

Residence in 1935: Same Place

Resident on farm in 1935: No

Sheet Number: 12A

Attended School or College: Yes

Highest Grade Completed: High School, 2nd year

Weeks Worked in 1939: O

Income: O

Income Other Sources: No

Neighbors: View others on page

Household Members: Nam Age ,:.;;.:.:.:z=::::::::::::=a~=------~=- ( Abelina Fernandez 52

Angelina Fernandez 16

Caroline Fernandez 15

Rudolph Fernandez 13

Source Citation Year: 1940; Census Place: San Diego, San Diego, California; Roll: m-t0627-00449; Page: 12A; Enumeration District: 62-98

Source Information https:/lsearch.ancestrylibrary.com/cgi-bin/sse.dll? _phsrc=wSH 137 &_phstart=successSource&usePU BJs=true&qh=feORtfN7MPidHkj8YWLNg%3D%3.. . 1/2 DD&aflalff a, CCW: I IHl1PP ♦V 0,1'11111· CDa11 ---t-ei,,..~ IJXTUX'ffl CSN808 OP THB UNlTllD ITATa: 1940 ---'6-...lliAiilSl.rii!i-.,_fV"----- a.__,,,._ • ..._ -~.__. . ;,;;_ ·:-.:; POPULATION SCHBDULB .... __ ...... _t:rmltanl I i • --- 4 -==--~ 1 i id -~= • I I • 1 ·~=~:S::::a_-...""\: J l J ! J ' ...... ! _,-! =i:1_,_

..! /1., , ll)l,."f.. / l!l. - t." .. 14,.. ~- 2. • l)( .._ I ·• .._ ir.uc, ""- ... -.1 .... "' i< ...... , _o ,., 4 j{ ' 1 ... i.. ~. (; :Di• 'Ila 411,,. 1111.. _ ... J n ._ _, • - _ ...! ---'_ "lo. u,_ ·-,; - ~ ,a, .._ .., 1 I ,, .,_ I'\ _ _o -· s ,1[_ ,..,._ ~ ,o ~, k ...... • - ~, •- ~ •.,,.~ .. n lu" ... dJ,.c o .. w'' ..,..._ 'f t ,~~n .P~ .. - --... ·. - ,..,1, ..• .,. -::!: ...! ....!

u ,..!! I' ,,,, ·, · ,, ,:z:;..._ ... _., J_-i'_, ,; .. w 14§ ... • In t; I ... •n .16 L ti. " la.. .IUt .... - ,_ - I ,,.. e..1.. . IR. 71 D 7 / I/ 1..., ~,r L. •• .!!. 1---.:....a--' ,.,_ ,.. n.. .•1 .... , !f.. ,J 'If "' ..., i... JO •" 1f I. :.. , .. :t.tn I. .._ 111a. ._ l"W ~ - ,.. ~o ~ 17 • :!! I~ I•• _1,, '.JI ·_., / V I I I aa IZtil.l!lltUL...... i:J>, ____ .f ,.(l ~- ,9. (l - .. IO.q ~ .... l'i' )' l"D • - n' 0. ,__ ...... k. - - I~ ,.,. tlt..2.ll ii .,.... :!"·~ + .• .... ·~~·. = . - .. 0 (J -.P. · ••• .....-•• I !1...ilh.., ~1"1 '1 ,.,_.. 3 I -- .. ,.,. •• -t.--1-.... -....1 ... Is- - I) '"' - ~ l O \. • '2 ,.J ',/ ", I / I\ • qy <> i._ .Q.&11 : t ,, o. _..,.., ....,.,-.. r.,. ..~ . ..

- .. __.!. .... ' L A._,, "' • ,_ " " f .'I I~ .. n "' • 'ff/ _.!': "1 II 'I,. it,{ !r, ... I. ,1.:0. ... ,i,.".,1, 1n~ •· ,,._, ~ "l... ,,!.;,. '7 iA. " .. _,, 1,., 1... - ... - - 44.. -1!.1. -- !r.,- .-, In.. 'ff1R "'-I/•• l.11. w1 •

IA,V..16.1:zl~i,of IT!', "• gf • ~, •' ... .,..141,,ln... A. - I,, - - al>>,., at ------·,---+-+==-.....,.'-:'':!'l~':'--i'Ll~.~-'1>--'-tl'll'lf-qil'"'lll:-li.a.+'~.!>...~l'J"l'L'f-'1447+:'~y"~... •~fg..J+']~,.- .."""4----+--:;::---tt.-+~~i..tl"'"I.Rj-.2Jl"""fl·ll.f·.-:•·p'L-r'r=,i-===-t--=---+-...:-=---t"'--f--t-l-f'"z+.a!::,,..L)::+l~..._Hl~ae!.fa _, •. .J JI.# II/.. ,_ I.J MI!!. ~- t. ' ~ !j ,, ~ ~ I- 31 o L. 'IJ •• J. r ,. i.... •• M .. ..,, .l~ ... ' fl • ..: -IUI! ··· - - - I ,,, IL. :.1,-_ , ,.,, ·,. .. ' 'JI .,. ,./1 I..! ... ,.,,. 1£ .. "" ~ ,, " - I'll • i..~• ... [ti! ., Ot. ... ~ ...11. c3 1 ,.1•• , J1 14 • . M N. I 'ff.••• --'l1S'I "'- <1>.l .... iti. "ll f. If n ~ ., ~..., ,,__ _ ,o • - 16S · • I .._ ...... _I..._ '°" > '~ ~ !.., 1111- I.a. 9 f I -·- ;! M. ..._ ,._1 ... 1... 11 •- = 65 ....

a 11 - .,,,_,,.. JI,. fl. .I. O<,, 9 _,_- ~- b<.141., IA. - ...... _ C .a• 1> .... __ , ...... --. .. --• .,.. __ u,a ------_....,--...... _ 114-... --...... ,l ...... __ ...... --- --~-.....----- ..___ - .....~a!L-- ...__ - .:...... ,.._.,.. ------...... 411t ---- ______.- ...... _.~-__..,...... ;..__ --·------.. ------.. 10/28/2019 1930 United States Federal Census - Ancestrylibrary.com ~ ancestry·

Cruz Fernandez in the 1930 United States Federal Census I

[8 View blank form

Name: Cruz Fernandez

Birth Year: abt 1903

Gender: Female

Race : Mexican (Latino)

Birthplace: Mexico

Marital status: Married

Home in 1930: Orange, Orange, California, USA

Map of Home: View Map

Street address: W. Chapman Ave

Institution: Orange County Hospital

House Number: 1070

Family Number: 380

Age at first Marriage: 19

At tended School: No

Able to Read and Write: Yes

Father's Birthplace: Mexico

Mother's Birthplace: Mexico

Language Spoken: Spanish Immigration Year: 1929

Naturalizat ion : Alien

Able to Speak English : No

Household Members: Name Age ------='-- Cruz Fernandez 27

Neighbors: View others on page

Source Citation Year: 1930; Census Place: Orange, Orange, California; Page: 28; Enumeration District: 0059; FHL microfilm: 2339916

Source Information Ancestry.com.1930 United States Federal Census [database on-line]. Provo, UT, USA: Ancestry.com Operations Inc, 2002.

Original data: United States of America, Bureau of the Census. Fi~eenth Census of the Un ited States, 1930. Washington, D.C.: National Archives and Records Administration, 1930. T626, 2,667 rolls.

Description

https ://search .an cestrylibrary.com/cgi-bin/sse .dll?db= 1930usfedcen& indiv=try&h = 123967729 1/2 ~ - DD.&aTIIDT o• collJID.C&-ll'IIUu or ,::n a:nua r "~ .,._._~ .. C«J.,lr ___ _ • l''ifb,u,•m CEBSUS OF THE utnTED ST.A.TES: 1930 ... l -, C('1, d J:S ...... , ______~ POPULATIOll SCHEDULE

ltUCS orm::am mna.1ma&ta•ffl'l ~ uao.- ■OldDU4 ~. ...- WGW.IQOf",__ ..... OCCOPill0.9 UV amGSU1' UU.DGIJ.. """""'"' -.:.r::r~.:--=-- _• fJ --I ,._.,..,.., .... .s::__...... = ...... 41 ....,_.,__...... __ f ---r:;=5 ~\~ r:: ~= =- - a::.-:::.-~ -=:::.· ...... , lj fr1 I Ii - 'S T• •.:.:- ~ --- ...... _...... ll • ~ :~~:e:~a~:r::-I•=-= ~~s-- ·' --..:...... -::u::---::.-.:'._'I:" - OIIII J111 II i• ~t _,_ -- J ...- JI ~. : -~c-,~ ~ ~ --- J I J ! ~ • ia it =.:.:- --- pl II ~ ==-~-= :s· .. == . . . . -...... N n -.. - - .. . . e . '~a . - -u. ·.. -?? · £ / 1"1 Ill l,h .s !H, ll. 1,# . ~II·- ,,,- ii o,,- ()_ - ----J J - ,._..,,_ .. .,,. Ml,~ r,. ..,_ /.. .: , _,, Ai• 10, ,,_ 1-z. "· ,. < .. V u.~ &: ;, ,. I , , ,,. ,. .,,. -.,; p /' , •; 1 1 ,,. ✓ - M vi .. s rlf. - ~ a, .,_ ~ ,· 'l.. • • ., 41 .,_ = ,, ..,h M 1_.J.,_, s ~ I ,,. I , 61 .,.;_ , ·-· ··- ,. ., 1 _J_ . ,. ..,., A, , . '7- • . ,,, :a,_ ,. .. , •• _<: 11,.. . • _, , V ,,.. "11 d, .. I). ,,,, , ., ,~. ,. L ~ ,, -Z. I ., I,,,_ ,I,_ .L. 1<1 l u1 l.r.1 1-"1 17 1-:J. , .. . , . -?., • , • , . I '1! ,, h , M ~ Jt lwl l"i. ,...... I. ,. ,., ... ,., lt;u --;, d • s, ~·fl'< .◄ • I Ill 21_ lo. A • -3'!-/ , · h:. .;.. ,,. , -· u. ~ L., "'- ~, " s ' .. ,p_ ., . ',a, ,,. s '"'·· ,._, ..,__ , . -if., . ,J,,__ . , "., ,. . .,, ,., . M "' 7t... ~- ...... ,., , ..,_ ,T ,,,__ .d• --7.._ ./-'.... -:1-... , ,~. ,,... 0 7':.,,-~.,- M. s 1, .. ' ~ ,,__ ~ :t, ,. '.i,_ ,,, WJ 1,., I• ~: ✓ - --z.... ,. .I, ./ ,,.., -- tl ...... 11, lb ,,_ ... .. ◄ > ,,. "'· GI ··,/.. t:( 1/. ,_ ,.,._ ,, C: '.& Iv.... 17h...... :.. -:I, J1. :...... ). ,, .. . r.u lfi ,~ , -;fl_ • .,.,_ ' "' .I -D .I L ,,_ .,,,, .. 7r, ✓ - 'Al, J " z «. -4 > .. ~ , - I t= ""' IM ,,. .. , ., .I. .,,,,_ ,.,,, -m.., .,,,,._~ /. . , ,, ,,,.,~_ '2, .1 ., c. •" ~ , •• r !." ,,,. f- ~/ -- , '' s fM., ,., / ., J I t= • ,.,, s :;;. ,. --,. 11 .. r I . .. 10 ,,.,. -s, [_j ., ('_, I' ,, s ;;. ,,_ ,, / z ,. .,, . Tl - · •- -,,, , ~ -- tY..,. _..,. y_< _ '.6. 'N. "~-A ./~ /, : / ..,.,, ,. 7'. 1,1 ..L 72 I I F .. . /II '19 ◄ ~ ~- ' , t? . , ,,,. ... , ,,_ ,,,_ , ~ -,/ ~ F "·· 11- ~ 711.~• .:.... -~- "' .. n .,_ .. - ,.._ , . ", l"A, ", F ' 1,r I><. "· ., .,, ., ,.. ,. ,, - > 7f ... . •· ' JI 4,.,, p ..,. l,,, :a, , . . , -~.a IA• ,- ..,,_ I .J , ·I,-_ ., ""-'· -..-: "' 1~ ✓,,_,✓ ...;., / ,/ . n. ,.. JJ, .J -D , __ ,: .,!\_ .,, s ~· , ... I".,,., ·. . ,. .. I '111 " ;/ ,,.,, ,. lr, ,. . --,.. , "'7ll.' _J• • .I ,. I"/ .-rt! J¥J u.. '?>, . .. ., . .,'ru 7/. ,I'...... ,_ 17 "' 71'. J~_ -,, ,, ,,.,__ ;;,,__ ../ /1. .•• -

Dominguoz,Librada D Escobar, Aurelia D 10&9 I 9E>E, K Brawley Calif Brawley CalU Dublin, Johnny R e:scobar, Mrs Mary C D 980 I St PO Box 71 Brawley Ca Hf Brawley Calif Duran, Antonio D Escobar, Pedro N. D b21 Vine 966 K Brawley Calif Brawloy Callf Encinal, Oulllgrmo V D Escobar, Refugio R D 1059 I P O Box 71 Brawley Calif Brawley Calif Encinas,Santiago D· Espinoza, Krs Margaret D 1059 I P 0 Box 943 Brawley Calif Br:-awley Ca Uf Eros,Abelardo V. D Espitia, Apolinar Galban D 910 Martin Pl 1034 H Brawley Calif Brawley Calif Eros, Abelardo D Espitia, Juana L D 914 Martin 1034 H Brawley Calif Brawley Calif

E:ros, Albert V D Esquer, Cele1onio B. D· 914 Martin 656 Stanley Pl Brawley Calif Brawley Calif Eros,Alexander R Esquiv1e1,Edward D 914 Martin Pl 918 J Brawley Ca 11 f Brawley Calif Eros, Mrs. Gloria T. D Estrada, Mrs. Elvira C. D 925 Martin Pl 955 J St Brawley Calif Brawley Callt Eros, Miss Ougdalupe V. D Evans, Leroy D 914 Martin 918 I Browley Calif Br:-awley Calif Eros,!l.anuel V. D Evans,Mary D 914 Martin Pl 411 10th Brawley Calif Brawley Calif Escalera, Albert P. R Evons, Pearlie D b34 So. 1'enth 918 I Brawley Calif Brawley Ca U f Escalera, Catarino· N D Fellelan, Raymundo R D 1058 Leonard Box 470 Brawley Calif Brawley Callf Escalera~ Cella O. D ( -f-ern.a~ Cruz G D ,j 934 Ivy '---...... __ _,,,...._ 1035 1 Brawley Calif ~ Br:-avtley Calif Eocalera, Mrs, Elvira D Fernandez, Felix C, D b:H So. Tenth 934 Ivy Brawley Calif Brawley Calif Escalera,Joe D Fernandez, Martin C, D z. P O Box 1031 Box 487 Br:-awley Calif Brawley Calif n Fontos. Mrs Mar~arlta D 10/28/2019 1930 United States Federal Census - Ancestrylibrary.com ~ ancestry·

Francisco Banuelos in the 1930 United States Federal Census

View

~ View blank form Name: Francisco Banuelos [Francisco Banvelos]

Birth Year: abt 1907

Gender: Male

Race: Mexican (Latino)

Birthplace: Mexico

Marital status: Single

Relation to Head of House: Employee

Home in 1930: Niland, Imperial, California, USA

Map of Home: View Map

Street address: Niland S to Mcec Road Wester, SP. RR.

Dwelling Number: 1

Family Number: 1

Attended School : No

Able to Read and Write: Yes

Father's Birthplace: Mexico

Mother's Birthplace: Mexico

Language Spoken : Spanish

Immigration Year: 1926

Naturalization: Alien

Able to Speak English: No

Occupation: Laborer

Industry: Steam railway

Class of Worker: Wage or salary worker

Employment: Yes Household Members: ------=--Name Age Ju Ii o Garcia 38

Rocha Alegandr 30

Francisco Banuelos 23

Santos Gomez 28 Diente Lopez 25 Negrete lndoxesio 36

Jose Negrete 26 https://search .ancestrylibrary.com/cgi-bin/sse.dll?_phsrc=wSH1 45&_phstart=successSource&usePUBJs=true&qh=h2gx51XS/fEpCjMiS5jMgg%3D%3 .. . 1/2 - I MWI Ge ~ a, 'ID CIIIW --... J~-..J,k -=-=-=-==-40--=--=~-=.,.-=_..,._~~..==- liHmta CU8U8 Gr '!BB UJDrED BTATE8: WO _.._ ___ _ POPULil'IOB' SCIIEDULE '-"'"""'"_.._ ;;, --1-A -- .. ~ ------, , fP.IINo~ 8hvubto5 __ _ ., __ v--::.:...!l&-==-=-==="'•==~-==-=-=..=-=,=,= ... ._. __._, ...... ,______..... _...,_. ,,.(;f....:.e,z ·-- ~~;.,. t r Attachment E.3 - Criterion C

Criterion C: Embodies distinctive characteristics of style, type, period, or method of construction or is a valuable example of the use of indigenous materials or craftsmanship.

Summary: This house was at first glance difficult to categorize as a style. Fenestration and doors were inconsistent and did not seem to fit any particular style. Shape of house is irregular. It lacked the Craftsman sloped columns, there was no use of indigenous stone in the foundation typical of houses in the area, and nothing in particular lent itself to identifying a particular style. Tongue and groove siding completely covers the house and additions, lacking fish-scale shingles on the siding under the gable ends. Only on close examination of the structure were evidence of modifications revealed. Windows have been filled in. Windows have been added or changed to different proportions. The front fac;:ade has been revised in appearance and function with the addition of a new front door in a new location, replacing a window. A large addition with a flat roof has been added to the gabled original house, changing the roofline and increasing the footprint by 45%. The porch has been modified, as has been the roof.

Peel back the layers of these revisions and what is revealed beneath is the original Folk Victorian. The building form was cross-gabled. Windows were tall and narrow 1/1 double hung, of which only a few remain. The front door to the house was on the eastern fac;:ade, but has now been relegated to that of a secondary entrance due to the creation of a "new" front door on the southern front fa9ade, replacing a window there. Bulge-outs have been added to the back of the house. But if you visualize the original configuration of the house as built in 1903 or 1904 (per the attached modified photos) then a Folk Victorian house emerges. 1 story, cross-gabled, lacking in ornamentation, this was the sort of home that a contractor would "design-build" without the aid of an architect.

This house has not retained essential aspects of integrity. Revisions to windows and doors are a critical degradation of the original fabric of the structure, representing the eyes of the building. A flat roof addition that simply overwhelms the west and north facades has been added. Quality of construction and trim of additions, revised windows, and doors are all far substandard in workmanship compared to originals. Although all of these revisions appear to be old enough to have taken on a significance of their own, they add nothing to the style of the underlying Folk Victorian, and in fact do nothing but distract from the architectural integrity of the original structure.

ORIGINAL FOOTPRINT: 624 SQ. FT:.

ORIGINAL FOOTPRINT: ORIGIN1 11L 624 SQ. FT. FRONT DOOR

ADDED FRONT DOOR

COVERED PORCH

2528 ISLAND AVE. BUILDING FOOTPRINT CHANGES 5 SQ. FT. ADDITION

21 SQ, FT ADDITION

ORIGINAL FOOTPRINT: · 624 SQ. FT

ORIGINAL FOOTPRINT:. ORIGIN L 624 SQ. FT. FRONT DOOR ADDITIONS: 278 SQ. FT.

CURRENT FOOTPRINT: ADDED 902 SQ. FT. FRONT DOOR 902 I 624 = 1.45 FOOTPRINT HAS w E INCREASED BY 45% COVERED PORCH

2528 ISLAND AVE. BUILDING FOOTPRINT CHANGES

Current Photo of North Elevation (back of house)

Modified photo, showing likely walls and windows before flat roof addition.

Windows

The original windows were very tall and narrow 1/1 double hung windows with classic Victorian headers and trim. Only 2 of the original windows remain. At least 5 other original window locations, as evidenced by clear patch marks in the siding, have either been completely filled in or replaced with windows of a much squatter proportion and lacking the original Victorian header and trim boards. It is likely that even more original windows were lost when the additions to the house were added.

The above pics show patch marks in the siding of the west façade, showing location and proportion of original window, which has been replaced with the short window shown.

The above pics show patch marks in the siding of the east façade, showing locations and proportions of original windows.

Current windows have 2 original tall and narrow 1/1 double hung original Victorian era windows. Others have been modified.

Above is a modified photo, Original windows were tall and narrow 1/1 double hung with heavy headers and detailed trim, typical of the Victorian style. Front façade (south) has two tall 1/1 double hung windows, and no door. Porch posts are shown as true 4 x 4 with bevel edges. An alley retaining wall is removed, and the back flat-roofed addition is removed.

This current photo show patch marks in the siding of the east façade, showing locations and proportions of original windows, which has been replaced with the short window shown, and one filled in completely. A bulge-out has been added to the back wing.

Above is a modified photo, showing original door and window locations with 1/1 double hung proportions. Also, bulge-out at the back wing was not present, and likely contained an additional window.

Doors The house currently has two front doors. The door on the east façade is the original front door location. This is apparent when looking at the Victorian header and trim boards, and integration with the overhead porch. The actual door at this location (and all door locations) has been replaced with a modern hollow core door in very poor condition. The “front door” on the south façade is an addition. It replaced an original tall and narrow 1/1 double hung window. So, when walking up to the front of the contemporary

structure a person is misled to believe that they are coming upon an original front door, when in fact they are entering through an original window location.

Current photo showing original front door (still present) and new front door location that replaced a window.

Front windows, 1 replace with new size, 1 converted to a door. Original front door, on east side.

Current South Façade With window revision and front door addition. Original front door is still around the corner, on the right. Porch posts are modern 3 ½ x 3 ½.

Original South Façade (modified photo) With 2 Victorian 1/1 double hung windows. Original front door is around the corner, on the right. Porch posts were true 4 x 4 with beveled edges.

Typical contemporary Logan Heights ·· house, showing 2528 Island likely front ,configL:Jration of windows and doors

~rJ '

~. Photo courtesy of San Diego History Center t! · /7/C,

Conclusion: All doors are replacements. Only 1 door location has original trim and header. Doors have been significantly modified.

Roof

The 1920 Sanborn Map shows an "X" on the main structure "tsai~ rr. 1920 Sanborn Map and the front porch, indicating a shingle roof was present in 1920. The 1921 Sanborn Map shows a dark dot on each roof, i'; indicating a change from sh ingle to composition.

Front Porch The front porch wraps around the east and south façade of the southernmost wing of the house. The porch roof itself appears to be original, judging by the True Dimension lumber used (real 2” x 4” lumber) and the bead board soffit. However, the porch posts have all been replaced by modern dimension 4 x 4’s, (3 ½” x 3 ½”) without beveled edges. Original post details can be determined by comparison with an original posts next to the real front door. Original posts were true 4” x 4”, with beveled edges. All porch handrails and handrail spindles are currently deteriorated modern 2 x 4’s and 2 x 2’s, with dimensions of 1 ½” x 3 ½” (2x4) and 1 ½” x 1 ½” (2x2). Some rails are pressure treated. Clearly the original rails were a full 2” thick because coping in the original post by the front door is 2” wide, not 1 ½”.

The 1920 Sanborn Map (oldest that shows the property) originally had an “X” on the porch roof, indicating a shingle roof. The 1921 Sanborn Map was changed to a solid Dot, indicating a change from shingle to composition roof.

Foundation The foundation that most of the house sits upon is 4” x 16” hollow concrete block. Originally the house did not sit on this block foundation because equipment for mass production of concrete foundation block was first revealed at the 1904 St. Louis Louisiana Purchase Exposition. With the house being constructed in 1904, it is almost impossible that the blocks used in the 2528 Island Ave foundation were produced in 1904, the year of construction. Other evidence of the foundation being a revision remain underneath the house. Looking into the crawlspace you can plainly see a large pile of dirt centered under the floor. This is consistent with manual excavation for foundation under an existing house resting on piers.

There is a trim board at the top of the concrete block foundation on the east façade. Both ends of this trim board have a 45 degree miter cut on the end, implying that the house was wrapped by this trim board which was largely removed when the foundation was installed.

The back 252 square foot addition is not on a concrete block foundation, and appears to be built slab-on-grade.

Conclusion: The original house has been raised, and any original wood skirt replace with concrete block.

The house has been significantly altered in ways that negatively impact the integrity of the original Folk Victorian house. The following is a list of these alterations, along with the “Secretary of the Interior’s Treatment Standards for Historic Properties” to show compliance, or lack of, of the alterations:

Important windows typical of the Folk Victorian style have either been filled in or replaced, or lost when blocked during a footprint expansion.

From the Secretary of the Interior’s Treatment Standards for Historic Properties: WINDOWS

RECOMMENDED NOT RECOMMENDED Replacing in kind an ent ire window that is too deteriorated to Removing a character-

Adding new window openings on rear or other secondary, less Changing the nu mber, location, size, or glazing pattern of windows visible elevations, if req uired by a new use. The new openings on primary or highly-visible elevations which will alter the historic and the windows in !hem should be compat,ible with the overa ll character of t he building. deS'ign of t he building but, in most cases , not duplicate the historic fenestration. Cutting new openings on character-defin ing elevat ions or cutting new openings that damage or destroy significa nt feat ures.

A new front door has been added to the south façade, significantly altering the primary façade. From the Secretary of the Interior’s Treatment Standards for Historic Properties: ENTRANCES AND PORCHES

RECOMMENDED NOT RECOMMENDED Identifying, retaining, and preserving entrances and porches and Removling or substant ially changing entrances and porches which their functional and decora tive features that are important in are ,important in defining t he overall historic character of t he bu ild defi ning the overa l I historic character ot the building. The materi ing so that, as a result, the character is diminished . als themse lves (includiing masonry, wood , and metal) are signifi cant, as are their feat ures, such as doors transoms, pilasters, Cutting new entra nces on a primary fa de columns, ba lustrades, stairs, roofs, and project ing canopies . Altering utilitarian or service entrances so t hey compete visually with t he historic primary entra~ , increas ing t heir size so that they ai:ipear signif icant ly more important • or add ing decorat ive details t hat cannot be doc umented to t he building or are incompatii ble with t he building's historic character.

A large 252 square foot flat roof addition was constructed, completely changing the north and west facades. This flat roof addition is out of character with the gabled roof of the original Folk Victorian house. From the Secretary of the Interior’s Treatment Standards for Historic Properties: ROOFS

RECOMMENDED NOT RECOMMENDED Des igning rooftop add it ions, elevator or stair iowers, decks or ier Changing a character-

Two other small bulge-outs have been added to the north wing of the house, adding 26 more square feet to the building footprint. One bulge-out contains an improperly proportioned window. The total of the additions to the original house have increased the structural footprint by 45%. From the Secretary of the Interior’s Treatment Standards for Historic Properties: NEW EXTERIOR ADDITIONS TO HISTORIC BUILDINGS AND RELATED NEW CONSTRUCTION

RECOMMENDED NOT RECOM MENDED Co nstructing a new add ition on a secondary or non-character- Constructing a new add ition on or ad jace nt to a primary elevation defining elevation and limiting its size and sca le in relationship to of the building which negative ly impacts the building's historic the historic bu ilding. character. Co nstructing a new add ition that results in the least possible loss A taching a new add ition in a ma nner Iha obscures, damages or of historic materia'ls so that character-

The roof was originally shingle, but is now composition. From the Secretary of the Interior’s Treatment Standards for Historic Properties: ROOFS

RECOMMENDED NOT RECOMMENDED Replacing in kind an entire roof covering or feature that is too Remov ing a feature of the roof that is unrepa irable and not replac deteriorated to repa ir (if the overall form and detailing are still ing it, or replacing it with a new roof feature that does not match. evident) using the physical evidence as a mod el to reprod uce the feature or when the replacement can be based on historic Us ing a subst itute material for the rep lacement that does not documentation. Exam ples of such a f eature could include a large convey he same appearance of the roof covering or the surviving section of roofi ng, a dormer, or a chimney. llf using the same kind components of the roof feature or that iis physically o.r chemica lly of material is not feasible, then a compati ble substitute mater,iall incompati ble. may be considered.

The front porch has had its original 4 x 4 beveled post replaced with modern 3 ½” x 3 ½” posts with straight edges, new railings and spindles of modern dimensional lumber. The floor of the porch has been changed to concrete, and the roof changed from shingle to composition. From the Secretary of the Interior’s Treatment Standards for Historic Properties: ENTRANCES AND PORCHES

RECOMMENDED NOT RECOMMEN DED Identifying, retaining, and presen,ingentra nces and porches and Remov,ing or substantially changing entrances and porches which their functiona'I and decorative features th at are important in are iimportant in defining the overa ll historic character of the build defining the overa l I historic character of the building. The materi ing so that, as a result, the character is diminished. als themse lves (including masonry, wood , and metal) are signifi ca nt, as are their features, such as doors, transoms, pilasters, Cutting new entrances on a primary f~ade . columns, ba lustrades, stairs, roofs, and projecting canopies .

The Southeastern San Diego Historic Context Statement states that registration requirements for 1868- 1916 residential cottages and bungalows lists the following character defining features:

• Location in an early subdivision, typically west of Escondido Freeway (CA-15) It is located to the west of CA-15). • Architectural style and form from this period, including Queen Anne, Folk Victorian, Folk National, Craftsman, and Prairie It is Folk Victorian style. • Set back from lot line Standard setback on south lot line, almost no setback on west lot line. • One story (or one story with raised basement) One story construction. • Gable or pyramidal roof Gable roof on original house, flat roof on addition. • Wood cladding (shingles or horizontal siding) Wood horizontal shiplap siding • Wood sash windows (double-hung or casement) Wood sash double-hung windows at 2 remaining locations, and at all replacement locations. • Wood door (glazed or paneled) All doors are replacements, and are modern hollow-core or metal clad.

Minimum Integrity Threshold In order to be eligible for listing in the local, state or national historical register, a property of this type and from this period must retain sufficient integrity to convey its significance. The minimum features required to retain integrity are as follows: • Clear example of residential architecture from this period This house was a typical residential structure of its day. • Retains original form and roofline Footprint has been increased by 45% with a large addition topped with a flat roof instead of the gabled roof of the original structure. • Retains most of its original ornamentation, if applicable (The retention of entry, window and/or roofline ornamentation should be considered most important). Original front door retains its original trim. Other doors added over time have different trim, not matching the original trim in style or quality. Only 2 original windows remain. These 2 windows retain their original trim. All other windows, added later, have different trim, not matching the original trim in style or quality. Roofline ornamentation was never present. Front porch handrails and posts have been replaced with modern dimension 4 x 4's and 2 x 2's. • Retains original cladding (no stucco) Original shiplap cladding is present. • Retains original windows and doors (or match in location, pattern, size, and materials) Only 1 door location is original (with modern door installed). Only 2 windows are original. Most windows were replaced with windows of completely different proportions, or removed and covered over entirely. Siding was used to fill in abandoned locations. One window on the front fac;ade was converted into, and replaced with, a door. • In historic districts, at least two-thirds of the properties must qualify as contributors in order for the district to retain integrity. 2528 Island Ave does not lie within the Sherman Heights or the Grant Hill Historic Districts.

Finding: The property has undergone significant modifications and does not qualify as historic under Criterion C. Attachment E.4 - Criterion D

Criterion D: Is representative of the notable work of a master builder, designer, architect, engineer, landscape architect, interior designer, artist or craftsman.

Summary: 2528 Island Ave. suffers from a scant amount of information from before 1930, with no building permits from the pre-WW2 era being discovered. Research found no evidence of a named architect or builder.

Even if a master architect or master builder had been involved, so many changes to key windows, doors, footprint, roofline, foundation, and porch have occurred that any attribution to a master would be nullified, as the existing structure no longer reflects their work.

Conclusion: The property does not qualify under Criterion D. Attachment E.5 - Criterion E

Summary: 2528 Island Ave. in San Diego is not listed on the National Register of Historic Places, nor is it listed on the California Historical Resources inventory for San Diego County. Both of these complete lists follow, showing that this property is not included.

Conclusion: The property does not qualify under Criterion E. San Diego listing of National Register properties Ref# Property Name Status Listed Date State City Street & Number Architects/Builders 77000331 Balboa Park Listed 12/22/1977 CA San Diego CA Quadrangle 41 Multiple Wheeler, WIiiiam H.; Wurster 96001177 Balboa Theatre Listed 10/24/1996 CA San Diego 868 4th Ave. Construction Co. et al. Beardsley, John R. and Florence 11000943 Porterfield, House Listed 12/22/2011 CA San Diego 3130 Shadowlawn St. May, Clifford Magee (Cliff May) 90002220 BERKELEY Listed 12/14/1990 CA San Diego B St. Pier Union Iron Works

86002665 Burnham--Marston House Listed 9/22/1986 CA San Diego 3563 Seventh Ave. Hebbard &·, Gill; Kaar,John 10 ml. from San Diego off U.S. 10, near S US Lighthouse Board; National 66000224 Cabrillo National Monument Listed 10/15/1966 CA San Diego tip of Point Loma Park Service

Goodhue,Bertram Grosvenor; 7 4000548 California Quadrangle Listed 5/17/1974 CA San Diego Balboa Park-El Prado Area Wlnslow,Carleton Monroe 78000750 Chaplain's House Listed 11/24/1978 CA San Diego 836 Washington St. Unknown Near National Ave., Logan Ave., and 100000802 Chicano Park Listed CA San Diego Dewey St. Larin, Alfredo 12001192 Chicano Park Listed 1/23/2013 CA San Diego Near National Ave. & Dewey St. Larin, Alfredo City of San Diego Police Headquarters, 98000833 Jails and Courts Listed 7/9/1998 CA San Diego 801 W. Market St. multiple 83001227 Coulter House Listed 9/30/1983 CA San Diego 3162 2nd Ave. Wlnslow,Carleton M. Sr. 7000935 Cuyamaca Village Listed 4/2/2008 CA San Diego Address Restricted Wheeler,Willlam H.; 85002723 Eagles Hall Listed 10/4/1985 CA San Diego 733 Eighth Ave. Siebert,Selmar

Walker & Eisen; Simpson, 1001458 El Cortez Apartment Hotel Listed 1/17/2002 CA San Diego 702 Ash St. William, Construction Co. Goodhue,Bertram G.; 76000515 El Prado Complex Listed 12/12/1976 CA San Diego Balboa Park Winslow,Carelton M. 70000143 Estudillo House Listed 4/15/1970 CA San Diego 4000 Mason St. Unknown Fleming, John Angel James; 98000700 Fleming, Guy and Margaret, House Listed 6/18/1998 CA San Diego 12279 Torrey Pines Park Rd. Fleming, Guy L. 73000433 Ford Building Listed 4/26/1973 CA San Diego Balboa Park, Palisades Area Teague.Walter Dorwin

War Department; Works 16000054 Fort Rosecrans National Cemetery Listed 3/8/2016 CA San Diego Cabrillo Memorial Dr. Progress Administration/ Vet. Bounded by RR tracks, Broadway, 4th, and 80000841 Gaslamp Quarter Historic District Listed 5/23/1980 CA San Diego 6th Sts. Multiple Georgia St. and University Ave., bet. 99000158 Georgia Street Bridge--Caltrans Bridge Listed 2/12/1999 CA San Diego Florida St. and Park Blvd. Cromly, James Rd., C.E. 6001157 Ginty, John, House Listed 12/18/2006 CA San Diego 1568 Ninth Ave. 80000842 Grand-Horton Hotel Listed 6/20/1980 CA San Diego 332, 328 and 334 F St. Comstock & Trotsche 79000523 Grant, U.S. Hotel Listed 8/27/1979 CA San Diego 326 Broadway St Albright,Harrison

92000966 Haines, Alfred, House Listed 7/30/1992 CA San Diego 2470 E St. Quayle,Charles; Quayle,William 82002245 Hawthorne Inn Listed 3/30/1982 CA San Diego 21211st Ave. Neale,Henry; Graham,R.A. Holzwasser--Walker Scoot Building and Quayle Brothers; Vawter, John 5000072 Owl Drug Building Listed 2/27/2005 CA San Diego 1014 Fifth ave. and 402-416 Broadway Terrel Independent Order of Odd Fellows 78000751 Building Listed 1/31/1978 CA San Diego 526 Market St. Goodrich,Levi Initial Point of Boundary Between U.S. 7 4000550 and Mexico Listed 9/6/1974 CA San Diego S of Imperial Beach off Monument Rd. Unknown

80000843 Johnson-Taylor Ranch Headquarters Listed 10/31/1980 CA San Diego E of San Diego and Black Mountain Rd. Multiple Simon, Louis A; Lumpkins, 12001109 La Jolla Post Office Listed 1/2/2013 CA San Diego 1140Wall St. William

12000443 Lafayette Hotel Listed 7/31/2012 CA San Diego 2223 El Cajon Blvd. Hope, Frank L., Jr.; Imig, Larry 80000844 Lee, Robert E., Hotel Listed 5/31/1980 CA San Diego 815 3rd Ave. and 314 F St. Dean,Willis J. 1000027 Lindstrom House Listed 2/13/2001 CA San Diego 4669 E. Talmadge Dr. May, Clifford Magee 76000516 Long-Waterman House Listed 6/14/1976 CA San Diego 2408 1st Ave. Benson,D.B. Marine Corps Recruit Depot Historic Goodhue,Bertram G.; Dawson 90001477 District Listed 1/31/1991 CA San Diego S of jct. of Barnett Ave. and Pacific Hwy. Construction Co. 74000552 Marston, George W., House Listed 12/16/1974 CA San Diego 3525 7th Ave. Gill,lrving John Palmer,Herbert; Kier.William 80000845 McClintock Storage Warehouse Listed 10/3/1980 CA San Diego 1202 Kettner Blvd. Ernest 79000524 Medico-Dental Building Listed 9/4/1979 CA San Diego 233 A St. Stevenson,Frank W. Prlor,Thomas Frank; 78000753 Mission Beach Roller Coaster Listed 12/27/1978 CA San Diego 3000 Mission Blvd. Church,Frederick A 89000805 Mission Brewery Listed 7/6/1989 CA San Diego 1715 Hancock St. Greisser,Richard 2000779 Mohnike Adobe Listed 7/17/2002 CA San Diego 12115 Black Mountain Rd. Mohnlke, Charles Frederick 84001181 Moylan, Maj. Myles, House Listed 3/22/1984 CA San Diego 2214--2224 2nd Ave. Falkenhan & GIii Goodhue,Bertram Grosvenor; Naval Air Station, San Diego, Historic Navy Bureau of Yards and 91000590 District Listed 5/21/1991 CA San Diego Naval Air Station, North Island, N. shore Docks 426 Naval Training Station Listed 7/5/2001 CA San Diego Barnett St. and Rosecrans Blvd. Naval Public Works Center 66000225 Old Mission Dam Listed 10/15/1966 CA San Diego N side of Mission St.-Gorge Rd. Unknown

7 4000350 Old Point Loma Lighthouse Listed 6/27/1974 CA San Diego Included in Cabrillo National Monument 71000182 Old Town San Diego Historic District Listed 9/3/1971 CA San Diego Jct. of US 5 and US 80 Multiple 84001182 Panama Hotel Listed 3/22/1984 CA San Diego 105W.FSt. Holmes,David H. Park Place Methodist Episcopal Church 83003432 South Listed 9/15/1983 CA San Diego 508 Olive St. Marsh,Norman Foote 100002676 PCF 816 (patrol craft fast) Listed 7/23/2018 CA San Diego 1492 N Harbor Dr. Sewart Seacraft San Diego listing of National Register properties Peterson, Robert O.--Russell Forester 14000136 House Listed 4/11/2014 CA San Diego 567 Gage Ln. Forester, Russell Maritime Museum of San Diego, 1492 N 10001160 PILOT (Pilot Boat) Listed 1/21/2011 CA San Diego Harbor Dr Goularte, Manuel Athaide, Joseph; Brown, Frank; 100000881 Portuguese Chapel of San Diego Listed 4/17/2017 CA San Diego 2818 Avenida de Portugal Lucas, John Quayle,Charles; 81000171 Pythias Lodge Building Listed 4/8/1981 CA San Diego 211 E St. and 870 3rd Ave. Quayle,Edward San Diego Marriot Marina, A Dock, 333 W. Trumpy, John Sr.; mathis Yacht 11000990 RENOWN (yacht) Listed 1/4/2012 CA San Diego Harbor Dr. Building Co. 75002185 Rockwell Field Listed 5/21/1991 CA San Diego North Island Kahn.Albert; Et al. 3000472 Rosecroft Listed 9/22/2003 CA San Diego 530 Slvergate Ave. Weaver, Emmor Brooke 82002246 Ruiz-Alvarado Ranch Site Listed 1/22/1982 CA San Diego Address Restricted 7001177 San Diego Armed Services YMCA Listed 11/15/2007 CA San Diego 500 W Broadway Wheeler, William H.; Loveless, 13000130 San Diego Athletic Club Listed 4/3/2013 CA San Diego 1250 6th Ave. llton E. et al. 88000554 San Diego Civic Center Listed 5/16/1988 CA San Diego 1600 Pacific Hwy. Hamill,Samuel W.; Et al. San Diego Fire Department Shops at 14001204 Station 6 Listed 1/27/2015 CA San Diego 1572 Columbia St. 5 ml. E of Old TO'f/n San Diego on Friars 70000144 San Diego Mission Church Listed 4/15/1970 CA San Diego Rd. Sanchez,Fr. Jose Bernardo 66000226 San Diego Presidio Listed 10/15/1966 CA San Diego Presidio Park 79000525 San Diego Rowing Club Listed 8/30/1979 CA San Diego 525 E. Harbor Dr Unknown 97000924 San Diego State College Listed 9/4/1997 CA San Diego 5300 Campanile Dr. multiple

San Diego Trust and Savings Bank Johnson, William Templeton; 99001565 Building Listed 12/17/1999 CA San Diego 530-540 Broadway Simpson Construction Company San Diego Veterans' War Memorial 1167 Buildlng--Balboa Park Listed 9/28/2000 CA San Diego 3325 Zoo Dr. Hamill, Samuel W.; et.al. 72000248 Santa Fe Depot Listed 6/26/1972 CA San Diego 1050 Kettner St. Bakewell & Brown 75000466 Sorrento Valley Site Listed 10/21/1975 CA San Diego Address Restricted 75000467 Spreckels Theatre Building Listed 5/28/1975 CA San Diego 123 W. Broadway Albright,Harrison 66000223 STAR OF INDIA Listed 11/13/1966 CA San Diego San Diego Embarcadero Unknown 99001180 Sunnyslope Lodge Listed 9/24/1999 CA San Diego 3733 Robinson Mews GIii, Irving John Sweet, A. H., Residence and Adjacent Mead & Requa; 87000621 Small House Listed 4/16/1987 CA San Diego 435 W. Spruce and 3141 Curlew Sts. Sessions,Kate Teacher Training School Building--San Sellon, George C.; Ellery, 98001193 Diego State Normal School Listed 9/17/1999 CA San Diego 4345 Campus Ave. Nathan W of Torrey Pines Rd., bordering Torrey Pines Scenic Dr. and Sand W a/Torrey 93000578 Torrey Pines Gliderport Listed 7/12/1993 CA San Diego Pines Golf Course 98000699 Torrey Pines Lodge Listed 6/18/1998 CA San Diego 12201 Torrey Pines Park Rd. Requa, Richard; et.al. Roughly the North/South R. within Torrey 98001248 Torrey Pines Park Road Listed 10/22/1998 CA San Diego Pines State Reserve 75000468 U.S. Courthouse Listed 1/29/1975 CA San Diego 325W.FSt. Taylor,James Knox

University Heights Water Storage and City of San Diego Water Dept.; 13000417 Pumping Station Historic District Listed 6/25/2013 CA San Diego 4236 Idaho St. Pittsburg-Des Moines Steel Co. 85000137 US Post Office--Downtown Station Listed 1/11/1985 CA San Diego 815 ESt. Johnson,William Templeton 71000183 Villa Montezuma Listed 5/6/1971 CA San Diego 1925 K St. Comstock & Trotsche Bristow & Lyman; 79000526 Watts Building Listed 4/26/1979 CA San Diego 520 E St. Engstum Co. California Landmarks in San Diego County

NO. 49 ADOBE CHAPEL OF THE IMMACULATE CONCEPTION - Originally built as the home of San Diego's John Brown. In 1850, the house was converted to a church by Don Jose Aguirre in 1858. Father Antonio D. Ubach, formerly a missionary among the Indians, was parish priest here from 1866 to 1907. It is said that he was the model for "Father Gaspara" in Helen Hunt Jackson's Ramona. In 1937 the WPA rebuilt the adobe chapel close to its original site. Location: 3950 Conde St, between Congress St and San Diego Ave, Old Town, San Diego

NO. 50 BALLAST POINT WHALING STATION SITE - Late in 1857, the three Johnson brothers and the twin Packard brothers came to this site to survey possibilities for a station to 'try out' or extract whale oil. Their operations began the next year. In 1869 the U.S. Government acquired the property for Fort Rosecrans and in 1873 whaling operations at Ballast Point ended. Location: Base of Ballast Point, S end of Rosecrans St, where historic markers are on a half circle, U.S. Naval Submarine Base, San Diego

NO. 51 OLD POINT LOMA LIGHTHOUSE - This lighthouse, built in 1854, was one of the first eight lighthouses on the Pacific Coast. It continued in use until 1891, when the new Pelican Point Lighthouse began operating. The Point Loma Lighthouse became the site of the Cabrillo National Monument in 1913. During World War II, the Navy used it as a signal tower. Today the lighthouse remains the central feature of the Point Loma Preserve. Location: Cabrillo National Monument, Point Loma, San Diego

NO. 52 MISSION DAM AND FLUME - After many attempts dated back to 1774 to provide a reliable source of water for crops and livestock for Mission San Diego de Alcala, a dam and flume system was finished between 1813 and 1816 by Indian laborers and Franciscan Missionaries to divert waters of the San Diego River for a distance of 6 miles. The aqueduct system continued in existence until 1831 when constant flooding caused the dam and flume to fall into disrepair. They were not repaired due to secularization of the missions. Location: In parking lot on N side of Fr. Junipero Serra Trail in Mission Trails Regional Park near NE entrance, San Diego

NO. 53 CASA DE ESTUDILLO - Three generations of Don Jose Marfa Estudillo's family made their home in Casa de Estudillo. Rich in historical background, the casa is often pointed out, erroneously, as Ramona's marriage place. Location: SE corner of San Diego Ave and Mason St, Old Town San Diego State Historic Park

NO. 54 FORT STOCKTON - Fortified briefly by Carlos Carrillo in 1828, this site became Fort Dupont (July-November 1846) after American forces took Old Town during the Mexican War. Retaken and held briefly by the Californios, it fell once more to the Americans, who renamed it Fort Stockton and used it as campaign headquarters for ending the Californio revolt in early 1847. The Mormon Battalion stayed here later that year. The post was abandoned on September 25, 1848. Location: Top of hill W of Presidio Dr in Presidio Park, Old Town, San Diego

NO. 55 FORT ROSECRANS NATIONAL CEMETERY -A burial ground before 1847, this graveyard became an Army post cemetery in the 1860s. It is the final resting place for most who fell at San Pasqual in 1846, and for the USS Bennington victims of 1905. It became Fort Rosecrans National Cemetery in 1934 and was placed under the Veterans Administration National Cemetery System in 1973. Over 50,000 who served the U.S. honorably in war and peace lie here. Location: Cabrillo Memorial Dr Point Loma, San Diego

NO. 56 CABRILLO LANDING SITE - Seeking the mythical Strait of Anian (the Northwest Passage) for Spain, on September 28, 1542, Iberian navigator Juan Rodrfguez Cabrillo brought his three ships to Ballast Point, the first European landing on the coast of Alta California. Location: Base of Ballast Point, S end of Rosecrans St, where historic markers are on a half circle, U.S. Naval Submarine Base, San Diego

NO. 57 LA PUNTA DE LOS MUERTOS - Sailors and marines were buried here in 1782, when San Diego Bay was surveyed and charted by Don Juan Pantoja y Arriaga, pilot, and Don Jose Tovar, mate, of the royal frigates La Princesa and La Favorita under command of Don Augustfn de Echeverria. Location: SE corner of Market St and Pacific Hwy (State Hwy 163), San Diego

NO. 59 SAN DIEGO PRESIDIO SITE - Soldiers, sailors, Indians, and Franciscan missionaries from New Spain occupied the land at Presidio Hill on May 17, 1769 as a military outpost. Two months later, Fr. Junfpero Serra established the first San Diego Mission on Presidio Hill. Officially proclaimed a Spanish Presidio on January 1, 1774, the fortress was later occupied by a succession of Mexican forces. The Presidio was abandoned in 1837 after San Diego became a pueblo. Location: Next to parking lot across Presidio Dr from Serra Museum, Presidio Park, Old Town, San Diego

NO. 60 CASA DE LOPEZ - Built about 1835 by Juan Francisco Lopez, one of San Diego's early Spanish settlers, the Casa Larga, or Long House, was among the first substantial houses built in the Pueblo of San Diego. In 1846 it was the r

home of Juan Matias Moreno, secretary to Pio Pico, California's last Mexican governor. Location: 3890 Twiggs St on west side of right entrance to restaurant, Old Town, San Diego

No. 61 OLD LA PLAY A From 1770 to 1870, this was San Diego's port. Over the Brookline hide house, Americans unofficially raised a U.S. flag in 1829. At that time La Playa was a thriving trading and shipping village. Richard Henry Dana's account of the hide business in Two Years Before the Mast is based on his hide-droghing experience here in 1835-36. The U.S. Navy later acquired the site and operated a coaling station and a quarantine station here. It is now a Navy research center. Location: On left side of Rosecrans St, at entrance to Military Reserve, Point Loma, San Diego

NO. 62 FORT ROSECRANS - President Millard Fillmore's executive order of 1852 created a U.S. Preserve on Point Loma. From 1870 to 1873 the coast artillery corpsmen evicted whalers from the site in order to begin the military installation. In 1899 it was named for William S. Rosecrans, Civil War general and California congressman. Major fortifications were constructed in 1891-1903 and 1941-1943. Transferred to the U.S. Navy in 1957, it became a submarine support facility. Location: Base of Ballast Point, S end of Rosecrans St, where historic markers are on a half circle, U.S. Naval Submarine Base, San Diego

NO. 63 PLAZA, SAN DIEGO VIEJO (WASHINGTON SQUARE) - This plaza was established as the center of the Mexican Pueblo of San Diego which elected its first ajuntamiento in 1834. On July 29, 1846, at 4 p.m., Lieutenant Stephen C. Rowan, U.S.N., from the U.S. sloop-of-war Cyane, raised the American flag over the plaza. Location: Old Town Plaza (Washington Square), Old Town San Diego State Historic Park

NO. 64 OLD LANDING, SITE OF EL DESEMBARCADERO - El Desembarcadero was one of the first landmarks designated during the first year of the landmark program. The site was recognized as the landing place for small boats carrying freight and passengers to Old San Diego. It was also believed to be the place visited in 1769 by the crews of the San Antonio and San Carlos in their search for fresh water. Location: Base of Ballast Point, S end of Rosecrans St, where historic markers are on a half circle, U.S. Naval Submarine Base, San Diego

NO. 65 THE WHALEY HOUSE - This house, in which the San Diego County Court met for about 20 years, was the first brick building to be erected in San Diego County. The bricks were made at Thomas Whaley's own kiln in Old Town in 1856, and the walls were finished with plaster made from ground seashells. Five generations of the Whaley family have occupied the old home. Location: 2482 San Diego Ave, Old Town, San Diego

NO. 66 CONGRESS HALL SITE - This building was originally a two-story public house built by George Dewitt Clinton Washington Robinson about 1867. From this building one of the last survivors of the pony express rode north. Location: Vacant lot, S side of 2734 Calhoun St, Old Town San Diego State Historic Park

NO. 67 SERRA PALM (SITE) - Site of the palm planted in 1769 by Padre Junipero Serra when he arrived at San Diego. Here the four divisions of the Portola Expedition met on July 1, 1769. The famous 'El Camino Real,' most celebrated trail in California, begins here. Location: Presidio Park, SE corner of Taylor St and Presidio Dr, San Diego

NO. 68 El CAMPO SANTO - El Campo Santo once included the adobe chapel on Conde Street, in which were buried Jose Antonio Aguirre, Maria Victoria Dominguez Estudillo and Cave Johnson Couts, distinguished early San Diegans. Between 1849 and 1897, 4 77 persons were buried in these grounds. Antonio Garra was the most eminent of many Native Americans interred here. A number of graves were relocated after 1874. A street railway bisected the cemetery in 1894. The wall around this portion was built in 1933. Restoration has continued to the present (1994 ). Location: On San Diego Ave between Arista and Conde Sts, San Diego, plaque currently in storage

NO. 69 SITE OF FORT GUIJARROS - An outpost of Spain's far-flung empire at its greatest extent, this fort was completed before 1800 from plans drawn by Alberto de Cordoba in 1795. Its major action came under Corporal Jose Velasquez on March 22, 1803, in the 'Battle of San Diego Bay' with the American Brig Lelia Byrd, which was smuggling sea otter pelts. Location: Base of Ballast Point, S end of Rosecrans St, where historic markers are on a half circle, U.S. Naval Submarine Base, San Diego

NO. 70 CASA DE PEDRORENA- This was the home of Miguel de Pedrorena, who arrived in San Diego Viejo in 1838. Don Miguel was a member of the Constitutional Convention at Monterey in 1849. Location: 2616 San Diego Ave, Old Town San Diego State Historic Park

NO. 71 CASA DE MACHADO - This adobe house, constructed about 1832 by Jose Manuel Machado, pioneer leatherjacket soldier of the Spanish Army who arrived at San Diego Presidio about 1782, is now used as a community church. Location: Park visitor center Old Town San Diego State Historic Park NO. 72 CASA DE BAN DINI - This adobe house was constructed about 1827 by Jose and Juan Bandini. As headquarters of Commodore Robert F. Stockton in 1846, it was the place where Kit Carson and Edward Beale delivered their urgent message of December 9, 1846, calling for reinforcements to be rushed to the aid of General Kearny. Location: On NE corner of Mason and Calhoun Sis, Old Town San Diego State Historic Park

NO. 73 CASA DE STEWART -Adobe house constructed by Jose Manuel Machado in 1830s for his daughter Rosa, wife of John C. Stewart. Stewart was a shipmate of Richard Henry Dana, Jr. who describes his 1859 visit to this house in Two Years Before the Mast. Location: NW corner of Congress and Mason Sis, Old Town San Diego State Historic Park

NO. 74 CASA DE CARRILLO - Presidio Comandante Francisco Marfa Ruiz built this house next to his 1808 pear garden lake in 1821 for his close relative and fellow soldier, Joaquin Carrillo, and his large family. From this adobe dwelling, in April 1829, daughter Josefa Carrillo eloped to Chile with Henry Delano Fitch. When Ruiz died in 1839 and Joaquin soon afterwards, son Ramon Carrillo sold this property to Lorenzo Soto. It was transferred several times before 1932, deteriorating gradually, until George Marston and associates restored the house and grounds and deeded them to the City of San Diego as a golf course. Location: About 100 ft NE of Juan St on Wallace St, Presidio Golf Course, San Diego

NO. 75 SITE OF CASA DE COTA -This adobe is said to have been built about 1835 by Juan or Ramon Cota. Location: NW corner of Twiggs and Congress Sis, Old Town, San Diego

NO. 239 MISSION SAN LUIS REY DE FRANCIA· Founded June 12, 1798 by Father Lasuen, then president of the California missions, and administered by Father Peyrf, Mission San Luis Rey is notable for its impressive architecture-a composite of Spanish, Moorish, and Mexican. Location: On State Hwy 76 (4050 Mission Ave) at Rancho Del Oro Dr, Oceanside

NO. 242 MISSION SAN DIEGO DE ALCALA- On Sunday, July 16, 1769, Fathers Junfpero Serra, Juan Vizcaino, and Fernando Parron raised and blessed a cross to establish Alta California's first mission. Relocated from Presidio Hill to this site in August 1774, the mission was the Mother of those founded in California by the Franciscan Order. The present buildings, first completed in 1813, were rebuilt in stages from 1915 to 1931 after many years of deterioration. They have been in use as a parish church since February 1941. Location: Mission San Diego de Alcala, 10818 San Diego Mission Rd, San Diego

NO. 243 ASISTENCIA SAN ANTONIO DE PALA - Notable for its bell tower, or campanile, the chapel vas built by Father Peyrf in 1816. Almost destroyed by earthquake and storm, it was later restored. (This mission was founded as a sub-mission of San Luis Rey de Francis) Location: Mission on Pala Mission Rd, plaque on State Hwy 76 (P.M. 23.6), Pala

NO. 244 DERBY DIKE - Until 1853 the erratic San Diego River dumped tons of debris into the harbor or poured into False Bay, now Mission Bay. At times it threatened to destroy Old Town San Diego. Lieutenant George Horatio Derby, U.S. Topographical Corps, built a dike that diverted the waters into False Bay. This was the first effort to tame the river, and one of the first U.S. Government projects in California. The river was not fully harnessed until the 1950s. Location: Presidio Park, SE corner of Taylor St and Presidio Dr, San Diego

NO. 304 VALLECITO STAGE DEPOT (STATION)-A reconstruction (1934) ofVallecito Stage Station built in 1852 at the edge of the Great Colorado Desert. It was an important stop on the first official transcontinental route, serving the San Diego-San Antonio ('Jackass') mail line (1857-1859), the Butterfield Overland Stage Line, and the southern emigrant caravans. Location: Vallecito Stage Station County Park, on County Rd S2 (P.M. 34.7), 3.7 mi NW of Agua Caliente Springs

NO. 311 WARNER'S RANCH - In 1844, Governor Manuel Micheltorena granted 44,322 acres to Juan Jose Warner, who built this house. General Kearny passed here in 1846, and the Mormon Battalion in 1847. The first Butterfield Stage stopped at this ranch on October 6, 1858, on its 2,600-mile, 24-day trip from Tipton, Missouri to San Francisco, the southern overland route into California. Location: On County Hwy S2 (P.M. 0.7), 0.7 mi E of junc of State Hwy 79, 4 mi SE of Warner Springs

NO. 369 CHAPEL OF SANTA YSABEL (SITE OF) - The first mass at a site nearby was celebrated September 20, 1818 by Father Fernando Martin. By 1822, Santa Ysabel was an asistencia, or mission outpost, that had a chapel, a granary, several houses, a cemetery, and about 450 neophytes. After secularization in the 1830s, priestly visits became rare. When the roof caved in, after 1850, ramadas were erected against one wall and services were held there. Tradition asserts this site has been used for religious services since 1818. The present chapel was constructed in 1924. Location: On Slate Hwy 79 (P.M. 21.8), 1 .4 mi N of Santa Ysabel

NO. 411 CAMPO STONE STORE - The pioneer Gaskill brothers of 1868 built a frame store which was raided on December 4, 1875 by border bandits. This fort-like replacement of summer 1855 was bought in 1896 by E.T. Aiken, resold to Klauber Wangenheim, 1889, and operated by Henry Marcus Johnson as the Mountain Commercial Company until 1925. In disrepair, it was bought after 1938 by E. M. Statler, given to San Diego County, and restored, 1943-48, as a museum. Location: State Hwy 94 (P.M. 50.6), at Campo Cr, Campo

NO. 412 JULIAN - Following the discovery of gold nearby during the winter of 1869-70, this valley became the commercial and social center of a thriving mining district. Ex-Confederate soldier Drury D. Batley laid out the town on his farmland and named it for his cousin and fellow native of Georgia, Michael S. Julian. By 1906 most mines were unprofitable. Since then the area has become more famous for the variety and quality of its apple crop. Location: Private plaque: Julian Memorial Park, Washington and Fourth Sis, Julian State plaque: In front of Town Hall, Julian ·

NO. 425 LA CANADA DE LOS COCHES RANCHO - Commemorating Canada de Los Caches Rancho, smallest Mexican grant in California, granted in 1843 to Apolinaria Lorenzana by Governor Manuel Micheltorena. This is the site of the old grist mill. Location: 13468 Old Hwy 80, Lakeside

NO. 452 MULE HILL - On December 7, 1846, the day following the Battle of San Pasqual fought five miles east of here, General Stephen Kearny's command, on its way to San Diego, was again attacked by Californians. The Americans counterattacked and occupied this hill until December 11. Short of food, they ate mule meat and named the place 'Mule Hill.' Location: On Pomerado Rd, 0.1 mi E of 1-15, 5 mi SE of Escondido

NO. 472 BOX CANYON - The old road, known as the Sonora, Colorado River, or Southern Emigrant Trail and later as the Butterfield Overland Mail Route, traversed Box Canyon just east of here. On January 19, 1847, the Mormon Battalion under the command of Lieutenant Colonel Philip St. G. Cooke, using hand tools, hewed a passage through the rocky walls of the narrow gorge for their wagons and opened the first road into Southern California. Location: On County Rd S2 (P.M. 25.7), 8.6 mi S of State Hwy 78, Anza-Borrego Desert State Park

NO. 482 CAMP WRIGHT - Camp Wright, named for Brigadier General George Wright, United States Army, who commanded the Pacific Department and California District from 1861 to 1865, was first established October 18, 1861 on Warner's Ranch to guard the line of communication between California and Arizona. The camp was moved to this site by Major Edwin A. Rigg, First California Volunteers, about November 23, 1861 and was abandoned December 1866. Location: State Hwy 79 (P.M. 49.3), Oak Grove

NO. 491 THE EXCHANGE HOTEL - This tablet marks the site of the Exchange Hotel. Here, on June 29, 1851, Masons met for the first time in San Diego and organized the lodge which became San Diego Lodge No. 35, F. & A.M., the oldest lodge of Masons in Southern California. Location: 2729 San Diego Ave, Old Town San Diego State Historic Park

NO. 502 OAK GROVE STAGE STATION - Oak Grove is one of the few remaining stations on the Butterfield Overland Mail route, which operated between San Francisco and two eastern terminals-St. Louis, Missouri and Memphis, Tennessee-from September 15, 1858 to March 2, 1861. During the Civil War the station was used as a hospital for nearby Camp Wright. Location: State Hwy 79 (P.M. 49.4), Oak Grove

NO. 523 SAN DIEGO BARRACKS - New San Diego was established as a quartermaster depot by Captain Nathaniel Lyon, 2nd U.S. Infantry, in 1850-51 to supply military establishments in Southern California. The name of the post was changed from New San Diego to San Diego Barracks by General Orders No. 2, Military Division of the Pacific, San Francisco, April 5, 1879. San Diego Barracks continued to operate as a subpost of Fort Rosecrans until abandoned December 15, 1921. Location: Parking lot on N side of Market St. (St Hwy 163), block bounded by Kettner Blvd & California St, San Diego

NO. 533 SAN PASQUAL BATTLEFIELD STATE HISTORIC PARK -While marching to the conquest and occupation of California during the Mexican War, a detachment of 1st U.S. Dragoons under the command of Brigadier General Stephen W. Kearny was met on this site by native California lancers under the command of General Andres Pico. In this battle, fought on December 6, 1846, severe losses were incurred by the American forces. The native Californians withdrew after Kearny had rallied his men on the field. Gallant action on the part of both forces characterized the Battle of San Pasqual, one of the significant actions during the Mexican War of 1846-1848. Location: San Pasqual Battlefield State Historic Park, State Hwy 78 (P.M. 25.1) at Old Pasqual Rd, 7 mi SE of Escondido

NO. 538 FIRST PUBLICLY OWNED SCHOOL BUILDING - The first public schoolhouse in this county, the Mason Street School-District No. 1, was erected at this site in 1865, when San Diego County covered an area larger than three New England states. It was restored by popular subscription in 1955. Location: 3966 Mason St, Old Town San Diego State Historic Park NO. 562 LA CHRISTIANITA- Near this spring, the first Christian baptism in Alta California was performed by Padre Francisco Gomez, a member of the Portola Expedition, in 1769. Location: Site and plaque in Camp Pendleton, Los Cristianitos Canyon, on Cristianitos Rd, 0.4 mi N. of intersection of San Mateo Rd, 3 mi E of 1-5 at San Clemente, plaque in San Clemente Civic Center 100 Avenida Presidio, San Clemente

NO. 616 LAS FLORES ASISTENCIA- From 1823 to the 1840s, the tile-roofed adobe chapel and hostel at Las Flores, built by Father Antonio Peyri, served as the asistencia to Mission San Lufs Rey and provided comfort to travelers on El Camino Real. The adobe structure and adjacent corral were the site of the April 1838 battle between Juan Bautista Alvarado and Carlos Antonio Carrillo contesting the provincial governorship of Alta California. Location: Camp Pendleton Marine Base, plaque located on hill 1,000 ft W of Orange Co Boy Scouts Adobe, 0.6 mi SE of Las Pulgas gate, 0.9 mi SW of 1-15 (P.M. 62.0) at Las Pulgas Rd, 10 mi S of San Clemente

NO. 626 BANCROFT RANCH HOUSE -Adobe built about 1863 by A. S. Ensworth. Home of Capt. Rufus K. Porter and family. Curved timbers brought from the Clarissa Andrews, famed coaling hulk formerly of the Pacific Mail Steamship Co. Historian Hubert Howe Bancroft later owned this estate and here wrote a part of his monumental History of California. Location: One block E of Memory and Bancroft Dr, Spring Valley

NO. 634 EL VADO - This route was opened by Captain Juan Bautista de Anza and Father Francisco Garces in 1774. Anza's expedition of 1775, a group of 240 soldiers and settlers coming from Sonora to found San Francisco, encamped near El Vado (The Ford) for three days and two nights, December 20-22, 1775. Location: 6 mi NW of Borrego Springs on Borrego Springs Rd (dirt), Anza -Borrego Desert State Park, ask at Visitor Center

NO. 635 LOS PUERTECITOS - Juan Bautista de Anza's expedition marched through this little pass December 19, 1775 on its way to strengthen Spanish colonization in California. Many of the 240 members of the party were recruited from Mexico to be the first residents of San Francisco. They had camped the preceding night somewhere in the wide flats just east of this monument. Location: On State Hwy 78 (P.M. 93.8), 1.6 mi E of_Ocotillo Wells

NO. 639 PALM SPRINGS - Here Mexican pioneers coming to California between 1862 and 1866 rested among the palms, here, too, came mountain men, the Army of the West, the Mormon Battalion, a boundary commission, '49ers, a railway survey team, the Butterfield Overland Mail stages, and the California Legion. This was the site of the Butterfield stage station built in 1858 by Warren F. Hall. Location: On Vallecito Creek Rd, 1.6 mi E of County Rd S2 (P.M. 43.1 ), 6.3 mi SE of Agua Caliente Springs, Anza Borrego Desert State Park

NO. 647 BUTTERFIELD OVERLAND MAIL ROUTE - This pass, Puerta, between the desert and the cooler valleys to the north, was used by the Mormon Battalion, Kearny's Army of the West, the Butterfield Overland Mail stages, and emigrants who eventually settled the West. The eroded scar on the left was the route of the Butterfield stages, 1858- 1861. The road on the right served as a county road until recent years. Location: Blair Valley, 0.5 mi E of County Rd S2 (P.M. 23.0), 5.8 mi S of State Hwy 78, Anza-Borrego Desert State Park

NO. 673 SAN GREGORIO - Somewhere in this narrow valley, perhaps on this very spot, the Anza Expeditions of 1774 and 1775 made their camps. Water for the 240 people and over 800 head of stock on the 1775 march was obtained from a series of wells, deeper than the height of a man, dug into the sandy bottom of the wash. Location: Borrego Sink, 3 mi SE of Palm Canyon and Peg Leg Rds, Anza -Borrego Desert State Park, ask at Visitor Center

NO. 711 MONTGOMERY MEMORIAL - At Otay Mesa, in 1883, John Joseph Montgomery made the first flight in a heavier-than-air craft 20 years before the Wrights. Montgomery made many more glider flights before accepting a professorship at Santa Clara College, where he continued his interest in aviation. Location: Montgomery-Walker Park, NE corner of Coronado Ave and Beyer Blvd, South San Diego

NO. 750 PEG LEG SMITH MONUMENT-Thomas L. Smith, better known as 'Peg Leg,' 1801-1866, was a mountain man, prospector, and spinner of tall tales. Legends regarding his lost gold mine have grown through the years, and countless people have searched the desert for its fabulous wealth. The mine could be within a few miles of this monument. Location: Henderson Canyon Rd, 1,000 ft N of Pegleg Rd, Anza-Borrego Desert State Park

NO. 764 SITE OF THE KATE 0. SESSIONS NURSERY - This plaque commemorates the life and influence of a woman who envisioned a beautiful San Diego. On this site she operated a nursery and gained world renown as a horticulturist, she was the first woman to receive the International Meyer Medal in genetics. Location: NW corner of Garnet Ave and Pico St (Pacific Beach area), San Diego NO. 784 EL CAMINO REAL (AS FATHER SERRA KNEW IT AND HELPED BLAZE IT)-This plaque was placed on the 250th anniversary of the birth of California's apostle, Padre Junfpero Serra, OFM, to mark El Camino Real as he knew it and helped blaze it. Location: Mission San Diego de Alcala, 10818 San Diego Mission Rd, San Diego to Mission San Francisco de Asis, San· Francisco.

NO. 785 SANTA CATARINA - This spring was named by Captain Juan Bautista de Anza when his overland exploration party camped here on March 14, 1774, on the journey that opened the Anza Trail from Sonora into Alta California. Anza's colonizing expedition of 1775, consisting of 240 persons and over 800 head of livestock, camped here the night of December 23. Location: Santa Catarina Springs, 10 mi NW of Borrego Springs (4-wheel drive dirt rd), Anza-Borrego Desert State Park, ask at Visitor Center

NO. 793 SAN FELIPE VALLEY AND STAGE STATION - Here the southern trail of explorers, trappers, soldiers, and emigrants crossed ancient trade routes of Kamia, Cahuilla, Diegueno, and Luisei'io Indians. On the flat southwest across the creek, Warren F. Hall built and operated the San Felipe home station of the Butterfield Mail, which operated from 1858 to 1861. Later the station was used by Banning Stages and by the military during the Civil War. Location: On County Hwy S2 (P.M. 15.9), 0.9 mi NW of intersection of State Hwy 78, near Anza-Borrego Desert State Park

NO. 798 SAN DIEGO STATE COLLEGE, SITE OF FIRST DOCTORATE DEGREE GRANTED BY THE CALIFORNIA STATE COLLEGE SYSTEM - Under the Master Plan for Higher Education adopted in 1960, the colleges in the newly established California College System were given degrees with the University of California, and independent degrees to individuals who have made unusual contributions toward learning and civilization. San Diego State College was the first of the California State Colleges to do so when, on June 7, 1963 it conferred an honorary doctorate upon the late President of the United States, John Fitzgerald Kennedy. Location: San Diego State University, entrance to service area of Cox Arenam off Canyon Crest Dr, San Diego

NO. 818 FIRST MILITARY FLYING SCHOOL IN AMERICA - The flat lands beyond have been a part of aviation history since Glenn Curtiss founded the first military flying school in America here on January 17, 1911. The Army operated Rockwell Field until January 31, 1939, the Navy commissioned the present air station on November 8, 1917. Location: Sunset Park, 200 block of Ocean Blvd, at entrance to Gate 5, Naval Air Station, North Island, Coronado

NO. 830 OLD TOWN SAN DIEGO STATE HISTORIC PARK - Settled by pensioned soldiers from the presidia and their families, Old Town grew into a cluster of adobe houses and garden plots in the early 1800s. By 1835, 'it was composed of about 40 dark brown looking huts.' The Stars and Stripes was first raised over the plaza in 1846 by Marines from the U.S.S. Cyane. Location: Old Town San Diego State Historic Park, plaque located W side of plaza at 4016 Wallace St, San Diego

NO. 844 HOTEL DEL CORONADO - This Victorian hotel, built in 1887, is one of America's largest wooden buildings. Few seaside resort hotels of this significant architectural style remain in America. The hotel has hosted several Presidents and other national figures. Location: Hotel Garden Patio, 1500 Orange Ave, Coronado

NO. 858 PEDRO FAGES TRAIL - On October 29, 1772, headed east from San Diego in search of army deserters, Colonel Pedro Fages made the first entry by a European into Oriflamme Canyon. From there, Fages and his men traveled on through Cajon Pass and around the Mojave and the Central Valley to eventually reach Mission San Lufs Obispo, discovering the Colorado desert and the San Joaquin Valley. Location: 1.7 mi SE on Sunrise Hwy (County Rd S1, P.M. 36) from intersection with Hwy 79 (P.M. 14.5), 8 mi SE of Julian

NO. 891 SPANISH LANDING - Near this point, sea and land parties of the Portola-Serra expedition met in 1769. Two ships, the San Antonio and San Carlos, anchored on May 4-5 and the scurvy-weakened survivors of the voyage established a camp, where on May 14 and July 1 they greeted the parties coming overland from Baja California. Together, they began the Spanish occupation of Alta California. Location: Spanish Landing Park, Harbor Dr San Diego

NO. 940 RANCHO GUAJOME - Formerly attached to Mission San Lufs Rey, this 2,219-acre ranch was briefly owned by two mission Indians and then came into the hands of Don Abel Stearns, Ysidora Bandini acquired it on her marriage to Col. Cave Johnson Couts. The adobe ranch house, built in 1852-53, is one of the finest extant examples of the traditional Spanish-Mexican one-story hacienda with an inner-outer courtyard plan. San Diego County acquired it in 1973 for the Guajome Regional Park. Location: Rancho Guajome Regional Park, 2210 N Santa Fe Ave, 4 mi E of Mission San Luis Rey, 3.3 mi N of Vista

NO. 982 HISTORIC PLANNED COMMUNITY OF RANCHO SANTA FE - Rancho Santa Fe began as Rancho San Dieguito, a land grant of nearly 9,000 acres made to Juan Marfa Osuna in 1845. The Santa Fe Railway Company later used the land to plant thousands of eucalyptus trees for use as railroad ties. In the 1920s Rancho Santa Fe became. one of the state's first planned communities unified by a single architectural theme, the Spanish Colonial Revival. Lilian Rice, one of California's first successful women architects, supervised the development and designed many of the buildings. Location: Village Green in front of The Inn, Rancho Santa Fe

NO. 1020 LEO CARRILLO RANCH (RANCHO DE LOS KIOTES) - Between 1937 and 1940, these adobe and wood buildings were built by actor Leo Carrillo as a retreat, working ranch, and tribute to old California culture and architecture. The Leo Carrillo Ranch, with its Flying 'LC' brand, originally covered 2,538 acres and was frequented by Carrillo and his friends until 1960. Leo Carrillo was a strong, positive, and well-loved role model who sought to celebrate California's early Spanish heritage, through a life of good deeds and charitable causes. Location: 6200 Flying L.C. Lane, Carlsbad

NO. 1023 NATIONAL CITY DEPOT TRANSCONTINENTAL RAILROAD - This National City California Southern Railroad depot built in 1882 served as the first Pacific Coast terminus station of the Santa Fe Railway system's transcontinental railroad. The station was the West Coast general office and figured prominently in Santa Fe's effort to break the economic and transportation monopoly of California held by the Central/Southern Pacific Railroads. The first transcontinental trains arrived in November 1885, resulting in one of the largest land booms in the history of California. Of the original five transcontinental railroad terminus stations, this unique Italianate designed station is the lone survivor. Location: 900 West 23 St, National City, San Diego

NO. 1026 SANTA MARGARITA RANCH HOUSE - In July 1769, the Portola Expedition named this area for St. Margaret of Antioch. The Mission San Luis Rey 1827 Inventories list a small building in the area. In 1841, Rancho San Onofre Y Santa Margarita was granted to Andres and Pio Pico, the last governor of Alta California. Land magnate Don Juan Forster owned the rancho from 1864-1882. Richard O'Neill and James Flood purchased 205, 000 acres in 1882. The ranch house stop served the 1882 transcontinental California Southern Railroad. In 1942, President Franklin D. Roosevelt dedicated Marine Corps Base Camp Joseph H. Pendleton. The railroad line continued as a vital military transportation link before devastation by the 1993 flood. Location: US Marine Corp Camp Pendleton, San Diego

NO. 1030 STAR OF INDIA - The "Star of India," a three-masted bark, is the oldest iron-hulled merchant ship afloat. Built on the Isle of Man, Great Britain, she was launched in 1863 and christened Euterpe. The Trans-Pacific trade from 1871-1898 resulted in the Euterpe circumnavigating the earth twenty-one times, stopping in San Francisco in 1873 and 1883. She was purchased by the Alaska Packers Association to service the salmon canneries in Alaska, leaving each season from Alameda during 1902-1923, Euterpe was renamed Star of India. The Star of India continues to sail the Pacific Ocean as an active reminder of early California's maritime commerce. Location: Docked at 1306 North Harbor Drive, San Diego

NO. 1031 FERRYBOAT BERKELEY- The steam ferryboat Berkeley was the first successful West Coast-built and operated ferry to be driven by a screw propeller as opposed to side-wheels. Built by the famous Union Iron Workers of San Francisco in 1898, the ferry operated until 1958 as part of the San Francisco Bay ferry system. The Berkeley is the oldest steel-hulled ferry on the West Coast and the earliest double-ended ferryboat to survive with her original historic fabric intact. After the 1906 San Francisco earthquake the Berkeley assisted in evacuating refugees to Oakland. Location: Docked at 1306 North Harbor Drive, San Diego

NO. 1042 USS RECRUIT - This 2/3 scale model of a destroyer escort {TOE_ 1) helped instruct as many as 50,000 naval recruits annually in basic naval procedure. Commissioned July 27, 1949, the Recruit was the Navy's only commissioned ship never to reach water. It is the sole survivor of three such ships built by the Navy following World War II. In 1982, the Recruit was reconditioned to serve as a training guided missile frigate. Naval recruits gave the structure its affectionate nickname, USS Neversail. Location: Liberty Station, Point Loma, San Diego

NO .. 1044 GIANT DIPPER ROLLER COASTER -The 1925 Giant Dipper Roller Coaster (or "Earthquake") is a large wooden roller coaster, and its highest "hills" reach a height of 75 feet. It is one of only two large wooden scaffolded roller coasters remaining on the West Coast. The Giant Dipper was designed by noted coaster builders Prior and Church. It is the prime survivor and most visible symbol of the Mission Beach Amusement Center. It was designated a National Historic Landmark in 1987. Location: 3190 Mission Boulevard, San Diego

NO. 1045 CAMP LOCKETT - Built in 1941, Camp Lockett was occupied by the military until 1946 and was the last training facility constructed for mounted cavalry units in Southern California. Camp Lockett also was the last military installation in California to house and train African American mounted troops, known as "Buffalo Soldiers," before their units were permanently disbanded as a mounted horse cavalry division. With the departure of the Buffalo Soldier units from Camp Lockett to the war theater of North Africa in 1944, the era of the horse soldier ended. Location: Campo, San Diego County Attachment E.6 - Criterion F

Summary: 2528 Island Ave. is not within either the Grant Hill, Sherman Heights, or the Golden Hill Historical Districts. As a property unto itself, it does not contain or constitute a group of resources of historical interest or aesthetic value.

Conclusion: The property does not qualify under Criterion F.